Pure anatase and rutile + anatase nanoparticles differently affect wheat seedlings

Less is more: The hormetic effect of titanium dioxide nanoparticles on plants

Titanium dioxide nanoparticles have attracted considerable attention due to their extensive applications; however, their multifaceted influence on plant physiology and the broader environment remains a complex subject. This review systematically synthesizes recent studies on the hormetic effects of TiO2 nanoparticles on plants - a phenomenon characterized by dual dose-response behavior that impacts various plant functions. It provides crucial insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying these hormetic effects, encompassing their effects on photosynthesis, oxidative stress response and gene regulation. The significance of this article consists in its emphasis on the necessity to establish clear regulatory frameworks and promote international collaboration to standardize the responsible adoption of nano-TiO2 technology within the agricultural sector. The findings are presented with the intention of stimulating interdisciplinary research and serving as an inspiration for further exploration and investigation within this vital and continually evolving field.

Photosynthesis governed by nanoparticulate titanium dioxide. The Pisum sativum L. case study

Wide availability of anthropogenic TiO2 nanoparticles facilitates their penetration into environment and prompts interactions with plants. They alter plants growth and change their nutritional status. In particular, metabolic processes are affected. In this work the effect of nanometric TiO2 on photosynthesis efficiency in green pea (Pisum sativum L.) was studied. Hydroponic cultivations with three Ti levels (10; 50 and 100 mg L-1) were applied. At all concentrations nanoparticles penetrated into plant tissues and were detected by the single particle ICP-MS/MS method. Nanoparticles altered the CO2 assimilation rate and gas exchange parameters (i.e. transpiration, stomatal conductance, sub-stomatal CO2 concentration). The most pronounced effects were observed for Ti 50 mg L-1 cultivation where photosynthesis efficiency, transpiration and stomatal conductance were increased by 14.69%, 4.58% and 8.92%, respectively. They were further confirmed by high maximum ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylation rate (27.40% increase), maximum electron transport rate (21.51% increase) and the lowest CO2 compensation point (45.19% decrease). Furthermore, concentrations of Cu, Mn, Zn, Fe, Mg, Ca, K and P were examined with the most pronounced changes observed for elements directly involved in photosynthesis (Cu, Zn, Mn, and Fe). The Cu concentrations in roots, stems and leaves for Ti 50 mg L-1 cultivation were below the control by 33.15%, 38.28% and 10.76%, respectively. The Zn content in analogous treatment and organs decreased by 30.24%, 26.69% and 13.35%. The Mn and Fe levels in leaves were increased by 72.22% and 50.32%, respectively. Our results indicated that plant defence mechanisms which restrain the water uptake have been overcome in pea by photocatalytic activity of nanoparticulate TiO2 which stimulated photosynthesis. On the contrary to the substantial stomatal conductance, the transpiration has been reduced because exceptional part of water flow was already consumed in chloroplasts and could not have been freed to the atmosphere.

Use of metal nanoparticles in agriculture. A review on the effects on plant germination

Agricultural nanotechnology has become a powerful tool to help crops and improve agricultural production in the context of a growing world population. However, its application can have some problems with the development of harvests, especially during germination. This review evaluates nanoparticles with essential (Cu, Fe, Ni and Zn) and non-essential (Ag and Ti) elements on plant germination. In general, the effect of nanoparticles depends on several factors (dose, treatment time, application method, type of nanoparticle and plant). In addition, pH and ionic strength are relevant when applying nanoparticles to the soil. In the case of essential element nanoparticles, Fe nanoparticles show better results in improving nutrient uptake, improving germination, and the possibility of magnetic properties could favor their use in the removal of pollutants. In the case of Cu and Zn nanoparticles, they can be beneficial at low concentrations, while their excess presents toxicity and negatively affects germination. About nanoparticles of non-essential elements, both Ti and Ag nanoparticles can be helpful for nutrient uptake. However, their potential effects depend highly on the crop type, particle size and concentration. Overall, nanotechnology in agriculture is still in its early stages of development, and more research is needed to understand potential environmental and public health impacts.

