Retrospective correction of head motion using measurements from an electromagnetic tracker

Rapid motion estimation and correction using self-encoded FID navigators in 3D radial MRI

PURPOSE

To develop a self-navigated motion compensation strategy for 3D radial MRI that can compensate for continuous head motion by measuring rigid body motion parameters with high temporal resolution from the central k-space acquisition point (self-encoded FID navigator) in each radial spoke.

METHODS

A forward model was created from low-resolution calibration data to simulate the effect of relative motion between the coil sensitivity profiles and the underlying object on the self-encoded FID navigator signal. Trajectory deviations were included in the model as low spatial-order field variations. Three volunteers were imaged at 3 T using a modified 3D gradient-echo sequence acquired with a Kooshball trajectory while performing abrupt and continuous head motion. Rigid body-motion parameters were estimated from the central k-space signal of each spoke using a least-squares fitting algorithm. The accuracy of self-navigated motion parameters was assessed relative to an established external tracking system. Quantitative image quality metrics were computed for images with and without retrospective correction using external and self-navigated motion measurements.

RESULTS

Self-encoded FID navigators achieved mean absolute errors of 0.69 ± 0.82 mm and 0.73 ± 0.87° relative to external tracking for maximum motion amplitudes of 12 mm and 10°. Retrospective correction of the 3D radial data resulted in substantially improved image quality for both abrupt and continuous motion paradigms, comparable to external tracking results.

CONCLUSIONS

Accurate rigid body motion parameters can be rapidly obtained from self-encoded FID navigator signals in 3D radial MRI to continuously correct for head movements. This approach is suitable for robust neuroanatomical imaging in subjects that exhibit patterns of large and frequent motion.

Robust retrospective motion correction of head motion using navigator-based and markerless motion tracking techniques

PURPOSE

This study investigated the artifacts arising from different types of head motion in brain MR images and how well these artifacts can be compensated using retrospective correction based on two different motion-tracking techniques.

METHODS

MPRAGE images were acquired using a 3 T MR scanner on a cohort of nine healthy participants. Subjects moved their head to generate circular motion (4 or 6 cycles/min), stepwise motion (small and large) and "simulated realistic" motion (nodding and slow diagonal motion), based on visual instructions. One MPRAGE scan without deliberate motion was always acquired as a "no motion" reference. Three dimensional fat-navigator (FatNavs) and a Tracoline markerless device (TracInnovations) were used to obtain motion estimates and images were separately reconstructed retrospectively from the raw data based on these different motion estimates.

RESULTS

Image quality was recovered from both motion tracking techniques in our stepwise and slow diagonal motion scenarios in almost all cases, with the apparent visual image quality comparable to the no-motion case. FatNav-based motion correction was further improved in the case of stepwise motion using a skull masking procedure to exclude non-rigid motion of the neck from the co-registration step. In the case of circular motion, both methods struggled to correct for all motion artifacts.

CONCLUSION

High image quality could be recovered in cases of stepwise and slow diagonal motion using both motion estimation techniques. The circular motion scenario led to more severe image artifacts that could not be fully compensated by the retrospective motion correction techniques used.

Evaluation of motion artefact reduction depending on the artefacts' directions in head MRI using conditional generative adversarial networks

Motion artefacts caused by the patient's body movements affect magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) accuracy. This study aimed to compare and evaluate the accuracy of motion artefacts correction using a conditional generative adversarial network (CGAN) with an autoencoder and U-net models. The training dataset consisted of motion artefacts generated through simulations. Motion artefacts occur in the phase encoding direction, which is set to either the horizontal or vertical direction of the image. To create T2-weighted axial images with simulated motion artefacts, 5500 head images were used in each direction. Of these data, 90% were used for training, while the remainder were used for the evaluation of image quality. Moreover, the validation data used in the model training consisted of 10% of the training dataset. The training data were divided into horizontal and vertical directions of motion artefact appearance, and the effect of combining this data with the training dataset was verified. The resulting corrected images were evaluated using structural image similarity (SSIM) and peak signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR), and the metrics were compared with the images without motion artefacts. The best improvements in the SSIM and PSNR were observed in the consistent condition in the direction of the occurrence of motion artefacts in the training and evaluation datasets. However, SSIM > 0.9 and PSNR > 29 dB were accomplished for the learning model with both image directions. The latter model exhibited the highest robustness for actual patient motion in head MRI images. Moreover, the image quality of the corrected image with the CGAN was the closest to that of the original image, while the improvement rates for SSIM and PSNR were approximately 26% and 7.7%, respectively. The CGAN model demonstrated a high image reproducibility, and the most significant model was the consistent condition of the learning model and the direction of the appearance of motion artefacts.

