Synthesis and Evaluation of Novel Ring-Strained Noncanonical Amino Acids for Residue-Specific Bioorthogonal Reactions in Living Cells

Cracking the Code: Reprogramming the Genetic Script in Prokaryotes and Eukaryotes to Harness the Power of Noncanonical Amino Acids

Over 500 natural and synthetic amino acids have been genetically encoded in the last two decades. Incorporating these noncanonical amino acids into proteins enables many powerful applications, ranging from basic research to biotechnology, materials science, and medicine. However, major challenges remain to unleash the full potential of genetic code expansion across disciplines. Here, we provide an overview of diverse genetic code expansion methodologies and systems and their final applications in prokaryotes and eukaryotes, represented by Escherichia coli and mammalian cells as the main workhorse model systems. We highlight the power of how new technologies can be first established in simple and then transferred to more complex systems. For example, whole-genome engineering provides an excellent platform in bacteria for enabling transcript-specific genetic code expansion without off-targets in the transcriptome. In contrast, the complexity of a eukaryotic cell poses challenges that require entirely new approaches, such as striving toward establishing novel base pairs or generating orthogonally translating organelles within living cells. We connect the milestones in expanding the genetic code of living cells for encoding novel chemical functionalities to the most recent scientific discoveries, from optimizing the physicochemical properties of noncanonical amino acids to the technological advancements for their in vivo incorporation. This journey offers a glimpse into the promising developments in the years to come.

Advances in the Synthesis of Bioorthogonal Reagents: s-Tetrazines, 1,2,4-Triazines, Cyclooctynes, Heterocycloheptynes, and trans-Cyclooctenes

Aligned with the increasing importance of bioorthogonal chemistry has been an increasing demand for more potent, affordable, multifunctional, and programmable bioorthogonal reagents. More advanced synthetic chemistry techniques, including transition-metal-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions, C-H activation, photoinduced chemistry, and continuous flow chemistry, have been employed in synthesizing novel bioorthogonal reagents for universal purposes. We discuss herein recent developments regarding the synthesis of popular bioorthogonal reagents, with a focus on s-tetrazines, 1,2,4-triazines, trans-cyclooctenes, cyclooctynes, hetero-cycloheptynes, and -trans-cycloheptenes. This review aims to summarize and discuss the most representative synthetic approaches of these reagents and their derivatives that are useful in bioorthogonal chemistry. The preparation of these molecules and their derivatives utilizes both classical approaches as well as the latest organic chemistry methodologies.

Late-Stage Functionalization of Living Organisms: Rethinking Selectivity in Biology

With unlimited selectivity, full post-translational chemical control of biology would circumvent the dogma of genetic control. The resulting direct manipulation of organisms would enable atomic-level precision in "editing" of function. We argue that a key aspect that is still missing in our ability to do this (at least with a high degree of control) is the selectivity of a given chemical reaction in a living organism. In this Review, we systematize existing illustrative examples of chemical selectivity, as well as identify needed chemical selectivities set in a hierarchy of anatomical complexity: organismo- (selectivity for a given organism over another), tissuo- (selectivity for a given tissue type in a living organism), cellulo- (selectivity for a given cell type in an organism or tissue), and organelloselectivity (selectivity for a given organelle or discrete body within a cell). Finally, we analyze more traditional concepts such as regio-, chemo-, and stereoselective reactions where additionally appropriate. This survey of late-stage biomolecule methods emphasizes, where possible, functional consequences (i.e., biological function). In this way, we explore a concept of late-stage functionalization of living organisms (where "late" is taken to mean at a given state of an organism in time) in which programmed and selective chemical reactions take place in life. By building on precisely analyzed notions (e.g., mechanism and selectivity) we believe that the logic of chemical methodology might ultimately be applied to increasingly complex molecular constructs in biology. This could allow principles developed at the simple, small-molecule level to progress hierarchically even to manipulation of physiology.

Truncation-Free Genetic Code Expansion with Tetrazine Amino Acids for Quantitative Protein Ligations

Quantitative labeling of biomolecules is necessary to advance areas of antibody-drug conjugation, super-resolution microscopy imaging of molecules in live cells, and determination of the stoichiometry of protein complexes. Bio-orthogonal labeling to genetically encodable noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) offers an elegant solution; however, their suboptimal reactivity and stability hinder the utility of this method. Previously, we showed that encoding stable 1,2,4,5-tetrazine (Tet)-containing ncAAs enables rapid, complete conjugation, yet some expression conditions greatly limited the quantitative reactivity of the Tet-protein. Here, we demonstrate that reduction of on-protein Tet ncAAs impacts their reactivity, while the leading cause of the unreactive protein is near-cognate suppression (NCS) of UAG codons by endogenous aminoacylated tRNAs. To overcome incomplete conjugation due to NCS, we developed a more catalytically efficient tRNA synthetase and developed a series of new machinery plasmids harboring the aminoacyl tRNA synthetase/tRNA pair (aaRS/tRNA pair). These plasmids enable robust production of homogeneously reactive Tet-protein in truncation-free cell lines, eliminating the contamination caused by NCS and protein truncation. Furthermore, these plasmid systems utilize orthogonal synthetic origins, which render these machinery vectors compatible with any common expression system. Through developing these new machinery plasmids, we established that the aaRS/tRNA pair plasmid copy-number greatly affects the yields and quality of the protein produced. We then produced quantitatively reactive soluble Tet-Fabs, demonstrating the utility of this system for rapid, homogeneous conjugations of biomedically relevant proteins.

