Polyclonal antibodies specific for liganded active site (metatype) of a high affinity anti-hapten monoclonal antibody

Application of Anti-Immune Complex Reagents in Small Molecule Analyte Immunoassays

The detection of small molecule analytes (SMAs) is of great significance for food and drug testing, environmental monitoring, and disease diagnosis. However, the performance of commercially available SMA immunoassays is limited by their low sensitivity and specificity due to the competitive format, leaving significant room for improvement. In recent years, the application of noncompetitive immunoassays for the detection of SMAs has become a hot topic, especially with the rapid evolution of antibody development technology. The remarkable development and application of anti-immune complex (anti-IC) reagents targeting antigen-specific antibodies have garnered significant interest from researchers and diagnostic companies, particularly in the field of SMA detection. The discovery and development history of anti-IC antibodies, the advantages and limitations of different anti-IC reagent preparation methods, and the mechanisms of interaction between ICs and anti-IC antibodies are reviewed. A comprehensive overview of the application of anti-IC antibodies in SMAs assay, including pesticide residue detection, mycotoxin detection, and clinical testing, as well as current challenges and potential solutions in noncompetitive immunoassays, is also summarized to provide a reference for the rapid and accurate detection of SMAs.

Detection of estradiol with a digital immunoassay using an anti-immunocomplex antibody and single-molecule observation of gold nanoparticles

Gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) have been widely applied to molecular sensors due to their optical properties. We previously reported a molecular detection by observing the scattered light of AuNPs at a single nanoparticle level using dark field microscopy (DFM). Recently, a molecular detection method using digital immunoassay has been reported, taking advantage of the characteristics of DFM. However, the digital immunoassays reported so far have been performed by a conventional sandwich immunoassay, which is difficult to apply to the detection of small molecules. In this study, with the aim of small molecule detection, we developed a digital immunoassay method using an anti-immunocomplex antibody that specifically recognizes immunocomplexes of small molecules with antibodies. The number of AuNPs modified with anti-immunocomplex antibody bound to immunocomplex of estradiol and anti-estradiol antibody was counted at a single nanoparticle level using DFM. We demonstrated for the first time that estradiol molecule can be detected by digital immunoassay using DFM and an anti-immunocomplex antibody with a detection sensitivity of 1 pg/mL.

Development of competitive and noncompetitive immunoassays for clothianidin with high sensitivity and specificity using phage-displayed peptides

Clothianidin is a widely used pesticide that has been banned from outdoor use by the European Union due to its toxicity. To improve the sensitivity and specificity of existing clothianidin immunoassays, we developed competitive and noncompetitive immunoassays for clothianidin based on phage-displayed peptides. Cyclic 8-, 9-, and 10-residue peptide libraries were constructed using an optimized phagemid pComb-pVIII to prevent the loss of theoretical library diversity. Twenty-eight peptidomimetics and two anti-immunocomplex peptides were isolated through a blended panning process and used to develop competitive and noncompetitive phage enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (P-ELISAs), respectively. After optimization, the half inhibition concentration (IC₅₀) and half saturation concentration (SC₅₀) of competitive and noncompetitive P-ELISAs were 3.83 ± 0.23 and 0.45 ± 0.02 ng/mL, respectively. Competitive P-ELISA showed 2.6-18.2% cross-reactivity with imidaclothiz, nitenpyram and imidacloprid. Importantly, noncompetitive P-ELISA, which has the best specificity and great sensitivity for clothianidin, showed no cross-reactivity with the analogs. The average recoveries of competitive and noncompetitive P-ELISAs were 73.8-104.1% and 76.6-102.2%, respectively, while the relative standard deviations were ≤ 11.0%. In addition, the results of P-ELISAs in the analysis of blind samples were consistent with those of high-performance liquid chromatography.

Intramolecular immunological signal hypothesis revived--structural background of signalling revealed by using Congo Red as a specific tool

Micellar structures formed by self-assembling Congo red molecules bind to proteins penetrating into functionrelated unstable packing areas. Here, we have used Congo red - a supramolecular protein ligand to investigate how the intramolecular structural changes that take place in antibodies following antigen binding lead to complement activation. According to our findings, Congo red binding significantly enhances the formation of antigen-antibody complexes. As a result, even low-affinity transiently binding antibodies can participate in immune complexes in the presence of Congo red, although immune complexes formed by these antibodies fail to trigger the complement cascade. This indicates that binding of antibodies to the antigen may not, by itself, fulfill the necessary conditions to generate the signal which triggers effector activity. These findings, together with the results of molecular dynamics simulation studies, enable us to conclude that, apart from the necessary assembling of antibodies, intramolecular structural changes generated by strains which associate high- affinity bivalent antibody fitting to antigen determinants are also required to cross the complement activation threshold.

Enzyme immunoassays as screening tools for catalysts and reaction discovery

This feature article summarizes the development and use of immunoassay techniques (ELISA) as screening tools for fast identification of efficient catalysts in libraries and for the discovery of new chemical reactions.

