Attenuation of chemically induced anxiogenic stimuli as a novel method for evaluating anxiolytic drugs: A comparison of clobazam with other benzodiazepines

What Is It Like to Be a Bass? Red Herrings, Fish Pain and the Study of Animal Sentience

Debates around fishes' ability to feel pain concern sentience: do reactions to tissue damage indicate evaluative consciousness (conscious affect), or mere nociception? Thanks to Braithwaite's discovery of trout nociceptors, and concerns that current practices could compromise welfare in countless fish, this issue's importance is beyond dispute. However, nociceptors are merely necessary, not sufficient, for true pain, and many measures held to indicate sentience have the same problem. The question of whether fish feel pain - or indeed anything at all - therefore stimulates sometimes polarized debate. Here, we try to bridge the divide. After reviewing key consciousness concepts, we identify "red herring" measures that should not be used to infer sentience because also present in non-sentient organisms, notably those lacking nervous systems, like plants and protozoa (P); spines disconnected from brains (S); decerebrate mammals and birds (D); and humans in unaware states (U). These "S.P.U.D. subjects" can show approach/withdrawal; react with apparent emotion; change their reactivity with food deprivation or analgesia; discriminate between stimuli; display Pavlovian learning, including some forms of trace conditioning; and even learn simple instrumental responses. Consequently, none of these responses are good indicators of sentience. Potentially more valid are aspects of working memory, operant conditioning, the self-report of state, and forms of higher order cognition. We suggest new experiments on humans to test these hypotheses, as well as modifications to tests for "mental time travel" and self-awareness (e.g., mirror self-recognition) that could allow these to now probe sentience (since currently they reflect perceptual rather than evaluative, affective aspects of consciousness). Because "bullet-proof" neurological and behavioral indicators of sentience are thus still lacking, agnosticism about fish sentience remains widespread. To end, we address how to balance such doubts with welfare protection, discussing concerns raised by key skeptics in this debate. Overall, we celebrate the rigorous evidential standards required by those unconvinced that fish are sentient; laud the compassion and ethical rigor shown by those advocating for welfare protections; and seek to show how precautionary principles still support protecting fish from physical harm.

Aggression, anxiety and vocalizations in animals: GABAA and 5-HT anxiolytics

A continuing challenge for preclinical research on anxiolytic drugs is to capture the affective dimension that characterizes anxiety and aggression, either in their adaptive forms or when they become of clinical concern. Experimental protocols for the preclinical study of anxiolytic drugs typically involve the suppression of conditioned or unconditioned social and exploratory behavior (e.g., punished drinking or social interactions) and demonstrate the reversal of this behavioral suppression by drugs acting on the benzodiazepine-GABAA complex. Less frequently, aversive events engender increases in conditioned or unconditioned behavior that are reversed by anxiolytic drugs (e.g., fear-potentiated startle). More recently, putative anxiolytics which target 5-HT receptor subtypes produced effects in these traditional protocols that often are not systematic and robust. We propose ethological studies of vocal expressions in rodents and primates during social confrontations, separation from social companions, or exposure to aversive environmental events as promising sources of information on the affective features of behavior. This approach focuses on vocal and other display behavior with clear functional validity and homology. Drugs with anxiolytic effects that act on the benzodiazepine-GABAA receptor complex and on 5-HT1A receptors systematically and potently alter specific vocalizations in rodents and primates in a pharmacologically reversible manner; the specificity of these effects on vocalizations is evident due to the effectiveness of low doses that do not compromise other physiological and behavioral processes. Antagonists at the benzodiazepine receptor reverse the effects of full agonists on vocalizations, particularly when these occur in threatening, startling and distressing contexts. With the development of antagonists at 5-HT receptor subtypes, it can be anticipated that similar receptor-specificity can be established for the effects of 5-HT anxiolytics.

