In vitro studies of the rabbit immune system. IV. Differential mitogen responses of isolated T and B cells

Determinants of the ability of malignant fibroma virus to induce immune dysfunction and tumor dissemination in vivo

The relationship of virus-induced immunological dysfunction and tumor dissemination was studied using two related tumor-causing leporipoxviruses: malignant fibroma virus (MV) and Shope fibroma virus (SFV). Recombinant viruses, produced by transferring MV's 10.7 kb BamHI C fragment to SFV, replicate in lymphocytes and suppress lymphocyte function in vitro. Those recombinants that replicate in lymphocytes and suppress lymphocyte function in vitro share about 3.5 kb from MV's C fragment. Some recombinants mimic MV in producing immune suppression and disseminated virus infection in vivo. Other recombinants, even some that are highly immunosuppressive in vitro (e.g. R71), only variably induce immune suppression in vivo, and do not cause disseminated disease. A segment of DNA from MV that transfers to Shope fibroma virus almost all of MV's virulence in vivo was identified.

Molecular signals in B cell activation. II. IL-2-mediated signals are required in late G1 for transition to S phase after ionomycin and PMA treatment

We report that sustained increase of intracellular calcium ion concentration and protein kinase C (PKC) activation maintained throughout the G1 phase of cell cycle do not provide sufficient signals to cause S-phase entry in rabbit B cells, and that additional signals transduced by IL-2 and IL-2 receptor interaction are essential for G1 to S transition. We have shown earlier that rabbit B cells can be activated to produce IL-2 and express functional IL-2 receptors after treatment with ionomycin and PMA. Herein we have compared the response of rabbit PBLs, which contain about 50% T cells, with those of purified B cells. After activation with ionomycin or PMA, comparable numbers of PBLs and B cells entered the cell cycle; but DNA synthesis by the PBL cultures was three to four times higher than that of cultures of purified B cells. Interestingly, IL-2 production by the PBL cultures was also three to four times higher than in B cell cultures, suggesting an involvement of IL-2 in inducing DNA synthesis in these cells. The hypothesis that IL-2, which is produced in early G1, acts in late G1 and is required for G1 to S transition in B cells was supported by the following observations: (i) IL-2 production by B cells was detected as early as 6 hr after activation and preceded DNA synthesis by at least 24 hr. (ii) B cell blasts in G1 (produced by treatment of resting B cells with ionomycin and PMA) showed DNA synthesis in response to IL-2, but showed very little DNA synthesis in response to restimulation with ionomycin and PMA. (iii) A polyclonal rabbit anti-human IL-2 antibody caused nearly complete inhibition of DNA synthesis by B cells activated by ionomycin and PMA. (iv) A PKC inhibitor, K252b, inhibited DNA synthesis in ionomycin and PMA-stimulated cells if added at the beginning of culture but was not inhibitory if added 16 hr later. We conclude that increased [Ca2+]i and PKC activation are not sufficient signals for G1 to S transition in B cells; entry into S is signaled by IL-2, and IL-2-mediated signal transduction probably does not involve increased [Ca2+]i or PKC activation.

DNA and immunoglobulin synthesis by rabbit peripheral blood lymphocytes in vitro: complete and incomplete stimulation

Activation of resting (G0) rabbit peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) into DNA synthesis and IgG synthesis was studied using sheep anti-rabbit IgG (SARIgG), protein A, pokeweed mitogen (PWM), and lipopolysaccharide (LPS). DNA synthesis was assayed by [125I]iododeoxyuridine incorporation. IgG synthesis was measured by determination of Ig in culture supernatants by an ELISA assay. Rabbit PBLs cultured with SARIgG or protein A for 48 hr and then without these reagents for 72 hr showed both DNA synthesis and Ig synthesis, whereas PWM and LPS had very little, if any, effect. PBLs stimulated with SARIgG for 6 hr and then without SARIgG for subsequent 114 hr did not become activated into DNA synthesis or IgG synthesis. However, PBLs prestimulated with SARIgG for 6 hr and then with PWM for 114 hr showed prominent DNA and IgG synthesis. LPS also maintained activation of PBLs after prestimulation of these cells with SARIgG, but the effect was much smaller than that of PWM. No evidence was found for production of factors by SARIgG-stimulated PBLs that could, by themselves, either stimulate resting cells or maintain activation of SARIgG-prestimulated cells. These results suggest that anti-IgG and protein A are complete activating mitogens for resting rabbit B cells to proliferate and differentiate into IgG-producing cells, whereas PWM and LPS are not able to activate G0 cells directly, but have a sustaining effect after activation of resting B cells with anti-IgG, either directly or via production of factors by accessory cells.