A System to Track Stent Location in the Human Body by Fusing Magnetometer and Accelerometer Measurements

This paper will introduce a simple locating system to track a stent when it is deployed into a human artery. The stent is proposed to achieve hemostasis for bleeding soldiers on the battlefield, where common surgical imaging equipment such as fluoroscopy systems are not available. In the application of interest, the stent must be guided to the right location to avoid serious complications. The most important features are its relative accuracy and the ease by which it may be quickly set up and used in a trauma situation. The locating approach in this paper utilizes a magnet outside the human body as the reference and a magnetometer that will be deployed inside the artery with the stent. The sensor can detect its location in a coordinate system centered with the reference magnet. In practice, the main challenge is that the locating accuracy will be deteriorated by external magnetic interference, rotation of the sensor, and random noise. These causes of error are addressed in the paper to improve the locating accuracy and repeatability under various conditions. Finally, the system's locating performance will be validated in benchtop experiments, where the effects of the disturbance-eliminating procedures will be addressed.

Motion guidance lines for robust data consistency-based retrospective motion correction in 2D and 3D MRI

PURPOSE

To develop a robust retrospective motion-correction technique based on repeating k-space guidance lines for improving motion correction in Cartesian 2D and 3D brain MRI.

METHODS

The motion guidance lines are inserted into the standard sequence orderings for 2D turbo spin echo and 3D MPRAGE to inform a data consistency-based motion estimation and reconstruction, which can be guided by a low-resolution scout. The extremely limited number of required guidance lines are repeated during each echo train and discarded in the final image reconstruction. Thus, integration within a standard k-space acquisition ordering ensures the expected image quality/contrast and motion sensitivity of that sequence.

RESULTS

Through simulation and in vivo 2D multislice and 3D motion experiments, we demonstrate that respectively 2 or 4 optimized motion guidance lines per shot enables accurate motion estimation and correction. Clinically acceptable reconstruction times are achieved through fully separable on-the-fly motion optimizations (˜1 s/shot) using standard scanner GPU hardware.

CONCLUSION

The addition of guidance lines to scout accelerated motion estimation facilitates robust retrospective motion correction that can be effectively introduced without perturbing standard clinical protocols and workflows.

Feasibility of tracking involuntary head movement for MRI using a coil as a magnetic dipole in a time-varying gradient

Accurate tracking involuntary head movements is fairly a challenging problem in MR imaging of the brain. Though there are few techniques available to monitor the head movement of the subject for a prospective motion correction, it is still an unsolved problem in MRI. In this theoretical study, we aim to describe an analytical investigation to track head movement inside an MR scanner by calculating the change in induced voltage in the head-mounted coils during the execution of time-varying gradients. We derive an expression to calculate the change in induced voltage in a coil placed in a time-varying gradient. We also derive a general equation to investigate the changes in the induced voltage in a set of coils mounted onto the head for the planar position and orientation of the coils. Each coil is considered as a magnetic dipole with location and sensitivity vectors. The changes of the vectors can track the head movement in the MR scanner by measuring the changes in the induced voltage in the coils. The dipole concept is valid for a wide range of coils. The changes in induced voltage in the coils are linear due to small changes in pose of the head. Movement parameters are estimated from the induced voltage changes. If the random noise voltage is less than 100 μV, it does not significantly affect movement parameters because the change in induced voltage in the coils dominates over the small noise voltage. This method and array of the coils may provide a real-life solution to the long-standing problem of head motion during MRI.

