Ultraviolet difference spectra of the lactose repressor protein. II. Trypsin core protein

Biomolecular Assemblies: Moving from Observation to Predictive Design

Biomolecular assembly is a key driving force in nearly all life processes, providing structure, information storage, and communication within cells and at the whole organism level. These assembly processes rely on precise interactions between functional groups on nucleic acids, proteins, carbohydrates, and small molecules, and can be fine-tuned to span a range of time, length, and complexity scales. Recognizing the power of these motifs, researchers have sought to emulate and engineer biomolecular assemblies in the laboratory, with goals ranging from modulating cellular function to the creation of new polymeric materials. In most cases, engineering efforts are inspired or informed by understanding the structure and properties of naturally occurring assemblies, which has in turn fueled the development of predictive models that enable computational design of novel assemblies. This Review will focus on selected examples of protein assemblies, highlighting the story arc from initial discovery of an assembly, through initial engineering attempts, toward the ultimate goal of predictive design. The aim of this Review is to highlight areas where significant progress has been made, as well as to outline remaining challenges, as solving these challenges will be the key that unlocks the full power of biomolecules for advances in technology and medicine.

Integrated insights from simulation, experiment, and mutational analysis yield new details of LacI function

Protein structural change underlies many signal transduction processes. Although end-state structures are known for various allosteric proteins, intermediates are difficult to observe. Recently, targeted molecular dynamics simulation (TMD) was used to examine the conformational transition and predict relevant intermediates for wild-type lactose repressor (LacI). A catalog of involved residues suggests that the transition of this homodimer is asymmetric and that K84 is a prominent participant in the dynamic N-subdomain interface. Previous experiments indicated that hydrophobic substitutions at position 84 engender slowed, biphasic inducer binding kinetics, which might reflect the same phenomena observed in TMD. Here, we report biochemical confirmation that DNA and inducer binding remain allosterically linked in K84A and K84L, albeit with a differential smaller than that found in wild-type LacI. Other features of these mutant proteins are consistent with an allosteric conformational shift that approximates that of the wild type. As a consequence, these repressors can be utilized to explore an unanswered question about LacI function: How many inducers (one or two per dimer) are required to diminish operator affinity? The biphasic natures of the K84L and K84A inducer association rates allow direct correlation between the two distinct inducer binding events and operator release. Indeed, the kinetics of operator release for the K84A and K84L closely parallel those for the second inducer binding event. Together with implications from previous equilibrium results for wild-type and mutant proteins, these kinetic data demonstrate that binding of two inducers per dimeric DNA binding unit is required to release the operator in these variant LacI proteins.

Ligand-induced conformational changes in lactose repressor: a fluorescence study of single tryptophan mutants

A key element in the ability of lac repressor protein to control transcription reversibly is the capacity to assume different conformations in response to ligand binding. To investigate regions of the protein involved in these conformational changes, mutant repressor proteins containing single tryptophans were created by mutating each of the two native tryptophan residues to tyrosine and changing the residue of interest to tryptophan. Tryptophans substituted in the following locations were highly accessible to quenchers with no changes in fluorescence or quenching properties in the presence of ligands: in the N-terminal helix-turn-helix for Y7, at the junction between the N-terminus and N-subdomain for L62, in the N-subdomain of the monomer-monomer interface for residue E100 or Q117, or at the C-terminal region for K325. Tryptophan at position F226 in the C-subdomain subunit interface was only moderately exposed to quenchers and unresponsive to ligands. In contrast, the fluorescence and quenching properties of single tryptophans placed in the central region of the protein were affected by ligands. Inducer binding altered the accessibility to quencher for tryptophan at H74 or F293, but no changes were detected upon binding operator. Exposure of tryptophan at the position occupied by Y273 was affected by both inducer and operator, indicating alterations in this region by both ligands. These results suggest that, in the areas of the lac repressor probed by these substitutions, the inducer-bound form differs from the conformation of the unliganded form.

Lactose repressor protein: functional properties and structure

The lactose repressor protein (LacI), the prototype for genetic regulatory proteins, controls expression of lactose metabolic genes by binding to its cognate operator sequences in E. coli DNA. Inducer binding elicits a conformational change that diminishes affinity for operator sequences with no effect on nonspecific binding. The release of operator is followed by synthesis of mRNA encoding the enzymes for lactose utilization. Genetic, chemical and physical studies provided detailed insight into the function of this protein prior to the recent completion of X-ray crystallographic structures. The structural information can now be correlated with the phenotypic data for numerous mutants. These structures also provide the opportunity for physical and chemical studies on mutants designed to examine various aspects of lac repressor structure and function. In addition to providing insight into protein structure-function correlations, LacI has been utilized in a wide variety of applications both in prokaryotic gene expression and in eukaryotic gene regulation and studies of mutagenesis.

