Behavioral microanalysis of spatial delayed alternation performance: rehearsal through overt behavior, and effects of scopolamine and chlordiazepoxide

Mouse Behavior on the Trial-Unique Nonmatching-to-Location (TUNL) Touchscreen Task Reflects a Mixture of Distinct Working Memory Codes and Response Biases

The trial-unique nonmatching to location (TUNL) touchscreen task shows promise as a translational assay of working memory (WM) deficits in rodent models of autism, ADHD, and schizophrenia. However, the low-level neurocognitive processes that drive behavior in the TUNL task have not been fully elucidated. In particular, it is commonly assumed that the TUNL task predominantly measures spatial WM dependent on hippocampal pattern separation, but this proposition has not previously been tested. In this project, we tested this question using computational modeling of behavior from male and female mice performing the TUNL task (N = 163 across three datasets; 158,843 trials). Using this approach, we empirically tested whether TUNL behavior solely measured retrospective WM, or whether it was possible to deconstruct behavior into additional neurocognitive subprocesses. Overall, contrary to common assumptions, modeling analyses revealed that behavior on the TUNL task did not primarily reflect retrospective spatial WM. Instead, behavior was best explained as a mixture of response strategies, including both retrospective WM (remembering the spatial location of a previous stimulus) and prospective WM (remembering an anticipated future behavioral response) as well as animal-specific response biases. These results suggest that retrospective spatial WM is just one of a number of cognitive subprocesses that contribute to choice behavior on the TUNL task. We suggest that findings can be understood within a resource-rational framework, and use computational model simulations to propose several task-design principles that we predict will maximize spatial WM and minimize alternative behavioral strategies in the TUNL task.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Touchscreen tasks represent a paradigm shift for assessment of cognition in nonhuman animals by automating large-scale behavioral data collection. Their main relevance, however, depends on the assumption of functional equivalence to cognitive domains in humans. The trial-unique, delayed nonmatching to location (TUNL) touchscreen task has revolutionized the study of rodent spatial working memory. However, its assumption of functional equivalence to human spatial working memory is untested. We leveraged previously untapped single-trial TUNL data to uncover a novel set of hierarchically ordered cognitive processes that underlie mouse behavior on this task. The strategies used demonstrate multiple cognitive approaches to a single behavioral outcome and the requirement for more precise task design and sophisticated data analysis in interpreting rodent spatial working memory.

Response and sample bridging in a primate short-term memory task

Freely-moving rodents can solve short-term memory (STM) tasks using "response bridging" strategies, relying on motor patterns instead of mnemonic functions. This limits the interpretational power of results yielded by some STM tasks in rodents. To determine whether head-fixed monkeys can employ parallel non-mnemonic strategies, we measured eye position and velocity of two head-fixed monkeys performing a delayed response reaching and grasping task. We found that eye position during the delay period was correlated with reach direction. Moreover, reach direction as well as grasp object could be predicted from eye kinematics during the delay. Both eye velocity and eye position contributed to the prediction of reach direction. These results show that motor signals carry sufficient information to allow monkeys to solve STM tasks without using any mnemonic functions. Thus, the potential of animals to solve STM tasks using motor patterns is more diverse than previously recognized.

The Cognitive Effect Profiles of NMDA Receptor Modulating Drugs are Resolvable If Stimulus Complexity Is Varied in a Number Discernment Task

Number discernment is at the heart of task accuracy for laboratory animals performing Fixed Consecutive Number (FCN) operant tasks. Narrow-limit FCN tasks, in particular, are useful for measuring working memory in rat subjects because performance efficacy, which is set up to concord with food delivery, depends on a fairly precise quantification of cues generated by the rat's ongoing behavior. Reported here is a behavioral pharmacology study that utilized a group of overtrained and FCN-schedule-compliant rats injected in a randomized series of testing sessions with different types of N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor modulating drugs. Modifications made to the narrowlimit FCN schedule permitted a simultaneous measure of druginduced compromises in subjects' sensory integrative or motor coordinating capabilities. This highly sensitive model implicated the intrachannel and the glutamate recognition NMDA receptor binding sites as prime mediators of NMDA antagonist associated memory impairments because drugs acting at the mentioned sites lowered counting efficacy without altering sensorimotor function.

A novel 2- and 3-choice touchscreen-based continuous trial-unique nonmatching-to-location task (cTUNL) sensitive to functional differences between dentate gyrus and CA3 subregions of the hippocampus

RATIONALE

The touchscreen continuous trial-unique non-matching-to-location task (cTUNL) has been developed to optimise a battery of tasks under NEWMEDS (Novel Methods leading to New Medication in Depression and Schizophrenia, http://www.newmeds-europe.com ). It offers novel task features of both a practical and a theoretical nature compared to existing touchscreen tasks for spatial working memory.

