Assessing improvements in the dexamethasone suppression test using receiver operating characteristics analysis

The relevance of the in- versus outpatient status for studies on HPA-axis in depression: spontaneous hypercortisolism is a feature of major depressed inpatients and not of major depression per se

Increased spontaneous activity of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA)-axis is frequently reported in major depressed inpatients. The aim of the present study was to determine whether there are differences in spontaneous HPA-axis activity between major depressed inpatients and outpatients. Toward this end, the authors measured basal 9:00 a.m. plasma cortisol and the integrated assessment of plasma morning cortisol secretion over 2 (AUC 120) hours in 48 major depressed inpatients, 17 major depressed outpatients and 73 normal volunteers. Major depressed inpatients exhibit significantly higher plasma cortisol values than healthy controls and major depressed outpatients. The cortisol data from the latter are not significantly different from these of the healthy controls. The cortisol differences between in and outpatients were still present after considering the influences of age, sex, body mass index, severity or endogeneity of illness, unipolar/bipolar subclassification, or specific symptoms such as suicidal thoughts, insomnia, psychomotor disorders, psychoticism, weight loss or anxiety. The results indicate that hypercortisolism as measured by basal morning plasma levels is not a feature of major depression per se, but rather of an interaction between the illness and hospitalization.

Can disulfiram potentiate the dexamethasone suppression test in depressive patients?

Transient DST non-suppression during disulfiram-treatment was fortuitously observed in a depressed patient. A disulfiram-potentiated DST (DSTd) was constructed by giving 800 mg disulfiram on the dexamethasone and postdexamethasone days. DST and DSTd were compared intraindividually in 21 patients and 14 controls. Disulfiram-potentiation was significant in constantly depressed patients, and in questionable controls due to possible subclinical depression or somatic factors which may cause 'false-positive' results. It did not occur in depressed patients during marked improvement or long-term recovery, and not in accurately screened controls. DSTd was significantly correlated with depression ratings, whereas DST was not.

MMPI assessment of the DSM-III-R histrionic personality disorder

This study investigated the MMPI characteristics of a group of 25 Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (3rd ed., rev. [DSM-III-R]; American Psychiatric Association, 1987) histrionic personality disorder patients, contrasted with a mixed group of 57 other personality disorder patients. All patients were diagnosed by means of a semistructured interview (SCID-II; Spitzer, Williams, & Gibbon, 1987). Effects for diagnostic category were found for MMPI Scales 9 (Ma), 0 (Si) and for the HST scale, developed by Morey, Waugh, and Blashfield (1985) for the diagnosis of the histrionic personality disorder. Further analysis of the results revealed that these MMPI scales, and especially the HST scale, mainly assess a social introversion-extraversion dimension, on which histrionic inpatients can be differentiated from nonhistrionic inpatients. This study does not offer direct empirical support for the use of the HST scale as a measurement of the DSM-III-R histrionic personality disorder concept.

Immune disorders in depression: higher T helper/T suppressor-cytotoxic cell ratio

This study investigated the leukocyte T helper and T suppressor-cytotoxic cell (sub)set profile of minor, simple major and melancholic depressives versus normal controls. Using both monoclonal antibody staining and flow cytometry, we determined the absolute numbers and percentages of the following T cell immune subsets: T helper (CD4+), T virgin (CD4+CD45+), T memory (CD4+CD45-), T suppressor/cytotoxic (CD8+), CD8+ T suppressor (CD8+CD57-) and CD8+ T cytotoxic (CD8+CD57+) cells. After computing the CD4+/CD8+ ratio, we detected a significantly increased ratio in depressed patients as compared with healthy controls. Depression per se is characterized by a higher percentage of CD4+ and a lower percentage of CD8+CD57- cells. Melancholic depressed subjects exhibit a significantly increased number of CD4+ and CD4+CD45- cells. The combined use of various percentages of CD4+ and CD8+ (sub)sets yields a high degree of marker positivity for melancholia: through cumulative evaluation of those percentages, the marker positivity increases to 68% (sensitivity) and the specificity is 95%. These results together with our previous reports may refer to a depression-related state of T cell activation.

