Rapid and efficient degradation of endogenous proteins in vivo identifies stage-specific roles of RNA Pol II pausing in mammalian development

Pause Patrol: Negative Elongation Factor's Role in Promoter-Proximal Pausing and Beyond

RNA polymerase (Pol) II is highly regulated to ensure appropriate gene expression. Early transcription elongation is associated with transient pausing of RNA Pol II in the promoter-proximal region. In multicellular organisms, this pausing is stabilized by the association of transcription elongation factors DRB-sensitivity inducing factor (DSIF) and Negative Elongation Factor (NELF). DSIF is a broadly conserved transcription elongation factor whereas NELF is mostly restricted to the metazoan lineage. Mounting evidence suggests that NELF association with RNA Pol II serves as checkpoint for either release into rapid and productive transcription elongation or premature termination at promoter-proximal pause sites. Here we summarize NELF's roles in promoter-proximal pausing, transcription termination, DNA repair, and signaling based on decades of cell biological, biochemical, and structural work and describe areas for future research.

Cell-type specific, inducible and acute degradation of targeted protein in mice by two degron systems

Despite its broad application in in vitro studies, the application of targeted protein degradation (TPD) to animal models faces considerable challenges. Here, we develop inducible and cell-type specific TPD systems in mice using two degron systems: Oryza sativa TIR1F74G (OsTIR1)-auxin-inducible degron 2 (AID2) and human cereblon (hCRBN)-SALL4 degron (S4D). Efficient degradation of Satb1Venus protein by these systems recapitulates phenotypes observed in the Satb1-deficient mice. These TPD are successfully applied in both the fetal and neonatal stages. The OsTIR1-AID2 system proves to be effective for membrane proteins such as PD-1, emulating the effects of the anti-PD-1 antibody. Degradation of Bcl11b reveals a role of Bcl11b which was not characterized by the Cre-loxP system. Collectively, in vivo TPD technologies developed in this study enable inducible, temporal, and cell type-specific depletion of target proteins with high efficacy in mice. These technologies have a wide range of applications in the diverse fields of biological and medical research.

The transcription factor GABPA is a master regulator of naïve pluripotency

The establishment of naïve pluripotency is a continuous process starting with the generation of inner cell mass (ICM) which then differentiating into epiblast (EPI). Recent studies have revealed key transcription factors (TFs) for ICM formation, but which TFs initiate EPI specification remains unknown. Here, using a targeted rapid protein degradation system, we show that GABPA is not only a regulator of major ZGA, but also a master EPI specifier required for naïve pluripotency establishment by regulating 47% of EPI genes during E3.5 to E4.5 transition. Chromatin binding dynamics analysis suggests that GABPA controls EPI formation at least partly by binding to the ICM gene promoters occupied by the pluripotency regulators TFAP2C and SOX2 at E3.5 to establish naïve pluripotency at E4.5. Our study not only uncovers GABPA as a master pluripotency regulator, but also supports the notion that mammalian pluripotency establishment requires a dynamic and stepwise multi-TFs regulatory network.

Establishment and characterization of mouse lines useful for endogenous protein degradation via an improved auxin-inducible degron system (AID2)

The development of new technologies opens new avenues in the research field. Gene knockout is a key method for analyzing gene function in mice. Currently, conditional gene knockout strategies are employed to examine temporal and spatial gene function. However, phenotypes are sometimes not observed because of the time required for depletion due to the long half-life of the target proteins. Protein knockdown using an improved auxin-inducible degron system, AID2, overcomes such difficulties owing to rapid and efficient target depletion. We observed depletion of AID-tagged proteins within a few to several hours by a simple intraperitoneal injection of the auxin analog, 5-Ph-IAA, which is much shorter than the time required for target depletion using conditional gene knockout. Importantly, the loss of protein is reversible, making protein knockdown useful to measure the effects of transient loss of protein function. Here, we also established several mouse lines useful for AID2-medicated protein knockdown, which include knock-in mouse lines in the ROSA26 locus; one expresses TIR1(F74G), and the other is the reporter expressing AID-mCherry. We also established a germ-cell-specific TIR1 line and confirmed the protein knockdown specificity. In addition, we introduced an AID tag to an endogenous protein, DCP2 via the CAS9-mediated gene editing method. We confirmed that the protein was effectively eliminated by TIR1(F74G), which resulted in the similar phenotype observed in knockout mouse within 20 h.

