A case of congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV

Erythroid Krüppel-Like Factor (KLF1): A Surprisingly Versatile Regulator of Erythroid Differentiation

Erythroid Krüppel-like factor (KLF1), first discovered in 1992, is an erythroid-restricted transcription factor (TF) that is essential for terminal differentiation of erythroid progenitors. At face value, KLF1 is a rather inconspicuous member of the 26-strong SP/KLF TF family. However, 30 years of research have revealed that KLF1 is a jack of all trades in the molecular control of erythropoiesis. Initially described as a one-trick pony required for high-level transcription of the adult HBB gene, we now know that it orchestrates the entire erythroid differentiation program. It does so not only as an activator but also as a repressor. In addition, KLF1 was the first TF shown to be directly involved in enhancer/promoter loop formation. KLF1 variants underlie a wide range of erythroid phenotypes in the human population, varying from very mild conditions such as hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin and the In(Lu) blood type in the case of haploinsufficiency, to much more serious non-spherocytic hemolytic anemias in the case of compound heterozygosity, to dominant congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV invariably caused by a de novo variant in a highly conserved amino acid in the KLF1 DNA-binding domain. In this chapter, we present an overview of the past and present of KLF1 research and discuss the significance of human KLF1 variants.

A novel human cellular model of CDA IV enables comprehensive analysis revealing the molecular basis of the disease phenotype

Red blood cell disorders can result in severe anemia. One such disease congenital dyserythropoietic anemia IV (CDA IV) is caused by the heterozygous mutation E325K in the transcription factor KLF1. However, studying the molecular basis of CDA IV is severely impeded by the paucity of suitable and adequate quantities of material from patients with anemia and the rarity of the disease. We, therefore, took a novel approach, creating a human cellular disease model system for CDA IV that accurately recapitulates the disease phenotype. Next, using comparative proteomics, we reveal extensive distortion of the proteome and a wide range of disordered biological processes in CDA IV erythroid cells. These include downregulated pathways the governing cell cycle, chromatin separation, DNA repair, cytokinesis, membrane trafficking, and global transcription, and upregulated networks governing mitochondrial biogenesis. The diversity of such pathways elucidates the spectrum of phenotypic abnormalities that occur with CDA IV and impairment to erythroid cell development and survival, collectively explaining the CDA IV disease phenotype. The data also reveal far more extensive involvement of KLF1 in previously assigned biological processes, along with novel roles in the regulation of intracellular processes not previously attributed to this transcription factor. Overall, the data demonstrate the power of such a model cellular system to unravel the molecular basis of disease and how studying the effects of a rare mutation can reveal fundamental biology.

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV in the genetic era: A rare neonatal case report of rapid identification with a review of the literature

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV (CDAIV) is a rare inherited hematological disorder, presenting with severe anemia due to altered erythropoiesis and hemolysis, with variable needs for recurrent transfusions. We present a case of a transfusion-dependent male newborn who presented at birth with severe hemolytic anemia, and required an intrauterine transfusion. Genetic testing rapidly identified a Kruppel-like factor 1 (KLF1) pathogenic variant (c.973G>A, p.E325K), known to be causative for CDAIV. This case highlights the advantages of next-generation sequencing testing for congenital hemolytic anemia: diagnostic speed, guidance on natural history, and optimized clinical management and anticipatory guidance for parents and clinicians. Additionally, we reviewed the literature for all CDAIV cases.

Modelling the erythroblastic island niche of dyserythropoietic anaemia type IV patients using induced pluripotent stem cells

Introduction: Congenital dyserythropoietic anaemia (CDA) type IV has been associated with an amino acid substitution, Glu325Lys (E325K), in the transcription factor KLF1. These patients present with a range of symptoms, including the persistence of nucleated red blood cells (RBCs) in the peripheral blood which reflects the known role for KLF1 within the erythroid cell lineage. The final stages of RBCs maturation and enucleation take place within the erythroblastic island (EBI) niche in close association with EBI macrophages. It is not known whether the detrimental effects of the E325K mutation in KLF1 are restricted to the erythroid lineage or whether deficiencies in macrophages associated with their niche also contribute to the disease pathology. Methods: To address this question, we generated an in vitro model of the human EBI niche using induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) derived from one CDA type IV patient as well as two iPSC lines genetically modified to express an KLF1-E325K-ERT2 protein that could be activated with 4OH-tamoxifen. The one patient iPSC line was compared to control lines from two healthy donors and the KLF1-E325K-ERT2 iPSC line to one inducible KLF1-ERT2 line generated from the same parental iPSCS. Results: The CDA patient-derived iPSCs and iPSCs expressing the activated KLF1-E325K-ERT2 protein showed significant deficiencies in the production of erythroid cells with associated disruption of some known KLF1 target genes. Macrophages could be generated from all iPSC lines but when the E325K-ERT2 fusion protein was activated, we noted the generation of a slightly less mature macrophage population marked by CD93. A subtle trend in their reduced ability to support RBC enucleation was also associated with macrophages carrying the E325K-ERT2 transgene. Discussion: Taken together these data support the notion that the clinically significant effects of the KLF1-E325K mutation are primarily associated with deficiencies in the erythroid lineage but it is possible that deficiencies in the niche might have the potential to exacerbate the condition. The strategy we describe provides a powerful approach to assess the effects of other mutations in KLF1 as well as other factors associated with the EBI niche.

