FORMATION OF GENETICALLY MOSAIC MOUSE EMBRYOS, AND EARLY DEVELOPMENT OF "LETHAL (T12/T12)-NORMAL" MOSAICS

A fascination with tailless mice: a scientific historical review of studies of the T/t complex

The T/t complex of the mouse attracted many of the major figures of mouse genetics to perform genetic, cytogenetic, physiological, biochemical and molecular biological studies of it. These studies started with the discovery of short tailed mutants (Ts) and recessive lethal developmental mutations (ts) which mapped to the same "locus" in the early 1920s in France. However, due to the non-receptivity of French scientists to genetics, they continued to be studied in mostly Anglophone countries to be joined by a wider international community in the 1970s. These discoveries led to developmental studies of the lethal mutants which provided the origin of mammalian developmental genetics. The fascinating property of transmission ratio distortion (non-50/50 segregation of alleles in offspring of males) elicited tremendous interest. There were false leads (that the region consisted of unusual DNA, that the alleles controlled cell surface antigens on embryonic cells and spermatozoa) and exciting discoveries. This historical review provides a review of this extensive area of research and some of the individuals involved in it.

Mouse embryos, chimeras, and embryonal carcinoma stem cells-Reflections on the winding road to gene manipulation

The relationship of embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells, the stem cells of germ cell- or embryo-derived teratocarcinoma tumors, to early embryonic cells came under intense scrutiny in the early 1970s when mouse chimeras were produced between EC cells and embryos. These chimeras raised tantalizing possibilities and high hopes for different areas of research. The normalization of EC cells by the embryo lent validity to their use as in vitro models for embryogenesis and indicated that they might reveal information about the relationship between malignancy and differentiation. Chimeras also showed the way for the potential introduction of genes, selected in EC cells in vitro, into the germ line of mice. Although EC cells provided material for the elucidation of early embryonic events and stimulated many studies of early molecular differentiation, after years of intense scrutiny, they fell short as the means of genetic manipulation of the germ line, although arguably they pointed the way to the development of embryonic stem (ES) cells that eventually fulfilled this goal.

The road to gene manipulation in the mouse: Jean Brachet Memorial Lecture of the International Society of Differentiation (delivered June 21, 2023 at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)

Genetic manipulation in mammals has progressed rapidly in the past decade with the advent of CRISPR-Cas gene editing tools, promising profound impacts on the understanding of human development, health and disease. However, many years of research in divergent fields of experimental embryology, genetics, reproduction, molecular biology and transgenic technology laid the groundwork and have played critical roles for this progress. This article details various threads of research and the central role of the laboratory mouse that came together in reaching this point, all from the perspective of a scientist whose research was deeply immersed in the field.

Next-Generation Lineage Tracing and Fate Mapping to Interrogate Development

Lineage tracing and fate mapping, overlapping yet distinct disciplines to follow cells and their progeny, have evolved rapidly over the last century. Lineage tracing aims to identify all progeny arising from an individual cell, placing them within a lineage hierarchy. The recent emergence of genomic technologies, such as single-cell and spatial transcriptomics, has fostered sophisticated new methods to reconstruct lineage relationships at high resolution. In contrast, fate maps, schematics showing which parts of the embryo will develop into which tissue, have remained relatively static since the 1970s. However, fate maps provide spatial information, often lost in lineage reconstruction, that can offer fundamental mechanistic insight into development. Here, we broadly review the origins of fate mapping and lineage tracing approaches. We focus on the most recent developments in lineage tracing, permitted by advances in single-cell genomics. Finally, we explore the current potential to leverage these new technologies to synthesize high-resolution fate maps and discuss their potential for interrogating development at new depths.

Coordination between patterning and morphogenesis ensures robustness during mouse development

The mammalian preimplantation embryo is a highly tractable, self-organizing developmental system in which three cell types are consistently specified without the need for maternal factors or external signals. Studies in the mouse over the past decades have greatly improved our understanding of the cues that trigger symmetry breaking in the embryo, the transcription factors that control lineage specification and commitment, and the mechanical forces that drive morphogenesis and inform cell fate decisions. These studies have also uncovered how these multiple inputs are integrated to allocate the right number of cells to each lineage despite inherent biological noise, and as a response to perturbations. In this review, we summarize our current understanding of how these processes are coordinated to ensure a robust and precise developmental outcome during early mouse development. This article is part of a discussion meeting issue 'Contemporary morphogenesis'.

Growth-factor-mediated coupling between lineage size and cell fate choice underlies robustness of mammalian development

Precise control and maintenance of population size is fundamental for organismal development and homeostasis. The three cell types of the mammalian blastocyst are generated in precise proportions over a short time, suggesting a mechanism to ensure a reproducible outcome. We developed a minimal mathematical model demonstrating growth factor signaling is sufficient to guarantee this robustness and which anticipates an embryo's response to perturbations in lineage composition. Addition of lineage-restricted cells both in vivo and in silico, causes a shift of the fate of progenitors away from the supernumerary cell type, while eliminating cells using laser ablation biases the specification of progenitors toward the targeted cell type. Finally, FGF4 couples fate decisions to lineage composition through changes in local growth factor concentration, providing a basis for the regulative abilities of the early mammalian embryo whereby fate decisions are coordinated at the population level to robustly generate tissues in the right proportions.

