Inhibited transport of graphene oxide nanoparticles in granular quartz sand coated with Bacillus subtilis and Pseudomonas putida biofilms

Transport and retention of functionalized graphene oxide nanoparticles in saturated/unsaturated porous media: Effects of flow velocity, ionic strength and initial particle concentration

The widespread use of nanomaterials has raised the threat of nanoparticles (NPs) infection of soils and groundwater resources. This research aims to investigate three parameters including flow velocity, ionic strength (IS), and initial particle concentration effects on transport behavior and retention mechanism of functionalization form of graphene oxide with polyvinylpyrrolidone (GO-PVP). The transport of GO-PVP was investigated in a laboratory-scale study through saturated/unsaturated (Saturation Degree = 0.91) sand columns. Experiments were conducted on flow velocity from 1.20 to 2.04 cm min-1, initial particle concentration from 10 to 50 mg L-1, and IS of 5-20 mM. The retention of GO-PVP was best described using the one-site kinetic attachment model in HYDRUS-1D, which accounted for the time and depth-dependent retention. According to breakthrough curves (BTCs), the lower transport related to the rate of mass recovery of GO-PVP was obtained by decreasing flow velocity and initial particle concentration and increasing IS through the sand columns. Increasing IS could improve the GO-PVP retention (based on katt and Smax) in saturated/unsaturated media; katt increases from 2.81 × 10-3 to 3.54 × 10-3 s-1 and Smax increases from 0.37 to 0.42 mg g-1 in saturated/unsaturated conditions, respectively. Our findings showed that the increasing retention of GO-PVP through the sand column under unsaturated condition could be recommended for the reduction of nanoparticles danger of ecosystem exposure.

Effects of biofilms on the retention and transport of PFOA in saturated porous media

Understanding the fate and transport of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) in soil and groundwater is essential to reliable assessments of its risks. This study investigated the impacts of Gram-positive Bacillus subtilis (BS), Gram-negative Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) and wild microbiota (WM) biofilm on the transport of PFOA in saturated sand columns at two ionic strengths (i.e., 1.0 and 20.0 mM NaCl). The retention of PFOA in biofilm-coated sand columns was higher than that in uncoated sand columns, due to biofilm-induced reinforced hydrophobic interactions and surface roughness, and decreased zeta potential. However, the retention effects varied among biofilm bacterial species with PFOA retardation factors in PA, WM and BS columns of 1.29-1.38, 1.21-1.29 and 1.11-1.15, respectively. Notably, PA biofilm had the most pronounced effect on PFOA retention. While increasing ionic strength promoted the retention of PFOA in BS biofilm-coated sand, it had no significant impact on PFOA transport in PA and WM biofilm-coated sand. This could be attributed to the differences in biofilm composition, deviating the ionic strengths effects on electrostatic double layer compression. The advection dispersion equation coupled with two-site kinetic retention model well described the transport of PFOA in all saturated columns. Our findings reveal that biofilm plays important roles in PFOA transport in porous media, instructive for risk assessment and remediation of PFOA contamination.

The detection and characterization techniques for the interaction between graphene oxide and natural colloids: A review

The high dispersibility of graphene oxide (GO) and the universality of natural colloids (clay minerals, (hydr)oxides of Al, Fe, silica, etc.) make them interact easily. Many kinds of analytical methods have been used to study the interaction between GO and natural colloids. This review provides a comprehensive overview of analytical methods for the detection and quantification of interaction process. We highlighted the influence of the most relevant environmental factors (ionic strength, pH, etc.) on batch experiment, quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring measurements, and column experiments. Besides, the benefits and drawbacks of spectroscopic, microscopic techniques, theoretical models, calculation and time-resolved dynamic light scattering methods also have discussed in this work. This review can give some guidance to researchers in their selection and combination of the technique for the research of the interaction between GO and natural colloids.

