Analysis of the ion transfer through the channel of 9,11,13,15-phenylalanylgramicidin A

The membrane interface dictates different anchor roles for "inner pair" and "outer pair" tryptophan indole rings in gramicidin A channels

We investigated the effects of substituting two of the four tryptophans (the "inner pair" Trp(9) and Trp(11) or the "outer pair" Trp(13) and Trp(15)) in gramicidin A (gA) channels. The conformational preferences of the doubly substituted gA analogues were assessed using circular dichroism spectroscopy and size-exclusion chromatography, which show that the inner tryptophans 9 and 11 are critical for the gA's conformational preference in lipid bilayer membranes. [Phe(13,15)]gA largely retains the single-stranded helical channel structure, whereas [Phe(9,11)]gA exists primarily as double-stranded conformers. Within this context, the (2)H NMR spectra from labeled tryptophans were used to examine the changes in average indole ring orientations, induced by the Phe substitutions and by the shift in conformational preference. Using a method for deuterium labeling of already synthesized gAs, we introduced deuterium selectively onto positions C2 and C5 of the remaining tryptophan indole rings in the substituted gA analogues for solid-state (2)H NMR spectroscopy. The (least possible) changes in orientation and overall motion of each indole ring were estimated from the experimental spectra. Regardless of the mixture of backbone folds, the indole ring orientations observed in the analogues are similar to those found previously for gA channels. Both Phe-substituted analogues form single-stranded channels, as judged from the formation of heterodimeric channels with the native gA. [Phe(13,15)]gA channels have Na(+) currents that are ~50% and lifetimes that are ~80% of those of native gA channels. The double-stranded conformer(s) of [Phe(9,11)]gA do not form detectable channels. The minor single-stranded population of [Phe(9,11)]gA forms channels with Na(+) currents that are ~25% and single-channel lifetimes that are ~300% of those of native gA channels. Our results suggest that Trp(9) and Trp(11), when "reaching" for the interface, tend to drive both monomer folding (to "open" a channel) and dimer dissociation (to "close" a channel). Furthermore, the dipoles of Trp(9) and Trp(11) are relatively more important for the single-channel conductance than are the dipoles of Trp(13) and Trp(15).

The gramicidin channel ion permeation free-energy profile: direct and indirect effects of CHARMM force field improvements

A revised CHARMM force field for tryptophan residues is studied as well as a new grid-based correction algorithm, called CMAP, using molecular dynamics simulations of gramicidin A (1JNO) embedded in a lipid bilayer (DMPC) with 1 mol/kg NaCl or KCl saline solution. The conformational stability of the interfacial side chains is studied, which shows good stability on the 10 ns time scale. The revised force field for the tryptophan side chain produces, in the decomposition, a Na(+) PMF(Trp) profile that is consonant with the prediction from the experimental results, analyzed with rate theory by Durrant et al. (2006), but in stark contrast to the prediction of the original CHARMM force field, version 22. However, the effect is diluted in the PMF profile due to indirect effects mediated by other components of the system (polypeptide, lipid molecules, ions, and water molecules). CMAP corrections to the L-amino acids help reduce the excessive translocation barrier. Decomposition demonstrates that this effect is due to effects on the K(+) PMF(H(2)O) profile rather than on the K(+) PMF(gA) profile. The results have been confirmed to be robust using an alternative umbrella-potential method. Further force field balancing efforts (direct and indirect) are required for future studies to evaluate whether these effects give rise to predictions that are consistent with those observables extracted from real experiments.

