The profile of antibiotic resistance genes in pig manure composting shaped by composting stage: Mesophilic-thermophilic and cooling-maturation stages

Exogenous additives reshape the microbiome and promote the reduction of resistome in co-composting of pig manure and mushroom residue

Comprehensive understanding of the microbiome and resistome evolution in compost is crucial for guaranteeing the safety of organic fertilizers. Current studies using different composting systems and sequencing technologies have yielded varying conclusions on the efficacy of exogenous additives (EAs) in reducing antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in compost. This study employed metagenomics to investigate the impact of various EAs on microbial communities, ARGs, their coexistence with mobile genetic elements (MGEs), and ARG hosts in co-composting. Our results demonstrated that EAs significantly reshaped the microbial communities and facilitated a notable reduction in total ARG abundance and diversity, primarily by decreasing core ARGs. Cooperative rather than antagonistic relationships among bacteria. The RA changes in total ARGs are mainly caused by a decrease in the prevalence of core ARGs. Furthermore, EAs showed significant efficacy in reducing clinical ARGs, including cfxA, tetX1, cfxA6, vanA, and aac (6')-Ib', with diatomite (5 %) and zeolite (5 %) being the most effective. The effect of EAs on ARGs and microbial community assembly were stochastic processes. Composting stage and EAs jointly reduced the association between ARGs and MGEs in the composting system. The reduction of ARGs attributed to a decreased abundance of potential pathogenic ARG-associated hosts and diminished associations with MGEs. In conclusion, EAs present a straightforward and effective approach for promoting ARGs reduction in compost, offering crucial insights for assessing the environmental risks associated with the release of agricultural ARGs.

Effects of adding corn straw and apple tree branches on antibiotic resistance genes removal during sheep manure composting

The study investigates the effects of composting sheep manure with corn straw (CM) and sheep manure with apple tree branches (AM) on antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and microbial communities. The results indicate that AM treatment enables the compost pile to reach the high-temperature phase more quickly. The total phosphorus and total potassium content in AM treatment compost increased compared to the initial stage of composting, while CM treatment effectively enhanced the total nitrogen and total phosphorus content, and CM treatment compost was more conducive to reducing the compost's electrical conductivity. The relative abundance of total ARGs for sulfonamides, tetracyclines, and integrase genes in CM treatment compost were lower than in AM treatment compost. CM treatment was beneficial in reducing the relative abundance of sul1 and tetA-02 by 33.61% and 35.51%, respectively. Both treatments were effective in reducing the relative abundance of sul3 and intI2. The relative abundance of Chloroflexi and Proteobacteria in AM treatment decreased over time, while Bacteroidetes increased, which was opposite to the trend observed in CM treatment. There were significant correlations between the compost's physicochemical properties, bacterial communities, ARGs, and mobile genetic elements (MGEs). ARGs and MGEs can exist in multiple host bacteria, and various ARGs and MGEs can also be hosted in the same bacterium. Mantel analysis showed that the total organic matter, total phosphorus, and total potassium had the greatest contributions to the changes in ARGs and MGEs, while temperature and bacterial communities regulated ARGs by affecting MGEs. Obviously, adding corn straw is more effective in reducing the abundance of ARGs during the sheep manure composting.

Meta-analysis addressing the potential of antibiotic resistance gene elimination through aerobic composting

The significant increase in antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in organic solid wastes (OSWs) has emerged as a major threat to the food chain. Aerobic composting is a widely used technology for OSW management, with the potential to influence the fate of AGRs. However, the variability of the ARG elimination effects reported in different studies has highlighted the uncertainty regarding the effects of composting on ARGs. To identify the potential of composting in reducing ARG and the factors (e.g., composting technologies and physiochemical properties) influence ARG changes, a meta-analysis was conducted with a database including 4,232 observations. The abundances of ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) can be substantially reduced by 74.3% and 78.8%, respectively, via aerobic composting. During composting, the ARG levels in chicken and swine manure tended to be reduced more significantly (81.7% and 78.0%) compared to those in cattle manure (52.3%) and sewage sludge (32.6%). The reduction rate of sulfonamide resistant genes was only 35.3%, which was much lower than those of other types. MGEs and composting duration (CD) were identified as the most important factors driving ARG changes during composting. These findings provide a comprehensive insight into the effects of composting on ARG reduction, which may help prevent the transmission in food systems.

Deciphering and predicting changes in antibiotic resistance genes during pig manure aerobic composting via machine learning model

Livestock manure is one of the most important pools of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in the environment. Aerobic composting can effectively reduce the spread of antibiotic resistance risk in livestock manure. Understanding the effect of aerobic composting process parameters on manure-sourced ARGs is important to control their spreading risk. In this study, the effects of process parameters on ARGs during aerobic composting of pig manure were explored through data mining based on 191 valid data collected from literature. Machine learning (ML) models (XGBoost and Random Forest) were utilized to predict the rate of ARGs changes during pig manure composting. The model evaluation index of the XGBoost model (R2 = 0.651) was higher than that of the Random Forest (R2 = 0.490), indicating that XGBoost had better prediction performance. Feature importance was further calculated for the XGBoost model, and the XGBoost black box model was interpreted by Shapley additive explanations analysis. Results indicated that the influencing factors on the ARGs variation in pig manure were sequentially divided into thermophilic period, total composting period, composting real time, and thermophilic stage average temperature. The findings gave an insight into the application of ML models to predict and decipher the ARG changes during manure composting and provided suggestions for better composting manipulation and optimization of process parameters.

Synthesis and characterization of new composite from modified silica-coated MnFe2O4 nanoparticles for removal of tetracycline from aqueous solution

In this study, a new composite from silica coated MnFe2O4 nanoparticles, diethylenetriamine, 3-chloropropyl trimethoxysilane and Mg-Al Layered Double Hydroxide (Mg-Al LDH/DETA/CPTMS/SCNPs) composite was synthesized. The Mg-Al LDH/DETA/CPTMS/SCNPs composite was examined by Fourier transform infrared spectrometer (FT-IR), Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDS), X-ray diffraction (XRD), Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Vibrating Sample Magnetometry (VSM). The synthesized composite exhibited magnetic property with a saturation magnetization of 0.40 emu g-1. The Mg-Al LDH/DETA/CPTMS/SCNPs composite was utilized as a successful adsorbent for removal of tetracycline from aqueous solutions. The effect of various operation factors such as initial drug concentration, adsorbent dosage, pH and contact time were investigated. The optimized variable conditions such as adsorbent dose of 60 mg L-1, drug concentration of 100 mg L-1, pH = 7 and contact time 30 min were obtained. For describing the adsorption isotherms, the Langmuir, Freundlich and Temkin adsorption models were utilized. The results indicated that the adsorption isotherm is in good agreement with Langmuir model. According to the Langmuir analysis, the maximum adsorption capacity (qm) of the Mg-Al LDH/DETA/CPTMS/SCNPs composite for tetracycline was obtained to be 40.16 mg g-1. The kinetic studies revealed that the adsorption in all cases to be a pseudo second-order process. The negative value of ΔG° and the positive value of ΔH° showed the adsorption process to be spontaneous and endothermic.

Variations in antibiotic resistance genes during long-term operation of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) have been widely detected in the environment. Anaerobic digestion (AD) has the potential ability to remove ARGs, and a comprehensive study is needed on the variations in ARGs during AD. In this study, variations in antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and microbial communities were investigated during the long-term operation of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactor. An antibiotic mixture of erythromycin, sulfamethoxazole and tetracycline was added to the UASB influent and the operation period was 360 days. The abundances of 11 ARGs and class 1 integron-integrase gene were detected in the UASB reactor, and the correlation between the ARGs and the microbial community was analyzed. The composition of ARGs indicated that the main ARGs in the effluent were sul1, sul2, and sul3, whereas the main ARG in the sludge was tetW. Correlation analysis indicated a negative correlation between microorganisms and ARGs in the UASB. In addition, most of ARGs showed a positive correlation with norank_f_Propionibacteriaceae and Clostridum_sensu_stricto_6, which were identified as potential hosts. These findings may help develop a feasible strategy for removing ARGs from aquatic environments during anaerobic digestion.

