Potential control of chicken coccidiosis by maternal immunization

Evaluation of immunogenicity and efficacy of the enterobactin conjugate vaccine in protecting chickens from colibacillosis

Colibacillosis is one of the most common and economically devastating infectious diseases in poultry production worldwide. Innovative universal vaccines are urgently needed to protect chickens from the infections caused by genetically diverse avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC). Enterobactin (Ent) is a highly conserved siderophore required for E. coli iron acquisition and pathogenesis. The Ent-specific antibodies induced by a novel Ent conjugate vaccine significantly inhibited the in vitro growth of diverse APEC strains. In this study, White Leghorn chickens were immunized with the Ent conjugate vaccine using a crossed design with two variables, vaccination (with or without) and APEC challenge (O1, O78, or PBS control), resulting in six study groups (9 to 10 birds/group). The chickens were subcutaneously injected with the vaccine (100 μg per bird) at 7 days of age, followed by booster immunization at 21 days of age. The chickens were intratracheally challenged with an APEC strain (10⁸ CFU/bird) or PBS at 28 days of age. At 5 days post infection, all chickens were euthanized to examine lesions and APEC colonization of the major organs. Immunization of chickens with the Ent vaccine elicited a strong immune response with a 64-fold increase in the level of Ent-specific IgY in serum. The hypervirulent strain O78 caused extensive lesions in lung, air sac, heart, liver, and spleen with significantly reduced lesion scores observed in the vaccinated chickens. Interestingly, the vaccination did not significantly reduce APEC levels in the examined organs. The APEC O1 with low virulence only caused sporadic lesions in the organs in both vaccination and control groups. The Ent conjugate vaccine altered the bacterial community of the ileum and cecum. Taken together, the findings from this study showed the Ent conjugate vaccine could trigger a strong specific immune response and was promising to confer protection against APEC infection.

Full-length transcriptome analysis and identification of transcript structures in Eimeria necatrix from different developmental stages by single-molecule real-time sequencing

Background

Eimeria necatrix is one of the most pathogenic parasites, causing high mortality in chickens. Although its genome sequence has been published, the sequences and complete structures of its mRNA transcripts remain unclear, limiting exploration of novel biomarkers, drug targets and genetic functions in E. necatrix.

Methods

Second-generation merozoites (MZ-2) of E. necatrix were collected using Percoll density gradients, and high-quality RNA was extracted from them. Single-molecule real-time (SMRT) sequencing and Illumina sequencing were combined to generate the transcripts of MZ-2. Combined with the SMRT sequencing data of sporozoites (SZ) collected in our previous study, the transcriptome and transcript structures of E. necatrix were studied.

Results

SMRT sequencing yielded 21,923 consensus isoforms in MZ-2. A total of 17,151 novel isoforms of known genes and 3918 isoforms of novel genes were successfully identified. We also identified 2752 (SZ) and 3255 (MZ-2) alternative splicing (AS) events, 1705 (SZ) and 1874 (MZ-2) genes with alternative polyadenylation (APA) sites, 4019 (SZ) and 2588 (MZ-2) fusion transcripts, 159 (SZ) and 84 (MZ-2) putative transcription factors (TFs) and 3581 (SZ) and 2039 (MZ-2) long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs). To validate fusion transcripts, reverse transcription-PCR was performed on 16 candidates, with an accuracy reaching up to 87.5%. Sanger sequencing of the PCR products further confirmed the authenticity of chimeric transcripts. Comparative analysis of transcript structures revealed a total of 3710 consensus isoforms, 815 AS events, 1139 genes with APA sites, 20 putative TFs and 352 lncRNAs in both SZ and MZ-2.

Conclusions

We obtained many long-read isoforms in E. necatrix SZ and MZ-2, from which a series of lncRNAs, AS events, APA events and fusion transcripts were identified. Information on TFs will improve understanding of transcriptional regulation, and fusion event data will greatly improve draft versions of gene models in E. necatrix. This information offers insights into the mechanisms governing the development of E. necatrix and will aid in the development of novel strategies for coccidiosis control.

Graphical Abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13071-021-05015-7.