The congenital dyserythropoieitic anemias: genetics and pathophysiology

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The congenital dyserythropoietic anemias (CDA) are hereditary disorders characterized by ineffective erythropoiesis. This review evaluates newly developed CDA disease models, the latest advances in understanding the pathogenesis of the CDAs, and recently identified CDA genes.

RECENT FINDINGS

Mice exhibiting features of CDAI were recently generated, demonstrating that Codanin-1 (encoded by Cdan1) is essential for primitive erythropoiesis. Additionally, Codanin-1 was found to physically interact with CDIN1, suggesting that mutations in CDAN1 and CDIN1 result in CDAI via a common mechanism. Recent advances in CDAII (which results from SEC23B mutations) have also been made. SEC23B was found to functionally overlap with its paralogous protein, SEC23A, likely explaining the absence of CDAII in SEC23B-deficient mice. In contrast, mice with erythroid-specific deletion of 3 or 4 of the Sec23 alleles exhibited features of CDAII. Increased SEC23A expression rescued the CDAII erythroid defect, suggesting a novel therapeutic strategy for the disease. Additional recent advances included the identification of new CDA genes, RACGAP1 and VPS4A, in CDAIII and a syndromic CDA type, respectively.

SUMMARY

Establishing cellular and animal models of CDA is expected to result in improved understanding of the pathogenesis of these disorders, which may ultimately lead to the development of new therapies.

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemias

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemias (CDAs) are a heterogeneous group of inherited anemias that affect the normal differentiation-proliferation pathways of the erythroid lineage. They belong to the wide group of ineffective erythropoiesis conditions that mainly result in monolinear cytopenia. CDAs are classified into the 3 major types (I, II, III), plus the transcription factor-related CDAs, and the CDA variants, on the basis of the distinctive morphological, clinical, and genetic features. Next-generation sequencing has revolutionized the field of diagnosis of and research into CDAs, with reduced time to diagnosis, and ameliorated differential diagnosis in terms of identification of new causative/modifier genes and polygenic conditions. The main improvements regarding CDAs have been in the study of iron metabolism in CDAII. The erythroblast-derived hormone erythroferrone specifically inhibits hepcidin production, and its role in the mediation of hepatic iron overload has been dissected out. We discuss here the most recent advances in this field regarding the molecular genetics and pathogenic mechanisms of CDAs, through an analysis of the clinical and molecular classifications, and the complications and clinical management of patients. We summarize also the main cellular and animal models developed to date and the possible future therapies.

Hemoglobin switching in mice carrying the Klf1Nan variant

Haploinsufficiency for transcription factor KLF1 causes a variety of human erythroid phenotypes, such as the In(Lu) blood type, increased HbA2 levels, and hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin. Severe dominant congenital dyserythropoietic anemia IV (OMIM 613673) is associated with the KLF1 p.E325K variant. CDA-IV patients display ineffective erythropoiesis and hemolysis resulting in anemia, accompanied by persistent high levels of embryonic and fetal hemoglobin. The mouse Nan strain carries a variant in the orthologous residue, KLF1 p.E339D. Klf1Nan causes dominant hemolytic anemia with many similarities to CDA-IV. Here we investigated the impact of Klf1Nan on the developmental expression patterns of the endogenous beta-like and alpha-like globins, and the human beta-like globins carried on a HBB locus transgene. We observe that the switch from primitive, yolk sac-derived, erythropoiesis to definitive, fetal liver-derived, erythropoiesis is delayed in Klf1wt/Nan embryos. This is reflected in globin expression patterns measured between E12.5 and E14.5. Cultured Klf1wt/Nan E12.5 fetal liver cells display growth- and differentiation defects. These defects likely contribute to the delayed appearance of definitive erythrocytes in the circulation of Klf1wt/Nan embryos. After E14.5, expression of the embryonic/fetal globin genes is silenced rapidly. In adult Klf1wt/Nan animals, silencing of the embryonic/fetal globin genes is impeded, but only minute amounts are expressed. Thus, in contrast to human KLF1 p.E325K, mouse KLF1 p.E339D does not lead to persistent high levels of embryonic/fetal globins. Our results support the notion that KLF1 affects gene expression in a variant-specific manner, highlighting the necessity to characterize KLF1 variant-specific phenotypes of patients in detail.

