Development of mouse germ cells in cultures of fetal gonads

Making a good egg: human oocyte health, aging, and in vitro development

Mammalian eggs (oocytes) are formed during fetal life and establish associations with somatic cells to form primordial follicles that create a store of germ cells (the primordial pool). The size of this pool is influenced by key events during the formation of germ cells and by factors that influence the subsequent activation of follicle growth. These regulatory pathways must ensure that the reserve of oocytes within primordial follicles in humans lasts for up to 50 years, yet only approximately 0.1% will ever be ovulated with the rest undergoing degeneration. This review outlines the mechanisms and regulatory pathways that govern the processes of oocyte and follicle formation and later growth, within the ovarian stroma, through to ovulation with particular reference to human oocytes/follicles. In addition, the effects of aging on female reproductive capacity through changes in oocyte number and quality are emphasized, with both the cellular mechanisms and clinical implications discussed. Finally, the details of current developments in culture systems that support all stages of follicle growth to generate mature oocytes in vitro and emerging prospects for making new oocytes from stem cells are outlined.

Dynamic changes of histone methylation in mammalian oocytes and early embryos

Histone methylation is a key epigenetic mechanism and plays a major role in regulating gene expression during oocyte maturation and early embryogenesis. This mechanism can be briefly defined as the process by which methyl groups are transferred to lysine and arginine residues of histone tails extending from nucleosomes. While methylation of the lysine residues is catalyzed by histone lysine methyltransferases (KMTs), protein arginine methyltransferases (PRMTs) add methyl groups to the arginine residues. When necessary, the added methyl groups can be reversibly removed by histone demethylases (HDMs) by a process called histone demethylation. The spatiotemporal regulation of methylation and demethylation in histones contributes to modulating the expression of genes required for proper oocyte maturation and early embryonic development. In this review, we comprehensively evaluate and discuss the functional importance of dynamic histone methylation in mammalian oocytes and early embryos, regulated by KMTs, PRMTs, and HDMs.

Establishment of an organ culture system to induce Sertoli cell differentiation from undifferentiated mouse gonads

Organ culture systems are useful for elucidating the process of testicular differentiation from mammalian undifferentiated genetically male gonads, as they permit various experiments, including experiments involving the control of gene expression. However, without addition of testicular differentiation-related factors, it is difficult to induce the formation of testis cord from immature gonads by a time point earlier 12 tail somites (ts) that corresponding to 11.0 days post coitum (dpc). In this study, we attempted to establish an organ culture system that induces testis formation from immature gonads (around 8 ts: 10.5 dpc) just before Sry (sex-determining region of the Y chromosome) expression. A paired gonad-mesonephros complex of around 8 ts was placed in the groove of an agarose gel block and put the semi-cylindrical piece of agarose gel to maintain the gonad morphology. The gonads were cultured in the gas phase for 96 hr. As a result, testis cord-like structures appeared in many genetically male gonads. Cells expressing the Sertoli cell markers Sox9 (SRY-box 9) and Amh (anti-Müllerian hormone) were observed, while granulosa cell marker Foxl2 (forkhead box L2) was not detected. In addition, Sox9- and Amh-expressing cells were observed throughout the entire gonad in many individuals. Amh mRNA expression was also upregulated. Surprisingly, formation of a partial testicular structure was observed from more immature gonads (6 ts). These results show that our gonadal organ culture system is useful for elucidating the regulation mechanism of Sry expression in undifferentiated bipotential gonads.

Complete in vitro oogenesis: retrospects and prospects

Precise control of mammalian oogenesis has been a traditional focus of reproductive and developmental biology research. Recently, new reports have introduced the possibility of obtaining functional gametes derived in vitro from stem cells. The potential to produce functional gametes from stem cells has exciting applications for regenerative medicine though still remains challenging. In mammalian females ovulation and fertilization is a privilege reserved for a small number of oocytes. In reality the vast majority of oocytes formed from primordial germ cells (PGCs) will undergo apoptosis, or other forms of cell death. Removal occurs during germ cell cyst breakdown and the establishment of the primordial follicle (PF) pool, during the long dormancy at the PF stage, or through follicular atresia prior to reaching the ovulatory stage. A way to solve this limitation could be to produce large numbers of oocytes, in vitro, from stem cells. However, to recapitulate mammalian oogenesis and produce fertilizable oocytes in vitro is a complex process involving several different cell types, precise follicular cell-oocyte reciprocal interactions, a variety of nutrients and combinations of cytokines, and precise growth factors and hormones depending on the developmental stage. In 2016, two papers published by Morohaku et al. and Hikabe et al. reported in vitro procedures that appear to reproduce efficiently these conditions allowing for the production, completely in a dish, of a relatively large number of oocytes that are fertilizable and capable of giving rise to viable offspring in the mouse. The present article offers a critical overview of these results as well as other previous work performed mainly in mouse attempting to reproduce oogenesis completely in vitro and considers some perspectives for the potential to adapt the methods to produce functional human oocytes.

Differentiation of Mouse Primordial Germ Cells into Functional Oocytes In Vitro

Various complex molecular events in oogenesis cannot be observed in vivo. As a bioengineering technique for female reproductive tissues, in vitro culture systems for female germ cells have been used to analyze oogenesis and preserve germ cells for over 20 years. Recently, we have established a new methodological approach for the culture of primordial germ cells (PGCs) and successfully obtained offspring. Our PGC culture system will be useful to clarify unresolved mechanisms of fertility and sterility from the beginning of mammalian oogenesis, before meiosis. This review summarizes the history of culture methods for mammalian germ cells, our current in vitro system, and future prospects for the culture of germ cells.

Etoposide damages female germ cells in the developing ovary

BACKGROUND

As with many anti-cancer drugs, the topoisomerase II inhibitor etoposide is considered safe for administration to women in the second and third trimesters of pregnancy, but assessment of effects on the developing fetus have been limited. The purpose of this research was to examine the effect of etoposide on germ cells in the developing ovary. Mouse ovary tissue culture was used as the experimental model, thus allowing us to examine effects of etoposide on all stages of germ cell development in the same way, in vitro.

RESULTS

Fetal ovaries from embryonic day 13.5 CD1 mice or neonatal ovaries from postnatal day 0 CD1 mice were cultured with 50-150 ng ml(-1) or 50-200 ng ml(-1) etoposide respectively, concentrations that are low relative to that in patient serum. When fetal ovaries were treated prior to follicle formation, etoposide resulted in dose-dependent damage, with 150 ng ml(-1) inducing a near-complete absence of healthy follicles. In contrast, treatment of neonatal ovaries, after follicle formation, had no effect on follicle numbers and only a minor effect on follicle health, even at 200 ng ml(-1). The sensitivity of female germ cells to etoposide coincided with topoisomerase IIα expression: in the developing ovary of both mouse and human, topoisomerase IIα was expressed in germ cells only prior to follicle formation.

