Care-seeking behavior with breast cancer symptoms in Caucasian and African-American women

Research Guided by the Theory of Care-Seeking Behavior: A Scoping Review

BACKGROUND

A particular Theory of Care-Seeking Behavior was developed to explain care-seeking behavior with psychosocial concepts, external conditions, and clinical and demographic factors. Having a careful review of studies based on this theory could guide future research on care-seeking behaviors.

OBJECTIVES

With a scoping review: describe characteristics of studies guided by a Theory of Care-Seeking Behavior, summarize support for the relationships of proposed, explanatory variables with care-seeking behaviors, and examine support for propositions in the theory.

METHOD

Searching 5 electronic databases, we sought studies that were: full-text, peer-reviewed, in English, data-based, guided by the theory, and published from January 1, 1992, to January 1, 2022.

RESULTS

Across 18 identified articles, the behaviors studied included: symptomatic screening (n = 8), asymptomatic screening (n = 7), and care-seeking behaviors for either screening or symptoms (n = 3). A total of 3328 adults participated in the studies. In 16 studies, all participants were female. In 60% to 83% of studies, researchers had reported findings that supported the relationships of explanatory concepts with care-seeking behavior. Among the 7 studies that tested the 2 propositions of theory, all 7 tests failed to support the proposition that clinical and demographic factors influence care-seeking behavior indirectly through psychosocial variables. Six tests supported the proposition that psychosocial variables influence behavior conditionally, on external conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Relationships of these explanatory variables with care-seeking behaviors were supported, as was 1 of 2 propositions. The Theory of Care-Seeking Behavior can be applied to new clinical situations to continue to build knowledge of the theory and understanding of care-seeking behaviors.

Measures of psychosocial factors that may influence help-seeking behaviour in cancer: A systematic review of psychometric properties

Advanced stage cancer is frequently attributed to delays in presentation to a healthcare professional. To reduce undue delay, it is imperative to understand the reasons underlying help-seeking behaviour and to measure those using valid and reliable tools. This systematic review aimed to identify how studies have measured psychosocial factors affecting time to presentation for (potential) cancer symptoms. A total of 35 studies were included. Most studies failed to use valid and reliable tools, and predominantly provided inconclusive results regarding psychosocial factors and time to presentation when no or minimal psychometric evidence was present. Consequently, measure selection and future measure development should be guided by psychometric principles.

Understanding Hmong women's beliefs, feelings, norms, and external conditions about breast and cervical cancer screening

OBJECTIVES

To describe the beliefs, feelings, norms, and external conditions regarding breast and cervical cancer screening in a sample of Hmong women.

DESIGN AND SAMPLE

In a descriptive design, female Hmong researchers recruited 16 Hmong women (ages 24-73) at a community center. Guided by the Theory of Care Seeking Behavior (TCSB), researchers asked participants semi-structured questions about their beliefs, feelings, norms, and external conditions in a group setting. Researchers documented responses in writing and audio recordings. Guided by theory, we used directed content analysis to categorize responses.

RESULTS

Participants' beliefs' about screening included uncertainty about causes of breast and cervical cancer, uncertainty about Western forms of treatments, and terminal illness as outcomes of such cancer. Many felt embarrassed about breast and cervical cancer screening. Their cultural norms about undressing for an exam and listening to authority figures were different from Western norms. External conditions that influenced participants' for screenings included difficulties in communicating with interpreters and clinicians.

CONCLUSIONS

Consistent with the TCSB, Hmong women's beliefs, affect, cultural norms and external conditions helped to understand their use of breast and cervical screening. Findings could guide nursing and public health interventions to improve culturally sensitive, cancer screening for Hmong women.

Measuring barriers to incontinence care seeking

AIMS

The objective of this study was to establish the factor validity of a modified Melnyck's Barrier Scale and estimate its reliability in an ethnically heterogeneous incontinent female population.

METHODS

Computer assisted telephone interviews (CATI) were conducted on a nonprobability sample of 275 incontinent females (95 Caucasian, 95 African American, 80 Hispanic, 5 Other). Study participants were asked to rate the degree to which barrier items affected their seeking medical care for incontinence on a 4-point Likert scale ranging from 0 (none) to 3 (greatly). A confirmatory factor analysis was conducted to confirm the structure of the modified Melnyk's Barrier Scale and assess its fit in our racially heterogeneous incontinent female population. Cronbach's alpha coefficients were estimated to establish the reliability of the final barrier measurement model and its subscales.