Energy balance survey for the design and auto-thermal thermophilic aerobic digestion of algal-based membrane bioreactor for Landfill Leachate Treatment(under organic loading rates): Experimental and simulation-based ANN and NSGA-II

Although algal-based membrane bioreactors (AMBRs) have been demonstrated to be effective in treating wastewater (landfill leachate), there needs to be more research into the effectiveness of these systems. This study aims to determine whether AMBR is effective in treating landfill leachate with hydraulic retention times (HRTs) of 8, 12, 14, 16, 21, and 24 h to maximize AMBR's energy efficiency, microalgal biomass production, and removal efficiency using artificial neural network (ANN) models. Experimental results and simulations indicate that biomass production in bioreactors depends heavily on HRT. A decrease in HRT increases algal (Chlorella vulgaris) biomass productivity. Results also showed that 80% of chemical oxygen demand (COD) was removed from algal biomass by bioreactors. To determine the most efficient way to process the features as mentioned above, nondominated sorting genetic algorithm II (NSGA-II) techniques were applied. A mesophilic, suspended-thermophilic, and attached-thermophilic organic loading rate (OLR) of 1.28, 1.06, and 2 kg/m3/day was obtained for each method. Compared to suspended-thermophilic growth (3.43 kg/m3.day) and mesophilic growth (1.28 kg/m3.day), attached-thermophilic growth has a critical loading rate of 10.5 kg/m3.day. An energy audit and an assessment of the system's auto-thermality were performed at the end of the calculation using the Monod equation for biomass production rate (Y) and bacteria death constant (Kd). According to the results, a high removal level of COD (at least 4000 mg COD/liter) leads to auto-thermality.

A Potential Indicator Gene, tetM, to Assess Contamination by Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Greenhouses in South Korea

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) have been emerging as a concerning threat to both environment and public health. The continuous input of manure, irrigation water, and fertilizers increases the abundance of ARGs in agricultural environments. However, current risk assessments have focused on clinical settings, which are not applicable to environmental settings. Therefore, we herein aimed to identify and assess indicator genes to reduce the time and effort required for ARG surveillance. A nationwide ana-lysis of 322 ARGs and 58 mobile genetic elements (MGEs) was performed on 42 greenhouse and 19 control soil samples. The chemical properties and pH of soil were also investigated to characterize differences between greenhouse and control soil samples. The results obtained showed that the abundance of ARGS was significantly higher and ion concentrations were higher in greenhouse samples than in control samples. These results indicate that agricultural activities increased the abundance of ARGs. Furthermore, the abundance of core genes was significantly higher in greenhouse samples than in control samples, and the chemical characteristics of soil significantly differed between these samples. Among the discriminatory genes selected, tetM was identified as an ARG surveillance indicator gene based on its clinical relevance, prevalence in the soil resistome, and relationship with mobile genetic elements. The present results will contribute to the continuous and rapid surveillance of antibiotic resistance dissemination and proliferation in greenhouses in South Korea.

Size matters: Powder biochar promotes the elimination of antibiotics resistance genes and potential hosts during swine manure composting

Livestock manure faced acute environmental pollution and ecology risky caused by antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). This study investigated the effects of biochar particle size including powder biochar (75 μm, PB), and granular biochar (2 mm, GB) on ARGs variation during the aerobic composting. The results showed that the total relative abundance (RA) of the ARGs decreased significantly in all the treatments after composting. While compared to the removal efficiency of total RA in the control (CK), PB decreased by 90.99 % and GB increased by 93.25 %, and both PB and GB removed MGEs completely. Sulfonamide antibiotic resistance genes were the main contributor of the ARGs rebounding. PB addition could hinder the rebounding of sulfonamide antibiotic resistance genes during the later stage of the composting. Co-occurrence network analysis showed that the addition of biochar (both types) increased the complexity of the microbial community the competition of inter-phylum, which was indicated by the higher number of edge and density and lower positive connection. The different ARGs removal efficiency in these two treatments might be that PB promoted the competition both inter-phylum and potential hosts-other microbes, resulted in fewer kinds and abundance of ARGs hosts, while GB increased the stability of ARGs hosts making it more resistant to environment changes. Totally, compared with the global adjustment strategy of microbial communities, more exclusive methods focusing on the controlling of ARGs hosts should be explored to decrease the ecological risk of composting products during composting process.

Antibiotics and antibiotic resistance gene dynamics in the composting of antibiotic fermentation waste - A review

Fate of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) during composting of antibiotic fermentation waste (AFW) is a major concern. This review article focuses on recent literature published on this subject. The key findings are that antibiotics can be removed effectively during AFW composting, with higher temperatures, appropriate bulking agents, and suitable pretreatments improving their degradation. ARGs dynamics during composting are related to bacteria and mobile genetic elements (MGEs). Higher temperatures, suitable bulking agents and an appropriate C/N ratio (30:1) lead to more efficient removal of ARGs/MGEs by shaping the bacterial composition. Keeping materials dry (moisture less than 30%) and maintaining pH stable around 7.5 after composting could inhibit the rebound of ARGs. Overall, safer utilization of AFW can be realized by optimizing composting conditions. However, further removal of antibiotics and ARGs at low levels, degradation mechanism of antibiotics, and spread mechanism of ARGs during AFW composting require further investigation.

Reduction of mobile genetic elements determines the removal of antibiotic resistance genes during pig manure composting after thermal pretreatment

Animal manure is a primary repository of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and mobile genetic elements (MGEs). This work explored the efficiency of ARGs and MGEs removal during pig manure composting after thermal pretreatment (TPC) and the underlying mechanisms. TPC resulted in a decrease of 94.7% and 92.3% in the relative abundance of ARGs and MGEs which was 48.9% and 76.6% lower than control, respectively. Network analysis indicated that reductions of ARGs and MGEs in TPC were relevant to decrease in the amount and abundance of bacterial hosts. Furthermore, total ARGs abundance in TPC was correlated with that of intI1 and Tn916/1545 (P < 0.001). Redundancy analysis supported a leading role of MGEs in ARGs dynamics in TPC. Reduction of MGEs rather than bacterial hosts contributed mainly to ARGs removal in TPC, as revealed by structural equation modeling. In conclusion, TPC was an effective method to treat animal manure containing ARGs.

Exploring the humification process of municipal sludge in hyperthermophilic composting through metagenomic and untargeted metabolomic

Hyperthermophilic composting (HC) has been widely recognized for the advantage of high treatment efficiency for organic wastes. However, the humification process is still unclear. In this study, the humification process of HC was investigated, compared to conventional composting (CK). The results showed that the highest composting temperature, organic matter degradation rate, and humification index in HC were 92.62 °C, 23.98%, and 1.59, while those in CK were 70.23 °C, 14.49 %, and 1.04, indicating HC accelerated humification process. Moreover, the results of metagenomic and untargeted metabolomic showed that the genes and metabolisms related to carbohydrate, lipid, amino acid, fatty acid, and nucleotide were more abundant in HC. Consequently, the metabolic pathways regarding organic matter degradation and microbial reproduction were enhanced in the high temperature stage of HC, further accelerating the humification reaction in the low temperature stage. This work contributes to the comprehension of the humification mechanism in HC.