CONCLUSIONS

Exposure of pre-follicular ovaries, in which topoisomerase IIα expression was germ cell-specific, resulted in a near-complete elimination of germ cells prior to follicle formation, with the remaining germ cells going on to form unhealthy follicles by the end of culture. In contrast, exposure to follicle-enclosed oocytes, which no longer expressed topoisomerase IIα in the germ cells, had no effect on total follicle numbers or health, the only effect seen specific to transitional follicles. Results indicate the potential for adverse effects on fetal ovarian development if etoposide is administered to pregnant women when germ cells are not yet enclosed within ovarian follicles, a process that starts at approximately 17 weeks gestation and is only complete towards the end of pregnancy.

Signaling Pathways Involved in Mammalian Sex Determination and Gonad Development

The development of any organ system requires a complex interplay of cellular signals to initiate the differentiation and development of the heterogeneous cell and tissue types required to carry out the organs' functions. In this way, an extracellular stimulus is transmitted to an intracellular target through an array of interacting protein intermediaries, ultimately enabling the target cell to elicit a response. Surprisingly, only a small number of signaling pathways are implicated throughout embryogenesis and are used over and over again. Gonadogenesis is a unique process in that 2 morphologically distinct organs, the testes and ovaries, arise from a common precursor, the bipotential genital ridge. Accordingly, most of the signaling pathways observed throughout embryogenesis also have been shown to be important for mammalian sex determination and gonad development. Here, we review the mechanisms of signal transduction within these pathways and the importance of these pathways throughout mammalian gonad development, mainly concentrating on data obtained in mouse but including other species where appropriate.

Methods for the Study of Gonadal Development

Current knowledge on gonadal development and sex determination is the product of many decades of research involving a variety of scientific methods from different biological disciplines such as histology, genetics, biochemistry, and molecular biology. The earliest embryological investigations, followed by the invention of microscopy and staining methods, were based on histological examinations. The most robust development of histological staining techniques occurred in the second half of the nineteenth century and resulted in structural descriptions of gonadogenesis. These first studies on gonadal development were conducted on domesticated animals; however, currently the mouse is the most extensively studied species. The next key point in the study of gonadogenesis was the advancement of methods allowing for the in vitro culture of fetal gonads. For instance, this led to the description of the origin of cell lines forming the gonads. Protein detection using antibodies and immunolabeling methods and the use of reporter genes were also invaluable for developmental studies, enabling the visualization of the formation of gonadal structure. Recently, genetic and molecular biology techniques, especially gene expression analysis, have revolutionized studies on gonadogenesis and have provided insight into the molecular mechanisms that govern this process. The successive invention of new methods is reflected in the progress of research on gonadal development.

In vitro differentiation of germ cells from stem cells: a comparison between primordial germ cells and in vitro derived primordial germ cell-like cells

Stem cells are unique cell types capable to proliferate, some of them indefinitely, while maintaining the ability to differentiate into a few or any cell lineages. In 2003, a group headed by Hans R. Schöler reported that oocyte-like cells could be produced from mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells in vitro. After more than 10 years, where have these researches reached? Which are the major successes achieved and the problems still remaining to be solved? Although during the last years, many reviews have been published about these topics, in the present work, we will focus on an aspect that has been little considered so far, namely a strict comparison between the in vitro and in vivo developmental capabilities of the primordial germ cells (PGCs) isolated from the embryo and the PGC-like cells (PGC-LCs) produced in vitro from different types of stem cells in the mouse, the species in which most investigation has been carried out. Actually, the formation and differentiation of PGCs are crucial for both male and female gametogenesis, and the faithful production of PGCs in vitro represents the basis for obtaining functional germ cells.

Lessons from mouse chimaera experiments with a reiterated transgene marker: revised marker criteria and a review of chimaera markers

Recent reports of a new generation of ubiquitous transgenic chimaera markers prompted us to consider the criteria used to evaluate new chimaera markers and develop more objective assessment methods. To investigate this experimentally we used several series of fetal and adult chimaeras, carrying an older, multi-copy transgenic marker. We used two additional independent markers and objective, quantitative criteria for cell selection and cell mixing to investigate quantitative and spatial aspects of developmental neutrality. We also suggest how the quantitative analysis we used could be simplified for future use with other markers. As a result, we recommend a five-step procedure for investigators to evaluate new chimaera markers based partly on criteria proposed previously but with a greater emphasis on examining the developmental neutrality of prospective new markers. These five steps comprise (1) review of published information, (2) evaluation of marker detection, (3) genetic crosses to check for effects on viability and growth, (4) comparisons of chimaeras with and without the marker and (5) analysis of chimaeras with both cell populations labelled. Finally, we review a number of different chimaera markers and evaluate them using the extended set of criteria. These comparisons indicate that, although the new generation of ubiquitous fluorescent markers are the best of those currently available and fulfil most of the criteria required of a chimaera marker, further work is required to determine whether they are developmentally neutral.

The Aorta-Gonad-Mesonephros Organ Culture Recapitulates 5hmC Reorganization and Replication-Dependent and Independent Loss of DNA Methylation in the Germline

Removal of cytosine methylation from the genome is critical for reprogramming and transdifferentiation and plays a central role in our understanding of the fundamental principles of embryo lineage development. One of the major models for studying cytosine demethylation is the mammalian germ line during the primordial germ cell (PGC) stage of embryo development. It is now understood that oxidation of 5-methylcytosine (5mC) to 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC) is required to remove cytosine methylation in a locus-specific manner in PGCs; however, the mechanisms downstream of 5hmC are controversial and hypothesized to involve either active demethylation or replication-coupled loss. In the current study, we used the aorta-gonad-mesonephros (AGM) organ culture model to show that this model recapitulates germ line reprogramming, including 5hmC reorganization and loss of cytosine methylation from Snrpn and H19 imprinting control centers (ICCs). To directly address the hypothesis that cell proliferation is required for cytosine demethylation, we blocked PI3-kinase-dependent PGC proliferation and show that this leads to a G1 and G2/M cell cycle arrest in PGCs, together with retained levels of cytosine methylation at the Snrpn ICC, but not at the H19 ICC. Taken together, the AGM organ culture model is an important tool to evaluate mechanisms of locus-specific demethylation and the role of PI3-kinase-dependent PGC proliferation in the locus-specific removal of cytosine methylation from the genome.

