Do Si/As ratios in growth medium affect arsenic uptake, arsenite efflux and translocation of arsenite in rice (Oryza sativa)?

Effect of inorganic arsenic in paddy soil on the migration and transformation of selenium species in rice plants

Selenium (Se) in paddy rice is one of the significant sources of human Se nutrition. However, the effect of arsenic (As) pollution in soil on the translocation of Se species in rice plants is unclear. In this research, a pot experiment was designed to examine the effect of the addition of 50 mg As/kg soil as arsenite or arsenate on the migration of Se species from soil to indica Minghui 63 and Luyoumingzhan. The results showed that the antagonism between inorganic As and Se was closely related to the rice cultivar and Se oxidation state in soil. Relative to the standalone selenate treatment, arsenite significantly (p < 0.05) decreased the accumulation of selenocystine, selenomethionine and selenate in the roots, stems, sheaths, leaves, brans and kernels of both cultivars by 21.4%-100.0%, 40.0%-100.0%, 41.0%-100%, 5.4%-96.3%, 11.3%-100.0% and 26.2%-39.7% respectively, except for selenocystine in the kernels of indica Minghui 63 and selenomethionine in the leaves of indica Minghui 63 and the stems of indica Luyoumingzhan. Arsenate also decreased (p < 0.05) the accumulation of selenocystine, selenomethionine and selenate in the roots, stems, brans and kernels of both cultivars by 34.9%-100.0%, 30.2%-100.0%, 11.3%-100.0% and 5.6%-39.6% respectively, except for selenate in the stems of indica Minghui 63. However, relative to the standalone selenite treatment, arsenite and arsenate decreased (p < 0.05) the accumulation of selenocystine, selenomethionine and selenite only in the roots of indica Minghui 63 by 45.5%-100.0%. Our results suggested that arsenite and arsenate had better antagonism toward Se species in selenate-added soil than that in selenite-added soil; moreover, arsenite had a higher inhibiting effect on the accumulation of Se species than arsenate.

Unveiling the significance of foliar-applied silicon, selenium and phosphorus for the management and remediation of arsenic in two different rice genotypes

Under paddy soil conditions, rice plants are vulnerable to arsenic (As) accumulation, thus causing potential threat to human health. Here we investigated the influence of foliar-applied phosphorus (P: 10 and 20 mg L-1), silicon (Si: 0.6 and 1.5 g L-1) and selenium (Se: 5 and 10 mg L-1) on As accumulation, morphological and physiological attributes of two contrasting rice genotypes (KSK-133 and Super Basmati) under As stress (25 mg kg-1 as arsenate). Silicon foliar dressing significantly (p < 0.05) reduced grain As uptake (up to 67%) and improved rice growth and chlorophyll content (28-66%) in both rice genotypes over their controls. Phosphorus foliar application resulted in a notable decrease (17%) in grain As uptake of coarse rice genotype (KSK-133), while it slightly increased grain As uptake in the fine one (Super Basmati; 6%) compared to controls. However, foliar-applied Se did not show significant effects on rice plants growth attributes and As uptake in both genotypes. Similarly, biochemical and enzymatic attributes (i.e., lipid peroxidation, electrolyte leakage, peroxidase and catalase) were improved with Si application in rice plants, except for P treatment that was only effective for coarse one. Foliar-applied Si also resulted in reduced cancer risk and hazard quotient (< 0.10) for both rice genotypes. This study advances our understanding on critical role of different foliar-applied nutrients and rice genotypes, which is imperative to develop effective As remediation and management strategies in coarse and fine rice genotypes and protect human health.