Metabolomics as a Tool to Understand Nano-Plant Interactions: The Case Study of Metal-Based Nanoparticles

Metabolomics is a powerful tool in diverse research areas, enabling an understanding of the response of organisms, such as plants, to external factors, their resistance and tolerance mechanisms against stressors, the biochemical changes and signals during plant development, and the role of specialized metabolites. Despite its advantages, metabolomics is still underused in areas such as nano-plant interactions. Nanoparticles (NPs) are all around us and have a great potential to improve and revolutionize the agri-food sector and modernize agriculture. They can drive precision and sustainability in agriculture as they can act as fertilizers, improve plant performance, protect or defend, mitigate environmental stresses, and/or remediate soil contaminants. Given their high applicability, an in-depth understanding of NPs' impact on plants and their mechanistic action is crucial. Being aware that, in nano-plant interaction work, metabolomics is much less addressed than physiology, and that it is lacking a comprehensive review focusing on metabolomics, this review gathers the information available concerning the metabolomic tools used in studies focused on NP-plant interactions, highlighting the impact of metal-based NPs on plant metabolome, metabolite reconfiguration, and the reprogramming of metabolic pathways.

Titanium and Zinc Based Nanomaterials in Agriculture: A Promising Approach to Deal with (A)biotic Stresses?

Abiotic stresses, such as those induced by climatic factors or contaminants, and biotic stresses prompted by phytopathogens and pests inflict tremendous losses in agriculture and are major threats to worldwide food security. In addition, climate changes will exacerbate these factors as well as their negative impact on crops. Drought, salinity, heavy metals, pesticides, and drugs are major environmental problems that need deep attention, and effective and sustainable strategies to mitigate their effects on the environment need to be developed. Besides, sustainable solutions for agrocontrol must be developed as alternatives to conventional agrochemicals. In this sense, nanotechnology offers promising solutions to mitigate environmental stress effects on plants, increasing plant tolerance to the stressor, for the remediation of environmental contaminants, and to protect plants against pathogens. In this review, nano-sized TiO₂ (nTiO₂) and ZnO (nZnO) are scrutinized, and their potential to ameliorate drought, salinity, and xenobiotics effects in plants are emphasized, in addition to their antimicrobial potential for plant disease management. Understanding the level of stress alleviation in plants by these nanomaterials (NM) and relating them with the application conditions/methods is imperative to define the most sustainable and effective approaches to be adopted. Although broad-spectrum reviews exist, this article provides focused information on nTiO₂ and nZnO for improving our understanding of the ameliorative potential that these NM show, addressing the gaps in the literature.

Low levels of TiO2-nanoparticles interact antagonistically with Al and Pb alleviating their toxicity

The contamination and bioavailability of deleterious metals in arable soils significantly limits crop development and yield. Aiming at mitigating Pb- and Al-induced phytotoxicity, this work explores the use of P25 titanium dioxide nanoparticles (nTiO₂) in soil amendments. For that, Lactuca sativa L. plants were germinated and grown in the presence of 10 ppm Pb or 50 ppm Al, combined or not with 5 ppm nTiO₂. Growth parameters, as well as endpoints of the redox state [cell relative membrane permeability (RMP), thiobarbituric acid reactive substances content, total phenolic content and photosynthesis (sugars and pigments levels, chlorophyll a fluorescence and gas exchange), were evaluated. Concerning Al, nTiO₂ treatment alleviated the impairments induced in germination rate, seedling length, water content, RMP, stomatal conductance (g_s), intercellular CO₂ (C_i), and net CO₂ assimilation rate (P_N). It increased anthocyanins contents and effective efficiency of photosystem II (Φ_PSII). In Pb-exposed plants, nTiO₂ amendment mitigated the effects in RMP, P_N, g_s, and C_i. It also increased the pigment contents and the transpiration rate (E) comparatively to the control without nTiO₂. These results clearly highlight the high potential of low doses of nTiO₂ in alleviating metal phytotoxicity, particularly the one of Pb. Additionally, further research should explore the use of these nanoparticles in agricultural soil amendments.