Noncontact dipole effects on channel permeation. III. Anomalous proton conductance effects in gramicidin

Proton transport on water wires, of interest for many problems in membrane biology, is analyzed in side-chain analogs of gramicidin A channels. In symmetrical 0.1N HCl solutions, fluorination of channel Trp(11), Trp-(13), or Trp(15) side chains is found to inhibit proton transport, and replacement of one or more Trps with Phe enhances proton transport, the opposite of the effects on K(+) transport in lecithin bilayers. The current-voltage relations are superlinear, indicating that some membrane field-dependent process is rate limiting. The interfacial dipole effects are usually assumed to affect the rate of cation translocation across the channel. For proton conductance, however, water reorientation after proton translocation is anticipated to be rate limiting. We propose that the findings reported here are most readily interpreted as the result of dipole-dipole interactions between channel waters and polar side chains or lipid headgroups. In particular, if reorientation of the water column begins with the water nearest the channel exit, this hypothesis explains the negative impact of fluorination and the positive impact of headgroup dipole on proton conductance.

The preference of tryptophan for membrane interfaces: insights from N-methylation of tryptophans in gramicidin channels

To better understand the structural and functional roles of tryptophan at the membrane/water interface in membrane proteins, we examined the structural and functional consequences of Trp --> 1-methyl-tryptophan substitutions in membrane-spanning gramicidin A channels. Gramicidin A channels are miniproteins that are anchored to the interface by four Trps near the C terminus of each subunit in a membrane-spanning dimer. We masked the hydrogen bonding ability of individual or multiple Trps by 1-methylation of the indole ring and examined the structural and functional changes using circular dichroism spectroscopy, size exclusion chromatography, solid state (2)H NMR spectroscopy, and single channel analysis. N-Methylation causes distinct changes in the subunit conformational preference, channel-forming propensity, single channel conductance and lifetime, and average indole ring orientations within the membrane-spanning channels. The extent of the local ring dynamic wobble does not increase, and may decrease slightly, when the indole NH is replaced by the non-hydrogen-bonding and more bulky and hydrophobic N-CH(3) group. The changes in conformational preference, which are associated with a shift in the distribution of the aromatic residues across the bilayer, are similar to those observed previously with Trp --> Phe substitutions. We conclude that indole N-H hydrogen bonding is of major importance for the folding of gramicidin channels. The changes in ion permeability, however, are quite different for Trp --> Phe and Trp --> 1-methyl-tryptophan substitutions, indicating that the indole dipole moment and perhaps also ring size and are important for ion permeation through these channels.

Tryptophan contributions to the empirical free-energy profile in gramicidin A/M heterodimer channels

Gramicidin A/gramicidin M heterodimer conductances were measured in planar lipid bilayers and found to form two distinguishable populations about halfway between the gramicidin A and gramicidin M homodimer conductances. This implies that the principle difference in the gramicidin A and gramicidin M transport free-energy profiles occurs at the channel center, where it would produce similar effects on the rate-limiting barrier for the two heterodimers. Kinetic analysis based on this and nearly all previously published homodimer conductance data for both gramicidin A and gramicidin M channels confirms this conclusion, indicating that the translocation step is approximately 100-fold slower in gramicidin M homodimers than in gramicidin A homodimers and that first- and second-ion exit-rate constants are higher by factors of 24 and 10, respectively. Assuming that the ratios of rate constants are related to the free-energy difference between gramicidin A and gramicidin M, we construct an effective ion-Trp free-energy interaction profile that has a minimum at the channel center.

Noncontact dipole effects on channel permeation. VI. 5F- and 6F-Trp gramicidin channel currents

Fluorination of peptide side chains has been shown to perturb gramicidin channel conductance without significantly changing the average side chain structure, which, it is hoped, will allow detailed analysis of electrostatic modulation of current flow. Here we report a 1312-point potassium current-voltage-concentration data set for homodimeric channels formed from gramicidin A (gA) or any of eight fluorinated Trp analogs in both lecithin and monoglyceride bilayers. We fit the data with a three-barrier, two-site, two-ion (3B2S) kinetic model. The fluorination-induced changes in the rate constants were constrained by the same factor in both lipids. The rate constant changes were converted to transition-state free-energy differences for comparison with previous electrostatic potential energy differences based on an ab initio force field. The model allowed a reasonably good fit (chi = 8.29 with 1271 degrees of freedom). The measured changes were subtle. Nevertheless, the fitted energy perturbations agree well with electrostatic predictions for five of the eight peptides. For the other three analogs, the fitted changes suggested a reduced translocation barrier rather than the reduced exit barrier as predicted by electrostatics.

