Lead immobilization in soil using new hydroxyapatite-like compounds derived from oyster shell and its uptake by plant

Cadmium, lead, and zinc immobilization in the soil using a phosphate compound with citric acid present

Low molecular weight organic acids (LMWOAs) are common in rhizospheric soil and may impede the interaction between phosphate and metals. Thus, studying how phosphate compounds impact metal immobilization in rhizospheric soil using LMWOAs is crucial. An incubation experiment examined the effects of NaH2PO4 (a P compound) (3%), various concentrations of citric acid (CA), and combinations of P and CA, on soil cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn) immobilization using the European Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) sequential extraction method, CaCl2 extraction method, zeta potential, fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), and X-ray diffraction (XRD). The P, low CA (2 mmol kg-1 soil) (CA2), and P-CA2 treatments reduced acid-soluble and CaCl2-extractable Cd, Pb, and Zn, indicating metal immobilization, with the P-CA2 treatment being the most effective. High CA (>5-20 mmol kg-1 soil) or a P with high CA reversed prior patterns, suggesting metal mobilization. The zeta potential study indicated that when pH increased, treatments became more negative, notably P-CA2 followed by P, suggesting that electrostatic adsorption was the predominant metal immobilization mechanism, especially in P-CA2. XRD tests, however, showed that the P treatment alone produced Cd phosphate, pyromorphite, and hopeite, indicating that sorption and precipitation were the main metal immobilization processes in the P treatment alone. In conclusion, P-CA2 was found to be the most efficient metal immobilization and redistribution treatment for contaminated soils. Rhizospheric CA may alter Cd, Pb, and Zn mineral stability. Therefore, when treating Cd, Pb, and Zn-contaminated soils with a P compound, CA should be addressed.

Effects of four amendments on cadmium and arsenic immobilization and their exposure risks from pakchoi consumption

Exposure to heavy metal(loid)s (HM) through contaminated food chains poses significant health risks to humans. While soil amendments are known to reduce HM bioavailability, their effects on bioaccessibility and health risks in soil-pakchoi-human systems remain unclear. To address this knowledge gap, we conducted a greenhouse pot experiment coupling soil immobilization with bioaccessibility-based health risk assessment for Cd and As exposure from pakchoi consumption. Four amendments (attapulgite, shell powder, nanoscale zero-valent iron, and biochar) were applied to soil, resulting in changes to soil characteristics (pH and organic matter), plant dry weight, and exchangeable fractions of As and Cd. Among the tested amendments, biochar exhibited the highest effectiveness in reducing the risk of Cd and As exposure from pakchoi consumption. The bioaccessibility-based health risk assessment revealed that the application of 5% biochar resulted in the lowest hazard index, significantly decreasing it from 1.36 to 0.33 in contaminated soil. Furthermore, the structural equation model demonstrated that pH played a critical role in influencing remediation efficiency, impacting the exposure of the human body to Cd and As. In conclusion, our study offers a new perspective on mitigating exposure risks of soil HM and promoting safe crop production. The results underscore the importance of considering bioaccessibility in health risk assessment and highlight the potential of biochar as a promising amendment for reducing Cd and As exposure from pakchoi consumption.

Immobilization of heavy metals in tannery sludge by the formation of tobermorite in subcritical water treatment with rice husk silica

Tannery sludge, heavy metals (HMs) enriched hazardous solid waste, is produced extensively in many regions of the world. Even though the sludge is hazardous, it can be considered a material resource, if organic matter and HMs in the sludge can be stabilized to minimize its negative environmental impacts. This research aimed to evaluate the efficacy of using subcritical water (SCW) treatment for tannery sludge treatment through immobilization and thus reduction of HMs to mitigate their potential environmental risk and toxicity. HMs in the tannery sludge were analyzed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and the average concentration of HMs (mg kg^-1) was found in the following decreasing order of Cr (12 950) > Fe (1265) > Cu (76) > Mn (44) > Zn (36) > Pb (14) with very high Cr concentration. The result of toxicity characteristics leaching procedure and sequential extraction procedure tests revealed that the raw tannery sludge leachate contained 11.24 mg L^-1 Cr, which classified the raw tannery sludge into a very high-risk category. After SCW treatment, the concentration of Cr in leachate was reduced to 1.6 mg L^-1 indicating risk reduction to a low-risk category. The eco-toxicity levels of other HMs also decreased considerably after SCW treatment. X-ray diffractometry (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis were employed to identify the effective immobilizing substances formed in the SCW treatment process. The favorable formation of immobilizing orthorhombic tobermorite (Ca₅Si₆O₁₆(OH)₂·4H₂O) at 240 °C in the SCW treatment process was confirmed by XRD and SEM analysis. The results confirmed that the formation of 11 Å tobermorite is capable of strongly immobilizing HMs in the SCW treatment process. Further, both orthorhombic 11 Å tobermorite and 9 Å tobermorite were successfully synthesized by SCW treatment on a mixture of tannery sludge including rice husk silica and Ca(OH)₂ with water under rather mild conditions. Hence, it can be concluded that SCW treatment of tannery sludge with supplementary silica from rice husk can effectively immobilize the HMs and significantly reduce their environmental risk through tobermorite formation.

