Enhancement of ANAMMOX activity by low-intensity ultrasound irradiation at ambient temperature

Review on ultrasonic technology enhanced biological treatment of wastewater

As a clean, sustainable and efficient technology of wastewater treatment, ultrasonic irradiation has gained special attention in wastewater treatment. It has been widely studied for degrading pollutants and enhancing biological treatment processes for wastewater treatment. This review focuses on the mechanism and updated information of ultrasonic technology to enhance biological treatment of wastewater. The mechanism involved in improving biological treatment by ultrasonic includes: 1) degradation of refractory substances and release carbon from sludges, 2) promotion of mass transfer and change of cell permeability, 3) facilitation of enzyme-catalyzed reactions and 4) influence of cell growth. Based on the above discussion, the effects of ultrasound on the enhancement of wastewater biological treatment processes can be categorized into indirect and direct ways. The indirect effect of ultrasonic waves in enhancing biological treatment is mainly achieved through the use of high-intensity ultrasonic waves. These waves can be used as a pretreatment to improve biodegradability of the wastewater. Moreover, the ultrasonic-treated sludge or its supernatant can serve as a carbon source for the treatment system. Low-intensity ultrasound is often employed to directly enhance the biological treatment of wastewater. The propose of this process is to improve activated sludge, domesticate polyphosphate-accumulating organisms, ammonia-oxidizing bacteria, and anammox bacteria, and achieve speedy start-up of partial nitrification and anammox. It has shown remarkable effects on maintaining stable operation, tolerating adverse conditions (i.e., low temperature, low C/N, etc.), resisting shock load (i.e., organic load, toxic load, etc.), and collapse recovery. These results indicate a promising future for biological wastewater treatment. Furthermore, virous ultrasonic reactor designs were presented, and their potential for engineering application was discussed.

A critical review of exogenous additives for improving the anammox process

Anammox achieves chemoautotrophic nitrogen removal under anaerobic and anoxic conditions and is a low-carbon wastewater biological nitrogen removal process with broad application potential. However, the physiological limitations of AnAOB often cause problems in engineering applications, such as a long start-up time, unstable operation, easily inhibited reactions, and difficulty in long-term strain preservation. Exogenous additives have been considered an alternative strategy to address these issues by retaining microbes, shortening the doubling time of AnAOB and improving functional enzyme activity. This paper reviews the role of carriers, biochar, intermediates, metal ions, reaction substrates, redox buffers, cryoprotectants and organics in optimizing anammox. The pathways and mechanisms of exogenous additives, which are explored to solve problems, are systematically summarized and analyzed in this article according to operational performance, functional enzyme activity, and microbial abundance to provide helpful information for the engineering application of anammox.

Impact mechanism and performance enhancement of ultrasound on ZVI-anammox system

The zero-valent iron-anaerobic ammonium oxidation (ZVI-anammox) system has received widespread attention due to its excellent nitrogen removal performance and user-friendly operation. However, its disadvantages include a short service life, high ZVI consumption, and poor system stability. The use of ultrasound as a physical method is increasing in various water treatment processes. In this study, a series of batch tests were conducted to obtain the best ultrasonic parameter and explore the comprehensive effects of ultrasound on a ZVI-anammox system. The highest specific anammox activity of the ZVI-anammox system was found to be 2.88 mg total nitrogen/g of volatile suspended solids/h after ultrasonic treatment (0.2 w/mL, 5 min), which was 37.85% higher than a control group. Additionally, the service life of ZVI extended by 28.57% and the total nitrogen removal efficiency changed from 58.03-72.08 to 63.92-78.33% under ultrasonic irradiation. These phenomena were related to the mechanical force and cavitation of ultrasonic waves. Judging from the characteristics of sludge and ZVI, ultrasound can promote anammox sludge granulation, ease ZVI passivation, and enhance the stability of the entire system. This paper also briefly discusses the impact mechanisms of ultrasound on the ZVI-anammox system. In brief, ultrasound destroys the surface structure of ZVI and thus provides numerous attachment points for microorganisms that improve the performance of the entire system. The proposed ultrasound combined with ZVI is a novel method that has potential for use in large-scale engineering applications in actual sewage treatment after comprehensive analysis.

