Electrochemical fabrication of pyramid-shape silver microstructure as effective and reusable SERS substrate

Advancements in reusable SERS substrates for trace analysis applications

Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS) technique is an effective analytical technique in which fingerprint information about analytes can be obtained, can provide detection limit performance at the single molecule level, and analyzes are performed in a single step without any intermediate steps. SERS technique offers additional benefits rather than other analytical techniques including high selectivity, ultrasensitive detection, uncomplicated protocols, in situ sampling, on-set capability and cost-effectiveness. As a result of the combination of developments in materials and nanotechnology science with the SERS analysis technique, this technique strengthens its use advantage day by day. The most important factor that limited the use of this technique was the fact that the solution containing the desired analyte(s) was dropped onto the SERS substrate and the same substrate could not be reused in subsequent analyses. To solve this problem, scientists have focused on developing reusable SERS substrates in recent years. In these studies, scientists basically used three SERS substrate cleaning applications (1) washing the SERS substrate with a suitable solvent that can elute the analyte from SERS surface after analysis, (2) cleaning the SERS substrate with catalytic degradation of analytes after analysis by modifying them with catalytic active materials and (3) Applying plasma cleaning procedure to SERS substrate after analysis and (4) applying adsorption and desorption procedure prior to SERS analysis. Herein, the aim of this review article is to evaluate the reusable SERS substrates-based methods based on their level of development and their potential to recycle. This review offers a coherent discussion on a wide range of sensing schemes employed in fabricating the SERS substrates. We utilized a critical approach in which elaborative examples were selected to highlight key shortcomings of various experimental configurations. In the same vein, there is a discussion of the advantages and limitations concerning the key instrumental advances and the expansion of the recent methods developed in this area.

Silver nanosheets self-assembled on polystyrene microspheres to form "hot spots" with different nanogap distances for high sensitive SERS detection

Herein, we reported a facile method to control the nanogap distance of silver (Ag) nanosheets to obtain high sensitive plasmonic Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) substrates. The sulfonated polystyrene (SPS) microspheres with different diameters were first fabricated using micro-emulsion synthesis, and then the SPS microspheres were coated with Ag nanosheets through chemical synthesis with citric acid/ascorbic acid to form Ag nanosheets@SPS (Ag@SPS) substrates with different nanogap distances. The results showed that the nanogap distance of Ag nanosheets self-assembled on SPS microspheres reduced from 80-150 nm to 28-68 nm when the diameter of SPS microspheres increased from 0.9 to 3.5 μm, and the enhancement factor (EF) increased from 105 to 107, the limit of detection of rhodamine 6G (R6G) for the Ag@SPS microspheres reduced from 10-10 to 10-13 mol/L. It confirmed that the Ag nanosheets coated on the surface of SPS microspheres could achieve ultra trace detection of analyte. Furthermore, the low concentration detection limit for melamine with the Ag@SPS microspheres substrate was about 10-8 mg/L, which is lower than the standard legislated by the European Union and the Food & Drug Administration. In addition, the SERS spectrum of 3-mercaptopropionic acid (3-MPA) could be also detected when its concentration was 10-8 mol/L. The prepared substrate offered a promising opportunity for SERS practical applications.

Label-free DNA detection using silver nanoprism decorated silicon nanoparticles: Effect of silicon nanoparticle size and doping levels

In the present work, we have fabricated silver nanoprism (AgNPrs)/silicon nanoparticle (SiNPs) hybrid arrays for highly sensitive detection of biomolecules via surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) technique. SiNPs having 7 to 37 nm in size and with phosphorous doping varying from 1 × 10¹⁹ to 1 × 10²⁰ cm^-3 were synthesized in nonthermal plasma synthesis. SiNPs were further immobilized on glass substrates using spin-coating, followed by deposition of AgNPrs using the drop-casting method. SERS studies showed that AgNPrs/SiNPs hybrid arrays exhibit substantial amplification of fingerprint bands of rhodamine 6G (R6G) compared to bare silicon as the reference. Raman signal intensity was found to be dependent on the size of SiNPs, with the largest nanoparticles exhibiting the highest SERS enhancement. In addition, an increase in phosphorous doping concentration was found to reduce R6G peak intensities. AgNPrs/SiNPs hybrid arrays showed excellent stability over time and high spot-to-spot reproducibility as well. Moreover, hybrid arrays enabled DNA detection through intense vibrational modes of human genomic DNA, with a lower detection limit of 1.5 pg/µL; indicating that AgNPrs/SiNPs sensors can serve as a reliable and cost-effective biosensing platform for rapid and label-free analysis of biomolecules.