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study was to determine whether the cTUNL task is sufficiently sensitive to differentiate between dentate gyrus (DG) and CA3 hippocampal subregion contributions to performance.

METHODS

The effect of DG and CA3 dysfunction on memory for locations in the cTUNL task was tested. Rats were assessed on versions of the task-two-choice and three-choice-that differed in memory load. Performance was challenged using manipulations of delay and the spatial separation between target and sample locations.

RESULTS

Dysfunction of the DG disrupts performance across both delay and spatial separations in two-choice cTUNL when the delay is variable and unpredictable. Increasing the working memory load (three stimuli) increases sensitivity to DG dysfunction, with deficits apparent at fixed, short delays. In contrast, CA3 dysfunction did not disrupt performance.

CONCLUSION

Acquisition of cTUNL was rapid, and the task was sensitive to manipulations of delays and separations. A three-choice version of the task was found to be viable. Finally, both the two- and three-choice versions of the task were able to differentiate between limited dysfunction to different areas within the hippocampus. DG dysfunction affected performance when using unpredictable task parameters. CA3 dysfunction did not result in impairment, even at the longest delays tested.

Animal paradigms to assess cognition with translation to humans

Cognition is a complex brain function that represents processes such as learning and memory, attention, working memory, and executive functions amongst others. Impairments in cognition are prevalent in many neuropsychiatric and neurological disorders with few viable treatment options. The development of new therapies is challenging, and poor efficacy in clinical development continues to be one of the most consistent reasons compounds fail to advance, suggesting that traditional animal models are not predictive of human conditions and behavior. An effort to improve the construct validity of neuropsychological testing across species with the intent of facilitating therapeutic development has been strengthening over recent years. With an emphasis on understanding the underlying biology, optimizing the use of appropriate systems (e.g., transgenic animals) to model targeted disease states, and incorporating non-rodent species (e.g., non-human primates) that may enable a closer comparison to humans, an improvement in the translatability of the results will be possible. This chapter focuses on some promising translational cognitive paradigms for use in rodents, non-human primates, and humans.

The touchscreen operant platform for testing working memory and pattern separation in rats and mice

The automated touchscreen operant chamber for rats and mice allows for the assessment of multiple cognitive domains within the same testing environment. This protocol presents the location discrimination (LD) task and the trial-unique delayed nonmatching-to-location (TUNL) task, which both assess memory for location. During these tasks, animals are trained to a predefined criterion during ∼20-40 daily sessions. In LD sessions, touching the same location on the screen is rewarded on consecutive trials, followed by a reversal of location-reward contingencies. TUNL, a working memory task, requires animals to 'nonmatch' to a sample location after a delay. In both the LD and TUNL tasks, spatial similarity can be varied, allowing assessment of pattern separation ability, a function that is thought to be performed by the dentate gyrus (DG). These tasks are therefore particularly useful in animal models of hippocampal, and specifically DG, function, but they additionally permit discernment of changes in pattern separation from those in working memory.

Muscarinic receptor pharmacology and circuitry for the modulation of cognition

The muscarinic cholinergic system constitutes an important part of the neuronal circuitry that modulates normal cognition. Muscarinic receptor antagonists are well known to produce or exacerbate impairments in attention, learning, and memory. Conversely, both direct-acting muscarinic receptor agonists and indirect-acting muscarinic cholinergic agonists, such as acetylcholinesterase inhibitors, have shown cognition-enhancing properties, including improvements in normal cognitive function, reversal of cognitive deficits induced by muscarinic receptor antagonists, and attenuation of cognitive deficits in psychiatric and neurological disorders, such as Alzheimer's disease and schizophrenia. However, until recently, the lack of small molecule ligands that antagonize or activate specific muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (mAChR) subtypes with high selectivity has been a major obstacle in defining the relative contributions of individual mAChRs to different aspects of cognitive function and for the development of novel therapeutic agents. These limitations may be potentially overcome by the recent discovery of novel mAChR subtype-selective compounds, notably allosteric agonists and positive allosteric modulators, which exhibit greater selectivity for individual mAChR subtypes than previous mAChR orthosteric agonists. In preclinical studies, these novel ligands have shown promising efficacy in several models for the enhancement of cognition. In this chapter, we will review the muscarinic cholinergic circuitry and pharmacology of mAChR agonists and antagonists relevant to the modulation of different aspects of cognition in animals and clinical populations.

Automatic recording of mediating behavior in delayed matching- and nonmatching-to-position procedures in rats

RATIONALE

Delayed matching-to-position and nonmatching-to-position procedures are widely used to model working memory in rodents. Mediating behavior-which enhances performance but is not explicitly required by the task-is generally considered an obstacle to the measurement of memory, but often occurs despite attempts to prevent it. The ubiquitous nature of mediating behavior suggests it might be analogous to rehearsal, an important component of learning and memory in humans.

