Increasing soil moisture faciliates the outcomes of exogenous sulfate rather than element sulfur in reducing cadmium accumulation in rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Chemical and mechanical coating of sulfur on baby corn biochar and their role in soil Pb availability, uptake, and growth of tomato under Pb contamination

In recent ages, industrial revolution and natural weathering processes have been increasing lead (Pb) contamination in agricultural soils, therefore, green remediation technologies are becoming attractive and cost-effective. In the current pot study, 1% and 2% (w/w) application rates of sulfur (S) alone and novel chemo-mechanically S-modified baby corn biochars (CSB and MSB) were applied in a Pb-contaminated (500 mg/kg) soil to evaluate tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum L.) growth, Pb uptake and its soil availability. The results from SEM-EDS and XRD patterns confirmed the S enrichment on the surface of baby-corn biochar. Further, Pb treatment alone imposed a significant reduction in biomass accumulation, photosynthetic pigments, antioxidative mechanism, root traits, and Pb-tolerance index because of increased soil Pb availability and its uptake, translocation and biological accumulation in various tissues of tomato. However, incorporation of lower rate of elemental S (1%) and higher rates of biochars, especially chemically S-modified biochar, CSB (2%) significantly improved dry biomass production, Pb-tolerance index, physiological attributes and antioxidative defense system of tomato plants. These results might be due to a prominent decrease in soil Pb availability by 37.5%, Pb concentration in shoot by 66.7% and root by 58.3%, soil to root transfer by 33.8%, and root to shoot transfer by 20.2% in tomato plants under 2% application rate of CSB, as compared with the Pb treatment without any amendment. Moreover, sulfur treatment induced a significant impact in reduction of soil pH (from 8.97-7.47) as compared to the biochar treatments under Pb-toxicity. The current findings provided an insight that 2% chemically S-modified biochar (CSB) has significant potential to improve the tomato growth by reducing Pb bioavailability in the Pb-contaminated soil, compared to the S alone and MSB amendments.

Roles of Chloride and Sulfate Ions in Controlling Cadmium Transport in a Soil-Rice System as Evidenced by the Cd Isotope Fingerprint

Anions accompanying inorganic fertilizers, such as chloride and sulfate ions, potentially affect the solubility, uptake, and transport of Cd to rice grains. However, the role of anions in controlling Cd transport in the soil-soil solution-Fe plaque-rice plant continuum remains poorly understood. Cd isotope ratios were applied to Cd-contaminated soil pots, hydroponic rice, and adsorption experiments with or without KCl and K2SO4 treatments to decipher transport processes in the complex soil-rice system. The chloride and sulfate ions increased the Cd concentrations in the soil solution, Fe plaque, and rice plants. Accordingly, the magnitude of positive fractionation from soil to the soil solution was less pronounced, but that between soil and Fe plaque or rice plant is barely varied. The similar isotope composition of Fe plaque and soil, and the similar fractionation magnitude between Fe plaque and the solution and between goethite and the solution, suggested that desorption-sorption between iron oxides and the solution could be important at the soil-soil solution-Fe plaque continuum. This study reveals the roles of chloride and sulfate ions: (i) induce the mobility of light Cd isotopes from soil to the soil solution, (ii) chloro-Cd and sulfato-Cd complexes contribute to Cd immobilization in the Fe plaque and uptake into roots, and (iii) facilitate second leaves/node II-to-grain Cd transport within shoots. These results provide insights into the anion-induced Cd isotope effect in the soil-rice system and the roles of anions in facilitating Cd migration and transformation.