Extracellular electron transfer influences the transport and retention of ferrihydrite nanoparticles in quartz sand coated with Shewanella oneidensis biofilm

Microbial biofilm has been found to impact the mobility of nanoparticles in saturated porous media by altering physicochemical properties of collector surface. However, little is known about the influence of biofilm's biological activity on nanoparticle transport and retention. Here, the transport of ferrihydrite nanoparticles (FhNPs) was studied in quartz sands coated with biofilm of Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 that is capable of reducing Fe(III) through extracellular electron transfer (EET). It was found that MR-1 biofilm coating enhanced FhNPs' deposition under different pH/ionic strength conditions and humic acid concentrations. More importantly, when the influent electron donor (glucose) concentration was increased to promote biofilm's EET activity, the breakthrough of FhNPs in biofilm-coated sands was inhibited. A lack of continuous and stable supply of electron donor, on the contrary, led to remobilization and release of the originally retained FhNPs. Column experiments with biofilm of EET-deficient MR-1 mutants (ΔomcA/ΔmtrC and ΔcymA) further indicated that the impairment of EET activity decreased the retention of FhNPs. It is proposed that the effective surface binding and adhesion of FhNPs that is required by direct EET cannot be neglected when evaluating the transport of FhNPs in sands coated with electroactive biofilm.

Bacteria transport and deposition in an unsaturated aggregated porous medium with dual porosity

Bacterial transport and deposition play an important role in the assessment and prediction of subsurface pollution risks. Bacteria transport experiments were performed under unsaturated flow conditions in an aggregated porous medium at the laboratory column scale, to investigate how the inter- and intra-aggregated pore space of this medium could affect transport and deposition under unsaturated flow conditions, where inter- and intra-pore spaces are not fully activated. The results obtained through experimental observations and numerical simulations showed that some intra- and inter-pore space of this medium was excluded from bacteria transport and retention, as confirmed by the non-uniform transport of bacteria pathways in the aggregated porous media under unsaturated flow conditions. Capillary energy was higher the than other forces acting at bacteria air-water-solid interfaces. If this energy should contribute in increasing bacteria deposition under unsaturated conditions, similar to what has been reported for sandy media, similar overall retention of E. coli and R. rhodochrous was obtained under unsaturated flow conditions, suggesting that capillary energy was not the driving force for bacteria deposition.

Effect of Strain-Specific Biofilm Properties on the Retention of Colloids in Saturated Porous Media under Conditions of Stormwater Biofiltration

Filter performance can be affected by bacterial colonization of the filtration media, yet little is known about how naturally occurring bacteria modify the surface properties of filtration media to affect colloidal removal. We used sand columns and simulated stormwater conditions to study the retention of model colloidal particles, carboxyl-modified-latex (CML) beads, in porous media colonized by naturally occurring bacterial strains. Colloid retention varied substantially across identical columns colonized by different, in some cases closely related, bacterial strains in a cell density independent manner. Atomic force microscopy was applied to quantify the interaction energy between CML beads and each bacterial strain's biofilm surface. We found interaction energy between CML and each strain was significantly different, with adhesive energies between the biofilm and CML, presumed to be associated with polymer-surface bonding, a better predictor of CML retention than other strain characteristics. Overall, the findings suggest that interactions with biopolymers in naturally occurring bacterial biofilms strongly influence colloid retention in porous media. This work highlights the need for more investigation into the role of biofilm microbial community composition on colloid removal in porous media to improve biofilter design and operation.

Transport and retention of graphene oxide nanoparticles in sandy and carbonaceous aquifer sediments: Effect of physicochemical factors and natural biofilm