OBJECTIVES

The aim was to study an easily recordable, rehearsal-like mediating response in rats under baseline conditions and after treatment with amnestic drugs [scopolamine (0.1-0.3 mg/kg) and delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC; 1-5.6 mg/kg)].

METHODS

Lighted nosepoke holes were used to present position cues and record delayed matching or nonmatching responses. Performance of a distractor task was required to prevent simply waiting at the correct choice, but the nosepoke holes were left accessible during the delay.

RESULTS

Each rat trained with the nonmatching task exhibited one of two mediating "strategies" that increased the odds of a correct choice: responding in the to-be-correct hole during the delay or responding in the opposite hole during the delay. Rats trained with the matching task all showed the former strategy. Treatment with scopolamine disrupted performance of the mediating response. Scopolamine and THC both decreased the effectiveness of the mediating response, increasing errors even on trials when the "appropriate" mediating behavior did occur.

CONCLUSIONS

The procedures and data analysis approach used here provide an objective, automated means of measuring mediating behavior, which might be useful as an animal model of memory rehearsal.

Hippocampal lesions in rats impair learning and memory for locations on a touch-sensitive computer screen: the "ASAT" task

It has been repeatedly demonstrated across species that the hippocampus is critical for spatial learning and memory. Consequently, numerous paradigms have been created to study spatial learning in the rodent. Most of these tasks, such as the Morris water maze, 8-arm radial maze, and T-maze, are non-automated procedures. It was our goal to create an automated task in the rodent that is quickly learned, hippocampal-dependent, and minimizes the confounding variables present in most tests measuring hippocampal-dependent learning and memory. To accomplish this, we created a novel search task using a standard operant box fitted with a touch-sensitive computer monitor. Subjects were required to locate an S+ "hidden" amongst other identical stimuli on the monitor. In two versions of the task the S+ stayed in the same location within a session but shifted location between sessions. In a third version of the task the S+ was moved to a new location after every 10 trials. It was found that the location of the S+ was quickly acquired each day (within 10 trials), and that the hippocampal-lesion group was impaired when compared to their control cohort. With the benefits inherent in automation, these tasks confer significant advantages over traditional tasks used to study spatial learning and memory in the rodent. When combined with previously developed non-spatial cognitive tests that can also be run in the touch-screen apparatus, the result is a powerful cognitive test battery for the rodent.

Hippocampal lesions impair performance on a conditional delayed matching and non-matching to position task in the rat

The hippocampus is thought to be involved in a range of cognitive processes, from the ability to acquire new memories, to the ability to learn about spatial relationships. Humans and monkeys with damage to the hippocampus are typically impaired on delayed matching to sample tasks, of which the operant delayed matching to position task (DMTP) is a rat analogue. The reported effects of hippocampal damage on DMTP vary, ranging from delay-dependent deficits to no deficit whatsoever. The present study investigates a novel memory task; the conditional delayed matching/non-matching to position task (CDM/NMTP) in the Skinner box. CDM/NMTP uses the presence of specific stimulus cues to signify whether a particular trial is matching or non-matching in nature. Thus, it incorporates both the task contingencies within one session, and supplements the requirement for remembering the side of the lever in the sample phase with attending to the stimulus and remembering the conditional discrimination for the rule. Rats were trained preoperatively and the effects of bilateral excitotoxic lesions of the hippocampus were examined on postoperative retention of the task. Rats with lesions of the hippocampus incurred a significant impairment on the task that was manifest at all delays intervals. Despite a bias towards matching during training, trials of either type were performed with equivalent accuracy and neither rule was affected differentially by the lesion. This task may prove useful in determining the cognitive roles of a range of brain areas.

Reduced attention and increased impulsivity in mice lacking NPY Y2 receptors: Relation to anxiolytic-like phenotype

Neuropeptide (NPY) Y2 receptors play an important role in some anxiety-related and stress-related behaviours in mice. Changes in the level of anxiety can affect some cognitive functions such as memory, attention and inhibitory response control. We investigated the effects of NPY Y2 receptor deletion (Y2(-/-)) in mice on visual attention and response control using the five-choice serial reaction time (5-CSRT) task in which accuracy of detection of a brief visual stimulus across five spatial locations may serve as a valid behavioural index of attentional functioning. Anticipatory and perseverative responses provide a measure of inhibitory response control. During training, the Y2(-/-) mice had lower accuracy (% correct), and made more anticipatory responses. At stimulus durations of 2 and 4s the Y2(-/-) were as accurate as the Y2(+/+) mice but still more impulsive than Y(+/+). At stimulus durations of 0.25 and 0.5s both groups performed worse but the Y2(-/-) mice made significantly fewer correct responses than the Y2(+/+) controls. The anxiolytic drug diazepam at 2mg/kg IP greatly increased the anticipatory responding of Y2(-/-) mice compared to Y2(+/+). The anxiogenic inverse benzodiazepine agonist, FG 7142, at 10mg/kg IP reduced the anticipatory responding of Y2(-/-) but not Y2(+/+) mice. These data suggest that NPY Y2 receptors make an important contribution to mechanisms controlling attentional functioning and "impulsivity". They also show that "impulsivity" of NPY Y2(-/-) mice may depend on their level of anxiety. These findings may help in understanding the pathophysiology of stress disorders and depression.

