Reflections on substrate water and dioxygen formation

Closing Kok's cycle of nature's water oxidation catalysis

The Mn4CaO5(6) cluster in photosystem II catalyzes water splitting through the Si state cycle (i = 0-4). Molecular O2 is formed and the natural catalyst is reset during the final S3 → (S4) → S0 transition. Only recently experimental breakthroughs have emerged for this transition but without explicit information on the S0-state reconstitution, thus the progression after O2 release remains elusive. In this report, our molecular dynamics simulations combined with density functional calculations suggest a likely missing link for closing the cycle, i.e., restoring the first catalytic state. Specifically, the formation of closed-cubane intermediates with all hexa-coordinate Mn is observed, which would undergo proton release, water dissociation, and ligand transfer to produce the open-cubane structure of the S0 state. Thereby, we theoretically identify the previously unknown structural isomerism in the S0 state that acts as the origin of the proposed structural flexibility prevailing in the cycle, which may be functionally important for nature's water oxidation catalysis.

The Effect of Removal of External Proteins PsbO, PsbP and PsbQ on Flash-Induced Molecular Oxygen Evolution and Its Biphasicity in Tobacco PSII

The oxygen evolution within photosystem II (PSII) is one of the most enigmatic processes occurring in nature. It is suggested that external proteins surrounding the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) not only stabilize it and provide an appropriate ionic environment but also create water channels, which could be involved in triggering the ingress of water and the removal of O2 and protons outside the system. To investigate the influence of these proteins on the rate of oxygen release and the efficiency of OEC function, we developed a measurement protocol for the direct measurement of the kinetics of oxygen release from PSII using a Joliot-type electrode. PSII-enriched tobacco thylakoids were used in the experiments. The results revealed the existence of slow and fast modes of oxygen evolution. This observation is model-independent and requires no specific assumptions about the initial distribution of the OEC states. The gradual removal of exogenous proteins resulted in a slowdown of the rapid phase (~ms) of O2 release and its gradual disappearance while the slow phase (~tens of ms) accelerated. The role of external proteins in regulating the biphasicity and efficiency of oxygen release is discussed based on observed phenomena and current knowledge.

Structure Function Studies of Photosystem II Using X-Ray Free Electron Lasers

The structure and mechanism of the water-oxidation chemistry that occurs in photosystem II have been subjects of great interest. The advent of X-ray free electron lasers allowed the determination of structures of the stable intermediate states and of steps in the transitions between these intermediate states, bringing a new perspective to this field. The room-temperature structures collected as the photosynthetic water oxidation reaction proceeds in real time have provided important novel insights into the structural changes and the mechanism of the water oxidation reaction. The time-resolved measurements have also given us a view of how this reaction-which involves multielectron, multiproton processes-is facilitated by the interaction of the ligands and the protein residues in the oxygen-evolving complex. These structures have also provided a picture of the dynamics occurring in the channels within photosystem II that are involved in the transport of the substrate water to the catalytic center and protons to the bulk.

Water Ligands Regulate the Redox Leveling Mechanism of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex of the Photosystem II

Understanding how water ligands regulate the conformational changes and functionality of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) in photosystem II (PSII) throughout the catalytic cycle of oxygen evolution remains a highly intriguing and unresolved challenge. In this study, we investigate the effect of water insertion (WI) on the redox state of the OEC by using the molecular dynamics (MD) and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) hybrid methods. We find that water binding significantly reduces the free energy change for proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) from Mn to YZ•, underscoring the important regulatory role of water binding, which is essential for enabling the OEC redox-leveling mechanism along the catalytic cycle. We propose a water binding mechanism in which WI is thermodynamically favored by the closed-cubane form of the OEC, with water delivery mediated by Ca2+ ligand exchange. Isomerization from the closed- to open-cubane conformation at three post-WI states highlights the importance of the location of the MnIII center in the OEC and the orientation of its Jahn-Teller axis to conformational changes of the OEC, which might be critical for the formation of the O-O bond. These findings reveal a complex interplay between conformational changes in the OEC and the ligand environment during the activation of the OEC by YZ•. Analogous regulatory effects due to water ligand binding are expected to be important for a wide range of catalysts activated by redox state transitions in aqueous environments.

On the simulation and interpretation of substrate-water exchange experiments in photosynthetic water oxidation

Water oxidation by photosystem II (PSII) sustains most life on Earth, but the molecular mechanism of this unique process remains controversial. The ongoing identification of the binding sites and modes of the two water-derived substrate oxygens ('substrate waters') in the various intermediates (Si states, i = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4) that the water-splitting tetra-manganese calcium penta-oxygen (Mn4CaO5) cluster attains during the reaction cycle provides central information towards resolving the unique chemistry of biological water oxidation. Mass spectrometric measurements of single- and double-labeled dioxygen species after various incubation times of PSII with H218O provide insight into the substrate binding modes and sites via determination of exchange rates. Such experiments have revealed that the two substrate waters exchange with different rates that vary independently with the Si state and are hence referred to as the fast (Wf) and the slow (WS) substrate waters. New insight for the molecular interpretation of these rates arises from our recent finding that in the S2 state, under special experimental conditions, two different rates of WS exchange are observed that appear to correlate with the high spin and low spin conformations of the Mn4CaO5 cluster. Here, we reexamine and unite various proposed methods for extracting and assigning rate constants from this recent data set. The analysis results in a molecular model for substrate-water binding and exchange that reconciles the expected non-exchangeability of the central oxo bridge O5 when located between two Mn(IV) ions with the experimental and theoretical assignment of O5 as WS in all S states. The analysis also excludes other published proposals for explaining the water exchange kinetics.