Noncontact dipole effects on channel permeation. V. Computed potentials for fluorinated gramicidin

Experimental and theoretical calculations indicate that the dipole moment of the four Trp side chains in gramicidin A (gA) channels modify channel conductance through long-range electrostatic interactions. Electrostatic ion/side-chain interaction energies along the channel were computed with CHARMM using ab initio atom charges for native and 4-, 5-, or 6-fluorinated Trp side chains. The bulk water reaction to the polar side chains was included using the method of images as implemented by, and channel waters in idealized structures were included. Ion/Trp interaction energies were approximately -0.6 kcal/mol throughout the channel for all four of the native Trp pairs. Channel waters produced a modest reduction in the magnitude of interactions, essentially offsetting images representing the bulk water outside the channel. The effects of side-chain fluorination depended on ring position and, to a lesser extent, residue number. Compared with native Trp, 5-fluorination reduces the translocation barrier with minor effects on the exit barrier. In contrast, 6-fluorination primarily reduces exit barrier. 4-Fluorination produces a more complex double-well energy profile. Effects of measured side-chain movements resulting from fluorination or change in lipid bilayer were negligible whereas thermal side chain librations cause large effects, especially in the region of the ion-binding sites.

Comparison of gramicidin A and gramicidin M channel conductance dispersities

To explore the possible role of Trp side chains in gramicidin channel conductance dispersity, we studied the dispersity of gramicidin M (gM), a gramicidin variant in which all four tryptophan residues are replaced with phenylalanine residues, and its enantiomer, gramicidin M(-) (gM(-)), and compared them to that of gramicidin A (gA). The conductances of highly purified gM and gM(-) were studied in alkali metal solutions at a variety of concentrations and voltages, in seven different types of lipid, and in the presence of detergent. Like gA channels, the most common gM channel conductance forms a narrow band. However, unlike gA channels, where the remaining 5-30% of channel conductances are broadly distributed below (and slightly above) the main band, in gM there is a narrow secondary band with <50% of the main peak conductance. This secondary peak was prominent in NaCl and KCl, but significantly diminished in CsCl and RbCl. Under some conditions, minor components can be observed with conductances yet lower than the secondary peak. Interconversions between the primary conductance state and these yet lower conductance states were observed. The current-voltage relations for both primary and secondary gM channel types have about the same curvature. The mean lifetime of the secondary channel type is below one third that of the primary type. The variants represent state deviations in the peptide or adjacent lipid structure.

Noncontact dipole effects on channel permeation. II. Trp conformations and dipole potentials in gramicidin A

The four Trp dipoles in the gramicidin A (gA) channel modulate channel conductance, and their side chain conformations should therefore be important, but the energies of different conformations are unknown. A conformational search for the right-handed helix based on molecular mechanics in vacuo yielded 46 conformations within 20 kcal/mol of the lowest energy conformation. The two lowest energy conformations correspond to the solid-state and solution-state NMR conformations, suggesting that interactions within the peptide determine the conformation. For representative conformations, the electrostatic potential of the Trp side chains on the channel axis was computed. A novel application of the image-series method of. Biophys. J. 9:1160-1170) was introduced to simulate the polarization of bulk water by the Trp side chains. For the experimentally observed structures, the CHARm toph19 potential energy (PE) of a cation in the channel center is -1.65 kcal/mol without images. With images, the PE is -1.9 kcal/mol, demonstrating that the images further enhance the direct dipole effect. Nonstandard conformations yielded less favorable PEs by 0.4-1.1 kcal/mol.