There is a paucity of information regarding the interaction between GONPs and natural aquifer sediments. Therefore, batch and column experiments were carried out to determine the transport, retention and attachment behavior of GONPs with the surfaces of native aquifer sediments. The experiments were performed with sediments comprising contrasting mineralogical features (sand grains, quartz and limestone sediments), at different temperatures, ionic strength and compositions. Uniquely, this research also investigated the effect of natural biofilm on the retention behavior of nanoparticles in porous media. The retention rate of GONPs at 22 °C was higher than at 4 °C. Moreover, there was greater retention of GONPs onto the surfaces of collectors at higher ionic strengths and cation valence. The retention profiles (RPs) of GONPs in pristine porous media at low ionic strength were linear, which contrasted with hyper-exponential shape of RPs at high ionic strength. The size-distribution analysis of retained GONPs showed decreasing particle diameter with increasing distance from the column inlet at high ionic strength and equal diameter at low ionic strengths. The GONP retention rate was higher for natural porous media than for sand, due to the presence of metal oxides heterogeneities. The presence of biofilm on porous media increased the retention rate of GONPs when compared to the porous media in the absence of biofilm.

Cotransport of Cu with Graphene Oxide in Saturated Porous Media with Varying Degrees of Geochemical Heterogeneity

Graphene oxide (GO) is likely to encounter heavy metals due to its widespread use and inevitable release into the subsurface environment, where the ubiquitous presence of iron oxides (e.g., hematite) would affect their interaction and transport. The present study aimed to investigate the cotransport of GO (20 mg L−1) and copper (0.05 mM CuCl2) in the presence of varying degrees of geochemical heterogeneity represented by iron oxide-coated sand fractions (ω = 0‒0.45) in water-saturated columns under environmentally relevant physicochemical conditions (1 mM KCl at pH 5.0‒9.0). The Langmuir-fitted maximum adsorption capacity of Cu2+ by GO reached 137.6 mg g−1, and the presence of 0.05 mM Cu2+ decreased the colloidal stability and subsequent transport of GO in porous media. The iron oxide coating was found to significantly inhibit the transport of GO and Cu-loaded GO in sand-packed columns, which can be explained by the favorable deposition of the negatively charged GO onto patches of the positively charged iron oxide coatings at pH 5.0. Increasing the solution pH from 5.0 to 9.0 promoted the mobility of GO, with the exception of pH 7.5, in which the lowest breakthrough of GO was observed. This is possibly due to the fact that the surface charge of iron oxide approaches zero at pH 7.5, suggesting that new “favorable” sites are available for GO retention. This study deciphered the complicated interactions among engineered nanomaterials, heavy metals, and geochemical heterogeneity under environmentally relevant physicochemical conditions. Our results highlight the significant role of geochemical heterogeneity, such as iron oxide patches, in determining the fate and transport of GO and GO-heavy metal association in the subsurface environment.

Deposition and release of carboxylated graphene in saturated porous media: Effect of transient solution chemistry

Chemical perturbation of pore-water in porous media may remobilize and release deposited colloids/nanomaterials into bulk flow. This re-entrainment process is important to accurately assessing the fate and transport of colloids/nanomaterials in the subsurface. This study investigated deposition and subsequent release of carboxylated graphene nanomaterials (CG) in water-saturated sand columns by first depositing CG at 100 mM NaCl or 2 mM CaCl₂ (Phase 1), followed by Phase 2 (elution with sequences of 50, 10, and 1 mM NaCl, or sequences of 0.5 and 0.1 mM CaCl₂), and then Phase 3 elution using deionized water. Approximate 89.2%-98.7% of injected CG was retained in sand through Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) interactions, Ca²⁺ bridging, and straining in Phase 1. Sequential reduction of ionic strength in Phases 2 and 3 resulted in increased release of deposited CG mainly due to the expansion of the electrical double layer thickness and thus decreased depth of the attractive secondary minimum. With increasing pulses of flushing solution, unrecoverable CG increased because weakly associated CG via the secondary minimum was likely translated to immobile regions. Significant tailing of CG released in Phase 3 suggests that CG retained in CaCl₂ was more resistant upon detachment than in NaCl. In cation exchange experiment, only 0.7% of applied CG was released, possibly ascribed to the CG remobilized by cation exchange was immediately re-entrained by the secondary minimum in 50 mM NaCl. Our findings indicate that retained nanomaterials (e.g., CG) can be remobilized and transported downward in transient solution chemistries, raising concerns about their potential migration risk to groundwater.

