A critical review of recent trends, and a future perspective of optical spectroscopy as PAT in biopharmaceutical downstream processing

Expediting online liquid chromatography for real-time monitoring of product attributes to advance process analytical technology in downstream processing of biopharmaceuticals

The application of Process Analytical Technology (PAT) principles for manufacturing of biotherapeutics proffers the prospect of ensuring consistent product quality along with increased productivity as well as substantial cost and time savings. Although this paradigm shift from a traditional, rather rigid manufacturing model to a more scientific, risk-based approach has been advocated by health authorities for almost two decades, the practical implementation of PAT in the biopharmaceutical industry is still limited by the lack of fit-for-purpose analytical methods. In this regard, most of the proposed spectroscopic techniques are sufficiently fast but exhibit deficiencies in terms of selectivity and sensitivity, while well-established offline methods, such as (ultra-)high-performance liquid chromatography, are generally considered as too slow for this task. To address these reservations, we introduce here a novel online Liquid Chromatography (LC) setup that was specifically designed to enable real-time monitoring of critical product quality attributes during time-sensitive purification operations in downstream processing. Using this online LC solution in combination with fast, purpose-built analytical methods, sampling cycle times between 1.30 and 2.35 min were achieved, without compromising on the ability to resolve and quantify the product variants of interest. The capabilities of our approach are ultimately assessed in three case studies, involving various biotherapeutic modalities, downstream processes and analytical chromatographic separation modes. Altogether, our results highlight the expansive opportunities of online LC based applications to serve as a PAT tool for biopharmaceutical manufacturing.

Soft sensor for viable cell counting by measuring dynamic oxygen uptake rate

Regulatory authorities in biopharmaceutical industry emphasize process design by process understanding but applicable tools that are easy to implement are still missing. Soft sensors are a promising tool for the implementation of the Quality by Design (QbD) approach and Process Analytical Technology (PAT). In particular, the correlation between viable cell counting and oxygen consumption was investigated, but problems remained: Either the process had to be modified for excluding CO2 in pH control, or complex kLa models had to be set up for specific processes. In this work, a non-invasive soft sensor for simplified on-line cell counting based on dynamic oxygen uptake rate was developed with no need of special equipment. The dynamic oxygen uptake rates were determined by automated and periodic interruptions of gas supply in DASGIP® bioreactor systems, realized by a programmed Visual Basic script in the DASware® control software. With off-line cell counting, the two parameters were correlated based on linear regression and led to a robust model with a correlation coefficient of 0.92. Avoidance of oxygen starvation was achieved by gas flow reactivation at a certain minimum dissolved oxygen concentration. The soft sensor model was established in the exponential growth phase of a Chinese Hamster Ovary fed-batch process. Control studies showed no impact on cell growth by the discontinuous gas supply. This soft sensor is the first to be presented that does not require any specialized additional equipment as the methodology relies solely on the direct measurement of oxygen consumed by the cells in the bioreactor.

Advances and opportunities in process analytical technologies for viral vector manufacturing

Viral vectors are an emerging, exciting class of biologics whose application in vaccines, oncology, and gene therapy has grown exponentially in recent years. Following first regulatory approval, this class of therapeutics has been vigorously pursued to treat monogenic disorders including orphan diseases, entering hundreds of new products into pipelines. Viral vector manufacturing supporting clinical efforts has spurred the introduction of a broad swath of analytical techniques dedicated to assessing the diverse and evolving panel of Critical Quality Attributes (CQAs) of these products. Herein, we provide an overview of the current state of analytics enabling measurement of CQAs such as capsid and vector identities, product titer, transduction efficiency, impurity clearance etc. We highlight orthogonal methods and discuss the advantages and limitations of these techniques while evaluating their adaptation as process analytical technologies. Finally, we identify gaps and propose opportunities in enabling existing technologies for real-time monitoring from hardware, software, and data analysis viewpoints for technology development within viral vector biomanufacturing.

Raman and NIR spectroscopy-based real-time monitoring of the membrane filtration process of a recombinant protein for the diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2

This research shows the detailed comparison of Raman and near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy as Process Analytical Technology tools for the real-time monitoring of a protein purification process. A comprehensive investigation of the application and model development of Raman and NIR spectroscopy was carried out for the real-time monitoring of a process-related impurity, imidazole, during the tangential flow filtration of Receptor-Binding Domain (RBD) of the SARS-CoV-2 Spike protein. The fast development of Raman and NIR spectroscopy-based calibration models was achieved using offline calibration data, resulting in low calibration and cross-validation errors. Raman model had an RMSEC of 1.53 mM, and an RMSECV of 1.78 mM, and the NIR model had an RMSEC of 1.87 mM and an RMSECV of 2.97 mM. Furthermore, Raman models had good robustness when applied in an inline measurement system, but on the contrary NIR spectroscopy was sensitive to the changes in the measurement environment. By utilizing the developed models, inline Raman and NIR spectroscopy were successfully applied for the real-time monitoring of a process-related impurity during the membrane filtration of a recombinant protein. The results enhance the importance of implementing real-time monitoring approaches for the broader field of diagnostic and therapeutic protein purification and underscore its potential to revolutionize the rapid development of biological products.

Simultaneous prediction of 16 quality attributes during protein A chromatography using machine learning based Raman spectroscopy models

Several key technologies for advancing biopharmaceutical manufacturing depend on the successful implementation of process analytical technologies that can monitor multiple product quality attributes in a continuous in-line setting. Raman spectroscopy is an emerging technology in the biopharma industry that promises to fit this strategic need, yet its application is not widespread due to limited success for predicting a meaningful number of quality attributes. In this study, we addressed this very problem by demonstrating new capabilities for preprocessing Raman spectra using a series of Butterworth filters. The resulting increase in the number of spectral features is paired with a machine learning algorithm and laboratory automation hardware to drive the automated collection and training of a calibration model that allows for the prediction of 16 different product quality attributes in an in-line mode. The demonstrated ability to generate these Raman-based models for in-process product quality monitoring is the breakthrough to increase process understanding by delivering product quality data in a continuous manner. The implementation of this multiattribute in-line technology will create new workflows within process development, characterization, validation, and control.