Enhanced As extraction from paddy soils with high As contamination risk by rice plant upon Si fertilization

Owing to flooded growing conditions and specific physiological characteristics, rice plant is more efficient in As uptake and accumulation, which provides a cost-effective and time-efficient pathway to deplete bioavailable As from paddy soils. In the present study, the enhancing effect of silicon (Si) fertilization on As extraction from heavily contaminated paddy soils by rice was explored Upon incorporation of one weak acid Si fertilizer (AcSF), soil As solubility was significantly promoted by 1.3-1.4-fold, while a slightly increase in porewater As was observed with alkaline soluble Si fertilizer Na2SiO3 (AlSF). With both Si fertilizers applied before transplanting, a relatively low Si/As molar ratio (<100) in soil porewater was obtained, As a result, soil As uptake by rice plant with Si fertilizers was enhanced by 37.2%-171.7% compared to control (CK). Notably, up to 91.6% of the total As in rice plant retained in root with Si fertilization, suggesting the importance of root removal. By harvesting the whole rice plant including roots, soil bioavailable As measured by diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) declined by 26.9%-31.3% in AlSF treatments relative to CK. Total soil As depletion by the whole rice plant was significantly enhanced from 2.8% in CK to 7.0%-11.2% in Si fertilizer treatments. In this way, 197.5 mg As m-2-232.5 mg As m-2 could be eliminated from soil following one rice-growth season, which was 2.3-2.7-fold higher compared to CK. These results identified the effectiveness of soluble Si fertilizer in enhancing soil As depletion by rice from paddy soils with high As contamination risk, which could serve as a cost-effective strategy with little technical-restriction.

Iron-based passivator mitigates the coupling process of anaerobic methane oxidation and arsenate reduction in paddy soils

Arsenic (As) is a toxic metalloid that is ubiquitous in paddy soils, where passivation is the most widely used method for remediating As contamination. Recently, anaerobic methane oxidation coupled with arsenate (As(V)) reduction (AOM-AsR) has been shown to act as a critical driver for As release in paddy fields. However, the effect and mechanism of the passivators on the AOM-AsR process remain unclear. In this study, we incubated arsenate-contaminated paddy soils under anaerobic conditions. Using isotopically labelled methane and different passivators, we found that an iron-based passivator containing calcium sulfate and iron oxide (9:1, m/m) named IBP showed a much better performance than the other passivators. Adding IBP decreased the arsenite (As(III)) concentration in the soil solution by 78% and increased the AOM rate by 55%. Furthermore, we employed high-throughput sequencing and real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) to investigate the ability of IBP to control As release mediated by AOM-AsR in paddy fields, as well as its underlying mechanism. Our results showed that IBP addition significantly increased anaerobic methanotrophic (ANME) archaea (ANME-2a-c, ANME-2d, and ANME-3) by 91%, and increased the methane-oxidizing bacterium Methylobacter by 262%. Similarly, IBP addition significantly increased the Fe(III) concentration in soil solution by 39% and increased the absolute abundance of Fe(III)-reducing bacteria (Geobacteraceae) by 21 times in soil. Adding IBP may significantly promote AOM coupled with Fe(III) reduction, significantly reducing electron transfer from AOM to As(V) reduction. Hence, IBP may be used as an efficient passivator to remediate As-contaminated soil using an active AOM-AsR process. These results provide a novel insight into controlling soil As release by regulating an active and critical As mobilization pathway in the environment.

Can As concentration in crop be controlled by Se fertilization? A meta-analysis and outline of As sequestration mechanisms

Arsenic (As) is a pollutant with a strong toxic effect on animals, plants and human beings. Exogenous selenium (Se) has been suggested to reduce the accumulation of As in crops, but contradictory results were found in the published literature. In order to clarify the possible processes, we collected the literature that reports on the effects of Se application on As uptake and accumulation in crops, analyzed the data by meta-analysis, and tested the effects of different factors on As accumulation by meta-regression model and subgroup analysis. The results highlighted a significant dose-dependent reduction of As content in crops after Se addition. Exogenous Se can significantly reduce As concentrations in grains by 18.76%. The reduction was dose-dependent for rice grains under aerobic soil conditions but not for rice grains under anoxic soil conditions. Se-enriched soils (greater than 0.5 mg kg^-1) significantly reduced As concentrations in grains. Selenium significantly decreased the transfer factor of As from root to shoot. Moreover, selenite had a stronger inhibiting effect on the transport of As from root to shoot than selenate. The inhibition of selenium fertilization on As concentrations seems to take place in root and soil, while physiological processes in rice may be involved in restricting uptake and transport from root to shoot. These findings provide new ideas for effectively alleviating the transfer of As to the human body through the food chain.