Accelerating anammox nitrogen removal in low intensity ultrasound-assisted ASBBR: Performance optimization, EPS characterization and microbial community analysis

Efficient enrichment of slow-growing anammox species is essential for rapid start-up and stable operation of high-rate anammox reactors. Herein, a low intensity ultrasound (LIU) was introduced into anaerobic sequencing batch biofilm reactors (ASBBRs) to enhance anammox nitrogen removal from nitrogen-rich wastewater. Operation results demonstrated that the maximum total nitrogen (TN) removal efficiency of 91.5% were achieved under the optimal ultrasonic parameters (32.7 °C water temperature, 0.18 W/cm² ultrasonic intensity and 25.7 min ultrasonication time). Moreover, significant increases of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) components and contents were observed via the ultrasonication stimulation. A close correlation between nitrogen removal and shifts in transformation and intensity of spectrum peaks was also verified by three-dimensional excitation-emission matrix spectroscopy (3D-EEM) analysis. High-throughput sequencing revealed that the relative abundance of Candidatus Kuenenia as the key anammox consortium significantly increased after applying optimal ultrasonication condition. Furthermore, enhancement mechanisms and future prospect of the LIU-assisted anammox process was elucidated and discussed. This research provides a viable and promising acceleration strategy for anammox-based process in practice.

Enhancement of Anammox performances in an ABR at normal temperature by the low-intensity ultrasonic irradiation

A lab-scale ultrasound enhancing Anammox reactor (ABR_U) was established and irradiated once a week by ultrasound with the optimal parameter (frequency of 25.0 kHz, intensity of 1.00 W cm^-2 and exposure time of 36.0 s) obtained by response surface methodology (RSM). ABR_U and the controlled Anammox reactor (ABR_C) without ultrasonic treatment were operated in parallel. The start-up time of Anammox process in ABR_U (59 d) was shorter than that in ABR_C (69 d). At the end of the nitrogen load-enhancing period, NLR (0.500 kg N m^-3 d^-1) and NRR (0.430 kg N m^-3 d^-1) in ABR_U were both higher than NLR (0.400 kg N m^-3 d^-1) and NRR (0.333 kg N m^-3 d^-1) in ABR_C. The results of RTQ-PCR demonstrated that the specific low-intensity ultrasound irradiation improved the enrichment levels of AnAOB in mature sludge. SEM images and the observation of the macroscopic morphology of mature sludge showed that the ultrasound irradiation strengthened the formation of Anammox granular sludge, thereby improved the interception capacity and impact load resistance of the reactor, and enhanced the nitrogen removal performance in ABR_U. The ultrasonic enhanced Anammox reactor based on an ABR with the optimal parameters can promote the rapid start-up and efficient and stable operation of the Anammox process at normal temperature (around 25.0 °C).

Effects of ultrasonic treatment on the ammonia-oxidizing bacterial (AOB) growth kinetics

Ultrasound has in the past few decades found applications in a variety of disciplines including chemistry, medicine, physics, and to a much less extent microbiology. Our previous studies found that ultrasonic treatment increases the activity of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) while suppressing nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB), resulting in beneficial effects in wastewater treatment. In this study, the kinetic and microbiological features of nitrifying microorganisms in activated sludge intermittently treated with ultrasound were investigated to gain an improved understanding of the mechanism involved in ultrasound-induced stimulation of AOB kinetics. The nitrifying microorganisms were initially enriched over 100 days in a laboratory sequential batch reactor (SBR). Ultrasonic treatment of the sludge was then applied with the treatment time in each 12 h SBR cycle progressively increased from 4 to 24 min. Application of the treatment for 21 days led to a doubled maximum specific ammonia oxidation rate, and also the enhanced dominance of known AOB Nitrosomonas genus in the biomass. This stimulatory effect is well described by a modified enzyme catalyzed reaction model, showing a good linear relationship between the natural logarithm value of μ_max,AOB and the applied ultrasonic energy density. This result suggests that ultrasonic treatment likely reduced the activation energy of key enzymes involved in ammonium oxidation.

