Plant microtubule inhibitors against trypanosomatids

Dinitroaniline Herbicide Resistance and Mechanisms in Weeds

Dinitroanilines are microtubule inhibitors, targeting tubulin proteins in plants and protists. Dinitroaniline herbicides, such as trifluralin, pendimethalin and oryzalin, have been used as pre-emergence herbicides for weed control for decades. With widespread resistance to post-emergence herbicides in weeds, the use of pre-emergence herbicides such as dinitroanilines has increased, in part, due to relatively slow evolution of resistance in weeds to these herbicides. Target-site resistance (TSR) to dinitroaniline herbicides due to point mutations in α-tubulin genes has been confirmed in a few weedy plant species (e.g., Eleusine indica, Setaria viridis, and recently in Lolium rigidum). Of particular interest is the resistance mutation Arg-243-Met identified from dinitroaniline-resistant L. rigidum that causes helical growth when plants are homozygous for the mutation. The recessive nature of the TSR, plus possible fitness cost for some resistance mutations, likely slows resistance evolution. Furthermore, non-target-site resistance (NTSR) to dinitroanilines has been rarely reported and only confirmed in Lolium rigidum due to enhanced herbicide metabolism (metabolic resistance). A cytochrome P450 gene (CYP81A10) has been recently identified in L. rigidum that confers resistance to trifluralin. Moreover, TSR and NTSR have been shown to co-exist in the same weedy species, population, and plant. The implication of knowledge and information on TSR and NTSR in management of dinitroaniline resistance is discussed.

Microtubules as antifungal and antiparasitic drug targets

INTRODUCTION

Diseases caused by fungi and parasites are major illnesses in humans as well as in animals. Microtubule-targeted drugs are highly effective for the treatment of fungal and parasitic infections; however, several human parasitic infections such as malaria, trypanosomiasis and leishmaniasis do not have effective remedial drugs. In addition, the emergence of drug-resistant fungi and parasites makes the discovery of new drugs imperative.

AREAS COVERED

This article describes similarities and dissimilarities between parasitic, fungal and mammalian tubulins and focuses on microtubule-targeting agents and therapeutic approaches for the treatment of fungal and parasitic diseases. New microtubule-targeted antileishmanial, antimalarial and antifungal drugs, with structures, biological activities and related patents, are described. The potential of dsRNA against tubulin to inhibit proliferation of protozoan and helminthic parasites is also discussed. Patent documents up to 2010 have been searched on USPTO, Patentscope, and Espacenet resources.

EXPERT OPINION

The article suggests that vaccination with tubulin may offer novel opportunities for the antiparasitic treatment. Native or recombinant tubulin used as antigen has been shown to elicit immune response and cure infection partially or fully in animals upon challenge by protozoan parasites and helminths, thus indicating the suitability of tubulin as a vaccine against parasitic diseases.

Characterization of trifluralin binding with recombinant tubulin from Trypanosoma brucei

The binding kinetics of five novel trifluralin analogs with recombinant alpha- and beta-tubulin proteins from Trypanosoma brucei rhodesiense was determined. Native tubulin from rats was used to determine the extent of binding of each analog to mammalian tubulin. The results of this study clearly demonstrate two important characteristics of the binding of these trifluralins to tubulin. Firstly, they have specific affinity for trypanosomal tubulin compared with mammalian tubulin irrespective of the chemical composition of the trifluralin analog tested. Secondly, they have a stronger affinity for trypanosomal alpha-tubulin compared with trypanosomal beta-tubulin. In addition, compounds 1007, 1008, 1016, and 1017 have strong binding affinities for alpha-tubulin, with limited binding affinity for mammalian tubulin, which indicates that these compounds selectively bind to trypanosomal tubulin.

