Dying for change: A roadmap to refine the fish acute toxicity test after 40 years of applying a lethal endpoint

Molecular variations to the proteome of zebrafish larvae induced by environmentally relevant copper concentrations

Contaminants are increasingly accumulating in aquatic environments and biota, with potential adverse effects on individual organisms, communities and ecosystems. However, studies that explore the molecular changes in fish caused by environmentally relevant concentrations of metals, such as copper (Cu), are limited. This study uses embryos of the model organism zebrafish (Danio rerio) to investigate effect of Cu on the proteome and amino acid (AA) composition of fish. Wild-type embryos at 24 h post-fertilisation were exposed to Cu (2 µg L-1 to 120 µg L-1) for 96 h and the number of healthy larvae were determined based on larvae that had hatched and did not display loss of equilibrium (LOE). The effect concentrations where Cu caused a 10 % (EC10) or 50 % (EC50) decrease in the number of healthy larvae were calculated as 3.7 µg L-1 and 10.9 µg L-1, respectively. Proteomics analysis of embryos exposed to the EC10 and EC50 concentrations of Cu revealed the proteome to differ more strongly after 48 h than 96 h, suggesting the acclimatisation of some larvae. Exposure to excess Cu caused differentially expressed proteins (DEPs) involved in oxidative stress, mitochondrial respiration, and neural transduction as well as the modulation of the AAs (Proline, Glycine and Alanine). This is the first study to suggest that LOE displayed by Cu-stressed fish may involve the disruption to GABAergic proteins and the calcium-dependent inhibitory neurotransmitter GABA. Moreover, this study highlights that proteomics and AA analysis can be used to identify potential biomarkers for environmental monitoring.

Fish acute toxicity of nine nanomaterials: Need of pre-tests to ensure comparability and reuse of data

Fish acute toxicity tests are commonly used in aquatic environmental risk assessments, being required in different international substances regulations. A general trend in the toxicity testing of nanomaterials (NMs) has been to use standardized aquatic toxicity tests. However, as these tests were primarily developed for soluble chemical, issues regarding particle dissolution, agglomeration or sedimentation during the time of exposure are not considered when reporting the toxicity of NMs. The aim of this study was to characterize the NM behaviour throughout the fish acute test and to provide criteria to assay the toxicity of nine NMs based on TiO2, ZnO, SiO2, BaSO4, bentonite, and carbon nanotubes, on rainbow trout following OECD Test Guideline (TG) nº203. Our results showed the importance of conducting a preliminary test (without fish) when working with NMs. They provide valuable information on, sample monitoring, agglomeration, sedimentation, dissolution, actual concentrations of NMs, needed to design the test. Among the NMs tested, only bentonite nanoparticles were stable during the 96-h pre-test and test in aquarium water. In contrast, the remaining NMs exhibited considerable loss and sedimentation within the first 24 h. The high sedimentation observed for almost all NMs highlights the need of consistently measuring the concentrations throughout the entire duration of the fish acute toxicity test to make reliable concentration-response relationships. Notable differences emerged in LC50 values when using actual concentrations as nominal concentrations overestimated concentrations by up to 85.6%. Among all NMs tested, only ZnO NMs were toxic to rainbow trout. A flow chart was specifically developed for OECD TG 203, aiding users in making informed decisions regarding the selection of test systems and necessary modifications to ensure accurate, reliable, and reusable toxicity data. Our findings might contribute to the harmonization of TG 203 improving result reproducibility and interpretability and supporting the development of read-across and QSAR models.

Weight of evidence tools in the prediction of acute fish toxicity

Acute fish toxicity (AFT) is a key endpoint in nearly all regulatory implementations of environmental hazard assessments of chemicals globally. Although it is an early tier assay, the AFT assay is complex and uses many juvenile fish each year for the registration and assessment of chemicals. Thus, it is imperative to seek animal alternative approaches to replace or reduce animal use for environmental hazard assessments. A Bayesian Network (BN) model has been developed that brings together a suite of lines of evidence (LoEs) to produce a probabilistic estimate of AFT without the testing of additional juvenile fish. Lines of evidence include chemical descriptors, mode of action (MoA) assignment, knowledge of algal and daphnid acute toxicity, and animal alternative assays such as fish embryo tests and in vitro fish assays (e.g., gill cytotoxicity). The effort also includes retrieval, assessment, and curation of quality acute fish toxicity data because these act as the baseline of comparison with model outputs. An ideal outcome of this effort would be to have global applicability, acceptance and uptake, relevance to predominant fish species used in chemical assessments, be expandable to allow incorporation of future knowledge, and data to be publicly available. The BN model can be conceived as having incorporated principles of tiered assessment and whose outcomes will be directed by the available evidence in combination with prior information. We demonstrate that, as additional evidence is included in the prediction of a given chemical's ecotoxicity profile, both the accuracy and the precision of the predicted AFT can increase. Ultimately an improved environmental hazard assessment will be achieved. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2023;19:1220-1234. © 2022 SETAC.

