Valine-restricted diet for patients with ECHS1 deficiency: Divergent clinical outcomes in two Japanese siblings

Further delineation of short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase deficiency in the Pacific population

Short-chain enoyl-coA hydratase (SCEH) deficiency due to biallelic pathogenic ECHS1 variants was first reported in 2014 in association with Leigh syndrome (LS) and increased S-(2-carboxypropyl)cysteine excretion. It is potentially treatable with a valine-restricted, high-energy diet and emergency regimen. Recently, Simon et al. described four Samoan children harbouring a hypomorphic allele (c.489G > A, p.Pro163=) associated with reduced levels of normally-spliced mRNA. This synonymous variant, missed on standard genomic testing, is prevalent in the Samoan population (allele frequency 0.17). Patients with LS and one ECHS1 variant were identified in NZ and Australian genomic and clinical databases. ECHS1 sequence data were interrogated for the c.489G > A variant and clinical data were reviewed. Thirteen patients from 10 families were identified; all had Pacific ancestry including Samoan, Māori, Cook Island Māori, and Tokelauan. All developed bilateral globus pallidi lesions, excluding one pre-symptomatic infant. Symptom onset was in early childhood, and was triggered by illness or starvation in 9/13. Four of 13 had exercise-induced dyskinesia, 9/13 optic atrophy and 6/13 nystagmus. Urine S-(2-carboxypropyl)cysteine-carnitine and other SCEH-related metabolites were normal or mildly increased. Functional studies demonstrated skipping of exon four and markedly reduced ECHS1 protein. These data provide further support for the pathogenicity of this ECHS1 variant which is also prevalent in Māori, Cook Island Māori, and Tongan populations (allele frequency 0.14-0.24). It highlights the need to search for a second variant in apparent heterozygotes with an appropriate phenotype, and has implications for genetic counselling in family members who are heterozygous for the more severe ECHS1 alleles. SYNOPSIS: Short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase deficiency is a frequent cause of Leigh-like disease in Māori and wider-Pacific populations, due to the high carrier frequency of a hypomorphic ECHS1 variant c.489G > A, p.[Pro163=, Phe139Valfs*65] that may be overlooked by standard genomic testing.

Valine and Inflammation Drive Epilepsy in a Mouse Model of ECHS1 Deficiency

ECHS1 Deficiency (ECHS1D) is a rare and devastating pediatric disease that currently has no defined treatments. This disorder results from missense loss-of-function mutations in the ECHS1 gene that result in severe developmental delays, encephalopathy, hypotonia, and early death. ECHS1 enzymatic activity is necessary for the beta-oxidation of fatty acids and the oxidation of branched-chain amino acids within the inner mitochondrial matrix. The pathogenesis of disease remains unknown, however it is hypothesized that disease is driven by an accumulation of toxic metabolites from impaired valine oxidation. To expand our knowledge on disease mechanisms, a novel mouse model of ECHS1D was generated that possesses a disease-associated knock-in (KI) allele and a knock-out (KO) allele. To investigate the behavioral phenotype, a battery of testing was performed at multiple time points, which included assessments of learning, motor function, endurance, sensory responses, and anxiety. Neurological abnormalities were assessed using wireless telemetry EEG recordings, pentylenetetrazol (PTZ) seizure induction, and immunohistochemistry. Metabolic perturbations were measured within the liver, serum, and brain using mass spectrometry and magnetic resonance spectroscopy. To test disease mechanisms, mice were subjected to disease pathway stressors and then survival, body weight gain, and epilepsy were assessed. Mice containing KI/KI or KI/KO alleles were viable with normal development and survival, and the presence of KI and KO alleles resulted in a significant reduction in ECHS1 protein. ECHS1D mice displayed reduced exercise capacity and pain sensation. EEG analysis revealed increased slow wave power that was associated with perturbations in sleep. ECHS1D mice had significantly increased epileptiform EEG discharges, and were sensitive to seizure induction, which resulted in death of 60% of ECHS1D mice. Under basal conditions, brain structure was grossly normal, although histological analysis revealed increased microglial activation in aged ECHS1D mice. Increased dietary valine only affected ECHS1D mice, which significantly exacerbated seizure susceptibility and resulted in death. Lastly, acute inflammatory challenge drove regression and early lethality in ECHS1D mice. In conclusion, we developed a novel model of ECHS1D that may be used to further knowledge on disease mechanisms and to develop therapeutics. Our data suggests altered metabolic signaling and inflammation may contribute to epilepsy in ECHS1D, and these alterations may be attributed to impaired valine metabolism.