Solid-state NMR and hydrogen-deuterium exchange in a bilayer-solubilized peptide: structural and mechanistic implications

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange has been monitored by solid-state NMR to investigate the structure of gramicidin M in a lipid bilayer and to investigate the mechanisms for polypeptide insertion into a lipid bilayer. Through exchange it is possible to observe 15N-2H dipolar interactions in oriented samples that yield precise structural constraints. In separate experiments the pulse sequence SFAM was used to measure dipolar distances in this structure, showing that the dimer is antiparallel. The combined use of orientational and distance constraints is shown to be a powerful structural approach. By monitoring the hydrogen-deuterium exchange at different stages in the insertion of peptides into a bilayer environment it is shown that dimeric gramicidin is inserted into the bilayer intact, i.e., without separating into monomer units. The exchange mechanism is investigated for various sites and support for a relayed imidic acid mechanism is presented. Both acid and base catalyzed mechanisms may be operable. The nonexchangeable sites clearly define a central core to which water is inaccessible or hydroxide or hydronium ion is not even momentarily stable. This provides strong evidence that this is a nonconducting state.

Noncontact dipole effects on channel permeation. I. Experiments with (5F-indole)Trp13 gramicidin A channels

Gramicidin A (gA), with four Trp residues per monomer, has an increased conductance compared to its Phe replacement analogs. When the dipole moment of the Trp13 side chain is increased by fluorination at indole position 5 (FgA), the conductance is expected to increase further. gA and FgA conductances to Na+, K+, and H+ were measured in planar diphytanoylphosphatidylcholine (DPhPC) or glycerylmonoolein (GMO) bilayers. In DPhPC bilayers, Na+ and K+ conductances increased upon fluorination, whereas in GMO they decreased. The low ratio in the monoglyceride bilayer was not reversed in GMO-ether bilayers, solvent-inflated or -deflated bilayers, or variable fatty acid chain monoglyceride bilayers. In both GMO and DPhPC bilayers, fluorination decreased conductance to H+ but increased conductance in the mixed solution, 1 M KCl at pH 2.0, where K+ dominates conduction. Eadie-Hofstee plot slopes suggest similar destabilization of K+ binding in both lipids. Channel lifetimes were not affected by fluorination in either lipid. These observations indicate that fluorination does not change the rotameric conformation of the side chain. The expected difference in the rate-limiting step for transport through channels in the two bilayers qualitatively explains all of the above trends.

High-resolution polypeptide structure in a lamellar phase lipid environment from solid state NMR derived orientational constraints

BACKGROUND

Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy provides novel structural constraints from uniformly aligned samples. These orientational constraints orient specific atomic sites with respect to the magnetic field direction and the unique molecular axis of alignment. Solid-state NMR is uniquely and ideally suited for providing such structural constraints on polypeptides and proteins in a lamellar phase lipid environment. Membrane protein structure represents a great challenge for structural biologists; a new approach for characterizing high resolution three-dimensional structure in such an environment is needed.

RESULTS

The optimal use of orientational constraints for defining three-dimensional structures is demonstrated with the elucidation of the gramicidin A channel structure at high resolution. Initial structures are refined against both the experimental constraints and the CHARMM energy using a novel simulated-annealing protocol to define torsion angle solutions with an error bar of approximately +/- 5 degrees.

CONCLUSIONS

This analysis results in the determination of a high-resolution, time averaged structure of gramicidin A obtained in a lipid bilayer environment above the gel-to-liquid crystalline phase transition temperature. It is demonstrated that solid-state NMR can be used to establish polypeptide, and potentially protein, structures in such an environment. Furthermore, this high-resolution structure is demonstrated to provide new insights into polypeptide function. For the gramicidin A channel the roles of the indole groups that facilitate ion transport and details of the cation solvation environment provided by the amide oxygens are characterized.