External Hardware and Sensors, for Improved MRI

Complex engineered systems are often equipped with suites of sensors and ancillary devices that monitor their performance and maintenance needs. MRI scanners are no different in this regard. Some of the ancillary devices available to support MRI equipment, the ones of particular interest here, have the distinction of actually participating in the image acquisition process itself. Most commonly, such devices are used to monitor physiological motion or variations in the scanner's imaging fields, allowing the imaging and/or reconstruction process to adapt as imaging conditions change. "Classic" examples include electrocardiography (ECG) leads and respiratory bellows to monitor cardiac and respiratory motion, which have been standard equipment in scan rooms since the early days of MRI. Since then, many additional sensors and devices have been proposed to support MRI acquisitions. The main physical properties that they measure may be primarily "mechanical" (eg acceleration, speed, and torque), "acoustic" (sound and ultrasound), "optical" (light and infrared), or "electromagnetic" in nature. A review of these ancillary devices, as currently available in clinical and research settings, is presented here. In our opinion, these devices are not in competition with each other: as long as they provide useful and unique information, do not interfere with each other and are not prohibitively cumbersome to use, they might find their proper place in future suites of sensors. In time, MRI acquisitions will likely include a plurality of complementary signals. A little like the microbiome that provides genetic diversity to organisms, these devices can provide signal diversity to MRI acquisitions and enrich measurements. Machine-learning (ML) algorithms are well suited at combining diverse input signals toward coherent outputs, and they could make use of all such information toward improved MRI capabilities. EVIDENCE LEVEL: 2 TECHNICAL EFFICACY: Stage 1.

Choreography Controlled (ChoCo) brain MRI artifact generation for labeled motion-corrupted datasets

MRI is a non-invasive medical imaging modality that is sensitive to patient motion, which constitutes a major limitation in most clinical applications. Solutions may arise from the reduction of acquisition times or from motion-correction techniques, either prospective or retrospective. Benchmarking the latter methods requires labeled motion-corrupted datasets, which are uncommon. Up to our best knowledge, no protocol for generating labeled datasets of MRI images corrupted by controlled motion has yet been proposed. Hence, we present a methodology allowing the acquisition of reproducible motion-corrupted MRI images as well as validation of the system's performance by motion estimation through rigid-body volume registration of fast 3D echo-planar imaging (EPI) time series. A proof-of-concept is presented, to show how the protocol can be implemented to provide qualitative and quantitative results. An MRI-compatible video system displays a moving target that volunteers equipped with customized plastic glasses must follow to perform predefined head choreographies. Motion estimation using rigid-body EPI time series registration demonstrated that head position can be accurately determined (with an average standard deviation of about 0.39 degrees). A spatio-temporal upsampling and interpolation method to cope with fast motion is also proposed in order to improve motion estimation. The proposed protocol is versatile and straightforward. It is compatible with all MRI systems and may provide insights on the origins of specific motion artifacts. The MRI and artificial intelligence research communities could benefit from this work to build in-vivo labeled datasets of motion-corrupted MRI images suitable for training/testing any retrospective motion correction or machine learning algorithm.

Rigid motion-resolved B1+ prediction using deep learning for real-time parallel-transmission pulse design

PURPOSE

Tailored parallel-transmit (pTx) pulses produce uniform excitation profiles at 7 T, but are sensitive to head motion. A potential solution is real-time pulse redesign. A deep learning framework is proposed to estimate pTx B 1 + distributions following within-slice motion, which can then be used for tailored pTx pulse redesign.

METHODS

Using simulated data, conditional generative adversarial networks were trained to predict B 1 + distributions in the head following a displacement. Predictions were made for two virtual body models that were not included in training. Predicted maps were compared with ground-truth (simulated, following motion) B1 maps. Tailored pTx pulses were designed using B1 maps at the original position (simulated, no motion) and evaluated using simulated B1 maps at displaced position (ground-truth maps) to quantify motion-related excitation error. A second pulse was designed using predicted maps (also evaluated on ground-truth maps) to investigate improvement offered by the proposed method.

RESULTS

Predicted B 1 + maps corresponded well with ground-truth maps. Error in predicted maps was lower than motion-related error in 99% and 67% of magnitude and phase evaluations, respectively. Worst-case flip-angle normalized RMS error due to motion (76% of target flip angle) was reduced by 59% when pulses were redesigned using predicted maps.

CONCLUSION

We propose a framework for predicting B 1 + maps online with deep neural networks. Predicted maps can then be used for real-time tailored pulse redesign, helping to overcome head motion-related error in pTx.

Tracking of rigid head motion during MRI using an EEG system

Purpose

To demonstrate a novel method for tracking of head movements during MRI using electroencephalography (EEG) hardware for recording signals induced by native imaging gradients.

