On the genesis of incomplete Sendai virions

Defective viral genomes: advances in understanding their generation, function, and impact on infection outcomes

Defective viral genomes (DVGs) are truncated derivatives of their parental viral genomes generated during an aberrant round of viral genomic replication. Distinct classes of DVGs have been identified in most families of both positive- and negative-sense RNA viruses. Importantly, DVGs have been detected in clinical samples from virally infected individuals and an emerging body of association studies implicates DVGs in shaping the severity of disease caused by viral infections in humans. Consequently, there is growing interest in understanding the molecular mechanisms of de novo DVG generation, how DVGs interact with the innate immune system, and harnessing DVGs as novel therapeutics and vaccine adjuvants to attenuate viral pathogenesis. This minireview focuses on single-stranded RNA viruses (excluding retroviridae), and summarizes the current knowledge of DVG generation, the functions and diversity of DVG species, the roles DVGs play in influencing disease progression, and their application as antivirals and vaccine adjuvants.

Defective Interfering Particles of Negative-Strand RNA Viruses

Viral defective interfering particles (DIPs) were intensely studied several decades ago but research waned leaving open many critical questions. New technologies and other advances led to a resurgence in DIP studies for negative-strand RNA viruses. While DIPs have long been recognized, their exact contribution to the outcome of acute or persistent viral infections has remained elusive. Recent studies have identified defective viral genomes (DVGs) in human infections, including respiratory syncytial virus and influenza, and growing evidence indicates that DVGs influence disease severity and may contribute to viral persistence. Further, several studies have advanced our understanding of key viral and host factors that regulate DIP formation and activity. Here we review these discoveries and highlight key questions moving forward.

A specific sequence in the genome of respiratory syncytial virus regulates the generation of copy-back defective viral genomes

Defective viral genomes of the copy-back type (cbDVGs) are the primary initiators of the antiviral immune response during infection with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) both in vitro and in vivo. However, the mechanism governing cbDVG generation remains unknown, thereby limiting our ability to manipulate cbDVG content in order to modulate the host response to infection. Here we report a specific genomic signal that mediates the generation of a subset of RSV cbDVG species. Using a customized bioinformatics tool, we identified regions in the RSV genome frequently used to generate cbDVGs during infection. We then created a minigenome system to validate the function of one of these sequences and to determine if specific nucleotides were essential for cbDVG generation at that position. Further, we created a recombinant virus unable to produce a subset of cbDVGs due to mutations introduced in this sequence. The identified sequence was also found as a site for cbDVG generation during natural RSV infections, and common cbDVGs originated at this sequence were found among samples from various infected patients. These data demonstrate that sequences encoded in the viral genome determine the location of cbDVG formation and, therefore, the generation of cbDVGs is not a stochastic process. These findings open the possibility of genetically manipulating cbDVG formation to modulate infection outcome.

Defective (interfering) viral genomes re-explored: impact on antiviral immunity and virus persistence

Defective viral genomes (DVGs) are natural products of virus replication that occur in many positive and negative sense RNA viruses, including Ebola, dengue and respiratory syncytial virus. DVGs, which have severe genomic truncations and require a helper virus to replicate, have three well-described functions: interference with standard virus replication, immunostimulation, and establishment of virus persistence. These functions of DVGs were first described almost 50 years ago, yet only recent studies have shown the molecular intersection between their immunostimulatory and pro-persistence activities. Here, we review more than half a century of scientific literature on the immunostimulatory and pro-persistence functions of DVGs. We highlight recent advances in the field and the critical role DVGs have in both the acute and long-term virus-host interactions.

Evidence that Receptor Destruction by the Sendai Virus Hemagglutinin-Neuraminidase Protein Is Responsible for Homologous Interference

Receptor destruction has been considered one of the mechanisms of homologous Sendai virus (SeV) interference. However, direct evidence of receptor destruction upon virus infection and its relevance to interference is missing. To investigate a precise mechanism of homologous interference, we established SeV persistently infected cells. The persistently infected cells inhibited superinfection by homologous SeV but supported replication of human parainfluenza virus 2 (hPIV2) and influenza A virus (IAV). We confirmed that SeV particles could not attach to or penetrate the infected cells and that the hemagglutinin-neuraminidase (HN) protein of SeV was involved in the interference. Lectin blot assays showed that the α2,3-linked sialic acids were specifically reduced in the SeV-infected cells, but the level of α2,6-linked sialic acids had not changed. As infection with IAV removed both α2,3- and α2,6-linked sialic acids, especially α2,3-linked sialic acids, IAV-infected cells inhibited superinfection of SeV. These results provide concrete evidence that destruction of the specific SeV receptor, α2,3-linked sialic acids, is relevant to homologous interference by SeV.