Growth of malignant rabbit fibroma virus in lymphoid cells

To understand better the immunosuppressive capacity of malignant rabbit fibroma virus (MV), we characterized MV growth in lymphoid cells. Replication of MV occurs in unstimulated normal spleen cells in vitro and is enhanced by adding T- or B-lymphocyte mitogens. In splenic T-lymphocyte preparations, comparable results are found: virus growth in the absence of mitogen, augmented by adding Con A. Unlike mature T cells, thymic lymphocytes support MV replication only when mitogen is added. When spleen cells from rabbits infected with MV in vivo are removed and cultured without mitogen, MV growth is again observed, with virus titer increasing about 10-fold per day of culture. In spleen cell populations from MV tumor-bearing rabbits, MV grows best in T lymphocytes, moderately in B lymphocytes, and least efficiently in adherent cells. When spleen cells are examined immediately following sacrifice, MV antigens are expressed solely on T lymphocytes from rabbits infected in vivo with MV 7 days previously. However, following overnight incubation in vitro a population of non-T lymphocytes displays cell membrane virus antigens. MV adapts itself somewhat to growth in lymphocytes, showing significantly greater growth in lymphocytes following passage in lymphocytes than is observed for non-lymphocyte-propagated virus. MV-infected lymphocytes also elaborate a factor that enhances MV growth in lymphocytes. Thus, MV replicates preferentially in mature T lymphocytes but will grow well in B cells as well. In vivo infection produces relatively small amounts of recoverable virus. However, when these lymphocytes are cultured in vitro virus replicates very well without added mitogens. These growth patterns may help to understand MV-induced immunologic dysfunction.

In vitro growth of two related leporipoxviruses in lymphoid cells

We examined the in vitro growth patterns of two leporipoxviruses, malignant rabbit fibroma virus (MV) and Shope fibroma virus (SFV), in lymphoid cells. MV replicates well in normal spleen cells in vitro. At low m.o.i. (0.001), dramatic virus growth occurs in unstimulated cell cultures. This growth is enhanced by addition of the T lymphocyte mitogen, concanavilin A, or the B lymphocyte mitogen, Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide. Shope fibroma virus does not grow in lymphocytes in culture, with or without mitogen stimulation. MV itself profoundly inhibits lymphocyte mitogenesis, while SFV does not. MV and SFV added to normal lymphocytes do not appear to alter their viability in culture. Thus, MV appears to be novel in its ability to replicate to high titer in resting lymphocytes. This growth pattern may be useful in understanding MV-induced immunologic dysfunction.

Mitogen-induced phosphorylation of cytosolic proteins in rabbit T- and B-lymphocytes

The addition of anti-immunoglobulin (anti-Ig) to purified rabbit B-cells or concanavalin A (Con A) to purified rabbit T-cells within minutes resulted in the phosphorylation of a number of cytosolic proteins. Two-dimensional (2-D) electrophoresis and autoradiography of 32P-labeled cell sonicates was used to identify proteins whose phosphorylation was enhanced by these mitogens. Two proteins, pp58 and pp90, were phosphorylated 1.5 min after addition of anti-Ig to B-cells. Four other proteins, pp60, pp65, pp67 and pp95, were phosphorylated at later times. Three of these proteins were also phosphorylated after addition of Con A to purified T-cells. These phosphoproteins do not correspond to any previously described cytoplasmic proteins. Although all of these phosphoproteins were present in the cytosolic fraction, pp58 may be associated with the cytoskeleton. Protein pp58 is also distinguished from the rest by its absence from 2-D gels run under non-reducing conditions. Treatment of the B-cells with F(ab')2 fragments of anti-Ig stimulated phosphorylation but Fab' fragments did not--indicating that receptor cross-linking is required to induce phosphorylation. Both pp58 and pp90 contained phosphoserine, but neither phosphothreonine nor phosphotyrosine. Quantitatively the 32P-labeling of pp58 was 2.7-fold over background at 10 min after anti-Ig addition. The identification of these phosphoproteins, which may play a role in activational cascades or in cytoskeletal rearrangements, hopefully will help to clarify the interrelationships between cyclic nucleotide dependent and independent kinases in lymphocyte activation.