Strategic validation of variants of uncertain significance in ECHS1 genetic testing

BACKGROUND

Enoyl-CoA hydratase short-chain 1 (ECHS1) is an enzyme involved in the metabolism of branched chain amino acids and fatty acids. Mutations in the ECHS1 gene lead to mitochondrial short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase 1 deficiency, resulting in the accumulation of intermediates of valine. This is one of the most common causative genes in mitochondrial diseases. While genetic analysis studies have diagnosed numerous cases with ECHS1 variants, the increasing number of variants of uncertain significance (VUS) in genetic diagnosis is a major problem.

METHODS

Here, we constructed an assay system to verify VUS function for ECHS1 gene. A high-throughput assay using ECHS1 knockout cells was performed to index these phenotypes by expressing cDNAs containing VUS. In parallel with the VUS validation system, a genetic analysis of samples from patients with mitochondrial disease was performed. The effect on gene expression in cases was verified by RNA-seq and proteome analysis.

RESULTS

The functional validation of VUS identified novel variants causing loss of ECHS1 function. The VUS validation system also revealed the effect of the VUS in the compound heterozygous state and provided a new methodology for variant interpretation. Moreover, we performed multiomics analysis and identified a synonymous substitution p.P163= that results in splicing abnormality. The multiomics analysis complemented the diagnosis of some cases that could not be diagnosed by the VUS validation system.

CONCLUSIONS

In summary, this study uncovered new ECHS1 cases based on VUS validation and omics analysis; these analyses are applicable to the functional evaluation of other genes associated with mitochondrial disease.

Acyl-CoA dehydrogenase substrate promiscuity: Challenges and opportunities for development of substrate reduction therapy in disorders of valine and isoleucine metabolism

Toxicity of accumulating substrates is a significant problem in several disorders of valine and isoleucine degradation notably short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase (ECHS1 or crotonase) deficiency, 3-hydroxyisobutyryl-CoA hydrolase (HIBCH) deficiency, propionic acidemia (PA), and methylmalonic aciduria (MMA). Isobutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase (ACAD8) and short/branched-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (SBCAD, ACADSB) function in the valine and isoleucine degradation pathways, respectively. Deficiencies of these acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (ACAD) enzymes are considered biochemical abnormalities with limited or no clinical consequences. We investigated whether substrate reduction therapy through inhibition of ACAD8 and SBCAD can limit the accumulation of toxic metabolic intermediates in disorders of valine and isoleucine metabolism. Using analysis of acylcarnitine isomers, we show that 2-methylenecyclopropaneacetic acid (MCPA) inhibited SBCAD, isovaleryl-CoA dehydrogenase, short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase and medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase, but not ACAD8. MCPA treatment of wild-type and PA HEK-293 cells caused a pronounced decrease in C3-carnitine. Furthermore, deletion of ACADSB in HEK-293 cells led to an equally strong decrease in C3-carnitine when compared to wild-type cells. Deletion of ECHS1 in HEK-293 cells caused a defect in lipoylation of the E2 component of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex, which was not rescued by ACAD8 deletion. MCPA was able to rescue lipoylation in ECHS1 KO cells, but only in cells with prior ACAD8 deletion. SBCAD was not the sole ACAD responsible for this compensation, which indicates substantial promiscuity of ACADs in HEK-293 cells for the isobutyryl-CoA substrate. Substrate promiscuity appeared less prominent for 2-methylbutyryl-CoA at least in HEK-293 cells. We suggest that pharmacological inhibition of SBCAD to treat PA should be investigated further.