Disturbances in acute phase plasma proteins during melancholia: additional evidence for the presence of an inflammatory process during that illness

1. Leukocyte enumeration through flow cytometry has revealed that severe depression may be accompanied by a systemic immune activation, indicative of an inflammatory response. The latter condition allegedly involves an important modification of acute phase plasma protein (APP) equilibrium. 2. In order to elucidate whether the state of severe depression is represented by alterations in APPs, the authors measured: alpha 1 antitrypsin (alpha 1 AT), alpha 2 macroglobulin (alpha 2 M), haptoglobin (Hp), alpha 1 acid glycoprotein (alpha 1 S), transferrin (Tf), complement component 4 (C4) and C-reactive protein (CRP). Interleukin-1-beta (II-1 beta) and interleukin-6 (II-6) circulating levels were determined. 3. Hyperhaptoglobinemia and hypotransferrinemia are hallmarks for major depression and depression per se, respectively. The disorders in Hp and Tf circulating levels are highly sensitive to (83%) and specific for (100%) melancholia as opposed to the healthy state. 4. Disorders in both APPs are significantly related to the absolute number of blood monocytes. 5. The authors observed a trend towards lower alpha 2M and higher alpha 1S values in severely depressed subjects. Severity of depression was significantly related to Hp and alpha 1S (both positively) and to alpha 2M and Tf (both negatively) values. 6. No significant intercategory differences in C4 could be established, whilst only a few subjects exhibited measurable CRP, II-1 beta and II-6 circulating levels. 7. Our findings may support the hypothesis that depression is accompanied by an inflammatory response.

Adrenocorticotropin hormone, beta-endorphin and cortisol responses to oCRF in melancholic patients

Several authors have reported attenuated adrenocorticotropin hormone (ACTH) responses to corticotropin releasing factor (CRF) administration in melancholic patients as compared with healthy controls. In order to explore the integrity of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA)-axis in melancholics, we examined the following parameters in 98 subjects: the ACTH; beta-endorphin; and cortisol responses to ovine CRF (oCRF) (100 micrograms/i.v.); and the postdexamethasone cortisol values. We found significant lower CRF-induced ACTH responses in melancholic patients as opposed to healthy controls and minor depressives, while major depressives occupied an intermediate position. The psychopathological correlates of the blunted CRF-induced ACTH responses were feelings of worthlessness, self-reproach, or excessive guilt. The CRF-stimulated beta-endorphin and cortisol response did not differ between the study samples. Higher baseline plasma cortisol was associated with attenuated CRF-induced ACTH responses, but these effects were not pertinent to melancholia. There were no relationships between the disordered oCRF test results, and postdexamethasone cortisol values, age, body size, sex and severity of illness. The diagnostic power of the oCRF and the dexamethasone suppression test for melancholia is enhanced when both test results are combined.

Low MMPI diagnostic performance for the DSM-III--R obsessive-compulsive personality disorder

This study investigated the diagnostic performance of the MMPI validity and clinical scales, and especially of Scale 7 (Pt), for the DSM-IIII--R obsessive-compulsive personality disorder by comparing the MMPI variables for 24 obsessive-compulsive with those for 58 nonobsessive-compulsive inpatients. Both groups were diagnosed by semistructured interview (SCID-II). The obsessive-compulsive group obtained for the mean MMPI profile a 2-(6-1) (D-Pa-Hs) code, with a tendency for a lowered Scale 4 (Pd) score, compared to the nonobsessive-compulsive group. Neither the ROC analysis of the individual MMPI scales, including Scale 7 (Pt), nor the analyses of frequency of two-point codes and elevated (T greater than 69) scales showed any clear indications of good diagnostic performance for the DSM-III--R obsessive-compulsive personality disorder.

Anthropometric and biochemical assessment of the nutritional state in depression: evidence for lower visceral protein plasma levels in depression

Severe depression is characterized by anorexia and weight loss, symptoms that could endanger the patient's nutritional state. In order to investigate the nutritional state of depressed patients we determined the following in 113 healthy controls and depressed inpatients: (1) anthropometric variables such as body weight, ideal body weight (IBW), percentage of IBW, mean arm circumference, triceps skinfold thickness and arm muscle circumference, and (2) biochemical parameters such as albumin (Alb), prealbumin (Prealb), and transferrin (Tf). We were unable to detect any differences in the anthropometric parameters between healthy controls, minor and major depressed patients. Depressed patients exhibited significantly lower Alb and Tf levels than healthy controls. The drop in both plasma proteins was highly sensitive (72%) and specific (92%) for melancholia. These results may point towards the existence of a disorder in protein homeostasis or protein malnutrition without a marasmic component.