Environmental RNA as a Noninvasive Tool for Assessing Toxic Effects in Fish: A Proof-of-concept Study Using Japanese Medaka Exposed to Pyrene

Although environmental RNA (eRNA) is emerging as a noninvasive tool to assess the health status of aquatic macroorganisms, the potential of eRNA in assessing chemical hazards remain largely untested. In this study, we investigated the ability of eRNA to detect changes in gene expression in Japanese medaka fish (Oryzias latipes) in response to sublethal pyrene exposure, as a model toxic chemical. We performed standardized acute toxicity tests and collected eRNA from tank water and RNA from fish tissue after 96 h of exposure. Our results showed that over 1000 genes were detected in eRNA and the sequenced read counts of these genes correlated with those in fish tissue (r = 0.50). Moreover, eRNA detected 86 differentially expressed genes in response to pyrene, some of which were shared by fish RNA, including the suppression of collagen fiber genes. These results suggest that eRNA has the potential to detect changes in gene expression in fish in response to environmental stressors without the need for sacrificing or causing pain to fish. However, we also found that the majority of sequenced reads of eRNA (>99%) were not mapped to the reference medaka genome and they originated from bacteria and fungi, resulting in low sequencing depth. In addition, eRNA, in particular nuclear genes, was highly degraded with a median transcript integrity number (TIN) of <20. These limitations highlight the need for future studies to improve the analytical methods of eRNA application.

Defining piscine endpoints: Towards score sheets for assessment of clinical signs in fish research

The seminar 'Severity and humane endpoints in fish research' organized by the University of Bergen, the Industrial and Aquatic Laboratory, together with Fondazione Guido Bernadini, took place on 4 October 2019 in Bergen, Norway. The seminar was followed by a workshop, 'Establishing score sheets and defining endpoints in fish experiments', held on 28 January 2020, also in Bergen. The purpose of the seminar was to raise awareness about fish ethics together with severity classification and humane endpoints in fish studies, using examples from farmed fish, mainly salmonids and lumpfish. The overall aim of the workshop was to better define humane endpoints in fish experiments, as well as to discuss suggestions for development and use of score sheets for assessing clinical signs related to endpoints. Endpoints for fish should not only be based on what we know about fish diseases and the lesions they induce but should also take into consideration knowledge about fish species and life stage, fish anatomy, physiology and the general state and behaviour of the fish. For this reason, to reinforce that endpoints should come from the animal's perspective and needs, we renamed humane endpoints for fish to piscine endpoints. This paper reports the main messages from the workshop sessions including advice on development and use of score sheets.

Hazards of current concentration-setting practices in environmental toxicology studies

The setting of concentrations for testing substances in ecotoxicological studies is often based on fractions of the concentrations that cause 50% mortality (LC50 or LD50) rather than environmentally relevant levels. This practice can result in exposures to animals at test concentrations that are magnitudes of order greater than those experienced in the environment. Often, such unrealistically high concentrations may cause non-specific biochemical or morphologic changes that primarily reflect the near-lethal health condition of the animal subjects, as opposed to effects characteristic of the particular test compound. Meanwhile, it is recognized that for many chemicals, the toxicologic mode of action (MOA) responsible for lethality may differ entirely from the MOAs that cause various sublethal effects. One argument for employing excessively high exposure concentrations in sublethal studies is to ensure the generation of positive toxicological effects, which can then be used to establish safety thresholds; however, it is possible that the pressure to produce exposure-related effects may also contribute to false positive outcomes. The purpose of this paper is to explore issues involving some current usages of acute LC50 data in ecotoxicology testing, and to propose an alternative strategy for performing this type of research moving forward. Toward those ends, a brief literature survey was conducted to gain an appreciation of methods that are currently being used to set test concentrations for sublethal definitive studies.