Identifying and reducing potentially wrong immunoassay results even when plausible and "not-unreasonable"

The primary role of the clinical laboratory is to report accurate results for diagnosis of disease and management of illnesses. This goal has, to a large extent been achieved for routine biochemical tests, but not for immunoassays which remained susceptible to interference from endogenous immunoglobulin antibodies, causing false, and clinically misleading results. Clinicians regard all abnormal results including false ones as "pathological" necessitating further investigations, or concluding iniquitous diagnosis. Even more seriously, "false-negative" results may wrongly exclude pathology, thus denying patients' necessary treatment. Analytical error rate in immunoassays is relatively high, ranging from 0.4% to 4.0%. Because analytical interference from endogenous antibodies is confined to individuals' sera, it can be inconspicuous, pernicious, sporadic, and insidious because it cannot be detected by internal or external quality assessment procedures. An approach based on Bayesian reasoning can enhance the robustness of clinical validation in highlighting potentially erroneous immunoassay results. When this rational clinical/statistical approach is followed by analytical affirmative follow-up tests, it can help identifying inaccurate and clinically misleading immunoassay data even when they appear plausible and "not-unreasonable." This chapter is largely based on peer reviewed articles associated with and related to this approach. The first section underlines (without mathematical equations) the dominance and misuse of conventional statistics and the underuse of Bayesian paradigm and shows that laboratorians are intuitively (albeit unwittingly) practicing Bayesians. Secondly, because interference from endogenous antibodies is method's dependent (with numerous formats and different reagents), it is almost impossible to accurately assess its incidence in all differently formulated immunoassays and for each analytes/biomarkers. However, reiterating the basic concepts underpinning interference from endogenous antibodies can highlight why interference will remain analytically pernicious, sporadic, and an inveterate problem. The following section discuses various stratagems to reduce this source of inaccuracy in current immunoassay results including the role of Bayesian reasoning. Finally, the role of three commonly used follow-up affirmative tests and their interpretation in confirming analytical interference is discussed.

Prokaryotic expression of a novel mouse pro-apoptosis protein PNAS-4 and application of its polyclonal antibodies

Mouse PNAS-4 (mPNAS-4) has 96% identity with human PNAS-4 (hPNAS-4) in primary sequence and has been reported to be involved in the apoptotic response to DNA damage. However, there have been no studies reported of the biological functions of mPNAS-4. In studies conducted by our group (unpublished data), it was interesting to note that overexpression of mPNAS-4 promoted apoptotic death in Lewis lung carcinoma cells (LL2) and colon carcinoma cells (CT26) of mice both in vitro and in vivo. In our studies, mPNAS-4 was cloned into the pGEX-6P-1 vector with GST tag at N-terminal in Escherichia coli strain BL21(DE3). The soluble and insoluble expression of recombinant protein mPNAS-4 (rmPNAS-4) was temperature-dependent. The majority of rmPNAS-4 was insoluble at 37 degrees C, while it was almost exclusively expressed in soluble form at 20 degrees C. The soluble rmPNAS-4 was purified by one-step affinity purification, using a glutathione Sepharose 4B column. The rmPNAS-4 protein was further identified by electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry analysis. The search parameters of the parent and fragment mass error tolerance were set at 0.1 and 0.05 kDa, respectively, and the sequence coverage of search result was 28%. The purified rmPNAS-4 was further used as immunogen to raise polyclonal antibodies in New Zealand white rabbit, which were suitable to detect both the recombinant and the endogenous mPNAS-4 in mouse brain tissue and LL2 cells after immunoblotting and/or immunostaining. The purified rmPNAS-4 and our prepared anti-mPNAS-4 polyclonal antibodies may provide useful tools for future biological function studies for mPNAS.

Polyclonal antibody-based noncompetitive immunoassay for small analytes developed with short peptide loops isolated from phage libraries

To date, there are a few technologies for the development of noncompetitive immunoassays for small molecules, the most common of which relies on the use of anti-immunocomplex antibodies. This approach is laborious, case specific, and relies upon monoclonal antibody technology for its implementation. We recently demonstrated that, in the case of monoclonal antibody-based immunoassays, short peptide loops isolated from phage display libraries can be used as substitutes of the anti-immunocomplex antibodies for noncompetitive immunodetection of small molecules. The aim of this work was to demonstrate that such phage ligands can be isolated even when the selector antibodies are polyclonal in nature. Using phenoxybenzoic acid (PBA), a major pyrethroid metabolite, as a model system, we isolated the CFNGKDWLYC peptide after panning a cyclic peptide library on the PBA/anti-PBA immunocomplex. The sensitivity of the noncompetitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) setup with this peptide was 5-fold (heterologous) or 400-fold (homologous) higher than that of the competitive assay setup with the same antibody. Phage anti-immunocomplex assay (PHAIA) was also easily adapted into a rapid and highly sensitive dipstick assay. The method not only provides a positive readout but also constitutes a major shortcut in the development of sensitive polyclonal-based assays, avoiding the need of synthesizing heterologous competing haptens.

Noncompetitive Detection of Low Molecular Weight Peptides by Open Sandwich Immunoassay

Small peptides with less than 1000 in molecular weight are not considered amenable to sandwich immunoassays due to their difficulty of simultaneous recognition by two antibodies. As an alternative, we attempted noncompetitive detection of small peptides by open sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (OS-ELISA) utilizing the antigen-induced enhancement of antibody VH/VL interaction. Taking fragments of human osteocalcin (BGP), a major non-collagen peptide produced in bone, as model peptides, OS immunoassay was performed using the cloned VH and VL cDNAs from two anti-BGP monoclonal antibodies either recognizing the N- or C-terminal fragment, respectively. When the clones were used for OS-ELISA with immobilized VL fragment and phage-displayed VH fragment, enhanced VH/VL interaction upon BGP addition was observed. Especially the clone for the C-terminal fragment showed a superior detection limit as well as a wider working range than those of competitive assay. The result was reproduced with purified VH-alkaline phosphatase and MBP-VL fusion proteins, where the latter was directly immobilized onto the microplate wells. The minimum detectable fragment was the hexamer including the C-terminus. This simple approach with a single monoclonal antibody with a short measurement time may prove a useful tool in immunodiagnostics as well as in proteomics research.