IMPORTANCE

Viral interference is a classically observed phenomenon, but the precise mechanism is not clear. Using SeV interference, we provide concrete evidence that reduction of the α2,3-linked sialic acid receptor by the HN of SeV is closely related with viral interference. Since SeV infection resulted in decrease of only α2,3-linked sialic acids, IAV, which also utilized α2,6-linked sialic acids to initiate infection, superinfected the SeV-infected cells. In contrast, SeV could not superinfect the IAV-infected cells because both α2,3- and α2,6-linked sialic acids were removed. These results indicate that receptor destruction critically contributes to viral interference.

Defective interfering influenza virus RNAs: time to reevaluate their clinical potential as broad-spectrum antivirals?

Defective interfering (DI) RNAs are highly deleted forms of the infectious genome that are made by most families of RNA viruses. DI RNAs retain replication and packaging signals, are synthesized preferentially over infectious genomes, and are packaged as DI virus particles which can be transmitted to susceptible cells. Their ability to interfere with the replication of infectious virus in cell culture and their potential as antivirals in the clinic have long been known. However, until now, no realistic formulation has been described. In this review, we consider the early evidence of antiviral activity by DI viruses and, using the example of DI influenza A virus, outline developments that have led to the production of a cloned DI RNA that is highly active in preclinical studies not only against different subtypes of influenza A virus but also against heterologous respiratory viruses. These data suggest the timeliness of reassessing the potential of DI viruses as a novel class of antivirals that may have general applicability.

Culture of human amniotic cells: a system to study interferon production

This study investigated whether primary culture of human amniotic membrane cells (PCHAM) could be used as an in vitro model system for the study of interferon (IFN) production. PCHAM cells infected with Newcastle disease virus (NDV) produced the two antigenic types of IFN, previously shown in a amniotic membrane cells (HAM) system. PCHAM IFN was detected as early as 2 h after NDV infection and was composed by two antigenically distinct fractions, one neutralized with anti-HuIFN beta antibody and another that is not related to IFN beta, -alpha and -gamma. These fractions correspond respectively to 80 and 20 per cent of the IFN produced 4 h after virus induction, 55 and 45 per cent of the IFN produced from 4 to 12 h and 67 and 33 per cent of the IFN produced 12 h after virus induction. A cDNA library, established from PCHAM with or without NDV infection, was screened for IFN alpha and -beta using specific primers. The PCR product, amplified by IFN beta primers, was cloned, sequenced and expressed in Escherichia coli M15. The sequences of several cloned cDNAs were identical to HuIFN beta gene and the antiviral activity of the expressed protein was neutralized only by antiHuIFN-beta antibody. The other IFN fraction not neutralized by polyclonal antibodies anti-IFN beta, -alpha and -gamma is now being studied.

Detection and characterization of subgenomic RNAs in hepatitis A virus particles

Defective viral particles containing deleted genomes were detected in harvests of cell cultures infected with various HAV isolates. The most prominent deletions were identified within the region of the genome coding for structural proteins. In this location three different deletions spanning nts 930-4380 (A), 1140-3820 (B), and 1370-3240 (C) were characterized. In addition to these internal deletions, various truncated RNAs were detected lacking either partially or completely the 3' terminal region which is supposed to code for viral replicase. RNA molecules with internal deletions as well as those with 3' terminal truncations could also be extracted directly from infected cells. During multiple consecutive passages of a given HAV strain, deletions A, B, and C accumulated and a quantitative increase of deleted RNAs occurred. Type and predominance of deletions varied with virus strains (CLF, GBM, MBB11/5, HM175, CR326, H141) and with the type of cells used for propagation (MRC-5, BGM, HELF, PLC/PRF/5). However, within the limits of the reliability of S1 analysis the endpoints of deletions A, B, and C were conserved. The mechanisms leading to formation of deletions remain unclear. Yet, some sequences flanking internal deletions showed homology with common splice signals and 3' terminal truncations proved to be confined to a distinct region within the genome.

Nucleotide sequences that affect replicative and transcriptional efficiencies of Sendai virus deletion mutants

Structural features of the genomes of virus deletion mutants (DI virions) influence their replication efficiency. Among nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses, substitution of the genomic 3' terminus by a complementary copy of the 5' terminus (so-called "copy-back" sequence) could enhance replication either because the new 3' end is a better promoter of RNA replication or because DI RNAs that possess this sequence are incapable of acting as templates for transcription. Here we provide evidence that both mechanisms operate in mixed infections with Sendai virus DI RNAs. RNAs incapable of transcription always outgrew RNA species that were transcribed. This was true even when the 3'-terminal sequence of the untranscribed RNA was identical to the genomic 3' terminus, as in the case of an internally deleted DI genome (RNA Ra) rendered transcriptionally inert by point mutations of bases 47 and 51 at the 5' end of the positive-strand leader RNA template. Nevertheless, Ra was outgrown by a copy-back DI RNA, indicating that the 3' genomic end of Ra is a less efficient site for replication initiation than the copy-back sequence.

