Evidence of stable monomeric species in the unfolding of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase from Photobacterium leiognathi

A decision tree model for the prediction of homodimer folding mechanism

The formation of protein homodimer complexes for molecular catalysis and regulation is fascinating. The homodimer formation through 2S (2 state), 3SMI (3 state with monomer intermediate) and 3SDI (3 state with dimer intermediate) folding mechanism is known for 47 homodimer structures. Our dataset of forty-seven homodimers consists of twenty-eight 2S, twelve 3SMI and seven 3SDI. The dataset is characterized using monomer length, interface area and interface/total (I/T) residue ratio. It is found that 2S are often small in size with large I/T ratio and 3SDI are frequently large in size with small I/T ratio. Nonetheless, 3SMI have a mixture of these features. Hence, we used these parameters to develop a decision tree model. The decision tree model produced positive predictive values (PPV) of 72% for 2S, 58% for 3SMI and 57% for 3SDI in cross validation. Thus, the method finds application in assigning homodimers with folding mechanism.

A novel procedure for identification of the folding/unfolding patterns of dimeric proteins

The unfolding of proteins has been widely used for investigating the thermodynamic properties of monomeric proteins but has been used infrequently for dimeric (or oligomeric) proteins, because of the inherent cooperation of denaturation and dissociation of the dimers (oligomers). Here, we introduce a thermodynamic parameter K(obs) to discriminate the diverse folding patterns of dimeric proteins. K(obs) remains constant as the protein concentration increases for the true one-step curve of unfolding pattern (A), increases and reaches a plateau for one-step curves with monomeric intermediate pattern (B), and increases steadily with no plateau for one-step curves with dimeric intermediate pattern (C).

Structural features differentiate the mechanisms between 2S (2 state) and 3S (3 state) folding homodimers

The formation of homodimer complexes for interface stability, catalysis and regulation is intriguing. The mechanisms of homodimer complexations are even more interesting. Some homodimers form without intermediates (two-state (2S)) and others through the formation of stable intermediates (three-state (3S)). Here, we analyze 41 homodimer (25 2S and 16 3S) structures determined by X-ray crystallography to estimate structural differences between them. The analysis suggests that a combination of structural properties such as monomer length, subunit interface area, ratio of interface to interior hydrophobicity can predominately distinguish 2S and 3S homodimers. These findings are useful in the prediction of homodimer folding and binding mechanisms using structural data.

Systematically perturbed folding patterns of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)-associated SOD1 mutants

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis is a neurodegenerative syndrome associated with 114 mutations in the gene encoding the cytosolic homodimeric enzyme Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD). In this article, we report that amyotrophic lateral sclerosis-associated SOD mutations with distinctly different disease progression can be rationalized in terms of their folding patterns. The mutations are found to perturb the protein in multiple ways; they destabilize the precursor monomers (class 1), weaken the dimer interface (class 2), or both at the same time (class 1 + 2). A shared feature of the mutational perturbations is a shift of the folding equilibrium toward poorly structured SOD monomers. We observed a link, coupled to the altered folding patterns, between protein stability, net charge, and survival time for the patients carrying the mutations.

Active-site copper and zinc ions modulate the quaternary structure of prokaryotic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase

The influence of the constitutive metal ions on the equilibrium properties of dimeric Photobacterium leiognathi Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase has been studied for the wild-type and for two mutant protein forms bearing a negative charge in the amino acid clusters at the dimer association interface. Depletion of copper and zinc dissociates the two mutant proteins into monomers, which reassemble toward the dimeric state upon addition of stoichiometric amounts of zinc. Pressure-dependent dissociation is observed for the copper-depleted wild-type and mutated enzymes, as monitored by the fluorescence shift of a unique tryptophan residue located at the subunit association interface. The spectral shift occurs slowly, reaching a plateau after 15-20 minutes, and is fully reversible. The recovery of the original fluorescence properties, after decompression, is fast (less than four minutes), suggesting that the isolated subunit has a relatively stable structure, and excluding the presence of stable intermediates during the dimer-monomer transition. The dimer dissociation process is still incomplete at 6.5 kbar for the copper-depleted wild-type and mutated enzymes, at variance with what is generally observed for oligomeric proteins that dissociate below 3 kbar. Measurement of the degree of dissociation, at two different protein concentrations, allows us to calculate the standard volume variation upon association, Delta V, and the dissociation constant K(d0), at atmospheric pressure, (25 ml/mol and 3 x 10(-7)M, respectively). The holoprotein is fully dimeric even at 6.5 kbar, which allows us to evaluate a lower Delta G degrees limit of 11.5 kcal/mol, corresponding to a dissociation constant K(d0)<10(-9)M.