Assignment of the slowly exchanging substrate water of nature's water-splitting cofactor

Identifying the two substrate water sites of nature's water-splitting cofactor (Mn4CaO5 cluster) provides important information toward resolving the mechanism of O-O bond formation in Photosystem II (PSII). To this end, we have performed parallel substrate water exchange experiments in the S1 state of native Ca-PSII and biosynthetically substituted Sr-PSII employing Time-Resolved Membrane Inlet Mass Spectrometry (TR-MIMS) and a Time-Resolved 17O-Electron-electron Double resonance detected NMR (TR-17O-EDNMR) approach. TR-MIMS resolves the kinetics for incorporation of the oxygen-isotope label into the substrate sites after addition of H218O to the medium, while the magnetic resonance technique allows, in principle, the characterization of all exchangeable oxygen ligands of the Mn4CaO5 cofactor after mixing with H217O. This unique combination shows i) that the central oxygen bridge (O5) of Ca-PSII core complexes isolated from Thermosynechococcus vestitus has, within experimental conditions, the same rate of exchange as the slowly exchanging substrate water (WS) in the TR-MIMS experiments and ii) that the exchange rates of O5 and WS are both enhanced by Ca2+→Sr2+ substitution in a similar manner. In the context of previous TR-MIMS results, this shows that only O5 fulfills all criteria for being WS. This strongly restricts options for the mechanism of water oxidation.

Comprehensive Evaluation of Models for Ammonia Binding to the Oxygen Evolving Complex of Photosystem II

The identity and insertion pathway of the substrate oxygen atoms that are coupled to dioxygen by the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) remains a central question toward understanding Nature's water oxidation mechanism. In several studies, ammonia has been used as a small "water analogue" to elucidate the pathway of substrate access to the OEC and to aid in determining which of the oxygen ligands of the tetramanganese cluster are substrates for O-O bond formation. On the basis of structural and spectroscopic investigations, five first-sphere binding modes of ammonia have been suggested, involving either substitution of an existing H2O/OH-/O2- group or addition as an extra ligand to a metal ion of the Mn4CaO5 cluster. Some of these modes, specifically the ones involving substitution, have already been subject to spectroscopy-oriented quantum chemical investigations, whereas more recent suggestions that postulate the addition of ammonia have not been examined so far with quantum chemistry for their agreement with spectroscopic data. Herein, we use a common structural framework and theoretical methodology to evaluate structural models of the OEC that represent all proposed modes of first-sphere ammonia interaction with the OEC in its S2 state. Criteria include energetic, magnetic, kinetic, and spectroscopic properties compared against available experimental EPR, ENDOR, ESEEM, and EDNMR data. Our results show that models featuring ammonia replacing one of the two terminal water ligands on Mn4 align best with experimental data, while they definitively exclude substitution of a bridging μ-oxo ligand as well as incorporation of ammonia as a sixth ligand on Mn1 or Mn4.

Evolutionary diversity of proton and water channels on the oxidizing side of photosystem II and their relevance to function

One of the reasons for the high efficiency and selectivity of biological catalysts arise from their ability to control the pathways of substrates and products using protein channels, and by modulating the transport in the channels using the interaction with the protein residues and the water/hydrogen-bonding network. This process is clearly demonstrated in Photosystem II (PS II), where its light-driven water oxidation reaction catalyzed by the Mn4CaO5 cluster occurs deep inside the protein complex and thus requires the transport of two water molecules to and four protons from the metal center to the bulk water. Based on the recent advances in structural studies of PS II from X-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy, in this review we compare the channels that have been proposed to facilitate this mass transport in cyanobacteria, red and green algae, diatoms, and higher plants. The three major channels (O1, O4, and Cl1 channels) are present in all species investigated; however, some differences exist in the reported structures that arise from the different composition and arrangement of membrane extrinsic subunits between the species. Among the three channels, the Cl1 channel, including the proton gate, is the most conserved among all photosynthetic species. We also found at least one branch for the O1 channel in all organisms, extending all the way from Ca/O1 via the 'water wheel' to the lumen. However, the extending path after the water wheel varies between most species. The O4 channel is, like the Cl1 channel, highly conserved among all species while having different orientations at the end of the path near the bulk. The comparison suggests that the previously proposed functionality of the channels in T. vestitus (Ibrahim et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 117:12624-12635, 2020; Hussein et al., Nat Commun 12:6531, 2021) is conserved through the species, i.e. the O1-like channel is used for substrate water intake, and the tighter Cl1 and O4 channels for proton release. The comparison does not eliminate the potential role of O4 channel as a water intake channel. However, the highly ordered hydrogen-bonded water wire connected to the Mn4CaO5 cluster via the O4 may strongly suggest that it functions in proton release, especially during the S0 → S1 transition (Saito et al., Nat Commun 6:8488, 2015; Kern et al., Nature 563:421-425, 2018; Ibrahim et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 117:12624-12635, 2020; Sakashita et al., Phys Chem Chem Phys 22:15831-15841, 2020; Hussein et al., Nat Commun 12:6531, 2021).

Solar energy conversion by photosystem II: principles and structures

Photosynthetic water oxidation by Photosystem II (PSII) is a fascinating process because it sustains life on Earth and serves as a blue print for scalable synthetic catalysts required for renewable energy applications. The biophysical, computational, and structural description of this process, which started more than 50 years ago, has made tremendous progress over the past two decades, with its high-resolution crystal structures being available not only of the dark-stable state of PSII, but of all the semi-stable reaction intermediates and even some transient states. Here, we summarize the current knowledge on PSII with emphasis on the basic principles that govern the conversion of light energy to chemical energy in PSII, as well as on the illustration of the molecular structures that enable these reactions. The important remaining questions regarding the mechanism of biological water oxidation are highlighted, and one possible pathway for this fundamental reaction is described at a molecular level.

The electron-proton bottleneck of photosynthetic oxygen evolution

Photosynthesis fuels life on Earth by storing solar energy in chemical form. Today's oxygen-rich atmosphere has resulted from the splitting of water at the protein-bound manganese cluster of photosystem II during photosynthesis. Formation of molecular oxygen starts from a state with four accumulated electron holes, the S₄ state-which was postulated half a century ago¹ and remains largely uncharacterized. Here we resolve this key stage of photosynthetic O₂ formation and its crucial mechanistic role. We tracked 230,000 excitation cycles of dark-adapted photosystems with microsecond infrared spectroscopy. Combining these results with computational chemistry reveals that a crucial proton vacancy is initally created through gated sidechain deprotonation. Subsequently, a reactive oxygen radical is formed in a single-electron, multi-proton transfer event. This is the slowest step in photosynthetic O₂ formation, with a moderate energetic barrier and marked entropic slowdown. We identify the S₄ state as the oxygen-radical state; its formation is followed by fast O-O bonding and O₂ release. In conjunction with previous breakthroughs in experimental and computational investigations, a compelling atomistic picture of photosynthetic O₂ formation emerges. Our results provide insights into a biological process that is likely to have occurred unchanged for the past three billion years, which we expect to support the knowledge-based design of artificial water-splitting systems.

