Genetic Influences on Sexual Behavior Differentiation. In: Gerall AA, Moltz H, Ward IL, editors. Sexual Differentiation. Boston: Springer US; 1992. pp. 1-40. [DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4899-2453-7_1]

Representing sex in the brain, one module at a time

Sexually dimorphic behaviors, qualitative or quantitative differences in behaviors between the sexes, result from the activity of a sexually differentiated nervous system. Sensory cues and sex hormones control the entire repertoire of sexually dimorphic behaviors, including those commonly thought to be charged with emotion such as courtship and aggression. Such overarching control mechanisms regulate distinct genes and neurons that in turn specify the display of these behaviors in a modular manner. How such modular control is transformed into cohesive internal states that correspond to sexually dimorphic behavior is poorly understood. We summarize current understanding of the neural circuit control of sexually dimorphic behaviors from several perspectives, including how neural circuits in general, and sexually dimorphic neurons in particular, can generate sexually dimorphic behaviors, and how molecular mechanisms and evolutionary constraints shape these behaviors. We propose that emergent themes such as the modular genetic and neural control of dimorphic behavior are broadly applicable to the neural control of other behaviors.

Of mice and rats: key species variations in the sexual differentiation of brain and behavior

Mice and rats are important mammalian models in biomedical research. In contrast to other biomedical fields, work on sexual differentiation of brain and behavior has traditionally utilized comparative animal models. As mice are gaining in popularity, it is essential to acknowledge the differences between these two rodents. Here we review neural and behavioral sexual dimorphisms in rats and mice, which highlight species differences and experimental gaps in the literature, that are needed for direct species comparisons. Moving forward, investigators must answer fundamental questions about their chosen organism, and attend to both species and strain differences as they select the optimal animal models for their research questions.

The androgen receptor governs the execution, but not programming, of male sexual and territorial behaviors

Testosterone and estrogen are essential for male behaviors in vertebrates. How these two signaling pathways interact to control masculinization of the brain and behavior remains to be established. Circulating testosterone activates the androgen receptor (AR) and also serves as the source of estrogen in the brain. We have used a genetic strategy to delete AR specifically in the mouse nervous system. This approach permits us to determine the function of AR in sexually dimorphic behaviors in males while maintaining circulating testosterone levels within the normal range. We find that AR mutant males exhibit masculine sexual and territorial displays, but they have striking deficits in specific components of these behaviors. Taken together with the surprisingly limited expression of AR in the developing brain, our findings indicate that testosterone acts as a precursor to estrogen to masculinize the brain and behavior, and signals via AR to control the levels of male behavioral displays.

Sex differences and effects of neonatal aromatase inhibition on masculine and feminine copulatory potentials in prairie voles

Copulatory behaviors in most rodents are highly sexually dimorphic, even when circulating hormones are equated between the sexes. Prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster) are monomorphic in their display of some social behaviors, including partner preferences and parenting, but differences between the sexes in their masculine and feminine copulatory behavior potentials have not been studied in detail. Furthermore, the role of neonatal aromatization of testosterone to estradiol on the development of prairie vole sexual behavior potentials or their brain is unknown. To address these issues, prairie vole pups were injected daily for the first week after birth with 0.5 mg of the aromatase inhibitor 1,4,6-androstatriene-3,17-dione (ATD) or oil. Masculine and feminine copulatory behaviors in response to testosterone or estradiol were later examined in both sexes. Males and females showed high mounting and thrusting in response to testosterone, but only males reliably showed ejaculatory behavior. Conversely, males never showed feminine copulatory behaviors in response to estradiol. Sex differences in these behaviors were not affected by neonatal ATD, but ATD-treated females received fewer mounts and thrusts than controls, possibly indicating reduced attractiveness to males. In other groups of subjects, neonatal ATD demasculinized males' tyrosine hydroxylase expression in the anteroventral periventricular preoptic area, and estrogen receptor alpha expression in the medial preoptic area. Thus, although sexual behavior in both sexes of prairie voles is highly masculinized, aromatase during neonatal life is necessary only for females' femininity. Furthermore, copulatory behavior potentials and at least some aspects of brain development in male prairie voles are dissociable by their requirement for neonatal aromatase.