Genetic Links to Episodic Movement Disorders: Current Insights

Episodic or paroxysmal movement disorders (PxMD) are conditions, which occur episodically, are transient, usually have normal interictal periods, and are characterized by hyperkinetic disorders, including ataxia, chorea, dystonia, and ballism. Broadly, these comprise paroxysmal dyskinesias (paroxysmal kinesigenic and non-kinesigenic dyskinesia [PKD/PNKD], paroxysmal exercise-induced dyskinesias [PED]) and episodic ataxias (EA) types 1-9. Classification of paroxysmal dyskinesias has traditionally been clinical. However, with advancement in genetics and the discovery of the molecular basis of several of these disorders, it is becoming clear that phenotypic pleiotropy exists, that is, the same variant may give rise to a variety of phenotypes, and the classical understanding of these disorders requires a new paradigm. Based on molecular pathogenesis, paroxysmal disorders are now categorized as synaptopathies, transportopathies, channelopathies, second-messenger related disorders, mitochondrial or others. A genetic paradigm also has an advantage of identifying potentially treatable disorders, such as glucose transporter 1 deficiency syndromes, which necessitates a ketogenic diet, and ADCY5-related disorders, which may respond to caffeine. Clues for a primary etiology include age at onset below 18 years, presence of family history and fixed triggers and attack duration. Paroxysmal movement disorder is a network disorder, with both the basal ganglia and the cerebellum implicated in pathogenesis. Abnormalities in the striatal cAMP turnover pathway may also be contributory. Although next-generation sequencing has restructured the approach to paroxysmal movement disorders, the genetic underpinnings of several entities remain undiscovered. As more genes and variants continue to be reported, these will lead to enhanced understanding of pathophysiological mechanisms and precise treatment.

Nutritional Interventions for Patients with Mitochondrial POLG-Related Diseases: A Systematic Review on Efficacy and Safety

Ketogenic diet is recommended as a treatment to reduce seizure frequency in patients with intractable epilepsy. The evidence and safety results are sparse for diet interventions in patients with pathogenic polymerase gamma (POLG) variants and intractable epilepsy. The aim of this systematic review is to summarize the efficacy of diet treatment on seizure frequency, clinical symptoms, and potential deleterious effect of liver involvement in patients with mitochondrial diseases caused by pathogenic POLG variants. Literature was searched in PubMed, Embase; and Cochrane in April 2022; no filter restrictions were imposed. The reference lists of retrieved studies were checked for additional literature. Eligibility criteria included verified pathogenic POLG variant and diet treatment. Overall, 880 studies were identified, providing eight case-reports representing nine patients eligible for inclusion. In eight of nine cases, clinical symptoms were improved; six out of nine cases reported improvements in seizure frequency. However, increasing levels of liver enzymes after initiating ketogenic diet were found in four of the nine cases, with one case revealing decreased levels of liver enzymes after initiating long-chain triglyceride restriction. Viewed together, the studies imply that ketogenic diet can have a positive impact on seizure frequency, but may induce progression of liver impairment in patients with pathogenic POLG variants.

Clinical improvements after treatment with a low-valine and low-fat diet in a pediatric patient with enoyl-CoA hydratase, short chain 1 (ECHS1) deficiency

Background

Enoyl-CoA hydratase short-chain 1 (ECHS1) is a key mitochondrial enzyme that is involved in valine catabolism and fatty acid beta-oxidation. Mutations in the ECHS1 gene lead to enzymatic deficiency, resulting in the accumulation of certain intermediates from the valine catabolism pathway. This disrupts the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex and the mitochondrial respiratory chain, with consequent cellular damage. Patients present with a variable age of onset and a wide spectrum of clinical features. The Leigh syndrome phenotype is the most frequently reported form of the disease. Herein, we report a case of a male with ECHS1 deficiency who was diagnosed at 8 years of age. He presented severe dystonia, hyperlordosis, moderate to severe kyphoscoliosis, great difficulty in walking, and severe dysarthria. A valine-restricted and total fat-restricted diet was considered as a therapeutic option after the genetic diagnosis. An available formula that restricted branched-chain amino acids and especially restricted valine was used. We also restricted animal protein intake and provided a low-fat diet that was particularly low in dairy fat.

Results

This protein- and fat-restricted diet was initiated with adequate tolerance and adherence. After three years, the patient noticed an improvement in dystonia, especially in walking. He currently requires minimal support to walk or stand. Therefore, he has enhanced his autonomy to go to school or establish a career for himself. His quality of life and motivation for treatment have greatly increased.

Conclusions

There is still a substantial lack of knowledge about this rare disorder, especially knowledge about future effective treatments. However, early diagnosis and treatment with a valine- and fat-restricted diet, particularly dairy fat-restricted diet, appeared to limit disease progression in this patient with ECHS1 deficiency.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13023-022-02468-6.

