Morphometric modifications associated with early sensory experience in the rat olfactory bulb: II. Stereological study of the population of olfactory glomeruli

Anatomical and Functional Connectivity at the Dendrodendritic Reciprocal Mitral Cell-Granule Cell Synapse: Impact on Recurrent and Lateral Inhibition

In the vertebrate olfactory bulb, reciprocal dendrodendritic interactions between its principal neurons, the mitral and tufted cells, and inhibitory interneurons in the external plexiform layer mediate both recurrent and lateral inhibition, with the most numerous of these interneurons being granule cells. Here, we used recently established anatomical parameters and functional data on unitary synaptic transmission to simulate the strength of recurrent inhibition of mitral cells specifically from the reciprocal spines of rat olfactory bulb granule cells in a quantitative manner. Our functional data allowed us to derive a unitary synaptic conductance on the order of 0.2 nS. The simulations predicted that somatic voltage deflections by even proximal individual granule cell inputs are below the detection threshold and that attenuation with distance is roughly linear, with a passive length constant of 650 μm. However, since recurrent inhibition in the wake of a mitral cell action potential will originate from hundreds of reciprocal spines, the summated recurrent IPSP will be much larger, even though there will be substantial mutual shunting across the many inputs. Next, we updated and refined a preexisting model of connectivity within the entire rat olfactory bulb, first between pairs of mitral and granule cells, to estimate the likelihood and impact of recurrent inhibition depending on the distance between cells. Moreover, to characterize the substrate of lateral inhibition, we estimated the connectivity via granule cells between any two mitral cells or all the mitral cells that belong to a functional glomerular ensemble (i.e., which receive their input from the same glomerulus), again as a function of the distance between mitral cells and/or entire glomerular mitral cell ensembles. Our results predict the extent of the three regimes of anatomical connectivity between glomerular ensembles: high connectivity within a glomerular ensemble and across the first four rings of adjacent glomeruli, substantial connectivity to up to eleven glomeruli away, and negligible connectivity beyond. Finally, in a first attempt to estimate the functional strength of granule-cell mediated lateral inhibition, we combined this anatomical estimate with our above simulation results on attenuation with distance, resulting in slightly narrowed regimes of a functional impact compared to the anatomical connectivity.

Scaling Principles of Distributed Circuits

Identifying shared quantitative features of a neural circuit across species is important for 3 reasons. Often expressed in the form of power laws and called scaling relationships [1, 2], they reveal organizational principles of circuits, make insights gleaned from model systems widely applicable, and explain circuit performance and function, e.g., visual circuits [3, 4]. The visual circuit is topographic [5, 6], wherein retinal neurons target and activate predictable spatial loci in primary visual cortex. The brain, however, contains many circuits, where neuronal targets and activity are unpredictable and distributed throughout the circuit, e.g., olfactory circuits, in which glomeruli (or mitral cells) in the olfactory bulb synapse with neurons distributed throughout the piriform cortex [7-10]. It is unknown whether such circuits, which we term distributed circuits, are scalable. To determine whether distributed circuits scale, we obtained quantitative descriptions of the olfactory bulb and piriform cortex in six mammals using stereology techniques and light microscopy. Two conserved features provide evidence of scalability. First, the number of piriform neurons n and bulb glomeruli g scale as n∼g^3/2. Second, the average number of synapses between a bulb glomerulus and piriform neuron is invariant at one. Using theory and modeling, we show that these two features preserve the discriminatory ability and precision of odor information across the olfactory circuit. As both abilities depend on circuit size, manipulating size provides evolution with a way to adapt a species to its niche without designing developmental programs de novo. These principles might apply to other distributed circuits like the hippocampus.

Determination of the connectivity of newborn neurons in mammalian olfactory circuits

The mammalian olfactory bulb is a forebrain structure just one synapse downstream from the olfactory sensory neurons and performs the complex computations of sensory inputs. The formation of this sensory circuit is shaped through activity-dependent and cell-intrinsic mechanisms. Recent studies have revealed that cell-type specific connectivity and the organization of synapses in dendritic compartments are determined through cell-intrinsic programs already preset in progenitor cells. These progenitor programs give rise to subpopulations within a neuron type that have distinct synaptic organizations. The intrinsically determined formation of distinct synaptic organizations requires factors from contacting cells that match the cell-intrinsic programs. While certain genes control wiring within the newly generated neurons, other regulatory genes provide intercellular signals and are only expressed in neurons that will form contacts with the newly generated cells. Here, the olfactory system has provided a useful model circuit to reveal the factors regulating assembly of the highly structured connectivity in mammals.