Protective immunity against Eimeria maxima induced by vaccines of Em14-3-3 antigen

Eimeria maxima 14-3-3 (Em14-3-3) open reading frame (ORF) which consisted of 861 bp encoding a protein of 286 amino acids was successfully amplified and sequenced. Subsequently, the Em14-3-3 ORF was subcloned into pET-32a (+) and pVAX1, respectively. RT-PCR and immunoblot analyses confirmed that the target gene was successfully transcribed and expressed in vivo. Immunofluorescence analysis showed that Em14-3-3 was expressed in both the sporozoites and merozoites. The animal experiments demonstrated that both rEm14-3-3 and pVAX1-14-3-3 could clearly alleviate jejunum lesions and body weight loss. The Em14-3-3 vaccines could increase oocyst decrease ratio, as well as produce an anticoccidial index of more than 165. The percentages of CD4⁺ in both the Em14-3-3 immunized groups were much higher, when compared with those of PBS, pET32a (+), and pVAX1 controls (P < 0.05). Similarly, the anti-Em14-3-3 antibody titers of both rEm14-3-3 and pVAX1-14-3-3 immunized groups showed higher levels compared with those of PBS, pET32a (+), and pVAX1 controls (P < 0.05). The IFN-γ and tumor growth factor-β (TGF-β) levels showed significant increments in the rEm14-3-3 and pVAX1-14-3-3 immunized groups, when compared with those in the negative controls (P < 0.05). These results demonstrated that Em14-3-3 could be used as a promising antigen candidate for developing vaccines against E. maxima.

In vivolocalization of antibodies raised againstEimeria maximawall forming bodies during sexual intracellular development

Apicomplexan parasites cause devastating diseases in humans and livestock. Previously we demonstrated that antibodies targeting transmissible forms of the apicomplexan parasite,Eimeria, are effective at reducing parasite shedding thus preventing the transmission of the disease. However, the mechanisms responsible have not been fully defined. Moreover, there is no direct evidence that the parasite-specific IgG antibodies can reach the parasite developing in the enterocytes of the infected chicken host. This study summarizes our efforts using host immunity, parasite proteomics and 3D microscopy to provide a step forward in our understanding of how this immune response works.Eimeria maximais an important pathogen of poultry and used as a surrogate for a number of human pathogens includingToxoplasmaandPlasmodium. Our studies demonstrate that immunization with the purified wall forming bodies (WFBs) results in a production of parasite-specific IgG antibodies, which have the ability to reachin situgametocytes in the intestinal lumen and permeate the enterocyte/parasite membranes in order to bind to the cytoplasmic Type 1 and Type 2 WFBs. This raises the intriguing possibility that via this process antibodies block the development ofEimeria maxima in vivo.

Strategies for anti-coccidial prophylaxis

Coccidiosis, a serious disease resulting from infection with parasitic protozoa of the genusEimeria, causes significant economic losses to the poultry industry, where intensive rearing facilitates transmission of infectious oocysts via the fecal/oral route. Current control relies primarily on prophylactic drugs in feed but, whilst cost effective, the rise of drug resistance and public demands for residue-free meat has encouraged development of alternative control strategies. Chickens that recover from infection withEimeriadevelop solid immunity that is directed against the early asexual stages of the parasite life cycle. This has allowed development of a number of vaccines that utilize deliberate infection with controlled doses of virulent oocysts or reproductively attenuated lines ofEimeria.The latter are immunogenic but non-pathogenic. The realization that both prophylactic drugs and attenuated vaccines control but do not eradicate infection withEimeriaencouraged development of a vaccine based upon maternal immunity. Laying hens exposed toEimeriaare able to transfer protective antibodies to hatchlings via egg yolks and these antibodies have been used to identify parasite proteins that are conserved across the genus. When delivered maternally, these provide an economical means of preventing coccidiosis, offering immediate protection to newly hatched chicks.

Eimeria maxima recombinant Gam82 gametocyte antigen vaccine protects against coccidiosis and augments humoral and cell-mediated immunity

Intestinal infection with Eimeria, the etiologic agent of avian coccidiosis, stimulates protective immunity to subsequent colonization by the homologous parasite, while cross-protection against heterologous species is poor. As a first step toward the development of a broad specificity Eimeria vaccine, this study was designed to assess a purified recombinant protein from Eimeria maxima gametocytes (Gam82) in stimulating immunity against experimental infection with live parasites. Following Gam82 intramuscular immunization and oral parasite challenge, body weight gain, fecal oocyst output, lesion scores, serum antibody response, and cytokine production were assessed to evaluate vaccination efficacy. Animals vaccinated with Gam82 and challenged with E. maxima showed lower oocyst shedding and reduced intestinal pathology compared with non-vaccinated and parasite-challenged animals. Gam82 vaccination also stimulated the production of antigen-specific serum antibodies and induced greater levels of IL-2 and IL-15 mRNAs compared with non-vaccinated controls. These results demonstrate that the Gam82 recombinant protein protects against E. maxima and augments humoral and cell-mediated immunity.