A Novel Variation of the Short-Chain Enoyl-CoA Hydratase-1 Gene Presenting with a Novel Mild Phenotype: The Second Case Report from India

A 9-year-old girl presented with asymmetric abnormal twisting movements affecting her left side more than the right side, initially action induced, but later persistent. Examination revealed generalized persistent dystonia with choreoathetosis and right partial tonic ocular tilt reaction. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed T1 and T2 fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) hypointense and T2 hyperintense signal changes in bilateral globus pallidi. Clinical exome sequencing revealed compound heterozygous variatnts in enoyl-CoA hydratase-1 (ECHS1) gene: a novel pathogenic variant in exon 6, chr10:g.133366045G > A (p.Gln224Ter) and a likely pathogenic variant in exon 5, chr10:g.133366990G > A (p.Ala173Val). Metabolic testing and arterial lactate levels were normal. She was treated with valine restricted diet, trihexiphenidyl, clonazepam, N-acetyl cysteine and mitochondrial cocktail, without significant improvement over the 6 months follow-up period.

A Case of ECHS1 Deficiency with Severe Encephalopathy and Status Epilepticus after a Propofol Sedation: Case Report

BACKGROUND

Short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase (ECHS1) deficiency is a rare metabolic disorder. Concerned patients present with Leigh syndrome symptoms or a Leigh-like syndrome. Only 58 patients are known worldwide. The ECHS1 is a key component in β-oxidation and valine catabolic pathways.

CASE

Here we report a 6-month-old Lebanese boy born to consanguineous parents. He presented an increased muscle tone, hyperexcitability, feeding problems, horizontal nystagmus, and developmental delay. Magnetic resonance imaging of the brain revealed frontal brain atrophy, corpus callosum atrophy, and T2 hyperintensity in pallidum, internal capsule, pons, and thalamus. In the postsedation phase, the patient displayed a sudden generalized seizure with transition to status epilepticus. Therefore, we conducted metabolic examinations, which showed elevated levels of 2-methyl-2,3-DiOH-butyrate and 3-methylglutaconate in urine. Single exome sequencing revealed the homozygous mutation c.476A > G in the ECHS1 gene.

CONCLUSION

This case report describes the clinical symptoms and the diagnostics of ECHS1 deficiency. It shows the importance of further metabolic and genetic testing of patients with motoric conspicuities and developmental delay. It is important to be cautious with propofol sedation of patients who present an unknown neurological disorder, when metabolic disturbance or especially mitochondriopathy is suspected.

Pathogenic Biallelic Mutations in ECHS1 in a Case with Short-Chain Enoyl-CoA Hydratase (SCEH) Deficiency-Case Report and Literature Review

ECHS1 gene mutations are known to cause mitochondrial short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase 1 deficiency, a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by psychomotor development delay, lactic acidosis, and basal ganglia lesions resembling Leigh syndrome. Short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase 1 (ECHS1) deficiency is a very rare and new disorder, with a wide phenotypic spectrum and different outcomes ranging from neonatal death to survival into adulthood. Since the identification of ECHS1 deficiency in 2014, almost 63 patients with pathogenic mutations in the ECHS1 gene have been described to date. This paper focuses on the clinical and molecular findings as well as the evolution of a Caucasian girl diagnosed with ECHS1 deficiency who carries a new compound heterozygous mutation in the ECHS1 gene. Polymorphic symptoms, namely failure to thrive, significant global developmental delay/regression, movement disorders, ocular abnormalities, hearing loss, seizure, and cardiac myopathy, may be a challenge in mitochondrial disorder suspicion. Early diagnosis, an appropriate diet with valine restriction, and trigger avoidance are essential, as there is no effective therapy for the disease. This disorder influences life quality in these patients and their caregivers, and it has the potential to be fatal.

Valine metabolites analysis in ECHS1 deficiency

Short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase (ECHS1) is involved in amino acid and fatty acid catabolism in mitochondria and its deficiency causes Leigh syndrome or exercise-induced dystonia. More than 60 patients with this condition have been reported till date. The accumulation of intermediate metabolites of valine is assumed to be responsible for the cytotoxicity. Since protein restriction, including valine reportedly improves neurological symptoms, it is essential to consider the possible incidence of and diagnose ECHS1 syndrome in the earlier stages. This study reported the liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) urine and plasma metabolite analysis in six cases, including four new cases with ECHS1 deficiency. The values of urine cysteine/cysteamine conjugates from valine metabolites, S-(2-carboxypropyl) cysteine/cysteamine from methacrylyl-CoA, and S-(2-carboxyethyl) cysteine/cysteamine from acryloyl-CoA were separated between six patients and six normal controls. The LC-MS/MS analysis revealed that these metabolites can be used for the early diagnosis and evaluation of diet therapy.