CORP: Using transgenic mice to study skeletal muscle physiology

The development of tissue-specific inducible transgenic mice has provided a powerful tool to study gene function and cell biology in almost any tissue of interest at any given time within the animal's life. The purpose of this review is to describe how to use two different inducible transgenic systems, the Cre-loxP system and the Tet-ON/OFF system, that can be used to study skeletal muscle physiology. Myofiber- and satellite cell-specific Cre-loxP transgenic mice are described as is how these mice can be used to knockout a gene of interest or to deplete satellite cells in adult skeletal muscle, respectively. A myofiber-specific Tet-ON system is described as is how such mice can be used to overexpress a gene of interest or to label myonuclei. How to effectively breed and genotype the transgenic mice are also described in detail. The hope is this review will provide the basic information necessary to facilitate the incorporation of tissue-specific inducible transgenic mice into a skeletal muscle research program.

Dynamic lineage priming is driven via direct enhancer regulation by ERK

Central to understanding cellular behaviour in multi-cellular organisms is the question of how a cell exits one transcriptional state to adopt and eventually become committed to another. Fibroblast growth factor-extracellular signal-regulated kinase (FGF -ERK) signalling drives differentiation of mouse embryonic stem cells (ES cells) and pre-implantation embryos towards primitive endoderm, and inhibiting ERK supports ES cell self-renewal¹. Paracrine FGF-ERK signalling induces heterogeneity, whereby cells reversibly progress from pluripotency towards primitive endoderm while retaining their capacity to re-enter self-renewal². Here we find that ERK reversibly regulates transcription in ES cells by directly affecting enhancer activity without requiring a change in transcription factor binding. ERK triggers the reversible association and disassociation of RNA polymerase II and associated co-factors from genes and enhancers with the mediator component MED24 having an essential role in ERK-dependent transcriptional regulation. Though the binding of mediator components responds directly to signalling, the persistent binding of pluripotency factors to both induced and repressed genes marks them for activation and/or reactivation in response to fluctuations in ERK activity. Among the repressed genes are several core components of the pluripotency network that act to drive their own expression and maintain the ES cell state; if their binding is lost, the ability to reactivate transcription is compromised. Thus, as long as transcription factor occupancy is maintained, so is plasticity, enabling cells to distinguish between transient and sustained signals. If ERK signalling persists, pluripotency transcription factor levels are reduced by protein turnover and irreversible gene silencing and commitment can occur.

Twin Inc

This paper presents an account of how human spontaneous embryonic chimeras are formed. On the prevalent view in the philosophical literature, it is said that chimeras are the product of two embryos that fuse to form a new third embryo. We call this version of fusion synthesis. In contrast to synthesis, we present an alternative mechanism for chimera formation called incorporation, wherein one embryo incorporates the cells of a second embryo into its body. We argue that the incorporation thesis explains other types of chimera formation, which are better understood, and is more consistent than synthesis with what is known about embryological development. Incorporation also has different implications than synthesis and so avoids the philosophical puzzles that are often said to accompany embryonic chimera formation-puzzles which pose problems to the human embryo's persistence from fertilization to the fetal stage of human development.

Gene Expression Noise Enhances Robust Organization of the Early Mammalian Blastocyst

A critical event in mammalian embryo development is construction of an inner cell mass surrounded by a trophoectoderm (a shell of cells that later form extraembryonic structures). We utilize multi-scale, stochastic modeling to investigate the design principles responsible for robust establishment of these structures. This investigation makes three predictions, each supported by our quantitative imaging. First, stochasticity in the expression of critical genes promotes cell plasticity and has a critical role in accurately organizing the developing mouse blastocyst. Second, asymmetry in the levels of noise variation (expression fluctuation) of Cdx2 and Oct4 provides a means to gain the benefits of noise-mediated plasticity while ameliorating the potentially detrimental effects of stochasticity. Finally, by controlling the timing and pace of cell fate specification, the embryo temporally modulates plasticity and creates a time window during which each cell can continually read its environment and adjusts its fate. These results suggest noise has a crucial role in maintaining cellular plasticity and organizing the blastocyst.

A critical event in mammalian embryo development is construction of a mass of embryonic stem cells surrounded by a distinct shell that later forms the placenta along with other structures. Despite sustained investigation, multiple hypotheses for what is responsible for this organization persist and it remains unclear what is responsible for the robust organization (remarkable ability for embryos to pattern correctly) of these structures. Here, we utilize multi-scale, stochastic modeling along with fluorescence imaging to investigate the factors that contribute to the incredible robustness of this organizational process. Results point to two factors that contribute to this robustness: 1) the timing and pace of cell fate specification and 2) stochastic gene regulatory effects. The former creates a window of time during which each cell can continually read their environment and adjust their gene expressions (and consequently fate) in response to dynamic rearrangements of cells arising from cell divisions and motions. The latter improves cell plasticity, providing the capability for cells to adjust to changes in their local environment. Fluorescence imaging results demonstrate that the magnitude and structure of gene expression variations match those predicted to promote organizational robustness.