Pig manure treatment strategies for mitigating the spread of antibiotic resistance

Due to the risk of pathogenic antibiotic-resistant bacteria and their antibiotic-resistance genes transfer from livestock feces to the soil and cultivated crops, it is imperative to find effective on-farm manure treatments to minimize that hazardous potential. An introduced worldwide policy of sustainable development, focus on ecological agricultural production, and the circular economy aimed at reducing the use of artificial fertilizers; therefore, such treatment methods should also maximize the fertilization value of animal manure. The two strategies for processing pig manure are proposed in this study-storage and composting. The present study examines the changes in the physicochemical properties of treated manure, in the microbiome, and in the resistome, compared to raw manure. This is the first such comprehensive analysis performed on the same batch of manure. Our results suggest that while none of the processes eliminates the environmental risk, composting results in a faster and more pronounced reduction of mobile genetic elements harboring antibiotic resistance genes, including those responsible for multi-drug resistance. Overall, the composting process can be an efficient strategy for mitigating the spread of antibiotic resistance in the environment and reducing the risk of its transfer to crops and the food chain while providing essential fertilizer ingredients.

Co-occurrence pattern of ARGs and N-functional genes in the aerobic composting system with initial elevated temperature

Animal manure is known to harbor antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Aerobic composting is a prevalent cost-effective and sustainable method to treat animal waste. However, the effect of initially elevated temperature on antibiotic resistome during the composting process is unclear. In this study composting was subjected to initial external heating (EHC) for a period of 5 days compared to conventional composting (CC). After composting ARGs abundance was significantly reduced by 2.43 log in EHC and 1.95 log in CC. Mobile genetic elements (MGEs) also exhibited a reduction of 1.95 log in EHC and 1.49 log in CC. However, during the cooling phase, the genes resisting macrolide lincosamide and streptogramin B (MLSB) rebounded by 0.04 log in CC. The potential human pathogenic bacteria Pseudomonas (41.5-61.5%) and Actinobacteria (98.4-98.8%) were significantly reduced in both treatments and the bulk of targeted antibiotics were eliminated by 80.74% in EHC and 68.98% in CC. ARGs and N-functional genes (NFGs), mainly denitrification genes, were carried by the same microbial species, such as Corynebacterium sp. and Bacillus sp., of the dominant phylum. Redundancy analysis (RDA) revealed that CC microbial communities played a key role in the enrichment of ARGs while in EHC the variation of ARGs was attributed to the composting temperature. The number of high-risk ARGs was also lower in EHC (4) compared with CC (6) on day 30. These results provide insight into the effects of an initially enhanced temperature on ARGs removal and the relationship between ARGs and NFGs during the composting process.

A Critical Review on the Vermicomposting of Organic Wastes as a Strategy in Circular Bioeconomy: Mechanism, Performance, and Future Perspectives

AbstractTo meet the current need for sustainable development, vermicomposting (VC), a natural, eco-friendly, and cost-effective technology, can be a wise selection for the bioconversion of organic wastes into value-added by-products. However, no one has tried to establish the VC technology as an economically sustainable technology by exploring its linkage to circular bioeconomy. Even, no researcher has made any effort to explore the usability of the earthworms (EWs) as a protein supplement while assessing the economic perspectives of VC technology. Very few studies are available on the greenhouse gas (GHG) emission potential of VC technology. Still, the contribution of VC technology towards the non-carbon waste management policy is not yet explored. In the current review, a genuine effort has been made to inspect the contribution of VC technology towards the circular bioeconomy, along with evaluating its capability to bioremediate the organic wastes generated from domestic, industrial, and agricultural premises. The potential of the EWs as a protein source has also been explored to strengthen the contribution of VC technology towards the circular bioeconomy. Moreover, the linkage of the VC technology to the non-carbon waste management policy has been comprehensively demonstrated by highlighting its carbon sequestration and GHG emission potentials during the treatment of organic wastes. It has been observed that the cost of food production was reduced by 60--70% by replacing chemical fertilizers with vermicompost. The implication of the vermicompost significantly lessened the harvesting period of the crops, thereby helping the farmers attain higher profits by cultivating more crops in a single calendar year on the same plot. Furthermore, the vermicompost could hold the soil moisture for a long time, lessening the water demand up to 30-40%, which, in turn, reduced the frequency of irrigation. Also, the replacement of the chemical fertilizers with vermicompost resulted in a 23% increment in the grapes' yield, engendering an extra profit of up to 110000 rupees/ha. In Nepal, vermicompost has been produced at a cost of 15.68 rupees/kg, whereas it has been sold to the local market at a rate of 25 rupees/kg as organic manure, ensuring a net profit of 9.32 rupees/kg of vermicompost. EWs embraced 63% crude protein, 5-21% carbohydrates, 6-11% fat, 1476 kJ/100 g of metabolizable energy, and a wide range of minerals and vitamins. EWs also contained 4.11, 2.04, 4.43, 2.83, 1.47, and 6.26  g/kg (on protein basis) of leucine, isoleucine, tryptophan, arginine, histidine, and phenylalanine, respectively, enhancing the acceptability of the EW meal (EWM) as the protein supplement. The inclusion of 3 and 5% EWM in the diet of broiler pullets resulted in a 12.6 and 22.5% increase in their feed conversion ratio (FCR), respectively after one month. Similarly, when a 100% fish meal was substituted by 50% EWM and 50% fish meal, the FCR and growth rate of Parachanna obscura were increased substantially. The VC of maize crop residues mixed with pig manure, cow dung, and biochar, in the presence of Eisenia fetida EWs, yielded only 0.003-0.081, 0-0.17, and 130.40-189.10 g CO₂-eq.kg^-1 emissions of CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O, respectively. Similarly, the VC of tomato stems and cow dung ensured 2.28 and 5.76 g CO₂-eq.kg^-1 CO₂ emissions of CH₄ and N₂O, respectively. Additionally, the application of vermicompost at a rate of 5 t/ha improved the soil organic carbon proportion and aggravated carbon sequestration. The land application of vermicompost improved micro-aggregation and cut down the tillage, reducing GHG emissions and triggering carbon sequestration. The significant findings of the current review suggest that VC technology potentially contributes to the concept of circular bioeconomy, substantially negotiates potential GHG emissions, and complies with the non-carbon waste management policy, reinforcing its acceptability as an economically sound and environmentally benevolent organic waste bioremediation alternative.

Performances of antibiotic resistance genes profile upon the action of biochar-activated peroxydisulfate in composting

In this study, the amendment of biochar-activated peroxydisulfate during composting to remove antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) by direct (microbial community succession) and indirect methods (physicochemical factors) was analyzed. When implementing indirect methods, the synergistic effect of peroxydisulfate with biochar optimized the physicochemical habitat of compost, maintaining its moisture within a range of 62.95%-65.71%, and a pH of 6.87-7.73, and causing the compost to mature 18 days earlier than the control groups. The direct methods caused the optimized physicochemical habitat to adjust the microbial communities and reduce the abundance of most of the ARG host bacteria (Thermopolyspora, Thermobifida, and Saccharomonospora), thus inhibiting this substance's amplification. Heatmap analysis confirmed the necessary connection between physicochemical factors, microbial communities, and ARGs. Moreover, a mantel test confirmed the direct significant effect of the microbial communities on ARGs and the indirect significant effect of physicochemical factors on ARGs. The results showed that the abundance of more ARGs was down-regulated at the end of composting and regulated by biochar-activated peroxydisulfate, especially for the abundance of AbaF, tet(44), golS, and mryA, which was significantly decreased by 0.87-1.07 fold. These results provide new insights into the removal of ARGs during composting.

