Co-fermentation of sewage sludge with ryegrass for enhancing hydrogen production: Performance evaluation and kinetic analysis

Exploitation of microbial activities at low pH to enhance planetary health

Awareness is growing that human health cannot be considered in isolation but is inextricably woven with the health of the environment in which we live. It is, however, under-recognized that the sustainability of human activities strongly relies on preserving the equilibrium of the microbial communities living in/on/around us. Microbial metabolic activities are instrumental for production, functionalization, processing, and preservation of food. For circular economy, microbial metabolism would be exploited to produce building blocks for the chemical industry, to achieve effective crop protection, agri-food waste revalorization, or biofuel production, as well as in bioremediation and bioaugmentation of contaminated areas. Low pH is undoubtedly a key physical-chemical parameter that needs to be considered for exploiting the powerful microbial metabolic arsenal. Deviation from optimal pH conditions has profound effects on shaping the microbial communities responsible for carrying out essential processes. Furthermore, novel strategies to combat contaminations and infections by pathogens rely on microbial-derived acidic molecules that suppress/inhibit their growth. Herein, we present the state-of-the-art of the knowledge on the impact of acidic pH in many applied areas and how this knowledge can guide us to use the immense arsenal of microbial metabolic activities for their more impactful exploitation in a Planetary Health perspective.

Volatile fatty acids recovery and antibiotic degradation from erythromycin fermentation residues by combined thermal pretreatment and anaerobic fermentation: Insights into microbial communities and metabolic pathways

High resistance of erythromycin has been the key factor restricting the disposal of erythromycin fermentation residues (EFR). Considering the high sensitivity of erythromycin to acidic conditions, anaerobic fermentation may be a good approach for EFR treatment, through which pH decreases along with the volatile fatty acids (VFA) accumulation. This study firstly explored the EFR treatment by combined thermal pretreatment and anaerobic fermentation. Results showed that thermal pretreatment and anaerobic fermentation exhibited a synergistic effect on erythromycin removal. Erythromycin concentration decreased to 20.0 mg/L with the maximum removal rate of 60.0%, which was 140% and 71.4% higher than erythromycin removal by sole thermal pretreatment and anaerobic fermentation. Thermal pretreatment induced the increased VFA production by 22.3% with the highest VFA concentration of 5325.4 mg/L. Microbial analysis shows that thermal pretreatment stimulated erythromycin degradation and VFA production by increasing the microbial diversity and enriching the functional enzymes involved in acetate-producing pathways.

Co-anaerobic digestion of sawdust and chicken manure with plant herbs: Biogas generation and kinetic study

Plant herbs specifically serai wangi (SW) and peppermint (PPM) are selected for its insect repellent properties as the use of chicken manure (CM) in anaerobic digestion (AD) potentially attract flies due to the digestate produced. Hence, the addition of SW and PPM in the AD system of CM could deter flies' infestation while producing biogas. Previous work has shown that AD of sawdust (SD) and CM with these plant herbs were able to produce biogas and reduce the flies attraction towards the digestate. However, the combination of SW and PPM for AD of CM has yet to be investigated. This work describes the effect of mixing SW and PPM on the co-AD of SDCM with respect to biogas production, methane yield and kinetic analysis. The mixture of SW and PPM was varied at different concentrations. The composition of methane in biogas was characterized every 10 days by using gas chromatography (GC) equipped with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD). The results suggest that co-AD of 10SW10PPM exhibited the highest biogas production (52.28 mL/g_vs) and methane yield (30.89 mL/g_vs), which the purity of methane increased by 18.52% as compared to SDCM. However, increasing the concentration of SW and PPM does not significantly improve the overall process. High R² (0.927-0.999), low RMSE (0.08-0.61) and low prediction error (<10.00%) were displayed by the modified Gompertz, logistic and Cone models. In contrast, Monod and Fitzhugh model is not preferred for the co-AD of SDCM with a mixture of SW and PM, as a high prediction error is obtained throughout the study. Increasing the dosage of PPM decreases the maximum cumulative methane yield, ranging from 31.76 to 7.01 mL/g_vs for modified Gompertz and 89.56 to 19.31 mL/g_vs for logistic model. The Modified Gompertz obtained a lag phase of 10.01-28.28 days while the logistic model obtained a lag phase of 37.29-52.48 days.