Predicting the oxidation states of Mn ions in the oxygen-evolving complex of photosystem II using supervised and unsupervised machine learning

Serial Femtosecond Crystallography at the X-ray Free Electron Laser (XFEL) sources enabled the imaging of the catalytic intermediates of the oxygen evolution reaction of Photosystem II (PSII). However, due to the incoherent transition of the S-states, the resolved structures are a convolution from different catalytic states. Here, we train Decision Tree Classifier and K-means clustering models on Mn compounds obtained from the Cambridge Crystallographic Database to predict the S-state of the X-ray, XFEL, and CryoEM structures by predicting the Mn's oxidation states in the oxygen-evolving complex. The model agrees mostly with the XFEL structures in the dark S₁ state. However, significant discrepancies are observed for the excited XFEL states (S₂, S_3, and S₀) and the dark states of the X-ray and CryoEM structures. Furthermore, there is a mismatch between the predicted S-states within the two monomers of the same dimer, mainly in the excited states. We validated our model against other metalloenzymes, the valence bond model and the Mn spin densities calculated using density functional theory for two of the mismatched predictions of PSII. The model suggests designing a more optimized sample delivery and illumiation systems are crucial to precisely resolve the geometry of the advanced S-states to overcome the noncoherent S-state transition. In addition, significant radiation damage is observed in X-ray and CryoEM structures, particularly at the dangler Mn center (Mn4). Our model represents a valuable tool for investigating the electronic structure of the catalytic metal cluster of PSII to understand the water splitting mechanism.

Alternative Mechanism for O2 Formation in Natural Photosynthesis via Nucleophilic Oxo-Oxo Coupling

O2 formation in photosystem II (PSII) is a vital event on Earth, but the exact mechanism remains unclear. The presently prevailing theoretical model is "radical coupling" (RC) involving a Mn(IV)-oxyl unit in an "open-cubane" Mn4CaO6 cluster, which is supported experimentally by the S3 state of cyanobacterial PSII featuring an additional Mn-bound oxygenic ligand. However, it was recently proposed that the major structural form of the S3 state of higher plants lacks this extra ligand, and that the resulting S4 state would feature instead a penta-coordinate dangler Mn(V)=oxo, covalently linked to a "closed-cubane" Mn3CaO4 cluster. For this proposal, we explore here a large number of possible pathways of O-O bond formation and demonstrate that the "nucleophilic oxo-oxo coupling" (NOOC) between Mn(V)=oxo and μ3-oxo is the only eligible mechanism in such a system. The reaction is facilitated by a specific conformation of the cluster and concomitant water binding, which is delayed compared to the RC mechanism. An energetically feasible process is described starting from the valid S4 state through the sequential formation of peroxide and superoxide, followed by O2 release and a second water insertion. The newly found mechanism is consistent with available experimental thermodynamic and kinetic data and thus a viable alternative pathway for O2 formation in natural photosynthesis, in particular for higher plants.

Electron-Transfer Route in the Early Oxidation States of the Mn4CaO5 Cluster in Photosystem II

The electron transfer from the oxygen-evolving Mn4CaO5 cluster to the electron acceptor D1-Tyr161 (TyrZ) is a prerequisite for water oxidation and O2 evolution. Here, we analyzed the electronic coupling in the rate-limiting electron-transfer transitions using a combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical/polarizable continuum model approach. In the S0 to S1 transition, the electronic coupling between the electron-donor Mn3(III) and TyrZ is small (2 meV). In contrast, the electronic coupling between the dangling Mn4(III) and TyrZ is significantly large (172 meV), which suggests that the electron transfer proceeds from Mn3(III) to TyrZ via Mn4(III). In the S1 to S2 transition, the electronic coupling between Mn4(III) and TyrZ is also larger (124 meV) than that between Mn1(III) and TyrZ (1 meV), which favors the formation of the open-cubane S2 conformation with Mn4(IV) over the formation of the closed-cubane S2 conformation with Mn1(IV). In the S0 to S1 and S1 to S2 transitions, the Mn4 d-orbital and the TyrZ π-orbital are hybridized via D1-Asp170, which suggests that D1-Asp170 commonly provides a dominant electron-transfer route.

Capturing the sequence of events during the water oxidation reaction in photosynthesis using XFELs

Ever since the discovery that Mn was required for oxygen evolution in plants by Pirson in 1937 and the period-four oscillation in flash-induced oxygen evolution by Joliot and Kok in the 1970s, understanding of this process has advanced enormously using state-of-the-art methods. The most recent in this series of innovative techniques was the introduction of X-ray free-electron lasers (XFELs) a decade ago, which led to another quantum leap in the understanding in this field, by enabling operando X-ray structural and X-ray spectroscopy studies at room temperature. This review summarizes the current understanding of the structure of Photosystem II (PS II) and its catalytic centre, the Mn4 CaO5 complex, in the intermediate Si (i = 0-4)-states of the Kok cycle, obtained using XFELs.

Water oxidation in oxygenic photosynthesis studied by magnetic resonance techniques

The understanding of light-induced biological water oxidation in oxygenic photosynthesis is of great importance both for biology and (bio)technological applications. The chemically difficult multistep reaction takes place at a unique protein-bound tetra-manganese/calcium cluster in photosystem II whose structure has been elucidated by X-ray crystallography (Umena et al. Nature 2011, 473, 55). The cluster moves through several intermediate states in the catalytic cycle. A detailed understanding of these intermediates requires information about the spatial and electronic structure of the Mn₄ Ca complex; the latter is only available from spectroscopic techniques. Here, the important role of Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) and related double resonance techniques (ENDOR, EDNMR), complemented by quantum chemical calculations, is described. This has led to the elucidation of the cluster's redox and protonation states, the valence and spin states of the manganese ions and the interactions between them, and contributed substantially to the understanding of the role of the protein surrounding, as well as the binding and processing of the substrate water molecules, the O-O bond formation and dioxygen release. Based on these data, models for the water oxidation cycle are developed.