Defeat engenders pentylenetetrazole-appropriate responding in rats: antagonism by midazolam

Defeat and the threat of defeat by an aggressive conspecific is stressful and may engender an anxiety- or fear-like state in animals; the present experiment investigated whether defeat generalized to the discriminative stimulus properties of PTZ and how benzodiazepine receptors were involved in this generalization. Separate groups of male Long-Evans rats (Rattus norvegicus) were trained to discriminate 20 mg/kg pentylenetetrazole (PTZ) or 0.4 mg/kg midazolam (MDZ) from saline in a two-choice drug-discrimination task. After establishing stimulus control, PTZ- and MDZ-trained rats were exposed to an aggressive conspecific which resulted in defeat, as defined by the display of defensive and submissive postures as well as audible and ultrasonic vocalizations. Administration of saline after defeat resulted in greater than 80% PTZ lever selection in 15 out of 25 PTZ-trained rats; this effect was attenuated through pretreatment with MDZ (1 mg/kg). Furthermore, short-term defeat substitution for the PTZ discriminative stimulus was not accompanied by long-term changes in the post-defeat generalization curves for PTZ and MDZ when compared to pre-defeat generalization curves. Nor did defeat alter the antagonism of PTZ by diazepam (2.5 mg/kg) or MDZ by flumazenil (10 mg/kg). In order further to characterize the necessary features for defeat substitution for the PTZ discriminative stimulus, exposure to a threatening conspecific was also attempted by PTZ-trained rats protected from physical contact with a wire mesh cage. In these tests, saline continued to engender greater than 50% PTZ lever responding in 15 of 25 rats.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Maternal adrenalectomy and adult offspring in a conflict situation in the rat

The effects of the absence of maternal adrenals during pregnancy (P), during lactation (L), during pregnancy and lactation (PL) were studied on pain suppressed behavior (punished drinking test) of the adult offspring in comparison with controls (C). The female L offspring showed a lower responsiveness to the anxiogenic stimulus, as demonstrated by increased water intake, decreased percentage of ineffective licks, and decreased time to perform 300 licks compared to C. The male L behavior was not affected. Reduced growth was not responsible for the reduced anxiogenic reactivity because also both male and female PL offspring had lower weight than C, but did not show any significant effect. Pain threshold in the tail flick test was the same in all types of offspring. Thus, absence of maternal adrenals, specifically during lactation, significantly affects behavior of female offspring. It is discussed whether this is due to the lack of a physiological influence of maternal adrenal hormones on brain ontogenesis (hippocampal glucocorticoid receptors), or on the development of the brain-pituitary-adrenal system during neonatal life of the offspring.

The discriminative stimulus produced by pentylenetetrazol: effects of systemic anxiolytics and anxiogenics, aggressive defeat and midazolam or muscimol infused into the amygdala

Rats were trained to discriminate the interoceptive stimulus generated by systemic administration of pentylenetetrazol. A series of experiments confirmed earlier studies that rats generalized to the pentylenetetrazol cue following treatment with drugs purported to have anxiogenic properties, such as β-carboline carboxylic acid (βCCM) and FG 7142. The benzodiazepine antagonist, Ro 15-1788, did not generalize to the pentylenetetrazol cue. Anxiolytic drugs, such as the benzodiazepines chlordiazepoxide and midazolam, prevented discrimination of the pentylenetetrazol cue and resulted in generalization to the saline vehicle. Ritanserin, a 5-HT(2) receptor antagonist and putative anxiolytic compound, did not prevent discrimination of the pentylenetetrazol cue. Subjecting the rats to aggressive defeat in a home cage intruder test (following injection of saline) resulted in a significant proportion of them generalizing to the pentylenetetrazol discriminative stimulus. This result is discussed in terms of the suggested anxiogenic nature of the effects of treatment with pentylenetetrazol. Infusion of midazolam bilaterally into the amygdala antagonized, in a dose-dependent manner, dis crimination of the interoceptive stimulus generated by systemic treatment with FG 7142 (which itself generalized to the pentylenetetrazol cue). Furthermore, infusion of the GABA agonist, muscimol, bilaterally into the amygdala antagonized the pentylenetetrazol discri minative stimulus in a dose-dependent manner. These data suggest that amygdaloid mech anisms may be involved in the generation or discrimination of the distinctive, interoceptive stimuli associated with pentylenetetrazol and the β-carboline, FG 7142. The data are discussed in the context of suggested functions of the amygdaloid complex in fear-motivated behaviour.

Anxiety in the rat is associated with decreased release of 5-HT and glycine from the hippocampus

Rats, implanted with dialysis loops in the dorsal hippocampus, were injected with subconvulsant doses of pentylenetetrazole (PTZ 15 and 30 mg/kg) and a 30-min sample collected for high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis of amines and amino acids. Immediately after the sampling period they were given a 5-min test in the elevated plus-maze. On the basis of their performance in this test, they were divided into an 'anxious' and a 'non-anxious' group. The anxious group had significantly lower levels of glycine and serotonin (5-HT) release. Although PTZ decreased the release of noradrenaline, this was not correlated with behavioural differences in the elevated plus-maze.

