Nitrous acid mutagenesis of duplex DNA as a three-component system

2 Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Butylated Hydroxyanisole

Butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) is used in cosmetic formulations as a chemical preservative and as an antioxidant. Both animal and human studies have shown that BHA is absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract and metabolized. Tissue storage may occur with BHA because of its lipid solubility. However, the amount stored is limited by rapid metabolism and excretion. Reported acute oral LD50 values for BHA in rats varied from 2.0 to > 5.0 g/kg. Formulations containing BHA elicited, at most, minimal or moderate skin and eye irritation in rabbits. An extensive number of subchronic and chronic oral studies have been conducted and are reviewed.

BHA given orally or parenterally to mice and rats was shown to inhibit the carcinogenic effects of a broad range of chemical carcinogens. BHA has been shown to inhibit mutagenesis and was not a mutagenic agent in standard in vitro tests. No evidence of carcinogenicity was observed when BHA was administered to mice by subcutaneous injection, by intraperitoneal injection, or by topical application. No carcinogenesis was demonstrated following dietary administration of BHA to either rats or dogs. An increased incidence of forestomach papillomas and squamous cell carcinomas has been observed in rats fed BHA. Studies with pregnant rabbits, mice, rats, and hamsters receiving BHA during gestation by a variety of oral dosage regimens revealed no significant embryotoxic or teratogenic effects.

Clinical data for BHA in cosmetic formulations indicated that they were generally nonsensitizing, nonphotosensitizing, and only minimally or mildly irritating. It is concluded that BHA is safe as a cosmetic ingredient in the present practices of use.

Toxicity of hexamethylenediamine

Hexamethylendiamine (HMDA; CAS No. 124-09-4; 6055-52-3 for the dihydrochloride salt) is moderately toxic following acute doses/exposures with oral lethal doses in rats ranging from 750 to 1500 mg/kg. HMDA is extremely irritating to the skin and eyes and is not a sensitizer in guinea pigs. Repeated exposure inhalation studies have defined the upper respiratory tract to be the first target of HMDA. The irritation seen is proportional to the exposure concentration. Systemic damage is limited. Genetic testing is not extensive, but there is no indication of activity. HMDA is neither a developmental nor a reproductive toxin, but in one developmental study, the fetal No-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) was lower than that of the maternal animal. No carcinogenicity studies have been conducted. Documented human experience is limited, but indications of HMDA's irritative properties are found in the literature. HMDA does not persist or bioaccumulate in the environment. The chemical is not particularly toxic to fish and aquatic invertebrates but is quite toxic to algae. HMDA is rapidly absorbed and metabolized by the rat with little tissue storage.

Nitrate, nitrite and N-nitroso compounds

A risk assessment has been made on nitrate, nitrite and N-nitroso compounds encountered in the human diet. Vegetables constitute a major source of nitrate providing over 85% of the average daily human dietary intake. Nitrite and N-nitroso compounds present in the diet contribute relatively small amounts to the body burden and the major source of these biologically reactive compounds is derived from the bacterial and mammalian metabolism of ingested nitrate. Additionally, endogenous synthesis provides an important source contributing to the body burden of nitrate. Data from animal toxicological studies, human effects and epidemiological surveys have been reviewed and evaluated. It is concluded that there is no firm scientific evidence at present to recommend drastic reductions beyond the average levels of nitrate encountered in vegetables grown in keeping with good agricultural practice. Recommendations have also been made for further animal and human studies to be carried out to elucidate the potential risks to man from ingested nitrate.