Cold anammox process and reduced graphene oxide - Varieties of effects during long-term interaction

Because of its energy efficiency, the anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) process has been recognized as the most promising biological nitrogen removal process, but its implementation in mainstream wastewater treatment plants is limited by its relatively high optimal temperature (30 °C). Recently, it was shown that during short-term batch experiments, reduced graphene oxide (RGO) displayed accelerated reaction activity at low temperatures (10-15 °C). In this study, the long-term effects of RGO on the low-temperature anammox process in a sequencing batch reactor (SBR), are studied for the first time, including different methods of interaction. The results presented here show that RGO can stimulate anammox activity up to 17% through two factors: bacterial growth stimulation, which was especially significant at higher temperatures (>15 °C), and an increase of the anammox reaction rate, which occurred only below 15 °C. The bacterial community structure was not influenced by addition of RGO. Moreover, after incubation in an anammox bioreactor, RGO showed signs of degradation and chemical changes as evidenced by the presence of oxygen and calcium on its surface. According to the literature and the obtained results, it is proposed that RGO is oxidized and oxygen is reduced by the organic mediator that is involved in the enzymatic reactions. However, activated sludge is a very complex structure created by numerous, undefined microorganisms, which makes it difficult to determine the exact oxidation mechanism.

Achieving mainstream nitrogen removal via the nitrite pathway from real municipal wastewater using intermittent ultrasonic treatment

Achieving mainstream nitrogen removal via the nitrite pathway (NH₄⁺ → NO₂^- → N₂) is highly beneficial for energy neutral/positive wastewater treatment. Our previous batch assays revealed that ultrasonic treatment can suppress nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) while enhancing the activity of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB). Based on this concept, this study investigated the feasibility of applying ultrasonication to achieve the nitrite pathway in mainstream wastewater treatment. Two lab-scale sequencing batch reactors were set-up in parallel and fed with real municipal wastewater. With 100% of the sludge treated every 12 h at a treatment energy input of 0.066 kJ per mg mixed liquor suspended solids, the nitrite pathway was rapidly (within two weeks) established in the experimental reactor with stable effluent nitrite accumulation ratio (NO₂^-/(NO₂^- + NO₃^-)) of above 80% and significantly decreased NOB population. In comparison, the control reactor always possessed the conventional nitrification and denitrification pathway. Economic analysis indicated that energy consumption is too high for practical applications. However, this technology may be used in conjunction with other technologies, whereby this ultrasonic treatment can be used infrequently (e.g. once every few months) when the nitrite pathway becomes unstable.

Short-term effects of reduced graphene oxide on the anammox biomass activity at low temperatures

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) is an efficient process for nitrogen removal from wastewater, but its common use is limited by its relatively high optimal temperature (30 °C). One of the major bottlenecks of the implementation of mainstream PN/A process is the low activity of the anammox bacteria at low temperature. Due to this reason over the past years, numerous researchers have attempted to overcome this limitation. Recently it was shown that the reduced graphene oxide (RGO) can accelerate the anammox bacteria activity. However all these studies were performed at high temperatures (over 30 °C). Thus, in this study, supporting the anammox process at low temperatures (10-30 °C) by the RGO was investigated for the first time. The statistical analysis confirmed that RGO significantly affects the anammox activity. The stimulation effect of RGO on the anammox bacteria activity is of particular importance at low temperatures, when drastic decrease in process activity is observed at temperatures below 15 °C. The short-term experimental results demonstrated stimulation of the anammox activity at 13 °C, up to 28% by 15 mg RGO/L, but concentrations above 40 mg RGO/L caused the process inhibition, up to 30% with 50 mg RGO/L. However, the effect of RGO probably depends on the nanomaterial dose per biomass unit and the optimal range of this value was evaluated as 20 to 45 mg RGO/g VSS (volatile suspended solids).

Recent advances on biogranules formation in dark hydrogen fermentation system: Mechanism of formation and microbial characteristics

Hydrogen producing granules (HPGs) are most promising biological methods used to treat organic rich wastes and generate clean hydrogen energy. This review provides information regarding types of immobilization, supporting materials and microbiome involved on HPG formation and its performances. In this review, importance has been given to three kinds of immobilization techniques such as adsorption, encapsulation, and entrapment. The HPG, characteristics and types of organic and inorganic supporting materials followed for enhancing hydrogen yield were also discussed. This review also considers the applications of HPG for sustainable and high rate hydrogen production. A detailed discussion on insight of key mechanism for HPGs formation and its performances for stable operation of high rate hydrogen production system are also provided.