Effects of myo-inositol hexakisphosphate, ferrihydrite coating, ionic strength and pH on the transport of TiO2 nanoparticles in quartz sand

Evaluating the fate and transport of nanoparticles (NPs) in the subsurface environment is critical for predicting the potential risks to both of the human health and environmental safety. It is believed that numerous environmental factors conspire to control the transport dynamics of nanoparticles, yet the effects of organic phosphates on nanoparticles transport remain largely unknown. In this work, we quantified the transport process of TiO₂ nanoparticle (nTiO₂) and their retention patterns in water-saturated sand columns under various myo-inositol hexakisphosphate (IHP) or phosphate (Pi) concentrations (0-180 μM P), ferrihydrite coating fractions (λ, 0-30%), ionic strengths (1-50 mM KCl), and pH values (4-8). The transport of nTiO₂ was enhanced at increased P concentration due to the enhanced colloidal stability. As compared with Pi at the equivalent P level, IHP showed stronger effect on the electrokinetic properties of nTiO₂ particles due to its relatively more negative charge and higher adsorption affinity, thereby facilitating the nTiO₂ transport (and thus reduced retention) in porous media. At the IHP concentration of 5 μM, the retention of nTiO₂ increased with increasing λ and ionic strength, while decreased with pH. In addition, the retention profiles of nTiO₂ showed a typical hyperexponential pattern for most scenarios mainly due to the unfavorable attachment, and can be well described by a hybrid mathematical model that coupled convection dispersion equations with a two-site kinetic model and DLVO theory. These quantitative estimations revealed the importance of IHP on affecting the transport of nTiO₂ typically in phosphorus-enriched environments. It provides new insights into advanced understanding of the co-transport of nanoparticles and phosphorus in natural systems, essential for both nanoparticle exposure and water eutrophication.

Effects of low-molecular weight organic acids on the transport of graphene oxide nanoparticles in saturated sand columns

The impact of low-molecular weight organic acids (LMWOAs) on the transport of graphene oxide (GO) nanoparticles in saturated quartz sand was investigated. The different LMWOAs such as acetic acid, glycolic acid, malonic acid, and tartaric acid were used in experiments. The effects of LMWOAs on the transport of GO were markedly dependent upon organic acid species. In general, the transport enhancement effects followed the order of tartaric acid > malonic acid > glycolic acid > acetic acid, the regular pattern might be related to amount and type of functional groups of LMWOAs. Additionally, the different enhanced ability of LMWOAs was determined by their molecular weight. In the presence of Na⁺, the main deposition mechanism was ascribed to steric hindrance and competition between LMWOA and GO for deposition sites on grain surfaces under acidic conditions (i.e., pH 4.0 and 5.0). Batch adsorption experiments indicated the extents of competitive adsorption between LMWOAs and GO on quartz sand. In addition, the DLVO theory was not applicable to describe the transport of GO in the presence of LMWOAs at pH 5.0. Nevertheless, electrostatic and steric repulsion, existing between GO and sand grains, were the most important deposition mechanisms under the neutral condition (i.e., pH 7.0). When Ca²⁺ was the main cation in the background solution, the transport enhancement effects followed quite similar order to those of Na⁺, mainly due to different complexing strength of organic acids.

Visualization of graphene oxide transport in two-dimensional homogeneous and heterogeneous porous media

Graphene oxide (GO) has been indicated to be biotoxic and risky in environment, its environmental behavior thus has received increasing attention in recent. In this study, homogeneous and heterogeneous sand tanks were used to examine the transport behaviors of GO nanoparticles in two-dimensional (2-D) porous media under various conditions. Light transmission visualization (LTV) technology was applied to visualize the real-time transport, retention, and release of GO. GO transport in 2-D porous media was simulated with a simplified Double Monod model. GO mobility decreased with the increasing solution ionic strength (IS) and decreasing media grain size. Preferential flow played an important role in GO transport in 2-D heterogeneous porous media. Even without vertical flow in the sand tanks, GO still spread vertically through dispersion, suggesting the importance of the dispersion process to nanoparticle fate and transport in 2-D porous media. LTV images and breakthrough curves showed that some of the previous retained GO particles were instantaneously remobilized with IS decreasing. With the consideration of the vertical dispersion, simulations of the Double Monod model matched the experimental data well. Findings from this work contribute to expand current knowledge of environmental fate and transport of GO, leading to better assessment and prediction of its environmental risks.