A genetic approach to dissect sexually dimorphic behaviors

It has been known since antiquity that gender-specific behaviors are regulated by the gonads. We now know that testosterone is required for the appropriate display of male patterns of behavior. Estrogen and progesterone, on the other hand, are essential for female typical responses. Research from several groups also indicates that estrogen signaling is required for male typical behaviors. This finding raises the issue of the relative contribution of these two hormonal systems in the control of male typical behavioral displays. In this review we discuss the findings that led to these conclusions and suggest various genetic strategies that may be required to understand the relative roles of testosterone and estrogen signaling in the control of gender-specific behavior.

The role of androgen receptors in the masculinization of brain and behavior: what we've learned from the testicular feminization mutation

Many studies demonstrate that exposure to testicular steroids such as testosterone early in life masculinizes the developing brain, leading to permanent changes in behavior. Traditionally, masculinization of the rodent brain is believed to depend on estrogen receptors (ERs) and not androgen receptors (ARs). According to the aromatization hypothesis, circulating testosterone from the testes is converted locally in the brain by aromatase to estrogens, which then activate ERs to masculinize the brain. However, an emerging body of evidence indicates that the aromatization hypothesis cannot fully account for sex differences in brain morphology and behavior, and that androgens acting on ARs also play a role. The testicular feminization mutation (Tfm) in rodents, which produces a nonfunctional AR protein, provides an excellent model to probe the role of ARs in the development of brain and behavior. Tfm rodent models indicate that ARs are normally involved in the masculinization of many sexually dimorphic brain regions and a variety of behaviors, including sexual behaviors, stress response and cognitive processing. We review the role of ARs in the development of the brain and behavior, with an emphasis on what has been learned from Tfm rodents as well as from related mutations in humans causing complete androgen insensitivity.

Sexual behavior in male rodents

The hormonal factors and neural circuitry that control copulation are similar across rodent species, although there are differences in specific behavior patterns. Both estradiol (E) and dihydrotestosterone (DHT) contribute to the activation of mating, although E is more important for copulation and DHT for genital reflexes. Hormonal activation of the medial preoptic area (MPOA) is most effective, although implants in the medial amygdala (MeA) can also stimulate mounting in castrates. Chemosensory inputs from the main and accessory olfactory systems are the most important stimuli for mating in rodents, especially in hamsters, although genitosensory input also contributes. Dopamine agonists facilitate sexual behavior, and serotonin (5-HT) is generally inhibitory, though certain 5-HT receptor subtypes facilitate erection or ejaculation. Norepinephrine agonists and opiates have dose-dependent effects, with low doses facilitating and high doses inhibiting behavior.

Cellular phenotype of androgen receptor-immunoreactive nuclei in the developing and adult rat brain

Androgen exposure during development and adulthood promotes cell-to-cell communication, modulates the size of specific brain nuclei, and influences hormone-dependent behavioral and neuroendocrine functions. Androgen action involves the activation of androgen receptors (AR). To elucidate the mechanisms involved in AR-mediated effects on forebrain development, double-label fluorescent immunohistochemistry and confocal microscopy were employed to identify the cellular phenotype of AR-immunoreactive (AR(+)) cells in the developing (embryonic day 20, postnatal days 0, 4, 10) and adult male rat forebrain. Sections were doubly labeled with antibodies directed against AR and one of the following: neurons (immature, nestin; mature, NeuN) or astrocytes [immature, vimentin; mature, glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP)] or mature oligodendrocytes (mGalC). In all brain regions examined, by far the majority of AR(+) cells were neurons. In addition, small subsets of AR(+) cells were identified as mature astrocytes (GFAP(+)) but only in specific brain regions at specific ages. AR(+)/GFAP(+) cells were observed in the cerebral cortex but only in postnatal day 10 rats and in the arcuate nucleus of the hypothalamus but only in adult rats. Immature neurons, immature astrocytes, and oligodendrocytes were not AR(+) at any age, in any region. Thus, both neurons and astrocytes in the male rat forebrain contain ARs, suggesting that androgens, via ARs, may exert effects on both cell types in an age- and region-dependent manner.