Ecotoxicological effects of titanium dioxide nanoparticles and Galaxolide, separately and as binary mixtures, in radish (Raphanus sativus)

Nano-TiO₂ and Galaxolide (HHCB) are continually released into the environment because they are common ingredients of personal care products. In this study, the effects of nano-TiO₂ and HHCB, individually and as binary mixtures, on Raphanus sativus were investigated. Growth indices (germination rate, root length, and shoot elongation), random amplification of polymorphic DNA profiles of DNA damage in the seedling roots, and expression of genes related to DNA damage, repair, and the cell cycle were assessed. Radish germination was not affected by nano-TiO₂ (5-200 mg L^-1) but was inhibited by HHCB (≥50 mg L^-1). Nano-TiO₂ and HHCB both caused severe DNA damage, including DNA mismatch damage, DNA double-strand breaks, and chromosomal damage. The binary mixtures indicated antagonistic effects occurred, and 200 mg L^-1 nano-TiO₂ decreased the genetic toxicity of HHCB. Of the genes that were examined, MRE11 and WRKY40 were the most sensitive to nano-TiO₂ and HHCB, indicating that these genes could be used as sensitive biomarkers for exposure of R. sativus to nano-TiO₂ and HHCB. The results improve our understanding of the risks posed by nano-TiO₂ and HHCB to R. sativus in particular and possibly to other plants.

Influence of GdVO4:Eu3+ Nanocrystals on Growth, Germination, Root Cell Viability and Oxidative Stress of Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) Seedlings

The increasing application of lanthanide-doped nanocrystals (LDNCs) entails the risk of a harmful impact on the natural environment. Therefore, in the presented study the influence of gadolinium orthovanadates doped with Eu³⁺ (GdVO₄:Eu³) nanocrystals on wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), chosen as a model plant species, was investigated. The seeds were grown in Petri dishes filled with colloids of LDNCs at the concentrations of 0, 10, 50 and 100 µg/mL. The plants’ growth endpoints (number of roots, roots length, roots mass, hypocotyl length and hypocotyl mass) and germination rate were not significantly changed after the exposure to GdVO₄:Eu³⁺ nanocrystals at all used concentrations. The presence of LDNCs also had no effect on oxidative stress intensity, which was determined on the basis of the amount of lipid peroxidation product (thiobarbituric acid reactive substances; TBARS) in the roots. Similarly, TTC (tetrazolium chloride) assay did not show any differences in cells’ viability. However, root cells of the treated seedlings contained less Evans Blue (EB) when compared to the control. The obtained results, on the one hand, suggest that GdVO₄:Eu³⁺ nanocrystals are safe for plants in the tested concentrations, while on the other hand they indicate that LDNCs may interfere with the functioning of the root cell membrane.

TiO2 nanoparticles dose, application method and phosphorous levels influence genotoxicity in Rice (Oryza sativa L.), soil enzymatic activities and plant growth

The present study focused on investigating the effect of titanium dioxide nanoparticles (TiO₂NPs) on rice (Oryza sativa L.) growth and changes in soil health in two contrasting soil textures (silt-loam and clay). Moreover, response of rice to different methods of TiO₂NPs application and phosphorous fertilizer levels were also evaluated. For toxicity assessment, pot experiment was carried out. TiO₂NPs (0, 500, 750 mg kg^-1) were applied and plants were grown till vegetative stage. After harvesting, physiological parameters, stress assay, soil microbial and enzymatic activities were determined. Based on the results of toxicity study, impact of three methods of TiO₂NPs application (foliar, irrigation, soil) and four phosphorous fertilizer levels (0, 10, 20, 40 mg kg^-1) on rice growth were assessed. During the 1st phase, results showed an adverse effect of TiO₂NPs on plant growth and soil microorganisms in both soil textures at 750 mg kg^-1. The H₂O₂ production, lipid peroxidation and leaf membrane injury index were increased by 4.3-, 2.4-, and 1.9-folds in clay soil upon 750 mg kg^-1 TiO₂NPs application. Likewise, at the same level of TiO₂NPs; microbial biomass, dehydrogenase, and respiration were decreased by 0.91-, 0.79-, and 0.78- folds respectively. In 2nd phase, maximum shoot length, biomass, phosphorous uptake and rice grain protein content were observed under application of TiO₂NPs (500 mg kg^-1) through irrigation method in combination with 40 mg P kg^-1. However, 20 and 40 mg P kg^-1 performed equally well upon TiO₂NPs application and the results were not statistically significant. The results suggest that 750 mg kg^-1 of TiO₂NPs negatively affect plant growth and soil enzymatic activities. Moreover, combined application of TiO₂NPs (500 mg kg^-1) through irrigation and 20 mg P kg^-1 is recommended to be the optimum for growth of rice plant.