Transport and retention of reduced graphene oxide materials in saturated porous media: Synergistic effects of enhanced attachment and particle aggregation

The increasing production and use of graphene-based nanomaterials (e.g., graphene oxide (GO) and reduced graphene oxide (RGO)) will lead to their environmental release. To date, transport of RGOs in saturated porous media is poorly understood. Here, we examined the transport behaviors of three RGO materials obtained by reducing a GO product with commonly used reducing agents - N₂H₄, NaBH₄ and L-ascorbic acid (referred to as N₂H₄-RGO, NaBH₄-RGO and VC-RGO, respectively). When the dominant background cation was Na⁺, K⁺ or Mg²⁺, the mobility of the RGOs and GO in saturated quartz sand correlated well with their surface C/O ratio. Interestingly, the lower mobility of the more reduced materials (the ones with higher C/O values) was not only the results of their less negative surface charges and larger particle sizes, but also the outcome of their greater hydrophobicity, in line with the calculated extended Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (XDLVO) profiles. Counterintuitively, when the background cation was Ca²⁺, the least reduced material among the three RGOs, VC-RGO, exhibited the lowest mobility. Analysis of electrophoretic and aggregation properties, as well as pH-effect experiments, indicated that the surprisingly low mobility of VC-RGO was attributable to the strong cation-bridging effect (primarily Ca²⁺-bridging between RGO and quartz sand) associated with this material, as VC-RGO contained the highest amount of surface carboxyl group (a strong metal-binding moiety). Notably, enhanced attachment (due to increased hydrophobic effect and cation-bridging) and particle aggregation appeared to work synergistically to increase RGO retention, as the attachment of large RGO aggregates significantly enhanced particle straining by narrowing the flow path. These observations reveal a largely overlooked link between the mobility of graphene-based materials and their key physicochemical properties.

Advances in the applications of graphene adsorbents: from water treatment to soil remediation

Graphene, a novel carbon allotrope, is single-layered graphite with honeycomb lattice. Its unique structure endows graphene many outstanding physical/chemical properties and a large surface area, which are beneficial to its applications in many areas. The potential applications of graphene in pollution remediation are adsorption, membrane separation, catalysis, environmental analysis, and so on. The adsorption efficiency of graphene adsorbents largely depends on its surface area, porous structure, oxygen-containing groups and other functional groups, adsorption conditions, and also the properties of adsorbates. With appropriate modifications, graphene materials are mostly efficient adsorbents for organic pollutants (e.g. dyes, pesticides, and oils) and inorganic pollutants (e.g. metal ions, nonmetal ions, and gas). Since our first report of graphene adsorbents in 2010, plenty of studies have been dedicated to developing various graphene adsorbents and to evaluating their performance in treating contaminated water. Recently, there is a growing trend in graphene adsorbents that could be applied in soil remediation, where the situation is much more complicated than in aqueous systems. Herein, we review the design of graphene adsorbents for water treatment and analyze their potential in soil remediation. Several suggestions to accelerate the research on graphene-based soil remediation technology are proposed.