Application of humic acid and hydroxyapatite in Cd-contaminated alkaline maize cropland: A field trial

Soil quality is critical to the quality and safety of agricultural products, and remediation of heavy metal contaminated soils is an urgent task to be implemented. This study applied hydroxyapatite (HAP) and humic acid (HA) as remediation materials to Cd-contaminated alkaline cropland. Data on soil pH, electrical conductivity (EC), cation exchange capacity (CEC), soil organic matter (SOM), diethylenetriamine pentaacetic acid (DTPA) extraction, and improved BCR sequential extraction were obtained for different periods. The joint application of HAP and HA enhanced the soil's buffering capacity. During the experiment, treatment groups CK, H1, H2, H3, and H4 showed changes in pH of 0.29, 0.28, 0.21, 0.24, and 0.32, respectively, and changes in the conductivity of 341.4, 183.0, 133.1, 104.6 and 320.2 μS/cm. Soil organic matter had a positive effect on soil's effective phosphorus content. HAP and HA both reduced the BCF_grain/soil of Cd for the maize, but the impact of HA was more substantial (20.19 % reduction compared to CK). HA increased the yield of maize by 44.20 %. The combination of HA and HAP was recommended.

Application of bovine bone meal and oyster shell meal to heavy metals polluted soil: Vegetable safety and bacterial community

The development of efficient, environmentally friendly soil amendments is necessary in order to minimize the risk of metal contaminants (Cd, Pb, Cu, and Zn) to the soil ecosystem. As soil amendments, bovine bone meal (BM) and oyster shell meal (OS) reduced the mobility and bioavailability of metals primarily by increasing soil pH. Soil geochemical properties (pH, EC, CEC, Ca, P, and K) after amendment supplementation were more likely to affect metal migration than enzyme activity. Furthermore, BM and OS were found to suppress the Cd and Pb uptake by water spinach, keeping them below international standards for safe utilization. The protein and sugar content and peroxidase (POD) activity showed a significant negative correlation with the amount of metal in water spinach, whereas superoxide dismutase (SOD), ascorbate peroxidase (APX) activities and malondialdehyde (MDA) content exhibited a positive correlation with metal content in water spinach. We also found that BM and OS had less perturbation to phylum-level and genus-level bacterial composition during the remediation of heavy metals contaminated soil. Based on the above, we assume that BM and OS are eco-friendly soil amendments, which could improve soil nutrients contents, stabilize heavy metals and regulate bacterial community structure. Our research contributes to resource utilization of waste and holds promise for widespread application in current agricultural systems.

Supplying amendments alleviates aluminum toxicity and regulates cadmium accumulation by spinach in strongly acidic soils