Antibody response against endogenous stages of an attenuated strain of Eimeria tenella

The application of attenuated vaccines for the prevention of chicken coccidiosis has increased exponentially in recent years. In Eimeria infections, protective immunity is thought to rely on a strong cell mediated response with antibodies supposedly playing a minor role. However, under certain conditions antibodies seem to be significant in protection. Furthermore, antibodies could be useful for monitoring natural exposure of flocks to Eimeria spp. and for monitoring the infectivity of live vaccines. Our objective was to investigate the chicken antibody response to the different parasite life cycle stages following infection with an attenuated strain of Eimeria tenella. Western blotting analysis of parasite antigens prepared from the lining of caeca infected with the attenuated strain of E. tenella revealed two dominant antigens of 32 and 34 kDa, apparently associated with trophozoites and merozoites that were present at high concentrations between 84 and 132 h post-infection. When cryosections of caeca infected with E. tenella were probed with IgY purified from immune birds the most intense reaction was observed with the asexual stages. Western blotting analysis of proteins of purified sporozoites and third generation merozoites and absorption of stage-specific antibodies from sera suggested that a large proportion of antigens is shared by the two stages. The time-courses of the antibody response to sporozoite and merozoite antigens were similar but varied depending on the inoculation regime and the degree of oocyst recirculation.

Characterisation of the antigenic and immunogenic properties of bacterially expressed, sexual stage antigens of the coccidian parasite, Eimeria maxima

Coccidiosis in poultry is caused by the intestinal parasite Eimeria; it causes significant financial losses to the commercial poultry industry worldwide. CoxAbic is the first commercially available subunit vaccine against coccidiosis. The vaccine consists of affinity purified sexual stage (gametocyte) antigens (APGA) isolated from Eimeria maxima. Production of this vaccine is time-consuming and laborious and, therefore, a recombinant subunit vaccine substitute for CoxAbic is desirable. The genes encoding the two immunodominant components of CoxAbic, gam56 and gam82, were cloned into the bacterial expression vector, pTRCHisB, and the proteins expressed and purified. Both recombinant proteins were recognised by protective chicken antibodies that were raised to APGA, by immunoblotting. In a competitive ELISA, a combination of the recombinant proteins inhibited the binding of anti-APGA antibodies to APGA by 76%, which was comparable to the inhibition of 98% observed when APGA was used as the competing protein in the assay. In two breeds of chicken (Australorp and Cobb500), the recombinant proteins alone, or in combination, elicited a dose-dependent, antibody response that recognised APGA by ELISA, and gametocytes by immunoblotting. Together, the results suggested that the development of a recombinant subunit vaccine that maintains the antigenic and immunogenic properties of the native protein vaccine, CoxAbic, is feasible.

Managing parasiticide resistance

Resistance to antiparasitic drugs is all too common in parasites of veterinary interest. The fact that resistance has arisen in so many different species of parasite and hosts against so many different drugs and in so many geographic areas suggests that the resistances may have common features. Such features may be useful in generating ideas for resistance management. Although describing the nature and presence of resistance remains an important objective, there is now a pressing need to develop improved methods of detection of resistance and to devise schemes for integrated parasite management (IPM). Multidisciplinary teams of researchers and extension workers are exploring new ways to deal with the problem of resistance.