MMPI characteristics of the DSM-III-R avoidant personality disorder

The clinical description provided by the MMPI Scale 0 (Social Introversion, Si) reflects an apparent and striking affinity with the DSM-III--R concept of the avoidant personality disorder which was here investigated by comparing the MMPI variables of 22 avoidant with 60 other, nonavoidant personality disordered inpatients. Both of the groups were diagnosed by use of a semistructured interview (SCID-II). The avoidant group obtained for mean MMPI profile a 2-6-7 (D-Pa-Pt) code. Significant differences were found between groups on MMPI Scales 2 (D), 7 (Pt), 9 (Ma), and 0 (Si). ROC analysis of the diagnostic performance showed the importance and utility of the evaluation of Scale 0 (Si) in the psychodiagnostic assessment of the avoidant personality disorder.

Abnormal pituitary function during melancholia: reduced alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone secretion and increased intact ACTH non-suppression

In order to investigate pituitary alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone (alpha-MSH), intact (1-39 structure) adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), and adrenal cortisol secretion, we measured 8 a.m. plasma levels of those hormones before and after administration of 1 mg dexamethasone in 39 depressed inpatients and 10 healthy controls. We found a significantly lower baseline alpha-MSH secretion in melancholic patients as opposed to healthy controls. There were no significant relations between alpha-MSH secretion on the one hand and ACTH or cortisol secretion on the other. Dexamethasone did not affect the 8 a.m. alpha-MSH circulating levels. The post-dexamethasone intact ACTH and cortisol values were significantly higher in melancholics as compared with healthy, minor and simple major depressed subjects. ACTH non-suppression was defined as post-dexamethasone intact ACTH greater than or equal to 12 pg/ml. ACTH non-suppression was found to be more sensitive (70%) and specific (100%) for melancholia than cortisol non-suppression. By means of pathway analysis we have established that cortisol non-suppression during a severe depression is completely determined by an augmented ACTH escape from suppression by dexamethasone. It is concluded that the assay of post-dexamethasone intact ACTH could, in the future, replace post-dexamethasone cortisol determination.

A multivariate study of simultaneous escape from suppression by dexamethasone of urinary free cortisol, plasma cortisol, adrenocorticotropic hormone and beta-endorphin in melancholic patients

To investigate the relationships between pre- and postdexamethasone hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis functioning in depression, we measured the levels of baseline and postdexamethasone urinary free cortisol (UFC), plasma cortisol, adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) and beta-endorphin. We found that dexamethasone significantly suppressed all hormone levels. All 4 postdexamethasone hormones--but not their baseline levels--were significantly higher in melancholic subjects than in minor and simple major depressives. We have accumulated evidence that the melancholic and minor depression groups form discrete classes in postdexamethasone HPA axis hormone levels; this supports the biological heterogeneity hypothesis of melancholia. We found that a combination of the postdexamethasone UFC and beta-endorphin values yielded the most significant diagnostic tool for melancholia. Our results suggest that the measurements of both hormones may constitute the most accurate index reflecting the HPA axis escape from suppression by dexamethasone in melancholia. By means of pathway analysis, we determined the causal relationships between age, dexamethasone circulating levels, diagnostic depression classification and the various baseline and postdexamethasone hormone values.

"Biological markers" and psychiatric diagnosis: risk-benefit balancing using ROC analysis

Although the clinical interview retains a central role in psychiatric diagnosis, recent research has suggested that "biological markers" may ultimately increase the precision of clinicians' nosologic and therapeutic decisions. Evaluating and operationalizing diagnostic tests require mathematical techniques that reflect the tests' essential features and limitations, and that guide clinicians in particular clinical situations. In this article we describe a technique that combines signal detection theory and utility-based decision theory, and apply the technique to published data in which sleep architecture was used as a biological marker for depression. We show how outcome utilities influence the optimum REM latency cut-off and show how this relationship is influenced by the prevalence of depression in the population being tested. We also make specific calculations of the practical limits that must be imposed on uncertainties in utilities to operationalize a diagnostic test for a specific clinical situation.