Al toxicity and Cd pollution are key limiting factors for agricultural production in the acidic soils in China. The application of amendments is an effective and promising measure for remediating strongly acidic Cd-contaminated soils. However, the information on applying amendments for alleviating Al toxicity and regulating plant Cd accumulation is still rare. Here, oyster shell (OS), red mud (RM), hydroxyapatite (HAP), and biochar (BC) at 30 g kg^-1 were investigated for alleviating Al toxicity and decreasing Cd accumulation in spinach plants. The results showed that four amendments significantly increased soil pH, and reduced soil exchangeable Al³⁺ and DTPA-Cd, promoted spinach growth (P < 0.05). Al(OH)₃⁰ and Al-HA were the main forms of active Al in soil. The BC and OS were more effective to alleviate Al toxicity but significantly (P < 0.05) increased Cd accumulation in spinach. RM and HAP effectively reduced the uptake of Cd by spinach plants as well as alleviated Al toxicity (P < 0.05). Bivariate correlation analysis and the partial least squares path modeling analysis indicated that soil exchangeable Al³⁺ was the main limiting factor for biomass production. Our study demonstrated that HAP could significantly alleviate Al toxicity, promote spinach growth, and decrease Cd accumulation in strongly acidic Cd-contaminated soils. Besides, OS and BC effectively alleviated soil Al toxicity leading to promoting the growth of spinach. Compared with CK, RM treatment significantly reduced soil Cd bioavailability (61.2%) and decreased Cd concentration and uptake of spinach plants by 90.0% and 50.7%. These results indicated that RM could be used as an efficient amendment in Cd contaminated.

Isotherm models for adsorption of heavy metals from water - A review

Adsorption is a widely used technology for removing and separating heavy metal from water, attributed to its eco-friendly, cost-effective, and high efficiency. Adsorption isotherm modeling has been used for many years to predict the adsorption equilibrium mechanism, adsorption capacity, and the inherent characteristics of the adsorption process, all of which are substantial in evaluating the performance of adsorbents. This review summarizes the development history, fundamental characteristics, and mathematical derivations of various isotherm models, along with their applicable conditions and application scenarios in heavy metal adsorption. The latest progress in applying isotherm models with a one-parameter, two-parameter, and three-parameter in heavy metal adsorption using carbon-based materials, which has gained much attention in recent years as low-cost adsorbents, is critically reviewed and discussed. Several experimental factors affecting the adsorption equilibrium, such as solution pH, temperature, ionic strength, adsorbent dose, and initial heavy metal concentration, are briefly discussed. The criteria for selecting the optimum isotherm for heavy metal adsorption are proposed by comparing various adsorption models and analyzing mathematical error functions. Finally, the relative performance of different isotherm models for heavy metal adsorption is compared, and the future research gaps are identified.

Effects of biochar and organic-inorganic fertilizer on pomelo orchard soil properties, enzymes activities, and microbial community structure

Fertilizer management can influence soil microbes, soil properties, enzymatic activities, abundance and community structure. However, information on the effects of biochar in combination with organic-inorganic fertilizer after 3 years under pomelo orchard on soil bacterial abundance, soil properties and enzyme activities are not clear. Therefore, we conducted a field experiment with seven treatments, i.e., (1) Ck (control), (2) T1 (2 kg biochar plant^–1), (3) T2 (4 kg biochar plant^–1), (4) T3 (2 kg organic-inorganic mixed fertilizer plant^–1), (5) T4 (4 kg biochar + 1.7 kg organic-inorganic mixed fertilizer plant^–1), (6) T5 (4 kg biochar + 1.4 kg organic-inorganic mixed fertilizer plant^–1), and (7) T6 (4 kg biochar + 1.1 kg organic-inorganic mixed fertilizer plant^–1). The soil microbial communities were characterized using high-throughput sequencing of 16S and internal transcribed spacer (ITS) ribosomal RNA gene amplicons. The results showed that biochar combined with organic-organic fertilizer significantly improved soil properties (pH, alkali hydrolysable nitrogen, available phosphorus, available potassium, and available magnesium) and soil enzymatic activities [urease, dehydrogenase (DHO), invertase and nitrate reductase (NR) activities]. Furthermore, soil bacterial relative abundance was higher in biochar and organic-inorganic treatments as compared to control plots and the most abundant phyla were Acidobacteria (40%), Proteobacteria (21%), Chloroflexi (17%), Planctomycetes (8%), Bacteroidetes (4%), Verrucomicrobia (2%), and Gemmatimonadetes (1%) among others. Among the treatments, Acidothermus, Acidibacter, Candidatus Solibacter and F473 bacterial genera were highest in combined biochar and organic-inorganic treatments. The lowest bacterial abundance and bacterial compositions were recorded in control plots. The correlation analysis showed that soil attributes, including soil enzymes, were positively correlated with Chloroflexi, Planctomycetes, verrucomicrobia, GAL15 and WPS-2 bacterial abundance. This study demonstrated that biochar with organic-inorganic fertilizer improves soil nutrients, enzymatic activities and bacterial abundance.