Nitrite-induced mutations in a forward mutation assay: influence of nitrite concentration and pH

The mutagenicity of sodium nitrite at three pHs (7.4, 6.4 and 5.4) has been investigated by treating a shuttle vector plasmid in vitro and assaying for mutations within the supF target gene following replication of the damaged plasmid in human Ad293 cells. Mutation frequency increased with increasing nitrite concentration and decreasing pH. Among treatments from which a significant number of mutants could be collected, the most commonly induced mutations were GC-->AT transitions (44-56% of total mutations), followed by GC-->TA transversions (24-30%). The types of mutations induced at different nitrite concentrations and different pH's were similar, though some differences in their distribution throughout the supF gene were noted. These results provide information on the types of mutations that may be produced following the processing of nitrite-induced DNA damage in human cells.

Molecular models that may account for nitrous acid mutagenesis in organisms containing double-stranded DNA

Nitrous acid (NA) is often presumed to cause base substitutions in organisms with double-stranded DNA as a direct consequence of oxidative deamination of adenine and of cytosine residues. Here we summarize evidence indicating that other mechanisms are involved in the case of NA-induced G/C-->A/T transition mutations. We present several models for pathways of NA mutagenesis that may account for our experimental results and overlapping data noted in the literature. One model proposes that the base substitution mutations observed are due to DNA alkylation damage mediated via nitrosation of polyamines and/or other ubiquitous cellular molecules. Other models assume that predisposing lesions, such as G-to-G cross-links, are first formed. The cross-links are pictured as leading to perturbations in DNA structure that allow subsequent opportunity for NA-induced deaminations of cytosine residues in their immediate vicinity. The deaminations preferentially result in G/C-->A/T transition mutations at sites highly dependent on adjoining base sequence context (i.e., in NA "mutational hotspots"). A final model proposes that NA-induced G/C-->A/T transition mutations arise mainly from oxidative deamination of guanosine residues and not from deamination of cytosine residues in duplex DNA.

Nitrates, nitrites and N-nitrosocompounds: a review of the occurrence in food and diet and the toxicological implications

Data on occurrence of nitrate, nitrite and N-nitrosocompounds in food and drinking water, and on total dietary intakes are reviewed. Metabolic, toxicological and epidemiological studies are surveyed and the implications with respect to safety evaluation are addressed. It is concluded that, on the basis of recent long-term animal studies and of clinical experience in man, the current Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) allocated to nitrate by the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives of 0-5 mg/kg body weight/day (expressed as sodium nitrate) might be increased to 0-25 mg/kg body weight/day. Based on similar criteria, the ADI for nitrite would be 0-0.1 mg/kg body weight/day (expressed as sodium nitrite). In view of the known carcinogenicity of N-nitrosocompounds, exposure to these compounds in food should be minimized by appropriate technological means, such as lowering the nitrite concentration in preserved foods to the minimum required to ensure microbiological safety and use of inhibitors of nitrosation like alpha-tocopherol or ascorbic acid. Further work is needed to define the minimal levels of nitrite in foods needed to inhibit outgrowth of Clostridium botulinum and toxin production.

Synthetic antioxidants: biochemical actions and interference with radiation, toxic compounds, chemical mutagens and chemical carcinogens

Biological actions of 4 commonly used synthetic antioxidants--butylated hydroxyanisole, butylated hydroxytoluene, ethoxyquin and propyl gallate--on the molecular, cellular and organ level are complied. Such actions may be divided into modulation of growth, macromolecule synthesis and differentiation, modulation of immune response, interference with oxygen activation and miscellaneous. Moreover, an overview of beneficial and adverse interactions of these antioxidants with exogenous noxae is given. Beneficial interactions include radioprotection, protection against acute toxicity of chemicals, antimutagenic activity and antitumorigenic action. Possible mechanisms of the antitumorigenic action of antioxidants are discussed. This discussion is centered around antioxidant properties which may contribute to a modulation of initiation-related events, especially their ability to interfere with carcinogen metabolism. The beneficial interactions of antioxidants with physical and chemical noxae are contrasted to those leading to unfavorable effects. These include radiosensitization, increased toxicity of other chemicals, increased mutagen activity and increased tumor yield from chemical carcinogens. At present, the latter one can most adequately be characterized as tumor promotion at least in the case of butylated hydroxytoluene. It is concluded that current information is insufficient to promote expectations as to the use of antioxidants in the prevention of human cancer.