L-5-hydroxytryptophan stimulated cortisol escape from dexamethasone suppression in melancholic patients

The dexamethasone suppression test (DST) was carried out in 62 depressed patients. At 0800 the postdexamethasone cortisol values were determined and 125 mg L-5-hydroxytryptophan (L-5-HTP) was administered. The second cortisol sample at 0930 revealed a significant enhancing effect for L-5-HTP on the postdexamethasone cortisol values in melancholic patients, whereas no effects were detected in minor depressives. Our results show that L-5-HTP converts some DST suppressors into nonsuppressors, whereas the escape from dexamethasone in some nonsuppressors is markedly stimulated. The L-5-HTP-stimulated 0930 postdexamethasone cortisol values performed markedly better than the 0800 DST results: at a cut-off value of greater than or equal to 5 micrograms/dl the sensitivity for melancholia increased from 46% to 68%, and the specificity remained unchanged (96%).

Receiver operating characteristic analysis for validating EEG sleep discrimination of elderly depressed and demented patients

Receiver operating characteristic analysis is a useful tool in validating a diagnostic marker. This technique was applied to a discriminant function model using selected electroencephalographic sleep measures (sleep maintenance, percentage of rapid-eye-movement sleep, and percentage of indeterminate non-rapid-eye-movement sleep) in elderly patients with major depression or dementia of the Alzheimer type. The diagnostic model correctly classified 79.8% of elderly depressed and demented patients. The area under the curve was 0.86, statistically different from 0.5, which would be expected by chance (P less than .0001) and indicating good predictive power of the model. A logistic regression analysis demonstrated the reliability and stability of the diagnostic equation.

Biological heterogeneity of melancholia: results of pattern recognition methods

In this study, we have measured the following biological variables in 78 depressed inpatients: adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH) responses to corticotropin releasing factor (CRH: 100 micrograms intravenously), postdexamethasone cortisol and ACTH values, and circulating concentrations of L-tryptophan (L-TRP). Patients were categorized according to the DMS-III as (1) minor depression, (2) simple major depression, and (3) major depression with melancholia/psychotic features. By means of various pattern recognition methods, we determined whether these diagnostic groups constitute discrete biological classes or form relevant stages (i.e., continuous categories) in a continuum of progressing biological dysfunction. We established that unipolar depression constitutes one biological continuum characterized by a progression of lower CRH-induced ACTH responses, lower L-TRP levels, and higher postdexamethasone cortisol and ACTH values along the diagnostic spectrum. However, the biological differences in these markers between melancholia and minor depression are quantitatively prominent to the extent that they become qualitative. These findings support the biological heterogeneity hypothesis of melancholia. Simple major depression is a heterogeneous class with regard to the biological markers employed.

A revised interpretation of postdexamethasone ACTH and cortisol findings in unipolar depressed females

Baseline 8 a.m. adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) and cortisol levels and the postdexamethasone ACTH/cortisol values at 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. were determined in 86 depressed females diagnosed using DSM-III criteria. Postdexamethasone ACTH and cortisol values were significantly correlated with their baseline levels. We have shown that regression analysis should be used to assess dexamethasone-induced changes as the residual ACTH and cortisol responses, with the relative effects of the baseline data on the hormone responses being partialed out. The residual ACTH and cortisol values were significantly increased in the most severely depressed females as compared to minor depressives. The residual ACTH responses were markedly correlated with the residual cortisol responses. Cortisol nonsuppression during a depressive episode appeared to be determined by an augmented ACTH escape from dexamethasone suppression. The residual ACTH and cortisol responses could prove to be the most sensitive reflection of the disorder in the negative feedback by dexamethasone on the pituitary. In clinical practice, the ratio ln (postdexamethasone ACTH): ln (basal ACTH) can be used, since this ratio is linearly correlated with the residual ACTH responses.

Do serum dexamethasone levels improve the DST?

Some investigators have reported that dexamethasone suppression test (DST) accuracy might be improved by incorporating dexamethasone concentrations ([dex]) into test results. Using receiver operating characteristic methods, we evaluated data from four studies in which cortisol and dexamethasone levels were measured simultaneously at one or more times after drug ingestion. We compared DST accuracy using cortisol alone with various diagnostic indices incorporating [dex]. In none of the 21 comparisons did the [dex] factor enhance diagnostic performance.