Antibody Engineering-Based Approach for Hapten Immunometric Assays with High Sensitivity

The trace characterization of physiologically active substances with low molecular weight (e.g., steroids, catecholamines, prostaglandins, and oligopeptides), which are classified as "haptens", is an important subject in clinical analysis, and competitive immunoassays have conventionally been used for this purpose. However, the subfemtomole-range determination of haptens is very difficult, as the sensitivity of competitive immunoassays is essentially limited by the affinity of the anti-hapten antibodies that barely reaches the range of 10(11) (l/mol) as the affinity constant (K(a)). Although a noncompetitive "immunometric assay" format, the two-site immunometric assay (sandwich immunoassay), enables even subattomole-range measurements of macromolecules such as proteins, this principle can not be directly applied to haptens, as their low molecular mass prohibits simultaneous binding by two antibody molecules. To overcome such limitations, we are required either to create artificial antibodies showing ultrahigh affinity to haptens by protein engineering of antibody molecules ("antibody engineering") or establishment of novel immunometric assay formats applicable to haptens. This review surveys the background and recent approach for subfemtomole-range determination of haptens using novel immunometric assay methods. Our studies for the development of hapten immunometric assays are also described.

Recent developments for SPIE-IA, a new sandwich immunoassay format for very small molecules

Recent publications describing new elegant approaches to assay small analytes using noncompetitive format were briefly reviewed. Among these methods, we have developed a new protocol, named SPIE-IA, which involves a cross-linking step achieved using chemical hombifunctional reagents, UV irradiation or free radicals. This new method proved to be useful to detect naturally occurring analyte/antibody complexes or to protect the analytes against degradation by peptidases. On the other hand, SPIE-IA could allow to study the adverse biological effects of UV and some aspects of free radical chemistry or to evaluate the antioxidant activity of molecules.

Monoclonal antibodies generated against an affinity-labeled immune complex of an anti-bile acid metabolite antibody: an approach to noncompetitive hapten immunoassays based on anti-idiotype or anti-metatype antibodies

Conventional immunoassays for haptens such as steroids and synthetic drugs are dependent on the competitive reaction between an unlabeled antigen (analyte) and a labeled antigen against a limited amount of anti-hapten antibody. Although noncompetitive immunoassay procedures such as two-site immunometric assays offer a much higher sensitivity, direct application of this principle to haptens has been difficult due to their small molecular mass precluding simultaneous binding by two antibody molecules. Here, we have attempted to develop a noncompetitive immunoassay system based on anti-idiotype or anti-metatype antibodies. Ursodeoxycholic acid 7-N-acetylglucosaminide (UDCA 7-NAG), which is a bile acid metabolite (molecular weight, 595.8), was selected as the model hapten. A/J mice were immunized with a monoclonal antibody against UDCA 7-NAG, which had been affinity-labeled with a relevant hapten derivative. The fusion between the immune spleen cells and P3/NS1/1-Ag4-1 myeloma cells yielded four kinds of alpha-type and two kinds of beta-type monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies, each recognizing the framework region and paratope of the anti-hapten antibody. The use of a selected combination between alpha-type and beta-type antibodies together with the anti-hapten antibody provided a noncompetitive assay system with a subfemtomole order sensitivity (detection limit, 118 amol) and a practical specificity.

Anti-metatype antibody stabilization of Fv 4-4-20 variable domain dynamics

Anti-metatype (anti-Met) antibodies are immunoglobulins that specifically recognize and stabilize antibodies in their liganded or metatypic state, but lack specificity for either the hapten or the unliganded antibody. Autologous anti-Met antibodies were previously observed in vivo, suggesting that a metatypic autoantibody response could play a physiological role in the immune network, e.g. controlling the clearance of immune complexes from circulation. The first elicited anti-Met antibodies were against the fluorescein-liganded high affinity murine anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody 4-4-20. The fluorescein-hapten system has proved to be an invaluable tool for both the recognition and characterization of the metatypic response by utilization of its spectral properties. In this investigation, hydrostatic pressure measurements, in conjunction with fluorescence spectroscopy, were performed on the recombinant Fv derivative (Fv 4-4-20) of the high affinity anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody 4-4-20 complexed to anti-Met antibodies to study the influence of anti-Met antibodies of Fv 4-4-20 intervariable domain interactions. Anti-Met antibodies bound to liganded Fv 4-4-20 were observed to cause a change in the fluorescence properties of fluorescein that was not observed when anti-Met antibodies were bound to the liganded parent immunoglobulin. The variation of these spectral properties upon addition of anti-Met antibodies was shown to be correlated with dissociation of the variable domains in Fv 4-4-20 in response to its interaction with the anti-Met antibody. The ability to cause variable domain dissociation was dependent on whether monoclonal or polyclonal anti-Met antibodies were bound to the metatype. A model was proposed that elucidated the interaction of anti-Met antibodies, polyclonal and monoclonal, with variable domains of the primary anti-antigen antibody.