Sodium hydrosulfite together with silicon detoxifies arsenic toxicity in tomato plants by modulating the AsA-GSH cycle

The main intent of the current research was to appraise if combined application of hydrogen sulfide (H₂S, 0.2 mM) and silicon (Si 2.0 mM) could improve tolerance of tomato plants to arsenic (As as sodium hydrogen arsenate heptahydrate, 0.2 mM) stress. Plant growth, chlorophylls (Chl), PSII maximum efficiency (Fv/Fm), H₂S concentration and L-cysteine desulfhydrase activity were found to be suppressed, but leaf and root As, leaf proline content, phytochelatins, malondialdehyde (MDA) and H₂O₂ as well as the activity of lipoxygenase (LOX) increased under As stress. H₂S and Si supplied together or alone enhanced the concentrations of key antioxidant biomolecules such as ascorbic acid, and reduced glutathione and the activities of key antioxidant system enzymes including catalase (CAT), superoxide dismutase (SOD), dehydroascorbate reductase (DHAR), glutathione reductase (GR), and glutathione S-transferase (GST). In comparison with individual application of H₂S or Si, the joint supplementation of both had better effect in improving growth and key biochemical processes, and reducing tissue As content, suggesting a putative collaborative role of both molecules in improving tolerance to As-toxicity in tomato plants.

Rice seed (IR64) priming with potassium humate for improvement of seed germination, seedling growth and antioxidant defense system under arsenic stress

The intolerable levels of arsenic (As) in groundwater and its application in rice cultivation are continuously affecting the rice production in Ganga-Meghna-Brahmaputra (GMB) plain. The reduced germination and plant growth rates under excessive As stress ultimately lead to lower yield. To mitigate this concerning issue, the present study was carried out to evaluate the potential of K-humate priming on seed germination and plant growth under As stress. Seeds were primed with 100 mg/l K-humate for 12 h prior to germination. The germination percentages in unprimed seeds were 65 ± 5.0% and 58.3 ± 7.6% under stress level of 50 μM AsV and 50 μM AsIII, respectively. However, germination percentage in K-humate primed seeds were 75 ± 5.0% and 68.3 ± 2.9% under AsV and AsIII stress, respectively. The vigour index I (VG I) and vigour index II (VG II) recorded on 12 DAS (days after seeding) were also increased by 1.47 and 1.51 fold, respectively with K-humate supplementation under As stress. Detrimental effects of AsIII on seed germination, seedling growth and other physiological parameters were more suppressive than AsV. Application of K-humate not only improved seed germination, seedling growth and nutrient uptake but also decreased the oxidative stress markers and antioxidant activities by minimizing As uptake and translocation in the seedlings.

Different effects of foliar application of silica sol on arsenic translocation in rice under low and high arsenite stress

Foliar application of Si can generally reduce As translocation from roots to shoots in rice; however, it does not always work, particularly under high As stress. Here, the effects of foliar application of nanoscale silica sol on As accumulation in rice were investigated under low (2 μmol/L) and high (8 μmol/L) arsenite stress. The results revealed that foliar Si application significantly decreased the As concentration in shoots under low arsenite stress, but showed different effects under high arsenite stress after 7 days of incubation. The reduction in root-to-shoot As translocation under the 2As+Si treatment was related to the down-regulation of OsLsi1 and OsLsi2 expression and up-regulation of OsABCC1 expression in roots. In the 8As+Si treatment, the expressions of OsLsi1, OsLsi2, and OsABCC1 were significantly promoted, which resulted in substantially higher As accumulation in both the roots and shoots. In the roots, As predominantly accumulated in the symplasts (90.6%-98.3%), in which the majority of As was sequestered in vacuoles (79.0%-94.0%) under both levels of arsenite stress. Compared with that of the 8As treatment, the 8As+Si treatment significantly increased the As concentration in cell walls, but showed no difference in the vacuolar As concentration, which remained constant at approximately 69.1-71.7 mg/kg during days 4-7. It appeared that the capacity of root cells to sequester As in the vacuoles had a threshold, and the excess As tended to accumulate in the cell walls and transfer to the shoots via apoplasts under high arsenite stress. This study provides a better understanding of the different effects of foliar Si application on As accumulation in rice from the view of arsenite-related gene expression and As subcellular distribution in roots.