Two-dimensional 1H, 15N NMR investigation of uniformly 15N-labeled lac repressor headpiece

15N uniformly labeled lac repressor and lac repressor headpiece were prepared. 15N NMR spectra of lac repressor were shown resolution inadequate for detailed study while the data showed that the 15N labeled N-terminal part of the protein is quite suitable for this type of study allowing future investigation of the specific interaction of the lac repressor headpiece with the lac operator. We report here the total assignment of proton 1H and nitrogen 15NH backbone resonances of this headpiece in the free state. Assignments of the 15N resonances of the protein were obtained in a sequential manner using heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence (HMQC), relayed HMQC nuclear Overhauser and relayed HMQC-HOHAHA spectroscopy. More than 80 per cent of residues were assigned by their 15NH(i)-N1H(i + 1) and 15NH(i)-N1H(i - 1) connectivities. Values of the 3JNH alpha splitting for 39 of the 51 residues of the headpiece were extracted from HMQC and HMQC-J. The observed 15NH(i)-C beta H cross peaks and the 3JNH alpha coupling constants values are in agreement with the three alpha-helices previously described [Zuiderweg, E.R.P., Scheek, R.M., Boelens, R., van Gunsteren, W.F. and Kaptein, R., Biochimie 67, 707 (1985)]. The 3JNH alpha coupling constants can be now used for a more confident determination of the lac repressor headpiece. From these values it is shown that the geometry of the ends of the second and third alpha-helices exhibit deviation from the canonical alpha-helix structure. On the basis of NOEs and 3JNH alpha values, the geometry of the turn of the helix-turn-helix motif is discussed.

lac operator DNA modification in the presence of proteolytic fragments of the repressor protein

Singly end-labeled DNA fragments containing the lactose operator were methylated in the presence of the lactose repressor and homogeneous preparations of its proteolytic fragments. Binding of core protein produced by mild trypsin digestion yielded a methylation perturbation pattern that differed significantly from that elicited by binding to intact repressor, although similarities in the patterns for these related proteins were noted in the central, asymmetric region of the operator. An NH2-terminal peptide (residues 1 to 56) from lac repressor bound operator fragments in a nitrocellulose filter assay, but failed to perturb DNA methylation significantly relative to the pattern in the absence of peptide. Binding of hybrid tetramers of core and intact repressor monomers produced related but unique methylation patterns for the purines on the operator fragment. The general pattern of perturbation observed suggests preferred binding of a single NH2 terminus to the promoter-distal region of the operator and asymmetric interaction of the core region with the operator sequence. Differences in purine methylation patterns produced by the presence of effector complexes of repressor and core protein suggest the possible nature of changes in protein topology that result in the affinity changes accompanying induction.

Predicted structure of the sugar-binding site of the lac repressor

The lactose repressor protein from Escherichia coli binds sugars, primarily galactosides, which modulate its interactions with operator DNA and thereby affect synthesis of the lac metabolic enzymes. The affinity of the repressor for operator DNA is decreased by binding inducer sugars and increased by binding anti-inducer sugars. Based on regions of the primary structure implicated by genetic methods to be involved in sugar binding, amino acid sequence homology between L-arabinose-binding protein (ABP) and lac repressor has recently been reported. The sugar-binding sites for these two proteins might be expected to have similar structural features, as both bind L-arabinose and D-galactose. The high resolution structure of ABP reported in the accompanying article provides complete definition of amino acids in the sugar-binding site. By identification of homologous residues in the lac repressor, we have now predicted the structure of the portion of the repressor sugar-binding site which accommodates the galactosyl moiety. This prediction provides the first potential view of the inducer/anti-inducer site in the repressor protein.

Perturbation of lac operator DNA modification by tryptic core protein from lac repressor

Operator DNA fragments were modified in the presence of lac repressor protein or its trypsin-resistant core. Operator DNA was alkylated or cleaved enzymatically with these related proteins present to compare the influences of their binding on the reactivities or enzymatic susceptibilities of individual bases in the sequence. These two protein species have pronounced and distinguishable effects on the reactivity of the bases of the operator fragment toward methylation by dimethyl sulfate. Perturbation of base alkylation by the trypsin-resistant core repressor is most pronounced in the inner, asymmetric region of the operator DNA, while repressor effects extend further on either end of the operator sequence. Digestion of the two protein-operator complexes by DNase I yields fragment patterns that differ primarily in extent of protection. These data extend the experimental base supporting the involvement of the core region of the lac repressor in addition to its NH2 termini in the operator-specific binding activity of this protein.