Toward a more precise and informative nomenclature describing fetal and neonatal male germ cells in rodents

The germ cell lineages are among the best characterized of all cell lineages in mammals. This characterization includes precise nomenclature that distinguishes among numerous, often subtle, changes in function or morphology as development and differentiation of germ cells proceed to form the gametes. In male rodents, there are at least 41 distinct cell types that occur during progression through the male germ cell lineage that gives rise to spermatozoa. However, there is one period during male germ cell development-that which occurs immediately following the primordial germ cell stage and prior to the spermatogonial stage-for which the system of precise and informative cell type terminology is not adequate. Often, male germ cells during this period are referred to simply as "gonocytes." However, this term is inadequate for multiple reasons, and it is suggested here that nomenclature originally proposed in the 1970s by Hilscher et al., which employs the terms M-, T1-, and T2-prospermatogonia, is preferable. In this Minireview, the history, proper utilization, and advantages of this terminology relative to that of the term gonocytes are described.

Effects of Growth Factors on Establishment and Propagation of Embryonic Stem Cells from Very Early Stage IVF Embryos and Their Characterization in Buffalo

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Although ES cells have been derived from very early stage embryos in different species, but, so far ES cell line could be derived from early stage IVF embryos in buffalo. The present experiment was carried out to study the effects of different growth factors on attachment, formation of ES cell colonies, their extent of passaging and relative expression of pluripotency marker in these colonies in buffalo.

METHODS AND RESULTS

For this, 8~16 cell stages zona free IVF embryos were cultured with different culture condition viz. Control, Media-I: (Control+SCF), Media-II: (Control+SCF+bFGF) and Media-III: (Control+SCF+bFGF+IGF1). A total of 25 number of embryos were cultured in each medium. The efficiency (%) of blastomere attachment, % stem cell colony formation were recorded and number of passaging were evaluated in each culture condition. The results indicated that the efficiency of embryonic blastomere attachment, % stem cell colonies formation and propagation were significantly higher when medium was supplemented with growth factors viz. SCF, bFGF and IGF-1 (Media-III) than when supplemented with either SCF or SCF+bFGF. The expression of pluripotent genes viz Oct4, Nanog, FoxD3 and KLF4 were significantly higher (p<0.005) when medium was supplemented with three growth factors.

CONCLUSIONS

It can be concluded that when 8~16 cell stages zona free IVF embryos of buffalo was cultured on feeder,the %of blastomere attachment, % of ES cell colony formation and their further propagation were higher in ES cell medium supplemented with SCF+bFGF+IGF1 which may be due to high expression of pluripotent stem cell markers.

Growth of mouse oocytes to maturity from premeiotic germ cells in vitro

In the present study, we established an in vitro culture system suitable for generating fertilizable oocytes from premeiotic mouse female germ cells. These results were achieved after first establishing an in vitro culture system allowing immature oocytes from 12–14 day- old mice to reach meiotic maturation through culture onto preantral granulosa cell (PAGC) monolayers in the presence of Activin A (ActA). To generate mature oocytes from premeiotic germ cells, pieces of ovaries from 12.5 days post coitum (dpc) embryos were cultured in medium supplemented with ActA for 28 days and the oocytes formed within the explants were isolated and cocultured onto PAGC monolayers in the presence of ActA for 6–7 days. The oocytes were then subjected to a final meiotic maturation assay to evaluate their capability to undergo germinal vesicle break down (GVBD) and reach the metaphase II (MII) stage. We found that during the first 28 days of culture, a significant number of oocytes within the ovarian explants reached nearly full growth and formed preantral follicle-like structures with the surrounding somatic cells. GSH level and Cx37 expression in the oocytes within the explants were indicative of proper developmental conditions. Moreover, the imprinting of Igf2r and Peg3 genes in these oocytes was correctly established. Further culture onto PAGCs in the presence of ActA allowed about 16% of the oocytes to undergo GVBD, among which 17% reached the MII stage during the final 16–18 hr maturation culture. These MII oocytes showed normal spindle and chromosome assembly and a correct ERK1/2 activity. About 35% of the in vitro matured oocytes were fertilized and 53.44% of them were able to reach the 2-cell stage. Finally, around 7% of the 2-cell embryos developed to the morula/blastocyst stage.

A proposal of a novel experimental procedure to genetically identify disease gene loci in humans

Forward genetics in humans is beneficial in terms of diagnosis and treatment of genetic diseases, and discovery of gene functions. However, experimental mating is not possible among humans. In order to overcome this problem, I propose a novel experimental procedure to genetically identify human disease gene loci. To accomplish this, somatic cells from patients or their parents are reprogrammed to the pluripotent state, oogenesis is induced, the oocytes are parthenogenetically activated in the presence of cytochalasin, and embryonic stem cells are established from the parthenogenetic blastocysts. This protocol produces a set of diploid pluripotent stem cell clones having maternal and paternal chromosomes in different manners to each other. The genetic loci for the disease genes are determined through the conventional processes of positional cloning. Thus, taking advantage of the strategy proposed here, if the abnormality is reproducible using patient-derived pluripotent stem cells, a single carrier of the genetic mutations would be adequate to identify the disease gene loci.

Mouse germ cell development: from specification to sex determination

Primordial germ cells (PGCs) are embryonic progenitors for the gametes. In the gastrulating mouse embryo, a small group of cells begin expressing a unique set of genes and so commit to the germline. Over the next 3-5 days, these PGCs migrate anteriorly and increase rapidly in number via mitotic division before colonizing the newly formed gonads. PGCs then express a different set of unique genes, their inherited epigenetic imprint is erased and an individual methylation imprint is established, and for female PGCs, the silent X chromosome is reactivated. At this point, germ cells (GCs) commit to either a female or male sexual lineage, denoted by meiosis entry and mitotic arrest, respectively. This developmental program is determined by cues emanating from the somatic environment.

Effects of in vitro culture of mouse fetal gonads on subsequent ovarian development in vivo and oocyte maturation in vitro

Under organ culture, female fetal gonads in mice cannot develop beyond the preantral follicle stage unless the follicles are individually isolated and cultured again. In this study, we investigated the effect of in vitro culture of female fetal gonads before transplantation on subsequent in vivo development. The gonads derived from female fetuses 12.5 days postcoitum were organ-cultured for 0, 7 and 14 days, and then were grafted underneath the kidney capsules of severe combined immunodeficient mice and recovered at 21, 14 and 7 days post-transplantation, respectively. The histological analysis of the grafts showed that the in vitro culture of the fetal gonads restricted follicular development to the antral follicle stage post-transplantation. In the grafts cultured for 14 days, particularly, no antral follicle was observed. However, the oocytes in these follicles had grown to around 65 microm in diameter and had competence to resume meiosis in vitro. When the fetal gonads were grafted after culture for 7 and 14 days, 13.0% and 6.8% of the oocytes progressed to the metaphase II stage, respectively. These data showed significant differences (P < 0.05) in comparison with the control group (25.3%). Our results indicate that the in vitro culture of female fetal gonads before transplantation affects the subsequent in vivo development of both follicular cells and oocytes, and in vitro oocyte maturation. However, this effect seems to be more severe in terms of follicular development when compared with oocyte growth and maturation.