Emerging Trends in Metalloid-Dependent Signaling in Plants

Metalloids are semiconducting elements that constitute a small group in the periodic table of elements. Their occurrence in nature either poses an environmental threat or benefit to plants. The precise mechanisms or manner of crosstalk of metalloid interference and sensing remain open questions. Standard plant nutrient solutions contain the metalloid boron (B) as a micronutrient, while silicon (Si) is considered a beneficial element routinely supplied only to some plants such as grasses. By contrast, arsenic (As) is a severe environmental hazard to most organisms, including plants, while the less abundant metalloids germanium (Ge), antimony (Sb), and tellurium (Te) display variable degrees of toxicity. Here we review the molecular events and mechanisms that could explain the contrasting (or overlapping) action of metalloids on the cell and cell signaling.

Using rice as a remediating plant to deplete bioavailable arsenic from paddy soils

Rice plant is efficient in arsenic (As) accumulation due to enhanced soil As release under flooded condition and its effective As uptake. Therefore, rice plant can be used to remove bioavailable As from paddy soil. In this study, the depleting dynamics of soil As with rice growth was mapped two-dimensionally with the zirconium-oxide diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) technique. Further, the key biochemistry promoting soil As bioavailability was studied to better understand the underlying processes. Results revealed that the average DGT-As encompassing the root zone decreased steeply from 331 in the seedling stage to 136 in the heading & flowering stage and further to 118 μg l^-1 at harvest, which was 26% lower than that of the control at 160 μg l^-1. During this process, rhizosphere porewater As developed a dynamic profile similar to Fe and dissolved organic carbon, with the diversity of arrA gene peaking at heading & flowering stage. The data support soil As release from microbial reduction of Fe hydroxides fueled by root exudation as carbon source. Arsenic was mainly accumulated in the roots, accounting for up to 95% of total As in rice plants. Removal of rice roots resulted in ~19% lower DGT-As in post-harvest soil compared to without removing the roots. As a result, a sharp decline in As accumulation in rice plants was obtained in the second planting after removing one crop of rice roots. The results highlight that rice, as a paddy-adapted plant, is effective in As uptake in the roots, and thereby removing rice roots efficiently depletes bioavailable As from paddy soils.

Effects of zinc oxide nanoparticles on arsenic stress in rice (Oryza sativa L.): germination, early growth, and arsenic uptake

This study describes the role of zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs) in alleviating arsenic (As) stress in rice (Oryza sativa) germination and early seedling growth. Seeds of rice were primed with different concentrations (10, 20, 50, 100, and 200 mg L^-1) of ZnO NPs and As (0, and 2 mg L^-1) for 12 days in petri dishes. Two milligrams per liter of As treatment represented a stress condition, which was evidenced by germination rate, seedling length, seedling dry weight, chlorophyll, superoxide dismutase (SOD), catalase (CAT), and malondialdehyde (MDA) content of rice shoot. ZnO NPs amendment (10-100 mg L^-1) increased the germination rate (2.3-8.9%), shoot weight (18.2-42.4%), root weight (5.2-23.9%), and chlorophyll content (3.5-40.1%), while elevated the SOD (2.2-22.8%) and CAT (7.2-60.7%) activities and reduced the MDA content (17.5-30.8%). As concentrations were significantly decreased by 8.4-72.3% and 10.2-56.6%, respectively, in rice roots and shoots with ZnO NPs amendment (10-200 mg L^-1) by the As adsorption of ZnO NPs and promoted biomass of rice. All the amendments improved the Zn concentrations in rice shoots and roots. Overall, ZnO NPs provide effective resistance to arsenic toxicity by increasing germination, biomass, and nutrients of Zn and decreasing As uptake in rice.