RESULTS

The 14-item modified Melnyk's Barrier Scale contained 3 items that loaded on the inconvenience factor (factor loadings 0.659-0.812). Three items loaded on the relationship factor (factor loadings 0.452-0.796). Two items loaded on the site-related factor (factor loadings 0.554-0.960). Three items loaded on the cost factor (factor loadings 0.481-0.891). Three items loaded on the fear factor (factor loadings 0.457-0.624). Cronbach's alpha coefficient for the final 14-item modified Melnyk's Barrier Scale was 0.828 (Inconvenience subscale 0.79, Relationship subscale 0.68, Site related subscale 0.69, cost subscale 0.71, fear subscale 0.57).

CONCLUSION

We offer the Barriers to Incontinence Care Seeking questionnaire (BICS-Q) to epidemiologic researchers, given its factor validity and reliability, to operationalize barriers when studying relationships between ethnicity and health care disparities.

Care-seeking behaviors of African American women with breast cancer symptoms

In this descriptive correlational study, 48 African American women were assessed for delay in care-seeking for breast cancer symptoms by examining: (a) relationships between selected psychosocial variables (fear, denial, utility, and social norm) and delay, (b) relationships between delay and having an identified health provider, affordable health care services, and accessible health-care services, (c) whether denial would mediate the effect of fear on delay, (d) whether utility would moderate the effects of social norm and facilitating conditions on delay, and (e) whether denial was related to escape-avoidance coping. Participants completed mailed questionnaires. Pearson correlation and separate regression analyses showed that denial was associated with increased delay. Confrontive coping, social support, and problem-solving strategies had no relationship with delay. Interventions focusing on denial could help enhance early care seeking.

Research institute for nurse scientists responds to the challenge to expand and strengthen research focused on breast cancer in African American women

In an era where scientifically derived 'evidence' is used as a basis for nursing practice, it is imperative that nurses have a breadth of knowledge relative to the fundamentals of nursing science; knowledge of the current standards of nursing and medical practice; and knowledge of the characteristics, needs, concerns, and challenges of diverse consumer and patient population groups. Yet, while a significant body of 'evidence' that describes the experiences and needs of African American women across the breast care continuum has been generated, research suggests that there is a need to expand and strengthen this body of science. This report presents an overview of a decade of research focused on breast cancer among African American women and describes an initiative funded by the Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation to expand and strengthen nursing science that aims to reduce and/or eliminate excess breast cancer morbidity and mortality among African American women. Cancer 2007. (c) 2006 American Cancer Society.

Medical and psychosocial predictors of delay in seeking medical consultation for breast symptoms in women in a public sector setting

We examined demographic, medical and psychosocial factors related to delay in seeking medical consultation for breast symptoms. In this cross-sectional survey, 124 women with breast symptoms attending an outpatient breast surgery clinic in a county general hospital completed questionnaires measuring demographic, medical and psychosocial variables. Our outcome variable was delay in seeking medical consultation. Younger age (p <or= 0.05), less education (p <or= 0.01), absence of a lump (p <or= 0.05), lower perceived risk (p <or= 0.001), less spirituality (p <or= 0.01), cost (p <or= 0.001) and not wanting to think about breast symptom(s) (p <or= 0.05) were related to delay. Multivariate analyses showed absence of a breast lump by education interaction (p <or= 0.05), risk perception (p <or= 0.001), spirituality (p <or= 0.01) and cost (p <or= 0.001) collectively accounted for 38.4% of the variance in delay. Health promotion programs targeting low-income populations should emphasize the importance of breast symptoms other than lumps, especially to younger and less educated women.

Gambling with your life: The process of breast cancer treatment decision making in Chinese women

Treatment decision making (TDM) studies have primarily focused on assessing TDM quality and predominantly presume rational analytic processes as the gold standard. In a grounded theory study of 22 Hong Kong Chinese women following breast surgery who completed an in-depth interview exploring the process of TDM in breast cancer (BC), narrative data showed that discovery of a breast abnormality and emotional responses to BC diagnosis influence the TDM process. Lack of guidance from surgeons impaired TDM. Decisions were, for the most part, made using intuitive, pragmatic and emotionally driven criteria in the absence of complete information. The experience of TDM, which was likened to gambling, did not end once the decision was made but unfolded while waiting for surgery and the post-operative report. In this waiting period, women were emotionally overwhelmed by fear of death and the uncertainty of the surgical outcome, and equivocated over whether they had made the 'right' choice. This suggests that Chinese women feel they are gambling with their lives during TDM. These women are particularly emotionally vulnerable whilst waiting for their surgery and the post-surgical clinical pathology results. Providing emotional support is particularly important at this time when these women are overwhelmed by uncertainty.