The AID2 system offers a potent tool for rapid, reversible, or sustained degradation of essential proteins in live mice

Studying essential genes required for dynamic processes in live mice is challenging as genetic perturbations are irreversible and limited by slow protein depletion kinetics. The first-generation auxin-inducible-degron (AID) system is a powerful tool for analyzing inducible protein loss in cultured cells. However, auxin administration is toxic to mice, preventing its long-term use in animals. Here, we use an optimized second-generation AID system to achieve the conditional and reversible loss of the essential centrosomal protein CEP192 in live mice. We show that the auxin derivative 5-Ph-IAA is well tolerated over two weeks and drives near-complete CEP192-mAID degradation in less than one hour in vivo. Prolonged CEP192 loss led to cell division failure and cell death in proliferative tissues. Thus, the second-generation AID system is well suited for rapid and/or sustained protein depletion in live mice, offering a valuable new tool for interrogating protein function in vivo.

Transcriptional remodeling by OTX2 directs specification and patterning of mammalian definitive endoderm

The molecular mechanisms that drive essential developmental patterning events in the mammalian embryo remain poorly understood. To generate a conceptual framework for gene regulatory processes during germ layer specification, we analyzed transcription factor (TF) expression kinetics around gastrulation and during in vitro differentiation. This approach identified Otx2 as a candidate regulator of definitive endoderm (DE), the precursor of all gut- derived tissues. Analysis of multipurpose degron alleles in gastruloid and directed differentiation models revealed that loss of OTX2 before or after DE specification alters the expression of core components and targets of specific cellular signaling pathways, perturbs adhesion and migration programs as well as de-represses regulators of other lineages, resulting in impaired foregut specification. Key targets of OTX2 are conserved in human DE. Mechanistically, OTX2 is required to establish chromatin accessibility at candidate enhancers, which regulate genes critical to establishing an anterior cell identity in the developing gut. Our results provide a working model for the progressive establishment of spatiotemporal cell identity by developmental TFs across germ layers and species, which may facilitate the generation of gut cell types for regenerative medicine applications.

How CRISPR Is Revolutionizing the Generation of New Models for Cancer Research

Cancers arise through acquisition of mutations in genes that regulate core biological processes like cell proliferation and cell death. Decades of cancer research have led to the identification of genes and mutations causally involved in disease development and evolution, yet defining their precise function across different cancer types and how they influence therapy responses has been challenging. Mouse models have helped define the in vivo function of cancer-associated alterations, and genome-editing approaches using CRISPR have dramatically accelerated the pace at which these models are developed and studied. Here, we highlight how CRISPR technologies have impacted the development and use of mouse models for cancer research and discuss the many ways in which these rapidly evolving platforms will continue to transform our understanding of this disease.

NELF focuses sites of initiation and maintains promoter architecture

Many factors control the elongation phase of transcription by RNA polymerase II (Pol II), a process that plays an essential role in regulating gene expression. We utilized cells expressing degradation tagged subunits of NELFB, PAF1 and RTF1 to probe the effects of depletion of the factors on nascent transcripts using PRO-Seq and on chromatin architecture using DFF-ChIP. Although NELF is involved in promoter proximal pausing, depletion of NELFB had only a minimal effect on the level of paused transcripts and almost no effect on control of productive elongation. Instead, NELF depletion increased the utilization of downstream transcription start sites and caused a dramatic, genome-wide loss of H3K4me3 marked nucleosomes. Depletion of PAF1 and RTF1 both had major effects on productive transcript elongation in gene bodies and also caused initiation site changes like those seen with NELFB depletion. Our study confirmed that the first nucleosome encountered during initiation and early elongation is highly positioned with respect to the major TSS. In contrast, the positions of H3K4me3 marked nucleosomes in promoter regions are heterogeneous and are influenced by transcription. We propose a model defining NELF function and a general role of the H3K4me3 modification in blocking transcription initiation.