Application of Raman spectroscopy during pharmaceutical process development for determination of critical quality attributes in Protein A chromatography

Raman spectroscopy is considered a Process Analytical Technology (PAT) tool in biopharmaceutical downstream processes. In the past decade, researchers have shown Raman spectroscopy's feasibility in determining Critical Quality Attributes (CQAs) in bioprocessing. This study verifies the feasibility of implementing a Raman-based PAT tool in Protein A chromatography as a CQA monitoring technique, for the purpose of accelerating process development and achieving real-time release in manufacturing. A system connecting Raman to a Tecan liquid handling station enables high-throughput model calibration. One calibration experiment collects Raman spectra of 183 samples with 8 CQAs within 25 h. After applying Butterworth high-pass filters and k-nearest neighbor (KNN) regression for model training, the model showed high predictive accuracy for fragments (Q2 = 0.965) and strong predictability for target protein concentration, aggregates, as well as charge variants (Q2≥ 0.922). The model's robustness was confirmed by varying the elution pH, load density, and residence time using 19 external validation preparative Protein A chromatography runs. The model can deliver elution profiles of multiple CQAs within a set point ± 0.3 pH range. The CQA readouts were presented as continuous chromatograms with a resolution of every 28 s for enhanced process understanding. In external validation datasets, the model maintained strong predictability especially for target protein concentration (Q2 = 0.956) and basic charge variants (Q2 = 0.943), except for overpredicted HCP (Q2 = 0.539). This study demonstrates a rapid, effective method for implementing Raman spectroscopy for in-line CQA monitoring in process development and biomanufacturing, eliminating the need for labor-intensive sample pooling and handling.

Adaptive modeling optimized by the data fusion strategy: Real-time dying cell percentage prediction using capacitance spectroscopy

The previous research showcased a partial least squares (PLS) regression model accurately predicting cell death percentages using in-line capacitance spectra. The current study advances the model accuracy through adaptive modeling employing a data fusion approach. This strategy enhances prediction performance by incorporating variables from the Cole-Cole model, conductivity and its derivatives over time, and Mahalanobis distance into the predictor matrix (X-matrix). Firstly, the Cole-Cole model, a mechanistic model with parameters linked to early cell death onset, was integrated to enhance prediction performance. Secondly, the inclusion of conductivity and its derivatives over time in the X-matrix mitigated prediction fluctuations resulting from abrupt conductivity changes during process operations. Thirdly, Mahalanobis distance, depicting spectral changes relative to a reference spectrum from a previous time point, improved model adaptability to independent test sets, thereby enhancing performance. The final data fusion model substantially decreased root-mean squared error of prediction (RMSEP) by around 50%, which is a significant boost in prediction accuracy compared to the prior PLS model. Robustness against reference spectrum selection was confirmed by consistent performance across various time points. In conclusion, this study illustrates that the data fusion strategy substantially enhances the model accuracy compared to the previous model relying solely on capacitance spectra.

Generative data augmentation and automated optimization of convolutional neural networks for process monitoring

Chemometric modeling for spectral data is considered a key technology in biopharmaceutical processing to realize real-time process control and release testing. Machine learning (ML) models have been shown to increase the accuracy of various spectral regression and classification tasks, remove challenging preprocessing steps for spectral data, and promise to improve the transferability of models when compared to commonly applied, linear methods. The training and optimization of ML models require large data sets which are not available in the context of biopharmaceutical processing. Generative methods to extend data sets with realistic in silico samples, so-called data augmentation, may provide the means to alleviate this challenge. In this study, we develop and implement a novel data augmentation method for generating in silico spectral data based on local estimation of pure component profiles for training convolutional neural network (CNN) models using four data sets. We simultaneously tune hyperparameters associated with data augmentation and the neural network architecture using Bayesian optimization. Finally, we compare the optimized CNN models with partial least-squares regression models (PLS) in terms of accuracy, robustness, and interpretability. The proposed data augmentation method is shown to produce highly realistic spectral data by adapting the estimates of the pure component profiles to the sampled concentration regimes. Augmenting CNNs with the in silico spectral data is shown to improve the prediction accuracy for the quantification of monoclonal antibody (mAb) size variants by up to 50% in comparison to single-response PLS models. Bayesian structure optimization suggests that multiple convolutional blocks are beneficial for model accuracy and enable transfer across different data sets. Model-agnostic feature importance methods and synthetic noise perturbation are used to directly compare the optimized CNNs with PLS models. This enables the identification of wavelength regions critical for model performance and suggests increased robustness against Gaussian white noise and wavelength shifts of the CNNs compared to the PLS models.

Micro simulated moving bed chromatography-mass spectrometry as a continuous on-line process analytical tool

Continuous manufacturing is becoming increasingly important in the (bio-)pharmaceutical industry, as more product can be produced in less time and at lower costs. In this context, there is a need for powerful continuous analytical tools. Many established off-line analytical methods, such as mass spectrometry (MS), are hardly considered for process analytical technology (PAT) applications in biopharmaceutical processes, as they are limited to at-line analysis due to the required sample preparation and the associated complexity, although they would provide a suitable technique for the assessment of a wide range of quality attributes. In this study, we investigated the applicability of a recently developed micro simulated moving bed chromatography system (µSMB) for continuous on-line sample preparation for MS. As a test case, we demonstrate the continuous on-line MS measurement of a protein solution (myoglobin) containing Tris buffer, which interferes with ESI-MS measurements, by continuously exchanging this buffer with a volatile ammonium acetate buffer suitable for MS measurements. The integration of the µSMB significantly increases MS sensitivity by removing over 98% of the buffer substances. Thus, this study demonstrates the feasibility of on-line µSMB-MS, providing a versatile PAT tool by combining the detection power of MS for various product attributes with all the advantages of continuous on-line analytics.