Genetic Code Expansion for Site-Specific Labeling of Antibodies with Radioisotopes

Due to their target specificity, antibody-drug conjugates─monoclonal antibodies conjugated to a cytotoxic moiety─are efficient therapeutics that can kill malignant cells overexpressing a target gene. Linking an antibody with radioisotopes (radioimmunoconjugates) enables powerful diagnostics and/or closely related therapeutic applications, depending on the isotope. To generate site-specific radioimmunoconjugates, we utilized genetic code expansion and subsequent conjugation by inverse electron-demand Diels-Alder cycloaddition reactions. We show that, using this approach, site-specific labeling of trastuzumab with either zirconium-89 (89Zr) for diagnostics or lutetium-177 (177Lu) for therapeutics yields efficient radioimmunoconjugates. Positron emission tomography imaging revealed a high accumulation of site-specifically 89Zr-labeled trastuzumab in tumors after 24 h and low accumulation in other organs. The corresponding 177Lu-trastuzumab radioimmunoconjugates were comparably distributed in vivo.

Synthetic Organelles for Multiple mRNA Selective Genetic Code Expansions in Eukaryotes

Engineering new functionalities into living eukaryotic systems is one of the main goals of synthetic biology. To this end, often enzyme evolution or de novo protein design is employed, which each have their own advantages and disadvantages. As complimentary tools, we recently developed orthogonally translating and film-like synthetic organelles that allow to create new enzyme functionalities based on spatial separation. We applied this technology to genetic code expansion (GCE) and showed that it is possible to equip eukaryotic cells with multiple orthogonal genetic codes that enable the specific reprogramming of distinct translational machineries, each with single-residue precision.In this protocol, we describe how synthetic organelles can be used to perform mRNA selective GCE and how they can be further developed to allow the simultaneous incorporation of distinct noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) into selected proteins and how this can be used to label proteins selectively with fluorescent dyes via bioorthogonal chemistry.

Quantitative Analysis and Optimization of Site-Specific Protein Bioconjugation in Mammalian Cells

Despite a range of covalent protein modifications, few techniques exist for quantification of protein bioconjugation in cells. Here, we describe a novel method for quantifying in cellulo protein bioconjugation through covalent bond formation with HaloTag. This approach utilizes unnatural amino acid (UAA) mutagenesis to selectively install a small and bioorthogonally reactive handle onto the surface of a protein. We utilized the fast kinetics and high selectivity of inverse electron-demand Diels-Alder cycloadditions to evaluate reactions of tetrazine phenylalanine (TetF) with strained trans-cyclooctene-chloroalkane (sTCO-CA) and trans-cyclooctene lysine (TCOK) with tetrazine-chloroalkane (Tet-CA). Following bioconjugation, the chloroalkane ligand is exposed for labeling by the HaloTag enzyme, allowing for straightforward quantification of bioconjugation via simple western blot analysis. We demonstrate the versatility of this tool for quickly and accurately determining the bioconjugation efficiency of different UAA/chloroalkane pairs and for different sites on different proteins of interest, including EGFP and the estrogen-related receptor ERRα.

A dark intermediate in the fluorogenic reaction between tetrazine fluorophores and trans-cyclooctene

Fluorogenic labeling via bioorthogonal tetrazine chemistry has proven to be highly successful in fluorescence microscopy of living cells. To date, trans-cyclooctene (TCO) and bicyclonyne have been found to be the most useful substrates for live-cell labeling owing to their fast labeling kinetics, high biocompatibility, and bioorthogonality. Recent kinetic studies of fluorogenic click reactions with TCO derivatives showed a transient fluorogenic effect but could not explain the reaction sequence and the contributions of different intermediates. More recently, fluorescence quenching by potential intermediates has been investigated, suggesting their occurrence in the reaction sequence. However, in situ studies of the click reaction that directly relate these observations to the known reaction sequence are still missing. In this study, we developed a single-molecule fluorescence detection framework to investigate fluorogenic click reactions. In combination with data from ultra-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry, this explains the transient intensity increase by relating fluorescent intermediates to the known reaction sequence of TCO with fluorogenic tetrazine dyes. More specifically, we confirm that the reaction of TCO with tetrazine rapidly forms a fluorescent 4,5-dihydropyridazine species that slowly tautomerizes to a weakly fluorescent 1,4-dihydropyridazine, explaining the observed drop in fluorescence intensity. On a much slower timescale of hours/days, the fluorescence intensity may be recovered by oxidation of the intermediate to a pyridazine. Our findings are of importance for quantitative applications in fluorescence microscopy and spectroscopy as the achieved peak intensity with TCO depends on the specific experimental settings. They clearly indicate the requirement for more robust benchmarking of click reactions with tetrazine dyes and the need for alternative dienophiles with fast reaction kinetics and stable fluorescence emission to further applications in advanced fluorescence microscopy.