Reversible Structural Isomerization of Nature's Water Oxidation Catalyst Prior to O-O Bond Formation

Photosynthetic water oxidation is catalyzed by a manganese–calcium oxide cluster, which experiences five “S-states” during a light-driven reaction cycle. The unique “distorted chair”-like geometry of the Mn₄CaO₅₍₆₎ cluster shows structural flexibility that has been frequently proposed to involve “open” and “closed”-cubane forms from the S₁ to S₃ states. The isomers are interconvertible in the S₁ and S₂ states, while in the S₃ state, the open-cubane structure is observed to dominate inThermosynechococcus elongatus (cyanobacteria) samples. In this work, using density functional theory calculations, we go beyond the S₃⁺Y_z state to the S₃ⁿY_z^• → S₄⁺Y_z step, and report for the first time that the reversible isomerism, which is suppressed in the S₃⁺Y_z state, is fully recovered in the ensuing S₃ⁿY_z^• state due to the proton release from a manganese-bound water ligand. The altered coordination strength of the manganese–ligand facilitates formation of the closed-cubane form, in a dynamic equilibrium with the open-cubane form. This tautomerism immediately preceding dioxygen formation may constitute the rate limiting step for O₂ formation, and exert a significant influence on the water oxidation mechanism in photosystem II.

Why Did Nature Choose Manganese over Cobalt to Make Oxygen Photosynthetically on the Earth?

All contemporary oxygenic phototrophs─from primitive cyanobacteria to complex multicellular plants─split water using a single invariant cluster comprising Mn₄CaO₅ (the water oxidation catalyst) as the catalyst within photosystem II, the universal oxygenic reaction center of natural photosynthesis. This cluster is unstable outside of PSII and can be reconstituted, both in vivo and in vitro, using elemental aqueous ions and light, via photoassembly. Here, we demonstrate the first functional substitution of manganese in any oxygenic reaction center by in vitro photoassembly. Following complete removal of inorganic cofactors from cyanobacterial photosystem II microcrystal (PSIIX), photoassembly with free cobalt (Co²⁺), calcium (Ca²⁺), and water (OH^-) restores O₂ evolution activity. Photoassembly occurs at least threefold faster using Co²⁺ versus Mn²⁺ due to a higher quantum yield for PSIIX-mediated charge separation (P*): Co²⁺ → P* → Co³⁺Q_A^-. However, this kinetic preference for Co²⁺ over native Mn²⁺ during photoassembly is offset by significantly poorer catalytic activity (∼25% of the activity with Mn²⁺) and ∼3- to 30-fold faster photoinactivation rate. The resulting reconstituted Co-PSIIX oxidizes water by the standard four-flash photocycle, although they produce 4-fold less O₂ per PSII, suggested to arise from faster charge recombination (Co³⁺Q_A ← Co⁴⁺Q_A^-) in the catalytic cycle. The faster photoinactivation of reconstituted Co-PSIIX occurs under anaerobic conditions during the catalytic cycle, suggesting direct photodamage without the involvement of O₂. Manganese offers two advantages for oxygenic phototrophs, which may explain its exclusive retention throughout Darwinian evolution: significantly slower charge recombination (Mn³⁺Q_A ← Mn⁴⁺Q_A^-) permits more water oxidation at low and fluctuating solar irradiation (greater net energy conversion) and much greater tolerance to photodamage at high light intensities (Mn⁴⁺ is less oxidizing than Co⁴⁺). Future work to identify the chemical nature of the intermediates will be needed for further interpretation.

Molecular Principles of Redox-Coupled Protonation Dynamics in Photosystem II

Photosystem II (PSII) catalyzes light-driven water oxidization, releasing O₂ into the atmosphere and transferring the electrons for the synthesis of biomass. However, despite decades of structural and functional studies, the water oxidation mechanism of PSII has remained puzzling and a major challenge for modern chemical research. Here, we show that PSII catalyzes redox-triggered proton transfer between its oxygen-evolving Mn₄O₅Ca cluster and a nearby cluster of conserved buried ion-pairs, which are connected to the bulk solvent via a proton pathway. By using multi-scale quantum and classical simulations, we find that oxidation of a redox-active Tyr_z (Tyr161) lowers the reaction barrier for the water-mediated proton transfer from a Ca²⁺-bound water molecule (W3) to Asp61 via conformational changes in a nearby ion-pair (Asp61/Lys317). Deprotonation of this W3 substrate water triggers its migration toward Mn1 to a position identified in recent X-ray free-electron laser (XFEL) experiments [Ibrahim et al. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2020, 117, 12,624-12,635]. Further oxidation of the Mn₄O₅Ca cluster lowers the proton transfer barrier through the water ligand sphere of the Mn₄O₅Ca cluster to Asp61 via a similar ion-pair dissociation process, while the resulting Mn-bound oxo/oxyl species leads to O₂ formation by a radical coupling mechanism. The proposed redox-coupled protonation mechanism shows a striking resemblance to functional motifs in other enzymes involved in biological energy conversion, with an interplay between hydration changes, ion-pair dynamics, and electric fields that modulate the catalytic barriers.