Effects of beta-carbolines in animal models of anxiety

Animal models of anxiety can be classified into three main groups: those based on conflict or conditioned fear; those exploiting the anxiety produced by novelty; those in which anxiety or aversion is chemically induced. This review briefly describes the existing tests and, where available, the results obtained with beta-carbolines. Many of the beta-carbolines are anxiogenic in the tests, however ZK 91296 and ZK 93423 appear to have anxiolytic properties, and ZK 93426 has a similar profile to that of the benzodiazepine receptor antagonist RO 15-1788. By the results across the spectrum of tests, the reliability and sensitivity of the tests is assessed. The evidence that the anxiogenic and anxiolytic actions of the beta-carbolines are mediated by the BDZ binding sites is also discussed.

Actions of the beta-carboline ZK 93426 in an animal test of anxiety and the holeboard: interactions with Ro 15-1788

The effects of the beta-carboline ZK 93426, a putative benzodiazepine receptor antagonist, were investigated in the social interaction test of anxiety and in the holeboard. Like the receptor antagonist Ro 15-1788, ZK 93426 (2.5-10 mg/kg) caused a specific reduction in social interaction (interpreted as an anxiogenic effect) and caused a significant elevation in exploratory head-dipping (5 mg/kg). When low (ineffective) doses of both compounds (1 mg/kg ZK 93426; 4 mg/kg Ro 15-1788) were administered together they significantly reduced social interaction. No further reductions in social interaction were observed when effective doses of both compounds (5 mg/kg ZK 93426; 10 mg/kg Ro 15-1788) were tested in combination; it is likely that this is due to almost total benzodiazepine receptor occupancy at effective doses of either compound. When doses of each compound (5 mg/kg ZK 93426; 10 mg/kg Ro 15-1788) that resulted in stimulation of head-dipping were examined in combination, the elevation in exploration was no longer observed. Since at higher doses of both compounds there is an attenuation of the elevation in head-dipping, it is again likely that the effects of the two compounds are additive.

Intrinsic actions of the benzodiazepine receptor antagonist Ro 15-1788

The imidazodiazepine Ro 15-1788 is a benzodiazepine receptor antagonist that was initially reported to be lacking in intrinsic activity in a variety of test situations in which benzodiazepine-like effects can be identified. However, many recent studies have shown that this compound does indeed have intrinsic activity in a variety of behavioural, neurological, electrophysiological and biochemical preparations in both animals and man. The purpose of the present review is firstly to describe these intrinsic actions, and secondly to consider to what extent these intrinsic actions of Ro 15-1788 have implications for current concepts of the functioning of the benzodiazepine receptor.

Can drug effects on anxiety and convulsions be separated?

The effects of benzodiazepines, barbiturates, a series of novel putative anxiolytic compounds and anxiogenic compounds are reviewed in animal tests of anxiety and on experimentally-induced seizures. It is clear from the data that drug effects on anxiety and convulsions are not always in the same direction; certain compounds are apparently both anxiolytic and proconvulsant, others are anxiogenic and anticonvulsant, others have varied effects depending on the test situation. It is suggested that this work necessitates considerable revision of our traditional concepts of an "anticonvulsant." The extent to which drug-induced anxiety is correlated with weak epileptiform activity in the brain is discussed. Finally, the Discussion considers a number of possible mechanisms that could underlie the separation of drug effects on anxiety and convulsions that is observed.

The anxiogenic action of RO 5-4864 in the social interaction test: effect of chlordiazepoxide, RO 15-1788 and CGS 8216

RO 5-4864 (20 mg/kg), a benzodiazepine with high affinity for peripheral-type benzodiazepine binding sites in rat kidney and brain, but not for the "classical" CNS sites, reduced the time spent by pairs of rats in active social interaction, without reducing locomotor activity, possibly reflecting an anxiogenic action. This anxiogenic effect was not reversed by chlordiazepoxide (5 or 10 mg/kg) given acutely, but was reversed by chlordiazepoxide (5 mg/kg) given for 5 days prior to testing. RO 15-1788 (10 mg/kg), a drug that antagonises several effects of benzodiazepines but has little affinity for peripheral-type sites, had no action on the reduction in social interaction induced by RO 5-4864. However, CGS 8216 (10 mg/kg) which also antagonises the effects of benzodiazepines and has little affinity for RO 5-4864 recognition sites, significantly enhanced the reduction in social interaction caused by RO 5-4864, and the combination produced a significant decrease in locomotor activity. These results are discussed in terms of possible sites of action of RO 5-4864 on the GABA-benzodiazepine receptor complex.