Distinct negative elongation factor conformations regulate RNA polymerase II promoter-proximal pausing

Metazoan gene expression regulation involves pausing of RNA polymerase (Pol II) in the promoter-proximal region of genes and is stabilized by DSIF and NELF. Upon depletion of elongation factors, NELF appears to accompany elongating Pol II past pause sites; however, prior work indicates that NELF prevents Pol II elongation. Here, we report cryoelectron microscopy structures of Pol II-DSIF-NELF complexes with NELF in two distinct conformations corresponding to paused and poised states. The paused NELF state supports Pol II stalling, whereas the poised NELF state enables transcription elongation as it does not support a tilted RNA-DNA hybrid. Further, the poised NELF state can accommodate TFIIS binding to Pol II, allowing for Pol II reactivation at paused or backtracking sites. Finally, we observe that the NELF-A tentacle interacts with the RPB2 protrusion and is necessary for pausing. Our results define how NELF can support pausing, reactivation, and elongation by Pol II.

Degron tagging for rapid protein degradation in mice

Degron tagging allows proteins of interest to be rapidly degraded, in a reversible and tuneable manner, in response to a chemical stimulus. This provides numerous opportunities for understanding disease mechanisms, modelling therapeutic interventions and constructing synthetic gene networks. In recent years, many laboratories have applied degron tagging successfully in cultured mammalian cells, spurred by rapid advances in the fields of genome editing and targeted protein degradation. In this At a Glance article, we focus on recent efforts to apply degron tagging in mouse models, discussing the distinct set of challenges and opportunities posed by the in vivo environment.

Orthogonal IMiD-Degron Pairs Induce Selective Protein Degradation in Cells

Immunomodulatory imide drugs (IMiDs) including thalidomide, lenalidomide, and pomalidomide, can be used to induce degradation of a protein of interest that is fused to a short zinc finger (ZF) degron motif. These IMiDs, however, also induce degradation of endogenous neosubstrates, including IKZF1 and IKZF3. To improve degradation selectivity, we took a bump-and-hole approach to design and screen bumped IMiD analogs against 8380 ZF mutants. This yielded a bumped IMiD analog that induces efficient degradation of a mutant ZF degron, while not affecting other cellular proteins, including IKZF1 and IKZF3. In proof-of-concept studies, this system was applied to induce efficient degradation of TRIM28, a disease-relevant protein with no known small molecule binders. We anticipate that this system will make a valuable addition to the current arsenal of degron systems for use in target validation.

Chemical-genetics refines transcription factor regulatory circuits

Transcriptional dysregulation is a key step in oncogenesis, but our understanding of transcriptional control has relied on genetic approaches that are slow and allow for compensation. Chemical-genetic approaches have shortened the time frame for the analysis of transcription factors from days or weeks to minutes. These studies show that while DNA-binding proteins bind to thousands of sites, they are directly required to regulate only a small cadre of genes. Moreover, these transcriptional control networks are far more distinct, with much less overlap and interconnectivity than predicted from DNA binding. The identified direct targets can then be used to dissect the mechanism of action of these factors, which could identify ways to therapeutically manipulate these oncogenic transcriptional control networks.

Transcriptional elongation control in developmental gene expression, aging, and disease

The elongation stage of transcription by RNA polymerase II (RNA Pol II) is central to the regulation of gene expression in response to developmental and environmental cues in metazoan. Dysregulated transcriptional elongation has been associated with developmental defects as well as disease and aging processes. Decades of genetic and biochemical studies have painstakingly identified and characterized an ensemble of factors that regulate RNA Pol II elongation. This review summarizes recent findings taking advantage of genetic engineering techniques that probe functions of elongation factors in vivo. We propose a revised model of elongation control in this accelerating field by reconciling contradictory results from the earlier biochemical evidence and the recent in vivo studies. We discuss how elongation factors regulate promoter-proximal RNA Pol II pause release, transcriptional elongation rate and processivity, RNA Pol II stability and RNA processing, and how perturbation of these processes is associated with developmental disorders, neurodegenerative disease, cancer, and aging.

