The characteristics of multi-substrates (low and high C/N) anaerobic digestion: focus on energy recovery and the succession of methanogenic pathway

Succession from acetoclastic to hydrogenotrophic microbial community during sewage sludge anaerobic digestion for bioenergy production

To assess microbial dynamics during anaerobic digestion (AD) of sewage sludge (SWS) from a municipal Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP), a Biochemical Methane Potential (BMP) assay at 37 °C under mono-digestion conditions was conducted. Utilizing the Illumina MiSeq platform, 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene sequencing unveiled a core bacterial community in the solid material, showcasing notable variations in profiles. The research investigates changes in microbial communities and metabolic pathways to understand their impact on the efficiency of the digestion process. Prior to AD, the relative abundance in SWS was as follows: Proteobacteria > Bacteroidota > Actinobacteriota. Post-AD, the relative abundance shifted to Firmicutes > Synergistota > Proteobacteria, with Sporanaerobacter and Clostridium emerging as dominant genera. Notably, the methanogenic community underwent a metabolic pathway shift from acetoclastic to hydrogenotrophic in the lab-scale reactors. At the genus level, Methanosaeta, Methanolinea, and Methanofastidiosum predominated initially, while post-AD, Methanobacterium, Methanosaeta, and Methanospirillum took precedence. This metabolic transition may be linked to the increased abundance of Firmicutes, particularly Clostridia, which harbor acetate-oxidizing bacteria facilitating the conversion of acetate to hydrogen.

New insights into the factors influencing methanogenic pathways in anaerobic digesters

INTRODUCTION

Anaerobic digestion integrates waste treatment, energy generation, and nutrient recycling, producing methane mainly through acetoclastic (AM) and hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis (HM). Methanogenic pathway management can improve biogas productivity and quality. The balance between pathways is influenced by environmental and physicochemical conditions, with conflicting results on the effect of different factors often reported. This systematic review aims to clarify the influence of various parameters on methanogenic pathways in anaerobic digesters.

METHODS

Literature search was conducted in the Web of Science and Scopus databases. The effects of different parameters on the predominant methanogenic pathway were evaluated using Kruskal-Wallis tests and Spearman's rank correlation.

RESULTS

Thermophilic temperatures and high free ammonia nitrogen concentrations (>300 mg L-1) increase HM, with a strong combined effect of these variables. Conversely, under moderate temperature and ammonia concentrations, the primary feedstock influences the methanogenic pathway, with algae biomass, pig manure, and food industry wastewater showing the lowest contribution of hydrogenotrophic methanogens. pH effect varied with temperature, with acidic and alkaline pH favoring HM in mesophilic and thermophilic digesters, respectively. Furthermore, higher levels of volatile fatty acids (>2000 mg L-1), carbohydrates (>10 g/L) and lipids (>10 g/L) also appeared to favor HM over AM, while most metals - especially Cr, Se and W - promoted AM.

CONCLUSION

This study emphasizes the role of various factors in methanogenic pathway selection, highlighting the impact of previously overlooked parameters, such as inorganic elements and organic matter composition. These insights are essential for understanding the methanogenic pathway balance and optimizing biogas processes.

Evaluation of the efficiency of dry anaerobic digester in the production of biogas and fertilizer using activated sludge and plant waste

The process of dry anaerobic digestion (DAD) is an effective economic and environmentally friendly method due to its features such as reducing the volume of waste, destroying pathogens, consuming less energy, and producing biogas rich in energy and fertilizer. This study was conducted on a pilot scale with a reactor volume of 24 L in 30 days for three ratios of C/N: 30, 25, and 20 separately using a mixture of activated sludge and plant waste. During the process, the temperature, pH, and ratio of C/N were measured at certain times, and the percentage of gases produced by the Gas chromatography (GC) device was also measured. The results were compared with the National standard of Iran (Compost, Physical, and Chemical Specifications) at the end of the process. The results showed that the average volume of biogas produced in ratios of C/N: 30, 25, 20 is 1.7, 2.5, and 1.5 L. d-1, respectively. The results showed that in the C/N ratio of 20, and 25, the amount of, C/N ratio and NO3 are in the range the standard of class 1, and the amount of Phosphorus pentoxide (P2O5) is in the range the standard of class 2. The results showed that the average microbial parameters in ratios of C/N: 30, 25, and 20 are lower than the national standard of Iran. The dry digester is an efficient method in waste treatment, methane gas production, and quality fertilizer close to the national standard of Iran.