Cell cycle analysis of fetal germ cells during sex differentiation in mice

Background information. Primordial germ cells in developing male and female gonads are responsive to somatic cell cues that direct their sex-specific differentiation into functional gametes. The first divergence of the male and female pathways is a change in cell cycle state observed from 12.5 dpc (days post coitum) in mice. At this time XY and XX germ cells cease mitotic division and enter G₁/G₀ arrest and meiosis prophase I respectively. Aberrant cell cycle regulation at this time can lead to disrupted ovarian development, germ cell apoptosis, reduced fertility and/or the formation of germ cell tumours.

Results. In order to unravel the mechanisms utilized by germ cells to achieve and maintain the correct cell cycle states, we analysed the expression of a large number of cell cycle genes in purified germ cells across the crucial time of sex differentiation. Our results revealed common signalling for both XX and XY germ cell survival involving calcium signalling. A robust mechanism for apoptosis and checkpoint control was observed in XY germ cells, characterized by p53 and Atm (ataxia telangiectasia mutated) expression. Additionally, a member of the retinoblastoma family and p21 were identified, linking these factors to XY germ cell G₁/G₀ arrest. Lastly, in XX germ cells we observed a down-regulation of genes involved in both G₁- and G₂-phases of the cell cycle consistent with their entry into meiosis.

Conclusion. The present study has provided a detailed analysis of cell cycle gene expression during fetal germ cell development and identified candidate factors warranting further investigation in order to understand cases of aberrant cell cycle control in these specialized cells.

Developmental and Ultrastructual Characteristics of Mouse Oocytes Grown in Vitro from Primordial Germ Cells

The aim of this study was to clarify the developmental and ultrastructual characteristics of oocytes grown in vitro from primordial germ cells. The female genital ridges at 12.5 days post coitus were cultured for 18 days on an insert membrane in Waymouth's MB752/1 medium, supplemented with 15% fetal bovine serum and 1 mM sodium pyruvate; subsequently, the follicles isolated from the tissue were cultured for eight days in Waymouth's medium supplemented with 5 microg/ml insulin, 5 microg/ml transferrin, 5 ng/ml selenium, 10 mIU/ml follicle stimulating hormone, and 100 ng/ml stem cell factor. The primordial germ cells developed in vitro into oocytes of more than 60 microm in diameter. The transmission electron microscopic analysis indicated that the oocytes, which developed in vitro, showed no obvious abnormality in their ultrastructure and had organelles appropriate for the oocyte size. However, a delay in the progressive changes of morphology in some of the organelles during oocyte growth was often found when comparing them to oocytes grown in vivo.

Evaluation of triploid<-->diploid and trisomy-3<-->diploid mouse chimeras as models for investigating how lineage restriction occurs in confined placental mosaicism

Human confined placental mosaicism (CPM), where the placental trophoblast is mosaic for a chromosome abnormality but the fetus is chromosomally normal, can cause problems for prenatal diagnosis, but its causes are poorly understood. Tetraploid↔diploid chimeras provide a model for the development of one type of CPM, but animal models for other types of restricted mosaicism are needed. The objective of the present study was to evaluate triploid↔diploid and trisomy-3↔diploid chimeric mouse conceptuses as new models for investigating the development of restricted mosaicism. Novel stocks of mice were generated to produce triploid and trisomy-3 embryos that could be identified by DNA in situ hybridisation to a chromosome 3 transgenic marker. Triploid↔diploid and trisomy-3↔diploid mouse chimeras were produced by embryo aggregation, and the contribution of triploid or trisomy-3 cells was analysed in the fetus and extraembryonic tissues. Only two trisomy-3↔diploid chimeras were analysed but trisomy-3 cells contributed well to all lineages, so these chimeras did not show restricted mosaicism. In contrast, triploid cells usually contributed poorly to all lineages in the ten 3n↔2n chimeras analysed. They contributed more to the primitive endoderm derivatives than other lineages and were present in the primitive endoderm derivatives of all ten chimeras, but excluded from fetuses and trophectoderm derivatives in some cases. This pattern of restricted mosaicism differs from that reported for tetraploid cells in tetraploid↔diploid chimeras, and triploid↔diploid chimeras may provide a useful model for the development of some types of restricted mosaicism in human conceptuses.

In vitro development of mouse fetal germ cells into mature oocytes

Little is known about the mechanisms underlying primordial follicular formation and the acquisition of competence to resume meiosis by growing oocytes. It is therefore important to establish an in vitro experimental model that allows one to study such mechanisms. Mouse follicular development has been studied in vitro over the past several years; however, no evidence has been presented showing that mature oocytes can be obtained from mouse fetal germ cells prior to the formation of primordial follicles. In this study, a method has been established to obtain mature oocytes from the mouse fetal germ cells at 16.5 days postcoitum (dpc). From the initiation of primordial follicular formation to the growth of early secondary follicles, ovarian tissues from 16.5 dpc fetal mice were cultured in vitro for 14 days. Subsequently, 678 intact secondary follicles were isolated from 182 mouse fetal ovaries and cultured for 12 days. A total of 141 oocytes inside antral follicles were matured in vitro, and 102 oocytes underwent germinal vesicle breakdown. We found that 97 oocytes were fertilized and 15 embryos were able to form morula-blastocysts. We also analyzed various genomic imprinting markers and showed that the erasure of genomic imprinting markers in the parental generation was also imposed on the oocytes that developed from fetal germ cells. Our results demonstrate that mouse fetal germ cells are able to form primordial follicles with ovarian cells, and that oocytes within the growing follicles are able to mature normally in vitro.

The role of Sry in mammalian sex determination

The testis-determining gene is the Y-linked gene responsible for initiating the developmental pathway leading to testis formation in males. A strategy based on determining the precise chromosomal location of this locus has been used to clone a new gene which has been called SRY in humans (Sry in mice). A variety of studies now show that this is indeed the testis-determining gene. Sry has a spatial and temporal pattern of expression which correlates with the initiation of testis differentiation. The amino acid sequence encoded by the gene suggests that the protein may function as a transcription factor, which fits well with models of sex determination. Some cases of XY sex reversal in humans and mouse have been attributed to mutations in SRY/Sry, indicating that it is normally necessary for testis determination. The finding that a genomic fragment carrying Sry can cause male development in XX mice has proved that Sry is the only gene from the Y chromosome necessary for testis determination.