Unfolding of lac repressor and its proteolytic fragment by urea: headpieces stabilize the core within lac repressor

Circular dichroism measurements were used to compared the urea-induced unfolding transition of the lac repressor with those of its separated tryptic fragments, the tetrameric core, and the N-terminal headpiece. The presence of the headpieces covalently linked to the core in the intact repressor leads to a stabilization against urea denaturation as compared to that for the isolated core. This results in a shift of the midpoint of the transition by about 0.5 M urea. When the inducer isopropyl beta-D-thiogalactoside is bound, the core is stabilized more than the entire repressor. The isolated headpiece is considerably more stable against urea denaturation than the tryptic core or the lac repressor. The reversible denaturation process of the headpiece was quantitatively analyzed, and the free energy of unfolding in the absence of urea was found to be 2.4 or 2.9 kcal/mol, depending on the method of calculation used. Comparison between the circular dichroism spectra of the lac repressor, the tryptic core of the lac repressor, and the headpiece supply further evidence that there are no major conformational differences between the structural domains (core and headpieces) before and after proteolytic cleavage of the lac repressor. These results are discussed with respect to the contacts between the different domains of the protein. It is concluded that relatively weak interdomain contacts are probably responsible for the stabilization of the core by the covalently linked headpieces and that these contacts might be weakened upon binding of the inducer.

Genetic assignment of resonances in the NMR spectrum of a protein: lac repressor

By using a systematic genetic approach, the resonances in the 19F NMR spectrum of 3-fluorotyrosine-substituted lac repressor protein have been assigned. The NMR data indicate that each monomer of the repressor consists of two distinct and independent domains. One domain, the NH2-terminal sixth of the primary sequence, which has been shown to be very important for DNA binding, is very mobile. The remaining COOH-terminal sequence is more rigid. Ligands of the repressor, which affect its DNA binding capability, lead to conformational changes in the COOH-terminal domain. The approach to the assignment of spectral features taken here can be extended to other systems.

Determination of the ligand-binding characteristics of several tight-binding mutants of the lactose repressor protein

Several tight-binding mutants of the lactose repressor protein have been characterized with respect to their fluorescence properties and their inducer, operator and nonspecific DNA-binding constants. The tryptophan fluorescence emission spectra for the mutants and the wild-type repressor are quite similar. However, alterations in the Stern-Volmer constants for iodide quenching of the tryptophans in the mutant proteins compared to wild-type suggest differences in the local environment or solvent accessibility for these amino acids in the tight-binding repressors. The inducer-binding affinities and association rate constants of the mutant proteins and protein-operator DNA fragment complexes are also altered compared to wild-type. The extents of these changes vary among the different mutant repressors. The nonspecific DNA-binding affinities of the mutant proteins are 2--3-fold greater than the wild-type repressor, and the affinities of the tight-binding proteins for a 29 base-pair operator DNA fragment are also increased, though to a varying extent depending upon the mutant. The phenotypic behavior of these proteins in vivo can be partially explained by these results obtained in vitro; however, it is likely that there are additional factors responsible for the tight-binding behavior of the proteins that were not detectable in these experiments.

Model for lactose repressor protein and its interaction with ligands

A model is presented for the structure of the lactose repressor protein and for its interaction with inducer, operator DNA, and nonspecific DNA. The proposed structure is based on experimental evidence from this laboratory and from the literature and is offered as an integration of the available data on this system. Features unique to this model include: (i) interaction of the core region of the protein with the operator, (ii) primary effects of the conformational change in response to inducer on the core-operator interaction, (iii) contacts between all four subunits of the protein and the operator DNA, and (iv) qualitative differences in operator and nonspecific DNA binding.

Modification of tyrosine residues of the lactose repressor protein

Reaction of the lactose repressor protein from Escherichia coli with high molar excesses (up to 800 fold) of tetranitromethane resulted in modification of tyrosine residues in the amino-terminal and core regions of the molecule. Tyrosines 7 and 17 exhibit significant reactivity at low levels (5-10 fold molar excess) of tetranitromethane. The loss of operator binding activity upon nitration at these low concentrations of reagent indicates involvement of these two tyrosines in the binding process. Inducer binding activity was maintained at approx. 90% of unreacted repressor for all excesses of reagent studied. Addition of inducer to the repressor prior to reaction resulted in decreased modification of tyrosines in the core region, but anti-inducers did not affect the reaction significantly. The effect of inducers on the pattern of reaction apparently reflects the conformational change which occurs upon binding of these ligands. Acetylation of the repressor protein with N-acetylimidazole modified lysines and tyrosines with complete loss of operator binding activity and retention of 75-80% of inducer binding activity.