Dose-response and type-dependent effects of antiviral drugs in anaerobic digestion of waste-activated sludge for biogas production

In the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, antiviral drugs (AVDs) were heavily excreted into wastewater and subsequently enriched in sewage sludge due to their widespread use. The potential ecological risks of AVDs have attracted increasing attention, but information on the effects of AVDs on sludge anaerobic digestion (AD) is limited. In this study, two typical AVDs (lamivudine and ritonavir) were selected to investigate the responses of AD to AVDs by biochemical methane potential tests. The results indicated that the effects of AVDs on methane production from sludge AD were dose- and type-dependent. The increased ritonavir concentration (0.05-50 mg/kg TS) contributed to an 11.27-49.43% increase in methane production compared with the control. However, methane production was significantly decreased at high lamivudine doses (50 mg/kg TS). Correspondingly, bacteria related to acidification were affected when exposed to lamivudine and ritonavir. Acetoclastic and hydrotropic methanogens were inhibited at a high lamivudine dose, while ritonavir enriched methylotrophic and hydrotropic methanogens. Based on the analysis of intermediate metabolites, the inhibition of lamivudine and the promotion of ritonavir on acidification and methanation were confirmed. In addition, the existence of AVDs could affect sludge properties. Sludge solubilization was inhibited when exposed to lamivudine and enhanced by ritonavir, perhaps caused by their different structures and physicochemical properties. Moreover, lamivudine and ritonavir could be partially degraded by AD, but 50.2-68.8% of AVDs remained in digested sludge, implying environmental risks.

Enhanced hydrogen production from sludge anaerobic fermentation by combined freezing and calcium hypochlorite pretreatment

A novel and high-efficiency sludge pretreatment method by combination of freezing and calcium hypochlorite (CH) for promoting the anaerobic fermentation performance was reported in this work. Experimental results indicated that a maximum biohydrogen production of 18.18 ± 0.43 mL/g volatile suspended solids (VSS) was realized by freezing (-5 °C) combined with CH (0.12 g/g VSS) pretreatment, which was 1.19, 4.05 and 11.36 times to that from the sole CH, sole freezing and control fermenters, respectively. Mechanism study showed that freezing + CH pretreatment efficiently disintegrated sludge flocs, producing abundant substrates for anaerobic fermentation. Model substances degradation experiment showed that the biochemical processes were all suppressed by freezing + CH method, but the suppressive degrees for hydrogen-consuming processes were greater than hydrogen-producing processes. 16S rRNA analysis revealed that the microbial community in freezing + CH treated reactor was more beneficial to hydrogen generation than that in the control, because the abundance of functional microbes was enriched from 6.81 % to 34.95 % by the co-treatment. Furthermore, sludge dewatering performance, including settleability, dewaterability and filterability, was enhanced by freezing + CH pretreatment.

Biomass ash pyrolyzed from municipal sludge and its adsorption performance toward tetracycline: effect of pyrolysis temperature and KOH activation