Sex-specific differences in mouse DMRT1 expression are both cell type- and stage-dependent during gonad development

Immunohistochemistry was used to examine GCNA1, a germ cell-specific protein, together with DMRT1 (Doublesex and Mab-3-related transcription factor-1), a transcription factor implicated in Sertoli cell and germ cell function, in order to resolve DMRT1's cellular profile during pre- and postnatal gonad development in the mouse. In the indifferent gonad (10.5-11.5 days postcoitus [dpc]), DMRT1 localized to somatic cells and GCNA1(+) germ cells and was indistinguishable in males and females. By 12.5 dpc, a clear sexual preference for DMRT1 in male somatic cells was observed, with male DMRT1 localized to testicular cords and more abundant in Sertoli cells than in germ cells and female DMRT1 diffusely labeled and markedly lower in somatic cells than in germ cells. A male somatic preference continued throughout development, with DMRT1 evident in Sertoli cells at all ages examined and absent in ovarian somatic cells from 13.5 dpc onward. In contrast, expression in primordial germ cells was not sexually distinct, and both sexes showed DMRT1 increasing through 13.5 dpc and absent by 15.5 dpc. Notably, sexual differences in germ cell DMRT1 were detected after birth, when it was detected only in spermatogonia of the testis. Colocalization of DMRT1 with proliferation markers KI67 and proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and stem cell markers OCT4 (also known as POU5F1) and NGN3 indicated that, in postnatal testes, DMRT1 was present in both stem and proliferating spermatogonia. Together, the findings implicate opposite functions for DMRT1 in somatic and germ cells of the testis. In Sertoli cells, DMRT1 expression correlated with differentiation, whereas in germ cells, it suggested a role in expansion and maintenance of undifferentiated spermatogonia.

Retinoic acid, meiosis and germ cell fate in mammals

Although mammalian sex is determined genetically, the sex-specific development of germ cells as sperm or oocytes is initiated by cues provided by the gonadal environment. During embryogenesis, germ cells in an ovary enter meiosis, thereby committing to oogenesis. By contrast, germ cells in a testicular environment do not enter meiosis until puberty. Recent findings indicate that the key to this sex-specific timing of meiosis entry is the presence or absence of the signaling molecule retinoic acid. Although this knowledge clarifies a long-standing mystery in reproductive biology, it also poses many new questions, which we discuss in this review.

Live offspring produced by mouse oocytes derived from premeiotic fetal germ cells

Mature mouse oocytes currently can be generated in vitro from the primary oocytes of primordial follicles but not from premeiotic fetal germ cells. In this study we established a simple, efficient method that can be used to obtain mature oocytes from the premeiotic germ cells of a fetal mouse 12.5 days postcoitum (dpc). Mouse 12.5-dpc fetal ovaries were transplanted under the kidney capsule of recipient mice to initiate oocyte growth from the premeiotic germ cell stage, and they were recovered after 14 days. Subsequently, the primary and early secondary follicles generated in the ovarian grafts were isolated and cultured for 16 days in vitro. The mature oocytes ovulated from these follicles were able to fertilize in vitro to produce live offspring. We further show that the in vitro fertilization offspring were normal and able to successfully mate with both females and males, and the patterns of the methylated sites of the in vitro mature oocytes were similar to those of normal mice. This is the first report describing premeiotic fetal germ cells able to enter a second meiosis and support embryonic development to term by a combination of in vivo transplantation and in vitro culture. In addition, we have shown that the whole process of oogenesis, from premeiotic germ cells to germinal vesicle (GV)-stage oocytes, can be carried out under the kidney capsule.

Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) regulates endocrine activity of the embryonic testis in the mouse

Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) is important for gonadal and reproductive functions in mammals, although the physiological role of this growth factor during gonadal development in rodents remains largely unknown. Here, we examined the steady-state levels of IGF-I mRNA by the reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). IGF-I protein expression was also detected by Western blot. The effect of IGF-I as promoter of 17alpha-hydroxylase/C17-20 lyase and 17beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase enzyme activity in vitro was evaluated by radioimmunoassay. Onset of IGF-I gene expression was on day E10 (urogenital ridge stage). IGF-I mRNA expression was markedly reduced on days E12 and E13 (testicular differentiation stage). IGF-I transcripts increased on day E14 and their transcription levels were maintained throughout the stages analyzed. Several IGF-I protein bands of 31-100 kDa were observed. Culture experiments demonstrated that 17alpha-hydroxyprogesterone and testosterone (T) secretion levels increased in the presence of IGF-I on days E11-E17. Additive effects of IGF-I plus (Bu)2cAMP were also seen during testicular development. It is proposed that IGF-I regulates the expression of key steroidogenic enzymes important for endocrine activity of the testis during prenatal development leading to establishment of the male phenotype and fertility.

Genes associated with the development of the male germ line

The development of the mammalian germ line has been well studied, from the designation of primordial germ cells and their migration in the embryo to their progression through gametogenesis. The pattern of germ cell development, as established through classical studies, is now being overlaid with molecular, genetic and epigenetic data. Eventually, proteonomics will lead to a deeper understanding of the function of these genes. Through knowledge of germ cell gene expression patterns, it is now possible to develop transgenic molecular tools for the isolation of germ cells at different stages of development. By linking stage-specific germ cell promoter regions to the green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter gene it is possible to tag these cells genetically for histological identification and cell sorting. Our long-term goal is to develop male germ cells as stem cells for therapeutic purposes. It is hoped that this goal will be achieved by purifying germ cells at different stages in development and gaining a deeper understanding of them by studying their gene expression patterns, potency and plasticity, both in vivo and in vitro.

A nuclear export signal within the high mobility group domain regulates the nucleocytoplasmic translocation of SOX9 during sexual determination

In mammals, male sex determination starts when the Y chromosome Sry gene is expressed within the undetermined male gonad. One of the earliest effect of Sry expression is to induce up-regulation of Sox9 gene expression in the developing gonad. SOX9, like SRY, contains a high mobility group domain and is sufficient to induce testis differentiation in transgenic XX mice. Before sexual differentiation, SOX9 protein is initially found in the cytoplasm of undifferentiated gonads from both sexes. At the time of testis differentiation and anti-Müllerian hormone expression, it becomes localized to the nuclear compartment in males whereas it is down-regulated in females. In this report, we used NIH 3T3 cells as a model to examine the regulation of SOX9 nucleo-cytoplasmic shuttling. SOX9-transfected cells expressed nuclear and cytoplasmic SOX9 whereas transfected cells treated with the nuclear export inhibitor leptomycin B, displayed an exclusive nuclear localization of SOX9. By using SOX9 deletion constructs in green fluorescent protein fusion proteins, we identified a functional nuclear export signal sequence between amino acids 134 and 147 of SOX9 high mobility group box. More strikingly, we show that inhibiting nuclear export with leptomycin B in mouse XX gonads cultured in vitro induced a sex reversal phenotype characterized by nuclear SOX9 and anti-Müllerian hormone expression. These results indicate that SOX9 nuclear export signal is essential for SOX9 sex-specific subcellular localization and could be part of a regulatory switch repressing (in females) or triggering (in males) male-specific sexual differentiation.