Psychosocial Variables, External Barriers, and Stage of Mammography Adoption

Guided by H. Triandis's (1980) theory of behavior and the transtheoretical model, the study purpose was to examine differences in psychosocial variables and external conditions by stage of mammography adoption. Sampled from a statewide population, participants (N=509) were women aged 51-80. They had been contacted by telephone, screened for eligibility (e.g., no history of cancer or recent mammogram), and interviewed 3-6 months later. Higher utility beliefs, social influences, and practitioner interactions about mammography were associated with improved stage of adoption, as were lower negative affect and external barriers regarding mammography. Higher decisional balance scores, with and without negative affect toward mammography were associated with improved stage. Controlling for variables reflecting pros and cons, negative affect toward mammography further distinguished among stages. A richer set of pros and cons measures could explain screening more fully.

Barriers to breast cancer control for African-American women: the interdependence of culture and psychosocial issues

BACKGROUND

This study evaluates the cultural context of the behaviors and beliefs of African-American women to determine the success or failure of breast cancer prevention and control interventions. Cultural and psychologic reactions, such as fear, distrust, fatalism, and other "historic rooted" factors, are major determinants to participation in these interventions by African-American women.

METHODS

Psychosocial and cultural issues were delineated through a literature review in the areas of cancer prevention, breast cancer control, and African-American women. Assessments were conducted to document key successful models and activities that increased the participation of African-American women in breast cancer prevention and control interventions. Current community-based intervention strategies and activities were assessed.

RESULTS

Effective breast cancer prevention and control programs must address and develop cultural competent models that promote behavioral change in this population of women.

CONCLUSIONS

Studying the relationship between culture and psychosocial issues is integral to our understanding of how African-American women participate and respond to cancer prevention and control interventions. Cultural competent models that reduce and eliminate cancer disparities in this population must be developed.

Women's uncertainties, coping, and moods regarding abnormal papanicolaou results

The overall purpose of this study was to understand the process of coping with the news of abnormal cervical cancer screening results. The specific aims were (1) to compare women's uncertainty about the implications of abnormal Papanicolaou (Pap) tests and women's psychological distress over time and (2) to describe relationships among uncertainty, perceived coping ability, coping strategies that were used and helpful, and psychological distress. Seventy-five women were interviewed using standardized measures after hearing the news of their abnormal Paps tests; 40 completed similar questionnaires before follow-up colposcopy, and 35 of these also completed questionnaires after colposcopy. Women's uncertainty about abnormal Pap test results decreased over time. Negative mood scores, reflecting psychological distress, did not change over time. Uncertainty about Pap tests, ambiguity about cancer, and perceived inability to deal with Pap test results were related positively. Uncertainty was related positively to the coping strategy of catharsis as well as to negative mood scores both after receiving the news and precolposcopy. Catharsis was associated with higher negative mood scores, but acceptance was associated with lower negative mood scores. The helpfulness of relaxation and diversion was associated with lower negative mood scores. Clinical interventions can address women's uncertainty and promote coping strategies to reduce psychological distress among women with abnormal cervical cancer screening results.

Explaining women's intentions and use of hormones with menopause

The purposes of this theoretically-based study were (a) to examine the contributions of psychosocial variables (i.e., affect, beliefs, and norms), habit, and facilitating conditions to explaining women's intentions and use of hormones with menopause and (b) to assess whether clinical or demographic factors explained intentions and use, when controlling for psychosocial, habit, and facilitating conditions variables. In a cross-sectional design, 184 pre-, peri-, and postmenopausal women completed questionnaire measures. To explain intentions, data from 124 participants who were not using hormones were analyzed. To explain use, data from 125 peri- and postmenopausal participants were analyzed. In multivariate analyses, anxiety was associated inversely with use; norms were associated positively with intentions and use. Age was associated inversely with intentions; hot flashes were associated inversely with use. Future researchers can examine the combined influences of affect, beliefs, and norms on decisions about hormones. Clinicians can address anxieties and assess social influences about hormone use, as well as offer ways to deal with hot flashes.

Health behavior change models and their socio-cultural relevance for breast cancer screening in African American women

Models of health behavior provide the conceptual bases for most of the breast cancer screening intervention studies. These models were not designed for and have not been adequately tested with African American women. The models discussed in this paper are: The Health Belief Model, the Theory of Reasoned Action/Theory of Planned Behavior, and the Transtheoretical Model. This paper will examine the socio-cultural relevance of these health behavior models, and discuss specific socio-cultural dimensions that are not accounted for by these paradigms. It is critical that researchers include socio-cultural dimensions, such as interconnectedness, health socialization, ecological factors and health care system factors into their intervention models with African American women. Comprehensive and socio-culturally based investigations are necessary to guide the scientific and policy challenge for reducing breast cancer mortality in African American women.