Triphenylmethane dye (C52H54N4O12) is potentially a hazardous substance in edible freshwater fish at trace level: toxicity, hematology, biochemistry, antioxidants, and molecular docking evaluation study

Malachite green (C₅₂H₅₄N₄O₁₂) is a synthetic dye that is used in textile industries as a colorant and in aquaculture sectors to contain microbial damage. Aquatic contamination of malachite green (MG) has been reported globally. Fish is the highest trophic organism among aquatic inhabitants, highly sensitive to waterborne contaminants (metals, coloring agents, etc.). Toxicity of waterborne chemicals on nontarget organisms can be determined by assessing biomarkers. Assessing blood parameters and tissue antioxidants (enzymatic and nonenzymatic) is useful to evaluate MG toxicity. To initiate the MG toxicity data for freshwater fish (Cyprinus carpio), the median lethal toxicity was primarily evaluated. Then, hematological, blood biochemical (glucose, protein, and cholesterol) and tissue biochemical (amino acids, lipids), and vital tissue (gills, liver, and kidney) antioxidant capacity (CAT, LPO, GST, GR, POxy, vitamin C, and GSH) of C. carpio were analyzed under acute (LC_50-96 h) and sublethal (Treatment I-1/10^th and Treatment II-1/5^th LC_50-96 h) exposure periods (28 days). Molecular docking for MG with hemoglobin was also obtained. Biomarkers examined were affected in the MG-treated groups with respect to the control group. Significant changes (p < 0.05) were observed in hematology (Hb, RBCs, and WBCs), glucose, proteins, lipids and tissue CAT, LPO, and GST activities under acute MG exposure. In sublethal treatment groups, biomarkers studied were significant (p < 0.05) throughout the study period. The potential for MG binding to hemoglobin was tested in this study. MG is potentially a multiorgan toxicant. Literally a chemical that is harmful to the aquatic environment if safety is concerned.

The onset of active gill respiration in post-embryonic zebrafish (Danio rerio) larvae triggers an increased sensitivity to neurotoxic compounds

Originally designed as a general alternative to acute fish toxicity testing (AFT), the fish embryo toxicity test (FET) has become subject to concerns with respect to neurotoxic substances. Whereas oxygen uptake in the fish embryo primarily occurs via diffusion across the skin, juvenile and adult fish rely on active ventilation of the gills. As a consequence, substances including, e.g., neurotoxicants which prevent appropriate ventilation of gills ("respiratory failure syndrome") might lead to suffocation in juvenile and adult fish, but not in skin-breathing embryos. To investigate if this respiratory failure syndrome might play a role for the higher sensitivity of juvenile and adult fish to neurotoxicants, a modified acute toxicity test using post-embryonic, early gill-breathing life-stages of zebrafish was developed with chlorpyrifos, permethrin, lindane, aldicarb, ziram and aniline as test substances. Additionally, a comparative study into bioaccumulation of lipophilic substances with log_Kow > 3.5 and swimbladder deflation as potential side effects of the respiratory failure syndrome was performed with 4 d old skin-breathing and 12 d old gill-breathing zebrafish. With respect to acute toxicity, post-embryonic 12 d larvae proved to be more sensitive than both embryos (FET) and adult zebrafish (AFT) to all test substances except for permethrin. Accumulation of chlorpyrifos, lindane and permethrin was 1.3- to 5-fold higher in 4 d old than in 12 d old zebrafish, suggesting that (intermediate) storage of substances in the yolk might reduce bioavailability and prevent metabolization, which could be a further reason for lower toxicity in 4 d than in 12 d old zebrafish. Whereas ziram and aniline showed no significant effect on the swimbladder, zebrafish exposed to chlorpyrifos, lindane and permethrin showed significantly deflated swimbladders in 12 d old larvae; in the case of aldicarb, there was a significant hyperinflation in 4 d old larvae. Swimbladder deflation in post-embryonic 12 d zebrafish larvae might be hypothesized as a reason for a lack of internal oxygen supplies during the respiratory failure syndrome, whereas in 4 d old embryos cholinergic hyperinflation of the swimbladder dominates over other effects. Regarding acute lethality, the study provides further evidence that the switch from transcutaneous to branchial respiration in post-embryonic zebrafish life-stages might be the reason for the higher sensitivity of juvenile and adult fish to neurotoxic substances.