An overview of the tasks used to test working memory in rodents

In rodents, working memory is a representation of an object, stimulus, or spatial location that is typically used within a testing session, but not between sessions, to guide behaviour. In this review we consider a number of the tasks used to assess this type of memory in the rodent, and highlight some of their limitations. Although the concept of working memory as applied to rodents has its origin in the experiments of David Olton and Werner Honig in the 1970s, many earlier experiments assessed the same type of memory under the guise of delayed reaction or alternation paradigms. We revisit these early tasks, and also consider the nature of working memory used on maze tasks, operant box based tasks, and non-spatial delayed non-matching to sample paradigms.

Animal cognition: defining the issues

The assessment of cognitive functions in rodents represents a critical experimental variable in many research fields, ranging from the basic cognitive neurosciences to psychopharmacology and neurotoxicology. The increasing use of animal behavioral tests as 'assays' for the assessment of effects on learning and memory has resulted in a considerable heterogeneity of data, particularly in the field of behavioral and psycho pharmacology. The limited predictive validity of changes in behavioral performance observed in standard animal tests of learning and memory indicates that a renewed effort to scrutinize the validity of these tests is warranted. In humans, levels of processing (effortful vs. automatic) and categories of information (procedural vs. episodic/declarative) are important variables of cognitive operations. The design of tasks that assess the recall of 'episodic' or 'declarative' information appears to represent a particular challenge for research using laboratory rodents. For example, the hypothesis that changes in inspection time for a previously encountered place or object are based on the recall of declarative/episodic information requires substantiation. In order to generalize findings on the effects of neuronal or pharmacological manipulations on learning and memory, obtained from one species and one task, to other species and other tasks, the mediating role of important sets of variables which influence learning and memory (e.g. attentional, affective) needs to be determined. Similar to the view that a neuronal manipulation (e.g. a lesion) represents a theory of the condition modeled (e.g. a degenerative disorder), an animal behavioral task represents a theory of the behavioral/cognitive process of interest. Therefore, the test of hypotheses regarding the validity of procedures used to assess cognitive functions in animals is an inherent part of the research process.

Blockade of Central Cholinergic Receptors Impairs New Learning and Increases Proactive Interference in a Word Paired-Associate Memory Task

Experimental data and computational models suggest that blockade of muscarinic cholinergic receptors impairs paired-associate learning and increases proactive interference (E. DeRosa & M. E. Hasselmo, 2000; M. E. Hasselmo & J. M. Bower, 1993). The results presented here provide evidence in humans supporting these hypotheses. Young healthy subjects first learned baseline word pairs (A-B) and, after a delay, learned additional overlapping (A-C) and nonoverlapping (D-E) word pairs. As predicted, when compared with subjects who received the active placebo glycopyrrolate (4 microg/kg) and subjects who were not injected, those who received scopolamine (8 microg/kg) showed (a) overall impairment in new word paired-associate learning, but no impairment in cued recall of previously learned associates; and (b) greater impairment in learning overlapping (A-C) compared with nonoverlapping (D-E) paired associates.

5-HT1A receptor agonist (8-OH-DPAT) and 5-HT2 receptor agonist (DOI) disrupt the non-cognitive performance of rats in a working memory task

The present study investigated the role of 5 -HT1A and 5 -HT2 receptors in the execution of a working memory task (delayed non-matching to position, DNMTP) by assessing the influence of 8-OH-DPAT (5-HT1A receptor agonist) and DOI (5-HT2 receptor agonist) on the performance of rats lesioned with 5,7-dihydroxytryptamine (5,7-DHT) and their controls. Post-mortem neurochemical analysis revealed that serotonin and 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid levels were reduced in examined brain areas (especially in the hippocampus where there was a 90 percent reduction). Noradrenaline concentrations were also decreased (mostly on the same side of the injection) by about 20 percent. 5,7-DHT lesioned rats did not significantly differ from their controls in performance in the DNMTP task. At the 30 microg/kg dose, 8-OH-DPAT did not affect the DNMTP-performance of rats, but at the higher dose (100 microg/kg) it reduced the probability of responding to the sample lever. DOI (100 and 300 microg/kg) also interfered with the non-cognitive performance of rats. Since neither of these agonists affected significantly the choice accuracy, they do not appear to influence the working memory per se. The 5,7-DHT lesioned rats did not differ from their controls in response to these agonists. These results suggest that the combination of 5-HT1A receptor stimulation by 8-OH-DPAT and 5-HT2 receptor stimulation by DOI can interfere with the non-cognitive performance of rats in the DNMTP task. The results further indicate that the effect of 8-OH-DPAT may be mediated through post-synaptic rather than pre-synaptic 5-HT1A receptors.