Mammalian germ cells: birth, sex, and immortality

The germ cell lineage in the mouse is not predetermined but is established during gastrulation, in response to signalling molecules acting on a subset of epiblast cells that move through the primitive streak together with extra-embryonic mesoderm precursors. After migration to the site of the future gonads, germ cell sex determination is achieved, with germ cell phenotype in male and female embryos diverging. Evidence suggests that all germ cells spontaneously take the female pathway, entering prophase of the first meiotic division five or six days after the birth of the germ cell lineage, with the exception of those located in the embryonic testis, which exit the cell cycle in response to some inhibitory signal and remain in Go until after birth, when spermatogenesis begins. In culture, germ cells respond to certain growth factors by proliferating indefinitely. These immortalized embryonic germ (EG) cell lines are chromosomally stable and pluripotent, closely resembling the embryonic stem (ES) cell lines derived from blastocyst-stage embryos. Human EG and ES cell lines have recently been made, raising the hope that their differentiation could be directed to specific cell types, of value in the clinical treatment of degenerative diseases.

Mesenchymal cell precursors of peritubular smooth muscle cells of the mouse testis can be identified by the presence of the p75 neurotrophin receptor

In the mouse embryo, at approximately 11.5 days postcoitum (dpc), cells migrate from the mesonephros into the developing testis to contribute to the somatic population of the interstitial compartment (i.e., peritubular myoid cells, Leydig cells, and endothelial cells). Studies from this laboratory have shown that the interstitial population of mesenchymal cells in fetal and newborn mouse testis express the p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75NTR, formerly known as the low-affinity nerve growth factor receptor); part of the cell population progressively congregates around testis cords, later to be replaced by contractile peritubular myoid cells, which express smooth muscle cell markers. In the present study, we show that the migrating cells and the p75NTR-expressing cells are the same population. We also show that the neurotrophin receptor is a useful endogenous marker to follow cell migration within the urogenital ridge and to identify and isolate mesenchymal precursors of myoid cells. A time-course immunolocalization study of the location of p75NTR-bearing cells within the urogenital ridge of mouse embryos between 10.5 and 12.5 dpc showed that the interstitium of the fetal testis was progressively occupied by p75NTR+ cells. The progressive increase of p75NTR expression within the developing testis was confirmed by immunoblot analysis of proteins isolated from the fetal gonads. Organ cultures of isolated testes or testis-mesonephros grafts confirmed that p75NTR+ cells do not appear in the testis unless a mesonephros is attached to it. Cells bearing the p75NTR receptor, purified from 12.5-dpc male mouse mesonephroi by immunomagnetic sorting, were able to differentiate in vitro into myoid cells. Immunofluorescence analysis of postnatal testis sections confirmed the presence around the tubules of cells coexpressing p75NTR and alpha-smooth muscle actin. The ability to identify and purify precursors of myoid cells may be of considerable help for studying the mechanisms regulating their differentiation.

Desert hedgehog (Dhh) gene is required in the mouse testis for formation of adult-type Leydig cells and normal development of peritubular cells and seminiferous tubules

Testes from adult and prepubertal mice lacking the Desert hedgehog (DHH:) gene were examined in order to describe further the role of Dhh in spermatogenesis because, in a previous report, DHH:-null male mice were shown to be sterile. Dhh is a signaling molecule expressed by Sertoli cells. Its receptor, patched (Ptc), has been previously localized to Leydig cells and is herein described as being localized also to peritubular cells. Two phenotypes of the mice were observed: masculinized (7.5% of DHH:-null males) and feminized (92.5%), both of which displayed abnormal peritubular tissue and severely restricted spermatogenesis. Testes from adult feminized animals lacked adult-type Leydig cells and displayed numerous undifferentiated fibroblastic cells in the interstitium that produced abundant collagen. The basal lamina, normally present between the myoid cells and Sertoli cells, was focally absent. We speculate that the abnormal basal lamina contributed to other characteristics, such as extracordal gonocytes, apolar Sertoli cells, and anastomotic seminiferous tubules. The two DHH:-null phenotypes described have common peritubular cell defects that may be indicative of the essential role of peritubular cells in development of tubular morphology, the differentiation of Leydig cells, and the ultimate support of spermatogenesis.

Mesonephric stromal cells differentiate into Leydig cells in the mouse fetal testis

Circumstantial evidence has suggested that Sry expression probably occurs in pre-Sertoli cells, implying that they produce signals required for testis differentiation. From experiments involving gonad/mesonephros grafts it has been shown that, at 11.5 days postcoitum stromal cells from the mesonephros invade the male gonad. Although in the grafted testes, Leydig cells appeared among the stromal cells, in these studies their origin remained elusive. In the current study, we reconstructed urogenital ridges in organ culture by grafting morphologically undifferentiated male genital ridges from CD-1 embryos, to mesonephroi from ROSA26 transgenic embryos whose cells express the bacterial beta-galactosidase. With an improved technique for the detection of beta-gal enzyme activity in electronmicrographs, we studied cell migration and differentiation of mesonephric cells into the testis in reconstructed urogenital ridges with XY or XX mesonephroi. It was found that, in addition to differentiation of myoid and connective cells, some migratory mesonephric cells acquired ultrastructural features of steroidogenic Leydig cells. Several beta-gal positive cells differentiated as Leydig cells in gonads grafted with either male or female mesonephros. The results suggest that mesonephric cells responded to putative signal(s) produced in the male gonad and participate in morphogenesis and cell differentiation of the fetal testis.

Differential expression of the Oct-4 transcription factor during mouse germ cell differentiation

The POU transcription factor Oct-4 is expressed in early mouse embryogenesis and in pluripotent ES and EC stem cell lines. After gastrulation in the embryo, Oct-4 expression is confined to the germline. The present study provides evidence that Oct-4 undergoes downregulation during oogenesis and spermatogenesis, coincident with entry into meiosis. Furthermore, analysis of maturation stages of oocytes showed that Oct-4 is upregulated de novo in the final stages of meiotic prophase I in female germ cells. These data suggest that Oct-4 downregulation in germ cells in both sexes might represent one of the molecular triggers involved in the commitment to meiosis. The upregulation of Oct-4 in oocytes at the completion of the prophase I of meiotic division further suggests a specific involvement of this transcription factor in oocyte growth or the acquisition of meiotic competence.