Explainable deep learning enhances robust and reliable real-time monitoring of a chromatographic protein A capture step

The application of model-based real-time monitoring in biopharmaceutical production is a major step toward quality-by-design and the fundament for model predictive control. Data-driven models have proven to be a viable option to model bioprocesses. In the high stakes setting of biopharmaceutical manufacturing it is essential to ensure high model accuracy, robustness, and reliability. That is only possible when (i) the data used for modeling is of high quality and sufficient size, (ii) state-of-the-art modeling algorithms are employed, and (iii) the input-output mapping of the model has been characterized. In this study, we evaluate the accuracy of multiple data-driven models in predicting the monoclonal antibody (mAb) concentration, double stranded DNA concentration, host cell protein concentration, and high molecular weight impurity content during elution from a protein A chromatography capture step. The models achieved high-quality predictions with a normalized root mean squared error of <4% for the mAb concentration and of ≈10% for the other process variables. Furthermore, we demonstrate how permutation/occlusion-based methods can be used to gain an understanding of dependencies learned by one of the most complex data-driven models, convolutional neural network ensembles. We observed that the models generally exhibited dependencies on correlations that agreed with first principles knowledge, thereby bolstering confidence in model reliability. Finally, we present a workflow to assess the model behavior in case of systematic measurement errors that may result from sensor fouling or failure. This study represents a major step toward improved viability of data-driven models in biopharmaceutical manufacturing.

Validation of the cell culture monitoring using a Raman spectroscopy calibration model developed with artificially mixed samples and investigation of model learning methods using initial batch data

The development of calibration models using Raman spectra data has long been challenged owing to the substantial time and cost required for robust data acquisition. To reduce the number of experiments involving actual incubation, a calibration model development method was investigated by measuring artificially mixed samples. In this method, calibration datasets were prepared using spectra from artificially mixed samples with adjusted concentrations based on design of experiments. The precision of these calibration models was validated using the actual cell culture sample. The results showed that when the culture conditions were unchanged, the root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP) of glucose, lactate, and antibody concentrations was 0.34, 0.33, and 0.25 g/L, respectively. Even when variables such as cell line or culture media were changed, the RMSEPs of glucose, lactate, and antibody concentrations remained within acceptable limits, demonstrating the robustness of the calibration models with artificially mixed samples. To further improve accuracy, a model training method for small datasets was also investigated. The spectral pretreatment conditions were optimized using error heat maps based on the first batch of each cell culture condition and applied these settings to the second and third batches. The RMSEPs improved for glucose, lactate, and antibody concentration, with values of 0.44, 0.19, and 0.18 g/L under constant culture conditions, 0.37, 0.12, and 0.12 g/L for different cell lines, and 0.26, 0.40, and 0.12 g/L when the culture media was changed. These results indicated the efficacy of calibration modeling with artificially mixed samples for actual incubations under various conditions.

Automated calibration and in-line measurement of product quality during therapeutic monoclonal antibody purification using Raman spectroscopy

Current manufacturing and development processes for therapeutic monoclonal antibodies demand increasing volumes of analytical testing for both real-time process controls and high-throughput process development. The feasibility of using Raman spectroscopy as an in-line product quality measuring tool has been recently demonstrated and promises to relieve this analytical bottleneck. Here, we resolve time-consuming calibration process that requires fractionation and preparative experiments covering variations of product quality attributes (PQAs) by engineering an automation system capable of collecting Raman spectra on the order of hundreds of calibration points from two to three stock seed solutions differing in protein concentration and aggregate level using controlled mixing. We used this automated system to calibrate multi-PQA models that accurately measured product concentration and aggregation every 9.3 s using an in-line flow-cell. We demonstrate the application of a nonlinear calibration model for monitoring product quality in real-time during a biopharmaceutical purification process intended for clinical and commercial manufacturing. These results demonstrate potential feasibility to implement quality monitoring during GGMP manufacturing as well as to increase chemistry, manufacturing, and controls understanding during process development, ultimately leading to more robust and controlled manufacturing processes.

Data Augmentation Techniques for Machine Learning Applied to Optical Spectroscopy Datasets in Agrifood Applications: A Comprehensive Review

Machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) have achieved great success in different tasks. These include computer vision, image segmentation, natural language processing, predicting classification, evaluating time series, and predicting values based on a series of variables. As artificial intelligence progresses, new techniques are being applied to areas like optical spectroscopy and its uses in specific fields, such as the agrifood industry. The performance of ML and DL techniques generally improves with the amount of data available. However, it is not always possible to obtain all the necessary data for creating a robust dataset. In the particular case of agrifood applications, dataset collection is generally constrained to specific periods. Weather conditions can also reduce the possibility to cover the entire range of classifications with the consequent generation of imbalanced datasets. To address this issue, data augmentation (DA) techniques are employed to expand the dataset by adding slightly modified copies of existing data. This leads to a dataset that includes values from laboratory tests, as well as a collection of synthetic data based on the real data. This review work will present the application of DA techniques to optical spectroscopy datasets obtained from real agrifood industry applications. The reviewed methods will describe the use of simple DA techniques, such as duplicating samples with slight changes, as well as the utilization of more complex algorithms based on deep learning generative adversarial networks (GANs), and semi-supervised generative adversarial networks (SGANs).

