Effect of temperature on tertiary nitrogen removal from municipal wastewater in a PHBV/PLA-supported denitrification system

Impacts of vegetable processing and cheese making effluent on soil microbial functional diversity, community structure, and denitrification potential of land treatment systems

The cheese making and vegetable processing industries generate immense volumes of high-nitrogen wastewater that is often treated at rural facilities using land applications. Laboratory incubation results showed denitrification decreased with temperature in industry facility soils but remained high in soils from agricultural sites (75% at 2.1°C). 16S rRNA, phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA), and soil respiration analyses were conducted to investigate potential soil microbiome impacts. Biotic and abiotic system factor correlations showed no clear patterns explaining the divergent denitrification rates. In all three soil types at the phylum level, Actinobacteria, Proteobacteria, and Acidobacteria dominated, whereas at the class level, Nitrososphaeria and Alphaproteobacteria dominated, similar to denitrifying systems such as wetlands, wastewater resource recovery facilities, and wastewater-irrigated agricultural systems. Results show that potential denitrification drivers vary but lay the foundation to develop a better understanding of the key factors regulating denitrification in land application systems and protect local groundwater supplies. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Incubation study denitrification rates decreased as temperatures decreased, potentially leading to groundwater contamination issues during colder months. The three most dominant phyla for all systems are Actinobacteria, Proteobacteria, and Acidobacteria. The dominant class for all systems is Nitrosphaeria (phyla Crenarchaeota). No correlation patterns between denitrification rates and system biotic and abiotic factors were observed that explained system efficiency differences.

Characterization of simultaneous ammonium and nitrate removal and microbial communities in airlift reactor using 3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate (PHBV) as carbon source and biofilm carrier

As a novel trend, solid carbon sources are applied to act as electron donors and biofilm carrier in biological denitrification process. In this study, simultaneous nitrate and ammonium removal process in an airlift sequencing batch reactor using 3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate (PHBV) as carbon source and biofilm carrier under intermittent aeration conditions was established to treat effluent of synthetic marine recirculating aquaculture system. The results showed that maximum nitrate and ammonia nitrogen removal rates of 0.45 and 0.09 kg m-3 d-1 were achieved. No significant nitrite accumulation was found during 200-day operation, while effluent dissolved organic carbon accumulation and particle size reduction significantly increased. Microbial community analysis and batch tests illuminate that the generated sludge and attached biofilm played important roles in nitrogen removal. This study demonstrates the potential mechanism for the nitrogen removal process mediated by 3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate and provide a new idea for the alternative solutions of solid carbon sources.

Seasonal and longitudinal water quality dynamics in three effluent-dependent rivers in Arizona

Effluent-fed streams, which receive inputs from wastewater treatment plants, are becoming increasingly common across the globe as urbanization intensifies. In semi-arid and arid regions, where many natural streams have dried up due to over extraction of water, many streams rely completely on treated effluent to sustain baseflow during dry seasons. These systems are often thought of as ‘second-class’ or highly disturbed stream ecosystems, but they have the potential to serve as refuges for native aquatic biota if water quality is high, especially in areas where few natural habitats remain. In this study, we investigated seasonal and longitudinal water quality dynamics at multiple sites across six reaches of three effluent-dependent rivers in Arizona (USA) with the objective (1) to quantify changes in effluent water quality due to distance traveled and season/climate and (2) to qualify whether water quality conditions in these systems are sufficient to support native aquatic species. Study reaches ranged in length from 3 to 31 km and in geographic setting from low desert to montane conifer forest. We observed the lowest water quality conditions (e.g., elevated temperature and low dissolved oxygen) during the summer in low desert reaches, and significantly greater natural remediation of water quality in longer vs. shorter reaches for several factors, including temperature, dissolved oxygen and ammonia. Nearly all sites met or exceeded water quality conditions needed to support robust assemblages of native species across multiple seasons. However, our results also indicated that temperature (max 34.2 °C), oxygen levels (min 2.7 mg/L) and ammonia concentrations (max 5.36 mg/L N) may occasionally be stressful for sensitive taxa at sites closest to effluent outfalls. Water quality conditions may be a concern during the summer. Overall, effluent-dependent streams have the capacity to serve as refuges for native biota in Arizona, and they may become the only aquatic habitat available in many urbanizing arid and semi-arid regions.