Play fighting in androgen-insensitivetfm rats: Evidence that androgen receptors are necessary for the development of adult playful attack and defense

The frequency of playful attack and the style of playful defense, are modifiable by gonadal steroids and change after puberty in male and female rats. The present study examined the play behavior exhibited by testicular feminized mutation (tfm)-affected males, who are insensitive to androgens but can bind estrogens aromatized from androgens, to determine the relative contributions of androgens and estrogens to the age-related changes in play behavior. tfm males did not exhibit a decrease in playful attack with age and were more likely to maintain the use of complete rotations, a juvenile form of playful defense, into adulthood. tfm males did however, show age related changes in the use of partial rotations and upright postures, two other forms of playful defense, that were similar to normal males. These data suggest that the development of play fighting and defense in males is dependent on both androgen- and estrogen-receptor-mediated effects.

Of mice and missing data: what we know (and need to learn) about male sexual behavior

With recent advances in molecular genetics, the popularity of mice as subjects for behavioral neuroscience is increasing at an exponential rate. Unfortunately, the existing body of knowledge on sexual behavior in male mice is not large and many basic gaps exist. The assumption that what is true of rats is also true of mice is a dangerous one that can misdirect and, in the worst case, impede progress. We summarize the current knowledge about the sexual behavior of male mice, with an emphasis on hormonal bases of these behaviors. Behavioral differences between strains, developmental actions of steroids, activational actions of steroids given peripherally and in the brain, and data generated in various receptor knockout and related mice are discussed. In addition, suggestions are made for the standardization of experimental protocols used in investigations of the sexual physiology and behavior of male mice in order to facilitate between-experiment and between-laboratory comparisons and to expedite the growth of knowledge in this area.

Sex difference in attraction thresholds for volatile odors from male and estrous female mouse urine

Volatile urinary odors from opposite sex conspecifics contribute to mate recognition in numerous mammalian species, including mice. We used a simple habituation/dishabituation testing procedure to ask whether the capacity to detect and investigate decreasing concentrations of volatile urinary odors is sexually differentiated in mice. Beginning 2 months after gonadectomy and in the absence of any sex steroid treatment, adult, sexually naive male and female CBA x C57Bl/6 F1 hybrid mice received two series of daily tests that involved the presentation of different dilutions of urine from C57Bl/6 males followed by urine from estrous females. Each test session began with three consecutive presentations of deionized water (10 microl on filter paper for 2 min, behind a mesh barrier which prevented direct physical access, in the home cage at 1-min intervals) followed by three presentations of one of five different dilutions of urine (a different dilution on each test day). Males and females showed equivalent, significant habituation/dishabituation responses (low investigation times for successive water presentations; increased investigation of the first urine stimulus, followed by a decline in successive urine investigation times) to both male and female urine/water dilutions of 1:1, 1:10, and 1:20. However, only female mice responded reliably to 1:40 and 1:80 dilutions of both types of urine, pointing to a sex dimorphism in the detection and/or processing of biologically relevant, volatile urinary odors by the main olfactory system.

Sex with knockout models: behavioral studies of estrogen receptor alpha

Estrogens are an important class of steroid hormones, having multiple targets, in the body and brain, and exerting ubiquitous effects on behavior. At present, two estrogen receptors (ERalpha and beta) have been cloned and sequenced in mammals. In the brain these receptors are regionally specific, but both have widespread distributions, which are largely non-overlapping. Given the newly emerging complexities of estrogen's mechanisms of action it is important to distinguish which pathways are involved in modifying which behaviors. We use a knockout mouse, lacking functional copies of the estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) gene, to study the mechanisms by which estrogens mediate behaviors. There are pronounced ramifications of ERalpha gene disruption on behavior. First, female ERalpha knockout (ERalphaKO) mice do not display normal feminine sexual behavior. Second, treatment of adult mice with androgens promotes masculine sexual behavior in both sexes. However, male-typical sexual behavior is severely compromised in male and female ERalphaKOs. Third, male ERalphaKOs do not exhibit the same social preferences for female mice as do wildtype (WT) littermates. Thus, the ERalpha is essential for normal expression of sexual behaviors. In addition, gonadectomized ERalphaKO and WT mice rapidly learn to escape from the Morris water maze. Exogenous estrogen treatment prevents WT females from learning this task, yet, has no effect in ERalphaKO mice, suggesting that estrogens effects on learning in adult females involves the ERalpha. Based on these data we hypothesize that ERalpha mediates many of the effects of estrogen on sexual behavior, learning, and memory.