Continuous Online Titer Monitoring in CHO Cell Culture Supernatant Using a Herringbone Nanofluidic Filter Array

Online monitoring of monoclonal antibody product titers throughout biologics process development and production enables rapid bioprocess decision-making and process optimization. Conventional analytical methods, including high-performance liquid chromatography and turbidimetry, typically require interfacing with an automated sampling system capable of online sampling and fractionation, which suffers from increased cost, a higher risk of failure, and a higher mechanical complexity of the system. In this study, a novel nanofluidic system for continuous direct (no sample preparation) IgG titer measurements was investigated. Tumor necrosis factor α (TNF-α), conjugated with fluorophores, was utilized as a selective binder for adalimumab in the unprocessed cell culture supernatant. The nanofluidic device can separate the bound complex from unbound TNF-α and selectively concentrate the bound complex for high-sensitivity detection. Based on the fluorescence intensity from the concentrated bound complex, a fluorescence intensity versus titer curve can be generated, which was used to determine the titer of samples from filtered, unpurified Chinese hamster ovary cell cultures continuously. The system performed direct monitoring of IgG titers with nanomolar resolution and showed a good correlation with the biolayer interferometry assays. Furthermore, by variation of the concentration of the indicator (TNF-α), the dynamic range of the system can be tuned and further expanded.

Characterisation of Cartilage Damage via Fusing Mid-Infrared, Near-Infrared, and Raman Spectroscopic Data

Mid-infrared spectroscopy (MIR), near-infrared spectroscopy (NIR), and Raman spectroscopy are all well-established analytical techniques in biomedical applications. Since they provide complementary chemical information, we aimed to determine whether combining them amplifies their strengths and mitigates their weaknesses. This study investigates the feasibility of the fusion of MIR, NIR, and Raman spectroscopic data for characterising articular cartilage integrity. Osteochondral specimens from bovine patellae were subjected to mechanical and enzymatic damage, and then MIR, NIR, and Raman data were acquired from the damaged and control specimens. We assessed the capacity of individual spectroscopic methods to classify the samples into damage or control groups using Partial Least Squares Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA). Multi-block PLS-DA was carried out to assess the potential of data fusion by combining the dataset by applying two-block (MIR and NIR, MIR and Raman, NIR and Raman) and three-block approaches (MIR, NIR, and Raman). The results of the one-block models show a higher classification accuracy for NIR (93%) and MIR (92%) than for Raman (76%) spectroscopy. In contrast, we observed the highest classification efficiency of 94% and 93% for the two-block (MIR and NIR) and three-block models, respectively. The detailed correlative analysis of the spectral features contributing to the discrimination in the three-block models adds considerably more insight into the molecular origin of cartilage damage.

Organ-on-a-Chip for Drug Screening: A Bright Future for Sustainability? A Critical Review

Globalization has raised concerns about spreading diseases and emphasized the need for quick and efficient methods for drug screening. Established drug efficacy and toxicity approaches have proven obsolete, with a high failure rate in clinical trials. Organ-on-a-chip has emerged as an essential alternative to outdated techniques, precisely simulating important characteristics of organs and predicting drug pharmacokinetics more ethically and efficiently. Although promising, most organ-on-a-chip devices are still manufactured using principles and materials from the micromachining industry. The abusive use of plastic for traditional drug screening methods and device production should be considered when substituting technologies so that the compensation for the generation of plastic waste can be projected. This critical review outlines recent advances for organ-on-a-chip in the industry and estimates the possibility of scaling up its production. Moreover, it analyzes trends in organ-on-a-chip publications and provides suggestions for a more sustainable future for organ-on-a-chip research and production.

Development of Raman Calibration Model Without Culture Data for In-Line Analysis of Metabolites in Cell Culture Media

In this study, we developed a method to build Raman calibration models without culture data for cell culture monitoring. First, Raman spectra were collected and then analyzed for the signals of all the mentioned analytes: glucose, lactate, glutamine, glutamate, ammonia, antibody, viable cells, media, and feed agent. Using these spectral data, the specific peak positions and intensities for each factor were detected. Next, according to the design of the experiment method, samples were prepared by mixing the above-mentioned factors. Raman spectra of these samples were collected and were used to build calibration models. Several combinations of spectral pretreatments and wavenumber regions were compared to optimize the calibration model for cell culture monitoring without culture data. The accuracy of the developed calibration model was evaluated by performing actual cell culture and fitting the in-line measured spectra to the developed calibration model. As a result, the calibration model achieved sufficiently good accuracy for the three components, glucose, lactate, and antibody (root mean square errors of prediction, or RMSEP = 0.23, 0.29, and 0.20 g/L, respectively). This study has presented innovative results in developing a culture monitoring method without using culture data, while using a basic conventional method of investigating the Raman spectra of each component in the culture media and then utilizing a design of experiment approach.

Characterizing viral samples using machine learning for Raman and absorption spectroscopy

Machine learning methods can be used as robust techniques to provide invaluable information for analyzing biological samples in pharmaceutical industries, such as predicting the concentration of viral particles of interest in biological samples. Here, we utilized both convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and random forests (RFs) to predict the concentration of the samples containing measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella-zoster viruses (ProQuad®) based on Raman and absorption spectroscopy. We prepared Raman and absorption spectra data sets with known concentration values, then used the Raman and absorption signals individually and together to train RFs and CNNs. We demonstrated that both RFs and CNNs can make predictions with R² values as high as 95%. We proposed two different networks to jointly use the Raman and absorption spectra, where our results demonstrated that concatenating the Raman and absorption data increases the prediction accuracy compared to using either Raman or absorption spectrum alone. Additionally, we further verified the advantage of using joint Raman-absorption with principal component analysis. Furthermore, our method can be extended to characterize properties other than concentration, such as the type of viral particles.