Asynchronous fate decisions by single cells collectively ensure consistent lineage composition in the mouse blastocyst

Intercellular communication is essential to coordinate the behaviour of individual cells during organismal development. The preimplantation mammalian embryo is a paradigm of tissue self-organization and regulative development; however, the cellular basis of these regulative abilities has not been established. Here we use a quantitative image analysis pipeline to undertake a high-resolution, single-cell level analysis of lineage specification in the inner cell mass (ICM) of the mouse blastocyst. We show that a consistent ratio of epiblast and primitive endoderm lineages is achieved through incremental allocation of cells from a common progenitor pool, and that the lineage composition of the ICM is conserved regardless of its size. Furthermore, timed modulation of the FGF-MAPK pathway shows that individual progenitors commit to either fate asynchronously during blastocyst development. These data indicate that such incremental lineage allocation provides the basis for a tissue size control mechanism that ensures the generation of lineages of appropriate size.

Early embryonic cell fate and lineage specification is tightly regulated in the preimplantation mammalian embryo. Here, the authors quantitatively examine the ratio of epiblast to primitive endoderm lineages in the blastocyst and show composition of the inner cell mass is conserved, independent of its size.

Regulation of embryonic size in early mouse development in vitro culture system

Mammals self-regulate their body size throughout development. In the uterus, embryos are properly regulated to be a specific size at birth. Previously, size and cell number in aggregated embryos, which were made from two or more morulae, and half embryos, which were halved at the 2-cell stage, have been analysed in vivo in preimplantation and post-implantation development in mice. Here, we examined whether or not the mouse embryo has the capacity to self-regulate growth using an in vitro culture system. To elucidate embryonic histology, cells were counted in aggregated or half embryos in comparison with control embryos. Both double- and triple-aggregated embryos contained more cells than did control embryos during all culture periods, and the relative growth ratios showed no growth inhibition in an in vitro culture system. Meanwhile, half embryos contained fewer cells than control embryos, but the number grew throughout the culture period. Our data suggest that the growth of aggregated embryos is not affected and continues in an in vitro culture system. On the other hand, the growth of half embryos accelerates and continues in an in vitro culture system. This situation, in turn, implied that post-implantation mouse embryos might have some potential to regulate their own growth and size as seen by using an in vitro culture system without uterus factors. In conclusion, our results indicated that embryos have some ways in which to regulate their own size in mouse early development.

Developmental plasticity is bound by pluripotency and the Fgf and Wnt signaling pathways

Plasticity is a well-known feature of mammalian development, and yet very little is known about its underlying mechanism. Here, we establish a model system to examine the extent and limitations of developmental plasticity in living mouse embryos. We show that halved embryos follow the same strict clock of developmental transitions as intact embryos, but their potential is not equal. We have determined that unless a minimum of four pluripotent cells is established before implantation, development will arrest. This failure can be rescued by modulating Fgf and Wnt signaling to enhance pluripotent cell number, allowing the generation of monozygotic twins, which is an otherwise rare phenomenon. Knowledge of the minimum pluripotent-cell number required for development to birth, as well as the different potentials of blastomeres, allowed us to establish a protocol for splitting an embryo into one part that develops to adulthood and another that provides embryonic stem cells for that individual.

Preimplantation mouse embryo: developmental fate and potency of blastomeres

During the past decade we have witnessed great progress in the understanding of cellular, molecular, and epigenetic aspects of preimplantation mouse development. However, some of the issues, especially those regarding the nature and regulation of mouse development, are still unresolved and controversial and raise heated discussion among mammalian embryologists. This chapter presents different standpoints and various research approaches aimed at examining the fate and potency of cells (blastomeres) of mouse preimplantation embryo. In dealing with this subject, it is important to recognize the difference between the fate of blastomere and the prospective potency of blastomere, with the first being its contribution to distinct tissues during normal development, and the second being a full range of its developmental capabilities, which can be unveiled only by experimental perturbation of the embryo. Studies of the developmental potential and the fate of blastomeres are of the utmost importance as they may lead to future clinical application in reproductive and regenerative medicine.

From mouse egg to mouse embryo: polarities, axes, and tissues

This review describes the three classical models (mosaic, positional, and polarization) proposed to explain blastocyst formation and summarizes the evidence concerning them. It concludes that the polarization model incorporates elements of the other two models and best explains most known information. I discuss key requirements of a molecular basis for the generation and stabilization of polarity and identify ezrin/E-cadherin, PAR proteins, and Cdx2 as plausible key molecular players. I also discuss the idea of a network process operating to build cell allocations progressively into committed differences. Finally, this review critically considers the possibility of developmental information being encoded within the oocyte and zygote. No final decision can be reached on a mechanism of action underlying any encoded information, but a cell interaction process model is preferred over one that relies solely on differential inheritance.