Roles of MnO2 on performance, sludge characteristics and microbial community in anammox system

The long-term impacts of MnO₂ on performance, sludge characteristics and microbial community of biogranule-based anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) process were evaluated in an up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor. It was found that the total nitrogen removal efficiency of reactor was fluctuated between 90%-93% at 1-200mgL^-1 MnO₂. Notably, the specific anammox activity was increased to maximum value of 657.3±10.6mgTNg^-1VSSd^-1 at 50mgL^-1 MnO₂ and then slightly decreased, but still higher than that achieved at 0-15mgL^-1 MnO₂, which had similar variation trends to the content of heme c and extracellular polymeric substances in anammox granules. High throughput sequencing indicated that MnO₂ could improve the microbial richness and diversity of anammox granules and Candidatus Kuenenia was always the dominant species, and its abundance continued to increase to 21.3% at the end of operational experiment. Therefore, MnO₂ could be applied to enhance the anammox process and the optimal influent MnO₂ concentration was lower than 50mgL^-1 in view of the reactor performance and cost issues.

Using low frequency and intensity ultrasound to enhance start-up and operation performance of Anammox process inoculated with the conventional sludge

A lab-scale ultrasound enhancing Anammox reactor (R1) was established and irradiated once a week by ultrasound with the optimal parameter (frequency of 25 kHz, intensity of 0.2 W cm^-2 and exposure time of 3 min) obtained by batch experiments. R1 and the controlled Anammox reactor (R2) without exposure to the ultrasound were operated in parallel. The start-up period of Anammox process (53 days) in R1 was shorter than that (61 days) in R2. The nitrogen loading-enhancing period (day 53-day 135) in R1 was also shorter than that (day 61-day 151) in R2. At the end of the nitrogen loading-enhancing period, NLR (0.76 kg N m^-3 d^-1) and NRR (0.68 kg N m^-3 d^-1) of R1 were both higher than NLR (0.66 kg N m^-3 d^-1) and NRR (0.56 kg N m^-3 d^-1) of R2. Moreover, The stability of Anammox process in R1 was better than that in R2. The results demonstrated that the periodical irradiation of ultrasound enhanced the start-up and operational performance of Anammox reactor. Microbial community analysis indicated that the ultrasound accelerated the microbial succession from some other bacteria to Anammox bacteria so that shorten the start-up period of Anammox process from the conventional activated sludge. It also indicated that the ultrasound strengthened the competitive advantage of Candidatus Kuenenia stuttgartiensis in Anammox bacteria of the mature sludge so as to enhance the nitrogen removal performance of the Anammox reactor under the operation condition of high nitrogen loading.

Nitrogen removal performance and operation strategy of anammox process under temperature shock

Sequencing batch reactors were used to study anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) process under temperature shock. Both long-term (15-35 °C) and short-term (10-50 °C) temperature effects on nitrogen removal performance were performed. In reactor operation test, the results indicated that ammonium removal rate decreased from 0.35 kg/(m³ day) gradually to 0.059 kg/(m³ day) when temperature dropped from 35 to 15 °C. Although bacteria morphology was not modified, sludge settling velocity decreased with decreasing temperature. In batch test, apparent activation energy (E_a) increased with decreasing temperature, which suggested the activity decrease of anaerobic ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AAOB). Low temperature inhibited AAOB and weakened nitrogen removal performance. The cardinal temperature model with inflection was first used to describe temperature effect on anammox process. Simulated results revealed that anammox reaction could occur at 10.52-50.15 °C with maximum specific anammox activity of 0.50 kg/(kg day) at 36.72 °C. The cold acclimatization of AAOB could be achieved and glycine betaine could slightly improve nitrogen removal performance at low temperature.