Mode of action of fenarimol against Leishmania spp

This paper evaluates the effects of certain herbicides on Leishmania spp., their mechanism of action, and the evolutionary origin of the relevant susceptible leishmanial targets. We demonstrated that a relatively nontoxic herbicide, fenarimol, successfully interferes with a leishmanial target, which is probably a relic of an ancient ancestor. Fenarimol impairs the function of leishmanial 14alpha-sterol demethylase, a key enzyme in the sterol biosynthetic pathway. Therefore, fenarimol or its derivatives may be candidates for development of anti-leishmanial drugs. Of the herbicides that have the capability to act as potential inhibitors of the metabolism of Leishmania spp., fenarimol was found as the most active substance against both promastigotes and amastigotes in culture. In addition, it ameliorated lesions caused by Leishmania major in mice. Light microscopy demonstrated rounding of the parasite shape. Increase of osmophilic vacuoles and autophagosomal structures were observed by transmission electron microscopy. Biochemical studies demonstrated that fenarimol inhibited sterol biosynthesis. Docking of fenarimol to the modeled catalytic binding site of 14alpha-lanosterol demethylase of L. major showed a geometrical fit. Fenarimol is stabilized via hydrophobic interactions with the residues that surround it and interactions with the heme ring. These results provide support to the hypothesis that fenarimol inhibits leishmanial sterol biosynthesis. Overall, the findings suggest an additional source of substances for development of anti-leishmanial drugs.

Trifluralin toxicity in a Chagas disease mouse model

Even though trifluralin (alpha,alpha,alpha-2,6-dinitro-N-N-dipropyl-p-toluidine) is effective for the treatment of experimental Chagas disease, more preclinical toxicity studies need to be performed. Cell toxicity of trifluralin was studied in Hep-G2 and Vero C76 cells treated with 50 and 150 microM trifluralin. The results show that duplication time, amount of cellular protein and cell protein/DNA values were normal. Histological, haematological and chemical parameters were measured in CF1 mice after oral trifluralin administration. Acute toxic effects were assayed by administration of 50 or 200 mg/kg body weight daily for 30 days, and chronic effects by administration of 200 mg/kg body weight once a week for 90 days (n = 20). In the acute scheme treatment, hepatic (glutamic-pyruvic, glutamic-oxalacetic and alkaline phosphatase activities; proteins and albumin plasma concentrations) and pancreatic (amylase, glycaemia) functions were normal. Mean corpuscular volume, haemoglobin and haematocrit decreased. Creatine phosphokinase, lactate dehydrogenase and glutamic-oxalacetic activity increased, suggesting lesion in myocardial tissue. Histology was normal, excepting for the heart (mild myocarditis). Similar results were observed in acutely treated animals. There were no differences in body weight gain for treated mice compared to controls. In view of the published therapeutic effects of trifluralin on CF1 Chagas disease model and considering the present results, trifluralin seems to be a moderately toxic drug with a potential selective effect on the myocardium.

Treatment of experimental chronic chagas disease with trifluralin

We tested trifluralin against Trypanosoma cruzi in a model of chronic Chagas disease in mice. CF1 mice (n=148) were intraperitoneally infected with 10(5) trypomastigotes of T. cruzi, H510C8C3 clone. One hundred mice were partially treated with benznidazole. Mortality was 100% at day 41 in the control group (n=48). At day 90 of the chronic disease (74% survival) mice were divided into three groups and treated orally with trifluralin (50 mg/kg/day, n=26), benznidazole (50 mg/kg/day, n=25) and vehicle (peanut oil; control group, n=23) for 60 days. Electrocardiography (under pentobarbital anaesthesia, 30 mg/kg/dose), serologic immunofluorescence and microstrout were performed at the beginning and at the end of the treatment. Mice were sacrificed at day 10 after treatment; cardiac tissue was studied histopathologically and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was performed. Spontaneous mortality was 30.43%, 3.85% and 4% in the control, trifluralin and benznidazole groups, respectively (significant survival, P=0.03). Microstrouts were negative in all three groups. Negative immunofluorescence titers were 0%, 16% (P=0.05) and 29% (P<0.02) in the control, trifluralin and benznidazole groups, respectively. The prevailing electrocardiographic disorder was prolongation of the PR interval in the control group, which was not significantly altered in trifluralin- and benznidazole-treated mice, suggesting that trifluralin and benznidazole improve or even stop the damage caused by the disease on the conduction system. Trifluralin- and benznidazole-treated animals showed similar histologic patterns of myocarditis. PCR results were negative for benznidazole and trifluralin (100% and 70.8%, respectively). These results show the therapeutic potential of trifluralin in the treatment of chronic Chagas disease.