Effects of scopolamine on working memory in rats in a delayed matching-to-position task, employing a subject-centered procedure

The effect of scopolamine hydrobromide on a delayed matching-to-position task was examined while controlling for two confounding factors, i.e., mediating behavior and slow performance on a task. The task was given on the basis of a subject-centered method in which delay intervals are dependent on subjects' performance. The performance of individual subjects, rather than averaged group performance, was taken as the focus of the analysis. The results indicated that scopolamine had an effect not only on speed of performing the task but also on the length of the retention interval. The effects differed considerably among individuals: the effects on both the length of the retention interval and the speed of performance were found for two of the five subjects. An effect on speed of performance alone was found for one subject. No effects on either measure were found in a further two subjects.

Medial prefrontal and neostriatal lesions disrupt performance in an operant delayed alternation task in rats

An operant version of the classical delayed alternation task is presented and applied to evaluate the effects of bilateral prefrontal and striatal lesions in rats. Retractable levers in a conventional operant chamber control discrete trial opportunities for making sequential choice responses to the two sides, and the rats are required to maintain repeated nose poke responses to a central panel during the delay interval, which is randomly varied. The operant task provides measures of the speed and accuracy of response alternation and side bias; analysis at different delay intervals provides an index of the memory demands of accurate performance; and analysis of accuracy depending on the response on preceding trials provides measures of proactive interference and perseveration. Following pretraining in the task contingencies, both striatal and prefrontal lesions induced profound deficits in task accuracy, with no change in side bias and only small changes in movement times. The deficit in the prefrontal lesion group recovered more rapidly, neither group showed any change in sensitivity to proactive interference, while the rats with striatal lesions alone exhibited an increased tendency to perseverate incorrect responses on either side. We conclude that the operant delayed alternation task should assist analysis of fronto-striatal function in rats as well as be useful for the analysis of strategies for fronto-striatal repair.

The effects of NMDA-induced retrohippocampal lesions on performance of four spatial memory tasks known to be sensitive to hippocampal damage in the rat

Four separate cohorts of rats were employed to examine the effects of cytotoxic retrohippocampal lesions in four spatial memory tasks which are known to be sensitive to direct hippocampal damage and/or fornix-fimbria lesions in the rat. Selective retrohippocampal lesions were made by means of multiple intracerebral infusions of NMDA centred on the entorhinal cortex bilaterally. Cell damage typically extended from the lateral entorhinal area to the distal ventral subiculum. Experiment 1 demonstrated that retrohippocampal lesions spared the acquisition of a reference memory task in the Morris water maze, in which the animals learned to escape from the water by swimming to a submerged platform in a fixed location. In the subsequent transfer test, when the escape platform was removed, rats with retrohippocampal lesions tended to spend less time searching in the appropriate quadrant compared to controls. Experiment 2 demonstrated that the lesions also spared the acquisition of a working memory version of the water maze task in which the location of the escape platform was varied between days. In experiment 3, both reference and working memory were assessed using an eight-arm radial maze in which the same four arms were constantly baited between trials. In the initial acquisition, reference memory but not working memory was affected by the lesions. During subsequent reversal learning in which previously baited arms were now no longer baited and vice versa, lesioned animals made significantly more reference memory errors as well as working memory errors. In experiment 4, spatial working memory was assessed in a delayed matching-to-position task conducted in a two-lever operant chamber. There was no evidence for any impairment in rats with retrohippocampal lesions in this task. The present study demonstrated that unlike direct hippocampal damage, retrohippocampal cell loss did not lead to a general impairment in spatial learning, implying that the integrity of the retrohippocampus and/or its interconnection with the hippocampal formation is not critical for normal hippocampal-dependent spatial learning and memory. This outcome is surprising for a number of current hippocampal theories, and suggests that other cortical as well as subcortical inputs to the hippocampus might be of more importance, and further raises the question regarding the functional significance of the retrohippocampal region.