The risks of sulfur addition on cadmium accumulation in paddy rice under different water-management conditions

Recently, the application of sulfur (S) has been recommended to control the accumulation of cadmium (Cd) in rice in contaminated paddy soil. However, the effects of exogenous S on Cd transfer in paddy rice systems under different water-management practices have not been systematically investigated. Pot experiments were performed to monitor the composition of soil pore water and the Cd accumulation in iron plaque and rice tissue were compared under different S (0 and 200 mg/kg Na₂SO₄) and water (continuous and discontinuous flooding) treatments. Sulfur application significantly increased Cd concentrations in soil pore water under discontinuous flooding conditions, but slightly reduced them under continuous flooding. Moreover, the oxidation/reduction potential (Eh) was the most critical factor that affected the Cd levels. When the Eh exceeded -42.5 mV, S became the second critical factor, and excessive S application promoted Cd dissolution. In addition, S addition elevated the Cd levels in iron plaque and reduced the Cd transfer from the iron plaque to rice roots. In rice, S addition inhibited Cd transfer from the rice roots to the straw; thus, more Cd was stored in the rice roots. Nevertheless, additional S application increased the Cd content in the rice grains by 72% under discontinuous flooding, although this effect was mitigated by continued flooding. Under simulated practical water management conditions, S addition increased the risk of Cd contamination in rice, suggesting that S application should be reconsidered as a paddy fertilization strategy.

Influence of straw-derived humic acid-like substance on the availability of Cd/As in paddy soil and their accumulation in rice grain

Humic acid amendments have been widely advocated for the remediation of heavy metal-contaminated soil. However, the impacts of straw-derived humic acid-like substances on the remediation of cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As) co-contaminated paddy soil remain unclear and the potential mechanism required clarification. In this study, we employed a pot experiment and chose a straw-derived humic acid-like substance (BFA) as the amendment with four doses to investigate how BFA affects the availability of Cd and As in soil and their accumulation in rice. The results showed that grain Cd decreased by 25.65-36.03%, while there was no significant change in total As (TAs) with the addition of BFA. The contents of DCB-Fe, DCB-As and DCB-Cd on the root surface decreased by 6.07-40.54% during the whole growth stage. The addition of BFA significantly decreased the pe + pH and enhanced the transformation of crystalline iron oxides (Fed) into amorphous forms (Feo) in the soil. The CaCl₂-extractable Cd decreased and the KH₂PO₄-extractable As increased with the decrease in pe + pH and Fed and the relative increase in Feo. The correlation analysis showed that the decrease in availability of Cd and translocation factor of Cd effectively decreased the grain Cd and the decrease in DCB-Cd may also contribute to decreasing the uptake of Cd by rice. However, the increase in As of roots and shoots might play key roles in restricting the transport of As to rice grains. Consequently, the addition of BFA could effectively reduce the Cd accumulation in rice under flooding conditions, while no risk of As accumulation in rice grain was observed. The present work provides a new perspective for the application of straw-derived humic acid-like substances as amendments on Cd-As co-contaminated soils, which should be advocated as an eco-friendly, economical and effective soil amendment in the future.

Immobilization of soil Cd by sulfhydryl grafted palygorskite in wheat-rice rotation mode: A field-scale investigation

The safe utilization of heavy metal contaminated farmland has attracted extensive attention of the whole society, and there is an urgent need to develop novel high-efficiency amendments. To clarify the actual remediation effect and potential for large-scale application of sulfhydryl grafted palygorskite (SGP) in Cd polluted soil in wheat-rice rotation mode, a field-scale experiment was conducted. SGP at the dosages of 0.5 g/kg-2.0 g/kg could reduce gain Cd contents by 27.15-59.05% and 16.16-79.47% for wheat and rice, respectively. The maximal decreases of soil available Cd figured out by DTPA extraction in wheat and rice season were 58.18% and 33.67%, respectively. The immobilization ratio for Cd was much more than that of trace elements, including Fe, Mn, Cu, and Zn, Ni. SGP showed an effective immobilization rate for soil Cd under the interference of many elements in the soil, pointing to the targeting and selectivity of its high-efficiency immobilization. It had no lifting effect on soil pH but decreased zeta potentials of soil particles. The sorption of Cd²⁺ on SGP amended soil could be fitted by the second-order kinetic model and Langmuir isotherm, and the changes of thermodynamic parameters showed SGP strengthened the fixation. SGP made the biological accumulation coefficient and transfer factor of rice grain drop dramatically but had no noticeable effect on these parameters of winter wheat, indicating different botanical responses. SGP as a novel immobilization amendment may provide an efficient and sustainable solution for the remediation of contaminated soil in wheat-rice rotation mode in field-scale.

