Chronic fatigue syndrome: the need for an integrative approach

COVID-19 and post-infectious myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: a narrative review

Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is a viral infection which can cause a variety of respiratory, gastrointestinal, and vascular symptoms. The acute illness phase generally lasts no more than 2-3 weeks. However, there is increasing evidence that a proportion of COVID-19 patients experience a prolonged convalescence and continue to have symptoms lasting several months after the initial infection. A variety of chronic symptoms have been reported including fatigue, dyspnea, myalgia, exercise intolerance, sleep disturbances, difficulty concentrating, anxiety, fever, headache, malaise, and vertigo. These symptoms are similar to those seen in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), a chronic multi-system illness characterized by profound fatigue, sleep disturbances, neurocognitive changes, orthostatic intolerance, and post-exertional malaise. ME/CFS symptoms are exacerbated by exercise or stress and occur in the absence of any significant clinical or laboratory findings. The pathology of ME/CFS is not known: it is thought to be multifactorial, resulting from the dysregulation of multiple systems in response to a particular trigger. Although not exclusively considered a post-infectious entity, ME/CFS has been associated with several infectious agents including Epstein-Barr Virus, Q fever, influenza, and other coronaviruses. There are important similarities between post-acute COVID-19 symptoms and ME/CFS. However, there is currently insufficient evidence to establish COVID-19 as an infectious trigger for ME/CFS. Further research is required to determine the natural history of this condition, as well as to define risk factors, prevalence, and possible interventional strategies.

The relationship of chronic fatigue to psychiatric illness in community, primary care and tertiary care samples

This paper reviews the psychiatric disorders associated with the symptom of fatigue in community, primary care and tertiary care samples. In each of these subsamples, studies using structured psychiatric interviews and operational diagnostic criteria are compared and contrasted. In summary, in community, primary care and tertiary care populations, there was a high association between the symptom of fatigue and affective and anxiety disorders. The prevalence rates of affective illness went up linearly in patients with fatigue as one moved from community to primary care and tertiary populations. The fact that fatigue is a common symptom in the community and is associated with significantly higher medical utilization when associated with affective and anxiety disorders may explain the increased association between this symptom and affective illness in primary and tertiary care.

Associations between neuroendocrine responses to the Insulin Tolerance Test and patient characteristics in chronic fatigue syndrome

OBJECTIVE

Subtle dysregulations of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis have been proposed as an underlying pathophysiological mechanism in chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). This study attempted to assess the relationship between patient characteristics and HPA axis functioning using a neuroendocrine challenge test.

METHOD

A test battery designed to assess different dimensions of CFS was given to 18 CFS patients and 17 controls. To evaluate the integrity of the HPA axis, the Insulin Tolerance Test (ITT), a centrally acting neuroendocrine challenge test, was performed on patients and controls. ACTH, salivary free cortisol and total plasma cortisol levels were assessed as a measure of the HPA axis stress response. Correlations of patient characteristics were calculated with integrated responses for all endocrine parameters.

RESULTS

CFS patients had a significantly reduced area under the ACTH response curve (AUC) in the ITT. The AUC was significantly associated with the duration of CFS symptoms (r = -.592, P = .005) and the severity of fatigue symptomatology (r = -.41, P = .045). In addition, duration of CFS was correlated with the severity of fatigue symptoms (r = .38, P = .045). Similar associations were not observed for cortisol parameters.

CONCLUSION

It has been postulated that neuroendocrine dysregulations observed in CFS are of an acquired nature. The results of a strong association between the integrated ACTH response and the duration of CFS emphasizes the need to consider factors known to be risk factors for the chronicity of CFS symptoms, such as profound inactivity, deconditioning and sleep abnormalities, as possible candidates for secondary causes of neuroendocrine dysregulations in CFS.

Sociosomatics and illness in chronic fatigue syndrome

OBJECTIVE

This study examines social processes that construct the course of chronic illness. Specifically, it identifies and describes mechanisms that constitute the process of role constriction in employment for individuals with chronic illness.

METHOD

Sixty-six persons meeting the Centers for Disease Control case definition of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) participated in a longitudinal study involving three waves of data collection over 3 years. Qualitative and quantitative methods were combined in the research, which included face-to-face semistructured interviews, telephone interviews, and self-report questionnaires. Materials presented in this study are drawn principally from the Year 1 face-to-face and telephone interviews.