Protein stability and conformational rearrangements in lipid bilayers: linear gramicidin, a model system

The replacement of four tryptophans in gramicidin A by four phenylalanines (gramicidin M) causes no change in the molecular fold of this dimeric peptide in a low dielectric isotropic organic solvent, but the molecular folds are dramatically different in a lipid bilayer environment. The indoles of gramicidin A interact with the anisotropic bilayer environment to induce a change in the molecular fold. The double-helical fold of gramicidin M, as opposed to the single-stranded structure of gramicidin A, is not compatible with ion conductance. Gramicidin A/gramicidin M hybrid structures have also been prepared, and like gramicidin M homodimers, these dimeric hybrids appear to have a double-helical fold, suggesting that a couple of indoles are being buried in the bilayer interstices. To achieve this equilibrium structure (i.e., minimum energy conformation), incubation at 68 degrees C for 2 days is required. Kinetically trapped metastable structures may be more common in lipid bilayers than in an aqueous isotropic environment. Structural characterizations in the bilayers were achieved with solid-state NMR-derived orientational constraints from uniformly aligned lipid bilayer samples, and characterizations in organic solvents were accomplished by solution NMR.

Gramicidin tryptophans mediate formamidinium-induced channel stabilization

Compared with alkali metal cations, formamidinium ions stabilize the gramicidin A channel molecule in monoolein bilayers (Seoh and Busath, 1993a). A similar effect is observed with N-acetyl gramicidin channel molecules in spite of the modified forces at the dimeric junction (Seoh and Busath, 1993b). Here we use electrophysiological measurements with tryptophan-to-phenylalanine-substituted gramicidin analogs to show that the formamidinium-induced channel molecule stabilization is eliminated when the four gramicidin tryptophans are replaced with phenylalanines in gramicidin M-. This suggests that the stabilization is mediated by the tryptophan side chains. Tryptophan residues 9, 13, and 15 must cooperate to produce the effect because replacement of any one of the three with phenylalanine significantly reduces stabilization; replacement of Trp-11 with phenylalanine causes negligible decrease in stabilization. In addition, formamidinium-related current-voltage supralinearity and open-channel noise are absent with gramicidin M-. When the lipid bilayer was formed with monoolein ether rather than monoolein ester, the channel lifetimes were reduced markedly and, at low voltage and relative to those in KCl solution, were decreased by a factor of 2, whereas the open-channel noise was unaffected and the current-voltage relation was only modestly affected. These results suggest that formamidinium modifies the state of the tryptophan side chains, which, in turn, affects channel lifetime, current-voltage supralinearity, and open-channel noise through interactions with water or lipid headgroup atoms including the lipid ester carbonyl.

Influence of the nature of the aromatic side-chain on the conductance of the channel of linear gramicidin: study of a series of 9,11,13,15-Tyr(O-protected) derivatives

This paper describes the single channel properties of a series of synthetic analogues of gramicidin A, where all four tryptophans are replaced either by tyrosine or by several O-protected (benzyl, methyl, ethyl or t-butyl) derivatives. It is shown that, although all analogues bear similar dipole moment on their side-chains, the conductance depends on the hydrophobicity of these protecting groups. An analysis of the conductance data suggests that the conductance is governed by the binding process and a possible explanation, based on conformational considerations, is proposed.

Photodynamic inactivation of an ion channel: gramicidin A

The ion channel formed by the peptide gramicidin A in planar lipid membranes is inactivated by visible light in the presence of the photosensitizer Rose Bengal. This is concluded from the strong decrease of the membrane conductance by more than two orders of magnitude. Experiments performed at different oxygen concentrations, in the presence of the singlet oxygen quenchers beta-carotene or alpha-tocopherol indicate, that presumably a type I process between the dye Rose Bengal and the tryptophan residues of the gramicidin channel with a subsequent oxidation of the tryptophans is responsible for the loss of the conductance properties of the channel.

Synthesis and ionic channels of a linear gramicidin containing naphthylalanine instead of tryptophan

Naphthylalanine gramicidin A was prepared by the solid phase method using an aminopolyacrylic resin after optical resolution of (D, L) naphthylalanine by enzymatic methods. Removal of the peptide from the resin was achieved by transesterification of the succinic ester linkage. Infrared spectroscopy indicated that the presence of naphthylalanine strongly modifies the monomer-dimer equilibrium. Single-channel measurements suggested that the conductance of the gramicidin channel can be governed by the dipole moment of the aromatic side-chains.