Converting a mAb downstream process from batch to continuous using process modeling and process analytical technology

The biopharmaceutical market is driving the revolution from traditional batch processes to continuous manufacturing for higher productivity and lower costs. In this work, a batch mAb downstream process has been converted into an integrated continuous process with the combination of multiple techniques. For process intensification, two batch mode unit operations (protein A capture chromatography, ultrafiltration/diafiltration) are converted into continuous ones; For continuity, surge tanks were used between adjacent steps, and level signals were used to trigger process start or stop, forming a holistic continuous process. For process automation, manual operations (e.g., pH and conductivity adjustment) were changed into automatic operation and load mass was controlled with process analytical technology (PAT). A model-based simulation was applied to estimate the loading conditions for the continuous capture process, resulting in 21% resin capacity utilization and 28% productivity improvement as compared to the batch process. Automatic load mass control of cation exchange chromatography was achieved through a customized in-line protein quantity monitoring system, with a difference of less than 1.3% as compared to off-line analysis. Total process time was shortened from 4 days (batch process) to less than 24 hours using the continuous downstream process with the overall productivity of 23.8 g mAb /day for the bench-scale system. Comparable yield and quality data were obtained in three test runs, indicating a successful conversion from a batch process to a continuous process. The insight of this work could be a reference to other similar situations. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Challenges and Opportunities of Implementing Data Fusion in Process Analytical Technology—A Review

The release of the FDA’s guidance on Process Analytical Technology has motivated and supported the pharmaceutical industry to deliver consistent quality medicine by acquiring a deeper understanding of the product performance and process interplay. The technical opportunities to reach this high-level control have considerably evolved since 2004 due to the development of advanced analytical sensors and chemometric tools. However, their transfer to the highly regulated pharmaceutical sector has been limited. To this respect, data fusion strategies have been extensively applied in different sectors, such as food or chemical, to provide a more robust performance of the analytical platforms. This survey evaluates the challenges and opportunities of implementing data fusion within the PAT concept by identifying transfer opportunities from other sectors. Special attention is given to the data types available from pharmaceutical manufacturing and their compatibility with data fusion strategies. Furthermore, the integration into Pharma 4.0 is discussed.

Modern Sensor Tools and Techniques for Monitoring, Controlling, and Improving Cell Culture Processes

The growing biopharmaceutical industry has reached a level of maturity that allows for the monitoring of numerous key variables for both process characterization and outcome predictions. Sensors were historically used in order to maintain an optimal environment within the reactor to optimize process performance. However, technological innovation has pushed towards on-line in situ continuous monitoring of quality attributes that could previously only be estimated off-line. These new sensing technologies when coupled with software models have shown promise for unique fingerprinting, smart process control, outcome improvement, and prediction. All this can be done without requiring invasive sampling or intervention on the system. In this paper, the state-of-the-art sensing technologies and their applications in the context of cell culture monitoring are reviewed with emphasis on the coming push towards industry 4.0 and smart manufacturing within the biopharmaceutical sector. Additionally, perspectives as to how this can be leveraged to improve both understanding and outcomes of cell culture processes are discussed.

Development of a General PAT Strategy for Online Monitoring of Complex Mixtures—On the Example of Natural Product Extracts from Bearberry Leaf (Arctostaphylos uva-ursi)

For the first time, a universally applicable and methodical approach from characterization to a PAT concept for complex mixtures is conducted—exemplified on natural products extraction processes. Bearberry leaf (Arctostaphylos uva-ursi) extract is chosen as an example of a typical complex mixture of natural plant origin and generalizable in its composition. Within the quality by design (QbD) based process development the development and implementation of a concept for process analytical technology (PAT), a key enabling technology, is the next necessary step in risk and quality-based process development and operation. To obtain and provide an overview of the broad field of PAT, the development process is shown on the example of a complex multi-component plant extract. This study researches the potential of different process analytical technologies for online monitoring of different component groups and classifies their possible applications within the framework of a QbD-based process. Offline and online analytics are established on the basis of two extraction runs. Based on this data set, PLS models are created for the spectral data, and correlations are conducted for univariate data. In a third run, the prediction potential is researched. Conclusively, the results of this study are arranged in the concept of a holistic quality and risk-based process design and operation concept.

Small footprint liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry for pharmaceutical reaction monitoring and automated process analysis

Liquid chromatography (LC) has broad applicability in the pharmaceutical industry, from the early stages of drug discovery to reaction monitoring and process control. However, small footprint, truly portable LC systems have not yet been demonstrated and fully evaluated practically for on-line, in-line or at-line pharmaceutical analysis. Herein, a portable, briefcase-sized capillary LC fitted with a miniature multi-deep UV-LED detector has been developed and interfaced with a portable mass spectrometer for on-site pharmaceutical analysis. With this configuration, the combined small footprint portable LC-UV/MS system was utilized for the determination of small molecule pharmaceuticals and reaction monitoring. The LC-UV/MS system was interfaced directly with a process sample cart and applied to automated pharmaceutical analysis, as well as also being benchmarked against a commercial process UPLC system (Waters PATROL system). The portable system gave low detection limits (∼3 ppb), a wide dynamic range (up to 200 ppm) and was used to confirm the identity of reaction impurities and for studying the kinetics of synthesis. The developed platform showed robust performance for automated process analysis, with less than 5.0% relative standard deviation (RSD) on sample-to-sample reproducibility, and less than 2% carryover between samples. The system has been shown to significantly increase throughput by providing near real-time analysis and to improve understanding of synthetic processes.

Spectrophotometric and colorimetric determination of gallium (III) with p-aminohippuric acid-functionalized citrate capped gold nanoparticles

A new technique for sensing Ga(III) concentration based on polyvinyl alcohol-citrate capped gold nanoparticle– p- aminohippuric acid hybrid (or three-layer core-shell configurations) has been demonstrated. The p- aminohippuric acid capped citrate-gold nanoparticles were comfortably agglomerated in the presence of Ga(III), and the color of the reaction quickly turned from red to violet or blue. Under the detection conditions, a good linear relationship was ideally obtained between the ratio of the absorbance intensity at 620 nm to that at 520 nm (A₆₂₀/A₅₂₀). The linear response range, the detection, and quantification limit was 34.9–418.3 μg/L and 7.6 μg/L, and 25 μg/L, respectively. To reflect the accuracy, the developed sensing approach was evaluated against certified reference materials (TMDA 51.3 fortified water and TMDA 28.3 fortified water). This colorimetric strategy was displayed excellent selectivity for Ga(III) over other examined ions. Additionally, the colorimetric method was properly used to detect the concentrations of Ga in tap water and certified reference material samples with recoveries ranging from 95.4 to 102.0%, displaying that the colorimetric procedure could be safely used for a realistic application.