Activity-dependent changes in cholinergic innervation of the mouse olfactory bulb

The interplay between olfactory activity and cholinergic modulation remains to be fully understood. This report examines the pattern of cholinergic innervation throughout the murine main olfactory bulb across different developmental stages and in naris-occluded animals. To visualize the pattern of cholinergic innervation, we used a transgenic mouse model, which expresses a fusion of the microtubule-associated protein, tau, with green fluorescence protein (GFP) under the control of the choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) promoter. This tau-GFP fusion product allows for a remarkably vivid and clear visualization of cholinergic innervation in the main olfactory bulb (MOB). Interestingly, we find an uneven distribution of GFP label in the adult glomerular layer (GL), where anterior, medial, and lateral glomerular regions of the bulb receive relatively heavier cholinergic innervation than other regions. In contrast to previous reports, we find a marked change in the pattern of cholinergic innervation to the GL following unilateral naris occlusion between the ipsilateral and contralateral bulbs in adult animals.

Odorants with multiple oxygen-containing functional groups and other odorants with high water solubility preferentially activate posterior olfactory bulb glomeruli

In past studies in which we mapped 2-deoxyglucose uptake evoked by systematically different odorant chemicals across the entire rat olfactory bulb, glomerular responses could be related to each odorant's particular oxygen-containing functional group. In the present study we tested whether aliphatic odorants containing two such functional groups (esters, ketones, acids, alcohols, and ethers) would stimulate the combination of glomerular regions that are associated with each of the functional groups separately, or whether they would evoke unique responses in different regions of the bulb. We found that these very highly water-soluble molecules rarely evoked activity in the regions responding to the individual functional groups; instead, they activated posterior glomeruli located about halfway between the dorsal and ventral extremes in both the lateral and the medial aspects of the bulb. Additional highly water-soluble odorants, including very small molecules with single oxygenic groups, also strongly stimulated these posterior regions, resulting in a statistically significant correlation between posterior 2-deoxyglucose uptake and molecular properties associated with water solubility. By showing that highly water-soluble odorants stimulate a part of the bulb associated with peripheral and ventral regions of the epithelium, our results challenge a prevalent notion that such odorants would activate class I odorant receptors located in zone 1 of the olfactory epithelium, which projects to the dorsal aspect of the bulb.

fMRI visualization of transient activations in the rat olfactory bulb using short odor stimulations

Odor-evoked activity in the olfactory bulb displays both spatial and temporal organization. The difficulty when assessing spatio-temporal dynamics of olfactory representation is to find a method that reconciles the appropriate resolution for both dimensions. Imaging methods based on optical recordings can reach high temporal and spatial resolution but are limited to the observation of the accessible dorsal surface. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) may be useful to overcome this limitation as it allows recording from the whole brain. In this study, we combined ultra fast imaging sequence and short stimulus duration to improve temporal resolution of odor-evoked BOLD responses. Short odor stimulations evoked high amplitude BOLD responses and patterns of activation were similar to those obtained in previous studies using longer stimulations. Moreover, short odor exposures prevented habituation processes. Analysis of the BOLD signal time course in the different areas of activation revealed that odorant response maps are not static entities but rather are temporally dynamic as reported by recent studies using optical imaging. These data demonstrated that fMRI is a non-invasive method which could represent a powerful tool to study not only the spatial dimension of odor representation but also the temporal dimension of information processing.