Large amount of municipal sludge is difficult to handle; its resource utilization is an effective measure. In this study, the municipal sludge from sewage treatment plant was pyrolyzed without gas protection at different temperatures and potassium hydroxide (KOH) concentrations for activation. The pyrolysis products, named biomass ash, with higher surface area and enriched pore structures could be obtained at the pyrolysis temperature of 773 K. Moreover, the KOH activation for raw municipal sludge could further increase the surface area of the pyrolysis biomass ash. The maximum specific surface area was 44.71 m2/g, which was obtained under 2 mol/L KOH activation before pyrolysis at 773 K. And in this situation, the obtained pyrolysis biomass ash as adsorbent showed the maximum adsorption capacity of 50.75 mg/g toward tetracycline (TC). Moreover, the TC adsorption onto pyrolysis biomass ash obtained under various conditions followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model. Adsorption thermodynamics analysis suggested the TC adsorption onto the pyrolysis biomass ash with no pre-activation was mainly due to the multi-molecule heterogeneous adsorption, while the TC adsorption onto pyrolysis biomass ash pretreated through the activation of KOH followed the monomer adsorption mechanism. This different adsorption mechanism was largely related to the pore structure, polarity, and aromaticity of the adsorbent.

The advantages of co-digestion of vegetable oil industry by-products and sewage sludge: Biogas production potential, kinetic analysis and digestate valorisation

The production of edible vegetable oils generates considerable amounts of energy-rich waste, which is usually not utilised fully. Besides, inefficient management of such wastes can have a negative impact on the environment. On the other hand, this waste can also serve as a raw material for the production of high value-added products, such is biogas. The mono-digestion of seven different by-products and wastes from the vegetable oil industry was investigated in this study: Pumpkin seeds press cake (PSPC), grape seeds press cake (GSPC), olive mill pomace (OMP), coconut oil cake (CC), filtration additive (FA), spent bleaching earth (SBE) and sludge from a vegetable oil industry (SOI) wastewater treatment plant. In addition, co-digestion of these substrates was performed with municipal sewage sludge (SS). Besides inoculum, rumen fluid was added to the reactors to enhance biogas production. The biogas production potential of the tested substrates was monitored by measuring various parameters. A kinetic analysis was later carried out and a growth test was performed on the digestates to evaluate their potential for agricultural use. The highest biogas yields in the mono-digestion test were obtained with the substrates with the highest fat content: 1402, 1288, 830 and 750 mL of biogas/gVS for SOI, FA, PSPC and CC substrate, respectively. Co-digestion of SS with by-products of vegetable oil industry such as FA, SBE, CC, SOI and PSPC increased the biogas yields by 94.9%, 74.1%, 30.8%, 27.4% and 23.6% compared to SS mono-digestion. Furthermore, the data for mono-digestion of PSPC, GSPC, and FA, and co-digestion of SS with these substrates, CC and SBE, have not been found in the literature to date. The maximum methane content ranged from 61 to 74 vol%, while the chemical oxygen demand removal efficiency ranged from 42 to 78%. Relatively high fatty acids contents and ammonium concentrations were measured in the reactors. Kinetic analysis showed the best fit to the experimental data for the Cone kinetic model (R² > 0.98). The First order kinetic model, Monod, and the modified Gompertz model also exhibited high R² values. The digestates obtained from co-digestion proved to be excellent in the cress seeds growth test at digestate concentrations of 5-10 wt%, while higher concentrations had a toxic effect.

Biological production of medium-chain carboxylates through chain elongation: An overview

Medium chain carboxylates (MCCs) have wide applications in various industries, but the traditional MCCs production methods are costly and unsustainable. Anaerobic fermentation offers a more scalable, economical and eco-friendly platform for producing MCCs through chain elongation which converts short chain carboxylates and electron donor into more valuable MCCs. However, the underlying microbial pathways are not well understood. In this review, biological production of MCCs through chain elongation is introduced elaborately, including the metabolic pathways, electron donor and substrates, microorganisms and influencing factors. Then, the strategies for enhancing MCCs production are extensively analyzed and summarized, along with the technologies for MCCs separation from the fermentation broth. Finally, challenges and perspectives concerning the large-scale MCCs production are proposed, providing suggestions for the future research. Extensive review demonstrated that anaerobic fermentation has great potential in achieving economical and sustainable MCCs production from complex organic substrates, including organic waste streams, which would significantly broaden the application of MCCs, especially in the renewable energy field. An interdisciplinary approach with knowledge from microbiology and biochemistry to chemical separations and environmental engineering is required to use this promising technology as a valorization method for converting organic biomass or organic wastes into valuable MCCs.