Antibody networks and imaging: elicitation of anti-fluorescein antibodies in response to the metatypic state of fluorescein-specific monoclonal antibodies

Studies are described regarding generation of anti-hapten antibodies starting with a monoclonal Ig immunogen in the ligand-induced conformation or metatypic state. Liganded monoclonal Ab1 antibodies represent the unique feature of the study since previous reports investigating internal imaging in the original Idiotype Network Hypothesis [Jerne, 1974 (Ann. Immun. 125C, 373-389)] were based on the non-liganded or idiotypic state [as reviewed in: Rodkey, 1980 (Microbiol. Rev. 44, 631-659); Kohler et al., 1979 (In: Methods in Enzymology: Antibodies, Antigens and Molecular Mimicry, pp. 3-35); Greenspan and Bona, 1993 (FASEB J. 7,437-444)]. Affinity-labeled liganded murine monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibodies served as immunogens administered both in the syngenic and xenogenic modes to determine if the metatypic state elicited anti-hapten antibodies through imaging-like mechanisms. Polyclonal and monoclonal anti-Ab1 reagents in various hosts were assayed for anti-fluorescein and/or anti-metatype specificity. Significant anti-fluorescein responses were measured indicating that the metatypic state directly or indirectly stimulates an anti-hapten antibody population.

Temperature and pH dependence of fluorescein binding within the monoclonal antibody 9-40 active site as monitored by hydrostatic pressure

In a comparative study, the thermodynamic parameter, DeltaV, was obtained using hydrostatic pressure-induced dissociation of fluorescein (Fl) from the active site of monoclonal antibody (mAb) 9-40 and its mutant and native derivatives equilibrated at six pH values (8.0, 7.5, 7.0, 6.5, 6.0, and 5.5) and four temperatures (35, 25, 15, and 5 degrees C). mAb 9-40 and its Fab and single-chain Fv (scFv) derivatives at pH 8.0 were found to have identical Fl dissociation behavior under pressure as a function of temperature. The pressure dissociation at 25 degrees C as a function of pH showed a sigmoidal dependence of DeltaV with a midpoint value at pH 7.4 for mAb 9-40. Comparison of experimental results for scFv 9-40/212 with its mutant scFv 9-40/212Arg-34L indicated that the pH dependence of mAb 9-40 was due to the titration of His-34L in the active site. Iodide quenching of bound Fl showed that the hapten in this active site was solvent accessible. Imperfect packing, which leads to increased conformational dynamics, was determined as a possible cause of the low affinity for mAb 9-40.

Comparative properties of the single chain antibody and Fv derivatives of mAb 4-4-20. Relationship between interdomain interactions and the high affinity for fluorescein ligand

Recombinant Fv derivative of the high affinity murine anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody 4-4-20 was constructed and expressed in high yields, relative to the single chain antibody (SCA) derivative (2 3-fold), in Escherichia coli. Both variable heavy (VH) and variable light (VL) domains, that accumulated as insoluble inclusion bodies, were isolated, denatured, mixed, refolded, and affinity-purified to yield active Fv 4-4-20. Affinity-purified Fv 4-4-20 showed identical ligand binding properties compared with the SCA construct, both were slightly lower than the affinities expressed by Fab or IgG 4-4-20. Proper protein folding was shown to be domain-independent by in vitro mixing of individually refolded variable domains to yield functional Fv protein. In solid phase and solution phase assays, Fv 4-4-20 closely approximated the SCA derivative in terms of both idiotype and metatype, confirming identical active site structures and conformations. The equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) for the VL/VH association (1.43 x 10(-7) M), which was determined using the change in fluorescein spectral properties upon ligand binding, was relatively low considering the high affinity displayed by the Fv protein for fluorescein (Kd, 2.9 x 10(-10) M). Thus, domain-domain stability in the Fv and SCA 4-4-20 proteins cannot be the sole cause of reduced affinity (2-3-fold) for fluorescein as compared with the Fab or IgG form of 4-4-20. With their identical ligand binding and structural properties, the decreased SCA or Fv affinity for fluorescein must be an ultimate consequence of deletion of the CH1 and CL constant domains. Collectively, these results verify the importance of constant domain interactions in antibody variable domain structure-function analyses and future antibody engineering endeavors.

Perturbation of antibody bound bifluorescent-ligand probe by polyclonal anti-metatype antibodies interacting with epitopes proximal to the liganded antibody active site

General localization of metatypic determinants recognized by polyclonal anti-metatype antibodies relative to the antibody active site of the high-affinity anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody 4-4-20 was achieved through use of a unique bifluorescent-ligand probe. The fluorescent probe possessed intrinsic energy-transfer properties with the fluorescein hapten serving as the energy acceptor. The donor group 5-(2-iodoacetyl) aminoethylaminonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (IAEDANS) proved environmentally sensitive both to binding of the FITC-cys-AEDANS ligand and to subsequent anti-metatype antibody interactions involving the antibody variable domains of 4-4-20. Spectral changes in ligand-conjugated AEDANS upon specific reactivity of the antibody with FITC suggested secondary interactions between AEDANS and the topological protein surface adjacent to the 4-4-20 active site. Results indicated that some anti-metatype antibodies (Fab fragments) within the polyclonal population bound to sites immediately surrounding the liganded active site and perturbed the interactions of AEDANS with topological sites. The results are discussed in terms of the types of interactions that may occur between the AEDANS moiety and the 4-4-20 antibody protein surface and subsequent perturbation of those interactions by anti-metatype antibodies.