From consumers' science to food functionality-Challenges and opportunities for vibrational spectroscopy

Current available methods used to measure or estimate the composition, functionality, and sensory properties of foods and food ingredients are destructive and time consuming. Therefore, new approaches are required by both the food industry and R&D organizations. Recent years have witnessed a steady growth on the applications and utilization of vibrational spectroscopy techniques [near (NIR), mid infrared (MIR), Raman] to analyse or estimate several properties in a wide range of foods and food ingredients. This chapter will provide with an overview of vibrational spectroscopy techniques, the combination of these techniques with multivariate data analysis, and examples on the use of these techniques to measure composition, and functional properties in a wide range of foods.

Comparison of UV- and Raman-based monitoring of the Protein A load phase and evaluation of data fusion by PLS models and CNNs

A promising application of Process Analytical Technology to the downstream process of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) is the monitoring of the Protein A load phase as its control promises economic benefits. Different spectroscopic techniques have been evaluated in literature with regard to the ability to quantify the mAb concentration in the column effluent. Raman and Ultraviolet (UV) spectroscopy are among the most promising techniques. In this study, both were investigated in an in-line setup and directly compared. The data of each sensor were analyzed independently with Partial-Least-Squares (PLS) models and Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) for regression. Furthermore, data fusion strategies were investigated by combining both sensors in hierarchical PLS models or in CNNs. Among the tested options, UV spectroscopy alone allowed for the most precise and accurate prediction of the mAb concentration. A Root Mean Square Error of Prediction (RMSEP) of 0.013 g L^-1 was reached with the UV-based PLS model. The Raman-based PLS model reached an RMSEP of 0.232 g L^-1 . The different data fusion techniques did not improve the prediction accuracy above the prediction accuracy of the UV-based PLS model. Data fusion by PLS models seems meritless when combining a very accurate sensor with a less accurate signal. Furthermore, the application of CNNs for UV and Raman spectra did not yield significant improvements in the prediction quality. For the presented application, linear regression techniques seem to be better suited compared with advanced nonlinear regression techniques, like, CNNs. In summary, the results support the application of UV spectroscopy and PLS modeling for future research and development activities aiming to implement spectroscopic real-time monitoring of the Protein A load phase.

Continuous optical in-line glucose monitoring and control in CHO cultures contributes to enhanced metabolic efficiency while maintaining darbepoetin alfa product quality

Great efforts are directed towards improving productivity, consistency and quality of biopharmaceutical processes and products. One particular area is the development of new sensors for continuous monitoring of critical bioprocess parameters by using online or in-line monitoring systems. Recently, we developed a glucose biosensor applicable in single-use, in-line and long-term glucose monitoring in mammalian cell bioreactors. Now, we integrated this sensor in an automated glucose monitoring and feeding system capable of maintaining stable glucose levels, even at very low concentrations. We compared this fed-batch feedback system at both low (< 1 mM) and high (40 mM) glucose levels with traditional batch culture methods, focusing on glycosylation and glycation of the recombinant protein darbepoetin alfa (DPO) produced by a CHO cell line. We evaluated cell growth, metabolite and product concentration under different glucose feeding strategies and show that continuous feeding, even at low glucose levels, has no harmful effects on DPO quantity and quality. We conclude that our system is capable of tight glucose level control throughout extended bioprocesses and has the potential to improve performance where constant maintenance of glucose levels is critical.

Bioproduction process of natural products and biopharmaceuticals: Biotechnological aspects

Decades of research have been put in place for developing sustainable routes of bioproduction of high commercial value natural products (NPs) on the global market. In the last few years alone, we have witnessed significant advances in the biotechnological production of NPs. The development of new methodologies has resulted in a better understanding of the metabolic flux within the organisms, which have driven manipulations to improve production of the target product. This was further realised due to the recent advances in the omics technologies such as genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics, metabolomics and secretomics, as well as systems and synthetic biology. Additionally, the combined application of novel engineering strategies has made possible avenues for enhancing the yield of these products in an efficient and economical way. Invention of high-throughput technologies such as next generation sequencing (NGS) and toolkits for genome editing Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats/CRISPR-associated 9 (CRISPR/Cas9) have been the game changers and provided unprecedented opportunities to generate rationally designed synthetic circuits which can produce complex molecules. This review covers recent advances in the engineering of various hosts for the production of bioactive NPs and biopharmaceuticals. It also highlights general approaches and strategies to improve their biosynthesis with higher yields in a perspective of plants and microbes (bacteria, yeast and filamentous fungi). Although there are numerous reviews covering this topic on a selected species at a time, our approach herein is to give a comprehensive understanding about state-of-art technologies in different platforms of organisms.

Manufacturing of bacteriophages for therapeutic applications

Bacteriophages, or simply phages, are the most abundant biological entities on Earth. One of the most interesting characteristics of these viruses, which infect and use bacteria as their host organisms, is their high level of specificity. Since their discovery, phages became a tool for the comprehension of basic molecular biology and originated applications in a variety of areas such as agriculture, biotechnology, food safety, veterinary, pollution remediation and wastewater treatment. In particular, phages offer a solution to one of the major problems in public health nowadays, i.e. the emergence of multidrug-resistant bacteria. In these situations, the use of virulent phages as therapeutic agents offers an alternative to the classic, antibiotic-based strategies. The development of phage therapies should be accompanied by the improvement of phage biomanufacturing processes, both at laboratory and industrial scales. In this review, we first present some historical and general aspects related with the discovery, usage and biology of phages and provide a brief overview of the most relevant phage therapy applications. Then, we showcase current processes used for the production and purification of phages and future alternatives in development. On the production side, key factors such as the bacterial physiological state, the conditions of phage infection and the operation parameters are described alongside with the different operation modes, from batch to semi-continuous and continuous. Traditional purification methods used in the initial phage isolation steps are then described followed by the presentation of current state-of-the-art purification approaches. Continuous purification of phages is finally presented as a future biomanufacturing trend.