Olfactory discrimination deficits in mice lacking the dopamine transporter or the D2 dopamine receptor

Previous pharmacological studies have implicated dopamine as a modulator of olfactory bulb processing. Several disorders characterized by altered dopamine homeostasis in olfaction-related brain regions display olfactory deficits. To further characterize the role of dopamine in olfactory processing, we subjected dopamine transporter knockout mice (DAT -/-) and dopamine receptor 2 knockout mice (D2 -/-) to a battery of olfactory tests. In addition to behavioral characterization, several neurochemical markers of olfactory bulb integrity and function were examined. DAT -/- mice displayed an olfactory discrimination deficit, but did not differ detectably from DAT wildtype (DAT +/+) mice in odor habituation, olfactory sensitivity, or odor recognition memory. Neurochemically, DAT -/- mice have decreased D2 receptor staining in the periglomerular layer of the olfactory bulb and increased tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactivity compared to DAT +/+ controls. D2 -/- mice exhibited the same olfactory deficit as the DAT -/- mice, further supporting the role of dopamine at the D2 synapse in olfactory discrimination processing. The findings presented in this paper reinforce the functional significance of dopamine and more specifically the D2 receptor in olfactory discrimination and may help explain the behavioral phenotype in the DAT and D2 knockout mice.

Evidence for the disproportionate mapping of olfactory airspace onto the main olfactory bulb of the hamster

Olfactory receptor neurons (ORNs) project to the rodent main olfactory bulb (MOB) from spatially distinct air channels in the olfactory recesses of the nose. The relatively smooth central channels of the dorsal meatus map onto the dorsal MOB, whereas the highly convoluted peripheral channels of the ethmoid turbinates project to the ventral MOB. Medial and lateral components of each projection stream innervate the medial and lateral MOB, respectively. To ascertain whether such topography entails the disproportionate representation seen in other sensory maps, we used disector-based stereological techniques in hamsters to estimate the number of ORNs associated with each channel in the nose and the number of their targets (glomeruli and mitral and tufted cells) in corresponding divisions of the MOB. Each circumferential half of the MOB (dorsal/ventral, medial/lateral) contained about 50% of the 3,100 glomeruli and about 50% of the 160,000 mitral and tufted cells per bulb. We found equivalent numbers of ORNs with dendritic knobs in the medial and lateral channels (4.5 million each). However, the central channels had only 2 million knobbed ORNs, whereas the peripheral channels had 7 million. Thus, there is a disproportionate mapping of the central-peripheral axis of olfactory airspace onto the dorsal-ventral axis of the MOB, encompassing a greater than threefold variation in the average convergence of ORNs onto MOB secondary neurons. We hypothesize that the disproportionate projections help to optimize chemospecific processing by compensating, with differing sensitivity, for significant variation in the distribution and concentration of odorant molecules along the olfactory air channels during sniffing.

Effects of unilateral deprivation in postnatal development of the olfactory bulb in an altricial rodent, the gerbil (Meriones unguiculatus)

To establish if olfactory bulb sensitivity to functional deprivation is related to the degree of development at birth, we studied the effects of surgical closure of one naris in the gerbil olfactory bulb development. The naris closure was performed at three different ages: at birth, P7 and P14 and maintained for 30 or 60 days. In coronal sections we measured total bulbar surface area and surface area of the different bulbar layers establishing an estimate multiple regression model for the percentage of surface area decrease in the deprived bulb related to non deprived one. The internal and external plexiform layers are the most sensitive layers to deprivation and age and duration of deprivation were factors in their mathematical models. The glomerular layer showed a surface reduction of about 25% without dependence either on age or duration. The deprived glomerular layer showed a much lower tyrosine hydroxylase-immunoreactivity and immunoreactive cell density than those in the non deprived one. However, differences in calbindin-immunoreactive and NADPH-diaphorase positive cell density between deprived and non deprived glomerular layer were not significant. Our results indicate that olfactory bulb sensitivity to functional deprivation is not related to the degree of precocity and changes in age and duration of deprivation cause different effects on the olfactory bulb layers.