Molecular mechanisms underlying totipotency

Numerous efforts to understand pluripotency in mammals, using pluripotent stem cells in culture, have enabled the generation of artificially induced pluripotent stem cells, which serve as a valuable source for regenerative medicine and the creation of disease models. In contrast to these tremendous successes in the pluripotency field in the past few decades, our understanding of totipotency, which is highlighted by its broader plasticity than pluripotency, is still limited. This is largely attributable to the scarcity of available materials and the lack of in vitro models. However, recent technological advances have unveiled molecular features that characterize totipotent cells. Single-cell or low-input sequencing technologies allow the dissection of pre- and post-fertilization developmental processes at the molecular level with high resolution. In this review, we describe some of the key findings in understanding totipotency and discuss how totipotency is acquired at the beginning of life.

An essential signaling function of cytoplasmic NELFB is independent of RNA polymerase II pausing

The four-subunit negative elongation factor (NELF) complex mediates RNA polymerase II (Pol II) pausing at promoter-proximal regions. Ablation of individual NELF subunits destabilizes the NELF complex and causes cell lethality, leading to the prevailing concept that NELF-mediated Pol II pausing is essential for cell proliferation. Using separation-of-function mutations, we show here that NELFB function in cell proliferation can be uncoupled from that in Pol II pausing. NELFB mutants sequestered in the cytoplasm and deprived of NELF nuclear function still support cell proliferation and part of the NELFB-dependent transcriptome. Mechanistically, cytoplasmic NELFB physically and functionally interacts with prosurvival signaling kinases, most notably phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase/AKT. Ectopic expression of membrane-tethered phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase/AKT partially bypasses the role of NELFB in cell proliferation, but not Pol II occupancy. Together, these data expand the current understanding of the physiological impact of Pol II pausing and underscore the multiplicity of the biological functions of individual NELF subunits.

A degron-based approach to manipulate Eomes functions in the context of the developing mouse embryo

The T-box transcription factor Eomesodermin (Eomes), also known as Tbr2, plays essential roles in the early mouse embryo. Loss-of-function mutant embryos arrest at implantation due to Eomes requirements in the trophectoderm cell lineage. Slightly later, expression in the visceral endoderm promotes anterior visceral endoderm formation and anterior-posterior axis specification. Early induction in the epiblast beginning at day 6 is necessary for nascent mesoderm to undergo epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT). Eomes acts in a temporally and spatially restricted manner to sequentially specify the yolk sac haemogenic endothelium, cardiac mesoderm, definitive endoderm, and axial mesoderm progenitors during gastrulation. Little is known about the underlying molecular mechanisms governing Eomes actions during the formation of these distinct progenitor cell populations. Here, we introduced a degron-tag and mCherry reporter sequence into the Eomes locus. Our experiments analyzing homozygously tagged embryonic stem cells and embryos demonstrate that the degron-tagged Eomes protein is fully functional. dTAG (degradation fusion tag) treatment in vitro results in rapid protein degradation and recapitulates the Eomes-null phenotype. However in utero administration of dTAG resulted in variable and lineage-specific degradation, likely reflecting diverse cell type-specific Eomes expression dynamics. Finally, we demonstrate that Eomes protein rapidly recovers following dTAG wash-out in vitro. The ability to temporally manipulate Eomes protein expression in combination with cell marking by the mCherry-reporter offers a powerful tool for dissecting Eomes-dependent functional roles in these diverse cell types in the early embryo.

Ribo-On and Ribo-Off tools using a self-cleaving ribozyme allow manipulation of endogenous gene expression in C. elegans

Investigating gene function relies on the efficient manipulation of endogenous gene expression. Currently, a limited number of tools are available to robustly manipulate endogenous gene expression between "on" and "off" states. In this study, we insert a 63 bp coding sequence of T3H38 ribozyme into the 3' untranslated region (UTR) of C. elegans endogenous genes using the CRISPR/Cas9 technology, which reduces the endogenous gene expression to a nearly undetectable level and generated loss-of-function phenotypes similar to that of the genetic null animals. To achieve conditional knockout, a cassette of loxP-flanked transcriptional termination signal and ribozyme is inserted into the 3' UTR of endogenous genes, which eliminates gene expression spatially or temporally via the controllable expression of the Cre recombinase. Conditional endogenous gene turn-on can be achieved by either injecting morpholino, which blocks the ribozyme self-cleavage activity or using the Cre recombinase to remove the loxP-flanked ribozyme. Together, our results demonstrate that these ribozyme-based tools can efficiently manipulate endogenous gene expression both in space and time and expand the toolkit for studying the functions of endogenous genes.