Investigation of cellular interaction and deployment in the early mammalian embryo using interspecific chimaeras between the rat and mouse

Mammalian chimaeras can be produced experimentally by aggregating early embryos or by injecting cells into them. They have been used to study several aspects of early development. However, lack of a genetic marker enabling unequivocal identification of all cells of either genotype in situ has frustrated full exploitation of the experimental possibilities offered by these organisms. Hence interspecific chimaeras have been produced between rat and mouse embryos in which cells of the two species can be identified in sectioned embryos by immune fluorescence. These chimaeric embryos have been used to study differentiation of the trophoblast and inner cell mass, and the deployment of cells during morphogenesis. Preliminary results suggest that the two tissues are determined by the blastocyst stage, and that the trophoblast forms part of the extra-embryonic membranes originally presumed to be derived from the inner cell mass. Also, rat inner cell mass cells can induce mitosis in mouse trophoblast. Futhermore, the distribution of rat cells in implanted embryos suggests that the embryo may grow in a coherent clonal manner from a very early stage. Very recently, chimaerism has been induced by transplanting single rat cells, which may allow a more critical analysis of morphogenesis and determination than was possible hitherto. An obvious question raised by crossing the species barrier is the extent to which results may be applicable to normal development. Adverse effects of immunological interaction between the mouse uterine foster-mother and fetal rat cells, and sorting out of cells according to species, are two of the problems that might complicate interpretation of these experiments.

Clonal analysis of cell fate during gastrulation and early neurulation in the mouse

The foundation of the germ layers and the extraembryonic mesoderm from the epiblast between 6.5 and 7.5 days post coitum (p.c.) is accompanied by substantial cell proliferation. It is followed during the next 24 hours by the organization of major systems of the embryo such as the central nervous system, somites, heart and vascular system. Injection in situ of a short-term lineage label (horse radish peroxidase) into single epiblast cells at 6.7 days p.c. and analysis of the descendant clones in cultured embryos have been used to trace these processes and led to the following conclusions: (1) There is extensive but not indiscriminate cell mixing at the onset of gastrulation; epiblast cells spread towards the primitive streak and descendants are there progressively incorporated into mesoderm. (2) The fate map of the mouse epiblast at the early primitive streak stage is topologically similar to those of other vertebrates. (3) Germ layers and the extraembryonic mesoderm are not clonally distinct before gastrulation, the region of overlapping boundaries in the fate map being occupied by cells that will have descendants in more than one layer. (4) Cranial neurectoderm is mainly derived from axial epiblast immediately anterior to the primitive streak of the early streak stage embryo, clonal descendants being spread rostrocaudally in the developing neural tube. Contribution to the putative floor plate is made by progenitors some of which also contribute to notochord and mesoderm.

The magic behind stem cells

This review article summarizes historical development of stem cell research, presents current knowledge on the plasticity potential of both embryonic and adult stem cells and discusses on the future of stem cell based therapies.

Neural differentiation and incorporation of bone marrow-derived multipotent adult progenitor cells after single cell transplantation into blastocyst stage mouse embryos

Previously we reported the characterization of multipotent adult progenitor cells (MAPCs) isolated from the bone marrow of rodents. In that study, single murine MAPCs derived from ROSA-26, beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal)-positive transgenic mice were injected into E3.5 C57/B16 mouse blastocysts. The resultant chimeric blastocysts were then implanted into pseudopregnant females and were allowed to develop naturally through birth and into adulthood. Chimeric mice were sacrificed 6 to 20 weeks after birth, and were processed for histological analysis. Beta-galactosidase activity was identified in all organs and tissues examined, and tissue-specific differentiation and engraftment was confirmed by colabeling with antibodies that recognize beta-Gal and tissue-specific markers. In the present study we have examined neural engraftment derived from the clonal expansion of a single MAPC during rodent development, and characterized the neural phenotype of MAPCs in the resultant chimeric animals. Donor cell-derived beta-Gal activity was evident throughout the brain. Double and triple immunofluorescent labeling studies revealed MAPC-derived neurons (NeuN/beta-Gal) and astrocytes (GFAP/beta-Gal) in the cortex, striatum, medial septal nucleus, hippocampus, cerebellum, substantia nigra, and thalamus. More specifically, donor-derived neurons contributed to each of the cellular layers of the cortex; the pyramidal and granule cell layers, as well as the hilus, of the hippocampus; Purkinje and granule cell layers in the cerebellum; and GABAergic cells in the caudate and putamen. This study characterizes the potential for MAPCs to differentiate into specific neuronal and glial phenotypes, and to integrate normally during development, after implantation into blastocysts, and provides additional evidence that MAPCs exhibit properties similar to embryonic stem cells.