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemia types Ib, II, and III: novel variants in the CDIN1 gene and functional study of a novel variant in the KIF23 gene

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemias (CDA) are disorders characterized by ineffective erythropoiesis and morphological anomalies in erythrocytes and erythroblasts. The purpose of this study is to identify the gene variants in patients diagnosed with CDA. We analyzed five unrelated patients and two siblings with a targeted panel of genes to CDA: CDAN1, CDIN1, SEC23B, KIF23, KLF1, and GATA1 genes. We found three novel variants in the CDIN1 gene (p.Leu136Val, p.Tyr247Cys, and p.Ile273Thr), four known variants in the SEC23B gene (p.Arg14Trp, p.Arg554Ter, p.Asp239Gly, and p.Ser436Leu), and one novel variant in the KIF23 gene (p.Leu945Trpfs*31). The in silico analysis of novel variants predict that they are pathogenic and, the in vitro study confirms the functional impact of the KIF23 variant on the protein location.

Severe anemia caused by dominant mutations in Krüppel-like factor 1 (KLF1)

The etiology and severity of anemia, a common blood disorder, are diverse. Dominant mutations in Krüppel-like factor 1 (KLF1/EKLF) underlie the molecular basis for some of them. KLF1 is a zinc finger transcription factor that plays an essential role in red blood cell proliferation and differentiation. Mutations have been identified in the KLF1 gene that cause hematologic diseases. Two of these alter one allele but generate an extreme phenotype: the mouse Nan mutation (E339D) leads to hemolytic neonatal anemia with hereditary spherocytosis, and the human CDA mutation (E325K) causes congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA) type IV. These modify functionally important amino acids in the zinc finger DNA-binding domain at positions involved in direct interactions with regulatory elements of KLF1's target genes. Although the two dominant mutations alter the same evolutionarily conserved glutamic acid residue, the substitutions are not equivalent and lead to divergent consequences for the molecular mechanisms underlying activity of these mutants, particularly in recognition and interaction with their unique binding sites. Consequently, the properties of the protein are transformed such that it acquires novel dominant characteristics whose effects may not be limited to the erythroid compartment. KLF1 mutants cause loss-of-function/haploinsufficiency effects on some KLF1 wild-type target genes, while at the same time gain-of-function effects activate ectopic sites and neomorphic gene expression. Such anomalies not only lead to intrinsic red cell problems, but also to expression of non-erythroid genes that systemically disturb organ development. This review highlights recent molecular, biochemical, and genetic studies of KLF1 mutants, particularly the dramatic consequences that come from just a single amino acid change. The study of these variants provides an important contribution to the overall understanding of the DNA-protein interface of the zinc finger subtype of transcription factors, and the potential clinical consequences of what might appear to be a minor change in sequence.

A Very Rare Congenital Dyserythropoietic Anemia Variant-Type IV in a Patient With a Novel Mutation in the KLF1 Gene: A Case Report and Review of the Literature

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemias comprise a group of very rare hereditary disorders characterized by ineffective erythropoiesis and distinct morphologic abnormalities of the erythroblasts in the bone marrow. The wide variety of phenotypes observed in these patients makes the diagnosis difficult; identification of the genetic variants is crucial in differential diagnosis and clinical management. We report the nineth case with congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV, with a novel mutation that has not been reported before.

A Krüppel-like factor 1 (KLF1) Mutation Associated with Severe Congenital Dyserythropoietic Anemia Alters Its DNA-Binding Specificity

Krüppel-like factor 1 (KLF1/EKLF) is a transcription factor that globally activates genes involved in erythroid cell development. Various mutations are identified in the human KLF1 gene. The E325K mutation causes congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA) type IV, characterized by severe anemia and non-erythroid-cell-related symptoms. The CDA mutation is in the second zinc finger of KLF1 at a position functionally involved in its interactions with DNA. The molecular parameters of how CDA-KLF1 exerts its biological effects have not been addressed. Here, using an in vitro selection strategy, we determined the preferred DNA-binding site for CDA-KLF1. Binding to the deduced consensus sequence is supported by in vitro gel shifts and by in vivo functional reporter gene studies. Two significant changes compared to wild-type (WT) binding are observed: G is selected as the middle nucleotide, and the 3' portion of the consensus sequence is more degenerate. As a consequence, CDA-KLF1 did not bind the WT consensus sequence. However, activation of ectopic sites is promoted. Continuous activation of WT target genes occurs if they fortuitously contain the novel CDA site nearby. Our findings provide a molecular understanding of how a single mutation in the KLF1 zinc finger exerts effects on erythroid physiology in CDA type IV.