The restoring effect of trifluralin and benznidazole on the abnormal fatty-acid pattern induced by Trypanosoma cruzi in the liver microsomes of infected mice

The fatty-acid composition of liver lipids from mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi (clone H510C8C3) or uninfected mice was investigated. The infected animals were treated orally for 30 days, with trifluralin (TFL) or benznidazole (BNZ), each at 100mg/kg.day, or only with the peanut oil used as the drug vehicle. The uninfected mice were also given the peanut oil. The treatments were stopped 10 days before the animals were killed. The liver microsomal lipids of each mouse were isolated and then analysed by gas-liquid chromatography. In terms of the total lipids, untreated infection evoked a significant increase in saturated fatty acids and the members of the n-9 fatty-acid family, with a concomitant decrease in the polyenoates of the n-3 and n-6 fatty-acid series. Each lipid subclass was affected to a different extent, the phospholipids being affected most. All lipid fractions, apart from the cholesterol esters, showed a significant increase in the proportion of n-9 isomers. Infection also produced a marked increase in the absolute amounts of triacylglycerides, cholesterol and cholesterol esters in liver microsomal membranes. After BNZ or TFL treatment, the fatty-acid pattern of mice that had been infected was indistinguishable from that of the control mice. The possible role of desaturase activity in the alterations observed is discussed.

Plasmodium: assessment of the antimalarial potential of trifluralin and related compounds using a rat model of malaria, Rattus norvegicus

A rodent model of malaria, Plasmodium berghei was used to assess the antimalarial potential of dinitroaniline herbicides. Trifluralin, pendimethalin, oryzalin, and benfluralin were all active against P. berghei in vitro at, or close to, submicromolar concentrations, with a rank order of potency similar to that against other protozoa. The dinitroanilines did not elicit a cytotoxic effect against a mammalian cell line at concentrations 100-fold higher than those for activity against P. berghei. Neither trifluralin nor oryzalin exhibited any antimalarial activity in vivo after oral administration at the maximum dose tolerated by the host. In a pharmacokinetic study, it was found that the lack of in vivo antimalarial activity was due to poor absorption. Other DNs which have better absorption characteristics than either trifluralin or oryzalin may offer more scope for antimalarial activity in vivo.

Expression of Giardia duodenalis beta-tubulin as a soluble protein in Escherichia coli

The beta-tubulin gene of the parasitic protozoan Giardia duodenalis has been expressed for the first time using a novel and direct method. The protein was expressed in both soluble and insoluble forms in an Escherichia coli-based expression system. The level of expression was found to be affected by several variables including the incubation temperature, length of time for which expression was carried out, and the E. coli culture volume. The protein expression system contributed no additional amino acids to the final fusion protein and the polyhistidine fusion sequence was easily removed from the beta-tubulin protein using a specific enterokinase enzyme. The expression system also provided a means of preparing a soluble protein and purifying it by a relatively straightforward affinity chromatography method to give a very high level of protein purity. This makes the protein suitable for a number of applications for characterization including beta-tubulin antibody assays, alpha-/beta-tubulin-binding regions, and beta-tubulin folding intermediates.

Dinitroaniline herbicides against protozoan parasites: the case of Trypanosoma cruzi

The drugs presently in use against Chagas disease are very toxic, inducing a great number of side effects. Alternative treatments are necessary, not only for Chagas disease but also for other diseases caused by protozoan parasites where current drugs pose toxicity problems. The plant microtubule inhibitor trifluralin has previously been tested with success against Leishmania, Trypanosoma brucei and several other protozoan parasites. Trypanosoma cruzi, the causative agent of Chagas disease, is also sensitive to the drug. This sensitivity has been correlated with the deduced amino acid sequences of alpha- and beta-tubulin of T. cruzi as compared with plant, mammal and other parasite sequences.