Stem cells today: A. Origin and potential of embryo stem cells

The study of embryo stem cells began in 1963, initially using disaggregates of cleaving rabbit and mouse embryos. Their differentiation in vitro was modest, and usually curtailed at best to the formation of trophectoderm cells, which attached to plastic. Rabbit morulae and blastocysts adhered more readily, trophectoderm forming a sheet of cells which was overgrown by stem cells from inner cell mass. Whole-blastocyst cultures on collagen-coated surfaces produced a pile of cells, and its outgrowths included neural, blood, neuronal, phagocytic and many other types of cell. When inner cell mass was freed and cultured intact or as cell disaggregates, lines of embryo stem cells (ES) were established which possessed good rates of cleavage, and immense stability in their secretion of enzymes, morphology and chromosomal complement. Developmental capacities of single mouse embryo stem cells were measured by injecting one or more into a recipient blastocyst, and extent of colonization in resulting chimaeras measured their pluripotency. In mouse, cell clumps were termed embryoid bodies, which produced similar outgrowths as in rabbit. Component cells again differentiated widely, depending to a limited extent on their exposure to various cytokines or substrates. Markers for differentiation or pluripotency were established, which revealed how neural, cardiac, haematological and other ES lines could be established in vitro. These have proved useful to study early differentiation and their use in grafting to sick recipients. Displaying similar properties, human ES cells emerged in the late 1990s. Models for the clinical use of ES cells showed how they colonized rapidly, travelled to target tissues via fetal pathways, differentiated and colonized target organs. No signs of inflammation or tissue damage were noted; injured tissues could be repaired including remyelination, and no cancers were formed. ES cells offer wide therapeutic potentials for humans, although extensive clinical trials are still awaited.

An extreme bias in the germ line of XY C57BL/6<->XY FVB/N chimaeric mice

Chimaeric analysis is a powerful method to address questions about the cell-autonomous nature of defects in spermatogenesis. Symplastic spermatids (sys) mice have a recessive mutation that causes male sterility due to an arrest in germ-cell development during spermiogenesis. Chimaeric mice were generated by aggregation of eight-cell embryos from sys (FVB/N genetic background) and wild-type C57BL/6 (B6) mice to determine whether the male germ-cell defect is cell-autonomous. The resulting FVB/N<->B6 chimaeras (<-> denotes fusion of embryos) were mated with FVB/N mice and coat colour of offspring was used to identify transmission of FVB/N or B6 gametes. Regardless of the relative contribution of B6 to somatic tissues of the chimaeras, almost all (282 of 284; 99.3%) offspring of B6 XY<->XY FVB/N (+/+ or sys/+) males (n = 9) received a FVB/N-derived paternal gamete. After mating of female B6<->FVB/N chimaeras, 51 of 73 (69.9%) offspring received an FVB-derived maternal gamete. Southern blot analysis of different tissues from chimaeric males indicated that, despite the presence of balanced chimaerism in somatic tissues, the germ line in B6 XY<->XY FVB/N mice was essentially FVB/N in composition. Thus there is a strong selective advantage for FVB/N male germ cells over B6 male germ cells in B6<->FVB/N-aggregation chimaeras at some stage during development of the male germ line. Each of three male chimaeras that were either B6 XY<->XY FVB/N (sys/sys) or B6 XX<->XY FVB/N (sys/sys) in composition was sterile, and testis histology was essentially sysmutant. This finding indicates that the function of the gene(s) affected in the sys mutation may be required in the testis, although whether expression is required in germ cells, somatic cells or both remains unknown. The extreme bias in transmission of male gametes has implications for experimental design in studies that use chimaeric analysis to address questions regarding the cell-autonomous nature of germ-cell defects in mice.

Personal pathways to embryonic stem cells

Work with numerous colleagues on embryo stem cells in vitro began in our laboratories in 1963, using cleaving embryos and blastocysts of the rabbit. Growth of disaggregated blastomeres from cleavage-stage embryos was weak. Trophoblast outgrowths from whole-embryo cultures provided a platform supporting inner cells that differentiated into blood islands, muscle, nerve cells, phagocytic cells, connective tissue and undefined elements. Stem cell lines derived from whole or disaggregated cells of rabbit inner cell mass and embryonic disc proved to be long-lasting (immortal), growing over months and years, stable enzymically, karyotypically and morphologically, and fully capable of resuming growth after cryopreservation. To measure the embryological potency of embryo stem cells, disaggregated or entire inner cell masses were injected into the blastocoelic cavity of mouse blastocysts. They contributed to the formation of chimaeras, and partially colonized most or all recipient tissues except trophectoderm. Gene markers for coat colour enabled their instant detection in recipient fetuses, newborns and adults. Cell lineages, the multipotency of single cells, and transgenesis all descended from this approach. Mouse and rat stem cells were grown from disaggregated blastocysts cultured in vitro or from tissues extracted from early post-implantation mouse embryos. They fully recolonized bone marrow in lethally irradiated adult mouse recipients, and in mice carrying inherited anaemias, migrating via liver to bone marrow and spleen. Some may have been hepatocyte or splenocyte precursors. Non-irradiated recipients were weakly colonized by embryo stem cells overcoming histocompatibility barriers. No signs of inflammation or cancer were noted. First studies on human embryo stem cells began, but were ended by an ethical decision preventing supplies of human blastocysts for research.

The initial phase of embryonic patterning in mammals

Although specification of the antero-posterior axis is a critical intial step in development of the fetus, it is not known either how, or at what stage in development, this process begins. Such information is vital for understanding not only normal development in mammals but also monozygotic twinning, which, at least in man, is associated with a significantly increased incidence of birth defects. According to recent studies in the mouse, specification of the fetal anteroposterior axis begins well before gastrulation, and probably even before the conceptus implants. Moreover, evidence is accruing that the origin of relevant asymmetries depends on information that is already present in the zygote before it embarks on cleavage. Hence, early development in mammals does not differ as markedly from that in other animals as has generally been assumed. Consequently, at present, the possibility of adverse effects of techniques used to assist human reproduction cannot be disregarded.