Optimization of Cattle Manure and Food Waste Co-Digestion for Biohydrogen Production in a Mesophilic Semi-Continuous Process

Biohydrogen production from organic solid waste has shown particular advantages over other methods owing to the combination of waste reduction and bioenergy production. In this study, biohydrogen production from the co-digestion of cattle manure and food waste was optimized in a mesophilic semi-continuous process. To maximize hydrogen production, the effects of the mixing ratio (the proportion of food waste in the substrate), substrate concentration, and hydraulic retention time (HRT) on the co-digestion were systematically analyzed using a Box–Behnken design. The results showed that strong interactive effects existed between the three factors, and they had a direct effect on the responses. Hydrogen was primarily produced via the butyrate pathway, which was accompanied by the competing heterolactic fermentation pathway. Propionate and valerate produced from lipids and proteins, respectively, were obtained along with butyrate. The optimal process parameters included a mixing ratio of 47% to 51%, a substrate concentration of 76 to 86 g L−1, and an HRT of 2 d. Under these optimal conditions, the hydrogen production rate and hydrogen yield were higher than 1.00 L L−1 d−1 and 30.00 mL g−1 VS, respectively, and the predicted results were consistent with the experimental data. The results indicate that the co-digestion of cattle manure and food waste is a practical and economically promising approach for biohydrogen production.

Chain elongation performances with anaerobic fermentation liquid from sewage sludge with high total solid as electron acceptor

This work studied the effect of total solid (TS) of sewage sludge on VFA production and composition in anaerobic fermentation. Results revealed that VFA concentration reached the highest of 10.16 g/L and the ratio of acetic acid, propionic acid and n-butyric acid was 5:2:2 with the 8% TS sewage sludge. In subsequent chain elongation with sludge fermentation liquid, n-caproic acid concentration reached 43.45 mmol/L. The microbial community analysis indicated that relative abundance of Clostridium_sensu_stricto_12 for n-caproic acid production was high (52.41%). The chain elongation with sludge fermentation liquid had more pathways to produce n-caproic acid, and the chain elongation reactions were thermodynamically possible. The mixed VFAs and high concentration of n-butyric acid benefitted n-caproic acid production. Carbon balance revealed that the VFA composition of sludge fermentation liquid was beneficial to the chain elongation. This study will contribute to wasted sludge minimization and high-value material production.

Kinetics of methane production during anaerobic fermentation of chicken manure with sawdust and fungi pre-treated wheat straw

The goal of this study was to determine the kinetic parameters of methane production during anaerobic fermentation of mixtures of chicken manure with sawdust and wheat straw overgrown with fungi. Pre-treatment of wheat straw was carried out with Pleurotus ostreatus and Trametes versicolor white-rot fungi. Mixtures of chicken manure with sawdust and wheat straw overgrown with fungi at different mass ratios (50:50, 60:40 and 80:20) were used as a substrate for anaerobic fermentation. For the control, ordinary wheat straw was used. Anaerobic fermentations were performed at (35, 40 and 45) °C. An individual process of anaerobic fermentation was maintained at constant temperature for 21 days. During the process, the volume and concentration of biogas produced were monitored. The most biogas produced was recorded for the straw overgrown with Pleurotus ostreatus fungi (ratio 50:50) at 45 °C, and the least in the case of straw overgrown with Trametes versicolor fungi (ratio 80:20) at 35 °C. At the beginning of anaerobic fermentation, the methane concentration increased faster at a higher temperature, while after 21 days, it was between 53 and 56% regardless of temperature.