Lupus-derived autoantibodies with dual autoactivity: anti-DNA and anti-Fc. II. Fine specificity of anti-self autoreactivity

The anti-immunoglobulin reactivity of two monoclonal, dual specific, autoantibodies, BV 17-45 and BV 04-01 was examined. The current study further defined the anti-immunoglobulin autoreactivity of these MoAbs to be Fc-specific. Both BV 17-45 and BV 04-01 bound their own Fc domains in addition to Fc regions of other MoAbs of similar isotype with varying levels of activity. The different anti-Fc reactivity patterns of BV 17-45 and BV 04-01 suggested that these MoAbs recognized distinct epitopes. Neither BV 17-45 nor BV 04-01 bound Fab fragments or single-chain antibody derivatives, which confirmed that the anti-immunoglobulin reactivity of these autoantibodies was Fc-specific. In addition, abrogation of anti-Fc reactivity was observed when affinity-labelled MoAbs were used as coating antigens in solid-phase ELISAs. These results implied that active-site ligand binding induced conformational changes which altered the Fc epitope(s) recognized by BV 17-45 and BV 04-01.

Primary structures of three Armenian hamster monoclonal antibodies specific for idiotopes and metatopes of the monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibody 4-4-20

This paper reports the complete V gamma, V kappa, C gamma 1 and C kappa nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequences of two hamster monoclonal anti-metatype antibodies, 3A5-1 and 4A6. These antibodies have been previously characterized in terms of their binding and molecular stabilization properties with liganded murine monoclonal and single-chain antibody 4-4-20 active sites. Also reported are the complete V kappa and C kappa nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequence of hamster monoclonal anti-idiotype antibody 1F4, which is specific for the unliganded 4-4-20 active site. Oligonucleotide primers based on the 5' ends of murine variable genes, along with primers specific for murine IgG C gamma 1 and kappa constant region genes, have been used in cDNA and polymerase chain reactions (PCRs) to amplify IgG cDNA from Armenian hamster/mouse hybridomas. The hamster C gamma 1 and C kappa domain sequences are highly homologous to previously reported murine sequences. The anti-idiotype mAb V kappa gene demonstrated strong similarity to the murine V kappa V gene subgroup while the two anti-metatype mAb V kappa genes approximated more closely to the murine V kappa III gene subgroup. The two anti-metatype mAbs utilized highly homologous V gamma genes, with differing HCDR 3 regions, that appeared similar to the murine V gamma I(a) subgroup. These sequence determinations represent the first primary structures reported for antibodies with anti-metatype activity and are additions to the relatively sparse hamster immunoglobulin genetic database. Results are discussed in terms of 4-4-20 active site specificity and anti-metatype activity, as well as immunoglobulin structural diversity in an anti-Ig immune response.

High-affinity rat anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody with unique fine specificity properties including differential recognition of dynamic ligand analogues

The ability of antibodies to specifically select and stabilize through binding one or more isomers of highly dynamic ligands remains a relatively unexplored immunochemical problem. The experimental strategy employed in this study was to elicit homogeneous antibodies to polyaromatic fluorescein which exists in one isomeric form. The binding properties of a monoclonal rat antifluorescein antibody specific to a given isomer were quantitatively studied to determine the capacity to bind dynamic analogues of fluorescein which exists in multiple isomers. To generate monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibodies that reacted with specific dynamic analogues of fluorescein possessing unconjugated aromatic ring systems, immune spleenocytes from Lou/M rats immunized with FITC(I)-KLH were fused with Balb/c SP2/0-Ag14 murine myeloma cells forming rat-mouse hybridomas. Cell line P2A12-1-C8 was selected for further characterization from the original 23 stable rat hybrids, since it produced a monoclonal antibody with a binding affinity 2.0 x 10(10)/M for fluorescein based on dissociation rate measurements. P2A12-1-C8 exhibited significant reactivity with HPF and phenol red, which are dynamic structural analogues of the homologous fluorescein ligand. No reactivity was demonstrated with phenolphthalein, which based on relative chemical structures was expected to be more reactive than phenol red. Computer-based molecular modeling and energy minimization studies of fluorescein, HPF, phenol red, and phenolphthalein showed that in terms of the most energetically favorable orientation of the three aromatic rings, phenol red more closely simulated fluorescein than phenolphthalein. The results were analyzed in terms of the mechanisms of dynamic ligand stabilization and binding involving accommodation of specific ligand isomers by energetically permissible conformational states exhibited by an antibody active site. Thus, antibody reactivity of an anti-fluorescein antibody with phenol red and phenolphthalein was dictated more by ligand dynamics and aromatic orientation than by chemical structure similarities.

Sandwich immunoassay for the hapten angiotensin II. A novel assay principle based on antibodies against immune complexes

Immunoassays for haptens such as short peptides or drugs are usually based on the principle of competition for a limited number of binding sites on antibody molecules. Owing to the small size of these antigens it has been thought that two specific antibodies cannot simultaneously bind a hapten. However, antisera containing so called anti-metatypic antibodies have been reported (Voss et al. (1988) Mol. Immunol. 25, 751-759) that bind to hapten-mAb complexes in a reaction where conformational changes on the primary antibody are important. Here, we report on monoclonal antibody pairs able to form ternary complexes with the octapeptide angiotensin II. The first mAb (mAb1) is conventional and binds angiotensin II with high affinity (Kd 10(-11) M). The secondary (anti-metatypic) mAbs (mAbs2s) recognize the immune complex consisting of angiotensin II bound to mAb1, but only poorly recognize mAb1 alone. An immunization technique involving tolerization with uncomplexed mAb1 was used to generate mAb2s. None of the mAbs2s were able to bind angiotensin II by themselves but all efficiently bound the complex of angiotensin II and mAb1. All mAb2s stabilized the angiotensin II-mAb1 complex and one mAb2 distinctly improved the specificity of the assay for angiotensin II. By either labelling mAb1 and immobilizing mAb2 (or vice versa) two-site immunometric assays with detection limits of 1 pg/ml angiotensin II have been established. The kinetics of the complex formation was investigated by fiber optic biospecific interaction analysis (FOBIA), a system allowing real time observation of binding events on the surface of a glass fiber. The association rate towards the liganded conformation of mAb1 was higher than towards the free mAb1. By contrast, the mAb2s dissociated at similar rates from complexed and uncomplexed mAb1.