Simultaneous denitrification and iron-phosphorus precipitation driven by plant biomass coupled with iron scraps in subsurface flow constructed wetlands

This study investigated the interaction between plant biomass and iron scraps and their influence on nitrogen (including nitrate and ammonia) and phosphorus removal in the subsurface flow constructed wetland. The results showed that with the addition of 0.5 g L^-1 of plant biomass and 5.0 g L^-1 of iron scraps, the nitrate, total nitrogen and total phosphorus removal were simultaneously improved. During 35 days of continuous operation, the plant biomass played main effect on the enhanced denitrification, accounting for about 57%, while iron scraps enhanced the other 43% of nitrogen removal and most phosphorus removal through precipitation inside the wetlands. Iron scraps could benefit the degradation of cellulose into low molecular carbohydrates by 10%, and the biomass could promote the oxidation of iron and increase the total phosphorus removal by 15%. Plant biomass coupled with iron scraps also improved simultaneously the richness, diversity and evenness of microbial community and promoted the abundance of Nitrospira (17.37%) and Thiobacillus (8.46%) in wetlands. In practice, putting iron scraps as matrix and placing plant biomass in the influent region would be a better choice. This research would provide a new method for effective utilization of plant biomass and iron scraps and further treatment of low-polluted wastewater in the wetlands.

Enhanced denitrification of dispersed swine wastewater using Ca(OH)2-pretreated rice straw as a solid carbon source

In a pilot-scale packed bed reactor, the denitrification performance and microbial community structure of the dispersed swine wastewater treatment using calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)₂) pretreated rice straw as a carbon source were investigated. In a Ca(OH)₂-pretreated rice straw supported denitrification system (Ca(OH)₂-RS), the removal efficiency of NO₃^--N was 96.39% at an influent NO₃^--N load of 0.04 kg/(m³•d). Meanwhile, there was no obvious accumulation of NO₂^--N or chemical oxygen demand (COD) in the effluent of Ca(OH)₂-RS. The contents of soluble microbial byproduct-like substances and tryptophan-like substances in the effluent of Ca(OH)₂-RS were reduced by 46.2% and 43.4%, respectively, compared with the influent. Overall, the Ca(OH)₂-pretreated rice straw system had a strong resistance to fluctuations in water quality conditions, such as influent NO₃^--N and COD concentrations. According to the microbial assay results, the Ca(OH)₂ pretreatment enriched more denitrifying bacteria. Among them, Proteobacteria (42.33%) and Bacteroidetes (35.28%) were the dominant bacteria. Moreover, the main denitrifying functional bacteria, generanorank_f_Saprospiraceae (13.32%), norank_f_Porphyromonadaceae (4.22%), and Flavobacterium (3.25%), were enriched in Ca(OH)₂-RS. This suggested that using Ca(OH)₂-pretreated rice straw as a carbon source was a stable and efficient technology to enhance the denitrification performance of dispersed swine wastewater.

A comprehensive assessment of upgrading technologies of wastewater treatment plants in Taihu Lake Basin

To meet the increasingly stringent discharge standards of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in the Taihu Lake Basin, the Chinese government successively established the National Special Water Project Program to develop new technologies to retrofit and upgrade existing wastewater treatment processes during the 11th, 12th, and 13th Five-Year Plans. However, there is a lack of systematic sorting of the existing research outcomes, and thus hinders the application and promotion of the upgrade technologies. Based on the outcomes of the National Special Water Project and a field survey, this research analyzed the current status of wastewater treatment in the Taihu Lake Basin and systematically integrated the retrofitting measures of WWTPs in terms of achieving the Grade IA of the national standard and local stricter discharge standards (DB 32/1072-2018 and DB 33/2169-2018). In particular, the boundary conditions, design parameters, specific recommendations of the technologies, and some typical engineering cases were provided accordingly. Finally, this study discussed the future development directions of WWTPs during the upgrade process from the perspective of carbon neutrality and digitalization. The present work will hopefully assist in retrofitting and constructing WWTPs to achieve the stricter effluent discharge criteria and help optimize the design and construction of WWTPs in the best way.