Immunologic dysfunction during viral oncogenesis. II. Inhibition of cellular immunity to viral antigens by malignant rabbit fibroma virus

The ability of two related viruses--Shope fibroma virus (SFV) and malignant rabbit fibroma virus (MV)--to induce virus-specific immune responses in lymphocytes of recipient animals was studied. SFV produces a benign local tumor which regresses in 12-14 days. Using an assay for virus-induced lymphocyte blastogenesis lymphocytes reactive to SFV were detected, both in rabbits bearing SFV-induced tumors and in rabbits whose SFV-induced tumor had regressed. These virus-reactive cells were detected in peripheral blood and spleen, and in lymph nodes draining the primary tumor. In contrast, MV produces a disseminated tumor and eventual death. MV does not induce detectable blastogenic responses in lymphocyte populations. SFV and MV are antigenically cross reactive: rabbits immune to SFV do not develop MV-induced tumors, and antisera to each virus neutralize both equally. Lymphocytes from SFV-infected rabbits proliferate in vitro in response to MV that has been inactivated by ultraviolet light (uv/MV) but not to infectious MV. In contrast, lymphocytes from rabbits infected with MV do not respond to uv-inactivated MV or to SFV. Thus, infectious MV inhibits the development of normal blastogenic responses in vivo and prevents the expression of those responses in lymphocytes from MV-resistant, SFV-immune rabbits in vitro. The relevance of this impairment to the differences in the clinical courses of SFV- and MV-induced tumors is discussed.

Anti-immunoglobulin-induced proliferative response of rabbit lymphocytes in a serum-free medium

The aim of this study was to determine if rabbit lymphocytes were activated with a specific ligand, anti-immunoglobulin (anti-Ig) in a well-defined serum-free medium. A modified medium, composed of Neuman-Tytell (NT) basal medium supplemented with BSA, transferrin (Tf), and fatty acids (FA), was found to support a vigorous anti-Ig-induced proliferative response of rabbit lymphocytes. The optimal concentrations of BSA, Tf and FA supplements were determined for the mitogen-induced response. The mitogenesis was enhanced by addition of 2-mercaptoethanol. The proliferation could be maintained for 10 days provided cells received fresh medium and mitogen on day 5. The presence of anti-Ig throughout the culture period is required for this extended proliferation. The response did not require the Fc portion of the anti-Ig and was blocked by soluble rabbit F(ab')2 fragments. The anti-Ig-activated blasts lacked a T cell surface marker and about half of them re-expressed sIg when anti-Ig was washed out (assayed 24 h later). The viability of the mitogen-induced cells on day 5 was above 55%, whereas the viability of the cells without mitogen was 36%. The supplemented NT medium could also support Con A-induced mitogenesis of rabbit lymphocytes. Additionally, Con A- and LPS-stimulated murine lymphocytes showed considerable proliferation for up to 5 days in the supplemented NT medium.

Biphasic changes of the immunological reactivity in the course of experimental lectin-induced arthritis of rabbits

A single injection of Lens culinaris lectin (LcL) into the knee joint cavity of non-sensitized rabbits produces an arthritis with an acute and chronic phase, lasting up to one year. The persistence of the lectin in the joint, related to the strong binding affinity of lectins to glycoproteins of connective tissue structures, and the presence of specific antibodies against LcL in the serum after the intra-articular injection make this model comparable to the antigen-induced arthritis. But in our system these conditions are further modified or amplified by the mitogenic activity of LcL itself. The cell-mediated immunity, studied by mitogenic stimulation of peripheral blood lymphocytes, is characterized by a biphasic change in the course of this experimental arthritis. Hyperresponsiveness to stimulation with LcL and Concanavalin A (Con A), decreased Con A-induced suppressor cell activity, and stimulatory serum factors could be detected in the early phase of inflammation. The late phase of arthritis (8 months after the induction) was characterized by hyporesponsiveness to mitogenic stimulation, normal suppressor cell activity and inhibitory serum factors. In spite of the differences of this experimental arthritis to the human rheumatoid arthritis, concerning mainly the initiation and the lack of systemic manifestation, there are surprising similarities between both, not only in the histopathological feature and the chronicity but also in the cell-mediated immune reactions. Therefore, similar pathogenetic mechanisms for the chronic phase can be suggested.