Corrupted DNA-binding specificity and ectopic transcription underpin dominant neomorphic mutations in KLF/SP transcription factors

Background

Mutations in the transcription factor, KLF1, are common within certain populations of the world. Heterozygous missense mutations in KLF1 mostly lead to benign phenotypes, but a heterozygous mutation in a DNA-binding residue (E325K in human) results in severe Congenital Dyserythropoietic Anemia type IV (CDA IV); i.e. an autosomal-dominant disorder characterized by neonatal hemolysis.

Results

To investigate the biochemical and genetic mechanism of CDA IV, we generated murine erythroid cell lines that harbor tamoxifen-inducible (ER™) versions of wild type and mutant KLF1 on a Klf1^−/− genetic background. Nuclear translocation of wild type KLF1 results in terminal erythroid differentiation, whereas mutant KLF1 results in hemolysis without differentiation. The E to K variant binds poorly to the canonical 9 bp recognition motif (NGG-GYG-KGG) genome-wide but binds at high affinity to a corrupted motif (NGG-GRG-KGG). We confirmed altered DNA-binding specificity by quantitative in vitro binding assays of recombinant zinc-finger domains. Our results are consistent with previously reported structural data of KLF-DNA interactions. We employed 4sU-RNA-seq to show that a corrupted transcriptome is a direct consequence of aberrant DNA binding.

Conclusions

Since all KLF/SP family proteins bind DNA in an identical fashion, these results are likely to be generally applicable to mutations in all family members. Importantly, they explain how certain mutations in the DNA-binding domain of transcription factors can generate neomorphic functions that result in autosomal dominant disease.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12864-019-5805-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The mouse KLF1 Nan variant impairs nuclear condensation and erythroid maturation

Krüppel-like factor 1 (KLF1) is an essential transcription factor for erythroid development, as demonstrated by Klf1 knockout mice which die around E14 due to severe anemia. In humans, >140 KLF1 variants, causing different erythroid phenotypes, have been described. The KLF1 Nan variant, a single amino acid substitution (p.E339D) in the DNA binding domain, causes hemolytic anemia and is dominant over wildtype KLF1. Here we describe the effects of the KLF1 Nan variant during fetal development. We show that Nan embryos have defects in erythroid maturation. RNA-sequencing of the KLF1 Nan fetal liver cells revealed that Exportin 7 (Xpo7) was among the 782 deregulated genes. This nuclear exportin is implicated in terminal erythroid differentiation; in particular it is involved in nuclear condensation. Indeed, KLF1 Nan fetal liver cells had larger nuclei and reduced chromatin condensation. Knockdown of XPO7 in wildtype erythroid cells caused a similar phenotype. We propose that reduced expression of XPO7 is partially responsible for the erythroid defects observed in KLF1 Nan erythroid cells.

Genetic disarray follows mutant KLF1-E325K expression in a congenital dyserythropoietic anemia patient

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV is caused by a heterozygous mutation, Glu325Lys (E325K), in the KLF1 transcription factor. Molecular characteristics of this disease have not been clarified, partly due to its rarity. We expanded erythroid cells from a patient's peripheral blood and analyzed its global expression pattern. We find that a large number of erythroid pathways are disrupted, particularly those related to membrane transport, globin regulation, and iron utilization. The altered genetics lead to significant deficits in differentiation. Glu325 is within the KLF1 zinc finger domain at an amino acid critical for site specific DNA binding. The change to Lys is predicted to significantly alter the target site recognition sequence, both by subverting normal recognition and by enabling interaction with novel sites. Consistent with this, we find high level ectopic expression of genes not normally present in the red cell. These altered properties explain patients' clinical and phenotypic features, and elucidate the dominant character of the mutation.