Contributions of blastocyst micromanipulation to the study of mammalian development

This is a personal account of why the author chose to focus on devising techniques for micromanipulating the blastocyst stage conceptus as a way of investigating early development in mammals. Its aim is to provide insight into what such technical innovations entailed and how they have contributed to present understanding of both embryology and the analysis of gene function in mammals. The ability to dissect and reconstitute mouse blastocysts, and to inject cells or tissue into them, enabled genes to be harnessed as markers for elucidating the lineage of cells and interactions between tissues from the stage when differentiation is first evident. Most importantly, it made it possible to apply clonal analysis to the study of cell fate in mammals. The scope of blastocyst micromanipulation was further enhanced when embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells and, particularly, embryonic stem (ES) cells were found to be able to participate in normal development and contribute to the germ line following injection into the blastocyst.

Removal of cytoplasm from one-celled mouse embryos induces early blastocyst formation

It has been recognized for several decades that the number of cleavage divisions which precede blastocyst formation in the mammalian embryo is rigorously fixed, such that removal of cells from the embryo, or augmentation of cell number by embryo aggregation, does not affect the timing of blastulation. Instead, embryos manipulated so as to reduce cell number form small blastocysts with fewer numbers of cells, while aggregate embryos form giant blastocysts. This tight control of the number of cleavage divisions ensures that the timing of blastocyst formation corresponds to the period of uterine receptivity for implantation. As yet, no experimental manipulation has succeeded in altering control of the number of cleavage divisions prior to blastulation, and as a consequence, the biological basis for the control mechanism is entirely obscure. We report here that removal of cytoplasm from one-celled mouse embryos does not alter the rate of cleavage, but does induce precocious formation of small blastocysts. These findings suggest that the early embryo "counts" cleavage divisions by measuring the size of its blastomeres, and that experimental reduction of cell size disturbs the counting mechanism and leads to abnormally early blastulation.

GENETIC MOSAICISM IN ADULT MICE OF QUADRIPARENTAL LINEAGE

Genetic mosaic mice can be produced by aggregating, during cleavage stages, the blastomeres of two embryos of different genotype into a single cluster, and by transferring the developing aggregates to the uterus of a surrogate mother. Substantial numbers of such composite embryos survive past birth. Among the living adult mosaic mice are individuals within which cells of markedly different immunogenetic constitution coexist. Through the incorporation of appropriate genetic markers into mosaics, many new possibilities now present themselves for analysis of biological problems during embryonic as well as adult life.

The microenvironment created by non-blocking embryos in aggregates may rescue blocking embryos via cell-embryo adherent contacts

Under our culture conditions, mouse embryos from the BALB/c inbred mouse strain develop successfully in culture only from the late 2-cell stage onwards (so-called 2-cell block), whether or not EDTA is added to the culture medium. (CBA x C57BL) F2 embryos do not exhibit a 2-cell block. Medium conditioned by culture of non-blocking embryos from the 2-cell to the 8-cell stage did not improve the development of blocking embryos, nor did co-culture of blocking and non-blocking embryos, with or without conditioned medium. On the other hand phytohaemagglutinin (PHA)-assisted aggregation of an early 2-cell BALB/c embryo with five surrounding non-blocking F2 embryos (2-cell or 8-cell) or five BALB/c 8-cell embryos allowed the early 2-cell BALB/c embryos to develop into blastocysts within 72 h. Aggregation of blocking BALB/c 2-cell embryos with each other had no 'rescue' effect. When blocking and non-blocking 2-cell embryos were aggregated together, an integrated blastocyst was formed; but when the early 2-cell BALB/c embryos were aggregated with non-blocking 8-cell embryos, the blocking embryos formed a separate small blastocyst, which nonetheless retained adherent contact with the non-blocking embryos throughout the culture period. Ultrastructural analysis showed that 2-cell embryos aggregated with the aid of PHA form close adherent cell contacts up to several micrometres in length.

Death before birth: clues from gene knockouts and mutations

A survey of mouse gene knockouts, transgene insertions and spontaneous mutations that are lethal prenatally reveals that surprisingly few developmental disturbances lead to death of the embryo and early foetus. These disturbances include failure to establish and maintain a vascular circulation, and failure to make the transition from yolk-sac-based to liver-based haematopoiesis. The embryo must also establish gestation-dependent routes of nutritional interaction with the mother, including implantation, formation of a yolk-sac vascular circulation, and formation of a chorioallantoic placenta. A number of embryonic organ and body systems, including the central nervous system, gut, lungs, urogenital system and musculoskeletal system, appear to have little or no survival value in utero.