A Motivational Message, External Barriers, and Mammography Utilization

Based on a theory of behavior, the interaction of a motivational message and external barriers on mammography utilization was tested. Participants (N = 101) had not had mammograms annually, and were identified from an urban clinic serving a disproportionally high percentage of indigent clients. Fifty-five percent were Caucasian; 45% were African-American. In an experimental design, half of the sample received a telephone discussion about rationale, feelings, and beliefs regarding mammograms, and half did not receive this contact. Four months later, nurses assessed women's recent mammography utilization and external barriers (e.g., affordability and accessibility). A logistic regression revealed an interaction between the intervention and barriers on postintervention mammography utilization (odds ratio: 2.12; p < 0.05). As proposed, the intervention was associated with a 64% rate of mammography utilization among women without barriers, but only a 26% rate among women with barriers. Not only should clinicians offer motivational messages about mammography, but also administrators should address external barriers to maximize mammography among socioeconomically disadvantaged groups.

Investigating Patient Satisfaction as an Outcome for Ultrasound-Guided Breast Procedures

An investigation of patient satisfaction with ultrasound-guided breast procedures (fine needle biopsy and cyst aspiration) was performed. The research was designed around a proposed imaging loop added to the Health Related Quality of Life model. A patient questionnaire, devised to assess three areas of the imaging loop—preanalytical, postanalytical, and overall satisfaction with the procedure—was administered. Results show a population of patients satisfied with these invasive procedures. Study patients' satisfaction levels were comparable with those of control subjects. Procedure anxiety was identified as a patient perception, but did not hamper level of satisfaction. Study patients also reported that ultrasound-guided breast procedures contributed to a perception of favorable overall health and gave a high level of patient satisfaction.

Influence of ethnicity and gender on cardiovascular responses to active coping and inhibitory-passive coping challenges

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to evaluate how black and white men and women responded physiologically to specific laboratory challenges.

METHODS

Hemodynamic responses to an active coping (evaluated speaking) and two inhibitory-passive coping (mirror tracing, cold pressor) tasks were examined in 138 black and white men and women.

RESULTS

Significant ethnicity by gender interactions occurred for the evaluated speaking task. Black men responded with lower blood pressure, cardiac output or heart rate, or both, than black women, white men, and white women, who did not differ from each other. Black men, relative to the other subgroups, also reported more inhibitory-passive coping, hostility, and pessimism, and less social support. Whites also responded with greater increases in systolic blood pressure during mirror tracing than blacks.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings indicate that black-white differences in physiological responsivity obtained for men may have limited generalizability for women. The results also suggest that environmental and social factors rather than genetic or constitutional factors may play a role in black-white reactivity differences.

Working from the inside out: implications of breast cancer activism for biomedical policies and practices

Much has been written about women with breast cancer: about women's lifestyles and reproductive strategies as possible risk factors for the disease, factors which impede or facilitate women's participation in mammography screening, ways to involve women in treatment decision-making, and women's ability to cope with breast cancer diagnoses. Seldom do these accounts examine breast cancer from the perspective of women with the disease. This essay presents material from an ethnographic study in the United States to explore the ways that women have come forward as informed consumers and activists working to make biomedical practices more responsive to the needs of women with breast cancer. Insofar as breast cancer activists reflect the concerns of a predominantly white, middle class constituency, however, additional questions are raised concerning their constructions of breast cancer and the problematics of treatment.

Testing theoretical explanations of mammography use

The theory of care-seeking behavior was tested in the context of mammography use among midwestern women (N = 178). In multivariate logistic regressions, mammography adherence in the past 5 years was related to habit, the interaction of anxiety and barriers, belief in one's risk of breast cancer, age, and family history of breast cancer. Recent use of mammograms (i.e., in the past 1 or 2 years, depending on age) was related to norm and habit. Intention was related to utility beliefs regarding mammography, norm, habit, and belief in one's risk of breast cancer. As proposed from theory, anxiety and barriers interacted to influence adherence, the variables of habit, utility beliefs, and norm were related to either recent use or intention. Contrary to theory, belief in one's risk of breast cancer, age, and family history of breast cancer were related to adherence or intention after controlling for theoretically derived variables. The explanatory variables for each outcome were not identical, indicating that these mammography-related outcomes are characteristically different.