Microbial Production of Hydrogen by Mixed Culture Technologies: A Review

With its high energy content and clean combustion, hydrogen is recognized as a renewable clean energy source with enormous potential. Biological hydrogen production is a promising alternative with significant advantages over conventional petroleum-derived chemical processes. Sustainable hydrogen production from renewable resources such as cassava, wastewater, and other agricultural waste is economically feasible for industrial applications. So far, the major bottlenecks in large-scale biological hydrogen production are the low production rate and yield. This review discusses the various factors that affect the metabolic pathways of dark hydrogen production, and highlights the state-of-the-art development of mixed culture technology. The aim of this review is to provide suggestions for the future directions of mixed culture technology, as well as by-product valorization in dark fermentation.

State of the art and challenges of biohydrogen from microalgae

Biohydrogen from microalgae has attracted extensive attention owing to its promising features of abundance, renewable and self sustainability. Unlike other well-established biofuels like biodiesel and bioethanol, biohydrogen from microalgae is still in the preliminary stage of development. Criticisms in microalgal biohydrogen centered on its practicality and sustainability. Various laboratory- and pilot-scale microalgal systems have been developed, and some research initiatives have exhibited potential for commercial application. This work provides a review of the state of the art of biohydrogen from microalgae. Discussions include metabolic pathways of light-driven transformation and dark fermentation, reactor schemes and system designs encompassing reactor configurations and light manipulation. Challenges, knowledge gaps and the future directions in metabolic limitations, economic and energy assessments, and molecular engineering are also delineated. Current scientific and engineering challenges of microalgal biohydrogen need to be addressed for technology leapfrog or breakthrough.

Biohydrogen and polyhydroxyalkanoate production from original hydrolyzed polyacrylamide-containing wastewater

This work aimed to study biohydrogen (H₂) and polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA) production from original hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM)-containing wastewater. NH₄⁺-N from HPAM hydrolysis was removed efficiently through short-cut nitrification and anoxic ammonia oxidation (anammox). Carbon/Nitrogen (C/N) ratios of effluent reached 51-97, and TOC decreased only 2%-4%, providing potential for subsequent H₂ and PHA production. The maximum yields of H₂ (0.833 mL·mg^-1_substrate) and Volatile Fatty Acid (VFA) (465 mg·L^-1) occurred at influent C/N ratio of 51. Substrate removal increased linearly with the activities of dehydrogenase and hydrogenase (R² ≥ 0.990), and H₂ yield rose exponentially with enzyme activities (R² ≥ 0.989). The maximum PHA yield (54.2% VSS) occurred at the 42nd hour and influent C/N ratio of 97. PHA yield was positively correlated with substrate uptake. The change of H₂-producing, PHA-accumulating and HPAM-degradating bacteria indicated that those functional microorganisms had synergistic effects on H₂ production and substrate uptake, as well as PHA accumulation and substrate uptake.

Biohydrogen production from co-fermentation of fallen leaves and sewage sludge

The co-fermentation of fallen leaves and sewage sludge was performed for the production of hydrogen at different mixing ratios. The experimental results indicated that the optimal mixing ratio of sludge to leaves was 20:80 (volatile solids (VS) basis), and the co-fermentation process showed a synergistic effect on biohydrogen production at this mixing ratio. The biohydorgen yield reached 37.8 mL/g-VS_added at the mixing ratio of 20:80, which was higher compared to the mono-fermentation of sludge (10.3 mL/g-VS_added) or the leaves (30.5 mL/g-VS_added). The VS removal was also highest (15.7%) at the mixing ratio of 20:80, which was higher compared to sludge mono-fermentation (6.2%) or leaves mono-fermentation (12.8%). Meanwhile, the co-fermentation process enhanced the biohydrogen production rate and led to a more efficient fermentation pathway. Microbial community analysis showed that the co-fermentation system enriched much more Clostridium, Bacillus and Rummeliibacillus genera, which was responsible for the synergistic effect on biohydrogen production.