KLF1 mutation E325K induces cell cycle arrest in erythroid cells differentiated from congenital dyserythropoietic anemia patient-specific induced pluripotent stem cells

Krüppel-like factor 1 (KLF1), a transcription factor controlling definitive erythropoiesis, is involved in sequential control of terminal cell division and enucleation via fine regulation of key cell cycle regulator gene expression in erythroid lineage cells. Type IV congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA) is caused by a monoallelic mutation at the second zinc finger of KLF1 (c.973G>A, p.E325K). We recently diagnosed a female patient with type IV CDA with the identical missense mutation. To understand the mechanism underlying the dyserythropoiesis caused by the mutation, we generated induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) from the CDA patient (CDA-iPSCs). The erythroid cells that differentiated from CDA-iPSCs (CDA-erythroid cells) displayed multinucleated morphology, absence of CD44, and dysregulation of the KLF1 target gene expression. In addition, uptake of bromodeoxyuridine by CDA-erythroid cells was significantly decreased at the CD235a⁺/CD71⁺ stage, and microarray analysis revealed that cell cycle regulator genes were dysregulated, with increased expression of negative regulators such as CDKN2C and CDKN2A. Furthermore, inducible expression of the KLF1 E325K, but not the wild-type KLF1, caused a cell cycle arrest at the G1 phase in CDA-erythroid cells. Microarray analysis of CDA-erythroid cells and real-time polymerase chain reaction analysis of the KLF1 E325K inducible expression system also revealed altered expression of several KLF1 target genes including erythrocyte membrane protein band 4.1 (EPB41), EPB42, glutathione disulfide reductase (GSR), glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI), and ATPase phospholipid transporting 8A1 (ATP8A1). Our data indicate that the E325K mutation in KLF1 is associated with disruption of transcriptional control of cell cycle regulators in association with erythroid membrane or enzyme abnormalities, leading to dyserythropoiesis.

KLF1 E325K-associated Congenital Dyserythropoietic Anemia Type IV: Insights Into the Variable Clinical Severity

We identified a child with KLF1-E325K congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type IV who experienced a severe clinical course, fetal anemia, hydrops fetalis, and postnatal transfusion dependence only partially responsive to splenectomy. The child also had complete sex reversal, the cause which remains undetermined. To gain insights into our patient's severe hematologic phenotype, detailed analyses were performed. Erythrocytes from the patient and parents demonstrated functional abnormalities of the erythrocyte membrane, attributed to variants in the α-spectrin gene. Hypomorphic alleles in SEC23B and YARS2 were also identified. We hypothesize that coinheritance of variants in relevant erythrocyte genes contribute to the clinical course in our patient and other E325K-linked congenital dyserythropoietic anemia IV patients with severe clinical phenotypes.

Clinical and genetic features of congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA)

INTRODUCTION

Congenital dyserythropoietic anemias (CDA) are characterized by hyporegenerative anemia with inadequate reticulocyte values, ineffective erythropoiesis, and hemolysis. Distinctive morphology of bone marrow erythroblasts and identification of causative genes allow classification into 4 types caused by variants in CDAN1, c15orf41, SEC23B, KIF23, and KLF1 genes.

OBJECTIVE

Identify pathogenic variants in CDA patients.

METHODS

Massive parallel sequencing with a targeted gene panel, Sanger sequencing, Comparative Genome Hybridization (CGH), and in silico predictive analysis of pathogenicity.

RESULTS

Pathogenic variants were found in 21 of 53 patients studied from 44 unrelated families. Six variants were found in CDAN1: two reported, p.Arg714Trp and p.Arg725Trp and, four novel, p.Arg623Trp, p.Arg946Trp, p.Phe1125Ser and p.Ser1227Gly. Twelve variants were found in SEC23B: seven reported, p.Arg14Trp, p.Glu109Lys, p.Arg217Ter, c.835-2A>G, p.Arg535Ter, p.Arg550Ter and p.Arg718Ter and, five novel, p.Val164Leu, p.Arg190Gln, p.Gln521Ter, p.Arg546Trp, and p.Arg611Gln. The variant p.Glu325Lys in KLF1 was found in one patient and p.Tyr365Cys in ALAS2 in an other. Moreover, we identified genomic rearrangements by CGH in some SEC23B-monoallelic patients.

CONCLUSIONS

New technologies for genetic studies will help to find variants in other genes, in addition to those known, that contribute to or modulate the CDA phenotype or support the correct diagnosis.

Survey and evaluation of mutations in the human KLF1 transcription unit

Erythroid Krüppel-like Factor (EKLF/KLF1) is an erythroid-enriched transcription factor that plays a global role in all aspects of erythropoiesis, including cell cycle control and differentiation. We queried whether its mutation might play a role in red cell malignancies by genomic sequencing of the KLF1 transcription unit in cell lines, erythroid neoplasms, dysplastic disorders, and leukemia. In addition, we queried published databases from a number of varied sources. In all cases we only found changes in commonly notated SNPs. Our results suggest that if there are mutations in KLF1 associated with erythroid malignancies, they are exceedingly rare.