RNA polymerase II dynamics shape enhancer-promoter interactions

How enhancers control target gene expression over long genomic distances remains an important unsolved problem. Here we investigated enhancer-promoter communication by integrating data from nucleosome-resolution genomic contact maps, nascent transcription and perturbations affecting either RNA polymerase II (Pol II) dynamics or the activity of thousands of candidate enhancers. Integration of new Micro-C experiments with published CRISPRi data demonstrated that enhancers spend more time in close proximity to their target promoters in functional enhancer-promoter pairs compared to nonfunctional pairs, which can be attributed in part to factors unrelated to genomic position. Manipulation of the transcription cycle demonstrated a key role for Pol II in enhancer-promoter interactions. Notably, promoter-proximal paused Pol II itself partially stabilized interactions. We propose an updated model in which elements of transcriptional dynamics shape the duration or frequency of interactions to facilitate enhancer-promoter communication.

Auxin-inducible degron system: an efficient protein degradation tool to study protein function

Targeted protein degradation, with its rapid protein depletion kinetics, allows the measurement of acute changes in the cell. The auxin-inducible degron (AID) system, rapidly degrades AID-tagged proteins only in the presence of auxin. The AID system being inducible makes the study of essential genes and dynamic processes like cell differentiation, cell cycle and genome organization feasible. The AID degradation system has been adapted to yeast, protozoans, C. elegans, Drosophila, zebrafish, mouse and mammalian cell lines. Using the AID system, researchers have unveiled novel functions for essential proteins at developmental stages that were previously difficult to investigate due to early lethality. This comprehensive review discusses the development, advancements, applications and drawbacks of the AID system and compares it with other available protein degradation systems.

The NELF pausing checkpoint mediates the functional divergence of Cdk9

Promoter-proximal pausing by RNA Pol II is a rate-determining step in gene transcription that is hypothesized to be a prominent point at which regulatory factors act. The pausing factor NELF is known to induce and stabilize pausing, but not all kinds of pausing are NELF-mediated. Here, we find that NELF-depleted Drosophila melanogaster cells functionally recapitulate the NELF-independent pausing we previously observed in fission yeast (which lack NELF). Critically, only NELF-mediated pausing establishes a strict requirement for Cdk9 kinase activity for the release of paused Pol II into productive elongation. Upon inhibition of Cdk9, cells with NELF efficiently shutdown gene transcription, while in NELF-depleted cells, defective, non-productive transcription continues unabated. By introducing a strict checkpoint for Cdk9, the evolution of NELF was likely critical to enable increased regulation of Cdk9 in higher eukaryotes, as Cdk9 availability can be restricted to limit gene transcription without inducing wasteful, non-productive transcription.

New insights into genome folding by loop extrusion from inducible degron technologies

Chromatin folds into dynamic loops that often span hundreds of kilobases and physically wire distant loci together for gene regulation. These loops are continuously created, extended and positioned by structural maintenance of chromosomes (SMC) protein complexes, such as condensin and cohesin, and their regulators, including CTCF, in a highly dynamic process known as loop extrusion. Genetic loss of extrusion factors is lethal, complicating their study. Inducible protein degradation technologies enable the depletion of loop extrusion factors within hours, leading to the rapid reconfiguration of chromatin folding. Here, we review how these technologies have changed our understanding of genome organization, upsetting long-held beliefs on its role in transcription. Finally, we examine recent models that attempt to reconcile observations after chronic versus acute perturbations, and discuss future developments in this rapidly developing field of research.

The regulation of transcription elongation in embryonic stem cells

Transcription elongation is a fundamental molecular process which is accurately regulated to ensure proper gene expression in cellular activities whereas its malfunction is associated with impaired cellular functions. Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) have significant value in regenerative medicine due to their self-renewal ability and their potential to differentiate to almost all types of cells. Therefore, dissection of the exact regulatory mechanism of transcription elongation in ESCs is crucial for both basic research and their clinical applications. In this review, we discuss the current understanding on the regulatory mechanisms of transcription elongation mediated by transcription factors and epigenetic modifications in ESCs.