Phenotypic expression of the fused (Fu) gene in chimaeric mice

The dominant gene Fused (Fu) produces skeletal abnormalities during embryonic development. It was previously shown that C57BL/6 mice contain a suppressor of Fu, which acts after fertilization. Chimaeras were used to study whether this gene would suppress the Fu phenotype after the 8-cell stage of embryo development. We found no effect of the suppressor gene on Fu phenotype (its degree and frequency of expression) in chimaeric mice. We conclude that either the suppressor gene from C57BL/6 mice can only influence Fu expression at the intracellular level or Fu expression is determined before the 8-cell embryonic stage.

Role of protein supplements in the culture of mouse embryos

The effect of various types of proteins used in single protein supplements for Bigger-Whitten-Whittingham (BWW) medium on the in vitro development of mouse preimplantation embryos was evaluated. Thioredoxin, superoxide dismutase (SOD), and apotransferrin showed prominent growth-promoting activity, whereas bovine serum albumin (BSA), fatty acid-free BSA, and catalase showed moderate promoting effects. beta-lipoprotein, ovalbumin and hemoglobin were ineffective, and holo-type transferrin and ceruloplasmin were actually toxic to the embryos. These results suggest that the growth-promotive effect of proteins on mouse pronuclear stage embryos is due to their antioxidative action, or to the removal of some free metal ion(s) such as Fe(3+). The mild growth promoting effect of both BSA and fatty acid free BSA suggest that the effect mediated by BSA is not dependent on bound fatty acids, but more likely is due to their antioxidative effect or chelating effect.

Simple and efficient production of embryonic stem cell-embryo chimeras by coculture

A method for the production of embryonic stem (ES) cell-embryo chimeras was developed that involves the simple coculture of eight-cell embryos on a lawn of ES cells. After coculture, the embryos with ES cells attached are transferred to normal embryo culture medium and allowed to develop to the blastocyst stage before reimplantation into foster mothers. Although the ES cells initially attach to the outside of the embryos, they primarily colonize the inner cell mass and its derivatives. This method results in the efficient production of chimeras with high levels of chimerism including the germ line. As embryos are handled en masse and manipulative steps are minimal, this method should greatly reduce the time and effort required to produce chimeric mice.

Cytokines modulate preimplantation development and pregnancy

Using two different models of pregnancy failure in mice, we show in this communication that preimplantation embryonic development can be controlled, in vivo, with cytokines. In one model, described by us previously, CSF-1 is shown to block gestations in plugged females due to its induction of defective early development. Pregnancies and preimplantation development are shown here to be restored to normal by TNF alpha or GM-CSF but not by TGF beta 1. In the second model, we reveal that CBA/J females plugged by various male strains produce spontaneously an extremely high proportion of abnormal precompaction embryos. Normal morulae and blastocysts, able to further develop and implant in vitro, are shown here to be induced by TNF alpha and to a lesser extent by GM-CSF and IL-1 alpha. These results suggest strongly that cytokines are potent modulators of early development. They may provide new and interesting insights into early events of mammalian embryonic development.

A multivariate morphometric analysis of hippocampal anatomical variation in C57BL/6 in equilibrium BALB/c chimeric mice

We investigated hippocampal anatomy in artificially-produced chimeras derived by the aggregation of embryos from two widely-studied inbred mouse strains, C57BL/6J and BALB/cJ. Contrary to expectations, the chimeras were not always intermediate between the parental strains. For a number of characters, the chimeras exceeded qualitatively as well as quantitatively the phenotypical range displayed by both inbred parental strains. These findings imply that if only one parent is available for comparison, for instance, in studies involving a normally inviable genotype, separating effects of this genotype from idiosyncratic effects inherent to the chimeric model will be very difficult, if not impossible.

The extended survival of tw5/tw5 mouse embryo cells in vitro

The tw5 haplotype is a recessive mutation which is lethal when homozygous in mouse embryos following implantation. This series of studies was undertaken to determine the effect of the tw5/tw5 genotype on embryos developing in vitro. Blastocyst embryos from +/tw5 inter se matings were compared with control blastocysts obtained from matings between T/+ and +/+ females and +/tw5 males for their abilities to continue development in vitro in two culture media. The data show that there are no significant differences between the percentages of experimental and control blastocyst embryos which attach and outgrow or which contain inner cell masses on any day of culture up to equivalent gestation day 21 in either media. These findings show that the life span of cells from tw5/tw5 embryos can be extended significantly by in vitro culture.

Adhesive and degradative properties of human placental cytotrophoblast cells in vitro