Behavioural effects of pentylenetetrazole reversed by chlordiazepoxide and enhanced by RO 15-1788

The effects of low doses of pentylenetetrazole (PTZ) on exploratory behaviour and locomotor activity in the rat, were measured in the holeboard apparatus. PTZ (30 mg/kg) significantly reduced exploratory head-dipping, an effect that was significantly reversed by chlordiazepoxide (5 mg/kg) and enhanced by RO 15-1788 (20 mg/kg). RO 15-1788 (20 mg/kg) also significantly enhanced the reduction in locomotor activity produced by PTZ (30 mg/kg); although this reduction was not reversed by chlordiazepoxide (5 mg/kg) the reduction in locomotor activity with the drug combination was no greater than that with either drug alone. The results are discussed with respect to a coupling between the benzodiazepine receptors and the site at which PTZ acts.

Discriminative stimulus properties of beta-carbolines characterized as agonists and inverse agonists at central benzodiazepine receptors

The discriminative stimulus properties of three beta-carboline derivatives were studied in three groups of rats trained, respectively, to discriminate diazepam (2.5 mg/kg IP), chlordiazepoxide (CDP, 5 mg/kg IP) or pentylenetetrazol (PTZ, 15 mg/kg IP) from saline in standard procedures employing two-lever operant chambers. Two beta-carbolines, ZK 91296 and ZK 93423, substituted for the benzodiazepines in both CDP- and diazepam-trained rats. The neutral benzodiazepine antagonists Ro 15-1788 blocked the diazepam discriminative stimulus and the ability of ZK 91296 to substitute for diazepam. A third beta-carboline, FG 7142, was not identified as benzodiazepine-like in generalization tests in either diazepam- or CDP-trained rats, but when administered together with CDP antagonized the benzodiazepine discriminative stimulus. In rats trained to discriminate PTZ from saline (a discrimination which is thought to depend on the anxiogenic properties of PTZ) the PTZ cue was antagonized by diazepam and ZK 93423, and partially antagonized by ZK 91296. The PTZ cue generalized to FG 7142 and this generalization was partially antagonized by Ro 15-1788. These results suggest that the three beta-carbolines provide more than one kind of discriminative stimulus, consistent with the classification of ZK 93423 as an agonist at central benzodiazepine receptors, with ZK 91296 as a partial agonist, and with FG 7142 as an inverse agonist. Pharmacologically, ZK 93423 and ZK 91296 may exhibit anxiolytic qualities, whereas FG 7142 produces anxiogenic effects.

Multiple sites of action for anxiogenic drugs: behavioural, electrophysiological and biochemical correlations

This review describes animal models of anxiety that are able to identify an anxiogenic drug effect. Evidence is reviewed for the anxiogenic action of several drugs that act at the GABA-benzodiazepine-chloride ionophore complex in the brain. The effects of their combinations with various other drugs thought to act at the same sites are discussed. The classification of these drugs on the basis of their behavioural profiles is compared with their classification based on biochemical and electrophysiological studies.