Selective and reversible effects of vinca alkaloids on Trypanosoma cruzi epimastigote forms: blockage of cytokinesis without inhibition of the organelle duplication

Vinca alkaloids, vincristine and vinblastine, produce differential effects on the cell division of Trypanosoma cruzi epimastigote forms depending on drug concentrations. These effects are related to different microtubule-based mechanisms. For 15 microM vinblastine and 50 microM vincristine, the drugs inhibit both nuclear division and cytokinesis, and affect cell shape. At 3 microM vinblastine and 10 microM vincristine, however, cytokinesis is inhibited without major effect on the progression of the cell cycle; this yields giant cells having multiple nuclei, kinetoplasts and flagella. Cultures maintained over 1 week with daily drug replacement produced cells with more than 16 nuclei and 24 kinetoplasts, indicating that an equivalent of a fifth cell cycle was initiated. The ultrastructure of the multinucleate cells showed a basic organization closely similar to that of trypanosomes. Cytokinesis inhibition by vinca alkaloids seems to result from modulations of interactions between microtubules and associated proteins, rather than from an inhibition of microtubule dynamics as is usually proposed for vinca alkaloids. Cytokinesis inhibition is reversible: after removing the drug, epimastigotes emerge from the multinucleate cells. The emerging process follows a precise axis and polarity which are determined by the position of the flagellum/kinetoplast complex. This region could play an essential role in cell morphogenesis since zoids (cells without a nucleus) are frequently observed.

The cytoskeleton of trypanosomatid parasites

Species of the trypanosomatid parasite genera Trypanosoma and Leishmania exhibit a particular range of cell shapes that are defined by their internal cytoskeletons. The cytoskeleton is characterized by a subpellicular corset of microtubules that are cross-linked to each other and to the plasma membrane. Trypanosomatid cells possess an extremely precise organization of microtubules and filaments, with some of their organelles, such as the mitochondria, kinetoplasts, basal bodies, and flagella, present as single copies in each cell. The duplication of these structures and changes in their position during life cycle differentiations provide markers and insight into events involved in determining cell form and division. We have a rapidly increasing catalog of these structures, their molecular cytology, and their ontogeny. The current sophistication of available molecular genetic techniques for use in these organisms has allowed a new functional analysis of the cytoskeleton, including functions that are intrinsic to the proliferation and pathogenicity of these parasites.

A comparison of the effects of a benzimidazole and the dinitroanilines against Leishmania infantum

Leishmania infantum promastigotes and amastigotes were axenically cultured and exposed to the known tubulin binding compounds, the dinitroanilines, trifluralin, benfluralin, pendimethalin, oryzalin and the precursor of the dinitroanilines, chloralin, as well as isomers of chloralin and trifluralin and to the benzimidazole, albendazole. Drug induced inhibition was observed using [3H]thymidine uptake compared with untreated controls. In vitro analysis demonstrated a significant difference in the activity of five of the seven dinitroanilines between both life cycle stages of L. infantum. The amastigotes were 20-times more sensitive to chloralin and its isomer than to the dinitroanilines whereas the promastigotes were similar in sensitivity to the dinitroanilines and to chloralin and its isomer. This interesting finding suggests that the dinitroaniline precursors may have different target sites in the amastigotes to those within the promastigotes. Additionally, both chloralin and its isomer, and to a lesser extent benfluralin, caused a substantial stimulation of thymidine incorporation (up to 50%) at low concentrations. Dose response analysis suggests that the dinitroanilines may have more than one mode of action against L. infantum amastigotes and promastigotes. The inhibitory effects of the dinitroanilines against L. infantum vary from previous findings using the dinitroanilines against other Leishmania spp. The 348 base pair DNA sequence coding for beta-tubulin from amino acid residues 132 to 248 was obtained for L. infantum and used to compare the in vivo efficacy of albendazole with predicted activity based on beta-tubulin sequences of known benzimidazole sensitive protozoa. The use of beta-tubulin sequence as a predictive model of benzimidazole activity is discussed with particular reference to L. infantum.