Human fetal development depends on the embryo rapidly gaining access to the maternal circulation. The trophoblast cells that form the fetal portion of the human placenta have solved this problem by transiently exhibiting certain tumor-like properties. Thus, during early pregnancy fetal cytotrophoblast cells invade the uterus and its arterial network. This process peaks during the twelfth week of pregnancy and declines rapidly thereafter, suggesting that the highly specialized, invasive behavior of the cytotrophoblast cells is closely regulated. Since little is known about the actual mechanisms involved, we developed an isolation procedure for cytotrophoblasts from placentas of different gestational ages to study their adhesive and invasive properties in vitro. Cytotrophoblasts isolated from first, second, and third trimester human placentas were plated on the basement membrane-like extracellular matrix produced by the PF HR9 teratocarcinoma cell line. Cells from all trimesters expressed the calcium-dependent cell adhesion molecule cell-CAM 120/80 (E-cadherin) which, in the placenta, is specific for cytotrophoblasts. However, only the first trimester cytotrophoblast cells degraded the matrices on which they were cultured, leaving large gaps in the basement membrane substrates and releasing low molecular mass 3H-labeled matrix components into the medium. No similar degradative activity was observed when second or third trimester cytotrophoblast cells, first trimester human placental fibroblasts, or the human choriocarcinoma cell lines BeWo and JAR were cultured on radiolabeled matrices. To begin to understand the biochemical basis of this degradative behavior, the substrate gel technique was used to analyze the cell-associated and secreted proteinase activities expressed by early, mid, and late gestation cytotrophoblasts. Several gelatin-degrading proteinases were uniquely expressed by early gestation, invasive cytotrophoblasts, and all these activities could be abolished by inhibitors of metalloproteinases. By early second trimester, the time when cytotrophoblast invasion rapidly diminishes in vivo, the proteinase pattern of the cytotrophoblasts was identical to that of term, noninvasive cells. These results are the first evidence suggesting that specialized, temporally regulated metalloproteinases are involved in trophoblast invasion of the uterus. Since the cytotrophoblasts from first trimester and later gestation placentas maintain for several days the temporally regulated degradative behavior displayed in vivo, the short-term cytotrophoblast outgrowth culture system described here should be useful in studying some of the early events in human placen

Regulation of mouse trophoblast giant cell nucleus development in hatched mouse blastocysts by cyclic cytidine 3',5'-monophosphate (cCMP)

The dibutyryl analog of cCMP enlarged the nuclei of trophoblast giant cells and promoted blastocyst development. The result suggests that cCMP has a trophic effect on embryonic development, specifically by altering the size of the trophoblast cell nucleus but does not enhance trophoblast cell proliferation processes.

Expression and function of cell surface extracellular matrix receptors in mouse blastocyst attachment and outgrowth

Mouse-hatched blastocysts cultured in vitro will attach and form outgrowths of trophoblast cells on appropriate substrates, providing a model for implantation. Immediately after hatching, the surfaces of blastocysts are quiescent and are not adhesive. Over the period 24-36 h post-hatching, blastocysts cultured in serum-free medium become adhesive and attach and spread on the extracellular matrix components fibronectin, laminin, and collagen type IV in a ligand specific manner. Attachment and trophoblast outgrowth on these substrates can be inhibited by addition to the culture medium of an antibody, anti-ECMr (anti-extracellular matrix receptor), that recognizes a group of 140-kD glycoproteins similar to those of the 140-kD extracellular matrix receptor complex (integrin) recognized in avian cells by CSAT and JG22 monoclonal antibodies. Addition to the culture medium of a synthetic peptide containing the Arg-Gly-Asp tripeptide cell recognition sequence of fibronectin inhibits trophoblast outgrowth on both laminin and fibronectin. However, the presence of the peptide does not affect attachment of the blastocysts to either ligand. Immunoprecipitation of 125I surface-labeled embryos using anti-ECMr reveals that antigens recognized by this antibody are exposed on the surfaces of embryos at a time when they are spreading on the substrate, but are not detectable immediately after hatching. Immunofluorescence experiments show that both the ECMr antigens and the cytoskeletal proteins vinculin and talin are enriched on the cell processes and ventral surfaces of trophectoderm cells in embryo outgrowths, in patterns similar to those seen in fibroblasts, and consistent with their role in adhesion of the trophoblast cells to the substratum.

Quantitative evaluation of coat-color patterns in artificially produced chimeras of the mouse by means of a microcomputer-based video-image analysis system

The possible application of microcomputer-based video-image analysis systems for the quantitative description of coat-color patterns in artificially produced chimeras and genetic mosaics of mice was investigated using a program developed by the author. This system is capable of extracting, from sampled images of pelts, the morphometric image features as defined by Pratt [1978] that are essential to the quantitative description of coat-color patterns in these animals. It does so with reasonable accuracy and speed and at low cost. No description of any similar system has been published in the literature. Performance of our system is described using C3H/HeJ----BALB/c chimeras as examples. The complex phenotypic expression of hair pigmentation in mice makes the use of a video-image analysis system like this one essential to evaluate the morphometric parameters of the patterns (e.g., the mixing ratios between the two components, the number of different-colored stripes, etc.) more precisely and reproducibly than has been done yet in the literature. The results indicate that the number of melanoblast clones in mice, as estimated from the number of minimal recognizable stripes (MRS), might be considerably larger than previously indicated; the figure presently obtained, i.e., 22.3 +/- 2.16 unilaterally in terms of the hypothetical maximum number of stripes (HMNS) (28.73 +/- 1.55, after correction for the random clumping) in the thoracicolumbar region of the mouse closely approximates the number of the somites in that region. Concerning the degree of mixing between the two components, it was proposed that the unmixed portion of the components derived from one strain increases in proportion to the second power of the increase in the relative total content of the same components. Work is in progress in our laboratory to analyze a large number of the chimeric pelts using the system described in this paper.