Alteration of the O2-Producing Mn4Ca Cluster in Photosystem II by the Mutation of a Metal Ligand

The O₂-evolving Mn₄Ca cluster in photosystem II (PSII) is arranged as a distorted Mn₃Ca cube that is linked to a fourth Mn ion (denoted as Mn4) by two oxo bridges. The Mn4 and Ca ions are bridged by residue D1-D170. This is also the only residue known to participate in the high-affinity Mn(II) site that participates in the light-driven assembly of the Mn₄Ca cluster. In this study, we use Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopy to characterize the impact of the D1-D170E mutation. On the basis of analyses of carboxylate and carbonyl stretching modes and the O-H stretching modes of hydrogen-bonded water molecules, we show that this mutation alters the extensive network of hydrogen bonds that surrounds the Mn₄Ca cluster in the same manner as that of many other mutations. It also alters the equilibrium between conformers of the Mn₄Ca cluster in the dark-stable S₁ state so that a high-spin form of the S₂ state is produced during the S₁-to-S₂ transition instead of the low-spin form that gives rise to the S₂ state multiline electron paramagnetic resonance signal. The mutation may also change the coordination mode of the carboxylate group at position 170 to unidentate ligation of Mn4. This is the first mutation of a metal ligand in PSII that substantially impacts the spectroscopic signatures of the Mn₄Ca cluster without substantially eliminating O₂ evolution. The results have significant implications for our understanding of the roles of alternate active/inactive conformers of the Mn₄Ca cluster in the mechanism of O₂ formation.

Structural dynamics in the water and proton channels of photosystem II during the S2 to S3 transition

Light-driven oxidation of water to molecular oxygen is catalyzed by the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) in Photosystem II (PS II). This multi-electron, multi-proton catalysis requires the transport of two water molecules to and four protons from the OEC. A high-resolution 1.89 Å structure obtained by averaging all the S states and refining the data of various time points during the S₂ to S₃ transition has provided better visualization of the potential pathways for substrate water insertion and proton release. Our results indicate that the O1 channel is the likely water intake pathway, and the Cl1 channel is the likely proton release pathway based on the structural rearrangements of water molecules and amino acid side chains along these channels. In particular in the Cl1 channel, we suggest that residue D1-E65 serves as a gate for proton transport by minimizing the back reaction. The results show that the water oxidation reaction at the OEC is well coordinated with the amino acid side chains and the H-bonding network over the entire length of the channels, which is essential in shuttling substrate waters and protons.

Effects of x-ray free-electron laser pulse intensity on the Mn K 1,3 x-ray emission spectrum in photosystem II-A case study for metalloprotein crystals and solutions

In the last ten years, x-ray free-electron lasers (XFELs) have been successfully employed to characterize metalloproteins at room temperature using various techniques including x-ray diffraction, scattering, and spectroscopy. The approach has been to outrun the radiation damage by using femtosecond (fs) x-ray pulses. An example of an important and damage sensitive active metal center is the Mn4CaO5 cluster in photosystem II (PS II), the catalytic site of photosynthetic water oxidation. The combination of serial femtosecond x-ray crystallography and Kβ x-ray emission spectroscopy (XES) has proven to be a powerful multimodal approach for simultaneously probing the overall protein structure and the electronic state of the Mn4CaO5 cluster throughout the catalytic (Kok) cycle. As the observed spectral changes in the Mn4CaO5 cluster are very subtle, it is critical to consider the potential effects of the intense XFEL pulses on the Kβ XES signal. We report here a systematic study of the effects of XFEL peak power, beam focus, and dose on the Mn Kβ1,3 XES spectra in PS II over a wide range of pulse parameters collected over seven different experimental runs using both microcrystal and solution PS II samples. Our findings show that for beam intensities ranging from ∼5 × 1015 to 5 × 1017 W/cm2 at a pulse length of ∼35 fs, the spectral effects are small compared to those observed between S-states in the Kok cycle. Our results provide a benchmark for other XFEL-based XES studies on metalloproteins, confirming the viability of this approach.

Structural Reorganization of a Synthetic Mimic of the Oxygen-Evolving Center in Multiple Redox Transitions Revealed by Electrochemical FTIR Spectra

In photosynthesis, the protein-bound natural oxygen-evolving center (OEC) undergoes multiple oxidation-state transitions in the light-driven water splitting reactions with a stepwise change in the oxidation potential. Because the protein is vulnerable to electrochemical oxidation, the multiple oxidation/reduction-state transitions can hardly be achieved by electrochemical oxidation with a continuous change in the oxidation potential. An OEC mimic that can undergo four redox transitions has been synthesized (Zhang, C., Science, 2015, 348, 690-693). Here we report an electrochemical FTIR spectroscopic study of this synthetic complex at its multiple oxidation states in the low-frequency region for Mn-O bonds. Compared with those of the native OEC induced by pulsed laser flashes, our results also show the existence of two structural isomers in the S₂ state, with the closed cubane conformer being more stable than the open cubane conformer, in contrast to that of the native OEC in which the open form is more stable.

The exchange of the fast substrate water in the S2 state of photosystem II is limited by diffusion of bulk water through channels - implications for the water oxidation mechanism

The molecular oxygen we breathe is produced from water-derived oxygen species bound to the Mn4CaO5 cluster in photosystem II (PSII). Present research points to the central oxo-bridge O5 as the 'slow exchanging substrate water (Ws)', while, in the S2 state, the terminal water ligands W2 and W3 are both discussed as the 'fast exchanging substrate water (Wf)'. A critical point for the assignment of Wf is whether or not its exchange with bulk water is limited by barriers in the channels leading to the Mn4CaO5 cluster. In this study, we measured the rates of H2 16O/H2 18O substrate water exchange in the S2 and S3 states of PSII core complexes from wild-type (WT) Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, and from two mutants, D1-D61A and D1-E189Q, that are expected to alter water access via the Cl1/O4 channels and the O1 channel, respectively. We found that the exchange rates of Wf and Ws were unaffected by the E189Q mutation (O1 channel), but strongly perturbed by the D61A mutation (Cl1/O4 channel). It is concluded that all channels have restrictions limiting the isotopic equilibration of the inner water pool near the Mn4CaO5 cluster, and that D61 participates in one such barrier. In the D61A mutant this barrier is lowered so that Wf exchange occurs more rapidly. This finding removes the main argument against Ca-bound W3 as fast substrate water in the S2 state, namely the indifference of the rate of Wf exchange towards Ca/Sr substitution.