Synergistic monoclonal antibodies' interactions and their use for determination of antibody specificities

Three monoclonal antibodies (MAb 3C11, F11 and 10D6) to human growth hormone (hGH) recognize independent epitopes and show mutually enhancing properties. Thus, 125I-hGH binding to each of these MAb augmented significantly in the presence of each one of the other two MAb. Moreover, preincubation of the hormone with paired MAb gave rise to ternary complexes (Ag:Ab1:Ab2) which bound better than the free tracer to the third MAb previously captured on a solid-phase. Highly stable quaternary complexes (Ag:Ab1:Ab2:Ab3) were thus formed. Since Fab fragments from the three MAb displayed the same behavior as the whole Ab molecule, neither the formation of multimolecular cyclic complexes nor the occurrence of interactions through Fc fragments could explain the reciprocal MAb binding enhancement. Therefore, the results obtained suggest that MAb 3C11, F11 and 10D6 produce some modification in the Ag, each one improving the binding of the two other MAb. Additionally, the inhibition of the formation of quaternary complexes between the MAb and hGH was used to evaluate specific Ab populations in polyclonal antisera, avoiding the masking effect of enhancing Ab. The results obtained indicate that Ab directed to the hGH antigenic domains defined by MAb 3C11, F11 and 10D6 could be detected in spite of the presence of enhancing Ab to all three MAb.

Elicitation of distinct populations of monoclonal antibodies specific for the variable domains of monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibody 4-4-20

Armenian hamsters were immunized with non-liganded, partially liganded or affinity-labeled anti-fluorescein Mab 4-4-20. Seventeen hybridoma producing monoclonal anti-4-4-20 antibodies were characterized from chemically-mediated fusions of immune hamster lymphocytes with murine Sp2/O-Ag14 myeloma cells. Distinct populations of anti-4-4-20 monoclonal antibodies were isolated from hamsters receiving immunizations with partially liganded Mab 4-4-20 relative to those receiving affinity-labeled 4-4-20. Two of the three monoclonal antibodies produced in response to partially liganded 4-4-20 were inhibited in their interaction with 4-4-20 by fluorescyl ligand. These two clones, 1F4 and 1B7, recognized unique epitopes on the 4-4-20 molecules, as demonstrated by non-reactivity with members of the 4-4-20 idiotype family. Additionally, 1F4 and 1B7 demonstrated the ability to delay the association of fluorescein with Mab 4-4-20. The 14 characterized non-ligand-inhibitable Mabs elicited to affinity-labeled 4-4-20 were classified into four separate groups based on various binding properties with members of the 4-4-20 idiotype family and binding to resolved H- and L-chains in a western blot. Members of three of the four groups showed strong reactivity with both 04-01 Ig and 04-01 SCA, which utilizes the same L-chain as Mab 4-4-20. Six non-ligand-inhibitable Mabs, 4A6, P1E11, 3A5-1, 2C3, 2C4, and 1A4, delayed the dissociation rate of ligand from Mab 4-4-20 and mutant 4-4-20 SCA L32phe.

Kinetic measurements of molecular interactions by spectrofluorometry

The kinetics of antibody-antigen interactions are reviewed in terms of general trends observed in both polyclonal and monoclonal antibody populations. Anti-fluorescein antibodies are featured in the review as model proteins to explore fluorescence-based kinetic measurements. Since the fluorescence of the fluorescein ligand is significantly quenched upon interaction with both polyclonal and monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibodies, the quenching parameter can be advantageously employed in measuring the rates of association (k1) and dissociation (k2). The near diffusion-limited k1 rates and the prolonged k2 rates are discussed in terms of antibody affinity and mechanisms involved in ligand binding. Specific prolongation effects of reagents, such as anti-metatype antibodies, on the dissociation rate are discussed in terms of antibody dynamics and conformational substates.

Anti-immune complex antibodies enhance affinity and specificity of primary antibodies

Antibodies have previously been described that enhance the binding of a second antibody to its antigen. The origin of this effect has been variously ascribed to binding to a neodeterminant on the Fc region, to a combined determinant representing portions of the second antibody and the immunogen, and to a ligand-induced conformation of the Fab fragment. This paper describes an antibody that recognizes an immune complex of an antibody to tetrahydrocannabinol (THC). The antibody binds the anti-THC antibody at an epitope recognized by an anti-idiotype antibody that is capable of blocking THC binding. The ability of various THC derivatives to enhance or inhibit binding taken together with equilibria and kinetic data support a model in which the anti-immune complex antibody interacts through adventitious binding to pendant groups on the THC derivatives. This type of interaction offers the opportunity to increase the sensitivity and specificity of immunoassays beyond the limits imposed by normal antibody binding. The implications of these findings with regard to earlier observations of anti-immune complex antibodies are discussed.