Monitoring E. coli Cell Integrity by ATR-FTIR Spectroscopy and Chemometrics: Opportunities and Caveats

During recombinant protein production with E. coli, the integrity of the inner and outer membrane changes, which leads to product leakage (loss of outer membrane integrity) or lysis (loss of inner membrane integrity). Motivated by current Quality by Design guidelines, there is a need for monitoring tools to determine leakiness and lysis in real-time. In this work, we assessed a novel approach to monitoring E. coli cell integrity by attenuated total reflection Fourier-transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy. Various preprocessing strategies were tested in combination with regression (partial least squares, random forest) or classification models (partial least squares discriminant analysis, linear discriminant analysis, random forest, artificial neural network). Models were validated using standard procedures, and well-performing methods were additionally scrutinized by removing putatively important features and assessing the decrease in performance. Whereas the prediction of target compound concentration via regression was unsuccessful, possibly due to a lack of samples and low sensitivity, random forest classifiers achieved prediction accuracies of over 90% within the datasets tested in this study. However, strong correlations with untargeted spectral regions were revealed by feature selection, thereby demonstrating the need to rigorously validate chemometric models for bioprocesses, including the evaluation of feature importance.

Advanced control strategies for bioprocess chromatography: Challenges and opportunities for intensified processes and next generation products

Recent advances in process analytical technologies and modelling techniques present opportunities to improve industrial chromatography control strategies to enhance process robustness, increase productivity and move towards real-time release testing. This paper provides a critical overview of batch and continuous industrial chromatography control systems for therapeutic protein purification. Firstly, the limitations of conventional industrial fractionation control strategies using in-line UV spectroscopy and on-line HPLC are outlined. Following this, an evaluation of monitoring and control techniques showing promise within research, process development and manufacturing is provided. These novel control strategies combine rapid in-line data capture (e.g. NIR, MALS and variable pathlength UV) with enhanced process understanding obtained from mechanistic and empirical modelling techniques. Finally, a summary of the future states of industrial chromatography control systems is proposed, including strategies to control buffer formulation, product fractionation, column switching and column fouling. The implementation of these control systems improves process capabilities to fulfil product quality criteria as processes are scaled, transferred and operated, thus fast tracking the delivery of new medicines to market.

Role of Nanoimprint Lithography for Strongly Miniaturized Optical Spectrometers

Optical spectrometers and sensors have gained enormous importance in metrology and information technology, frequently involving the question of size, resolution, sensitivity, spectral range, efficiency, reliability, and cost. Nanomaterials and nanotechnological fabrication technologies have huge potential to enable an optimization between these demands, which in some cases are counteracting each other. This paper focuses on the visible and near infrared spectral range and on five types of optical sensors (optical spectrometers): classical grating-based miniaturized spectrometers, arrayed waveguide grating devices, static Fabry–Pérot (FP) filter arrays on sensor arrays, tunable microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) FP filter arrays, and MEMS tunable photonic crystal filters. The comparison between this selection of concepts concentrates on (i) linewidth and resolution, (ii) required space for a selected spectral range, (iii) efficiency in using available light, and (iv) potential of nanoimprint for cost reduction and yield increase. The main part of this review deals with our own results in the field of static FP filter arrays and MEMS tunable FP filter arrays. In addition, technology for efficiency boosting to get more of the available light is demonstrated.

A multisensor approach for improved protein A load phase monitoring by conductivity-based background subtraction of UV spectra

Real-time monitoring and control of protein A capture steps by process analytical technologies (PATs) promises significant economic benefits due to the improved usage of the column's binding capacity, by eliminating time-consuming off-line analytics and costly resin lifetime studies, and enabling continuous production. The PAT method proposed in this study relies on ultraviolet (UV) spectroscopy with a dynamic background subtraction based on the leveling out of the conductivity signal. This point in time can be used to collect a reference spectrum for removing the majority of spectral contributions by process-related contaminants. The removal of the background spectrum facilitates chemometric model building and model accuracy. To demonstrate the benefits of this method, five different feedstocks from our industry partner were used to mix the load material for a case study. To our knowledge, such a large design space, which covers possible variations in upstream condition besides the product concentration, has not been disclosed yet. By applying the conductivity-based background subtraction, the root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP) of the partial least squares (PLS) model improved from 0.2080 to 0.0131 g L - 1 . Finally, the potential of the background subtraction method was further evaluated for single wavelength-based predictions to facilitate implementation in production processes. An RMSEP of 0.0890 g L - 1 with univariate linear regression was achieved, showing that by subtraction of the background better prediction accuracy is achieved then without subtraction and a PLS model. In summary, the developed background subtraction method is versatile, enables accurate prediction results, and is easily implemented into existing chromatography setups with typically already integrated sensors.

Process Analytical Technologies and Data Analytics for the Manufacture of Monoclonal Antibodies

Process analytical technology (PAT) for the manufacture of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) is defined by an integrated set of advanced and automated methods that analyze the compositions and biophysical properties of cell culture fluids, cell-free product streams, and biotherapeutic molecules that are ultimately formulated into concentrated products. In-line or near-line probes and systems are remarkably well developed, although challenges remain in the determination of the absence of viral loads, detecting microbial or mycoplasma contamination, and applying data-driven deep learning to process monitoring and soft sensors. In this review, we address the current status of PAT for both batch and continuous processing steps and discuss its potential impact on facilitating the continuous manufacture of biotherapeutics.