Scopolamine-induced impairment in concurrent fixed-interval responding in a radial maze task

The present study investigated the effects of scopolamine hydrobromide (SCOP: 0.06-1.0 mg/kg IP) and its quartenary analogue, scopolamine methylbromide (SCOPMB), on performance in a radial arm maze foraging task, to dissociate general drug-induced alterations of motor performance from measurement of impairments on more complex behaviors involving timing and memory. In this paradigm. rats are trained to free run a radial maze under an eight-alternative concurrent fixed-interval (FI) schedule of food reinforcement. The eight FIs (55 to 759 s) were assigned randomly to the arms of the maze, with a different pattern for each animal. SCOP produced dose-dependent degradation in response patterning and response rates in the concurrent FI schedules without significantly affecting the rates of arm entries or arm traversal latencies. The peripheral cholinergic antagonist, SCOPMB, generally produced small to moderate depressions in all measures with the exception of patterning of arm entries and pellets earned, but there were no clear dose-response relationships evident in the data. These results are consistent with the notion that central cholinergic mechanisms are involved in the mediation of complex conditioned behaviors.

Recognition memory in rats--III. Neurochemical substrates

In the first part of three overviews on recognition memory in the rat, we discussed the tasks employed to study recognition memory. In the second part, we discussed the neuroanatomical systems thought to be of importance for the mediation of recognition memory in the rat. In particular, we delineated two parallel-distributed neuronal networks, one that is essential for the processing of non-spatial/item recognition memory processes and incorporates the cortical association areas such as TE1, TE2 and TE3, the rhinal cortices, the mediodorsal thalamic nucleus and prefrontal cortical areas (Network 1), the other comprising of the hippocampus, mamillary bodies, anterior thalamic nuclei and medial prefrontal areas (Network 2), suggested to be pivotal for the processing of spatial recognition memory. The next step will progress to the level of the neurotransmitters thought to be involved. Current data suggest that the majority of drugs have non-specific, i.e. delay-independent effects in tasks measuring recognition memory. This may be due to attentional, motivational or motoric changes. Alternatively, delay-independent effects may result from altered acquisition/encoding rather than from altered retention. Furthermore, the neurotransmitter systems affected by these drugs could be important as modulators rather than as mediators of recognition memory per se. It could, of course, also be the case that systemic treatment induces non-specific effects which overshadow any specific, delay-dependent, effect. This possibility receives support from lesion experiments (for example, of the septohippocampal cholinergic system) or studies employing local intracerebral infusion techniques. However, it is evident that those delay-dependent effects are relatively subtle and more readily seen in delayed response paradigms, which tax spatial recognition memory. One interpretation of these results could be that some neurotransmitter systems are more involved in spatial than in item recognition memory processes. However, performance in delayed response tasks can be aided by mediating strategies. Drugs or lesions can alter those strategies, which could equally explain some of the (delay-dependent) drug effects on delayed responding. Thus, it is evident that neither of the neurotransmitter systems reviewed (glutamate, GABA, acetylcholine, serotonin, dopamine and noradrenaline) can be viewed as being directly and exclusively concerned with storage/retention. Rather, our model of recognition memory suggests that information about previously encountered items is differentially processed by distinct neural networks and is not mediated by a single neurotransmitter type.

Effects of cholinergic drug infusions into the dorsal part of the medial prefrontal cortex on delayed conditional discrimination performance in the rat

Effects of bilateral infusions of cholinergic drugs into the dorsal part of the medial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC) on performance in a delayed conditional discrimination (DCD) task were examined in rats. Scopolamine dose-dependently impaired performance. No delay-dependent effect was found indicating that scopolamine did not specifically affect working memory (WM). Physostigmine alone induced a slight improvement of DCD performance independent of delay and co-administration of physostigmine with scopolamine attenuated the scopolamine-induced impairment of DCD performance. Infusion of the muscarinic M2 antagonist AQRA-471, the M3 antagonist 4-DAMP and the mixed M1-M3 antagonist UH-AH 37 did not affect performance in the DCD task, suggesting that the effect of scopolamine is not mediated by a single muscarinic receptor subtype. The results furthermore indicate that the cholinergic system in the dmPFC does not play a specific role in WM processes in the DCD task. Furthermore, the results suggest that the dmPFC cholinergic system plays a role in the attentional processes involved in the DCD task.

Effects of infusion of cholinergic drugs into the prefrontal cortex area on delayed matching to position performance in the rat

Rats trained on a Delayed Matching To Position (DMTP) task displayed mediating behavior during delays to solve the task. Infusion of the cholinergic antagonist scopolamine into the medial Prefrontal Cortex area (mPFC), dose dependently impaired performance independent of delay. These results indicate that scopolamine does not specifically affect working memory. Infusion of the cholinesterase inhibitor physostigmine, muscarinic subtype receptor antagonists, the dopamine (D1) antagonist SCH23390, and of the GABA-A receptor antagonist bicuculline, did not affect performance in the DMTP task. In a post-hoc analysis scopolamine was found to impair discriminability in a delay-dependent manner only in animals that used mediating behavior in the majority of the trials. Furthermore, a time sampling method indicated that scopolamine infusions into the mPFC disrupted mediating behavior during the task. Results suggest that cholinergic systems in the mPFC play a role in directing attention to task relevant behavior.