Spraying silicon to decrease inorganic arsenic accumulation in rice grain from arsenic-contaminated paddy soil

Addition of Si to soil can reduce As uptake and accumulation in rice, while also enhancing As release from soil particles via competing sorption sites in soil minerals with As. Foliar application of Si might be an alternative pathway to reduce As accumulation in rice. It is not clear which growing stage would be better for spraying different types of Si solution to reduce inorganic As in edible parts of rice. Soil pot experiments were conducted to investigate whether total As and inorganic As accumulation in rice grains was alleviated via spraying Si in As-contaminated paddy soil. The results showed that foliar Si application at the tillering or jointing stage significantly reduced As concentrations in rice husks and grain via inhibiting the translocation of As from straw to husk or grain compared with other growing stages. Spraying of Si at the tillering stage markedly decreased the concentrations of inorganic As in rice bran and polished rice, accounting for 27.3% and 61.4% respectively. Furthermore, spraying Si solution mixed with surfactant-Tween 80 not only dramatically reduced the total As in rice tissues by 48.8%, but also significantly alleviated the accumulation of inorganic As in rice grain by 49.2%. Spraying Si restricted inorganic As in rice grain through the mechanism by which foliar Si application at tillering stage increased the Si concentrations in shoot and root, which downregulated Si transporters of Lsi1 and Lsi2 in the root and Lsi6 in the blade and sheath significantly, and finally decreased As uptake and transport. Therefore, spraying Si is an alternative and efficient pathway to reduce inorganic As accumulation of rice grain in As-contaminated soil.

Ultra-structure alteration via enhanced silicon uptake in arsenic stressed rice cultivars under intermittent irrigation practices in Bengal delta basin

The study implements a periodical intermittent water cycle during rice cultivation providing insight potential in minimizing soil bio-available arsenic. Soil As concentrations were 34 ± 0.49 and 72.03 ± 0.54 mg kg-1 As respectively in two selected fields with rice cultivars gosai and satabdi, in comparison to 42.26 ± 0.37 and 83.69 ± 0.48 mg kg-1 in continuously flooded field soil, determined through ICP-MS. The study found higher translocation of silicon from soil to rice plant parts under intermittent irrigation having pH range of 7.6-9.4 and greater availability of soil organic content that in turn release more labile silicon from soil to aqueous phase for plant accumulation. This increased uptake of silicon strengthens rice shoots, nodes and leaf xylem-phloem integrity compared to conventional continuously flooded rice cultivation approach, suppressing the arsenic translocation, as observed under FE-SEM real-time imaging. Fresh plants were analysed for bioaccumulation and translocation factors of arsenic and silicon to justify the enhanced silicon uptake under proposed practice. Plant stress regulator enzymes viz. malondialdehyde (MDA), total protein, superoxide dismutase (SOD), guaiacol peroxidase (GPX) and ascorbate peroxidase (APX) from both conditions and found to be better in intermittent method over conventional practice with higher productivity.

Monothioarsenate Uptake, Transformation, and Translocation in Rice Plants

Thioarsenates form under sulfur-reducing conditions in paddy soil pore waters. Sulfur fertilization, recently promoted for decreasing total arsenic (As) grain concentrations, could enhance their formation. Yet, to date, thioarsenate toxicity, uptake, transformation, and translocation in rice are unknown. Our growth inhibition experiments showed that the toxicity of monothioarsenate (MTA) was similar to that of arsenate but lower than that of arsenite. Higher toxicity of MTA with lower phosphate availability might imply uptake through phosphate transporters similar to arsenate. To demonstrate direct uptake of MTA by rice plants, a species-preserving extraction method for plant samples was developed. When plants were exposed to 10 μM MTA for 72 h, up to 19% and 4% of total As accumulated in roots and shoots, respectively, was MTA. Monothioarsenate was detected in xylem sap and root exudates, and its reduction to arsenite in rice roots and shoots was shown. Total As uptake was lower upon exposure to MTA compared to arsenate, but root to shoot translocation was higher, resulting in comparable As shoot concentrations. Thus, before promoting sulfur fertilization, uptake and detoxifying mechanisms of thioarsenates as well as potential contribution to grain As accumulation need to be better understood.