Enhanced yields of measles virus from cultured cells

Conditions for increasing the yield of measles virus from cultured cells have been investigated. Important factors for high virus yields were found to be cell type, incubation at 33 degrees C, concentration of serum in the medium, use of virus as inoculum within five passages of plaque purification, and repeated harvesting of the virus-containing medium at 12 h intervals after extensive virus-induced cell fusion had occurred. Under these conditions, Vero cells infected with the Edmonston strain of measles virus yielded a total of 2.98 X 10(9) plaque-forming units (p.f.u.) of released virus, which is equivalent to 270 p.f.u./cell. A similar amount of cell-associated virus was produced.

Suppression of vesicular stomatitis virus defective intefering particle generation by a function(s) associated with human chromosome 16

Human-mouse somatic cell hybrids were made between adenine phosphoribosyltransferase-deficient mouse L cells and a strain of human primary fibroblasts and selected in medium containing alanosine and adenine (J. A. Tischfield and F. H. Ruddle, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 71:45-49, 1974). These hybrids were tested for the generation of defective interfering (DI) particles of vesicular stomatitis virus to determine whether or not a host gene controls the induction of DI particles. None of the seven independently arising hybrid clones tested generated detectable DI particles during 13 successive undiluted passages. In addition, the parental human cells also failed to generate DI particles. In contrast, the parental mouse cells generated a detectable level of DI particles during continuous passage. Thus, failure to generate DI particles appears to act in a dominant fashion in these hybrids. Human chromosome 16 and adenine phosphoribosyltransferase were present, as a direct consequence of the selection system, in all of the hybrid clones that failed to generate DI particles. It was the only human chromosome observed in the cells of every hybrid clone. This was verified by both isozyme and karyotype analyses. After hybrids were back-selected (with 2,6-diaminopurine) for loss of human adenine phosphoribosyltransferase and chromosome 16, they gained the ability to generate DI particles. Replication of DI particles already present in virus stocks, however, was normal in all of the hybrid clones and the parental human cells. This suggests that the induction, but not the replication, of DI particles is affected by the human genome and that a factor on human chromosome 16 seems to selectively suppress the mouse cell's ability to generate DI particles in the hybrids. These results support the idea that the induction of DI particles is controlled in part by host cell function(s), as suggested previously (C. Y. Kang and R. Allen, J. Virol. 25:202-206, 1978).

Host cell factors involved in the production of slowly sedimenting nucleocapsids in measles virus-infected cells

A decrease in the sedimentation rates of the measles virus nucleocapsid, and the RNA contained within, were observed during acute measles virus infection when the growth conditions of Vero cells were altered. The change in sedimentation rates of virus nucleocapsids in these experiments was apparently due to the physiological state of the cell and was independent of the history of the measles virus used for infection since: (i) the same virus stock was used to infect cells from which nucleocapsids were prepared, (ii) nucleocapsid sedimentation rates were rapid when Vero cells freshly revived from liquid nitrogen were infected, but nucleocapsid profiles showed no decrease in the amount of slowly sedimenting material using the same cells and changing the virus preparation used for infection. Frequent cell splittings and numerous medium changes were among the growth factors which appeared to correlate to slowly sedimenting particle production. Changes in the amount of self-complementarity of the measles virus RNA were also observed under these conditions.

Analysis of a viral agent isolated from multiple sclerosis brain tissue: characterization as a parainfluenzavirus type 1

A virus originally isolated from cell cultures obtained by lysolecithin-induced fusion of human multiple sclerosis brain cells with CV-1 cells has been analyzed for its antigenic, RNA, and polypeptide compositions, and for selective biological properties. Our findings establish that this isolate, designated 6/94 virus, contains a 50S RNA genome and is, as yet, indistinguishable from Sendai virus in its antigenic and total polypeptide compositions. Despite these similarities, the 6/94 and Sendai viruses differ in certain phenotypic properties. 6/94 virus is markedly less cytocidal for chick fibroblasts, especially at 37 C and, after beta-propiolactone inactivation, it possesses a greater capacity for cell fusion and a lower toxicity than does comparably treated Sendai virus. In addition, 6/94 virus shows greater hemolytic activity.

Host effect on arbovirus replication: appearance of defective interfering particles in murine cells

Serial passage of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) in chicken embryo cells had little effect on SFV yield; however, high multiplicity infection of murine cells with one of the late passage pools (passage 9 SFV) resulted in a virus yield 10- to 20-fold lower than that obtained with earlier passage virus and 80-fold lower than the corresponding yield in chicken cells. This effect was accompanied by a striking decrease in the levels of 42S and 26S RNA and by increased proportions of a small single-stranded viral RNA (molecular weight, 9 x 10(5)) and of a low-molecular-weight replicative form. There was also a reduction in the number of specific membranous structures previously associated with the group A arbovirus replication complex. These results suggested that passage 9 SFV contained defective interfering particles which were detected more readily after one passage in a murine indicator host cell. Identical results were obtained with two different murine cell lines: one a leukemia virus-free clone of AKR cells and the other JLS-V9 cells chronically infected with Rauscher leukemia virus. Host production of RNA tumor virus particles apparently did not affect arbovirus replication.