The bacterial mutagenicity of three naturally occurring indoles after reaction with nitrous acid

Three naturally occurring indoles were evaluated for potential nitrosatability using the Nitrosation Assay Procedure (NAP test) as recommended by the World Health Organisation. All three indoles i.e. tryptophan, tryptamine and 5-hydroxy-tryptamine were nitrosated to products which were directly mutagenic for S. typhimurium TA1537. In addition, the products of nitrosation of tryptamine and 5-hydroxytryptamine were also mutagenic for strains TA1538, TA98 and TA1535 without the need for metabolic activation. The sensitivities of the frameshift-detecting strains TA1537, TA1538 and TA98 were of particular interest, since nitroso compounds are characteristically base-substitution mutagens. The mutagenic effects of the products formed after nitrosation of each indole at pH 3.6, were eliminated in the presence of S9 mix. This was not the case when the nitrosation assay was carried out at pH 2.6. At this pH the mutagenicity of the nitrosated products varied in the presence of S9 mix and depended upon the nature of the indole undergoing nitrosation, and the bacterial test strain utilised for the mutagenicity assay. This indicated that more than one mutagenic product was responsible for the observed effects. As well as pH, a number of other factors influenced the formation of mutagenic nitroso products. Most notably, the concentrations of precursor compounds (sodium nitrite, and indole) present in the NAP test were of critical importance. As the sodium nitrite concentration was reduced from that recommended by the W.H.O. (40 mM), so the mutagenicity decreased. For all three compounds significant mutagenic effects were lost at sodium nitrite concentrations below 15 mM. In conclusion the data presented in this paper clearly demonstrates that individuals are chronically exposed to naturally occurring substances which readily nitrosate in excess nitrous acid and yield bacterial mutagens.

Review: putative mutagens and carcinogens in foods. III. Butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT)

Although the average American's daily consumption of BHT can be measured in milligrams, there are numerous reports that BHT causes organ damage in laboratory animals. Only a few genotoxic effects of BHT have been reported, however, including mutagenicity in the abnormal sperm assay and ambiguous results regarding its teratogenicity. More dramatic are the modulatory effects of BHT on the actions of established mutagens and carcinogens. BHT can either enhance or inhibit mutagenic potency, depending on the substance tested. For example, in the Ames test, BHT is antimutagenic towards benzo(a)pyrene, but increases the number of Salmonella revertants induced by aflatoxin B1. BHT is one of the few compounds to have both tumor prophylactic and tumor promoting capacities. It is the temporal sequence in which BHT and carcinogens are administered to test animals which determines how BHT affects the response to these carcinogens. In common with other antioxidants, BHT inhibits the ability of carcinogens to induce tumors in various rodent organs when the animal is given BHT prior to carcinogen treatment. Unlike other antioxidants, however, the number of tumors increase when BHT is administered after carcinogen exposure. The comutagenic and cocarcinogenic properties of BHT have been demonstrated in tests ranging from the Ames test to cell transformation procedures to in vivo assays. These effects are probably mediated by metabolites of BHT, rather than by BHT itself.

Use of nitrous acid-dependent decrease in mutagenicity as an indication of the presence of mutagenic primary aromatic amines. Non-specific reactions with phenols and benzo[alpha]pyrene