Redox Isomerism in the S3 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex Resolved by Coupled Cluster Theory

The electronic and geometric structures of the water-oxidizing complex of photosystem II in the steps of the catalytic cycle that precede dioxygen evolution remain hotly debated. Recent structural and spectroscopic investigations support contradictory redox formulations for the active-site Mn4 CaOx cofactor in the final metastable S3 state. These range from the widely accepted MnIV 4 oxo-hydroxo model, which presumes that O-O bond formation occurs in the ultimate transient intermediate (S4 ) of the catalytic cycle, to a MnIII 2 MnIV 2 peroxo model representative of the contrasting "early-onset" O-O bond formation hypothesis. Density functional theory energetics of suggested S3 redox isomers are inconclusive because of extreme functional dependence. Here, we use the power of the domain-based local pair natural orbital approach to coupled cluster theory, DLPNO-CCSD(T), to present the first correlated wave function theory calculations of relative stabilities for distinct redox-isomeric forms of the S3 state. Our results enabled us to evaluate conflicting models for the S3 state of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) and to quantify the accuracy of lower-level theoretical approaches. Our assessment of the relevance of distinct redox-isomeric forms for the mechanism of biological water oxidation strongly disfavors the scenario of early-onset O-O formation advanced by literal interpretations of certain crystallographic models. This work serves as a case study in the application of modern coupled cluster implementations to redox isomerism problems in oligonuclear transition metal systems.

Size, Stoichiometry, Dimensionality, and Ca Doping of Manganese Oxide-Based Water Oxidation Clusters: An Oxyl/Hydroxy Mechanism for Oxygen-Oxygen Coupling

Gas-phase ion-trap reactivity experiments and density functional simulations reveal that water oxidation to H₂O₂ mediated by (calcium) manganese oxide clusters proceeds via formation of a terminal oxyl radical followed by oxyl/hydroxy O-O coupling. This mechanism is predicted to be energetically feasible for Mn₂O_y⁺ (y = 2-4) and the binary CaMn₃O₄⁺, in agreement with the experimental observations. In contrast, the reaction does not proceed for the tetramanganese oxides Mn₄O_y⁺ (y = 4-6) under these experimental conditions. This is attributed to the high fluxionality of the tetramanganese clusters, resulting in the instability of the terminal oxyl radical as well as an energetically unfavorable change of the spin state required for H₂O₂ formation. Ca doping, yielding a symmetry-broken lower-symmetry three-dimensional (3D) CaMn₃O₄⁺ cluster, results in structural stabilization of the oxyl radical configuration, accompanied by a favorable coupling between potential energy surfaces with different spin states, thus enabling the cluster-mediated water oxidation reaction and H₂O₂ formation.

Orientational Jahn-Teller Isomerism in the Dark-Stable State of Nature's Water Oxidase

The tetramanganese–calcium cluster of the oxygen‐evolving complex of photosystem II adopts electronically and magnetically distinct but interconvertible valence isomeric forms in its first light‐driven oxidized catalytic state, S₂. This bistability is implicated in gating the final catalytic states preceding O−O bond formation, but it is unknown how the biological system enables its emergence and controls its effect. Here we show that the Mn₄CaO₅ cluster in the resting (dark‐stable) S₁ state adopts orientational Jahn–Teller isomeric forms arising from a directional change in electronic configuration of the “dangler” Mn^III ion. The isomers are consistent with available structural data and explain previously unresolved electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic observations on the S₁ state. This unique isomerism in the resting state is shown to be the electronic origin of valence isomerism in the S₂ state, establishing a functional role of orientational Jahn–Teller isomerism unprecedented in biological or artificial catalysis.

Proton exit pathways surrounding the oxygen evolving complex of photosystem II

Photosystem II allows water to be the primary electron source for the photosynthetic electron transfer chain. Water is oxidized to dioxygen at the Oxygen Evolving Complex (OEC), a Mn₄CaO₅ inorganic core embedded on the lumenal side of PSII. Water-filled channels surrounding the OEC must bring in substrate water molecules, remove the product protons to the lumen, and may transport the product oxygen. Three water-filled channels, denoted large, narrow, and broad, extend from the OEC towards the aqueous surface more than 15 Å away. However, the role of each pathway in the transport in and out of the OEC is yet to be established. Here, we combine Molecular Dynamics (MD), Multi Conformation Continuum Electrostatics (MCCE) and Network Analysis to compare and contrast the three potential proton transfer paths. Hydrogen bond network analysis shows that near the OEC the waters are highly interconnected with similar free energy for hydronium at all locations. The paths diverge as they move towards the lumen. The water chain in the broad channel is better connected than in the narrow and large channels, where disruptions in the network are observed approximately 10 Å from the OEC. In addition, the barrier for hydronium translocation is lower in the broad channel. Thus, a proton released from any location on the OEC can access all paths, but the likely exit to the lumen passes through PsbO via the broad channel.

Arrested Substrate Binding Resolves Catalytic Intermediates in Higher-Plant Water Oxidation

Among the intermediate catalytic steps of the water-oxidizing Mn4 CaO5 cluster of photosystem II (PSII), the final metastable S3 state is critically important because it binds one substrate and precedes O2 evolution. Herein, we combine X- and Q-band EPR experiments on native and methanol-treated PSII of Spinacia oleracea and show that methanol-treated PSII preparations of the S3 state correspond to a previously uncharacterized high-spin (S=6) species. This is confirmed as a major component also in intact photosynthetic membranes, coexisting with the previously known intermediate-spin conformation (S=3). The high-spin intermediate is assigned to a water-unbound form, with a MnIV3 subunit interacting ferromagnetically via anisotropic exchange with a coordinatively unsaturated MnIV ion. These results resolve and define the structural heterogeneity of the S3 state, providing constraints on the S3 to S4 transition, on substrate identity and delivery pathways, and on the mechanism of O-O bond formation.

Kinetic modeling of substrate-water exchange in Photosystem II

We derive a model that provides an exact solution to the substrate-water exchange kinetics in a double-conformation system and use this model to interpret recently published data for Ca²⁺- and Sr²⁺-containing PSII in the S₂ state, in which the g = 2.0 and g = 4.1 conformations coexist. The component concentrations derived from the kinetic model provide an analytic description of the substrate-water exchange kinetics, allowing us to more accurately interpret the results. Based on this model and the previously reported data on the S₂ state g = 2.0 conformation, we obtain the substrate-water exchange rates of the g = 4.1 conformation and the conformational change rates. Two conclusions are made from the analyses. First, contrary to previous reports, there is no significant effect of substituting Sr²⁺ for Ca²⁺ on any of the exchange rate constants. Second, the exchange rate of the slowly-exchanging water (W_s) in the S₂ state g = 4.1 conformation is much faster than that in the S₂ state g = 2.0 conformation. The second conclusion is consistent with the assignment of W_s to W1 or W2 bound as terminal ligands to Mn4; Mn4 has been proposed to undergo an oxidation state change from Mn(IV) in the g = 2.0 conformation to Mn(III) in the g = 4.1 conformation.