Behavioral analogues of anxiety. Animal models

In the absence of fully characterized biological indexes, anxiety is at present measured as unpleasant effects reported verbally by patients. Because of the subjective nature of the syndrome, animal analogues have been difficult to design, but quests for new anxiolytics and a deeper understanding of the neurobiology of anxiety have fostered the development of several animal models. Usually, animals are exposed to exteroceptive or interoceptive stimuli which can be interpreted as capable of causing anxiety in humans. Then, the animals are observed for responses or behavioral deficits resulting from those stimuli in order to provide an index of anxiety. Behavioral responses that are reliably produced by those stimuli and that are also antagonized by anxiolytic drugs are accepted as analogues of anxiety. Exteroceptive stimuli, useful in this respect, consist of a variety of noxious treatments such as exposure to conflict-situations or unavoidable electric shock, whereas interoceptive stimuli consist of treatment with anxiogenic drugs or electrical stimulation of selected brain areas. Elicitation of unconditioned behavior or changes in the rate of conditioned (learned) responding have been employed as measures of anxiety responses following application of either exteroceptive or interoceptive stimuli. These measures, although useful in detecting anxiolytic drugs, possess several weaknesses. They suffer from difficulties in obtaining quantitative and objective data, they do not differentiate between anxiety and stress or fear, they are unable to measure further deterioration of behavior expected to occur when more potent anxiogenic stimuli are tested and they often present difficulty in differentiating direct motor effects of a number of stimuli are not related to anxiety. More recently, interest in the development of other analogues of anxiety has led to the use of drug-discrimination paradigms. In this approach, interoceptive discriminative stimuli, produced by anxiogenic drugs, are used as analogues of anxiety in animals. As an example of this approach, data are reviewed showing that pentylenetetrazol, an anxiogenic drug in humans, produces interoceptive stimuli which can be readily discriminated by rats. Further, these stimuli can be easily quantified through dose-response analysis. All known anxiogenic drugs generalize to pentylenetetrazol-induced interoceptive discriminative stimuli. Similarly, other anxiety-provoking situations in humans, such as withdrawal from dependence on benzodiazepines, also generalize to the pentylenetetrazol-induced stimuli. Alternatively, all known anxiolytic drugs antagonize these stimuli with a relative potency similar to

Anxiogenic action of a convulsant benzodiazepine: reversal by chlordiazepoxide

Ro5-3663, a convulsant benzodiazepine and a ligand for CNS picrotoxin sites, but not for benzodiazepine sites, had a significant dose-related (2 and 4 mg/kg) anxiogenic action in the social interaction test of anxiety. This anxiogenic effect was reversed by chlordiazepoxide (5 mg/kg).

Discriminative stimulus properties of a small dose of cocaine

This study characterized the interoceptive discriminative stimulus (IDS) produced by a small dose of cocaine. Rats were trained to use a dose of cocaine of 1.25 mg/kg vs saline as the basis for choosing one of two levers for food reinforcement on a fixed ratio 10 schedule. The discrimination was acquired over approx. 60 training sessions. d-Amphetamine generalized to cocaine with approximately equal potency (ED50's for cocaine and d-amphetamine were 0.07 and 0.06 mg/kg, respectively); 20 mg/kg cocaine and 10 mg/kg methylphenidate also generalized to the cocaine lever. Pentylenetetrazol, 20 mg/kg, did not generalize to the cocaine lever, and diazepam, 10 mg/kg, did not block the 1.25 mg/kg cocaine discrimination. These data indicate that when a small dose of cocaine is used as the basis of discrimination training, the discriminative stimulus that it produces is qualitatively and quantitatively similar to that produced by small doses of amphetamine, is still discriminated with a large dose of cocaine, and is dissimilar to the discriminative stimulus produced by pentylenetetrazol.

RO 15-1788 selectively reverses antagonism of pentylenetetrazol-induced discriminative stimuli by benzodiazepines but not by barbiturates

The specificity of ethyl 8-fluro-5,6-dihydro-5-methyl-6-oxo-4H-imidazo (1,5-a) (1,4) benzodiazepine-3-carboxylate (RO 15-1788) in reversing the effectiveness of diazepam and des-methylclobazam, but not of pentobarbital, in antagonizing discriminative stimuli produced by pentylenetetrazol is described. Male hooded rats were trained to discriminate pentylenetetrazol-induced interoceptive discriminative-stimuli (IDS) in a two-lever choice paradigm on an FR10 schedule of food reinforcement. These IDS pharmacologically model verbal report of anxiogenic activity in humans. Diazepam (1,4 benzodiazepine), des-methylclobazam (1,5 benzo-diazepine), and pentobarbital antagonized pentylenetetrazol-IDS. RO 15-1788 neither generalized to nor antagonized pentylenetetrazol-IDS. It also did not cause convulsions in pentylenetetrazol sensitized rats at doses up to 40 mg/kg. It did, however, antagonize the action of diazepam (10 mg/kg) as well as that of des-methylclobazam (160 mg/kg) but not that of pentobarbital. These data suggest that RO 15-1788 is not an anxiomimetic, anxiolytic or a convulsant drug, but it is a specific and effective antagonist of anxiolytic action of benzodiazepines.