Effects of oyster shell powder on leaching characteristics of nutrients in low-fertility latosol in South China

In this study, we analyzed the effect of oyster shell powder of different proportions on the nutrient leaching characteristics of latosol using an indoor soil column simulation test. Based on the optimized fertilizer application amount, we assessed five different amounts of oyster shell powder (0% (control, CK), 0.1% (T1), 0.2% (T2), 0.4% (T3), and 0.8% (T4)) and analyzed the intermittent and dynamic leaching characteristics of nutrients in the soil samples. The results indicated that the loss of nutrients in urea, superphosphate, and potassium chloride (due to leaching) increased linearly with the amount of fertilizer. By adding oyster shell powder, the leaching loss reduced by 23.90-57.25% for ammonium nitrogen, 6.31-10.07% for phosphorus, and 17.08-26.58% for potassium. However, the leaching loss for nitrate nitrogen increased by 2.5-5.8 times. In addition, the application of oyster shell powder to latosol provided acid adjustment and water retention enhancement, which increased the pH value of the soil by 3.77 (from pH 4.15 to 7.92) and reduced water loss by 2.52%. Thus, the application of oyster shell powder can reduce the acidity of the surface soil and retain water and fertilizer to a certain extent.

Mechanism underlying how a chitosan-based phosphorus adsorbent alleviates cadmium-induced oxidative stress in Bidens pilosa L. and its impact on soil microbial communities: A field study

In the present study, field experiments were conducted in Side village, Yangshuo, Guilin, Guangxi Province, China, using four C-BPA application levels (control (0 mg m^-2), T1 (100 mg m^-2), T2 (200 mg m^-2) and T3 (400 mg m^-2)) to clarify the mechanism by which a chitosan-based phosphorus adsorbent (C-BPA) applied as a passivator helps Bidens pilosa L. (B. pilosa L.) alleviate cadmium (Cd)-induced oxidative stress in Cd-contaminated soil. In the aqueous phase, C-BPA successfully adsorbed Cd²⁺ on the surface primarily via ion exchange, and C-BPA has potential Cd²⁺ adsorption capacity, enabling its use as a passivator in real Cd-contaminated environments. In Cd-contaminated soils, under C-BPA application at the T3 level, the pH value increased by 11.2%, and the acid-soluble form of Cd decreased by 26.5%. Additionally, the application of C-BPA improved the rhizosphere soil environment and impacted the soil microbial community diversity and structure. Among soil microbes, the soil fungal community was more sensitive than bacteria to C-BPA application. Dehydrogenase, acetic acid, soil pH and Eurotiomycetes or Dothideomycetes significantly impacted Cd accumulation in the leaves of B. pilosa L.; Cd accumulation in leaves was decreased by 68.1% under C-BPA application at the T3 level. Additionally, the variation of increased catalase (CAT) and peroxidase (POD) jointly promoted plant growth; the plant weight was increased by 112.7% under the C-BPA application at the T3 level. Notably, the production of CAT and POD by B. pilosa L. was more effective than the synthesis of glutathione (GSH) in helping B. pilosa L. eliminate excess reactive oxygen species (ROS). Therefore, our findings demonstrated that the application of C-BPA to Cd-contaminated soil can greatly improve the rhizosphere soil environment, help B. pilosa L. eliminate ROS and promote plant growth.

The sorption and short-term immobilization of lead and cadmium by nano-hydroxyapatite/biochar in aqueous solution and soil

In this study, the composite materials using different ratios of biochar (BC) to nano-hydroxyapatite (nHAP) were prepared for the remediation of lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd) contaminated water and soil. The sorption and the immobilization experiments indicated a higher sorption capacity and immobilization efficiency of Pb compared to those of Cd. The characteristics of XRD, FTIR, SEM, and XPS manifested that dissolution-precipitation, cation exchange, complexation, and cation-π interaction were the main four mechanisms for the sorption of Pb²⁺ and Cd²⁺ using composite material PC1 (nHAP/BC = 1/1). From semi-quantitative analysis, the mineral effect accounted for the majority of the immobilization of Pb and Cd. Due to obvious Pb-precipitates in the sorbed material, dissolution-precipitation primarily affected the sorption of Pb using PC1, while the immobilization of Cd was mainly attributable to cation exchange. Such results corresponded to the stable Pb-precipitates and unstable Cd-compounds in soil, among which the latter was prone to be released into the environment. The sorption capacity in aqueous solutions and the immobilization efficiencies in the soil for both Pb and Cd increased with the addition of nHAP, which were linearly correlated to the nHAP proportion in the composite materials. In future practical applications, the percentages of composite materials can be designed according to the specific pollutant concentration. This study sheds light on the explicit immobilization mechanisms for Pb and Cd in aqueous solutions to better understand their behaviors in the soil remediated by relevant materials.