Using X-ray Diffraction Techniques for Biomimetic Drug Development, Formulation, and Polymorphic Characterization

Drug development is a decades-long, multibillion dollar investment that often limits itself. To decrease the time to drug approval, efforts are focused on drug targets and drug formulation for optimal biocompatibility and efficacy. X-ray structural characterization approaches have catalyzed the drug discovery and design process. Single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) reveals important structural details and molecular interactions for the manifestation of a disease or for therapeutic effect. Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) has provided a method to determine the different phases, purity, and stability of biological drug compounds that possess crystallinity. Recently, synchrotron sources have enabled wider access to the study of noncrystalline or amorphous solids. One valuable technique employed to determine atomic arrangements and local atom ordering of amorphous materials is the pair distribution function (PDF). PDF has been used in the study of amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs). ASDs are made up of an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) within a drug dispersed at the molecular level in an amorphous polymeric carrier. This information is vital for appropriate formulation of a drug for stability, administration, and efficacy purposes. Natural or biomimetic products are often used as the API or the formulation agent. This review profiles the deep insights that X-ray structural techniques and associated analytical methods can offer in the development of a drug.

Activation energies for two steps in the S2→ S3 transition of photosynthetic water oxidation from time-resolved single-frequency infrared spectroscopy

The mechanism of water oxidation by the Photosystem II (PSII) protein-cofactor complex is of high interest, but specifically, the crucial coupling of protonation dynamics to electron transfer (ET) and dioxygen chemistry remains insufficiently understood. We drove spinach-PSII membranes by nanosecond-laser flashes synchronously through the water-oxidation cycle and traced the PSII processes by time-resolved single-frequency infrared (IR) spectroscopy in the spectral range of symmetric carboxylate vibrations of protein side chains. After the collection of IR-transients from 100 ns to 1 s, we analyzed the proton-removal step in the S₂ ⇒ S₃ transition, which precedes the ET that oxidizes the Mn₄CaO_x-cluster. Around 1400 cm^-1, pronounced changes in the IR-transients reflect this pre-ET process (∼40 µs at 20 °C) and the ET step (∼300 µs at 20 °C). For transients collected at various temperatures, unconstrained multi-exponential simulations did not provide a coherent set of time constants, but constraining the ET time constants to previously determined values solved the parameter correlation problem and resulted in an exceptionally high activation energy of 540 ± 30 meV for the pre-ET step. We assign the pre-ET step to deprotonation of a group that is re-protonated by accepting a proton from the substrate-water, which binds concurrently with the ET step. The analyzed IR-transients disfavor carboxylic-acid deprotonation in the pre-ET step. Temperature-dependent amplitudes suggest thermal equilibria that determine how strongly the proton-removal step is reflected in the IR-transients. Unexpectedly, the proton-removal step is only weakly reflected in the 1400 cm^-1 transients of PSII core complexes of a thermophilic cyanobacterium (T. elongatus).

Light-driven formation of manganese oxide by today's photosystem II supports evolutionarily ancient manganese-oxidizing photosynthesis

Water oxidation and concomitant dioxygen formation by the manganese-calcium cluster of oxygenic photosynthesis has shaped the biosphere, atmosphere, and geosphere. It has been hypothesized that at an early stage of evolution, before photosynthetic water oxidation became prominent, light-driven formation of manganese oxides from dissolved Mn(2+) ions may have played a key role in bioenergetics and possibly facilitated early geological manganese deposits. Here we report the biochemical evidence for the ability of photosystems to form extended manganese oxide particles. The photochemical redox processes in spinach photosystem-II particles devoid of the manganese-calcium cluster are tracked by visible-light and X-ray spectroscopy. Oxidation of dissolved manganese ions results in high-valent Mn(III,IV)-oxide nanoparticles of the birnessite type bound to photosystem II, with 50-100 manganese ions per photosystem. Having shown that even today’s photosystem II can form birnessite-type oxide particles efficiently, we propose an evolutionary scenario, which involves manganese-oxide production by ancestral photosystems, later followed by down-sizing of protein-bound manganese-oxide nanoparticles to finally yield today’s catalyst of photosynthetic water oxidation.

Photosynthetic formation of manganese (Mn) oxides from dissolved Mn ions was proposed to occur in ancestral photosystems before oxygenic photosynthesis evolved. Here, the authors provide evidence for this hypothesis by showing that photosystem II devoid of the Mn cluster oxidises Mn ions leading to formation of Mn-oxide nanoparticles.

Charge accumulation kinetics in multi-redox molecular catalysts immobilised on TiO2

Multi-redox catalysis requires the accumulation of more than one charge carrier and is crucial for solar energy conversion into fuels and valuable chemicals. In photo(electro)chemical systems, however, the necessary accumulation of multiple, long-lived charges is challenged by recombination with their counterparts. Herein, we investigate charge accumulation in two model multi-redox molecular catalysts for proton and CO2 reduction attached onto mesoporous TiO2 electrodes. Transient absorption spectroscopy and spectroelectrochemical techniques have been employed to study the kinetics of photoinduced electron transfer from the TiO2 to the molecular catalysts in acetonitrile, with triethanolamine as the hole scavenger. At high light intensities, we detect charge accumulation in the millisecond timescale in the form of multi-reduced species. The redox potentials of the catalysts and the capacity of TiO2 to accumulate electrons play an essential role in the charge accumulation process at the molecular catalyst. Recombination of reduced species with valence band holes in TiO2 is observed to be faster than microseconds, while electron transfer from multi-reduced species to the conduction band or the electrolyte occurs in the millisecond timescale. Finally, under light irradiation, we show how charge accumulation on the catalyst is regulated as a function of the applied bias and the excitation light intensity.