In vivo studies of spleen lymphoid cells implicated in antitumor immunity in hamsters

Hamsters were immunized with repeated and progressive doses of strongly antigenic SV40-transformed cells (ZDCl25) and these animals rejected a tumor graft. According to the in vivo Winn test, spleen cells from such immunized animals could be used to transfer the antitumor immunity and protect naive recipients. To characterize the immune effector cells, different techniques of fractionation were used. In all cases the best protection was obtained by whole cell populations, even after reconstitution. The "T-depleted' fraction was more active than the T cell fraction. As shown by the treatment with specific antisera, part of the active population bore surface IgG. The protective activity could be the result of cooperation between different cell populations, one of which, unknown at present, could be the promotor of the transferred immunity and of the tumor neutralization effect.

Effects of anti-Ig reagents on T cell functions I. Activation of rabbit T cells by anti-allotype antibodies

Rabbit lymphocytes were analyzed by flow microfluorometry, using anti-T cell and anti-Ig reagents. Rabbit T cells and cells expressing surface Ig (B cells) appeared to belong to distinct subpopulations which could be separated on the basis of their selective adherence to nylon wool columns or to anti-Ig-coated dishes. Using flow microfluorometry, no evidence was obtained for the expression of a allotypes (VH framework) on T cells. Separated lymphocyte populations were functionally characterized using an in vitro proliferation assay. B and T cells from rabbit spleen or peripheral blood responded in a differential fashion to B and T cell-specific mitogens and to anti-Ig antibodies. Although such T cells did not respond upon stimulation with anti-Ig antibodies alone, significant proliferation could be induced by simultaneous addition of anti-Ig and T cell growth factor. In addition, activated T cells, derived from lymph nodes of immunized rabbits, generated a proliferative response upon stimulation with anti-Ig reagents alone. The above-mentioned effects on T cells could be obtained using heterologous anti-Ig antibodies or isologous anti-allotype antibodies, directed either against a allotypes (VH framework) or against b allotypes (kappa light chain). Antibodies against the Fc portion of rabbit Ig or against irrelevant allotypic specificities were ineffective in triggering T cells. Fab fragments from anti-allotype antibodies were equally stimulatory for T cells as compared to intact IgG, indicating that cross-linking of Ig-like molecules is not a necessary requirement for anti-Ig-induced T cell activation.

Proliferative responses of rabbit lymphocytes to Pasteurella multocida decrease with prolonged immunization

Peripheral blood and splenic lymphocytes from rabbits immunized with Pasteurella multocida by various schedules were stimulated to undergo blast transformation in vitro in response to this antigen. Repeated immunizations suppressed this response.