Transport and retention behavior of carbonaceous colloids in natural aqueous medium: Impact of water chemistry

Carbon based materials are emerging as a sustainable alternative to their metal-oxide counterparts. However, their transport behavior under natural aqueous environment is poorly understood. This study investigated the transport and retention profiles of carbon nanoparticles (CNPs) and graphene oxide quantum dots (GOQDs) through column experiments in saturated porous media. CNPs and GOQDs (30 mg/L) were dispersed in natural river water (RW) and passed through the column at a flow rate of 1 mL/min, which mimicking the natural water flow rate. After every 10 min, the column effluents were collected and the mass recovery and retention profiles were monitored. Results indicated that the transport of both carbonaceous colloids was predominantly controlled by surface potential and ionic composition of natural water. The CNPs with its high surface potential (-40 mV) exhibited more column transport and was less susceptible to solution pH (5.6-6.8) variation as compared to GOQDs (-24 mV). The results showed that, monovalent salt (NaCl) was one of the dominating factors for the retention and transport of carbonaceous colloids compared to divalent salt (CaCl₂). Furthermore, the presence of natural organic matter (NOM) increased the transport of both carbonaceous colloids and thereby decreases the tendency for column retention.

Influence of humic acid on transport, deposition and activity of lysozyme in quartz sand

Interaction with natural organic matter (NOM) is hypothesized to impact the fate and bioavailability of enzymes and some hazardous proteins in terrestrial and aquatic environments. By using saturated column transport experiments the transport and deposition of the model enzyme lysozyme (LSZ), in the absence and presence of purified Aldrich humic acid (PAHA), was investigated at a series of mass ratios PAHA/LSZ at pH 5 and 8 and two ionic strength values (0.5 mM and 50 mM KCl solution). PAHA decreased LSZ transport under all conditions. The shapes of breakthrough curves (BTCs) and retention profiles (RPs) during cotransport of both colloids evolved from symmetrical to blocking with time and from flat to hyper-exponential with depth, respectively, in response to increases in mass ratio PAHA/LSZ. The results indicated that the "size-selective retention" and concurrent homo- and hetero-aggregation induced straining, which resulted in preferential retention of relatively large PAHA-LSZ aggregates in the column and elution of relatively small ones. Due to differences in aggregate size, in general, the enzyme activity of LSZ in the effluent was larger and that of the retained LSZ was smaller than that of the influent. Therefore, protein transport process could partially increase the enzyme activity and bring potential environmental hazards.

Considerations for Safe Innovation: The Case of Graphene

The terms "Safe innovation" and "Safe(r)-by-design" are currently popular in the field of nanotechnology. These terms are used to describe approaches that advocate the consideration of safety aspects already at an early stage of the innovation process of (nano)materials and nanoenabled products. Here, we investigate the possibilities of considering safety aspects during various stages of the innovation process of graphene, outlining what information is already available for assessing potential hazard, exposure, and risks. In addition, we recommend further steps to be taken by various stakeholders to promote the safe production and safe use of graphene.

Retention and transport of graphene oxide in water-saturated limestone media

In this work, column experiments were conducted to investigate the transport characteristics of graphene oxide (GO) nanoparticles in limestone media under various electrolytes, solution pH, and humic acid (HA) concentration conditions. In the limestone media, GO exhibited relatively low mobility with the mass recovery rate lower than 65.2%, even when solution ionic strength was low. The presence of HA enhanced its mobility. In addition, the presence of S^2-, a divalent anion, also promoted GO transport in limestone media compared to Cl^- under similar ionic strength conditions through neutralizing more positive charge and thus diminishing the cation bridging. Solution pH showed slight effect on the transport of GO in limestone with the mass recovery range from 40.3% to 51.7%. Over all, decreases in solution pH, HA concentration and increases in solution ionic strength reduced the mobility of GO in the limestone media under the tested conditions. These results indicated both environmental conditions and media characteristics played important roles in controlling GO fate and transport in porous media. The one-site kinetic deposition model was applied to describe the interactions between the GO and limestone media and model simulations fitted the observed experimental data very well. As limestone is an important component of aquiferous media in subsurface, findings from this study elucidated the key factors and processes controlling the fate of GO particles in limestone media, which can inform the prediction and assessment of the risks of GO in groundwater environment.