Synchronized oscillatory discharges of mitral/tufted cells with different molecular receptive ranges in the rabbit olfactory bulb

Individual glomeruli in the mammalian olfactory bulb represent a single or a few type(s) of odorant receptors. Signals from different types of receptors are thus sorted out into different glomeruli. How does the neuronal circuit in the olfactory bulb contribute to the combination and integration of signals received by different glomeruli? Here we examined electrophysiologically whether there were functional interactions between mitral/tufted cells associated with different glomeruli in the rabbit olfactory bulb. First, we made simultaneous recordings of extracellular single-unit spike responses of mitral/tufted cells and oscillatory local field potentials in the dorsomedial fatty acid-responsive region of the olfactory bulb in urethan-anesthetized rabbits. Using periodic artificial inhalation, the olfactory epithelium was stimulated with a homologous series of n-fatty acids or n-aliphatic aldehydes. The odor-evoked spike discharges of mitral/tufted cells tended to phase-lock to the oscillatory local field potential, suggesting that spike discharges of many cells occur synchronously during odor stimulation. We then made simultaneous recordings of spike discharges from pairs of mitral/tufted cells located 300-500 microm apart and performed a cross-correlation analysis of their spike responses to odor stimulation. In approximately 27% of cell pairs examined, two cells with distinct molecular receptive ranges showed synchronized oscillatory discharges when olfactory epithelium was stimulated with one or a mixture of odorant(s) effective in activating both. The results suggest that the neuronal circuit in the olfactory bulb causes synchronized spike discharges of specific pairs of mitral/tufted cells associated with different glomeruli and the synchronization of odor-evoked spike discharges may contribute to the temporal binding of signals derived from different types of odorant receptor.

A re-estimation of the number of glomeruli and mitral cells in the olfactory bulb of rabbit

Although morphological characteristics of mammalian olfactory bulb (OB) are well documented in rodents (rat, mice), only one study has been performed in rabbit, which is also commonly used in olfactory research. The study carried out by Allison and Warwick in 1949 led to surprising results still quoted in recent literature. The present study re-examined this question in young rabbit OB, while it was also conducted with rat as control. In five animals of each species, areas and coordinates of glomeruli and mitral profiles were measured in 10 coronal sections uniformly distributed along the rostrocaudal axis of the OB, and a distribution-free stereological method was used to compute values along this axis. For glomeruli, the estimated number was 4200 in rat and 6300 in rabbit. While this estimation matched with those found in literature in rat, it strikingly differed from the Allison and Warwick's value of 1900 only. For mitral cell number, we found 59,600 while the preceding study found 45,000 only. In contrast to the number of glomeruli, the mitral cell number in rat and rabbit were very close. Indeed, results showed 56, 200 in rat. The results suggest that the numbers of olfactory glomeruli and mitral cells has been previously underestimated in rabbit, and that the number of glomeruli changes as a function of species. In addition, both the results of the present study and reports in the literature suggest the number of mitral cells to be rather similar in mouse, rat and rabbit. As a consequence, the glomerular/mitral cell ratio is likely to varied in a wide range across species.

Unilateral naris closure and olfactory system development

In most animals there is bilateral access of odorants to the olfactory sensory epithelium. Air enters the nose through two external nares and passes back through the nasal cavity, which is divided down the midline by a cartilaginous nasal septum. The olfactory mucosa, a sheet of ciliated bipolar receptor cells, is found in the caudal two thirds of the nasal cavity. Axons from the sensory cells project to an ipsilateral extension of the telencephalon known as the olfactory bulb. If a single external naris of a rat pup is surgically closed (usually via brief cauterization) on the day after the day of birth (P1) and the subject is examined on P30, the size of the ipsilateral olfactory bulb is reduced by approximately 25%. The large reduction in size, coupled with the clear lamination and other features of the olfactory system, indicates that the manipulation is an ideal preparation for examining the regulation of early growth. We know that both olfactory bulbs are of equal size at the time of occlusion, but that 30 days later there is a large discrepancy. What series of events produces the changes? The present paper outlines what is known about the anatomical, biochemical and physiological changes introduced by naris occlusion in order to lay a framework for further work.