Trends in Application of SERS Substrates beyond Ag and Au, and Their Role in Bioanalysis

This article compares the applications of traditional gold and silver-based SERS substrates and less conventional (Pd/Pt, Cu, Al, Si-based) SERS substrates, focusing on sensing, biosensing, and clinical analysis. In recent decades plethora of new biosensing and clinical SERS applications have fueled the search for more cost-effective, scalable, and stable substrates since traditional gold and silver-based substrates are quite expensive, prone to corrosion, contamination and non-specific binding, particularly by S-containing compounds. Following that, we briefly described our experimental experience with Si and Al-based SERS substrates and systematically analyzed the literature on SERS on substrate materials such as Pd/Pt, Cu, Al, and Si. We tabulated and discussed figures of merit such as enhancement factor (EF) and limit of detection (LOD) from analytical applications of these substrates. The results of the comparison showed that Pd/Pt substrates are not practical due to their high cost; Cu-based substrates are less stable and produce lower signal enhancement. Si and Al-based substrates showed promising results, particularly in combination with gold and silver nanostructures since they could produce comparable EFs and LODs as conventional substrates. In addition, their stability and relatively low cost make them viable alternatives for gold and silver-based substrates. Finally, this review highlighted and compared the clinical performance of non-traditional SERS substrates and traditional gold and silver SERS substrates. We discovered that if we take the average sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of clinical SERS assays reported in the literature, those parameters, particularly accuracy (93-94%), are similar for SERS bioassays on AgNP@Al, Si-based, Au-based, and Ag-based substrates. We hope that this review will encourage research into SERS biosensing on aluminum, silicon, and some other substrates. These Al and Si based substrates may respond efficiently to the major challenges to the SERS practical application. For instance, they may be not only less expensive, e.g., Al foil, but also in some cases more selective and sometimes more reproducible, when compared to gold-only or silver-only based SERS substrates. Overall, it may result in a greater diversity of applicable SERS substrates, allowing for better optimization and selection of the SERS substrate for a specific sensing/biosensing or clinical application.

Sensors for Detection of the Synthetic Dye Rhodamine in Environmental Monitoring Based on SERS

This article presents a review of many types of SERS sensors for food safety and environmental pollution monitoring based on detecting rhodamine. It introduces the basic concepts of substrates, enhancement factors, and mechanisms, devices' sensors integrated with the microstructure. Here, we review the state-of-the-art research in the field of rhodamine monitoring and highlight the applications of SERS sensors. The trends in the development of substrates for different applications have been mentioned with the aim of providing an overview of the development of different SERS substrates. Thus, an efficient approach for rhodamine detection has a good perspective for application in environmental monitoring.

Assembly of long silver nanowires into highly aligned structure to achieve uniform "Hot Spots" for Surface-enhanced Raman scattering detection

Silver nanowires (AgNWs) as a promising surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) substrate could be used in the analytical science due to its high sensitivity. However, it is difficult for the randomly-distributed silver nanowires to offer uniform "hot spots" to achieve the SERS signal reproducibility of small molecules detection. Herein, the evaporation-induced aggregation had been used to assemble long silver nanowires into highly aligned structure to achieve uniform "hot spots" for SERS detection. The normal glass slide with well-aligned silver nanowires could act as a high sensitivity and excellent reproducibility SERS substrate to provide a versatile platform for detecting analytes. Rhodamine 6G (R6G) is used to evaluate the sensitivity and reproducibility of these AgNWs SERS substrates. Even the low concentration of the R6G was 10^-10 mol/L, the SERS features of R6G could be still observed clearly, and the uniform distribution of enhancement factor (EF) was higher than 0.8 × 10⁴ accounting for about 75 % in the observed mapping area. Moreover, the relative standard deviation (RSD) of SERS intensity at the band of 610 cm^-1 was used to estimate the signal reproducibility, and the calculated RSD value of aligned AgNWs substrate was about 3.6%, which was much higher than that of the randomly distributed AgNWs (26.8%) because of the highly aligned structure of silver nanowires with abundant and uniform inherent "hot spots". In addition, potential SERS detection of other small molecule, e.g. melamine was also demonstrated in the micromolar range.

Recent Advances in Agglomeration Detection and Dual-Function Application of Surface-Enhanced Raman Scattering (SERS)

Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) has been widely utilized in early detection of disease biomarkers, cell imaging, and trace contamination detection, owing to its ultra-high sensitivity. However, it is also subject to certain application restrictions in virtue of its expensive detection equipment and long-term stability of SERS-active substrate. Recently, great progress has been made in SERS technology, represented by agglomeration method. Dual readout signal detection methods are combined with SERS, including electrochemical detection, fluorescence detection, etc., establishing a new fantastic viewpoint for application of SERS. In this review, we have made a comprehensive report on development of agglomeration detection and dual-function detection methods based on SERS. The synthesis methods for plasmonic materials and mainstream SERS enhancement mechanism are also summarized. Finally, the key facing challenges are discussed and prospects are addressed.