Serum regulation of in vitro lymphocyte responses in early experimental syphilis

Sera from rabbits with early experimental syphilis were tested for their effect on in vitro lymphocyte transformation responses to related specific antigens (sonicated T. pallidum), unrelated specific antigens (sheep erythrocytes), and the T cell mitogen, concanavalin A. Results were compared with responses in preinfection sera and in sera from sham-infected rabbits. Titration experiments in which normal serum was used indicated that optimal lymphocyte responsiveness is obtained with a final serum concentration of 1%. Under these conditions, no differences in concanavalin A stimulation were observed in cultures with syphilitic sera. Responses to sonicated T. pallidum were inhibited, but only by 17 to 25% when compared with the response in preinfection sera. In cultures containing 10% serum, inhibition of lymphocyte proliferation to sonicated T. pallidum antigens was evident with sera from all syphilitic animals from day 10 (55% inhibition) through day 31 (80% inhibition) of infection. Responses to concanavalin A and sheep erythrocytes were significantly inhibited by day 10 sera; only 20% of the sera tested demonstrated substantial nonspecific inhibitory capacity. No differences were evident among sera from any of the sham-infected animals or among the preinfection sera from either group. Pooled serum with high inhibitory activity was fractionated by ammonium sulfate precipitation, DEAE ion exchange chromatography, and Sephadex G-200 gel filtration. Two separate inhibitors were identified: (i) a low-molecular-weight, ammonium sulfate-soluble, nonspecific inhibitory fraction containing albumin and alpha-globulins with the capacity to inhibit both antigen and mitogen responses and (ii) a high-molecular-weight, ammonium sulfate-precipitable, inhibitory fraction containing alpha-globulin and FTA-ABS-reactive immunoglobulin M which affected only the antigen-specific response to sonicated T. pallidum. Immunodiffusion failed to detect immunoglobulin or T. pallidum antigens in either fraction. DEAE-purified immunoglobulin G from immune serum was not inhibitory.

Immunity to homologous type III collagen after partial meniscectomy and sham surgery in rabbits

Cellular immunity to rabbit types I, II, and III collagen was detected after both partial medial meniscectomy and sham operation in rabbits when an in vitro 3H-thymidine incorporation assay was used. The blastogenic responses were commonly directed towards peptides derived from collagens by cyanogen bromide cleavage used to mimic proteinase degradation products. The responses to type III collagen peptides were by far the strongest and were seen in most rabbits that were operated on. We suggest that the responses to types I and II collagen were caused by a cross-reaction with type III collagen peptides. This conclusion was supported by the observation that spleen cells from rabbits directly immunized with homologous type III collagen peptides in Freund's complete adjuvant responded strongly to the immunizing peptides and also cross-reacted with types I and II collagen peptides. Immunity to cartilage proteoglycans was observed primarily in rabbits that had undergone meniscectomy and had severe cartilage degeneration. These results indicated that immunity to collagens will develop merely as a result of joint surgery, whereas immunity to proteoglycans is largely dependent upon an osteoarthritic lesion.

Age-related changes in the antigenicity of human articular cartilage proteoglycans

Rabbits were immunized with adult or foetal human articular cartilage proteoglycans and cell-mediated and antibody immunity assessed in vitro. Cellular immunity to proteoglycans of different ages was measured by the stimulation of 3H-thymidine incorporation into cultured spleen cells. Antibodies to proteoglycans in the rabbit sera were detected with an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The ability of adult and foetal proteoglycans to preabsorb antibody activity in this assay was compared. The results from both the cellular and antibody studies support the same conclusion, that adult proteoglycans express all foetal antigenic determinants and have additional determinants not seen on foetal proteoglycans. The reactivity of rabbit spleen cells to proteoglycans of different ages indicated that these determinants appear during maturation when the major changes in proteoglycan structure occur. The results did not appear to be due to differences in chondroitin sulphate content of the preparations, since the same observations were made with chondroitinase ABC-digested proteoglycans. The observations might be explained by other differences in glycosylation between the preparations or by postulating the synthesis during maturation of an additional proteoglycan species with a different core-protein. Such changes in the antigenicity of articular cartilage proteoglycans with age could account for the development of autoimmunity to proteoglycans in inflammatory joint diseases and may play a role in their pathogenesis.

Host response to Treponema pallidum in intradermally-infected rabbits: evidence for persistence of infection at local and distant sites

Intradermal infection of rabbits with Treponema pallidum imitiates rapid and active cellular response at the site of injection. During the first 2 weeks following infection, there is a marked increase in the numbers of organisms at the site of infection. Systemic dissemination of treponemes occurs during the early stage of infection, presumably before the immune response is fully mobilized. The mononuclear infiltration, which is apparent at the lesion site one week postinfection, becomes more pronounced at 2 weeks. The infiltrating cells are predominantly T lymphocytes and macrophages. By 4 weeks postinfection, most of the organisms have been cleared from the primary site; however, low numbers of treponemes survive locally and in distant tissues. Thus, whereas infection with T. pallidum appears to activate immune mechanisms which are capable of clearing most of the organisms from the primary lesion, some organisms are able to evade these mechanisms and persist in vivo.

Antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity and mitogen responsiveness of human peripheral blood lymphocytes differing in avidity for sheep erythrocytes

To characterize the effector cells (K-cells) in antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against a nucleated target cell (El 4), human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were fractionated by rosette sedimentation into subpopulations differing in avidity for sheep erythrocytes (E). The fractions obtained were assayed for surface markers, and as a functional T cell marker, for responsiveness to the mitogen leucoagglutinin (La). By depleting PBL of E-receptor-bearing cells (Et+), approximately half of the cytotoxic potential was found in the Et-depleted fraction. While the Et+ fraction had low activity on a per cell basis, it nevertheless contained a significant proportion of the original cytotoxicity. By sequential E-rosetting, fractions binding E with high avidity (Et+), low avidity (Et+) or not at all (E-) were obtained. Both E-binding fractions consisted primarily of T-cells, as judged from their surface marker profiles. Both fractions responded well to La, but with different dose optima. The E- fraction contained primarily B-and null cells and did not respond to La. Significant K-cell activity was found in all these fractions. The results show that a significant fraction of the K-cells have receptors for E and these can be of either high or low avidity. Since both EH+ and EL+ fractions respond well to La and contain K-cells, a T-cell origin of the latter is suggested. However, whether or not cytotoxicity and La-responsiveness are functions of the same cells remains to be established.

Surface Ig on rabbit lymphocytes. Rabbit B and T cells are distinct populations

Rabbit peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were analyzed by immunofluorescence using anti-T cell conjugates and anti-Fab, anti-a1 allotype, anti-IgM and anti-IgA conjugates. In addition, T cells were demonstrated by rosetting with papain-treated homologous erythrocytes. Control experiments, using acid treatment and incubation at 37 degrees C for 18 h after or without pronase treatment, revealed the endogenous origin of all surface determinants tested. A good correlation was found between results obtained with the two anti-T cell conjugates used and the T rosette test on PBL and on lymphoid cells isolated from various organs. In lymphocytes isolated from peripheral blood and from various lymphoid organs, the percentages of T and B cells were respectively 45 and 38 for PBL, 10 and 46 for bone marrow, 27 and 31 for appendix, 40 and 45 for spleen, 42 and 46 for Peyer's patches, 96 and 0.3 for thymus and 70 and 16 for peripheral lymph nodes. The percentage of "null" cells in lymphocyte populations derived from bone marrow and appendix is rather high. The final percentages of T and B cells in rabbit PBL depend to a significant extent on the method of isolation, especially isolation by Ficoll-Hypaque centrifugation results in a depletion of T cells. Moreover, a rather impure lymphoid cell suspension is obtained. In double incubation experiments, T cells (as defined by T cell antigen(s) or rosette formation) and B cells (Fab-bearing cells) were entirely different subpopulations. Allotypes of the a locus could not be detected on the surface of T cells. The results are discussed with respect to genetic coding of antigen receptors on B and T cells.

Artefactual variations in the B and T subpopulations of rabbit blood lymphocytes depending on method of isolation, and blocking of C3 receptors due to in vitro activation of complement

Marked differences were found in the proportions of lymphocyte subpopulations in rabbit peripheral blood depending on the techniques used for the purification of lymphocytes. Rosette-forming reactions were used to find the numbers of T lymphocytes, Ig-bearing cells and cells with receptors for C3 or IgG-Fc. Some of the methods used for lymphocyte separation altered the relative numbers of T and B lymphocytes, through a disproportionate loss of T cells. Other changes were due to in vitro activation of complement detectable by the presence of C3 on the lymphocyte cell-membrane and causing partial blocking of C3 receptors. Highest yields of lymphocytes were obtained from defibrinated blood treated with carbonyl iron to remove phagocytes and methyl cellulose to sediment erythrocytes. This procedure was accompanied by in vitro activation of complement, with the consequences mentioned. Complement activation was inhibited by taking the blood into either EDTA or citrate. As EDTA was cytotoxic for rabbit T lymphocytes, citrate was considered best although the resulting lymphocyte suspensions were contaminated with up to 25% granulocytes and monocytes owing to the inhibition of carbonyl iron uptake by the prior exposure to citrate.