Biomolecular modifications in the sacfry of Mogurnda adspersa in response to copper stress

Copper (Cu) is one of the most harmful contaminants in fresh-water systems. Fish larvae such as sacfry are particularly vulnerable to metals such as copper (Cu) due to a less-developed excretory organ system and permeable skin that can absorb metals directly from the water. However, the sublethal effects of metals on this life stage are not well understood. This study assessed the sublethal toxicity of Cu on purple-spotted gudgeon sacfry (PSG, Mogurnda adspersa). For this purpose, 96 h Cu toxicity bioassays were performed and toxic effects of Cu on PSG were measured at different levels of biological organization, from the individual (loss of equilibrium, wet weight), to tissue (chemical changes in retinal tissue composition) and molecular responses (whole body amino acid (AA) profiles). The EC₁₀ and EC₅₀ (ECx: effect concentration that affected X% of test organisms) were found to be 12 (9 - 15) µg Cu L^-1 and 22 (19 - 24) µg Cu L^-1, respectively. Copper stress caused a decrease in total amino acid content and changed the AA profile of PSG compared to the controls. Proton-induced X-ray emission (PIXE) mapping techniques showed accumulation of Cu in the retinal tissues disturbing the distribution of other elements such as zinc, sulfur, phosphorus and potassium. Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) microspectroscopy of control and Cu treated eye tissues revealed a change in protein secondary structure in retinal tissues in response to Cu accumulation, as well as decreased levels of the molecular retinal, consistent with the degradation of rhodopsin, a key protein in the visual sensory system. This is the first study to demonstrate the multi-level responses of PSG arising from exposure to environmentally realistic Cu concentrations and suggests that AA profiling can serve as a useful tool to assess the impacts of metals on fresh-water organisms.

Severity Classification of Clinical Signs and Defining the Moribund State as an Experimental Endpoint for Acute Toxicity Testing Using Japanese Medaka (Oryzias latipes)

Use of the moribund state as an endpoint for acute toxicity testing in fish is complicated by the lack of consensus about the sublethal signs that define the state or that can predict imminent death. Defining the moribund state in fish requires determination of the association between each observable sublethal sign and transition to imminent death. To establish a criterion for defining the moribund state in Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes), we determined death/clinical-sign ratios, defined as the proportion of fish with each clinical sign that transitioned to imminent death, for 13 clinical signs observed in individually housed fish exposed to one of two typical toxicants, three pharmaceuticals, two pesticides, and one metal. Also, the time from onset of each clinical sign to transition to imminent death (referred to as the survival time) was determined by continuous monitoring. Three of the observed clinical signs-immobility, lethargy, and immobility at the surface-were found to be indicators of the moribund state, with each of these signs having a death/clinical-sign ratio of 1.0. Evaluation of the survival time after onset of the other 10 signs enabled determination of whether timely euthanasia would be appropriate, thereby providing a means of reducing the suffering of laboratory fish in the period before death. Environ Toxicol Chem 2022;41:1089-1095. © 2022 SETAC.

Refining Procedures within Regulatory Toxicology Studies: Improving Animal Welfare and Data

Simple Summary

Before any new medicine can be administered to humans, or new chemical marketed, some tests using animals such as fish, mice, rats, rabbits, dogs, or monkeys are performed in order to satisfy the legal requirements of international regulatory and government agencies. These assess the potential for harmful side effects in humans or species found in the environment and to explore how the compound is processed within the body. The housing conditions and procedures performed (such as dosing of compounds and removal of small blood samples) are designed to minimize any pain, suffering, distress, or lasting harm that may be experienced by the animals. These refinements improve animal welfare but can also improve the data quality. Examples of new processes, technologies, or equipment that have been introduced within some UK facilities are shared in this article and provide opportunities to benefit many more animals undergoing testing across the world in the future.

Abstract

During the development of potential new medicines or agrochemicals, an assessment of the safety profile to humans and environmental species is conducted using a range of different in silico and in vitro techniques in conjunction with metabolism and toxicity studies using animals. The required studies are outlined within international regulatory guidelines which acknowledge and support the application of the 3Rs to reduce the number of animals used or to refine the procedures performed when these studies are deemed to be necessary. The continued development of new technologies and adoption of best-practice approaches to laboratory animal housing and study procedures has generated a series of refinements that can be incorporated into animal studies throughout the package. These refinements benefit the welfare of fish, mice, rats, rabbits, dogs, minipigs, and non-human primates (NHPs) whilst maintaining or improving data quality within general toxicology, metabolism, and other studies and can also bring efficiencies to processes that benefit study costs and timings. Examples are shared which cover the following topics: social housing of dogs and NHPs, surgical refinements in the rat bile duct cannulation model for collection of data for metabolism studies, whether fasting is really required prior to clinical pathology sampling, and the use of microsampling for toxicokinetics.