TiO2 nanoparticles induced sugar impairments and metabolic pathway shift towards amino acid metabolism in wheat

TiO₂-nanoparticles (TiO₂-NP) have the potential to impair plant development. Nevertheless, the metabolic processes behind the physiological responses to TiO₂-NP are still far from being fully understood. In this study, Triticum aestivum plants were exposed for 21 days to different concentrations (0; 5; 50; 150 mg L^-1) of TiO₂-NP (P25). After treatment, the metabolite profiles of roots and leaves were analysed. The content of >70 % of the identified metabolites changed in response to P25 and the impact on metabolic pathways increased with TiO₂-NP dose, with leaves showing higher alterations. Roots up-regulated monosaccharides, azelaic acid, and γ-aminobutanoic acid and triggered the tyrosine metabolism, whereas leaves up-regulated the metabolisms of reserve sugars and tocopherol, and the phenylalanine and tryptophan pathways. Both organs (mainly leaves) up-regulated the aspartate family pathway together with serine, alanine and valine metabolisms and the glycerolipids' biosynthesis. In addition, the citrate and glyoxylate metabolisms were down-regulated in both organs (highest dose). Sugar biosynthesis breakdown, due to photosynthetic disturbances, shifted the cell metabolism to use amino acids as an alternative energy source, and both ROS and sugars worked as signalling molecules activating organ dependent antioxidant responses. Concluding, these NP-pollutants severely impact multiple crop metabolic pathways and may ultimately compromise plant performance.

TiO2 nanoparticles in a biosolid-amended soil and their implication in soil nutrients, microorganisms and Pisum sativum nutrition

The wide use of nanoparticles (NPs), gives concern about their possible negative implications in the environment and living organisms. In particular, titanium dioxide (TiO2) NPs are accumulated in biosolids (Bs) coming from wastewater treatment plants, which in turn are used as farm soil amendments and are becoming an important way of NPs entrance in the terrestrial ecosystems. In this study, to simulate a low and cumulative load of TiO2 NPs, 80 and 800 mg TiO2per Kg of soil were spiked in the Bs prior to its addition to soil. The effects of different crystal phases of TiO2 NPs (pure anatase and pure rutile or their mixture) and their non-coated bulk counterparts (larger particles) on the availability of mineral nutrients and on the status of the bacterial communities together with the nutritional status of Pisum sativum L. plants were evaluated. Results showed the reduction, to different extents, on the availability of important soil mineral nutrients (e.g. Mn 65%, Fe 20%, P 27%, averagely), in some cases size- (e.g. P) and dose-dependent. Bacterial biodiversity was also affected by the presence of high TiO2 dose in soil. The mineral nutrition of pea plants was also altered, showing the main reduction in Mn (80% in the roots and 50% in the shoots), K, Zn, P (respectively, 80, 40, and 35% in the roots), and an increase of N in the shoots, with possible consequences on the quality of the crop. The present study gives new integrated data on the effects of TiO2 NPs in the soil-plant system, on the soil health and on the nutritional quality of crops, rising new implications for future policies and human health.

Antioxidant mechanisms to counteract TiO2-nanoparticles toxicity in wheat leaves and roots are organ dependent

Nanoparticles (NP) bioactivity is under deep scrutiny. In this work, the antioxidant response to TiO₂-NP in wheat (Triticum aestivum) was determined. For that, enzymatic and the non-enzymatic antioxidants were evaluated in plants exposed to the P25 anatase:rutile material composed of TiO₂-NP and under environmentally realistic doses (0; 5; 50; 150 mg/L for 20 days). Shoot but not root growth was reduced. In leaves, thiol metabolism and ascorbate accumulation were the preferred route whereas in roots the pre-existing antioxidant capacity was preferentially utilized. Both leaves and roots showed increased glutathione reductase and dehydroascorbate reductase activities and decreased ascorbate peroxidase activity. Roots, nevertheless, presented higher enzymatic basal levels than leaves. On the other hand, when examining non-enzymatic antioxidants, the ratio of reduced-to-oxidized glutathione (GSH/GSSG) increased in leaves and decreased in roots. Exposed leaves also presented higher total ascorbate accumulation compared to roots. TiO₂-NP exposure down regulated, with more prominence in roots, antioxidant enzyme genes encoding catalase, ascorbate peroxidase, monodehydroascorbate reductase and dehydroascorbate reductase. In leaves, superoxide dismutase gene expression was increased. All data pinpoint to TiO₂-NP toxicity above 5 mg/L, with aerial parts being more susceptible, which draws concerns on the safety doses for the use of these NPs in agricultural practices.