Sustainable valorization of slaughterhouse waste through anaerobic digestion: A circular economy perspective

Slaughterhouse waste (SHW) poses significant environmental challenges due to its complex composition. In response, a novel review exploration of anaerobic digestion (AD) as a means of valorising SHW within the context of the circular economy (CE) is presented. The physicochemical properties of individual SHW, representing key parameters for the correct management of the AD process, are scrutinized. These parameters are further connected with identifying suitable pretreatment methods to enhance biogas production. Subsequently, the review examines the diverse technologies employed in the AD of SHW, considering the complexities of mono- or co-digestion. Various AD systems are evaluated for their effectiveness in harnessing the substantial biogas production potential from SHW, encompassing key parameters, reactor configurations, and operational conditions that influence the AD process. Moreover, the review interestingly extends its scope to the recovery and management of digestate, the by-product of AD. Along with the digestate composition, strategies for various utilization of this by-product are discussed. This investigation thus underscores, within the principles of the CE, the dual sustainable benefits of SHW processing via AD in biogas production and utilization of the resultant nutrient-rich digestate in various sectors.

Enhanced methane production from source-separated human feces (brown water) by single phase anaerobic co-digestion: Effects of different co-substrates

Based on the concept of source separation of brown water (BW, human feces with flushing water) and yellow water (urine) in rural area, anaerobic co-digestion of BW with agricultural waste is a promising and effective method for rural waste treatment and resource recovery. The purpose of this study was to investigate the performance of different agricultural wastes (peanut straw (PST), peanut shell (PSH), swine wastewater acting as co-substrate for anaerobic co-digestion with BW, and the relative mechanisms were explored. When the mixed ratio was uniformly set as 1:1 (mass ratio, measured by volatile solid (VS)) and initial VS load as 20 g/L, the maximum cumulative methane production obtained by co-digestion (21 days) of BW and PST was 688 mL/g-VS, which performed better than the individual substrates (341 mL/g-VS), as well as the average of the sole BW and sole PST groups (531.2 mL/g-VS). The most impactful advantage was ascribed to the promotion of hydrolytic and acidogenic enzyme activities. The addition of PST also reduced the production of endogenous humus, which is difficult for biodegradation. Microbial community analysis showed that different co-substrates would affect the microbial community composition in the reactor. The relative abundance of hydrolytic acidogens in the PST and PSH co-digestion groups were higher than that in the SW co-digestion and sole BW groups, and the methanogenic archaea were dominated by the acetate-trophic Methanotrichaceae. The overall results suggest that anaerobic co-digestion is a feasible method, and co-digestion of BW and PST can improve methane production potential.

Enhanced anaerobic digestion of human feces by ferrous hydroxyl complex (FHC): Stress factors alleviation and microbial resistance improvement

Anaerobic digestion (AD) offers a reliable strategy for resource recovery from source-separated human feces (HF), but is limited by a disproportionate carbon/nitrogen (C/N) ratio. Ferrous hydroxyl complex (FHC) was first introduced into the HF-AD system to mediate methanogenesis. Mono-digestion of undiluted HF was inhibited by high levels of volatile fatty acids (VFAs), ammonia, and hydrogen sulfide (H2S). FHC addition at optimum dosage (500-1000 mg/L) increased the cumulative methane (CH4) yield by 22.7%, enhanced the peak value of daily CH4 production by 60.5%, and shortened the lag phase by 24.7%. H2S concentration in biogas was also greatly decreased by FHC via precipitation. FHC mainly facilitated the hydrolysis, acidification, and methanogenesis processes. The production and transformation of VFAs were optimized in the presence of FHC, thus relieving acid stress. FHC elevated the activities of alkaline protease, cellulase, and acetate kinase by 32.3%, 18.2%, and 30.3%, respectively. Microbial analysis revealed that hydrogenotrophic methanogens prevailed in mono-digestion at high HF loading but were weakened after FHC addition. FHC also enriched Methanosarcina, thereby expanding the methanogenesis pathway and improving the resistance to ammonia stress. This work would contribute to improving the methanogenic performance and resource utilization for HF anaerobic digestion.