Sulfur fertilization integrated with soil redox conditions reduces Cd accumulation in rice through microbial induced Cd immobilization

Sulfate and water management can be respectively applied to control Cd accumulation in rice, but the interaction mechanisms remain unclear. Three water management coupled with five sulfate application concentrations were employed to investigate rice Cd uptake. Results showed there was a significant interaction between sulfate application and soil redox state, and the highest sulfate treatments reduced rice grain Cd by 63.2, 53.5, and 59.4% under the flooding, flooding-moist alternate (FM), and moist irrigation (M) conditions, respectively. It could be explained by the reduction in rhizosphere soil available Cd and lower transport coefficient from root to aboveground. The Desulfovibrio was demonstrated to participate in CdS precipitation, and its abundance was promoted by sulfate especially under flooding. Additionaly, sulfate application facilitated Cd bounded to FeMn oxides, as rhizosphere soil pH raising under flooding. Under FM and M treatments, sulfate application reduced the abundance of Fe-reducing bacteria Geobacter, and correspondingly reduced Fe and Cd availability in rhizosphere soil. Summarily, Cd transfer from soil to rice can be reduced by applying sulfate fertilizer; which is favored by higher soil moisture because of the higher abundance of Desulfovibrio and lower abundance of Geobacter.

Differences and mechanism of dynamic changes of Cd activity regulated by polymorphous sulfur in paddy soil

Sulfur (S) can decrease the bioavailability of Cd in paddy soil, and therefore reduce Cd uptake by rice. However, the dynamic influence mechanism of different forms of sulfur on the bioavailability of cadmium in soil has not been systematically studied. In this study, we used Diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technology and soil pore water sampling technology to investigate the effects of different types of S application on the bioavailability of Cd. The three forms of S are elemental sulfur (S⁰), sodium sulfate (SO₄^2-), and mercapto-grafted palygorskite (MP), which have been treated in six ways according to CK, SL, SH, SO₄²L, SO₄²H, MP (L and H are the low and high levels of treatments). The results showed that soluble and labile Cd concentration was quickly fixed after flooding but activated after rice transplantation. Both MP and SL treatments increased the content of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and significantly reduced the accumulation of Cd in roots and grains. The Cd content of roots treated with MP was only 0.50 mg kg^-1, which was 77.6% lower than the Cd content in CK (2.22 mg kg^-1). S promotes the reduction and dissolution of Fe, and the formation of FeS/FeS₂ is also one of the reasons for the low bioavailability of Cd, while the SH treatment has a greater effect on lowering pH, so the effect of fixing Cd is not obvious. In addition, SO₄^2- treatment delays the soil reduction process, so it cannot effectively fix Cd. At the stage of rice maturity, dissolved Cd increased in S treatment, but MP treatment did not have this phenomenon. The possible reason was the consumption of DOC or the oxidation of CdS which caused Cd to enter the soil solution. Taken together, Fe-S play a critical role in controlling the mobilization of Cd in paddy systems.

Meta-analysis of the effects of liming on soil pH and cadmium accumulation in crops