Titanium dioxide nanoparticles impaired both photochemical and non-photochemical phases of photosynthesis in wheat

Titanium dioxide nanoparticles (TiO₂-NP) are increasingly being proposed for nanoagriculture but their effect on photosynthesis is limited and contradictory, mostly regarding putative chronical effects associated to the exposure to the commercial P25 formulation (anatase:rutile). This research aims at evaluating how chronical exposure to P25-NP affect photosynthetic processes in Triticum aestivum. Wheat plants were exposed (from the germination stage) to 0, 5, 50, and 150 mg L^-1 P25-NP for 20 days. P25-NP impaired both light-dependent and -independent phases of photosynthesis, decreased chlorophyll a content, maximal and effective efficiency of PSII, net photosynthetic rate, transpiration rate, stomatal conductance, intercellular CO₂ concentration, and starch content. On the other hand, no effects were observed in photochemical and in non-photochemical quenching values, on total soluble sugar (TSS) content or in RuBisCO activity. Our results support that the induced decay in chlorophyll a content compromised the electron transport through PSII and that stomatal limitations impaired CO₂ assimilation. The decline of starch content seems to be a consequence of its degradation as a mechanism to maintain the TSS levels. Consequently, we propose that photosynthetic related endpoints are sensitive and valuable biomarkers to assess TiO₂-NP toxicity.

Wheat chronic exposure to TiO2-nanoparticles: Cyto- and genotoxic approach

This study investigates the phytotoxicity of chronic exposure (up to 20 d) of different TiO₂ nanoparticles (TiO₂-NP) concentrations (5, 50, 150 mg L^-1) in Triticum aestivum. Germination was not affected by TiO₂-NP exposure and seedling shoot length (3 d) was enhanced. Contrarily, plants' shoot growth (20 d) was impaired. Effects on membrane permeability and total antioxidant capacity in TiO₂-NP chronic exposure were organ dependent: increased in leaves and decreased in roots. Roots also showed lower levels of lipid peroxidation. Flow cytometry revealed no changes in ploidy levels as well as in the cell cycle dynamics for both organs. However, TiO₂-NP induced clastogenic effects in roots with increases in micronucleated cells in root tips in a dose dependent manner. Also, increases of DNA single/double strand breaks were found in leaves, and effects were similar to all doses. Ti uptake and translocation to leaves were confirmed by ICP-MS, which was dependent on NP concentration. Overall, these data indicate that TiO₂-NP phytotoxicity is more severe after longer exposure periods, higher doses and more severe for shoots than roots. The observed effects are a result of both direct and indirect (oxidative stress and/or water imbalances) action of TiO₂-NP. Additionally, results highlight the negative impact that TiO₂-NP may have on crop growth and production and to the risk of trophic transfer.

Pb low doses induced genotoxicity in Lactuca sativa plants

Soil and water contamination by lead (Pb) remains a topic of great concern, particularly regarding crop production. The admissible Pb values in irrigation water in several countries range from ≈0.1 to ≈5 mg L-1. In order to evaluate putative effects of Pb within legal doses on crops growth, we exposed Lactuca sativa seeds and seedlings to increasing doses of Pb(NO3)2 up to 20 mg L-1. The OECD parameter seed germination and seedling/plant growth were not affected by any of the Pb-concentrations used. However, for doses higher than 5 mg L-1 significant DNA damage was detected: Comet assay detected DNA fragmentation at ≥ 5 mg L-1 and presence of micronuclei (MN) were detected for 20 mg L-1. Also, cell cycle impairment was observed for doses as low as 0.05 mg L-1 and 0.5 mg L-1 (mostly G2 arrest). Our data show that for the low doses of Pb used, the OECD endpoints were not able to detect toxicity, while more sensitive endpoints (related with DNA damage and mitotic/interphase disorders) identified genotoxic and cytostatic effects. Furthermore, the nature of the genotoxic effect was dependent on the concentration. Finally, we recommend that MN test and the comet assay should be included as sensitive endpoints in (eco)toxicological assays.