Facile Route to Effective Antimicrobial Aluminum Oxide Layer Realized by Co-Deposition with Silver Nitrate

The emergence and spreading of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has forced the focus of attention on a significant issue: the realization of antimicrobial surfaces for public spaces, which do not require extensive use of disinfectants. Silver represents one of the most used elements in this context, thanks to its excellent biocidal performance. This work describes a simple method for the realization of anodized aluminum layers, whose antimicrobial features are ensured by the co-deposition with silver nitrate. The durability and the chemical resistance of the samples were evaluated by means of several accelerated degradation tests, such as the exposure in a salt spray chamber, the contact with synthetic sweat and the scrub test, highlighting the residual influence of silver in altering the protective behavior of the alumina layers. Furthermore, the ISO 22196:2011 standard was used as the reference protocol to set up an assay to measure the effective antibacterial activity of the alumina-Ag layers against both Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus) and Gram-negative (Escherichia coli) bacteria, even at low concentrations of silver. Finally, the Ag-containing aluminum oxide layers exhibited excellent antimicrobial performances also following the chemical–physical degradation processes, ensuring good durability over time of the antimicrobial surfaces. Overall, this work introduces a simple route for the realization of anodized aluminum surfaces with excellent antibacterial properties.

A facile method in removal of PVP ligands from silver nanowires for high performance and reusable SERS substrate

Silver nanowires (i.e., AgNWs) can act as effective surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (i.e., SERS) substrates to detect small molecules. However, a lot of prepared AgNWs were often wrapped by polyvinylpyrrolidone (i.e., PVP) thin film to form an insulating layer to produce ill-defined AgNWs-PVP-AgNWs interface, limiting the plasmonic coupling among the stacked AgNWs. Herein, we reported a facile method in removal of PVP ligands from AgNWs for high performance and reusable SERS substrate. Sodium borohydride (NaBH₄) was used to completely remove the PVP ligands from the surface of AgNWs and produce a clean AgNWs-AgNWs interface that effectively enhances the localized surface plasmon resonance (i.e., LSPR) was produced, greatly improving the SERS activity of the AgNWs thin film. The SERS detection of rhodamine 6G (i.e., R6G) used with PVP AgNWs and without PVP AgNWs is 1.0 × 10^-9 and 1.0 × 10^-15 M, and the average enhancement factor (EF) is about 0.86 × 10⁴ and 9.35 × 10⁴, respectively. Moreover, the recyclable behavior of the AgNWs with several analyte molecules is much more interesting than that of the PVP@AgNWs. The SERS detection of AgNWs for R6G, the 3-mercaptopropionic acid (i.e., 3-MPA) and melamine with good recyclability in nanomolar and millimolar concentration can be easily detected.

Controlling Gold Electrodeposition on Porous Polymeric Templates Produced by the Breath-Figure Method: Fabrication of SERS-Active Surfaces

Porous structured surfaces decorated with gold nanoparticles can be fabricated in an economical two-step process. Sub-micrometric porous polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) templates are formed by using the breath-figure method (BFM) with a single-step spin-coating onto a conducting substrate to result in a set of delimited microdomains for gold electrodeposition. By controlling electrochemical parameters, distinct morphologies are engendered, among them, nanoparticles that present useful local Raman enhancement in the order of up to 10⁶ with stability of a solid-phase platform and characteristic chemical resistance of gold. The spatial confinement of metallic structures resulted in electromagnetic field enhancement, here compared to flat metallic surfaces where contributions of area effect and fluorescence quenching are responsible for a significant apparent enhancement to Raman spectra that has not been frequently reported to date.

Facile Fabrication of Micro/Nano Hierarchical SERS Sensor via Anisotropic Etching and Electrochemical Treatment for Malachite Green Detection

We propose a facile method to produce micro/nano hierarchical surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) active substrates using simple steps and inexpensive costs. The proposed SERS substrate is a silicon pyramid array covered by a nanostructured gold film (AuNS @ SiPA). Through finite element method (FEM) simulation, we showed that many strong local electric field enhancements (hot spots) were formed between the nano-gap of gold nanostructures. In addition, the micron-scale pyramid structure not only increases the sensing surface area of the sensor, but also helps trap light. By combining these micro and nano structures, the proposed micro/nano hierarchical SERS sensor exhibited high sensitivity. Experimental results confirmed that the AuNS @ SiPA substrate has high sensitivity. The SERS signal enhancement factor obtained from the Rhodamine 6G (R6G) probe molecules was as high as 1 × 107 and the SERS substrates were found to be able to detect a very low concentration of 0.01 nM malachite green (MG) solution. Therefore, this study provides a novel and practical method for fabricating SERS substrates that can facilitate the use of SERS in medicine, food safety, and biotechnology.