Comparative circular dichroism studies of an anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody (Mab 4-4-20) and its derivatives

This study presents circular dichroism (CD) spectra of a high-affinity monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibody (Mab 4-4-20), its Fab fragments, and corresponding single-chain antibody (SCA). In the region 200-250 nm, the differences in the CD spectra between these proteins reflect the uneven distribution of chromophores (tryptophan and tyrosine) rather than a major conformational change. On the basis of near-UV CD spectra, binding of the hapten fluorescein to these protein antibodies elicits an increased asymmetry in the microenvironment of the chromophoric residues in contact with the hapten and also perturbs the interface between VL and VH domains. The hapten-binding site provides a chiral microenvironment for fluorescein that elicits a pronounced induced fluorescein CD spectrum in both the visible and UV regions. In contrast to the parent molecules, SCA is thermolabile. Our results demonstrate that (1) UV CD spectra are useful for assessing the chromophoric microenvironment in the binding portion of antibodies and (2) the extrinsic fluorescein hapten CD spectra provide information about the interaction of hapten with the binding pocket.

Characterization of interactions involving anti-metatype antibodies and immune complexes

Immunizations of high affinity anti-fluorescein monoclonal antibody 4-4-20 affinity labeled with fluorescein 5-isothiocyanate into a rabbit elicited antibodies specific for the liganded conformation of 4-4-20 (termed "anti-metatype" antibodies). Reaction of liganded 4-4-20 with anti-metatype antibodies caused significant delay (up to 23-fold) in the rate of dissociation of fluorescein ligand from the active site. In this study, structural analogues of fluorescein, including fluorescein 5-isothiocyanate, fluorescein 6-isothiocyanate, 5-dichlorotriazinyl aminofluorescein and 5-carboxyfluorescein, were bound by monoclonal antibody 4-4-20 and anti-metatype antibody reactivity was observed through delay in the dissociation rate of ligand from Mab 4-4-20. Significant delays (ranging from 5- to 242-fold) were observed for all structural analogues examined indicating that 4-4-20 maintained similar but not necessarily identical conformations upon binding fluorescein structural analogues. Additionally, fluorescein 5-isothiocyanate and fluorescein 6-isothiocyanate were conjugated to carrier molecules of increasing mol. wt (ranging from 225 to 14,600 D) in an attempt to sterically interfere with "metatopes" at the mouth of the active site and localize regions of anti-metatype antibody binding. These fluorescein-conjugated compounds were reacted with 4-4-20, and binding of anti-metatype antibodies delayed dissociation rates from 24- to greater than 1500-fold. These results indicated that the mechanism whereby anti-metatype antibodies delay the release of fluorescyl ligands from the active site probably does not solely involve steric hindrance of the ligand due to binding of anti-metatype antibodies at the mouth of the active site. Studies with 4-4-20 Fab fragments and a single chain derivative of 4-4-20 (consisting of the variable regions tethered by a 14 amino acid linker) indicated that anti-metatype reactivity was specific for the immunoglobulin variable region.

Importance of dynamic properties of idiotopes in interactions with anti-Id antibodies

The concept of fluctuating conformational substates in equilibrium characterizing variable-regions of immunoglobulin idiotypes is discussed in terms of the dynamic properties of idiotopes and their stabilization upon interactions with anti-idiotope antibodies. Uniquely, polyclonal anti-Id antibodies are viewed in cooperative immobilizing interactions with the idiotopes thereby facilitating formation of stable complexes.

Autologous anti-metatype immune response in rabbits

Rabbits hyperimmunized with fluorescyl-conjugated KLH exhibited bound ligand associated with a high affinity circulating IgG anti-fluorescein population. After cessation of immunogen administration the liganded complexes were eventually spontaneously cleared from the circulation. Individual rabbits synthesized autologous anti-metatype antibodies specific for ligand-antibody complexes. Autologous anti-metatype antibodies reacted optimally with autologous liganded anti-fluorescein antibodies. However, cross reactivity was noted with allogenic rabbit liganded antibodies from three affinity-purified pools. An autologous anti-metatype response, reminiscent of autoanti-idiotype responses, has important implications concerning in vivo clearance of antigen-antibody complexes and may serve as a model to study immune complex diseases.

Fluorescence measurements of immune complexes of Mab 4-4-20 with isomeric haptens

Relative differences in the active site environment of a monoclonal antibody when covalently bound to two isomeric haptens were studied using fluorescence quenching and lifetime measurements. Murine monoclonal antibody 4-4-20, a well-characterized high affinity antifluorescein antibody, served as the model IgG protein. Isomeric haptenic probes comparatively studied were fluorescein-5-isothiocyanate (FITC I, the immunogen) and fluorescein-6-isothiocyanate (FITC II). In kinetic binding studies, the association rate for the interaction of 4-4-20 with FITC I was greater than 2,000 times faster than the reaction with FITC II. Fluorescence lifetimes for FITC I covalently bound to 4-4-20 were 3.89 ns and 0.37 ns, indicative of hapten bound outside and inside the active site, respectively. Fluorescence lifetime for FITC II within the active site was indistinguishable from bound FITC I, indicating that interactions with active site residues which resulted in a decreased lifetime were similar for both isomers. A decreased lifetime for active site bound FITC I was consistent with the 90-95% quenching of fluorescein fluorescence. Dynamic fluorescence quenching experiments with iodide and FITC I in the active site showed no solvent accessibility, whereas bound FITC II showed significant accessibility. These results suggest that the difference in bond angle which accompanies binding of isomer II relative to isomer I within the active site probably leads to steric constraints resulting in a more open configuration of the 4-4-20 active site.