Organization of the septal organ projection to the main olfactory bulb in adult and newborn rats

The septal organ, which is regarded as an olfactory subsystem, is a small patch of sensory epithelium located ventral to the main olfactory sheet on the septal wall of the nasal cavity. The only consensus to date regarding some proper area of projection of this subsystem is that the septal organ projects to the medial aspect of the main olfactory bulb. The purpose of our study was to analyze precisely the topographical organization of the bulbar projection of the septal organ in adult rats and in 3- to 15-day-old rats following WGA-HRP placements at the level of the septal epithelium. Results show that the septal organ projects exclusively to the posterior half of the main olfactory bulb and its projection area is mainly restricted to the ventromedial bulbar aspect. When the septal organ was fully injected, the pattern of bulbar projection was characterized by two types of glomerular labeling: 1) presence of single heavily labeled glomeruli identified as "septal" glomeruli, since they were mainly built up by afferents coming from the septal organ and (2) presence of a thin network of labeled septal fibers distributed in glomeruli which were mainly formed by afferents coming from the main olfactory epithelium. Although the pattern of mucosobulbar projection of the septal organ is already established in newborns, a significant increase in the number of "septal" glomeruli occurs during the first 15 postnatal days. Anatomical data indicate that even if the projection of the septal organ does not appear completely segregated in the olfactory bulb, this projection is not either exactly similar to that of the main olfactory epithelium.

Morphological variations among output neurons of the olfactory bulb in the frog (Rana ridibunda)

Morphological properties of putative output cells have been studied in detail in the olfactory bulb of frogs (Rana ridibunda). Intracellular injection of Lucifer Yellow was used to reconstruct individual neurons. Ten different anatomical features related to cell shape and position were studied quantitatively. The results show that output cells, generally considered to be a homogeneous group in the olfactory bulb of amphibians, are, in fact, quite different in their morphology. Using multidimensional analysis to examine differences among the output neurons, we found that they might be divided into at least two groups. In one group, the cell somata were located near the glomerular layer and the dendrites lay at large angles with respect to each other. In the other group, the cell somata were farther from the glomerular layer and their dendrites lay at smaller angles. From their morphology, these two cell groups appear to be homologous, respectively, to the superficial/middle tufted cells and deep tufted/mitral cells of mammals.

Mitral cell-to-glomerulus connectivity: an HRP study of the orientation of mitral cell apical dendrites

It has been suggested that the principal output cells of the main olfactory bulb, the mitral cells, along with the glomerulus they enter, form an anatomical and functional column. To test the extent to which mitral cell somata lying close together in the mitral cell layer are connected to the same glomerulus, we reconstructed 267 mitral cells labeled by extracellular injections of horseradish peroxidase (HRP) in the external plexiform layer. Results show that apical dendrites tilt rostrally from the somata to the glomeruli and this tilt is gradually greater as the somata are located more and more rostrally in the olfactory bulb. The apical dendrites of most mitral cells in the same region of the bulb are parallel. We analyzed the degree to which dendrites were parallel by measuring the difference in angle of all pairs of apical dendrites in each section, with the restriction that no cells were separated by more than 500 microns. About half of these pairs of dendrites differed in angle by 20 degrees or less and were therefore said to be parallel. The degree of parallelism did not vary with the cell pair location or with intercell distance. Study of glomerular connections of pairs of mitral cells as a function of intercell distance revealed that 96% of mitral cells connected to the same glomerulus were separated by less than 120 microns, while 72% of cells connected to adjacent glomeruli and only 29% of cells connected to distant, i.e., nonadjacent, glomeruli were separated by less than 120 microns.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Stereology: a method for analyzing images

This review deals with notions of shape, sizes, numbers, densities and orientation in space, all basic concepts in stereology. With the initiation by Delesse in 1847, but mainly since the beginning of the XXth century, many stereological methods have been published allowing us to relate two-dimensional measurements easily obtainable on flat histological images with three-dimensional characteristics of the structure analysed. Looking at these methods, the neurobiologist, generally impermeable to concepts of sampling, statistical bias, efficiency, cost of effort and distribution-free, is discountenanced and continues old laboratory usages and customs. Furthermore, for the last ten years, the advent of a plethora of new powerful tools, considered as assumption-free and more efficient than the previous ones, increase the risk proportionately the disarray of the potential user. The purpose of this review is to present synthetically all traditional and actual aspects of stereology in order to guide the reader in the labyrinth of this speciality. The necessarily short exposition is compensated by many references to which the beginner or the initiated can refer.