Suppression of coffee-ring effect via periodic oscillation of substrate for ultra-sensitive enrichment towards surface-enhanced Raman scattering

Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) has attracted extensive interest due to excellent molecule recognition and sensitive concentration detection. Nevertheless, the coffee ring effect (CR) during the analyte evaporation always causes an uneven distribution of the assembled hot-spots, and hence the unreliable SERS signal is produced. In this study, for the first time, we present a suppressed coffee ring (SCR) system via a combination of a magnetically functionalized membrane and reciprocating magnetic field to dynamically suppress the CR for highly reliable and ultra-sensitive SERS detection. The enrichment mechanism of the nanoparticles and the analyte molecules within the sessile droplet based on the proposed system was studied. We experimentally observed that the driving frequency could well affect the final pattern, and typically a higher driving frequency facilitated a smaller coverage area with better enrichment performance. With the use of R6G molecule and (100 nm) gold nanoparticles, we examined the uniformity and SERS of the assembled 'hot-spots' in the SCR system. The results indicate that the uniformity can be greatly improved via SCR in comparison of ring stain, with the RSD of a Raman signal as low as 7.1% even at a low concentration of 10^-12 mol L^-1. Such system also enables the further enhancement in the SERS signal, with the detection limit down to 10^-16 mol L^-1, the enhancement factor magnitude up to 10¹³, and the linear relationship between the SERS intensity and the analyte concentrations within the range of 10^-6-10^-12 and 10^-12-10^-16 mol L^-1, respectively. The applicability of the SCR-based SERS detection for diverse analytes was also proved with a similar but further enhanced signal of MB and 4-ATP. We believe that the excellent SCR-based SERS performance via the proposed system has great potentials for ultra-sensitive detection and/or precise quantitative analysis in various research fields and applications.

Morphology-Controlled Fabrication of Large-Scale Dendritic Silver Nanostructures for Catalysis and SERS Applications

Highly branched metallic nanostructures, which possess a large amount of catalyst active sites and surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) hot spots owing to their large surface areas, multi-level branches, corners, and edges, have shown potential in various applications including catalysis and SERS. In this study, well-defined dendritic silver (Ag) nanostructures were prepared by a facile and controllable electrochemical deposition strategy. The morphology of Ag nanostructures is controlled by regulating electrodeposition time and concentration of AgNO₃ in the electrolyte solution. Compared to conventional Ag nanoparticle films, dendritic Ag nanostructures exhibited larger SERS enhancement ascribed to the numerous hot spots exist in the nanogaps of parallel and vertically stacked multilayer Ag dendrites. In addition, the prepared dendritic Ag nanostructures show 3.2-fold higher catalytic activity towards the reduction of 4-nitrophenol (4-NP) by NaBH₄ than the Ag nanoparticle films. The results indicate that the dendritic Ag nanostructures represent a unique bifunctional nanostructure that serves as both efficient catalysts and excellent SERS substrates, which may be further employed as a nanoreactor for in situ investigation and real-time monitoring of catalytic reactions by SERS technique.

Biomimetic synthesis of Ag-coated glasswing butterfly arrays as ultra-sensitive SERS substrates for efficient trace detection of pesticides

In this work, we report a biomimetic synthesis route of 3D Ag nanofilm/glasswing butterfly wing hybrids (Ag-G.b.) by magnetron sputtering technology. The 3D surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) substrate is fabricated from an original chitin-based nanostructure, which serves as a bio-scaffold for Ag nanofilms to be coated on. The novel crisscrossing plate-like nanostructures of 3D Ag-G.b. nanohybrids with thick Ag nanofilms provide a substantial contribution to SERS enhancement. Measuring the SERS performance with crystal violet (CV), the Ag-G.b. nanohybrids with the sputtering time of 20 min (Ag-G.b.-20) shows the highest enhancement performance with an enhancement factor (EF) of up to 2.96 × 10⁷. The limit of detection (LOD) for CV was as low as 10^-11 M, demonstrating the ultrahigh sensitivity of the Ag-G.b.-20 substrate. In addition, the Ag-G.b.-20 substrate has an outstanding reproducibility across the entire area with the maximum value of relative standard deviation (RSD) of less than 10.78%. The nanohybrids also exhibit a long-term stability regarding Raman enhancement, as suggested by a duration stability test over a period of 60 days. Importantly, the high-performance Ag-G.b.-20 substrate is further applied as an ultra-sensitive SERS platform for the trace detection of acephate, showing its great potential application in biochemical sensing and food security.