Spatial distribution of bacterial resistance towards antibiotics of rural sanitation system in China and its potential link with diseases incidence

Chinese government is vigorously promoting toilet renovation in rural areas to reduce the risk of human feces exposure, which would cause infectious diseases, especially antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and pathogens. However, the distribution of ARGs in human feces from different regions of China remained ill-defined. It is not yet known how the survival of ARGs after toilet treatment is associated with the regional infection rates. Here, we investigated the prevalence of ARGs in human feces in rural areas of China and their potential relationship with infectious diseases for the first large-scale. The results showed that there were still high ARGs residues in human feces after rural toilet treatment, especially tetM-01 and ermB with average relative abundance as high as 1.21 × 10^-1 (Eastern) and 1.56 × 10^-1 (Northern), respectively. At a large regional scale, the significant differences in human feces resistomes were mainly shaped by the toilet types, TN, NH₃-N, and the bacterial community. A critical finding was that toilets still cannot effectively decrease the pathogenicity risk in human feces. The significant positive relationship (P<0.05) between infectious diseases and ARGs can infer that ARGs in human feces exposure might be a critical path for enhancing the incidence of diseases, as these ARGs hinder the effectiveness of antibiotics.

External static magnetic field potentiates the reduction of antibiotic resistance genes during swine manure composting

Livestock and poultry manure are repositories of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Accumulating evidence suggests that composting is an important way to effectively attenuate ARGs, but how to reinforce the reduction in ARGs during composting needs to be further investigated. This study explored the influence of an external static magnetic field on ARG mitigation enhancement during swine manure composting. The results showed that a total of 12 high-risk ARGs were identified. A relatively high magnetic field intensity (14.81 mT) was more effective in reducing the abundance of high-risk ARGs, and the removal rate was 20.66-100 %. It also reduced the abundance of 27.14 % of integrons, 79.44 % of insertion sequences, and 8.78 % of plasmids. Partial least squares path modeling showed that a relatively high magnetic field intensity treatment promoted the reduction in ermB by reducing the abundance of Phascolarctobacterium, Streptococcus, and insertion sequences. It also mitigated sul1 expression by reducing the abundance of Acinetobacter and integrons, and it mitigated tetM expression by decreasing Lactobacillus, Streptococcus, insertion sequences, and plasmids. These findings demonstrate that an external static magnetic field is an effective method for intensifying the reduction in ARGs, providing a feasible reference for controlling the potential ARG risk of organic waste composting.

Effect of biochars with different particle sizes on fates of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes during composting of swine manure

The impact of biochars with large particle sizes (LPB, 5-10 mm) and small particle sizes (SPB, <0.074 mm) on fates of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) during composting of swine manure with maize straw was explored. The results showed that antibiotics removal efficiencies were 40 %, 50 %, and 76 % for control treatment, control with LPB treatment, and control with SPB treatment after composting, respectively. The introduction of SPB reduced the total ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) levels by 28 % and 19 % after composting, respectively. The Mantel test results showed that organic matter, moisture content, and NH₄⁺-N contributed the most to changes in antibiotics and ARGs. The significant effects of biochar specific surface area and antibiotics on MGEs further regulated the behavior of ARGs. Therefore, composting with SPB is more conducive to the removal of antibiotics and ARGs during composting of swine manure.

Industrial-scale aerobic composting of livestock manures with the addition of biochar: Variation of bacterial community and antibiotic resistance genes caused by various composting stages

The presence of large amounts of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in livestock manures poses an impending, tough safety risk to ecosystems. To investigate more comprehensively the mechanisms of ARGs removal from industrial-scale composting of livestock manure based on biochar addition, we tracked the dynamics of bacterial community and ARGs at various stages of aerobic composting of livestock manures with 10% biochar. There were no significant effects of biochar on the bacterial community and the profiles of ARGs. During aerobic composting, the relative abundance of ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) showed overall trends of decreasing and then increasing. The key factor driving the dynamics of ARGs was bacterial community composition, and the potential hosts of ARGs were Caldicoprobacter, Tepidimicrobium, Ignatzschineria, Pseudogracilibacillus, Actinomadura, Flavobacterium and Planifilum. The retention of the thermophilic bacteria and the repopulation of the initial bacteria were the dominant reasons for the increase in ARGs at maturation stage. Additionally, among the MGEs, the relative abundance of transposon gene was substantially removed, while the integron genes remained at high relative abundance. Our results highlighted that the suitability of biochar addition to industrial-scale aerobic composting needs to be further explored and that effective measures are needed to prevent the increase of ARGs content on maturation stage.

Composting effect and antibiotic removal under a new temperature control strategy

The main objective of this study was to investigate the feasibility of a new temperature control strategy in the co-composting process to accelerate operation cycle and remove antibiotics from mixed organic wastes. The evaluation of the composting process showed that composting with temperature control (TC) was completed within 14 days. The final compost of TC exhibited a 10% higher degradation of organic matters, more humus formation and 11.25% lower heavy metals concentration than conventional composting (CC), which fully met the Chinese National Agricultural Organic Fertilizer Standard requirements. The degradation extent and kinetic of macrolides, tetracyclines, sulfonamides and fluoroquinolones showed that the removal efficiency of total antibiotics in TC was 23.58% higher than CC, with less half-life, which was significantly correlated with higher temperature. Particularly, the highest removal was observed for sulfonamides (87.45%) in TC, the half-life of which was reduced by 75.95% compared with CC. The higher degradation rate was attributed to enhanced decomposition of unstable antibiotics and degrading activity of microbes at high temperature. The microbiological analysis showed that the external heating led to a distinct composition and succession of bacterial community in TC. Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, Actinobacteriota and Bacteroidota were dominant and the emergence of Patescibacteria and Chloroflexi at cooling period in TC proved that the later composting environment was in an oligotrophic state. Current research provided a promising rapid composting approach for high-quality fertilizer production and antibiotic management in organic waste disposal.

Microbial cooperation promotes humification to reduce antibiotic resistance genes abundance in food waste composting

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) fate in a full-scale Food waste (FW) facility was investigated. Results showed that with the changes in ARGs, microbial networks could be naturally divided into two clusters, named as the ARGs increasing group (AI group) and the ARGs decreasing group (AD group). The significant difference between two groups (i.e. stronger microbial competition in the AI group and stronger microbial cooperation in the AD group) implied that the variation in ARGs over time were caused by a switch between competition and cooperation. These results indicated that microbial competition might increase ARGs abundance, while cooperation might reduce it. Meanwhile, structural-equation-model (SEM model) showed that humification indexes (e.g. GI value) was an indicator for characterizing microbial interactions and ARGs. The results of the linear model further confirmed that mature compost (GI values > 92.6 %) could reduce the risk of ARGs.

Three-dimensional printed bulking agents reduce antibiotic resistance genes in swine manure aerobic composting by regulating oxygen concentration to alter host microorganisms and mobile genetic elements

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in manure aerobic composting are a potential environmental pollutant. Therefore, reducing the abundance of ARGs is crucial. The effects of adding three-dimensional printed bulking agents (3DBAs) on ARGs in aerobic composting of swine manure were investigated in this study. Compared with the control group, 3DBAs with different addition dosages can greatest reduce the total ARGs by 5.98%, tetracycline resistance genes by 14.02%, macrolide resistance genes by 9.65%, and sulfonamide resistance genes by 20.59%. By further combining physicochemical parameters, host microorganisms, and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) for analysis, it was found that oxygen concentration was vital for ARGs reduction, and 3DBAs with regular porosity and uniform size indirectly regulate the activity of host microorganisms and MGEs abundance by changing the oxygen consumption, finally reducing vertical or horizontal ARGs transfer risks. Overall, 3DBAs addition is an effective strategy to reduce the abundance of ARGs in aerobic composting.