A single-step method for the purification of anti-FITC antibodies by use of a coumarin immunosorbent

Monoclonal anti-fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) antibody cross-reacts with 7-hydroxy coumarin derivatives conjugated to BSA. This property permitted the affinity purification of monoclonal anti-FITC antibodies from ascitic fluid using an-immunosorbent consisting of a 7-hydroxy coumarin derivative linked to Sepharose 4B. Ascitic fluid was applied to the immunosorbent column and, after washing, the bound antibody was eluted under extremely mild conditions using 3 M MgCl2. Antibody eluted in this manner was greater than 96% pure as assessed by SDS-PAGE. A polyclonal sheep anti-FITC antibody was also purified from serum on the same immunosorbent to greater than 94% purity. This simple and rapid method for the purification of anti-FITC antibodies will find applications in both immunodiagnostic procedures and in studies of hapten-antibody interactions. The affinity constant of the purified monoclonal anti-FITC antibody conjugated to horseradish peroxidase was assessed by ELISA and was found to be 1.5 x 19(9) M-1.

Anti-metatype antibody reactivity: a model for T-cell receptor recognition

Anti-metatype (Met) antibodies are anti-immunoglobulins that specifically recognize an antibody-liganded active site but lack specificity for either the ligand or the idiotype. As proposed here by Edward Voss, anti-metatype-metatype immunoglobulin interactions may serve as a model for the interaction of the T-cell receptor (TCR) with antigen-MHC (class I/class II) complexes: the anti-metatype immunoglobulin reagent simulates the TCR and the liganded antibody mimics the antigen-MHC complex. Such a model addresses the dilemma of two macromolecules interacting with the same antigenic determinant and may represent a rational approach to improve understanding of the initiation and regulation of the immune response.

Variable region primary structures of monoclonal anti-DNA autoantibodies from NZB/NZW F1 mice

VH and VL region primary structures of five NZB/NZW F1 derived monoclonal anti-DNA autoantibodies were determined from cloned cDNA. Comparative analysis of VH genes showed that except for two VH genes that shared complete identity the overall VH gene usage was diverse. Comparison of VH genes with those utilized in a variety of antibody responses showed they were generally unique to the autoanti-DNA response although framework homologies allowed assignment of four of five VH genes to existing murine heavy chain gene families. Only one out of five D segments shared homology to existing germline D segments, and all were rearranged to JH3. V kappa genes showed restriction for four of five light chains to the V kappa 1 subgroup. The V kappa 1 subgroup has been shown previously to be utilized in several anti-DNA autoantibodies as well as a variety of antibodies to exogenous antigens. H and L chain amino acid residues associated with the active site of a ssDNA specific autoantibody, 04-01, are discussed based on recently obtained crystallographic data.

Inter-relationship between immunoglobulin idiotype and metatype

Allogenic anti-metatype (Met) and anti-idiotype (Id) reagents were elicited to the liganded and nonliganded states, respectively, of a high affinity murine monoclonal anti-fluorescein IgM antibody. Through comparisons of the relative immunogenicity and specificity patterns of the resulting antibody reagents, interpretations regarding the relationship between metatopes and idiotopes were rendered. Anti-Id specificity was measured in terms of the degree of ligand inhibition to two different forms of the fluorescyl hapten (i.e. free ligand and conjugated to a macromolecule). Idiotypic analysis of 18-2-3 H and L chains (immunoglobulin heavy and light chains) demonstrated that recognition of 18-2-3 Id determinants required recombination of H and L chains. Anti-Met reagents were evaluated relative to the liganded and nonliganded states of the IgM antibody. Binding studies indicated anti-Met specificity for liganded or affinity labeled Mab (monoclonal antibody) 18-2-3, but not for nonliganded 18-2-3 or the fluorescein ligand. The affinity labeled metatypic state provided the optimum immunogen yielding an antibody reagent which was rendered specific for the liganded state upon absorption with appropriate immunoglobulin reagents. Antibodies specific for affinity labeled 18-2-3 did not react with liganded 4-4-20, an IgG2a monoclonal anti-fluorescein antibody of similar high affinity but unrelated idiotypically. Results were discussed in terms of intrasite, proximal-site and distal-site epitopes.

Three-dimensional structure of a fluorescein-Fab complex crystallized in 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol

The crystal structure of a fluorescein-Fab (4-4-20) complex was determined at 2.7 A resolution by molecular replacement methods. The starting model was the refined 2.7 A structure of unliganded Fab from an autoantibody (BV04-01) with specificity for single-stranded DNA. In the 4-4-20 complex fluorescein fits tightly into a relatively deep slot formed by a network of tryptophan and tyrosine side chains. The planar xanthonyl ring of the hapten is accommodated at the bottom of the slot while the phenylcarboxyl group interfaces with solvent. Tyrosine 37 (light chain) and tryptophan 33 (heavy chain) flank the xanthonyl group and tryptophan 101 (light chain) provides the floor of the combining site. Tyrosine 103 (heavy chain) is situated near the phenyl ring of the hapten and tyrosine 102 (heavy chain) forms part of the boundary of the slot. Histidine 31 and arginine 39 of the light chain are located in positions adjacent to the two enolic groups at opposite ends of the xanthonyl ring, and thus account for neutralization of one of two negative charges in the haptenic dianion. Formation of an enol-arginine ion pair in a region of low dielectric constant may account for an incremental increase in affinity of 2-3 orders of magnitude in the 4-4-20 molecule relative to other members of an idiotypic family of monoclonal antifluorescyl antibodies. The phenyl carboxyl group of fluorescein appears to be hydrogen bonded to the phenolic hydroxyl group of tyrosine 37 of the light chain. A molecule of 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol (MPD), trapped in the interface of the variable domains just below the fluorescein binding site, may be partly responsible for the decrease in affinity for the hapten in MPD.