Theory and Methods

Gradient switching during simultaneous EEG–fMRI induces distortions in EEG signals, which depend on subject head position and orientation. When EEG electrodes are interconnected with high‐impedance carbon wire loops, the induced voltages are linear combinations of the temporal gradient waveform derivatives. We introduce head tracking based on these signals (CapTrack) involving 3 steps: (1) phantom scanning is used to characterize the target sequence and a fast calibration sequence; (2) a linear relation between changes of induced signals and head pose is established using the calibration sequence; and (3) induced signals recorded during target sequence scanning are used for tracking and retrospective correction of head movement without prolonging the scan time of the target sequence. Performance of CapTrack is compared directly to interleaved navigators.

Results

Head‐pose tracking at 27.5 Hz during echo planar imaging (EPI) was demonstrated with close resemblance to rigid body alignment (mean absolute difference: [0.14 0.38 0.15]‐mm translation, [0.30 0.27 0.22]‐degree rotation). Retrospective correction of 3D gradient‐echo imaging shows an increase of average edge strength of 12%/−0.39% for instructed/uninstructed motion with CapTrack pose estimates, with a tracking interval of 1561 ms and high similarity to interleaved navigator estimates (mean absolute difference: [0.13 0.33 0.12] mm, [0.28 0.15 0.22] degrees).

Conclusion

Motion can be estimated from recordings of gradient switching with little or no sequence modification, optionally in real time at low computational burden and synchronized to image acquisition, using EEG equipment already found at many research institutions.

Characterisation of Children's Head Motion for Magnetic Resonance Imaging With and Without General Anaesthesia

Head motion is one of the major reasons for artefacts in Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), which is especially challenging for children who are often intimidated by the dimensions of the MR scanner. In order to optimise the MRI acquisition for children in the clinical setting, insights into children's motion patterns are essential. In this work, we analyse motion data from 61 paediatric patients. We compare structural MRI data of children imaged with and without general anaesthesia (GA), all scanned using the same hybrid PET/MR scanner. We analyse several metrics of motion based on the displacement relative to a reference, decompose the transformation matrix into translation and rotation, as well as investigate whether different regions in the brain are affected differently by the children's motion. Head motion for children without GA was significantly higher, with a median of the mean displacements of 2.19 ± 0.93 mm (median ± standard deviation) during 41.7±7.5 min scans; however, even anaesthetised children showed residual head motion (mean displacement of 1.12±0.35 mm). For both patient groups translation along the z-axis (along the scanner bore) was significantly larger in absolute terms (GA / no GA: 0.87±0.29/0.92 ± 0.49 mm) compared to the other directions. Considering directionality, both patient groups were moving in negative z-direction and thus, out of the scanner. The awake children additionally showed significantly more nodding rotation (0.33±0.20°). In future studies as well as in the clinical setting, these predominant types of motion need to be taken into consideration to limit artefacts and reduce re-scans due to poor image quality.

Free induction decay navigator motion metrics for prediction of diagnostic image quality in pediatric MRI

Purpose

To investigate the ability of free induction decay navigator (FIDnav)‐based motion monitoring to predict diagnostic utility and reduce the time and cost associated with acquiring diagnostically useful images in a pediatric patient cohort.

Methods

A study was carried out in 102 pediatric patients (aged 0‐18 years) at 3T using a 32‐channel head coil array. Subjects were scanned with an FID‐navigated MPRAGE sequence and images were graded by two radiologists using a five‐point scale to evaluate the impact of motion artifacts on diagnostic image quality. The correlation between image quality and four integrated FIDnav motion metrics was investigated, as well as the sensitivity and specificity of each FIDnav‐based metric to detect different levels of motion corruption in the images. Potential time and cost savings were also assessed by retrospectively applying an optimal detection threshold to FIDnav motion scores.

Results

A total of 12% of images were rated as non‐diagnostic, while a further 12% had compromised diagnostic value due to motion artifacts. FID‐navigated metrics exhibited a moderately strong correlation with image grade (Spearman's rho ≥ 0.56). Integrating the cross‐correlation between FIDnav signal vectors achieved the highest sensitivity and specificity for detecting non‐diagnostic images, yielding total time savings of 7% across all scans. This corresponded to a financial benefit of $2080 in this study.

Conclusions

Our results indicate that integrated motion metrics from FIDnavs embedded in structural MRI are a useful predictor of diagnostic image quality, which translates to substantial time and cost savings when applied to pediatric MRI examinations.