Enhancing control of multidrug-resistant plasmid and its host community with a prolonged thermophilic phase during composting

The plasmid-mediated horizontal transfer of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) among bacteria facilitates the evolution and dissemination of antibiotic resistance. Broad-host-range plasmids can be transferred to different bacterial hosts in soil, plant rhizospheres, and wastewater treatment plants. Although composting is an effective way to convert organic waste into fertilizer and reduce some ARGs, few studies have focused on its effects on the spread of ARG-carrying plasmids and their bacterial host communities during composting. In this study, a fluorescently labeled Pseudomonas putida (P. putida) harboring a broad-host-range plasmid RP4 carrying three ARGs was inoculated into a raw material microcosm and composted with different durations of the thermophilic phase. The fate of the donor and RP4 in composting was investigated. The prolonged thermophilic composting removed 95.1% of dsRed and 98.0% of gfp, and it inhibited the rebound of P. putida and RP4 during the maturation phase. The spread potential of RP4 decreased from 10⁻⁴ to 10⁻⁶ transconjugants per recipient after composting. In addition, we sorted and analyzed the composition of RP4 recipient bacteria using fluorescence-activated cell sorting combined with 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing. The recipient bacteria of RP4 belonged to eight phyla, and Firmicutes, accounting for 75.3%–90.1%, was the dominant phylum in the transconjugants. The diversity and richness of the RP4 recipient community were significantly reduced by prolonged thermophilic periods. Overall, these findings provide new insights for assessing the contribution of composting in mitigating the dissemination of plasmid-mediated ARGs, and the prolonged thermophilic phase of composting can limit the transfer of multidrug-resistant plasmids.

Metagenomic assembly reveals hosts and mobility of common antibiotic resistome in animal manure and commercial compost

BACKGROUND

Antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) used in intensive animal farming threaten human health worldwide; however, the common resistome, ARG mobility, and ARG host composition in different animal manures and mixed manure composts remain unclear. In the present study, metagenomic assembly and cross-sample mapping were used to comprehensively decipher the common resistome and its potential mobility and hosts in animal manure and composts.

RESULTS

In total, 201 ARGs were shared among different animal (layer, broiler, swine, beef cow, and dairy cow) manures and accounted for 86-99% of total relative abundance of ARGs. Except for multidrug, sulfonamide, and trimethoprim resistance genes, the relative abundance of most ARGs in composts was significantly lower than that in animal manure. Procrustes analysis indicated that antibiotic residues positively correlated with ARG composition in manure but not in composts. More than 75% ARG subtypes were shared between plasmids and chromosomes in our samples. Transposases could play a pivotal role in mediating the transfer of ARGs between different phyla in animal manure and composting. Cross-sample mapping to contigs carrying ARGs showed that the hosts of common resistome in manure had preference on animal species, and the dominant genus of ARG host shifted from Enterococcus in manure to Pseudomonas in composts. The broad host range and linking with diverse mobile genetic elements (MGEs) were two key factors for ARGs, such as sul1 and aadA, which could survive during composting. The multidrug resistance genes represented the dominant ARGs in pathogenic antibiotic-resistant bacteria in manure but could be effectively controlled by composting.

CONCLUSIONS

Our experiments revealed the common resistome in animal manure, classified and relative quantified the ARG hosts, and assessed the mobility of ARGs. Composting can mitigate ARGs in animal manure by altering the bacterial hosts; however, persistent ARGs can escape from the removal because of diverse host range and MGEs. Our findings provide an overall background for source tracking, risk assessment, and control of livestock ARGs.

Metagenomic and HT-qPCR analysis reveal the microbiome and resistome in pig slurry under storage, composting, and anaerobic digestion

Direct application of pig slurry to agricultural land, as a means of nutrient recycling, introduces pathogens, antibiotic resistant bacteria, or genes, to the environment. With global environmental sustainability policies mandating a reduction in synthetic fertilisation and a commitment to a circular economy it is imperative to find effective on-farm treatments of slurry that maximises its fertilisation value and minimises risk to health and the environment. We assessed and compared the effect of storage, composting, and anaerobic digestion (AD) on pig slurry microbiome, resistome and nutrient content. Shotgun metagenomic sequencing and HT-qPCR arrays were implemented to understand the dynamics across the treatments. Our results identified that each treatment methods have advantages and disadvantages in removal pollutants or increasing nutrients. The data suggests that storage and composting are optimal for the removal of human pathogens and anaerobic digestion for the reduction in antibiotic resistance (AMR) genes and mobile genetic elements. The nitrogen content is increased in storage and AD, while reduced in composting. Thus, depending on the requirement for increased or reduced nitrogen the optimum treatment varies. Combining the results indicates that composting provides the greatest gain by reducing risk to human health and the environment. Network analysis revealed reducing Proteobacteria and Bacteroidetes while increasing Firmicutes will reduce the AMR content. KEGG analysis identified no significant change in the pathways across all treatments. This novel study provides a data driven decision tree to determine the optimal treatment for best practice to minimise pathogen, AMR and excess or increasing nutrient transfer from slurry to environment.

Biochar can mitigate co-selection and control antibiotic resistant genes (ARGs) in compost and soil

Heavy metals (HMs) contamination raises the expression of antibiotic resistance (AR) in bacteria through co-selection. Biochar application in composting improves the effectiveness of composting and the quality of compost. This improvement includes the elimination and reduction of antibiotic resistant genes (ARGs). The use of biochar in contaminated soils reduces the bioaccessibility and bioavailability of the contaminants hence reducing the biological and environmental toxicity. This decrease in contaminant bioavailability reduces contaminants induced co-selection pressure. Conditions which favour reduction in HMs bioavailable fraction (BF) appear to favour reduction in ARGs in compost and soil. Biochar can prevent horizontal gene transfer (HGT) and can eliminate ARGs carried by mobile genetic elements (MGEs). This effect reduces maintenance and propagation of ARGs. Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, and Actinobacteria are the major bacteria phyla identified to be responsible for dissipation, maintenance, and propagation of ARGs. Biochar application rate at 2-10% is the best for the elimination of ARGs. This review provides insight into the usefulness of biochar in the prevention of co-selection and reduction of AR, including challenges of biochar application and future research prospects.

Short-term biodrying achieves compost maturity and significantly reduces antibiotic resistance genes during semi-continuous food waste composting inoculated with mature compost

Food waste (FW) is important object of resource utilization and source of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). This study investigated the effects of biodrying combined with inoculating mature compost (B&M) on the composting efficiency, succession of bacterial communities and their links with metabolism functions as well as the fate of ARGs during FW composting. The results showed that B&M could rapidly raise and maintain high relative abundance of Bacillaceae (66.59-94.44%) as well as composting temperature (45.86-65.86 ℃), so as to achieve the final maturity of FW composting in a short time by regulating microbial carbohydrate (14.02-15.31%) and amino acid metabolism (10.33-12.47%). Network analysis demonstrated that high temperature could effectively inhibit the proliferation and spread of potential bacterial hosts of ARGs and integrons including Lactobacillaceae, Enterobacteriaceae, Leuconostocaceae and Corynebacteriaceae during the first two days of composting. As a result, B&M significantly reduced the absolute (72.09-99.47%) and relative abundances (0.31-2.44 logs) of nearly all ARGs especially ermB, tetM, bla_CTX-M and bla_OXA. Present study deepened the knowledge of ARGs variation, succession and metabolism functions of bacterial communities when B&M processes were used for FW composting, suggesting a promising technology for reducing the transmission risk of ARGs and reaching maturity of FW composting.