Monitoring Thermal and Non-Thermal Treatments during Processing of Muscle Foods: A Comprehensive Review of Recent Technological Advances

Muscle food products play a vital role in human nutrition due to their sensory quality and high nutritional value. One well-known challenge of such products is the high perishability and limited shelf life unless suitable preservation or processing techniques are applied. Thermal processing is one of the well-established treatments that has been most commonly used in order to prepare food and ensure its safety. However, the application of inappropriate or severe thermal treatments may lead to undesirable changes in the sensory and nutritional quality of heat-processed products, and especially so for foods that are sensitive to thermal treatments, such as fish and meat and their products. In recent years, novel thermal treatments (e.g., ohmic heating, microwave) and non-thermal processing (e.g., high pressure, cold plasma) have emerged and proved to cause less damage to the quality of treated products than do conventional techniques. Several traditional assessment approaches have been extensively applied in order to evaluate and monitor changes in quality resulting from the use of thermal and non-thermal processing methods. Recent advances, nonetheless, have shown tremendous potential of various emerging analytical methods. Among these, spectroscopic techniques have received considerable attention due to many favorable features compared to conventional analysis methods. This review paper will provide an updated overview of both processing (thermal and non-thermal) and analytical techniques (traditional methods and spectroscopic ones). The opportunities and limitations will be discussed and possible directions for future research studies and applications will be suggested.

High-Throughput Raman Spectroscopy Combined with Innovate Data Analysis Workflow to Enhance Biopharmaceutical Process Development

Raman spectroscopy has the potential to revolutionise many aspects of biopharmaceutical process development. The widespread adoption of this promising technology has been hindered by the high cost associated with individual probes and the challenge of measuring low sample volumes. To address these issues, this paper investigates the potential of an emerging new high-throughput (HT) Raman spectroscopy microscope combined with a novel data analysis workflow to replace off-line analytics for upstream and downstream operations. On the upstream front, the case study involved the at-line monitoring of an HT micro-bioreactor system cultivating two mammalian cell cultures expressing two different therapeutic proteins. The spectra generated were analysed using a partial least squares (PLS) model. This enabled the successful prediction of the glucose, lactate, antibody, and viable cell density concentrations directly from the Raman spectra without reliance on multiple off-line analytical devices and using only a single low-volume sample (50–300 μL). However, upon the subsequent investigation of these models, only the glucose and lactate models appeared to be robust based upon their model coefficients containing the expected Raman vibrational signatures. On the downstream front, the HT Raman device was incorporated into the development of a cation exchange chromatography step for an Fc-fusion protein to compare different elution conditions. PLS models were derived from the spectra and were found to predict accurately monomer purity and concentration. The low molecular weight (LMW) and high molecular weight (HMW) species concentrations were found to be too low to be predicted accurately by the Raman device. However, the method enabled the classification of samples based on protein concentration and monomer purity, allowing a prioritisation and reduction in samples analysed using A280 UV absorbance and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The flexibility and highly configurable nature of this HT Raman spectroscopy microscope makes it an ideal tool for bioprocess research and development, and is a cost-effective solution based on its ability to support a large range of unit operations in both upstream and downstream process operations.

On the analysis of chromatographic biopharmaceutical data by curve resolution techniques in the framework of the area of feasible solutions

Monitoring preparative protein chromatographic steps by in-line spectroscopic tools or fraction analytics results in medium or large sized data matrices. Multivariate Curve Resolution (MCR) serve to compute or to estimate the concentration values of the pure components only from these data matrices. However, MCR methods often suffer from an inherent solution ambiguity which underlies the factorization problem. The typical unimodality of the chromatographic profiles of pure components can support the chemometric analysis. Here we present the pure components estimation process within the framework of the area of feasible solutions, which is a systematic approach to represent the range of all possible solutions. The unimodality constraint in combination with Pareto optimization is shown to be an effective method for the pure component calculation. Applications are presented for chromatograms on a model protein mixture containing ribonuclease A, cytochrome c and lysozyme and on a two-dimensional chromatographic separation of a monoclonal antibody from its aggregate species. The root mean squared errors of the first case study are 0.0373, 0.0529 and 0.0380 g/L compared to traditional off-line analytics. The second case study illustrates the potential of recovering hidden components with MCR from off-line reference analytics.

Towards smart biomanufacturing: a perspective on recent developments in industrial measurement and monitoring technologies for bio-based production processes

The biomanufacturing industry has now the opportunity to upgrade its production processes to be in harmony with the latest industrial revolution. Technology creates capabilities that enable smart manufacturing while still complying with unfolding regulations. However, many biomanufacturing companies, especially in the biopharma sector, still have a long way to go to fully benefit from smart manufacturing as they first need to transition their current operations to an information-driven future. One of the most significant obstacles towards the implementation of smart biomanufacturing is the collection of large sets of relevant data. Therefore, in this work, we both summarize the advances that have been made to date with regards to the monitoring and control of bioprocesses, and highlight some of the key technologies that have the potential to contribute to gathering big data. Empowering the current biomanufacturing industry to transition to Industry 4.0 operations allows for improved productivity through information-driven automation, not only by developing infrastructure, but also by introducing more advanced monitoring and control strategies.

The Sample, the Spectra and the Maths-The Critical Pillars in the Development of Robust and Sound Applications of Vibrational Spectroscopy

The last two decades have witnessed an increasing interest in the use of the so-called rapid analytical methods or high throughput techniques. Most of these applications reported the use of vibrational spectroscopy methods (near infrared (NIR), mid infrared (MIR), and Raman) in a wide range of samples (e.g., food ingredients and natural products). In these applications, the analytical method is integrated with a wide range of multivariate data analysis (MVA) techniques (e.g., pattern recognition, modelling techniques, calibration, etc.) to develop the target application. The availability of modern and inexpensive instrumentation together with the access to easy to use software is determining a steady growth in the number of uses of these technologies. This paper underlines and briefly discusses the three critical pillars-the sample (e.g., sampling, variability, etc.), the spectra and the mathematics (e.g., algorithms, pre-processing, data interpretation, etc.)-that support the development and implementation of vibrational spectroscopy applications.