The D1-V185N mutation alters substrate water exchange by stabilizing alternative structures of the Mn4Ca-cluster in photosystem II

In photosynthesis, the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of the pigment-protein complex photosystem II (PSII) orchestrates the oxidation of water. Introduction of the V185N mutation into the D1 protein was previously reported to drastically slow O₂-release and strongly perturb the water network surrounding the Mn₄Ca cluster. Employing time-resolved membrane inlet mass spectrometry, we measured here the H₂¹⁸O/H₂¹⁶O-exchange kinetics of the fast (W_f) and slow (W_s) exchanging substrate waters bound in the S₁, S₂ and S₃ states to the Mn₄Ca cluster of PSII core complexes isolated from wild type and D1-V185N strains of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. We found that the rate of exchange for W_s was increased in the S₁ and S₂ states, while both W_f and W_s exchange rates were decreased in the S₃ state. Additionally, we used EPR spectroscopy to characterize the Mn₄Ca cluster and its interaction with the redox active D1-Tyr161 (Y_Z). In the S₂ state, we observed a greatly diminished multiline signal in the V185N-PSII that could be recovered by addition of ammonia. The split signal in the S₁ state was not affected, while the split signal in the S₃ state was absent in the D1-V185N mutant. These findings are rationalized by the proposal that the N185 residue stabilizes the binding of an additional water-derived ligand at the Mn1 site of the Mn₄Ca cluster via hydrogen bonding. Implications for the sites of substrate water binding are discussed.

Current Understanding of the Mechanism of Water Oxidation in Photosystem II and Its Relation to XFEL Data

The investigation of water oxidation in photosynthesis has remained a central topic in biochemical research for the last few decades due to the importance of this catalytic process for technological applications. Significant progress has been made following the 2011 report of a high-resolution X-ray crystallographic structure resolving the site of catalysis, a protein-bound Mn4CaOxcomplex, which passes through ≥5 intermediate states in the water-splitting cycle. Spectroscopic techniques complemented by quantum chemical calculations aided in understanding the electronic structure of the cofactor in all (detectable) states of the enzymatic process. Together with isotope labeling, these techniques also revealed the binding of the two substrate water molecules to the cluster. These results are described in the context of recent progress using X-ray crystallography with free-electron lasers on these intermediates. The data are instrumental for developing a model for the biological water oxidation cycle.

Water-Oxidation Electrocatalysis by Manganese Oxides: Syntheses, Electrode Preparations, Electrolytes and Two Fundamental Questions

The efficient catalysis of the four-electron oxidation of water to molecular oxygen is a central challenge for the development of devices for the production of solar fuels. This is equally true for artificial leaf-type structures and electrolyzer systems. Inspired by the oxygen evolving complex of Photosystem II, the biological catalyst for this reaction, scientists around the globe have investigated the possibility to use manganese oxides (“MnOx”) for this task. This perspective article will look at selected examples from the last about 10 years of research in this field. At first, three aspects are addressed in detail which have emerged as crucial for the development of efficient electrocatalysts for the anodic oxygen evolution reaction (OER): (1) the structure and composition of the “MnOx” is of central importance for catalytic performance and it seems that amorphous, MnIII/IV oxides with layered or tunnelled structures are especially good choices; (2) the type of support material (e.g. conducting oxides or nanostructured carbon) as well as the methods used to immobilize the MnOx catalysts on them greatly influence OER overpotentials, current densities and long-term stabilities of the electrodes and (3) when operating MnOx-based water-oxidizing anodes in electrolyzers, it has often been observed that the electrocatalytic performance is also largely dependent on the electrolyte’s composition and pH and that a number of equilibria accompany the catalytic process, resulting in “adaptive changes” of the MnOx material over time. Overall, it thus has become clear over the last years that efficient and stable water-oxidation electrolysis by manganese oxides can only be achieved if at least four parameters are optimized in combination: the oxide catalyst itself, the immobilization method, the catalyst support and last but not least the composition of the electrolyte. Furthermore, these parameters are not only important for the electrode optimization process alone but must also be considered if different electrode types are to be compared with each other or with literature values from literature. Because, as without their consideration it is almost impossible to draw the right scientific conclusions. On the other hand, it currently seems unlikely that even carefully optimized MnOx anodes will ever reach the superb OER rates observed for iridium, ruthenium or nickel-iron oxide anodes in acidic or alkaline solutions, respectively. So at the end of the article, two fundamental questions will be addressed: (1) are there technical applications where MnOx materials could actually be the first choice as OER electrocatalysts? and (2) do the results from the last decade of intensive research in this field help to solve a puzzle already formulated in 2008: “Why did nature choose manganese to make oxygen?”.

Substrate water exchange in the S2 state of photosystem II is dependent on the conformation of the Mn4Ca cluster

The structural flexibility of the Mn₄Ca cluster in photosystem II supports the exchange of the central O5 bridge.

Water oxidation in photosystem II

Biological water oxidation, performed by a single enzyme, photosystem II, is a central research topic not only in understanding the photosynthetic apparatus but also for the development of water splitting catalysts for technological applications. Great progress has been made in this endeavor following the report of a high-resolution X-ray crystallographic structure in 2011 resolving the cofactor site (Umena et al. in Nature 473:55-60, 2011), a tetra-manganese calcium complex. The electronic properties of the protein-bound water oxidizing Mn4OxCa complex are crucial to understand its catalytic activity. These properties include: its redox state(s) which are tuned by the protein matrix, the distribution of the manganese valence and spin states and the complex interactions that exist between the four manganese ions. In this short review we describe how magnetic resonance techniques, particularly EPR, complemented by quantum chemical calculations, have played an important role in understanding the electronic structure of the cofactor. Together with isotope labeling, these techniques have also been instrumental in deciphering the binding of the two substrate water molecules to the cluster. These results are briefly described in the context of the history of biological water oxidation with special emphasis on recent work using time resolved X-ray diffraction with free electron lasers. It is shown that these data are instrumental for developing a model of the biological water oxidation cycle.