Entry of mouse embryonic germ cells into meiosis

Germ cells harvested from mouse embryonic genital ridges were mixed with disaggregated embryonic lung cells, and the reaggregates were cultured for 4-7 days. Germ cells derived from female embryos 10.5-13.5 days postcoitum (dpc) entered and progressed through meiotic prophase in vitro as in vivo, although with a 12- to 24-hr delay. If the cultures were maintained for 2-3 weeks, the germ cells developed into growing oocytes. When germ cells were taken from male embryos 10.5 and 11.5 dpc, they too entered and progressed through meiotic prophase, but germ cells from later embryos (12.5 and 13.5 dpc) developed as prospermatogonia, as in male genital ridges in vivo. When 11.5 dpc male genital ridges were disaggregated, reaggregated, and cultured in the same way as the lung reaggregates, the germ cells again entered meiotic prophase. We conclude that the male genital ridge at about 12 dpc produces a factor that inhibits entry of germ cells into meiosis, and that production of this factor is disrupted by prior disaggregation of the genital ridge. If a meiotic inducing substance is required for entry of germ cells into meiosis, it must be present in the male genital ridge as well as in the female genital ridge, and probably also in the lung.

Sex-dependent expression of placental (P)-cadherin during mouse gonadogenesis

BACKGROUND

Placental (P)-cadherin is one of a family of cell adhesion molecules that participate in embryonic sorting and organogenesis. In previous work, P-cadherin was localized to Sertoli cells in the mouse testis as early as postnatal day 1. This early postnatal localization raised questions about when P-cadherin first appeared in the embryonic testis and whether P-cadherin was expressed differentially in the embryonic testis and ovary.

METHODS

The localization of P-cadherin, epithelial (E)-cadherin, and Müllerian inhibiting substance was determined in frozen sections of mouse gonads between embryonic days 10.5 and 18 using indirect immunohistochemistry. Alkaline phosphatase reactivity was used to identify germ cells.

RESULTS

The expression of P-cadherin was traced back to the indifferent stage of gonadogenesis where uniform distribution was observed in the indifferent gonad of both sexes. However, after sexual differentiation, the expression of P-cadherin in the testis was localized to Sertoli cells in the testicular cords, while its expression in the ovary fell below detectable levels.

CONCLUSIONS

The localization of P-cadherin in the male and female indifferent gonad is similar and cannot be used to distinguish the future testis and ovary. The localization of P-cadherin in the testis after sexual differentiation suggests a role for P-cadherin in testicular cord formation. The common temporal pattern of P-cadherin and Müllerian inhibiting substance expression in Sertoli cells is consistent with a shared regulatory mechanism.

A quantitative test for developmental neutrality of a transgenic lineage marker in mouse chimaeras

The mouse transgene, provisionally designated TgN(Hbb-b1)83Clo, was produced by Dr C. Lo by pronuclear injection of the cloned beta-major globin gene and comprises a highly reiterated sequence that is readily detected by DNA in situ hybridization on histological sections. This fulfils many of the requirements of an ideal genetic cell marker and has been widely used for lineage studies with mouse chimaeras. However, it is not known whether it causes cell selection or influences developmental processes, such as cell mixing, in chimaeric tissues. In the present study, non-transgenic genetic markers (electrophoretic polymorphisms of glucose phosphate isomerase and differences in eye pigmentation) revealed no significant effect of the presence of hemizygous transgenic cells on the overall composition, size or gross morphology of 12 1/2 d chimaeric foetuses, placentas or extraembryonic membranes. Also, a previously described maternal genetic effect on the composition of chimaeric tissues occurred in the presence or absence of the transgene. These tests have demonstrated that hemizygous cells are not at a significant selective disadvantage, when incorporated into mouse aggregation chimaeras with non-transgenic cells. Further studies are needed to test whether homozygous transgenic cells are also selectively neutral and to test whether hemizygous or homozygous transgenic cells influence developmental processes, such as cell mixing, that were not tested.

Multiple functions for Pax6 in mouse eye and nasal development

Mouse embryos, homozygous for the small eye (Sey) mutation die soon after birth with severe facial abnormalities that result from the failure of the eyes and nasal cavities to develop. Mutations in the Pax6 gene are responsible for the Sey phenotype. As a general disruption of eye and nasal development occurs in the homozygous Sey embryos, it is unclear, from the mutant phenotype alone, which tissues require functional Psx6. To examine the roles for Pax6 in eye and nasal development we produced chimeric mouse embryos composed of wild-type and Sey mutant cells. In these embryos we found that mutant cells were excluded from both the lens and nasal epithelium. Both of these tissues were smaller, and in some cases absent, in chimeras with high proportions of mutant cells. The morphology of the optic cup was also severely affected in these chimeras; mutant cells were excluded from the retinal pigmented epithelium and did not intermix with wild-type cells in other regions. The evidence shows that Pax6 has distinct roles in the nasal epithelium and the principal tissue components of the embryonic eye, acting directly and cell autonomously in the optic cup and lens. We suggest that Pax6 may promote cell surface changes in the optic cup and control the fate of the ectoderm from which the lens and nasal epithelia are derived.

Effects of extracellular matrix on differentiation of mouse fetal gonads in the absence of mesonephros in vitro

The influence of mesonephric tissues and the extracellular matrix on mouse gonadal differentiation was examined in vitro. Gonadal ridges, with or without the adjacent mesonephric region, were removed from mouse embryos on day 12 post coitum (p.c.), and cultured in the presence or absence of reconstituted basement membrane (matrigel) for 5 days. Culturing control undifferentiated testes with mesonephric tissues induced normal testicular differentiation. When testes without mesonephric tissues were cultured in the absence of matrigel, testicular cord formation was not observed in the explants. Sertoli cells were irregularly arranged in the testicular parenchyma, and no continuous basal lamina was formed around the Sertoli cells. However, when testes without mesonephric tissues were embedded in matrigel and cultured for 5 days, the Sertoli cells were organized into testicular cord-like structures. The Sertoli cells positioned at the base of the cord-like structures were closely connected to the matrigel at their basal surface, and showed a polarized distribution of vimentin filaments in their basal cytoplasm. Leydig cells, on the other hand, were differentiated in all testicular explants. In all ovarian explants, germ cells normally entered meiotic prophase. Therefore, these findings indicate that the extracellular matrix permits testicular differentiation in the absence of the mesonephros, and that removal of mesonephric tissues leads to developmental failure of cord formation because the components of the extracellular matrix around pre-Sertoli cells are incomplete.