Prophylaxis and immunization in mice by use of virus-free defective T particles to protect against intracerebral infection by vesicular stomatitis virus

Defective interfering T particles of vesicular stomatitis virus provide remarkable protection against viral disease and death when introduced intracerebrally in large numbers along with an otherwise rapidly fatal low dose of standard infectious virus. This profound prophylactic effect of defective T particles is due to homologous autointerference since it is serotype-specific and interferon is not induced. This protective effect can be demonstrated only with preparations of T particles that have been purified completely free of infectious virions. When pure T particles are injected intracerebrally along with large doses of infectious virus, they convert an otherwise rapidly fatal disease process to a slowly progressing virus infection that generally terminates in death after many days of wasting disease and paralysis. Intracerebral injection of virus-free T particles alone is apparently innocuous to mice and stimulates immunity to massive doses of homologous infectious virus. In vitro, virus-free T particles at extremely high multiplicities depress cellular RNA and protein synthesis and kill BHK21 cells in culture, but do not exhibit such effects at moderately high multiplicities.

Persistent infection of cells in culture by measles virus. 3. Comparison of virus-specific RNA synthesized in primary persistent infection in HeLa cells

The pattern of actinomycin D-resistant RNA synthesis was examined during primary infection of HeLa cells by virulent Edmonston measles virus and in two HeLa clones persistently infected by the same strain of virus. One of these clones, K11, produces infectious virus of low virulence for HeLa cells, and the other, K11A-HG-1, has thus far failed to yield infectious virus. The patterns of virus-specific RNA synthesized in these three types of infection are qualitatively similar to each other and to the patterns of virus-specific RNA synthesis in other paramyxovirus infections. There were, however, quantitative differences. In addition, virions of the virulent Edmonston strain of measles virus were found to contain high-molecular-weight RNA with a sedimentation constant identical to that of Newcastle disease virus.

Transient inhibition of polyoma virus synthesis by sendai virus (parainfluenza I). II. Mechanism of the interference by inactivated virus

The mechanism of the transient inhibition of polyoma virus synthesis by betapropiolactone-inactivated Sendai virus was studied. Polyoma virus early functions did not appear to be affected, although deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and structural protein synthesis were inhibited 60 and 35% respectively. The inhibition of macromolecular synthesis was not sufficient to account for the 90% inhibition of infectious progeny formation. Encapsidation of polyoma DNA into mature virions appears to be completely inhibited after superinfection by beta-propiolactone-inactivated Sendai virus. Ultraviolet irradiation of live or beta-propiolactone-inactivated Sendai virus preparations abolishes the interfering capacity, indicating that a functional Sendai virus ribonucleic acid molecule is the interfering component.

Homologous interference by incomplete Sendai virus particles: changes in virus-specific ribonucleic acid synthesis

Incomplete Sendai virus particles (I particles) interfered with the replication of several strains of infectious Sendai virions (standard virus) but not with the replication of Newcastle disease virus, mumps virus, or Sindbis virus. I particles did not induce interferon, and ultraviolet irradiation of I particles abolished their ability to interfere. Protein synthesis was not necessary to establish interference. The degree of interference depended on the interval between exposure of cells to the I particles and challenge by standard virus, and this was reflected in the degree of inhibition of virus-specific ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis in infected cells. The most dramatic change was decreased accumulation of 50S virus-specific RNA in infected cells. RNA species sedimenting slower than 50S were not as markedly reduced in total amount, but hybridization experiments showed that a substantial portion of these slowly sedimenting RNA species were plus strands, presumably representing replicas of the RNA species in I particles. When I particles in insufficient numbers to interfere were added to cells as late as 8 hr after standard virus, there were no obvious changes in virus-specific RNA species in the cells; however, significant amounts of 19 and 25S RNA species, representing progeny of the I particles, appeared in the culture medium. It was concluded that interference was an intracellular event affecting an early step in virus replication. Competition by I particles for cell sites or substrates needed by standard virus seemed a less likely mechanism of interference than competition for enzymes specified by standard virus.

Absence of interference during high-multiplicity infection by clonally purified vesicular stomatitis virus

Stocks of vesicular stomatitis virus free of defective interfering particles were produced by serial clonal isolation. High-multiplicity infections with these stocks led to no interference or formation of defective interfering particles. Defective interfering particles were generated by three successive passages at high multiplicity.