The preoptic area/anterior hypothalamus of different strains of mice: sex differences and development

While sex differences in neural morphology in the preoptic area/anterior hypothalamus (POA/AH) have been demonstrated in many species, their existence in mice have been controversial. Given the increased use of transgenic and gene-disrupted mice, we characterized sex differences using Nissl stains, and the immunocytochemical location of estrogen receptor-alpha (ER-alpha) and galanin in the POA/AH of two widely used strains, C57BL/6 and 129SvEv, and a mixed strain (C57BL/6x129Sv); the wild-type littermates of steroidogenic factor-1 (SF-1) gene-disrupted mice. Cell grouping was not a reliable marker of sex. In adults, cells located beneath the anterior commissure (AC) were reliably larger in females than males in 129SvEv, but not in the other strains. Caudally, cells in a group medial to the medial extension of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BST) were significantly larger in males than females in C57BL/6J and SF-1 gene-disrupted wild-types. Cell groups discernible by embryonic day (E) 18 were not sexually dimorphic for cell size in C57BL/6J mice at E18 or postnatal day (P) 4. The pattern of distribution of cells containing ER-alpha was similar among the strains, reduced in the group medial to the BST; a pattern established by P0. Galanin-containing cells and fibers were seen from E15 to adulthood ventral to the AC. Caudally, a smaller group ventromedial to the BST was found only in 129SvEv adults. Sex differences in neural morphology which develop within the POA/AH depend upon multiple factors, particularly including genetic background.

Estrogen receptor function as revealed by knockout studies: neuroendocrine and behavioral aspects

Estrogens are an important class of steroid hormones, involved in the development of brain, skeletal, and soft tissues. These hormones influence adult behaviors, endocrine state, and a host of other physiological functions. Given the recent cloning of a second estrogen receptor (ER) cDNA (the ER beta), work on alternate spliced forms of ER alpha, and the potential for membrane estrogen receptors, an animal with a null background for ER alpha function is invaluable for distinguishing biological responses of estrogens working via the ER alpha protein and those working via another ER protein. Data generated to date, and reviewed here, indicate that there are profound ramifications of the ER alpha disruption on behavior and neuroendocrine function. First, data on plasma levels of estradiol (E2), testosterone (T), and luteinizing hormone (LH) in wild-type (WT) versus ER alpha- mice confirm that ER alpha is essential in females for normal regulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary gonadal axis. Second, ovariectomized female ER alpha- mice do not display sexual receptivity when treated with a hormonal regime of estrogen and progesterone that induces receptivity in WT littermates. Finally, male sexual behaviors are disrupted in ER alpha- animals. Given decades of data on these topics our findings may seem self-evident. However, these data represent the most direct test currently possible of the specific role of the ER alpha protein on behavior and neuroendocrinology. The ER alpha- mouse can be used to ascertain the specific functions of ER alpha, to suggest functions for the other estrogen receptors, and to study indirect effects of ER alpha on behavior via actions on other receptors, neurotransmitters, and neuropeptides.

Behavioral effects of estrogen receptor gene disruption in male mice

Gonadal steroid hormones regulate sexually dimorphic development of brain functions and behaviors. Their nuclear receptors offer the opportunity to relate molecular events in neurons to simple instinctive mammalian behaviors. We have determined the role of estrogen receptor (ER) activation by endogenous estrogen in the development of male-typical behaviors by the use of transgenic estrogen-receptor-deficient (ERKO) mice. Surprisingly, in spite of the fact that they are infertile, ERKO mice showed normal motivation to mount females but they achieved less intromissions and virtually no ejaculations. Aggressive behaviors were dramatically reduced and male-typical offensive attacks were rarely displayed by ERKO males. Moreover, ER gene disruption demasculinized open-field behaviors. In the brain, despite the evident loss of functional ER protein, the androgen-dependent system appears to be normally present in ERKO mice. Together, these findings indicate that ER gene expression during development plays a major role in the organization of male-typical aggressive and emotional behaviors in addition to simple sexual behaviors.