Distinct patterns of RNA polymerase II and transcriptional elongation characterize mammalian genome activation

How transcription is regulated as development commences is fundamental to understand how the transcriptionally silent mature gametes are reprogrammed. The embryonic genome is activated for the first time during zygotic genome activation (ZGA). How RNA polymerase II (Pol II) and productive elongation are regulated during this process remains elusive. Here, we generate genome-wide maps of Serine 5 and Serine 2-phosphorylated Pol II during and after ZGA in mouse embryos. We find that both phosphorylated Pol II forms display similar distributions across genes during ZGA, with typical elongation enrichment of Pol II emerging after ZGA. Serine 2-phosphorylated Pol II occurs at genes prior to their activation, suggesting that Serine 2 phosphorylation may prime gene expression. Functional perturbations demonstrate that CDK9 and SPT5 are major ZGA regulators and that SPT5 prevents precocious activation of some genes. Overall, our work sheds molecular insights into transcriptional regulation at the beginning of mammalian development.

Generation of knock-in degron tags for endogenous proteins in mice using the dTAG system

Controlling the abundance of a protein of interest in vivo is crucial to study its function. Here, we provide a step-by-step protocol for generating genetically engineered mouse (GEM) models harboring a degradation tag (dTAG) fused to endogenous proteins to enable their degradation. We discuss considerations for the overall design and details for vectors generation. Then, we include steps for generation and validations of edited mouse embryonic stem cells followed by mouse colony establishment via chimeric mouse generation.

For complete details on the use and execution of this protocol, please refer to Abuhashem et al. (2022c).

•

Generation of endogenous tagged degradable proteins in mouse models using dTAG system

•

Generation of genetically edited homozygous mouse embryonic stem cells

•

Details of successive steps from vector design to mouse model generation and validation

•

Detailed recommendations and considerations for tagging any protein of interest

Publisher’s note: Undertaking any experimental protocol requires adherence to local institutional guidelines for laboratory safety and ethics.

RNA Pol II pausing facilitates phased pluripotency transitions by buffering transcription

Promoter-proximal RNA Pol II pausing is a critical step in transcriptional control. Pol II pausing has been predominantly studied in tissue culture systems. While Pol II pausing has been shown to be required for mammalian development, the phenotypic and mechanistic details of this requirement are unknown. Here, we found that loss of Pol II pausing stalls pluripotent state transitions within the epiblast of the early mouse embryo. Using Nelfb -/- mice and a NELFB degron mouse pluripotent stem cell model, we show that embryonic stem cells (ESCs) representing the naïve state of pluripotency successfully initiate a transition program but fail to balance levels of induced and repressed genes and enhancers in the absence of NELF. We found an increase in chromatin-associated NELF during transition from the naïve to later pluripotent states. Overall, our work defines the acute and long-term molecular consequences of NELF loss and reveals a role for Pol II pausing in the pluripotency continuum as a modulator of cell state transitions.

Rapid and specific degradation of endogenous proteins in mouse models using auxin-inducible degrons

Auxin-inducible degrons are a chemical genetic tool for targeted protein degradation and are widely used to study protein function in cultured mammalian cells. Here, we develop CRISPR-engineered mouse lines that enable rapid and highly specific degradation of tagged endogenous proteins in vivo. Most but not all cell types are competent for degradation. By combining ligand titrations with genetic crosses to generate animals with different allelic combinations, we show that degradation kinetics depend upon the dose of the tagged protein, ligand, and the E3 ligase substrate receptor TIR1. Rapid degradation of condensin I and II - two essential regulators of mitotic chromosome structure - revealed that both complexes are individually required for cell division in precursor lymphocytes, but not in their differentiated peripheral lymphocyte derivatives. This generalisable approach provides unprecedented temporal control over the dose of endogenous proteins in mouse models, with implications for studying essential biological pathways and modelling drug activity in mammalian tissues.