RESULTS

When patterns of symptoms and of the illness course in CFS intersect with work requirements, they impede performance and place ill individuals at risk for job loss. Persons with CFS devise and implement specific strategies to resist role constriction and remain in the work force.

CONCLUSIONS

Role constriction is a social process of marginalization in chronic illness. Opposing forces of marginalization and resistance define the social course in chronic illness and suggest that chronicity can be thought of as a marginalized position in social space.

Antinuclear antibodies in children with chronic nonspecific complaints

Children who are chronically complaining nonspecific symptoms such as headache, fatigue, abdominal pain, and low grade fever are commonly seen in daily pediatric outpatient clinics. Some of them are unable to go to school and are diagnosed as school refusal by physicians or educational staff. On the other hand, there are children who do not fulfill any criteria of collagen diseases and whose anti-nuclear antibodies (ANA) are found to be positive. Some of these children have chronic nonspecific complaints. We prospectively studied the prevalence of ANA in children who visited a pediatric outpatient clinic because of chronic nonspecific complaints. Surprisingly, 74 out of 140 symptomatic children (52.4%) were positive for ANA, while only 5 out of 82 healthy control children (6.1%) were positive (p < 0.0001). 39 of 74 ANA positive patients (52.1%) have low ANA titers < or = 1:80, nevertheless 36 patients (47.9%) have high ANA titers > or = 1:160. ANA fluorescent patterns were homogeneous and speckled in 75.3%, speckled in 17.6% and others in 6.8%. ANA positive patients tended to have general fatigue and low grade fever, while gastrointestinal problems such as abdominal pain and diarrhea and orthostatic dysregulation symptoms were commonly seen in ANA negative patients. Children who were unable to go to school more than 1 day a week were seen significantly more in ANA positive patients than in negative patients. Autoantibody analysis using Western immunoblot revealed that 26 out of 63 ANA positive sera (41.3%) had antibodies to the 62 kD protein which had not been previously noticed. These data suggest that autoimmune mechanism may play a role in childhood chronic nonspecific symptoms. We therefore propose a new disease entity of the autoimmune fatigue syndrome in children. When chronically complaining children visit a pediatric out-patient clinic, immunological approaches should be considered before they are discriminated as school refusal or having psychogenic disorders.

Chronic fatigue syndrome. A practical guide to assessment and management

Chronic fatigue and chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) have become increasingly recognized as a common clinical problem, yet one that physicians often find difficult to manage. In this review we suggest a practical, pragmatic, evidence-based approach to the assessment and initial management of the patient whose presentation suggests this diagnosis. The basic principles are simple and for each aspect of management we point out both potential pitfalls and strategies to overcome them. The first, and most important task is to develop mutual trust and collaboration. The second is to complete an adequate assessment, the aim of which is either to make a diagnosis of CFS or to identify an alternative cause for the patient's symptoms. The history is most important and should include a detailed account of the symptoms, the associated disability, the choice of coping strategies, and importantly, the patient's own understanding of his/her illness. The assessment of possible comorbid psychiatric disorders such as depression or anxiety is mandatory. When the physician is satisfied that no alternative physical or psychiatric disorder can be found to explain symptoms, we suggest that a firm and positive diagnosis of CFS be made. The treatment of CFS requires that the patient is given a positive explanation of the cause of his symptoms, emphasizing the distinction among factors that may have predisposed them to develop the illness (lifestyle, work stress, personality), triggered the illness (viral infection, life events) and perpetuated the illness (cerebral dysfunction, sleep disorder, depression, inconsistent activity, and misunderstanding of the illness and fear of making it worse). Interventions are then aimed to overcoming these illness-perpetuating factors. The role of antidepressants remains uncertain but may be tried on a pragmatic basis. Other medications should be avoided. The only treatment strategies of proven efficacy are cognitive behavioral ones. The most important starting point is to promote a consistent pattern of activity, rest, and sleep, followed by a gradual return to normal activity; ongoing review of any 'catastrophic' misinterpretation of symptoms and the problem solving of current life difficulties. We regard chronic fatigue syndrome as important not only because it represents potentially treatable disability and suffering but also because it provides an example for the positive management of medically unexplained illness in general.