The fate of antibiotic resistance genes and their influential factors in swine manure composting with sepiolite as additive

Manures are storages for antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) entering the environment. This study investigated the effects of adding sepiolite at 0%, 2.5%, 5%, and 7.5% (CK, T1, T2, and T3, respectively) on the fates of ARGs during composting. The relative abundances (RAs) of the total ARGs in CK and T3 decreased by 0.23 and 0.46 logs, respectively, after composting. The RAs of 10/11 ARGs decreased in CK, whereas they all decreased in T3. The reduction in the RA of the total mobile genetic elements (MGEs) was 1.26 times higher in T3 compared with CK after composting. The bacterial community accounted for 47.93% of the variation in the abundances of ARGs. Network analysis indicated that ARGs and MGEs shared potential host bacteria (PHB), and T3 controlled the transmission of ARGs by reducing the abundances of PHB. Composting with 7.5% sepiolite is an effective strategy for reducing the risk of ARGs proliferating.

A sustainable and economic strategy to reduce risk antibiotic resistance genes during poultry manure bioconversion by black soldier fly Hermetia illucens larvae: Larval density adjustment

Black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens) larvae (BSFL) are common insects that are known for bioconversion of organic waste into a sustainable utilization resource. However, a strategy to increase antibiotic resistance gene (ARG) elimination in sustainable and economic ways through BSFL is lacking. In the present study, different larval densities were employed to assess the mcr-1 and tetX elimination abilities, and potential mechanisms were investigated. The application and economic value of each larval density were also analyzed. The results showed that the 100 larvae cultured in 100 g of manure group had the best density because the comprehensive disadvantage evaluation ratio was the lowest (14.97%, good bioconversion manure quality, low ARG deposition risk and reasonable larvae input cost). Further investigation showed that mcr-1 could be significantly decreased by BSFL bioconversion (4.42 ×10⁷ copies/g reduced to 4.79 ×10⁶-2.14 ×10⁵ copies/g)(P＜0.05); however, mcr-1 was increasingly deposited in the larval gut with increasing larval density. The tetX abundance was stabilized by BSFL bioconversion, except that the abundance at the lowest larval density increased (1.22 ×10¹⁰ copies/g increase, 34-fold). Escherichia was the host of mcr-1 and tetX in all samples, especially in fresh manure; Alcaligenes was the host of tetX in bioconversion manure; and the abundance of Alcaligenes was highly correlated with the pH of bioconversion manure. The pH of bioconversion manure was extremely correlated with the density of larvae. Klebsiella and Providencia were both hosts of tetX in the BSF larval gut, and Providencia was also the host of mcr-1 in the BSF larval gut. The density of larvae influenced the bioconversion manure quality and caused the ARG host abundance to change to control the abundance of ARGs, suggesting that larval density adjustment was a useful strategy to manage the ARG risk during BSFL manure bioconversion.

Insight into the evolution of antibiotic resistance genes and microbial community during spiramycin fermentation residue composting process after thermally activated peroxydisulfate pretreatment

Previous research has been demonstrated that the residual unextracted antibiotics in spiramycin fermentation residue (SFR) could be efficiently removed by thermally activated peroxodisulfate (TAP) pretreatment, indicating the improvement of biodegradability. This study aimed to investigate the effect of TAP pretreatment on the succession of bacterial community and fate of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) during SFR composting. Results indicated that TAP pretreatment increased the composting temperature and promoted the decomposition of organic matters. Furthermore, TAP pretreatment could increase bacterial alpha diversity and significantly reduce the relative abundance of ARGs (1.13-1.75 times) and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) (1.13-1.32 times) after composting. The compost of pretreated SFR by TAP could reduce the enrichment of ARGs and MGEs in the bacterial community, especially the rRNA methylase genes of ermB (4-142-folds). Redundancy analysis showed that Actinobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Proteobacteria and horizontal gene transfer mediated by MGEs (intI1) was positively related to the changes in ARGs (accounted for 97.4%). Network analysis showed that Firmicutes was the main bacterial hosts of ARGs and MGEs. These findings demonstrated that TAP pretreatment combined composting was a promising strategy for SFR safe treatment and disposal that could reduce the proliferation and transfer of ARGs.

Optimising mixed aerobic and anaerobic composting process parameters for reducing bacterial pathogenicity in compost-derived products

Although composting techniques are continuously optimised and adjusted, the removal of bacterial pathogen based on the quality of composting products needs further to ensure safe of agricultural use. In this study, we combined aerobic composting and anaerobic process to determine the optimal combination (turning frequency of once a day, the proportion of swine manure to corn straw (3:1), and mixed 6-day anaerobic process) that benefits the reduction of bacterial pathogens, among which the maximum removal efficiency of up to 92.96% was observed for Clostridium_sensu_stricto_1 reached, thereby improving the quality of the compost products. The variation partition analysis and redundancy analysis indicated that physicochemical factors such as temperature, TOC, and pH significantly affected the removal of bacterial pathogens. Therefore, the additive effects of physicochemical factors on bacterial pathogen removal requires further process optimisation. These findings offer powerful technological support for improving agricultural waste recycling and enhancing the safety of fertiliser application.

Microbial community competition rather than high-temperature predominates ARGs elimination in swine manure composting

Aerobic composting is commonly used in pig manure treatment, however, antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and their unclear transformation during composting process make the treated manure land using risky. The effects of enhanced thermophilic phase strategy (external heating (HTC) and thermophiles inoculation (MC)) on ARGs removal and the underlying mechanisms were investigated during swine manure composting. HTC increased the total relative abundance (RA) of ARGs by 32.38%, and MC decreased by 21.50% compared to CK by the end of the composting. Mantel test indicated that it was not temperature (P > 0.05), but environmental parameters (pH, Electric Conductivity (EC), etc.) and metabolic products (nitrogen forms) significantly affected the ARGs profile. Partial least-squares path modeling (PLS-PM) suggested that microbial community structure (bacterial abundance and diversities) was the main factor for ARGs evolution. Co-occurrence analysis revealed that HTC could promote the propagation of ARG hosts in later stage of the composting because the strong selection of thermophiles resulted in ecological niches vacancy, and MC enhanced the competition between hosts and nonhosts for ecological niches by increasing thermophiles diversities. These results suggested that competitive inhibition to potential ARGs hosts could be a helpful strategy in ARGs threaten elimination during composting.

Tetracycline hydrochloride-stressed succession in microbial communities during aerobic composting: Insights into bacterial and fungal structures

Available information that whether antibiotics affect the succession in microbial communities during aerobic composting remains limited. Thus, this work investigated the dynamic changes in bacterial and fungal structures during aerobic composting amended with tetracycline hydrochloride (TCH: 0, 50, 150 and 300 mg kg^-1). Composting phases significantly affected bacterial and fungal communities, but only fungi strongly responded to antibiotics, while bacteria did not. Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, Bacteroidota and Actinobacteriota were primary bacterial phylum. Neocallimastigomycota was dominant fungal phylum at temperature-heating phase, then Basidiomycota and Ascomycota became main fungal phylum at thermophilic and temperature-colling phases. Low TCH concentration promoted Chytridiomycota growth, while high TCH concentration inhibited mostly fungal activity in TCH-amended composting. Nitrogen species were critical factors controlling the succession in bacterial and fungal communities during composting process. These results cast a new light on understanding about microbial function during aerobic composting.