Deep Predictive Motion Tracking in Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Application to Fetal Imaging

Fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is challenged by uncontrollable, large, and irregular fetal movements. It is, therefore, performed through visual monitoring of fetal motion and repeated acquisitions to ensure diagnostic-quality images are acquired. Nevertheless, visual monitoring of fetal motion based on displayed slices, and navigation at the level of stacks-of-slices is inefficient. The current process is highly operator-dependent, increases scanner usage and cost, and significantly increases the length of fetal MRI scans which makes them hard to tolerate for pregnant women. To help build automatic MRI motion tracking and navigation systems to overcome the limitations of the current process and improve fetal imaging, we have developed a new real-time image-based motion tracking method based on deep learning that learns to predict fetal motion directly from acquired images. Our method is based on a recurrent neural network, composed of spatial and temporal encoder-decoders, that infers motion parameters from anatomical features extracted from sequences of acquired slices. We compared our trained network on held-out test sets (including data with different characteristics, e.g. different fetuses scanned at different ages, and motion trajectories recorded from volunteer subjects) with networks designed for estimation as well as methods adopted to make predictions. The results show that our method outperformed alternative techniques, and achieved real-time performance with average errors of 3.5 and 8 degrees for the estimation and prediction tasks, respectively. Our real-time deep predictive motion tracking technique can be used to assess fetal movements, to guide slice acquisitions, and to build navigation systems for fetal MRI.

Dynamic distortion correction for functional MRI using FID navigators

PURPOSE

To develop a method for slice-wise dynamic distortion correction for EPI using rapid spatiotemporal B₀ field measurements from FID navigators (FIDnavs) and to evaluate the efficacy of this new approach relative to an established data-driven technique.

METHODS

A low-resolution reference image was used to create a forward model of FIDnav signal changes to enable estimation of spatiotemporal B₀ inhomogeneity variations up to second order from measured FIDnavs. Five volunteers were scanned at 3 T using a 64-channel coil with FID-navigated EPI. The accuracy of voxel shift measurements and geometric distortion correction was assessed for experimentally induced magnetic field perturbations. The temporal SNR was evaluated in EPI time-series acquired at rest and with a continuous nose-touching action, before and after image realignment.

RESULTS

Field inhomogeneity coefficients and voxel shift maps measured using FIDnavs were in excellent agreement with multi-echo EPI measurements. The FID-navigated distortion correction accurately corrected image geometry in the presence of induced magnetic field perturbations, outperforming the data-driven approach in regions with large field offsets. In functional MRI scans with nose touching, FIDnav-based correction yielded temporal SNR gains of 30% in gray matter. Following image realignment, which accounted for global image shifts, temporal SNR gains of 3% were achieved.

CONCLUSIONS

Our proposed application of FIDnavs enables slice-wise dynamic distortion correction with high temporal efficiency. We achieved improved signal stability by leveraging the encoding information from multichannel coils. This approach can be easily adapted to other EPI-based sequences to improve temporal SNR for a variety of clinical and research applications.

Simultaneous Motion and Distortion Correction Using Dual-Echo Diffusion-Weighted MRI

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Geometric distortions resulting from large pose changes reduce the accuracy of motion measurements and interfere with the ability to generate artifact-free information. Our goal is to develop an algorithm and pulse sequence to enable motion-compensated, geometric distortion compensated diffusion-weighted MRI, and to evaluate its efficacy in correcting for the field inhomogeneity and position changes, induced by large and frequent head motions.

METHODS

Dual echo planar imaging (EPI) with a blip-reversed phase encoding distortion correction technique was evaluated in five volunteers in two separate experiments and compared with static field map distortion correction. In the first experiment, dual-echo EPI images were acquired in two head positions designed to induce a large field inhomogeneity change. A field map and a distortion-free structural image were acquired at each position to assess the ability of dual-echo EPI to generate reliable field maps and enable geometric distortion correction in both positions. In the second experiment, volunteers were asked to move to multiple random positions during a diffusion scan. Images were reconstructed using the dual-echo correction and a slice-to-volume registration (SVR) registration algorithm. The accuracy of SVR motion estimates was compared to externally measured ground truth motion parameters.

RESULTS

Our results show that dual-echo EPI can produce slice-level field maps with comparable quality to field maps generated by the reference gold standard method. We also show that slice-level distortion correction improves the accuracy of SVR algorithms as slices acquired at different orientations have different levels of distortion, which can create errors in the registration process.

CONCLUSIONS

Dual-echo acquisitions with blip-reversed phase encoding can be used to generate slice-level distortion-free images, which is critical for motion-robust slice to volume registration. The distortion corrected images not only result in better motion estimates, but they also enable a more accurate final diffusion image reconstruction.