Increasing cadmium (Cd) contamination in agricultural fields has resulted in a higher risk of Cd accumulation in the food chain. Lime addition can mitigate soil acidification and reduce Cd accumulation in crops cultured in Cd-contaminated soil. To determine key factors controlling the outcomes of liming in reducing Cd accumulation and enhancing soil pH, we performed a meta-analysis using previously published data from field and pot experiments. The results indicated that the liming showed positive effect sizes on the soil pH but negative effect sizes on Cd accumulation in crops, indicating the addition of different lime materials could enhance soil pH and reduce Cd accumulation in crops. The effect sizes of liming on soil pH under pot experimental conditions were higher than that under field experimental conditions, however, the effect sizes of application types and amount of limes on soil pH did not significantly differ between their individual different levels. Under a low background value of soil pH, SOM, CEC and clay, the addition of limes showed a significantly higher effect size on soil pH when compared to their individual higher soil background value, suggesting that the lower background values of soil pH, SOM, CEC and clay might facilitate the outcomes of liming to enhance soil pH. The experiment patterns, crop types and lime application amounts showed a limit effect on the outcomes of liming to reduce the shoot and grain Cd concentrations in crops. The lime types only showed a significant effect size on the shoot Cd accumulation but not on the grain Cd accumulation, in which the CaCO₃ had the highest effect size (absolute value, the same below) followed by Ca(OH)₂ and CaO. The low soil background values of total Cd concentration and CEC content, but a high soil SOM background content might facilitate the outcomes of liming to reduce the shoot Cd concentration in crops. However, only the background value of soil clay content showed a significantly negative effect size on the grain Cd accumulation, where a high soil clay content had a higher effect size than a low soil clay content. These findings provide useful knowledge about the effects of experiment patterns, crop types, soil conditions, lime types and lime addition amounts on the efficiency of liming in enhancing soil pH and decrease crop Cd concentration.

Influences of different source microplastics with different particle sizes and application rates on soil properties and growth of Chinese cabbage (Brassica chinensis L.)

The potentially negative effects of microplastics (MP) on agroecosystems have raised worldwide concerns. However, little is known about the negative effects of MP exposure on the soil-plant system. To fill up this knowledge gap, a pot experiment was set up, and two different MP types [high density polyethylene (HDPE) and general purpose polystyrene (GPPS)] were used, which had four particle sizes (<25, 25-48, 48-150, and 150-850 µm) at four application rates (2.5, 5, 10, and 20 g MP kg^-1 soil). Some soil properties and the growth of Chinese cabbage (Brassica chinensis L.) were monitored. The results showed that (1) MP application with high application rates and relatively small particle sizes significantly enhanced the soil urease activity, which accompanied with enhanced soil pH and decreased soil available concentrations of phosphorus and potassium in some cases. (2) The exposure of MP did not significantly affect the activity of soil catalase regardless of their application rates and sizes. MP with different application rates and small sizes significantly reduced the soil sucrase activity, but the largest size of MP enhanced the activity of soil sucrase. (3) GPPS at 10-20 g kg^-1 or with the sizes of <25 and 48-150 µm significantly reduced the fresh weight of Chinese cabbage, but the addition of HDPE had no remarkable effects on the fresh weight regarding of its application rates or sizes. (4) MP with high application rates and large sizes enhanced but small sizes of MP reduced the leaf soluble sugar concentration. The increasing application rates of MP and small size HDPE significantly reduced the starch concentration in the leaves of Chinese cabbage, however, the different sizes of GPPS showed limited effects on the leaf starch. The addition of MP with increasing application rates and different sizes always reduced the concentration of leaf chlorophyll. These parameters regarding to plant and soil could be used to assess the risks of MP pollution in the soil-plant systems. We found that the risks resulting from MP pollution were MP type-dependent and particle size-dependent. These findings indicate that overaccumulation of MP in the agriculture may possess an ecology risk and will negatively affect the agricultural sustainability and the food safety.

Sustainable management of cadmium-contaminated soils as affected by exogenous application of nutrients: A review