Ultrasonic Treatment Enhanced Ammonia-Oxidizing Bacterial (AOB) Activity for Nitritation Process

Oxidation of ammonia to nitrite rather than nitrate is critical for nitritation process for wastewater treatment. We proposed a promising approach by using controlled ultrasonic treatment to enhance the activity of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and suppress that of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). Batch activity assays indicated that when ultrasound was applied, AOB activity reached a peak level and then declined but NOB activity deteriorated continuously as the power intensity of ultrasound increased. Kinetic analysis of relative microbial activity versus ultrasonic energy density was performed to investigate the effect of operational factors (power, sludge concentration, and aeration) on AOB and NOB activities and the test parameters were selected for reactor tests. Laboratory sequential batch reactor (SBR) was further used to test the ultrasonic stimulus with 8 h per day operational cycle and synthetic waste urine as influent. With specific ultrasonic energy density of 0.09 kJ/mg VSS and continuously fed influent containing above 200 mg NH3-N/L, high AOB reproductive activity was achieved and nearly complete conversion of ammonia-N to nitrite was maintained. Microbial structure analysis confirmed that the treatment changed community of AOB, NOB, and heterotrophs. Known AOB Nitrosomonas genus remained at similar level in the biomass while typical NOB Nitrospira genus disappeared in the SBR under ultrasonic treatment and after the treatment was off for 30 days.

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) under realistic seasonal temperature variations: Characteristics of biogranules and process performance

In this study, the effects of realistic seasonal temperatures on the nitrogen removal performance of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) and the properties of the anammox granules were comparatively investigated for 330 days. The results demonstrated that the nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE), nitrogen loading rate (NLR) and nitrogen removal rate (NRR) were decreased dramatically, as the temperature decreased from 31.2 to 2.5 °C. However, the nitrogen removal performance recovered andante as the temperature increased gradually. After low temperature exposure, the settleability tended to worsen, and granules appeared to be more irregular with a smaller average granule diameter, and the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) content increased slightly, while the specific anammox activity (SAA) decreased obviously. This realistic seasonal temperatures based research was an illation of the actual operation, and could be potentially implemented to maintain stability for the application of anammox technology.

Appropriate Fe (II) addition significantly enhances anaerobic ammonium oxidation (Anammox) activity through improving the bacterial growth rate

The application of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (Anammox) process is often limited by the slow growth rate of Anammox bacteria. As the essential substrate element that required for culturing Anammox sludge, Fe (II) is expected to affect Anammox bacterial growth. This work systematically studied the effects of Fe (II) addition on Anammox activity based on the kinetic analysis of specific growth rate using data from batch tests with an enriched Anammox sludge at different dosing levels. Results clearly demonstrated that appropriate Fe (II) dosing (i.e., 0.09 mM) significantly enhanced the specific Anammox growth rate up to 0.172 d(-1) compared to 0.118 d(-1) at regular Fe (II) level (0.03 mM). The relationship between Fe (II) concentration and specific Anammox growth rate was found to be well described by typical substrate inhibition kinetics, which was integrated into currently well-established Anammox model to describe the enhanced Anammox growth with Fe (II) addition. The validity of the integrated Anammox model was verified using long-term experimental data from three independent Anammox reactors with different Fe (II) dosing levels. This Fe (II)-based approach could be potentially implemented to enhance the process rate for possible mainstream application of Anammox technology, in order for an energy autarchic wastewater treatment.

Towards energy neutral wastewater treatment: methodology and state of the art

Conventional biological wastewater treatment processes are energy-intensive endeavors that yield little or no recovered resources and often require significant external chemical inputs. However, with embedded energy in both organic carbon and nutrients (N, P), wastewater has the potential for substantial energy recovery from a low-value (or no-value) feedstock. A paradigm shift is thus now underway that is transforming our understanding of necessary energy inputs, and potential energy or resource outputs, from wastewater treatment, and energy neutral or even energy positive treatment is increasingly emphasized in practice. As two energy sources in domestic wastewater, we argue that the most suitable way to maximize energy recovery from wastewater treatment is to separate carbon and nutrient (particularly N) removal processes. Innovative anaerobic treatment technologies and bioelectrochemical processes are now being developed as high efficiency methods for energy recovery from waste COD. Recently, energy savings or even generation from N removal has become a hotspot of research and development activity, and nitritation-anammox, the newly developed CANDO process, and microalgae cultivation are considered promising techniques. In this paper, we critically review these five emerging low energy or energy positive bioprocesses for sustainable wastewater treatment, with a particular focus on energy optimization in management of nitrogenous oxygen demand. Taken together, these technologies are now charting a path towards to a new paradigm of resource and energy recovery from wastewater.