Progress on developing a recombinant coccidiosis vaccine

The past 10 years of research aimed at developing subunit vaccines against a number of apicomplexans, including Eimeria, Plasmodium and Toxoplasma, have, if anything, revealed the complex nature of parasite-host interactions. The Knowledge gained from this research has shown why developing a subunit vaccine based on a single recombinant antigen from one developmental stage of the parasite was an overly optimistic approach. Many apicomplexan parasites have acquired unique strategies to evade host immunity. The variable expression of genes encoding erythrocyte membrane protein 1 of Plasmodium falciparum [1] (Berendt et al. Parasitology 1994;108:S19-S28) exemplifies one such strategy. The particular mechanism for evading immune destruction depends on a number of interrelated factors, not least of which is the parasite life-cycle and the availability of susceptible hosts. The goal of any vaccine, be it an attenuated organism or a recombinant antigen, is to break the cycle of infection. The development of a recombinant vaccine against apicomplexan parasites will depend on identifying those antigens and intracellular processes that are vital to the parasite survival and those which exist merely as a way of evading immunity. The information that follows is a review of both molecular biology/biochemistry of eimerian parasites and factors that influence host immune responses to coccidia.

Control of coccidiosis: lessons from other sporozoa

Coccidiosis is the most important parasitic infection in poultry worldwide and also causes problems in cattle, sheep and goats. Control is largely limited to good husbandry and prophylactic chemotherapy using a range of drugs against which resistance is rapidly acquired. Attempts at vaccination using conventional vaccines have been disappointing and there is now a need for a new approach. Research into the immunology of coccidiosis has lagged behind that of other sporozoans and there are useful lessons that might be learned from studies on toxoplasmosis, cryptosporidiosis, theileriosis and malaria. In these infections the emphasis has turned to the cytokine network that drives the response towards protection. Central to these studies are the roles of interferon-gamma, interleukin-12 and activated macrophages with the involvement of nitric oxide in parasite killing. Cytotoxic T cells have also increasingly been implicated. Research has shown that different immune responses can be elicited by manipulating the cytokine system and these new concepts can be applied to the design of peptide or recombinant vaccines, and the possibilities of developing such vaccines against coccidiosis will be discussed.

The importance of transmission-blocking immunity in the control of infections by apicomplexan parasites

Transmission-blocking immunity may have great potential for use in the control of diseases caused by apicomplexan parasites. In this review I will describe our work on the application of transmission-blocking immunity to the control of the Eimeria parasite and compare our results to those working on transmission-blocking immunity against Cryptosporidium and Plasmodium. Eimeria causes the disease known as coccidiosis in domestic animals. Coccidiosis is particularly problematic in the chicken industry, mainly due to the crowded rearing conditions under which chicks are raised. In our work we identified, isolated and characterized 3 major gametocyte antigens (230 kDa, 82 kDa and 56/54 kDa) of Eimeria maxima. We used these native glycoproteins to immunize laying hens that, via the egg yolk, provide large amounts of transmission-blocking maternal antibodies to offspring chicks. We demonstrated that hatchlings from immunized hens shed 60-80% fewer oocysts (i.e. the infective stage of the life-cycle of Eimeria) than those from control hens. Such a reduction in oocyst output acts to significantly reduce parasite numbers in the litter of chicks raised in floor pens. This reduction in oocyst output is comparable to that seen using the most effective coccidiostat drugs and is probably sufficient to control coccidiosis under field conditions. Based on our results together with those of other groups working on transmission-blocking immunity against Cryptosporidium and Plasmodium, it appears that this immunological approach holds great promise for the control of apicomplexan parasites that cause diseases in both animals and man.

Characterization of immune response to Eimeria tenella antigens in a natural immunity model with hosts which differ serologically at the B locus of the major histocompatibility complex

A model to simulate natural immunity to Eimeria tenella was developed in three chicken lines which differ at the B locus of the major histocompatibility complex. Homozygous, 1-day-old chicks of the B19B19, B24B24, or B30B30 genotype were trickle immunized by being orally fed a small infectious dose of E. tenella oocysts for 5 consecutive days. These naturally exposed birds were then challenged at different times between 5 and 24 days after the final dose, and the level of protection was assessed 6 days after challenge, using body weight gain and intestinal lesion scores. The duration of immunity in naturally exposed birds differed among the major histocompatibility complex lines. Trickle immunization of the B19B19 haplotype afforded the longest and strongest level of protection compared to the other two haplotypes tested. In addition, in vitro splenic and peripheral blood lymphocyte proliferative responses in trickle-immunized birds were measured against sporozoite, merozoite, and tissue culture-derived E. tenella parasite antigens isolated from the recently described SB-CEV-1/F7 established cell line. The lymphocytes obtained from B19B19 birds trickle immunized responded in vitro to the E. tenella-infected SB-CEV-1/F7 tissue culture-derived parasite antigen. Furthermore, antigen-specific immune responses appeared earlier in immune, challenged B19B19 birds than in their naive, challenged counterparts. The development of a model simulating natural immunization will serve as a foundation to further characterize both humoral and cell-mediated responses to E. tenella tissue culture-derived parasite antigens and to better understand host protective immune responses to avian coccidiosis.