Genome-centric metagenomics revealed functional traits in high-solids anaerobic co-digestion of restaurant food waste, household food waste and rice straw

High-solids anaerobic co-digestion (HS-AcoD) of food waste (FW) and other organic wastes is an effective option to improve the biogas production and system stability compared to mono-digestion. However, the clean and sustainable HS-AcoD strategy for FW and associated microbial functional traits have not been well explored. Here, HS-AcoD of restaurant food waste (RFW), household food waste (HFW) and rice straw (RS) were performed. Results showed that the maximum synergy index (SI) of 1.28 were achieved when the volatile solids ratio of RFW, HFW and RS was 0.45:0.45:0.1. HS-AcoD alleviated the acidification process by regulating metabolism associated with hydrolysis and volatile fatty acids formation. The synergistic relationship between syntrophic bacteria and Methanothrix sp., and the enhanced metabolic capacity associated with the acetotrophic and hydrogenotrophic pathways dominated by Methanothrix sp., provided a further explanation of the synergistic mechanism. These findings advance the knowledge about microbial mechanisms underlying the synergistic effect of HS-AcoD.

Tree-based machine learning model for visualizing complex relationships between biochar properties and anaerobic digestion

The ideal conditions for anaerobic digestion experiments with biochar addition are challenging to thoroughly study due to different experimental purposes. Therefore, three tree-based machine learning models were developed to depict the intricate connection between biochar properties and anaerobic digestion. For the methane yield and maximum methane production rate, the gradient boosting decision tree produced R² values of 0.84 and 0.69, respectively. According to feature analysis, digestion time and particle size had a substantial impact on the methane yield and production rate, respectively. When particle sizes were in the range of 0.3-0.5 mm and the specific surface area was approximately 290 m²/g, corresponding to a range of O content (>31%) and biochar addition (>20 g/L), the maximum promotion of methane yield and maximum methane production rate were attained. Therefore, this study presents new insights into the effects of biochar on anaerobic digestion through tree-based machine learning.

Effects of initial volatile fatty acid concentrations on process characteristics, microbial communities, and metabolic pathways on solid-state anaerobic digestion

Solid-state anaerobic digestion (SSAD) is vulnerable to excess volatile fatty acids (VFA), mainly acetate and propionate. The co-effects of VFAs and microbial dynamics under VFA accumulation were investigated in SSAD of pig manure and corn straw. Adding 2 and 4 mg/g acetate or propionate caused initial increases in total VFAs, followed by decreases after day 6, resulting in 'mild' VFA accumulation, while adding 6 mg/g caused similarly increased VFAs, but with no subsequent decrease, causing 'severe' VFA accumulation and poor methanation performance. Mild propionate accumulation promoted acetate consumption, whereas acetate accumulation inhibited propionate degradation by affecting crucial redox reactions. Under severe VFA accumulation, hydrolysis and acidification mainly conducted by acid-tolerant Clostridium sp. exacerbated VFA inhibition, causing a competition between Methanosarcina and Methanosaeta, and impairments of acetoclastic and hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis and interspecies formate transfer. This study provides new insights into mechanisms of VFA accumulation in SSAD, and its effects on methanogenesis.