Chronic fatigue syndrome: sufferers' evaluation of medical support

In response to reports of negative cooperation between sufferers of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and their doctors, semi-structured interviews were conducted with sufferers from two different patient samples. Satisfaction with support received and with medical professionals in general was low. Sufferers complained about insufficient informational as well as emotional support from their doctors, and as a consequence most opted for alternative or complementary forms of treatment. In addition, disagreements over illness aetiology and treatment precluded effective cooperation. If satisfaction and compliance are to improve, sufferers will need more information about CFS and more support.

Neurobiology of chronic fatigue syndrome

1. Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is characterized by a new onset of significant fatigue for a period of six months or longer usually following an infection, injury or period of high stress. 2. The exact etiology of CFS is not known and a diagnostic test is not available. Hence, the diagnosis is made by exclusion of other explanations for the patient's symptoms and by meeting the CDC research case definitions. Early studies supported an infectious or immune dysregulation hypothesis for the pathophysiology of CFS. 3. Subsequent studies documented that neurological, affective and cognitive symptoms also occur at high rates in CFS patients. Neuropsychological, neuroendocrine studies and brain imaging have now confirmed the occurrence of neurobiological abnormalities in most patients with CFS. 4. In this article, the authors review these findings in relation to the clinical neurobiology of CFS and their potential relevance to biological psychiatry.

Can the chronic fatigue syndrome be defined by distinct clinical features?

To determine whether patients diagnosed as having chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) constitute a clinically homogeneous class, multivariate statistical analyses were used to derive symptom patterns and potential patient subclasses in 565 patients. The notion that patients currently diagnosed as having CFS constitute a single homogeneous class was rejected. An alternative set of clinical subgroups was derived. The validity of these subgroups was assessed by sociodemographic, psychiatric, immunological and illness behaviour variables. A two-class statistical solution was considered most coherent, with patients from the smaller class (27% of the sample) having clinical characteristics suggestive of somatoform disorders. The larger class (73% of sample) presented a more limited combination of fatigue and neuropsychological symptoms, and only moderate disability but remained heterogeneous clinically. The two patient groups differed with regard to duration of illness, spontaneous recovery, severity of current psychological morbidity, utilization of medical services and CD8 T cell subset counts. The distribution of symptoms among patients was not unimodal, supporting the notion that differences between the proposed subclasses were not due simply to differences in symptom severity. This study demonstrated clinical heterogeneity among patients currently diagnosed as CFS, suggesting aetiological heterogeneity. In the absence of discriminative clinical features, current consensus criteria do not necessarily reduce the heterogeneity of patients recruited to CFS research studies.

Coping with chronic fatigue syndrome: illness responses and their relationship with fatigue, functional impairment and emotional status

The implications of patients' approaches to managing chronic fatigue syndrome were examined in a cross-sectional study. With severity of fatigue controlled, attempting to maintain activity was associated with less functional impairment, while accommodating to the illness was positively related to impairment; behavioural disengagement was related not only to higher levels of impairment but also to greater emotional disturbance. Fatigue itself was positively associated with focusing on symptoms and with behavioural disengagement; it was associated also with illness accommodation, but only for illness of longer duration. The causal direction of relationships between coping and fatigue severity is ambiguous, and a follow-up study will address the effects of coping on changes in the illness over time.

Cell-mediated immune function and the outcome of chronic fatigue syndrome

This study examined the importance of cell-mediated immunity in determining the long-term outcome of patients diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome (CSF). A total of 103 patients (74%) of 139 previously enrolled in one of two treatment trials conducted within a university hospital referral center was reviewed a mean of 3.2 yr after trial entry. Ongoing symptom severity, levels of disability and immunological function were assessed at follow-up. The relationship between immunological function at trial entry and measures of outcome was also evaluated. Sixty-five patients (63%) had improved, while only 6 (6%) reported no current symptoms. Thirty-one subjects (30%) were unable to perform any form of work and 26 (25%) were on a disability benefit directly attributable to CFS. Cell-mediated immune function, as measured at trial entry or follow-up, did not appear to affect outcome. Whilst improvement occurred in the majority of patients with CFS, a substantial proportion (37%) remained functionally impaired. Impairment of cell-mediated immunological function measured during the course of the illness may not be an important factor in determining long-term outcome.