Characterization and immunoprotective properties of a monoclonal antibody against the major oocyst wall protein of Eimeria tenella

The oocyst wall of Eimeria spp. consists of a 10-nm-thick outer lipid layer and a 90-mm-thick inner layer of glycoprotein which has been described previously to be composed of a single major protein. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under reducing conditions and (125)I labelling of a oocyst wall fragments and of delipidated intact oocysts revealed a molecule of approximately 12 kDa as the major protein component of the oocyst wall of Eimeria tenella. An immunoglobulin M monoclonal antibody (c11B9F3) was produced against this 12-kDa oocyst wall protein sliced from a preparative SDS-polyacrylamide gel. Its reactivity by immunofluorescence against oocyst wall fragments and sporozoites or by immunoperoxidase assays of infected tissue sections was stage restricted to gametocytes and oocysts but pan-specific against all face of the oocyst wall. In chicks passively immunized with C11B9F3, oocyst output was significantly (P<0.01) reduced by 42 to 54% after homologous E. tenella infection and by 35% after heterologous Eimeria maxima infection compared with that of control groups. The results demonstrate the presence of a highly conserved, low-molecular-weight antigen on the oocyst wall and the gametocytes of Eimeria spp. which is a candidate for inclusion in a pan-specific, transmission-blocking vaccine against avian coccidiosis.

Cytokines and immunological control of Eimeria spp

Protozoan parasites belonging to the genus Eimeria cause considerable losses in livestock production in which stocking densities are high or environments restricted. The ability of hosts to mount immunological responses which limit parasite reproduction vary according to the particular species of Eimeria. Typically though, immune responses restrict parasite reproduction during primary infection and limit, if not prevent, subsequent infections. Although mechanisms of immunity are unknown, host immune responses have been exploited in the development of a method to control coccidiosis-immunisation with attenuated strains of Eimeria. Limitations of this control method, predominantly the cost of producing the attenuated parasites, necessitates identification of protective immune responses to facilitate selection of antigens for use in non-living vaccines. As in immune responses to many other parasitic infections of the gastrointestinal tract, the role of antibodies is at best minor, whereas T-cells are crucial. Numerous studies have shown that the intestinal mucosal T-cell population is dynamic; the number and phenotype of T-cells changes in response to Eimeria-infection. Specific changes in the intestinal T-cell population have not, however, been correlated with limitation of parasite reproduction. Experiments involving adoptive transfer of T-cell sub-populations and in vivo depletion of specific T-cells have shown that CD4+ T-cells and to a lesser extent CD8+ T-cells are important in immune responses which limit primary infection. In contrast, CD8+ T-cells are more important in subsequent infections with CD4+ T-cells having a lesser role. The effects of T-cells on Eimeria are partially mediated by the cytokines they release. Most attention has concentrated on interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) because these cytokines have been shown to limit other protozoan infections. IFN-gamma is produced in Eimeria-infected hosts but evidence that it is present at the site of infection is limited. Intestinal levels of IFN-gamma increase earlier in response to primary Eimeria-infection in mice which are relatively resistant, than in mice which are relatively susceptible. Neutralisation of endogenously produced IFN-gamma has shown that this cytokine limits oocyst production in either primary or secondary infections depending on the species of Eimeria. Production of TNF-alpha is also increased in infected hosts. In comparison with relatively susceptible mice, TNF-alpha is produced earlier and to a greater extent in the intestines of relatively resistant mice. Unexpectedly, injections of TNF-alpha into infected mice increased oocyst production. It remains to be determined whether the effects of endogenous TNF-alpha are the same as those of exogenous TNF-alpha. Mechanisms by which IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha modulate parasite reproduction have not been identified. A number of lines of experimentation have suggested that it is unlikely that IFN-gamma limits parasite reproduction through induction of the synthesis of reactive oxygen or reactive nitrogen intermediates, since both of these reactive intermediates have the capacity to exacerbate Eimeria-infection.