Characterisation and perspectives of energetic use of dissolved gas recovered from anaerobic effluent with membrane contactor

Biogas is a source of renewable energy, and its production and use has been validated in anaerobic-based sewage treatment plants (STPs). However, in these systems, a large amount of methane is lost as dissolved methane (D-CH₄) in the liquid effluent. In this study, the characteristics and potential energetic uses of the gas recovered during the desorption of D-CH₄ from anaerobic effluents with hollow fibre membrane contactors were investigated. A pilot-scale experiment was performed using sewage and two types of membrane contactors. The recovered gas contained considerable amounts of CH₄, CO₂, H₂S, N₂, and O₂; therefore, a gas upgrade is required prior to its use as a biofuel. The recovery process should be energetically self-sustainable, and induce a considerable decrease in the STP carbon footprint. Recovering D-CH₄ with membrane contactors could increase the energetic potential of anaerobic-based STPs up to 50 % and allow for more sustainable systems.

Phase separated pretreatment strategies for enhanced waste activated sludge disintegration in anaerobic digestion: An outlook and recent trends

A significant ecological problem was developed on disposing the enormous amounts of waste activated sludge (WAS) produced by traditional wastewater treatment. There have been various attempts recently originated to develop innovative methods for substantial sludge treatment. The most frequently used approach for treating sludge to produces methane and reduces sludge is anaerobic treatment. The hydrolysis phase in WAS limits the breakdown of complex macrobiotic compounds. The presence of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in biomass prevents the substrate from being hydrolyzed. Enhancing substrate hydrolysis involves removal of EPS preceded by phase separated pretreatment. Hence, a critical assessment of various phase separated pretreatment that has a remarkable effect on the anaerobic digestion process was documented in detail. Moreover, the economic viability and energy requirement of this treatment process was also discussed. Perspectives and recommendations for methane production were also provided to attain effectual sludge management.

Influence of NH3 and NH4+ on anaerobic digestion and microbial population structure at increasing total ammonia nitrogen concentrations

Despite the extensive research dedicated to ammonia inhibition, the effect of NH₃ and NH₄⁺ on each anaerobic digestion stage and the associated microorganisms is still not completely understood. In the past, the focus was mainly on methanogenesis and either on NH₃ or total ammonia nitrogen (TAN). Here, anaerobic digestion of two defined substrates, namely starch/NH₄Cl and casein, was investigated particularly regarding the effects of different NH₃/NH₄⁺ ratios on the involved microorganisms. TAN affected bacteria, primarily gram-positive ones, whereas archaea responded largely to the NH₃ concentration. These sensitivity differences are attributed to differences in the corresponding cell-membrane structures. A TAN decrease via stripping performed in two full-scale agricultural biogas plants resulted in increased bacterial diversity, with a pronounced increase in the propionate acetogens' abundance. Based on these data, it is suggested that inhibition can be avoided and processes stabilized in biogas plants by adjusting the NH₃/NH₄⁺ ratio, when feeding nitrogen-rich substrates.

Effectiveness of layered inoculation in solid-state anaerobic co-digestion of pig manure and corn straw: Focus on macro-, micro-, and genetic-levels

Layered inoculation can achieve rapid start-up and promote methanation performance of anaerobic digesters. Daily specific methane yield (SMY) rapidly increased to 2.93 mL/g VS/d during 0-13 days, and cumulative SMY reached 212 mL/g VS in the solid-state anaerobic co-digestion (SS-AcoD) of pig manure and corn straw. Data were collected at macro-, micro-, and genetic-levels of each substrate layer. The results showed that layered inoculation could improve volatile fatty acids utilization and prevent adverse effects of high total ammonium nitrogen concentrations. Layered inoculation accelerated hydrolysis, acidification, and methanogenesis of substrates, as evidenced by the efficient inoculation of Bacteroidetes, Anaerolineales, Methanosphaerula, and Methanothrix, which were primarily from inocula. The various stages of SS-AcoD were synergistically initiated during the first 13 days, and acetoclastic pathway was boosted. These results further explain why layered inoculation is an efficient method for improving methanation performance of SS-AcoD and achieving efficient utilization of organic solid waste.