Germ cells and germ cell sex

Whether germ cells succeed in making eggs or sperm depends both on their genetic constitution and on the tissue environment in which they develop. The decision as to whether it is oogenesis or spermatogenesis on which they initially embark depends only on their environment, however, and not at all on their own chromosomes. The foetal testis of the mouse produces an inhibitor of meiosis: germ cells that are exposed to it develop as prospermatogonia. Germ cells in the foetal ovary enter meiosis and develop as oocytes: this may represent the default pathway for germ cell sexual differentiation, or there may exist a meiosis-inducing substance. Experimental evidence suggests that any such substance must be present ubiquitously, not just in the ovary. The stage of foetal development at which meiosis is initiated may be programmed in the germ cell lineage.

Expression of a linear Sry transcript in the mouse genital ridge

Sry is the Y-chromosomal gene that is pivotal in the determination of sex in mammals, however the structure of the Sry transcript produced in the embryo has not been determined. We show here that the transcript expressed in the developing mouse gonad at the sex determining stage of development is linear, polyadenylated and encoded by a single exon, in contrast to the circular, apparently untranslated transcript produced in adult testes. The linear transcript was not detected in any other fetal tissue nor in any adult tissue tested, and was expressed only in the genital ridge portion of the urogenital ridge. The spatial and temporal profile of Sry expression suggests that its role in the mouse fetus is limited to initiating Sertoli cell development during testis determination.

A maternal genetic effect on the composition of mouse aggregation chimaeras

Two series of 12 1/2 day mouse chimaeric conceptuses were produced by aggregating (C57BL x CBA)F2 strain preimplantation embryos with embryos that differed at the Gpi-1s locus that encodes glucose phosphate isomerase, GPI-1. The composition of individual issues was evaluated by quantitative electrophoresis to estimate the % GPI-1A in the chimaeric tissue containing GPI-1A and GPI-1B. In one series of chimaeras, the GPI-1A cells were derived from a backcross between inbred BALB/c strain females and (BC x BALB/c)F1 males, where BC is the partly congenic strain C57BL/Ola.AKR-Gpi-lsa,c/Ws. In the other series of chimaeras, the GPI-1A cells were derived from the reciprocal backcross between (BC x BALB/c)F1 females and inbred BALB/c strain males. The [(BC x BALB/c)F1 female x BALB/c male]<==>(C57BL x CBA)F2 series of chimaeras was reasonably balanced so that GPI-1A and GPI-1B cells were fairly equally represented in the foetuses, placentas and extraembryonic membranes (tissue means: 37-51% GPI-1A). This series did not differ significantly in composition from an earlier series of (BC x BALB/c)F2<==>(C57BL x CBA)F2 chimaeras. However, the [BALB/c female x (BC x BALB/c)F1 male]<==>(C57BL x CBA)F2 series of chimaeras was unbalanced, with mean tissue compositions (28-33% GPI-1A) that were intermediate between the above two balanced series and the unbalanced (BALB/c x BALB/c)<==>(C57BL x CBA)F2 series (tissue means: 14-22% GPI-1A), that was studied previously. Thus, both (BALB/c x BALB/c) and [BALB/c x (BC x BALB/c)F1] embryos contributed less to the tissues of chimaeric conceptuses than either (BC x BALB/c)F2 or [BC x BALB/c)F1 x BALB/c] embryos. This implies that embryos from BALB/c mothers contributed less to the tissues of chimaeric conceptuses than embryos from (BC x BALB/c)F1 mothers. We, therefore, conclude that a maternal genetic effect is responsible for some of the differences in composition among the four groups of chimaeras. This maternal effect must act before the 8-cell stage but it is not yet known whether it is mediated via cytoplasmic inheritance, genomic imprinting or by the reproductive tract. Evidence that a maternal effect retards preimplantation development of embryos from BALB/c females is reviewed and the possibility that this might cause them to contribute poorly to chimaeric conceptuses when aggregated with more precociously developing embryos is discussed.

Genotypically unbalanced diploid<==>diploid foetal mouse chimaeras: possible relevance to human confined mosaicism

Two series of mouse chimaeras were produced by aggregating pairs of eight-cell embryos that differed at the Gpi-1s locus, encoding glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI-1); the paired embryos were respectively homozygous Gpi-1sa/Gpi-1sa and Gpi-1sb/Gpi-1sb. Chimaeric blastocysts were transferred to pseudopregnant females, that were homozygous Gpi-1sc/Gpi-1sc and produced only GPI-1C enzyme. Quantitative electrophoresis of GPI-1 was used to estimate the contribution of each embryo (GPI-1A and GPI-1B enzyme activity) to the foetus, placenta and other extraembryonic tissues of 12 1/2 day chimaeric conceptuses. For both series of chimaeras, the distributions of %GPI-1A in different tissues were classified as (1) balanced and typical, (2) balanced but atypical or (3) unbalanced. One series of chimaeras was clearly unbalanced, so that the cells derived from the (C57BL x CBA/Ca)F2 embryo (Gpi-1sb/Gpi-1sb) predominated over those derived from the BALB/c inbred strain (Gpi-1sa/Gpi-1sa) in most foetuses. Two significant observations were made concerning this unbalanced series. Firstly, the mean composition of the placenta and other extraembryonic tissues was similar to that in the foetus, i.e. also unbalanced with (C57BL x CBA/Ca)F2 (abbreviated to BF2) cells predominating. Secondly, despite this generalized deficiency of BALB/c cells, there were differences in the frequency of non-chimaeric tissues between different developmental lineages. In 20/38 [corrected] chimaeric conceptuses in the unbalanced series only BF2 cells were detected in the foetus, whereas both BF2 and BALB/c cells were present in at least one of the extraembryonic tissues. This group of chimaeras, therefore, shows some similarities to human confined mosaicism. Although chimaerism occurred more often in the primitive endoderm (hypoblast) lineage (yolk sac endoderm and parietal endoderm) than in the placenta, this may also be the case in human mosaics. The mosaic status of the human yolk sac endoderm is usually unknown so it is possible that mosaicism often occurs in the yolk sac endoderm as well as the trophectoderm in human 'confined placental mosaicism'. The uniformly unbalanced phenotype seen in the mouse chimaeras may be a result of generalized cell selection against BALB/c cells in all tissues. As an alternative explanation, we propose that most of the BALB/c cells in the blastocyst are allocated to the mural trophectoderm, which has a limited mitotic potential and so contributes little to the mid-gestation conceptus. Further work is required to test these possibilities.