Effect of denaturants on the structural properties of soybean lipoxygenase-1

The effect of chemical (urea) and physical (temperature and high pressure) denaturation on the structural properties of soybean lipoxygenase-1 (LOX1) was analyzed through dynamic fluorescence spectroscopy and circular dichroism. We show that the fluorescence decay of the native protein could be fitted by two lorentzian distributions of lifetimes, centered at 1 and 4 ns. The analysis of the urea-denatured protein suggested that the shorter distribution is mostly due to the tryptophan residues located in the N-terminal domain of LOX1. We also show that a pressure of 2400 bar and a temperature of 55 degrees C brought LOX-1 to a state similar to a recently described stable intermediate "I." Analysis of circular dichroism spectra indicated a substantial decrease of alpha-helix compared with beta-structure under denaturing conditions, suggesting a higher stability of the N-terminal compared with the C-terminal domain in the denaturation process.

Dynamics-function correlation in Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase: a spectroscopic and molecular dynamics simulation study

A single mutation (Val29-->Gly) at the subunit interface of a Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase dimer leads to a twofold increase in the second order catalytic rate, when compared to the native enzyme, without causing any modification of the structure or the electric field distribution. To check the role of dynamic processes in this catalytic enhancement, the flexibility of the dimeric protein at the subunit interface region has been probed by the phosphorescence and fluorescence properties of the unique tryptophan residue. Multiple spectroscopic data indicate that Trp83 experiences a very similar, and relatively hydrophobic, environment in both wild-type and mutant protein, whereas its mobility is distinctly more restrained in the latter. Molecular dynamics simulation confirms this result, and provides, at the molecular level, details of the dynamic change felt by tryptophan. Moreover, the simulation shows that the loops surrounding the active site are more flexible in the mutant than in the native enzyme, making the copper more accessible to the incoming substrate, and being thus responsible for the catalytic rate enhancement. Evidence for increased, dynamic copper accessibility also comes from faster copper removal in the mutant by a metal chelator. These results indicate that differences in dynamic, rather than structural, features of the two enzymes are responsible for the observed functional change.

Dynamic features of the subunit interface of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase as probed by tryptophan phosphorescence

As part of the more general inquiry on the molecular basis of specific recognition between macromolecules, the subunit-subunit interface structure of dimeric superoxide dismutase from Photobacterium leiognathi has been probed selectively by the phosphorescence emission of Trp-73, located at the subunit contact region. Copper at the catalytic site was found to quench completely the delayed emission and therefore all studies were conducted with the copper-free or Cd(2+)-substituted protein. The spectrum at 140 K is diagnostic for an indole ring located in a hydrophobic environment whereas a degree of spectral broadening indicates that the local structure is not unique. Environmental heterogeneity is confirmed by the nonuniform phosphorescence decay in buffer, at 274 K, with lifetime components of 44 and 20 ms of practically equal amplitude. Information on the flexibility of the interface region was gathered from both the intrinsic lifetime and the accessibility of acrylamide to the site of the chromophore. The magnitude of the intrinsic lifetime, its temperature dependence, and the accessibility to solutes like acrylamide describe a tight dimeric structure in which hydrophobic interactions seem to play an important role. In particular the acrylamide bimolecular rate constant is 1.4 x 10(4) M(-1) s(-1) and indicates highly hindered diffusion of the solute through the interface region. Cd(2+) complexation to the apoprotein caused no detectable changes in protein conformation although the metal was able to influence the flexibility of the Trp-73 environment, indicating the occurrence of a long-range communication between the intersubunit surface and the active site, which is more than 16 A away.

Role of the tertiary and quaternary structures in the stability of dimeric copper, zinc superoxide dismutases

The equilibrium unfolding process of human Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase has been quantitatively monitored through circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy as a function of increasing guanidinium hydrochloride concentration. The process occurs through the formation of a monomeric intermediate species following a three-state transition equilibrium. Comparison with the stability of the prokaryotic Cu,Zn SOD from P. leiognathi shows that the eukaryotic enzyme is more stable than the prokaryotic enzyme by approximately 3 kcal/mol. This difference is due to the monomer-to-unfolded equilibrium, while the dimer-to-monomer equilibrium is comparable for the two enzymes despite their different intersubunit interactions. These results are confirmed by the unfolding of the copper-depleted derivatives. The Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase represents a good example of how evolution has found two independent quaternary assemblies maintaining the same dimer stability.