Evaluations of biochar amendment on anaerobic co-digestion of pig manure and sewage sludge: waste-to-methane conversion, microbial community, and antibiotic resistance genes

Effects of biochar on co-digestion of pig manure and dewatered sewage sludge under different total solids (TS) were investigated. Biochar could accelerate the start-up of methanogenesis and shorten the adaptation phase. At TS5%, the methane daily production in biochar group was 60.6% higher than the control; nevertheless, when TS increased, the gap between two groups gradually narrowed. Additionally, the change on antibiotics resistance genes (ARGs) was also affected by TS and the biochar addition. Moreover, biochar was beneficial to reduce ARGs in liquid phase. At TS14%, the total ARGs abundance in the liquid phase of biochar group was 41.4% lower than the control, among which the reduction rates of etB(P), sul1, rpoB2, macA, mupA and mupB were more prominent. These findings could provide useful guidance for developing ARGs elimination strategy before their release into the environment.

Mechanism of a double-channel nitrogen-doped lignin-based carbon on the highly selective removal of tetracycline from water

A high-performance nitrogen-doped lignin-based carbon material (ILAC-N) was synthesized using industrial lignin and urea by hydrothermal and activation, as an absorbent of tetracycline hydrochloride (TC). The results showed that the ILAC-N comprises a double-channeled structure with micro and mesopores. It exhibits an excellent adsorption capacity of TC across a wide pH range (pH 2-11), with the highest adsorption capacity of 1396 mg g^-1 at 323 K. Tests in actual wastewater showed that the TC removal rate by ILAC-N exceeded 97.4%. Moreover, it maintained a removal rate of 84% after 10 regeneration cycles, revealing its high reusability. Mechanisms suggested that pore filling and π-π interaction played a critical role in this process. In conclusion, ILAC-N can be broadly applied to livestock manure and pharmaceutical wastewater treatment, owing to its high adsorption capacity, good adsorption properties across a wide pH range, excellent reusability. Furthermore, this research opens a new path for lignin utilization.

Variations in antibiotic resistance genes and removal mechanisms induced by C/N ratio of substrate during composting

For a comprehensive insight into the potential mechanism of the removal of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) removal induced by initial substrates during composting, we tracked the dynamics of physicochemical properties, bacterial community composition, fungal community composition, the relative abundance of ARGs and mobile genetic genes (MGEs) during reed straw and cow manure composting with different carbon to nitrogen ratio. The results showed that the successive bacterial communities were mainly characterized by the dynamic balance between Firmicutes and Actinobacteria, while the fungal communities were composed of Ascomycota. During composting, the interactions between bacteria and fungi were mainly negative. After composting, the removal efficiency of ARGs in compost treatment with C/N ≈ 26 (LL) was higher than that in compost treatment with C/N ≈ 35 (HL), while MGEs were completely degraded in HL and enriched by 2.3% in LL. The large reduction in the relative abundance of ARGs was possibly due to a decrease in the potential host bacterial genera, such as Advenella, Tepidimicrobium, Proteiniphilum, Acinetobacter, Pseudomonas, Flavobacteria and Arcbacter. Partial least-squares path modeling (PLS-PM) revealed that the succession of bacterial communities played a more important role than MGEs in ARGs removal, while indirect factors of the fungal communities altered the profile of ARGs by affecting the bacterial communities. Both direct and indirect factors were affected by composting treatments. This study provides insights into the role of fungal communities in affecting ARGs and highlights the role of different composting treatments with different carbon to nitrogen ration on the underlying mechanism of ARGs removal.

Key factors driving the fate of antibiotic resistance genes and controlling strategies during aerobic composting of animal manure: A review

Occurrence of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in animal manure impedes the reutilization of manure resources. Aerobic composting is potentially effective method for resource disposal of animal manure, but the fate of ARGs during composting is complicated due to the various material sources and different operating conditions. This review concentrates on the biotic and abiotic factors influencing the variation of ARGs in composting and their potential mechanisms. The dynamic variations of biotic factors, including bacterial community, mobile genetic elements (MGEs) and existence forms of ARGs, are the direct driving factors of the fate of ARGs during composting. However, most key abiotic indicators, including pH, moisture content, antibiotics and heavy metals, interfere with the richness of ARGs indirectly by influencing the succession of bacterial community and abundance of MGEs. The effect of temperature on ARGs depends on whether the ARGs are intracellular or extracellular, which should be paid more attention. The emergence of various controlling strategies renders the composting products safer. Four potential removal mechanisms of ARGs in different controlling strategies have been concluded, encompassing the attenuation of selective/co-selective pressure on ARGs, killing the potential host bacteria of ARGs, reshaping the structure of bacterial community and reducing the cell-to-cell contact of bacteria. With the effective control of ARGs, aerobic composting is suggested to be a sustainable and promising approach to treat animal manure.

Proliferation of antibiotic-resistant microorganisms and associated genes during composting: An overview of the potential impacts on public health, management and future

Antibiotic residues together with non-antibiotic drugs and heavy metals act as a selective pressure for the spread of antibiotic-resistant microorganisms (ARMs), antibiotic-resistant genes (ARGs), and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) during composting of livestock manure. ARMs, ARGs and MGEs have become emerging contaminants since they are regularly implicated in the majority of compost produced from livestock manure. The prevalence of these contaminants in agricultural soil receiving compost has drawn huge attention globally due to the risks they pose to the total environment. Although a large body of literature exists on the application of composting methods in minimizing the relative abundance of these contaminants, there is a paucity of information on the robustness, limitations and opportunities and threats of various composting protocols currently deployed. To address this knowledge gap, the current review compiled literature on the origin and mechanisms of the proliferation of ARMs, ARGs, and MGEs during composting of livestock manure. The effectiveness of current composting protocols in the reduction or removal of emerging contaminants was evaluated. Furthermore, the potential environmental impacts and human health risks of these contaminants following land application of compost were also presented. Finally, we propose some strategic approaches for the reduction of ARGs and MGEs during composting of livestock manure.

Airborne and indigenous microbiomes co-drive the rebound of antibiotic resistome during compost storage

Composting is widely used to reduce the abundance of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in solid waste. While ARG dynamics have been extensively investigated during composting, the fate and abundance of residual ARGs during the storage remain unexplored. Here, we tested experimentally how ARG and mobile genetic element (MGE) abundances change during compost storage using metagenomics, quantitative PCR and direct culturing. We found that 43.8% of ARGs and 39.9% of MGEs quickly recovered already during the first week of storage. This rebound effect was mainly driven by the regrowth of indigenous, antibiotic-resistant bacteria that survived the composting. Bacterial transmission from the surrounding air had a much smaller effect, being most evident as MGE rebound during the later stages of storage. While hyperthermophilic composting was more efficient at reducing the relative abundance of ARGs and MGEs, relatively greater ARG rebound was observed during the storage of hyperthermophilic compost, exceeding the initial levels of untreated sewage sludge. Our study reveals that residual ARGs and MGEs left in the treated compost can quickly rebound during the storage via airborne introduction and regrowth of surviving bacteria, highlighting the need to develop better storage strategies to prevent the rebound of ARGs and MGEs after composting.

Two types nitrogen source supply adjusted interaction patterns of bacterial community to affect humifaction process of rice straw composting

This study investigated effects of high-nitrogen source (urea) (R_UR) and protein-like nitrogen source (chicken manure) (R_CM) on humification process during lignocellulose biomass composting. It demonstrated that decreasing ratio of crude fiber (CF), polysaccharide (PS) and amino acids (AAs) in R_CM (29.75%, 53.93% and 73.73%, respectively) was higher than that in R_UR (14.73%, 28.74% and 51.92%, respectively). Humic substance (HS) concentration increased by 7.51% and 73.05% during R_UR and R_CM composting, respectively. The lower total links, more independent modularization and higher proportion of positive correlations between functional bacteria and organic components was observed with R_CM network than R_UR, indicating that protein-like nitrogen source supply may alleviate competition within bacterial community. Moreover, chicken manure supply favorably selects greater special functional bacterial taxa (Pusillimonas, Pedomicrobium, Romboustia and other 24 genus) related to AAs and stimulates the collaborative division of bacterial community. This is significance for strengthening effective transformation of organic components.