Cadmium (Cd) pollution in arable land is of great concern as it impairs plant growth and further threats human health via food-chain. Exogenous supplementation of nutrients is an environmentally-friendly, cost-effective, convenient and feasible strategy for regulating Cd uptake, transport and accumulation in plants. To sustain Cd-contaminated soils management, on the one hand, a low level of the Cd-contaminated soil is expected to cultivate crops with decreased Cd accumulation as affected by exogenous nutrients application, on another hand, a high level of the Cd-contaminated soil is suggested to cultivate phytoextraction plants with increased Cd accumulation as affected by exogenous nutrients application. Nevertheless, effects of nutrients on Cd accumulation in plants are still ambiguous. Thus, data of Cd accumulation in shoots of plants as affected by exogenous application of nutrients were collected from previously published articles between 2005 and 2021 in the present study. According to the data, exogenous supply of calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn) and silicon (Si) to a larger extent decrease Cd amounts in shoots of plants. By contrast, exogenous nitrogen (N), and deficient Ca, Mg and Fe supply have a great possibility to increase Cd amounts in shoots of plants. Although exogenous application of phosphorus (P), sulfur (S), potassium (K), zinc (Zn) and selenium (Se) have a great opportunity to increase biomass, they show different effects on Cd concentrations. As a result, the odds are even for increasing and decreasing Cd amounts in shoots of plants. Taken together, exogenous application of Ca, Mg, Fe, Mn and Si might decrease Cd accumulation in plants that are recommended for crops production. Exogenous N and deficient Ca, Mg and Fe supply might increase Cd accumulation in plants that are recommended for phytoextraction plants. Exogenous application of P, S, K, Zn and Se have half a chance to increase or decrease Cd accumulation in plants. Therefore, dosages, forms and species should be taken into account when exogenous P, S, K, Zn and Se are added.

Understanding the effects of sulfur input on mercury methylation in rice paddy soils

Sulfur could be introduced into paddy soils via dry or wet deposition, irrigation, and fertilization, which subsequently impacts the production of methylmercury (MeHg), a bioaccumulative neurotoxicant. However, effects of sulfur input on MeHg production are variable, possibly due to the multiple effects of sulfur on Hg mobility and/or microbial Hg methylators, leading to uncertainties in predicting MeHg risk. To address that, we explored the effects of different types and amounts of sulfur as well as concentrations of ambient sulfate on Hg methylation in paddy soils, and elucidated the mechanisms by quantifying changes in (1) Hg mobility and (2) microbial Hg methylators (e.g., sulfate-reducing bacteria, SRB). Our results indicated that MeHg levels increased by 40-86% and 30-96% in soils under various types (i.e., 200 mg kg^-1 elemental sulfur, ammonium sulfate, sulfur-coated urea and potassium sulfate (K₂SO₄)) and different amounts (i.e., 100, 200 and 400 mg kg^-1 K₂SO₄) of sulfur input. The enhanced MeHg production could be explained by increased Hg mobility but not changes in microbial Hg methylators. Besides, sulfate input increased MeHg levels (89-240%) in soils with low ambient sulfate levels (<100 mg kg^-1) but had no effect on high-sulfate soils (>380 mg kg^-1). These could be explained by the diverse responses of Hg mobility and microbial Hg methylators to sulfate input at different ambient sulfate levels. Our study opens the "black box" of Hg methylation under sulfur input, which would help reduce uncertainties in predicting MeHg risk in soils.

Seeking for an optimal strategy to avoid arsenic and cadmium over-accumulation in crops: Soil management vs cultivar selection in a case study with maize

Soil management and cultivar selection are two strategies to reduce the accumulation risk of heavy metals in crops. However, it is still an open question which of these two strategies is more efficient for the safe utilization of contaminated soil. In this study, the available bio-concentration factors (aBCF) of arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) among 39 maize cultivars were determined through a field experiment. The effect of soil management was mimicked by choosing diverse sampling sites having different soil available contents of As and Cd. The aBCF of As and Cd in grain ranged from 0.02 to 0.13 and 1.17 to 42.2, respectively. The accumulation ability of As and Cd was classified among different maize cultivars. Soil pH and total As controlled the level of available As in soils, while soil pH dominated available Cd in soil. A soil pH of 6.5 was recommended to simultaneously minimize soil available As and Cd by managing soil conditions. The quantitative effects of cultivar and soil management on grain As and Cd were expressed as Q [Grain As] = 0.746Q [Cultivar]-0.126Q [pH]+0.276Q [As_available] (R² = 0.648, P = 1.00 × 10^-37) and Q [Grain Cd] = 0.913Q [Cultivar]-0.192Q [pH]+0.071Q [SOC] (R² = 0.782, P = 1.00 × 10^-37), respectively. Cultivar selection contributed stronger than soil management to decrease the As and Cd levels in maize grains. A feasible method to seek for a more efficient strategy was proposed for the safe utilization of contaminated soil.