Physical symptoms of chronic fatigue syndrome are exacerbated by the stress of Hurricane Andrew

This study examined the effects of Hurricane Andrew on physical symptoms and functional impairments in a sample of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) patients residing in South Florida. In the months after Hurricane Andrew (September 15-December 31, 1992), 49 CFS patients were assessed for psychosocial and physical functioning with questionnaires, interviews, and physical examinations. This sample was made up of 25 CFS patients living in Dade county, a high impact area, and 24 patients in Broward and Palm Beach counties, areas less affected by the hurricane. Based on our model for stress-related effects on CFS, we tested the hypothesis that the patients who had the greatest exposure to this natural disaster would show the greatest exacerbation in CFS symptoms and related impairments in activities of daily living (illness burden). In support of this hypothesis, we found that the Dade county patients showed significant increases in physician-rated clinical relapses and exacerbations in frequency of several categories of self-reported CFS physical symptoms as compared to the Broward/Palm Beach county patients. Illness burden, as measured on the Sickness Impact Profile, also showed a significant increase in the Dade county patients. Although extent of disruption due to the storm was a significant factor in predicting relapse, the patient's posthurricane distress response was the single strongest predictor of the likelihood and severity of relapse and functional impairment. Additionally, optimism and social support were significantly associated with lower illness burden after the hurricane, above and beyond storm-related disruption and distress responses. These findings provide information on the impact of environmental stressors and psychosocial factors in the exacerbation of CFS symptoms.

The treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome: science and speculation

The chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is a heterogeneous disorder characterized by fatigue, neuropsychiatric symptoms, and various other somatic complaints. Treatment studies to date reflect both the diversity of medical disciplines involved in the management of patients with CFS and the multiple pathophysiologic mechanisms proposed. There have been few attempts to study integrated treatment programs, and although several controlled studies have been reported, no treatment has been shown clearly to result in long-term benefit in the majority of patients. Good clinical care integrating medical and psychologic concepts, together with symptomatic management, may prevent significant secondary impairment in the majority of patients. Future treatment studies should examine differential response rates for possible subtypes of the disorder (eg, documented viral onset, concurrent clinical depression), evaluate the extent of any synergistic effects between therapies (ie, medical and psychologic), and employ a wide range of biologic and psychologic parameters as markers of treatment response.

Professional and popular views of chronic fatigue syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To study the coverage of the chronic fatigue syndrome in the popular and professional press.

DESIGN

Search of all original research papers on the chronic fatigue syndrome published in British journals from 1980 onwards and of professional trade papers, national newspapers, and women's magazines. Interviews with six medical journalists.

SETTING

British scientific, medical, and popular press.

RESULTS

37 (49%) articles in research journals did not favour organic causes and 23 (31%) favoured organic causes. By contrast 31 (55%) articles in the medical trade press and 118 (69%) in national newspapers and women's magazines favoured organic causes.

CONCLUSIONS

Press coverage of chronic fatigue syndrome has amplified and distorted divisions in the research community concerning the chronic fatigue syndrome. Articles in the press concentrate on a simple medical model of illness reinforcing the stigma of psychological illness and dissatisfaction with traditional medical authority.

Seasonal symptom variation in patients with chronic fatigue: comparison with major mood disorders

The psychobiology of idiopathic fatigue has received renewed interest in the medical literature in recent years. In order to examine the relation between chronic, idiopathic fatigue and specific subtypes of depressive illness, we characterized the pattern and severity of seasonal symptom variation in 73 patients with chronic, idiopathic fatigue, compared to patients with major depression (n = 55), atypical depression (n = 35), and seasonal affective disorder (n = 16) Fifty of the fatigued subjects also met the specific Centers for Disease Control and Prevention case criteria for chronic fatigue syndrome, though this definition was unable to discriminate a distinct subgroup of patients, based on their seasonality scores alone. As a group, the fatigued subjects reported the lowest levels of symptom seasonality of any of the study groups. Further, even in those fatigued subjects with scores in the range of those seen in patients with seasonal affective disorder, seasonality was not reported to be a subjectively distressing problem. These findings lend support to the idea that although chronic fatigue shares some clinical features with certain mood disorders, they are not the same illnesses. These data are also consistent with the emerging view that chronic fatigue represents a heterogeneously determined clinical condition.