Comorbidity in the interpretation of dexamethasone suppression test results in children: a review and report

The dexamethasone suppression test (DST) was administered as part of the initial clinical assessment to 83 children and adolescents who were consecutively referred for outpatient evaluation. All diagnoses were made clinically by a child psychiatrist according to DSM-III criteria. A weight-corrected dose of dexamethasone of 17 micrograms/kg was used. DSM-III diagnoses were made independent of DST results. Patients were stratified into four main diagnostic groups: major depressive disorder (MDD) (N = 27); attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADDH) (N = 22); major depressive disorder plus attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (MDD + ADDH) (N = 29); and psychiatric controls (PC) (N = 5). Rates of dexamethasone nonsuppression were found to be similarly elevated in children with MDD (29.6%), ADDH (22.7%), and MDD + ADDH (37.9%). All 5 psychiatric control patients had a normal postdexamethasone suppression (0%). A similar pattern of results emerged in a reexamination of the literature on available studies of DST in juveniles which revealed that children with major affective disorders, attention deficit disorder (ADDH), and anxiety disorders had comparable DST results that were significantly higher than the 5.6% rate found in normal controls. These findings provide further support for similarities in DST results between ADDH and MDD in outpatients. Although these results suggest a lack of specificity of the DST as a laboratory aid for the diagnosis of juvenile affective disorders, they are also consistent with findings indicating that the DST may be an index of clinical severity and other findings suggesting a possible association between ADDH and MDD. Despite its limitations, the DST may provide potentially useful clinical and research information regarding the pathophysiology of psychiatric disorders and in alerting clinicians to the presence of serious psychiatric disorders. The findings also stress the relevance of assessing comorbidity in interpreting DST results.

Optimizing REM latency as a diagnostic test for depression using receiver operating characteristic analysis and information theory

New diagnostic techniques must be evaluated for their intrinsic accuracy and for their applicability to particular patient groups in specific clinical settings. Using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis and concepts from information theory, we have developed a new mathematical and graphical method that can evaluate, compare, and optimize the performance of diagnostic tests for any value of disorder prevalence. Our analytic method is appropriate to any test that sorts disordered from nondisordered subjects using a continuous or nonbinary diagnostic variable; its characterization of the fundamental properties of such tests thus has important implications for the evaluation and optimization of diagnostic modalities used by clinicians in all medical specialties. We demonstrate our method using published data from five studies that used sleep architecture as a "biological marker" for depression. Our analysis confirms that REM latency is comparable to the dexamethasone suppression test in its ability to discriminate depressed from control subjects. For each of the five studies, we show how optimal REM latency cut-off times may be selected so that diagnostic information yield is maximized, and we compare the ability of each study to detect depressed subjects in populations where the prevalence of affective disorder can be specified.

Neuroendocrine aspects of primary endogenous depression: IX. Receiver operating characteristic analysis of the dexamethasone suppression index vs. the dexamethasone suppression test in patients and controls

The dexamethasone suppression index (DSI), which is the product of the postdexamethasone (DEX) serum DEX concentration and the post-DEX serum cortisol concentration, has been suggested to be a more sensitive discriminative test for depression than the standard DEX suppression test (DST). We used receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis to examine the DSI, calculated in several ways, versus the standard DST in a sample of 40 endogenous major depressives and 40 matched normal control subjects. The ROC analysis indicated that the DSI offers no advantage over the standard DST, regardless of which criterion values are used to define cortisol nonsuppression. Serum DEX determinations appear to have value primarily as an indicator of the minimum DEX concentration necessary for an accurate DST.

Evaluation and optimization of diagnostic tests using receiver operating characteristic analysis and information theory

We describe a mathematical technique and an associated computer program for comparing, evaluating and optimizing diagnostic tests. The technique combines receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis with information theory and cost-benefit analysis to accomplish this. The program is menu driven and highly interactive; it generates 13 possible user-determined ASCII disk files which can be easily converted to graphs. These graphs allow the user to make detailed comparisons among various diagnostic tests for all values of disorder prevalence, and also provide guidelines for cut-off selection in order to optimize tests. These techniques are applied to three published studies of the enzyme screening assay for diagnosis of infection with the HIV virus. We show how graphs produced by this program can be used to compare and optimize these diagnostic tests. The program is written for an IBM-compatible microcomputer running on a DOS operating system.