Study on the advanced nitrogen removal under low temperature by biofilm on weak magnetic carriers

The advanced nitrogen removal under low temperature is inhibited because of reduction of the microbial activity. Packed bed reactors filled with different magnetic carriers (0, 0.3, 0.6, 0.9 mT) were constructed to enhance advanced denitrification under low temperature (5 ℃). Results showed that 0.3 and 0.9 mT carriers significantly improved denitrification, indicating the "window" effect. Total nitrogen removals were increased by 6.96% and 8.25%, and NO₂^- accumulation decreased by 25.70% and 13.90% in 0.3 and 0.9 mT reactors, respectively. Analysis of enzyme activity and electron transport chain showed that 0.3 mT carrier mainly increased NIR activity by improving compound III and cytC abundance while 0.9 mT carrier mainly increased NAR activity by improving compound I and NADH abundance, indicating different pathways. Similar microbial community in 0.3 and 0.9 mT reactors were revealed. Overall, weak magnetic carriers can be used to enhance advanced nitrogen removal under low temperature.

Effectiveness of agricultural waste in the enhancement of biological denitrification of aquaculture wastewater

Nitrogen pollution in aquaculture wastewater can pose a significant health and environmental risk if not removed before wastewater is discharged. Biological denitrification uses external carbon sources to remove nitrogen from wastewater; however, these carbon sources are often expensive and require significant energy. In this study, we investigated how six types of agricultural waste can be used as solid carbon sources in biological denitrification. Banana stalk (BS), loofah sponge (LS), sorghum stalk (SS), sweet potato stalk (SPS), watermelon skins (WS) and wheat husk (WH) were studied to determine their capacity to release carbon and improve denitrification efficiency. The results of batch experiments showed that all six agricultural wastes had excellent carbon release capacities, with cumulative chemical oxygen demands of 37.74-535.68 mg/g. During the 168-h reaction, the carbon release process followed the second-order kinetic equation and Ritger-Peppas equation, while carbon release occurred via diffusion. The kinetic equation fitting, scanning electron microscopy, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy results showed that LS had the lowest c_m and the maximum t_1/2 values and only suffered a moderate degree of hydrolysis. It also had the lowest pollutant release rate and cumulative chemical oxygen demand, as well as the most efficient removal of total phosphorous (TP) and total nitrogen (TN). Therefore, we concluded that LS has the lowest potential risk of excess carbon release and capacity for long-lasting and stable carbon release. The WS leachate had the highest TN contents, while the SPS leachate had the highest TP content. In the 181-h denitrification reaction, all six agricultural wastes completely removed nitrate and nitrite; however, SS had the highest denitrification rate, followed by LS, WH, BS, SPS, and WS (2.16, 1.35, 1.35, 1.34, 1.34, and 1.01 mg/(L·h), respectively). The denitrification process followed a zero-order and first-order kinetic equation. These results provide theoretical guidance for effectively selecting agricultural waste as a solid carbon source and improving the denitrification efficiency of aquaculture wastewater treatment.

Response difference of simultaneous sulfide and nitrite removal process to different cooling modes

The effects of various cooling modes (sudden cooling (25℃→10℃) and step cooling (25℃→20℃→15℃→10℃)) on the performance of simultaneous sulfide and nitrite removal process were reported. Regardless of cooling mode adopted, the process maintained good sulfide removal performance, and removal percentage was 100.00%. Considering nitrite removal percentage, the process was more sensitive to step cooling mode (k = 0.06707) in comparison to sudden cooling mode (k = 0.02760). Lowering temperature promoted the transformation from sulfate to elemental sulfur, and it was easier to increase the proportion of elemental sulfur (79.90%) by means of step cooling. The sulfide oxidation rate and nitrite reduction rate were 0.01540 mg /(L∙min) and 0.00354 mg /(L∙min), respectively, in the sudden cooling mode, and 0.01168 mg /(L∙min) and 0.00138 mg /(L∙min), respectively, in the step cooling mode. Low temperature reduced the diversity of microbial community, and Sulfurovum was still a dominant bacterial member in both cooling modes.