Treatment of mutagenic primary aromatic amines with nitrous acid is known to decrease their mutagenicity. We examined some factors concerning the validity of using decreases in mutagenicity due to nitrous acid treatment as an indication of the presence of mutagenic primary aromatic amines in complex mixtures. We found that treatment of benzo[alpha]pyrene with nitrous acid for the extended periods of time previously employed leads to formation of three nitrobenzo[alpha]pyrene isomers. Some of the isomers are direct-acting mutagens for S. typhimurium with considerably greater mutagenicity than benzo[alpha]pyrene isomers. In attempts to minimize reaction of chemicals other than aromatic amines, we found that only very brief reaction periods are required for complete reaction of nitrous acid with representative aromatic amines, essentially eliminating their mutagenicity. During such brief reaction periods modification of benzo[alpha]pyrene is negligible, but phenols react readily. Chromatographic analysis indicated that reaction of nitrous acid with aromatic amines leads to the formation of families of products, thereby increasing the complexity of the mixtures in which the amines may occur. Thus, experiments examining the effects of nitrous acid on the mutagenic activity of complex mixtures must be carefully designed, and the results must be interpreted cautiously.

Method for induction of mutations in physically defined regions of the herpes simplex virus genome

A procedure was developed for inducing mutations in isolated restriction enzyme fragments of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) DNA with nitrous acid. The mutations were then transferred to the viral genome by genetic recombination during cotransfection of rabbit kidney cells with the mutagenized fragments and intact HSV-1 DNA. The HpaI restriction enzyme fragments LD, B, LG, I, and J were mutagenized. Temperature-sensitive mutants were found at frequencies of 1 to 5% among the progeny of the transfections. Syncytial mutants also were found at high frequency when fragment B or LD was used for mutagenesis. Fifteen of these mutants, 11 temperature sensitive and 4 syncytial, were used for further studies, including complementation analysis, DNA synthesis, and marker rescue. Marker rescue data presented here and in the accompanying publication (A. L. Goldin, R. M. Sandri-Goldin, M. Levine, and J. C. Glorioso, J. Virol. 38: 50-58, 1981) confirm the map position of some of the newly isolated mutants.

Interaction of mutagenic spermidine-nitrous acid reaction products with uvr- and recA-dependent repair systems in Salmonella

It has been observed previously that the mutagenic action of nitrous acid may be potentiated by polyamines. We examined the cellular response of two deoxyribonucleic acid repair systems to treatment with spermidine-nitrite reaction products. uvrB- deficient mutants of Salmonella typhimurium LT2 showed enhanced lethal and mutagenic response to the reaction products. Lethal activity was further enhanced in a uvrB recA double mutant, whereas mutagenic activity was not detectable. Dependence of mutagenesis on the recA gene implicates the action of an error-prone repair system in the fixation of a premutagenic lesion as a mutation. From consideration of the substrate characteristics of the two repair systems studied, it is suggested that the deoxyribonucleic acid lesion formed by the reaction products of spermidine and nitrite is an intrastrand cross-link.

Nitrous acid damage to duplex deoxyribonucleic acid: distinction between deamination of cytosine residues and a novel mutational lesion

The rate of nitrous acid deamination of labeled cytosine residues in native Escherichia coli deoxyribonucleic acid was monitored in vitro by release of acid-soluble counts after treatment with uracil deoxyribonucleic acid glycosylase. The reaction exhibited a lag and was not stimulate by several agents previously shown to enhance base substitution mutagenesis during nitrous acid treatment of duplex deoxyribonucleic acid. We conclude that a significant proportion of nitrous acid induced mutagenic lesions are novel lesions and not cytosine deaminations.

Aryl-monoalkyl and cyclic triazenes: direct-acting mutagens

An aryl-monoalkyl triazene, methyl-p-tolyl triazene (MTT) and a cyclic triazene (delta2-triazoline) are direct-acting mutagens for Salmonella typhimurium bacteria and for cell-free Hemophilus influenzae DNA. MTT causes reversion of the hisG46 base-substitution mutation, but no reversion of the hisD3052 frameshift mutation. Induced mutation frequency is not strongly influenced by modifications in the genetic background of the S. typhimurium Ames tester strains, but is mildly enhanced by the addition of a pool of amino acids to the plating medium and is strongly enhanced by liquid preincubation before plating.