Minimal genetically encoded tags for fluorescent protein labeling in living neurons

Modern light microscopy, including super-resolution techniques, has brought about a demand for small labeling tags that bring the fluorophore closer to the target. This challenge can be addressed by labeling unnatural amino acids (UAAs) with bioorthogonal click chemistry. The minimal size of the UAA and the possibility to couple the fluorophores directly to the protein of interest with single-residue precision in living cells make click labeling unique. Here, we establish click labeling in living primary neurons and use it for fixed-cell, live-cell, dual-color pulse-chase, and super-resolution microscopy of neurofilament light chain (NFL). We also show that click labeling can be combined with CRISPR/Cas9 genome engineering for tagging endogenous NFL. Due to its versatile nature and compatibility with advanced multicolor microscopy techniques, we anticipate that click labeling will contribute to novel discoveries in the neurobiology field.

Condensed, microtubule-coating thin organelles for orthogonal translation in mammalian cells

Membraneless organelles are capable of selectively performing complex tasks in living cells despite dynamically exchanging with their surroundings. This is an exquisite example how self-organization of proteins and RNAs can lead to more complex functionalities in living systems. Importantly, the absence of a membrane boundary can enable easier access to larger macromolecular complexes that can be challenging to be transported across a membrane. We previously formed orthogonally translating designer membraneless organelles by combining phase separation with kinesin motor proteins to highly enrich engineered translational factors in large organelles. We also showed that even submicron thick designer organelles can be formed, by mounting them onto membranes, which, presumable assisted by 2D condensation, leads to thin film-like condensates. In this study we show that orthogonal translation can also be built with fiber-like appearing organelles. Here, the microtubule-end binding protein EB1 was used to form fiber-like OT organelles along the microtubule cytoskeleton that perform highly selective and efficient orthogonal translation. We also show an improved simplified design of OT organelles. Together this extends OT technology and demonstrates that the microtubule cytoskeleton is a powerful platform for advanced synthetic organelle engineering.

Visualizing the complexity of proteins in living cells with genetic code expansion

Genetic code expansion has emerged as an enabling tool to provide insight into functions of understudied proteinogenic species, such as small proteins and peptides, and to probe protein biophysics in the cellular context. Here, we discuss recent technical advances and applications of genetic code expansion in cellular imaging of complex mammalian protein species, along with considerations and challenges on using the method.

Dual film-like organelles enable spatial separation of orthogonal eukaryotic translation

Engineering new functionality into living eukaryotic systems by enzyme evolution or de novo protein design is a formidable challenge. Cells do not rely exclusively on DNA-based evolution to generate new functionality but often utilize membrane encapsulation or formation of membraneless organelles to separate distinct molecular processes that execute complex operations. Applying this principle and the concept of two-dimensional phase separation, we develop film-like synthetic organelles that support protein translation on the surfaces of various cellular membranes. These sub-resolution synthetic films provide a path to make functionally distinct enzymes within the same cell. We use these film-like organelles to equip eukaryotic cells with dual orthogonal expanded genetic codes that enable the specific reprogramming of distinct translational machineries with single-residue precision. The ability to spatially tune the output of translation within tens of nanometers is not only important for synthetic biology but has implications for understanding the function of membrane-associated protein condensation in cells.

•

2D phase separation was utilized to design orthogonal enzymes

•

Film-like organelles maintained distinct suppressor tRNA microenvironments

•

Dual film-like synthetic organelles enabled orthogonal translation in eukaryotes

•

Cells were equipped with two expanded genetic codes in addition to the canonical one

Synthesis and Evaluation of Novel Ring-Strained Noncanonical Amino Acids for Residue-Specific Bioorthogonal Reactions in Living Cells

Bioorthogonal reactions are ideally suited to selectively modify proteins in complex environments, even in vivo. Kinetics and product stability of these reactions are crucial parameters to evaluate their usefulness for specific applications. Strain promoted inverse electron demand Diels-Alder cycloadditions (SPIEDAC) between tetrazines and strained alkenes or alkynes are particularly popular, as they allow ultrafast labeling inside cells. In combination with genetic code expansion (GCE)-a method that allows to incorporate noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) site-specifically into proteins in vivo. These reactions enable residue-specific fluorophore attachment to proteins in living mammalian cells. Several SPIEDAC capable ncAAs have been presented and studied under diverse conditions, revealing different instabilities ranging from educt decomposition to product loss due to β-elimination. To identify which compounds yield the best labeling inside living mammalian cells has frequently been difficult. In this study we present a) the synthesis of four new SPIEDAC reactive ncAAs that cannot undergo β-elimination and b) a fluorescence flow cytometry based FRET-assay to measure reaction kinetics inside living cells. Our results, which at first sight can be seen conflicting with some other studies, capture GCE-specific experimental conditions, such as long-term exposure of the ring-strained ncAA to living cells, that are not taken into account in other assays.