Denitrification performance and microbial community of bioreactor packed with PHBV/PLA/rice hulls composite

In this study, a novel biodegradable PHBV/PLA/rice hulls (PPRH) composite was applied and tested as biofilm attachment carrier and carbon source in two bioreactors for biological denitrification process. The denitrification performance, effect of operational conditions and microbial community structure of PPRH biofilm were evaluated. The batch experiment results showed that PPRH-packed bioreactor could completely remove 50 mg L^-1 of NO₃^--N at natural pH (ca. 7.5) and room temperature. The continuous flow experiments indicated that high NO₃^--N removal efficiency (77%-99%) was achieved with low nitrite (<0.48 mg L^-1) and ammonia (<0.81 mg L^-1) accumulation, when influent NO₃^--N concentration was 30 mg L^-1 and hydraulic retention time was 2-6 h. Furthermore, the microbial community analysis indicated that bacteria belonging to genus Diaphorobacter in phylum Proteobacteria were the most dominant and major denitrifiers in denitrification. In summary, PPRH composite was a promising carbon source for biological nitrate removal from water and wastewater.

Efficient utilization of Iris pseudacorus biomass for nitrogen removal in constructed wetlands: Combining alkali treatment

Aquatic plant biomass like Iris pseudacorus can be used as electron donor to improve denitrification performance in subsurface constructed wetlands. However, the phenomenon that the nitrogen removal rate declined in the terminal stage restricted the utilization of litters. In terms of this problem, this study investigated the performance of the used biomass through alkali treatment on nitrogen removal and analyzed the effect of alkali treatment on the component and structure of biomass and microbial community. The results showed that the alkali-treated biomass could further enhance the nitrogen removal by nearly 15% compared with used ones. The significant damage of cell walls and compact fibers containing cellulose and lignin through alkali treatment mainly resulted in the improvement of carbon release and nitrogen removal. With the addition of alkali-treated biomass, the richness index of microbes was higher compared with other biomass materials. Furthermore, the abundance of denitrification related genera increased and the abundance of genera for nitrification was maintained. Based on these finds, a mode of a more efficient Iris pseudacorus self-consumed subsurface flow constructed wetlands was designed. In this mode, the effluent total nitrogen could be stabilized below 5 mg L^-1 for nine months and the weight of litters could be further cut down by 75%. These findings would contribute to efficient utilization of plant biomass for nitrogen removal enhancement and final residue reduction in the wetlands.

Solid-phase denitrification in high salinity and low-temperature wastewater treatment

Nitrogen removal from wastewater is often deteriorated under high salinity and low temperature. Solid-phase denitrification (SPD) might improve total nitrogen removal efficiency (TNRE) by stably supplying carbon resources under adverse conditions. In this study, an SPD biofilm reactor was successfully established by inoculating halophilic sludge and filling poly (butanediol succinate) (PBS) granules, and achieved over 96% TNRE at low temperature. More extracellular polysaccharides were produced at low temperature. Microbial network analysis evidenced dominant heterotrophic denitrifiers (Marinicella, Fusibacter, Saccharicrinis and Vitellibacter) at 25 °C were replaced by genera Melioribacter, Marinobacter, Desulfatitalea and Thiomicrospira at 15 °C. At low temperature, genes nirS and narG might be mainly responsible for denitrification. Fluorescence spectrum coupled with fluorescence regional integration and parallel factor analysis revealed low temperature increased the proportion of proteins of soluble microbial products. This study provides guidance for the practical application of SPD in the treatment of high salinity and low-temperature wastewater.