Double mutation in eleusine indica alpha-tubulin increases the resistance of transgenic maize calli to dinitroaniline and phosphorothioamidate herbicides

The repeated use of dinitroaniline herbicides on the cotton and soybean fields of the southern United States has resulted in the appearance of resistant biotypes of one of the world's worst weeds, Eleusine indica. Two biotypes have been characterized, a highly resistant (R) biotype and an intermediate resistant (I) biotype. In both cases the resistance has been attributed to a mutation in alpha-tubulin, a component of the alpha/beta tubulin dimer that is the major constituent of microtubules. We show here that the I-biotype mutation, like the R-biotype mutation shown in earlier work, can confer dinitroaniline resistance on transgenic maize calli. The level of resistance obtained is the same as that for E. indica I- or R-biotype seedlings. The combined I- and R-biotype mutations increase the herbicide tolerance of transgenic maize calli by a value close to the summation of the maximum herbicide tolerances of calli harbouring the single mutations. These data, taken together with the position of the two different mutations within the atomic structure of the alpha/beta tubulin dimer, imply that each mutation is likely to exert its effect by a different mechanism. These mechanisms may involve increasing the stability of microtubules against the depolymerizing effects of the herbicide or changing the conformation of the alpha/beta dimer so that herbicide binding is less effective, or a combination of both possibilities.

Dinitroaniline herbicide resistance and the microtubule cytoskeleton

Dinitroaniline herbicides have been used for pre-emergence weed control for the past 25 years in cotton, soybean, wheat and oilseed crops. Considering their long persistence and extensive use, resistance to dinitroanilines is fairly rare. However, the most widespread dinitroaniline-resistant weeds, the highly resistant (R) and the intermediate (I) biotypes of the invasive goosegrass Eleusine indica, are now infesting more than 1000 cotton fields in the southern states of the USA. The molecular basis of this resistance has been identified, and found to be a point mutation in a major microtubule cytoskeletal protein, alpha-tubulin. These studies have served both to explain the establishment of resistance and to reveal fundamental properties of tubulin gene expression and microtubule structure.

Microtubule Inhibitors as Potential Antimalarial Agents

The Steering Committee on Drugs for Malaria (CHEMAL) of the UNDP/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR) has identified tubulin as a potential drug target, but one that is not yet ;validated'. Several inhibitors of tubulins, the principal proteins of microtubules, are potent inhibitors of the development and multiplication of malarial parasites in culture and in vivo. However, most of these compounds are also inhibitors of mammalian cell proliferation. Here, Angus Bell reviews the structure and properties of microtubules, their roles in Plasmodium cells, and the effects of various microtubule inhibitors on the parasite. He argues that microtubule inhibitors are not equally toxic to all proliferating cells but, by virtue of differential tubulin binding, show selective toxicity that might allow their use as antimalarial drugs.

In vitro anticryptosporidial activity of dinitroaniline herbicides

Despite the evaluation of over 100 antimicrobial drugs, the diarrheal disease cryptosporidiosis has remained refractory to treatment. We report the evaluation of five dinitroaniline herbicides including trifluralin, profluralin, nitralin, pendimethalin, and fluchloralin for anticryptosporidial activity in an in vitro cultivation model of Cryptosporidium parvum. All five compounds exhibited significant anticryptosporidial activities with no corresponding evidence of toxicity. The most active compound was pendimethalin with an IC50 of 0.19 microM while nitralin was the least active with an IC50 of 4.5 microM. These compounds should be evaluated further in an animal model of cryptosporidiosis.

Efficacy of the herbicide trifluralin against four P-glycoprotein-expressing strains of Leishmania

Drug resistance has emerged as a major obstacle to chemotherapy for many infectious diseases. Trifluralin, an antimicrotubule herbicide, is a new experimental drug for treatment of leishmaniasis. Here, we found that it was effective against two strains of Leishmania that express the multidrug-resistant genes ldmdr1 and lmpgpA and two strains that express proteins that are immunologically cross-reactive with mammalian P glycoproteins. These results suggest that trifluralin is not subject to counteractions of these multidrug resistance mechanisms of Leishmania species.