Dissociation between cognitive and motor/motivational deficits in the delayed matching to position test: effects of scopolamine, 8-OH-DPAT and EAA antagonists

The effects of the muscarinic antagonists scopolamine HBr and MeBr, the 5-HT1A agonist 8-hydroxy-2-(di-n-propylamino)tetralin (8-OH-DPAT), and the N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) antagonists MK-801 and CGS-19755 on performance of rats in a delayed matching-to-position task were examined. Pretreatment with scopolamine HBr (0.05 and 0.1 mg/kg), resulted in a delay-dependent decrease in the percentage of correct responses and discriminability (log d), but had no effect on either the latency to complete trials, or the rate of trial completion during the fixed duration session. Scopolamine MeBr (0.1 mg/kg) did not impair percent correct or increase the response latency but did decrease the rate of trial completion. 8-OH-DPAT (up to 0.3 mg/kg), had no effect on percent correct, but did induce a small decrease in discriminability. The impairment in discriminability occurred only at a dose that substantially reduced the rate of trial completion. Both MK-801 (0.05 mg/kg) and CGS 19755 (10 mg/kg) induced a delay-independent impairment in percent correct, discriminability and a reduction in the rate of trial completion without affecting latency. A lower dose of CGS 19755 (5.0 mg/kg) induced a slight impairment in discriminability without significantly affecting the other measures. Taken together, these results demonstrate some dissociation between drug-induced cognitive and motor/motivational deficits in the DMTP test. However, the data question the specificity of putative cognitive impairments reported in many previous studies with the 5-HT1A agonist 8-OH-DPAT.

Cholinergic agents and delay-dependent performance in the rat

We tested cholinergic agents in delayed matching and nonmatching to position. Each task had a delay between the presentation of information and the chance to act on it later. We used a titrating procedure, new to experiments with rats, to determine the delay. Linopirdine (0.1 mg/kg), which releases acetylcholine, and physostigmine (0.1 mg/kg), a cholinesterase inhibitor, ameliorated the impairment of accuracy produced by scopolamine hydrobromide (0.1 mg/kg). In some cases, scopolamine hydrobromide decreased the number of trials, but physostigmine and linopirdine did not ameliorate that impairment. Both the muscarinic receptor antagonist, scopolamine hydrobromide (0.1 and 0.3 mg/kg), and its peripherally acting analog, scopolamine methylbromide (0.1 and 0.3 mg/kg), decreased accuracy. The impairment produced by scopolamine methylbromide suggests that the deficit produced by muscarinic receptor antagonism may have both a central and peripheral component. At the highest dose, scopolamine hydrobromide decreased the number of trials completed. Thus, some of the effects of scopolamine hydrobromide involve nonmnemonic performance factors. The performance deficits produced by scopolamine hydrobromide suggest that it may be necessary to qualify drug effects in terms of their action on both memorial and nonmemorial aspects of performance.

Validity of a delayed conditional discrimination task as a model for working memory in the rat

A delayed conditional discrimination (DCD) task in the rat was modified by requiring a response on an admission lever at the end of each delay. This requirement proved effective in precluding the use of positional cues as mediating behavior. Furthermore, validity of the procedure was assessed by examining how performance changed as a result of: length of the delay, retroactive and proactive interference, and encoding time. Results showed that log d, a measure of stimulus discriminability, decreased on longer delays (Experiment 1); decreased when an interfering stimulus was presented during delays (Experiment 2); decreased when the intertrial interval was made shorter (Experiment 3); and decreased when the sample stimuli were presented for a shorter period of time (Experiment 4). Log b, an index of bias, remained low throughout the study, indicating that no significant response bias was present. Taken together, the results support the notion that this modified DCD task is a valid model for working memory that effectively precludes the use of positional cues as mediating behavior in the rat.

Cardiovascular effects of the benzodiazepine receptor partial inverse agonist FG 7142 in rats

Effects of the benzodiazepine receptor (BZR) partial inverse agonist FG 7142 (FG) on basal and reactive cardiovascular measures were examined in freely moving rats. FG (8 mg/kg) modestly increased basal heart period, but had no effects on basal blood pressure. More notably, however, FG augmented the cardioacceleratory response to an auditory stimulus relative to vehicle controls. Selective blockade of sympathetic (atenolol, 1 mg/kg) or parasympathetic (scopolamine methylnitrate, 0.1 mg/kg) effects on the heart under control conditions revealed that the stimulus-evoked cardiac response originated from a concurrent (reciprocal) sympathetic activation and vagal withdrawal. Following FG pretreatment, both atenolol and scopolamine blocked the cardioacceleratory response to the auditory stimulus. Thus, although FG minimally increased basal heart period, FG significantly enhanced a reactive cardioacceleration. More importantly, these results demonstrate that the cardiovascular effects of BZR inverse agonists are more fully characterized by an assessment of both tonic and reactive cardiovascular responses.