Phosphorus Co-Existing in Water: A New Mechanism to Boost Boron Removal by Calcined Oyster Shell Powder

The removal of boron (B) from water by co-precipitation with hydroxyapatite (HAP) has been extensively studied due to its low cost, ease of use and high efficiency. However, there is no explicit mechanism to express how resolved B was trapped by HAP. Thus, in this work, the process of removing B from water was studied using a low-cost calcium (Ca) precipitation agent derived from used waste oyster shells. The results showed that the removal rate of B in the simulated wastewater by calcined oyster shell (COS) in the presence of phosphorus (P) is up to more than 90%, as opposed to virtually no removal without phosphate. For B removal, the treated water needs to be an alkaline solution with a high pH above 12, where B is removed as [CaB(OH)4]+ but is not molecular. Finally, the synergistic mechanism of co-precipitation between HAP and dissolved B, occlusion co-precipitation, was explained in detail. The proposed method discovered the relationship between Ca, P and B, and was aimed at removing B without secondary pollution through co-precipitation.

Combined effects of Penicillium oxalicum and tricalcium phosphate on lead immobilization: Performance, mechanisms and stabilities

Phosphorus (P) containing minerals are identified as effective Pb stabilizers in soil, while their low solubility limit the Pb immobilization efficiency. In this work, the combination of phosphate solubilizing fungi (PSF) Penicillium oxalicum and tricalcium phosphate (TCP) was constructed and applied to improve Pb immobilization stabilities in medium and soils. P. oxalicum+ TCP could significantly improve Pb²⁺ removal to above 99% under different TCP/Pb²⁺ and pH values. TCP and P. oxalicum could remarkably immobilize Pb by ion exchange, and PbC₂O₄ precipitation or surface adsorption, respectively. While the enhanced Pb immobilization in P. oxalicum+ TCP was explained by stronger Pb²⁺ interaction with tryptophan protein-like substances in extracellular polymeric substance, and the formation of the most stable Pb-phosphate compound hydroxypyromorphite (Pb₅(PO₄)₃OH). Toxicity characteristic leaching procedure test showed that only 0.91% of Pb²⁺ was leachable in P. oxalicum+ TCP treatment, significantly lower than that in P. oxalicum (2.90%) and TCP (7.52%) treatments. In addition, the lowest soil exchangeable Pb fraction (37.1%) and the highest available soil P (88.0 mg/kg) were both found in P. oxalicum+ TCP treatment. By synergistically forming stable Pb-containing products, thus the combination of PSF and P minerals could significantly improve Pb²⁺ immobilization and stability in soils.

Removal of organic pollutants from aqueous solution using metal organic frameworks (MOFs)-based adsorbents: A review

The development of metal organic frameworks (MOFs) has recently drawn a lot of scientific interest in water treatment due to the unique properties such as tunable porosities, large pore volumes, hierarchical structures, excellent adsorption and regeneration performances. MOFs represent an eco-friendly alternative to conventional adsorbents especially for the adsorptive removal of noxious organic pollutants from aqueous solution. Advanced MOFs' performances are justified by the introduction of functional groups, magnetic moieties, and specific foreign materials onto MOFs. This however leads to increase in the manufacturing costs of MOFs and consequently possess a huge challenge in large-scale applications. This review hence critically discusses the recent progresses in the development of MOFs-based adsorbents for the removal of selected organic pollutants (e.g., dyes, antibiotics and pesticides) from aqueous solution. Furthermore, major interaction mechanisms between MOFs and organic pollutants in response to numerous experimental conditions, such as pH, temperature, coexisting ions are put forward. Finally, some recommendations in support for designing MOFs with improved adsorption performances are also highlighted.