The different influences of ether and ester phospholipids on the conformation of gramicidin A. A molecular modelling study

With AMBER (assisted model building with energy refinement) molecular modelling techniques, the interactions between lipids which differ in the type of chain linkage (e.g., ether or ester) and gramicidin were approximated. It was found, theoretically, that replacement of the ester function in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) by an ether moiety induces a shift in the rotameric distribution of the Trp-15 side-chain in gramicidin A. Concomitantly, the channel entrance is contracted by approx. 0.4 A. The perturbation can be related to the strong hydrogen-bond formed between the lipid carbonyl group and the indole proton of the Trp-15 residue of gramicidin. In the ether lipid-gramicidin assembly a weaker H-bond is formed between Trp-15 and the phosphate moiety. To obtain a first indication of the influence of the strength of this H-bond on gramicidin A, a preliminary experimental study was set up. The transport properties of gramicidin A were studied using efflux measurements through vesicle walls containing ether and ester lipids, respectively. A change in the permeability of gramicidin A was found when ether lipids were added to a bilayer composed of the ester lipid dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC).

Single channels and surface potential of linear gramicidins

The single channel data for 4 different linear gramicidins containing either 4 Trp, 4 Phe, 4 Tyr or TyrBzl have been analyzed on the basis of 3 barriers-2 sites model. They form 2 families which differ by their single channel behavior and thus different energy profiles of the channel. A relationship between the surface potential and the entry barrier is proposed.

Gramicidin A analogs: influence of the substitution of the tryptophans by naphthylalanines

The synthesis of 4 linear gramicidins bearing both polar and non-polar aromatic side chains is described. From the single channels data, it appears that the relative positions of these residues has little or no influence on the conductance and that this conductance is governed mainly by the number of tryptophan residues. It is also shown that the effect of the bulkiness of the apolar aromatic side chain can be neglected.

Mixed monolayers of linear gramicidins and phospholipid. Surface pressure and surface potential studies

The behavior of two gramicidins incorporated into lipid monolayers is analyzed on the basis of the force and surface potential area curves. It is shown that the position of the gramicidins (helical axis parallel or perpendicular to the interface) depends on the monolayer pressure and that these molecules are not miscible with dioleoylphosphatidylcholine. Surface potential measurements suggest the existence of a relationship between the single channel characteristics and the surface potential and indicate that the tryptophans are essential for lowering the lipid surface potential in agreement with the single channel behaviour of both gramicidin A and gramicidin M.

Synthesis and characterization of Tyr(Bzl)9,11,13,15 and Tyr9,11,13,15 gramicidin A

Tyr(Bzl) and Tyr gramicidin A were prepared by the solid phase method using a 4-(oxymethyl)-Pam resin and Bpoc as alpha-amino-protecting group. The benzylated analog [Gr.T(Bzl)] was purified by chromatography on silica gel and then on LH60 Sephadex. Removal of benzyl groups was carried out by hydrogenolysis and the debenzylated derivative (Gr.T) was purified in the same way. Both gramicidins were checked and characterized by t.l.c., HPLC, circular dichroism, 1H n.m.r. and single channel measurements. CD spectra were found to be different for Gr.T(Bzl) and Gr.T and strongly dependent upon the solvent and the concentration. Single channel conductance of Gr. T is slightly lower than that of Gr.A (A Gr.T approximately equal to 0.7 A Gr.T).

Linear gramicidins at the air-water interface

The behavior of four linear gramicidins, which differ by the nature of their 9, 11, 13, and 15 aromatic residues, together with a covalent "head to tail" retro GA-DAla-GA dimer, has been examined at the air-water interface. It is shown that all four "monomers" have almost the same molecular area, which is compatible with either a single-stranded or a double-stranded helical model, whereas it is suggested that retro GA-DAla-GA could adopt another conformation. The surface potential measurements agree with those of different groups of molecules characterized by their single-channel behaviors.