Research progress in solid carbon source-based denitrification technologies for different target water bodies

Nitrogen pollution in water bodies is a serious environmental issue which is commonly treated by various methods such as heterotrophic denitrification. In particular, solid carbon source (SCS)-based denitrification has attracted widespread research interest due to its gradual carbon release, ease of management, and long-term operation. This paper reviews the types and properties of SCSs for different target water bodies. While both natural (wheat straw, wood chips, and fruit shells) and synthetic (polybutylene succinate, polycaprolactone, polylactic acid, and polyhydroxyalkanoates) SCSs are commonly used, it is observed that the denitrification performance of the synthetic sources is generally superior. SCSs have been used in the treatment of wastewater (including aquaculture wastewater), agricultural subsurface drainage, surface water, and groundwater; however, the key research aspects related to SCSs differ markedly based on the target waterbody. These key research aspects include nitrogen pollutant removal rate and byproduct accumulation (ordinary wastewater); water quality parameters and aquatic product yield (recirculating aquaculture systems); temperature and hydraulic retention time (agricultural subsurface drainage); the influence of dissolved oxygen (surface waters); and nitrate-nitrogen load, HRT, and carbon source dosage on denitrification rate (groundwater). It is concluded that SCS-based denitrification is a promising technique for the effective elimination of nitrate-nitrogen pollution in water bodies.

Temperature-induced difference in microbial characterizations accounts for the fluctuation of sequencing batch biofilm reactor performance

Generally, the purification performance of bioreactors could be influenced by temperature variation via shaping different microbial communities. However, the underlying mechanisms remain largely unknown. Here, the variation trends of microbial communities in three sequencing batch biofilm reactors (SBBRs) under four different temperatures (15, 20, 25, 30 °C) were compared. It was found that temperature increment led to an obvious enhancement in nutrient removal which was mainly occurred in the aerobic section. Meanwhile, distinct differences in dominant microbial communities or autotrophic nitrifiers were also observed. The performance of the SBBR reactors was closely associated with nitrifier communities since the treated wastewater was characterized by a severe lack of carbon sources (mean effluent COD ≤ 14.4 mg/L). Spearman correlation unraveled that: most of the differentiated microbes as well as the dominant potential functions were strongly associated with nutrient removal, indicating the temperature-induced difference in microbial community well explained the distinction in purification performance.

Denitrification using permeable reactive barriers with organic substrate or zero-valent iron fillers: controlling mechanisms, challenges, and future perspectives

Nitrate as a diffusive agricultural contaminant has been causing substantial groundwater quality deterioration worldwide. In situ groundwater remediation techniques using permeable reactive barriers (PRBs) have attracted increasing interest. Particularly, PRBs based on biological denitrification, using the organic substrate as a biostimulator, and chemical nitrate reduction, using zero-valent iron (ZVI) as a reductant, are two major PRB approaches for groundwater denitrification. This review paper analyzed the published studies over the past 10 years (2010-2020) using laboratory, modeling, and field-scale approaches to explore the performance and mechanisms of these two types of PRBs. Important factors affecting the denitrification efficiencies as well as the influential mechanisms were discussed. Several research gaps have been identified and further research needs are discussed in the end.

The influence mechanism of temperature on solid phase denitrification based on denitrification performance, carbon balance, and microbial analysis

In this work, the influence mechanism of temperature on solid phase denitrification (SPD) was investigated using a pilot-scale reactor supported with polycaprolactone (PCL). The results showed that under nitrate loads of ~31.5 mg N/(L·h), as temperature decreased from 30 °C to 13 °C, the nitrate removal efficiency declined from 94% to 57%. Furthermore, denitrification rate constants were input into Arrhenius equation and the resulting temperature coefficient was 1.04. Significantly nitrite accumulation and less effluent COD residue occurred at low-temperatures. Via stoichiometry, the sludge yield coefficient and COD demand for nitrate removal both increased as a function of increasing temperature; and were calculated at 20 °C as 0.069 g MLVSS/(g COD·d) and 3.265 g COD/g N, respectively. Carbon balance analysis indicated that the COD release rate (υ) at 30 °C was twice that at 13 °C. LEfSe analysis demonstrated that Desulfomicrobium, Desulfovibrio, and Meganema were abundant at low-temperature, while Simplicispira, Aquabacterium, and Acidovorax were enriched at high-temperature. Besides, carboxylesterase (PCL depolymerase) was more abundant at high-temperature, implying an association with a fast υ. Moreover, nar was enriched at low-temperature, while nir was depleted, which led to nitrite accumulation. These results provide reference for SPD design parameter estimation and/or optimal operation strategy.