Effects of benzodiazepine receptor ligands on simultaneous visual discriminations of variable difficulty

Benzodiazepine receptor (BZR) ligands have been demonstrated to affect the performance in tasks measuring attentional abilities. In such tasks, subjects typically are required to discriminate visual and/or auditory stimuli. The possibility that the effects of BZR ligands on the performance in tasks measuring attention are primarily due to effects on discriminative processes has not been tested systematically. Rats were trained to discriminate between simultaneously presented pairs of visual stimuli flashing either at 5 Hz versus 4.17, 3.75, 2.5, 1.67 or 1.25 Hz (group 1; FAST), or at 1.25, 1.46, 1.67, 2.5 or 3.33 Hz versus 5 Hz (group 2; SLOW) for 4.8 s (20 trials per discrimination type; sequence of pairs was randomized). In both groups, response accuracy depended significantly on the discriminability of the stimuli, with near perfect accuracy in response to most different pairs of stimuli and near chance-level accuracy in response to least different pairs of stimuli. Administration of the BZR full agonist chlordiazepoxide (1.56, 6.25, 9.38 mg/kg; i.p.) potently increased the number of errors of omission which, following the higher doses, confounded the effects on absolute numbers of correct and incorrect responses. However, the available data do not suggest that the agonist affected the animals' abilities to discriminate between the stimuli. Similarly, administration of the BZR ligands ZK 93 426 and MDL 26,479 (which negatively modulate GABAergic transmission) produced no systematic effects. These data suggest that the effects of BZR ligands on the performance in tasks measuring attentional abilities are not primarily due to effects on the animals' ability to discriminate sensory stimuli.

Interactions between the effects of basal forebrain lesions and chronic treatment with MDL 26,479 on learning and markers of cholinergic transmission

The effects of ibotenic acid-induced basal forebrain lesions and treatment with the triazole MDL 26,479 on the acquisition of an operant visual conditional discrimination task and on [3H]hemicholinium-3 and [3H]vesamicol binding were examined. Lesioned animals required more training sessions to acquire the stimulus-response rules of this task. They also showed longer response latencies throughout the experiment. The effects of the treatment with MDL 26,479 (5 mg/kg; i.p. 60 min before each training session) interacted with the effects of the lesion, producing a decrease in the number of sessions required to perform above chance-level in lesioned but not in control animals. MDL 26,479 did not seem to produce immediate performance effects but interacted with the learning process. The lesions destroyed the cell bodies in the area of the substantia innominata, basal nucleus of Meynert, and the globus pallidus. The number of frontocortical cholinergic terminals as primarily indicated by hemicholinium-3 binding was reduced in lesioned animals; however, another measure of cholinergic terminals, vesamicol binding, was unchanged. Behavioral performance of animals correlated significantly with hemicholinium binding in the frontal cortex of the right hemisphere. The fact that the lesion delayed but did not block the acquisition of the task may have been a result of compensatory mechanisms in remaining cholinergic terminals as indicated by stable vesamicol binding. These data allow assumptions about the conditions for the demonstration of beneficial behavioral effects of MDL 26,479. They also suggest that the long-term effects of basal forebrain lesions on cortical cholinergic transmission remain unsettled.

Attenuation of muscarinic receptor blockade-induced impairment of spatial delayed alternation performance by the triazole MDL 26,479

The interactions between the effects of MDL 26,479 (0.1, 0.39, 1.56, 6.25 mg/kg; IP) and the muscarinic antagonist scopolamine (0.03, 0.1 mg/kg; IP) on the performance of rats in a delayed alternation task (retention intervals: 2, 4, 8, 16, 32 s) were examined. Scopolamine dose-dependently reduced the relative number of correct responses and interacted with the effects of the length of retention intervals. MDL 26,479 did not affect correct responding but attenuated the behavioral impairments produced by scopolamine. Although this task did not explicitly exclude the possibility that the animals acquired mediational response strategies, and although the effects of scopolamine appeared to interfere with the execution of these strategies, to a major extent, the attenuative effects of MDL 26,479 were not related to its effects on mediational strategies. Thus, it is concluded that administration of MDL 26,479 mainly resulted in a re-establishment of the animals' ability to memorize and/or to recall the information required to exert correct responses.