Enhanced removal of antibiotic resistance genes and mobile genetic elements during swine manure composting inoculated with mature compost

Livestock manure is a major source of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) that enter the environment. This study assessed the effects of inoculation with mature compost (MC) on the fates of ARGs and the bacterial community during swine manure composting. The results showed that MC prolonged the thermophilic period and promoted the decomposition of organic matter, which was due to the rapid growth and reproduction of thermophilic bacteria (Bacillus, Thermobifida, and Thermobacillus). MC significantly reduced the relative abundances of ARGs (1.02 logs) and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) (1.70 logs) after composting, especially sulfanilamide resistance genes. The total ARGs removal rate was 1.11 times higher in MC than the control. Redundancy analysis and structural equation modeling showed that horizontal gene transfer mediated by MGEs (ISCR1 and intI1) was the main direct factor related to the changes in ARGs during composting, whereas the C/N ratio and pH were the two most important indirect factors. Network analysis showed that members of Firmicutes comprising Romboutsia, Clostridisensu_stricto_1, and Terrisporobacter were the main bacterial hosts of ARGs and MGEs. MC reduced the risk of ARGs transmission by decreasing the abundances of bacterial hosts. Thus, MC is a promising strategy for reducing the proliferation risk of ARGs.

Enhanced control of sulfonamide resistance genes and host bacteria during thermophilic aerobic composting of cow manure

Traditional composting has already shown a certain effect in eliminating antibiotic residues, antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARBs), and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). It is worth noting that the rebounding of ARGs and the succession of the bacterial community during conventional aerobic composting are still serious threats. Considering the probable risk, improved and adaptable technologies are urgently needed to control antibiotic resistance efficiently. This study monitored how thermophilic aerobic composting affected the ARGs, as well as the bacterial diversity during the composting of cow manure spiked with sulfamethoxazole (SMX) at different concentrations. Results showed that the degradation of SMX was enhanced during thermophilic aerobic composting (control > SMX25 > SMX50 > SMX100) and was no longer detected after 20 days of composting. High temperature or heat significantly stimulated the rebounding of certain genes. After 35 days, the abundance of detected genes (sul2, sulA, dfrA7, and dfrA1) significantly decreased (p < 0.05) in control and antibiotic-spiked treatments, except for sul1. The addition of three concentrations of SMX elicited a sharp effect on bacterial diversity, and microbial structure in SMX25 led to significant differences with others (p < 0.05). The network analysis revealed more rigorous interactions among ARGs and abundant genera, suggesting that the host of ARGs potentially increased at low concentrations of SMX. Especially, genera g_norank_f__Beggiatoaceae, Ruminiclostridium, Caldicoprobacter, g_norank_o_MBA03, Hydrogenispora, and Ruminiclostridium_1 were major potential hosts for sul1. In conclusion, the rebounding of ARGs could be intermitted partially, and more efficient control of antibiotic resistance could be achieved in the thermophilic composting compared to conventional methods.

Enrichment of antibiotic resistance genes after sheep manure aerobic heap composting

In this study, physio-chemical properties, 45 antibiotics, 6 heavy metals, 42 antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), 3 mobile genetic elements, and the bacterial community structure were investigated to analyze the fate of ARGs during sheep manure aerobic heap composting. Results showed that sheep manure heap composting could produce mature compost. The degradation processes reduced the total antibiotics content by 85%. The abundance of ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) were enriched 9-fold, with the major increases to sul and tet genes (sulI, sulII, tetQ, and tetX). Tetracycline and sulfonamide resistance genes were the most abundant ARGs after composting (more than 88% of all genes). The genes tetA, tetX and sulI were related to the most diverse bacteria that were most able to proliferate during heap composting. Therefore, sulI and tetX are the major ARGs to be controlled, and Actinobacteria and Bacteroidetes may be the major host bacteria.

In-feed antibiotic use changed the behaviors of oxytetracycline, sulfamerazine, and ciprofloxacin and related antibiotic resistance genes during swine manure composting

The dynamics of oxytetracycline (OTC), sulfamerazine (SM1), ciprofloxacin (CIP) and related antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) during swine manure composting were compared between manure collected from swine fed a diet containing these three antibiotics (T_D) and manure directly spiked with these drugs (T_S). The composting removal efficiency of OTC (94.9 %) and CIP (87.8 %) in the T_D treatment was significantly higher than that of OTC (83.8 %, P <  0.01) and CIP (83.9 %, P <  0.05) in the T_S treatment, while SM1 exhibited no significant difference (P >  0.05) between the two treatments. Composting effectively reduced the majority of ARGs in both T_D and T_S types of manure, especially tetracycline resistance genes (TRGs). Compared with the T_S treatment, the abundance of some ARGs, such as tetG, qepA, sul1 and sul2, increased dramatically up to 309-fold in the T_D treatment. The microbial composition of the composting system changed significantly during composting due to antibiotic feeding. Redundancy analysis suggested that the abundance of ARGs had a considerable impact on alterations in the physicochemical parameters (C/N, pH and temperature) and bacterial communities (Actinobacteria, Proteobacteria and Firmicutes) during the composting of swine manure.

The maturity period is the main stage of antibiotic resistance genes reduction in aerobic composting process of swine manure in sub-scale farms

This study was focused on the changes of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and their potential host bacteria during the swine manure composting on sub-scale farms. Eight target ARGs increased 427% on average, with a trend of increase at early stage and decrease at later stage, and the main reduction stage appeared in maturity stage. The abundance of ARGs was mainly affected by the community succession of potential host bacteria. Composting could reduce the abundance of potential host bacteria of ARGs as well as pathogens such as Pseudomonas, and reduce the environmental risks of swine manure. N/C and S levels had a positive effect on the potential host of most ARGs. Prolonging the maturity period would inhibit the growth of potential host bacteria of ARGs during composting, therefore inhibiting the transmission of ARGs.

The fate of antibiotic resistance genes in cow manure composting: shaped by temperature-controlled composting stages

Current work for animal manure processing is not up to the required standards and hence are not supposed to reflect the actual performance in antibiotic resistance control. As a result, this study carried out temperature-controlled aerobic composting, with sulfamethoxazole (SMX) as a typical antibiotic. The results of four different treatments demonstrated that temperature, water content, C/N ratio, EC, and pH showed no significant (p > 0.05) difference. Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) significantly decreased in the initial 10 days of the thermophilic phase, but the abundance of sul1 and sul2 increased greatly after 30 days. Moreover, ARGs were closely related with each other during the late stages of composting. A noteworthy effect of composting properties, especially temperature on bacterial community, which then had a positive effect on ARGs abundances. These findings provided evidence that the standard composting was still insufficient to control antibiotic resistance.

Removal of antibiotic resistance genes in pig manure composting influenced by inoculation of compound microbial agents

The influence of compound microbial agents on antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in pig manure composting was investigated. The results show that the addition of microbial agents promoted the reduction of total ARGs and the maximum removal efficiencies for absolute abundance (77.2%) and relative abundance (64.5%) were observed in the repeated dose and high dose groups, respectively. Four categories of ARGs declined with the reduction of Firmicutes and Tn916/1545, whereas two categories increased with the proliferation of intI1 and various potential hosts in the composting. The ARG profiles and bacterial communities were shaped by composting stages (mesophilic-thermophilic and cooling-maturation stages) in all groups. However, the addition of microbial agents accelerated the variation of composting stages, and may change the potential ARG hosts which influences the removal of ARGs. Of note, intI1 and two potential pathogens (Mycobacterium and Bacillus) correlated positively to several increased ARGs, implying the possible risks of compost products.