Ultrasound combined with dilute acid pretreatment of grass for improvement of fermentative hydrogen production

In this study, the dilute acid pretreatment combined with ultrasound was applied to improve fermentative hydrogen production from grass. The experimental results indicated that SCOD and soluble carbohydrate contents of grass was improved by 98.6% and 236.9% after the combined treatment, respectively. Surface morphology (SEM and AFM) and crystallinity analysis revealed that the combined pretreatment process could effectively destroyed the biomass structure and increased their surface area. Owing to the increased soluble organics proportion and better enzymatic accessibility of residual solids, the hydrogen yield reached 42.2 mL/g-dry grass after the combined treatment, which was 311.7%, 190.0% and 35.0% higher in comparison with the control, individual ultrasound and acid pretreated groups, respectively. Meanwhile, the combined treatment also increased the substrate utilization efficiency and induced a more efficient fermentation pathway. Bacterial community analysis revealed that more enrichment of Clostridium and less enrichment of Enterococcus contributed to the improved hydrogen production.

Improving mechanisms of biohydrogen production from grass using zero-valent iron nanoparticles

This paper investigated the improving mechanisms and microbial community dynamics of using zero-valent iron nanoparticles (Fe⁰ NPs) in hydrogen fermentation of grass. Results showed that Fe⁰ NPs supplement improved microbial activity and changed dominant microbial communities from Enterobacter sp. to Clostridium sp., which induced a more efficient metabolic pathway towards higher hydrogen production. Meanwhile, it is also proposed that Fe⁰ NPs could accelerate electron transfer between ferredoxin and hydrogenase, and promote the activity of key enzymes by the released Fe²⁺. The maximal hydrogen yield and hydrogen production rate were 64.7 mL/g-dry grass and 12.1 mL/h, respectively at Fe⁰ NPs dosage of 400 mg/L, which were 73.1% and 128.3% higher compared with the control group. Fe⁰ NPs also shorten the lag time and facilitated the hydrolysis and utilization of grass. This study demonstrated that Fe⁰ NPs could effectively improve hydrogen production and accelerate the fermentation process of grass.

Pretreatment of grass waste using combined ionizing radiation-acid treatment for enhancing fermentative hydrogen production

In this study, the combined ionizing radiation-acid pretreatment process was firstly applied to enhance hydrogen fermentation of grass waste. Results showed that the combined pretreatment synergistically enhanced hydrogen fermentation of grass waste. The SCOD and soluble polysaccharide contents of grass waste increased by 1.6 and 2.91 times after the combined pretreatment, respectively. SEM observation and crystallinity test showed the combined pretreatment effectively disrupted the grass structure. Owing to the more favorable substrate conditions, the hydrogen yield achieved 68 mL/g-dry grass_added after the combined pretreatment, which was 161.5%, 112.5% and 28.3% higher than those from raw, ionizing radiation pretreated and acid pretreated grass waste, respectively. The VS removal also increased from 13.9% to 25.6% by the combined pretreatment. Microbial community analysis showed that the abundance of dominant hydrogen producing genus Clostridium sensu stricto 1 increased from 37.9% to 69.4% after the combined pretreatment, which contributed to more efficient hydrogen fermentation.

Kinetics and microbial community analysis for hydrogen production using raw grass inoculated with different pretreated mixed culture

In this study, five pretreatment methods (heat shock, acid, base, aeration and gamma radiation) were applied for enriching hydrogen producers from anaerobically digested sludge, aiming to compare their hydrogen fermentation performance using raw ryegrass as substrate. Results showed that various pretreatment methods caused great variations on grass hydrogen fermentation performance. Acid pretreatment was most efficient compared with other tested pretreatment methods, with relevant hydrogen yield of 64.4mL/g dry grass and organics removal of 31.4%. Kinetics results showed that the first-order kinetic model fitted hydrogen evolution better than the modified Gompertz model. Microbiological analysis showed that various pretreatment methods caused great variations on microbial activity and microbial community composition. Clostridium and Enterococcus were two dominant genera, while relative abundances of these two genera varied greatly for different pretreated samples. Difference in microbial activity and microbial community distribution induced by the pretreatment methods might directly cause different ryegrass fermentation performance.