Evaluation of fatigability measurement: Integrative review

Cross-cultural translation, validation, and responsiveness of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale - Italian version (PFS-I) in a mixed-sample of older adults

INTRODUCTION

Older adults experience fatigue which impacts health-related quality of life. The Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale (PFS) was specifically designed to assess perceived physical and mental fatigability in older adults. The aim of this study was to translate the PFS into Italian (PFS-I) and to investigate its psychometric properties.

METHODS

The PFS-I was translated in accordance with international standards. The following properties were evaluated: structural validity, internal consistency, hypotheses testing for construct validity, test-retest reliability using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), and minimal clinically important difference (MCID) for responsiveness.

RESULTS

The study included 87 older adults with cardiovascular/respiratory diseases (CVRD), 46 with Parkinson disease (PD), and 67 healthy controls (HC). The PFS-I Physical and Mental subscales scores were significantly different in these populations, with HC reporting the lowest fatigability. Exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis showed a two-factor structure for both subscales, with good internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha: 0.86 and 0.89, respectively). The PFS-I Physical subscale showed weak goodness-of-fit of the confirmatory factor analysis models, whereas the PFS-I Mental subscale was deemed acceptable. Construct validity of the PFS-I was excellent with 75% (18 out of 24) of hypotheses accepted. Test-retest reliability was analyzed in a subset of 23 patients with CVRD and showed excellent results for both the PFS-I Physical and Mental subscales (ICC = 0.93 and 0.92, respectively). MCID ranged between 6 and 7 points for the Physical and 7-9 points for the Mental subscale.

CONCLUSIONS

The PFS-I is a valid, reliable, and responsive instrument to assess perceived fatigability for healthy older adults as well as those with CRVD and PD.

Effects of Energy Drink Consumption on Specific Cardiovascular and Psycho-Behavioral Parameters Among Medical Students at the University of Zakho

Background The consumption of energy drinks (EDs) among university students has become a prevalent trend, raising concerns about potential health risks. EDs are beverages containing various ingredients, most notably caffeine, taurine, and vitamins, that are consumed by the general public and athletes to reduce exhaustion, boost energy, and improve performance. Objectives This study aimed to investigate the prevalence of ED consumption and evaluate the effects of ED use on cardiovascular health and behavioral patterns in a sample of students at the University of Zakho. Methods This cross-sectional study involved a sample of 438 medical students aged 18-25 at the University of Zakho. Data were collected using a closed-ended questionnaire assessing socio-demographic characteristics, ED consumption habits, awareness of ED-related health risks, and cardiovascular measures such as blood pressure, pulse rate, presence of chest pain, and palpitation. Results The prevalence of consuming caffeine-content EDs was surprisingly high (70%, n=307) among the University of Zakho's medical students. Further categorization revealed that the prevalence was 42% (n=187) among low-frequency drinkers, 22.2% (n=95) among those who drank once a day, and 5.8% (n=25) among the frequent group. A higher percentage of ED drinkers (30%, n=92) developed tachycardia compared to students with a normal pulse (19.2%, n=59). Additionally, ED drinkers had significantly higher rates of elevated blood pressure (56.4%, n=173), palpitations (63.1%, n=194), and chest discomfort (73.2%, n=225) compared to non-drinkers (p <0.0001). Concerning behavioral characteristics, ED drinkers had a significantly higher rate of fatigability (79.3%, n=243) compared to non-drinkers (p <0.0001). They were more likely to experience somnolence (60.8%, n=187) compared to non-drinkers (p <0.05). Furthermore, the percentage of students with aggressive behavior was substantially higher (p <0.001) among ED drinkers (86.2%, n=265). Conclusion The findings collectively highlight the significant negative impact of energy drink consumption on health in general and cardiovascular and behavioral variables in particular. It also underscores the need for public health strategies and campus interventions to reduce ED consumption and raise awareness about their potential risks.

Fatigability-related oscillatory brain activity changes in people with MS

BACKGROUND

Fatigue, a multidimensional and challenging symptom associated with various underlying conditions, can manifest as a subjective feeling and a performance fatigability. The latter is often defined as an objectively measurable performance decline with time on task. Both syndromes are highly prevalent in people with multiple sclerosis (pwMS) and are often resistant to medical therapy. In the absence of valid and reliable objective parameters, the current cognitive fatigue diagnosis remains purely subjective. Assessing brain wave activity changes has repeatedly been a viable strategy for monitoring cognitive fatigue in healthy subjects. In this study, we aimed to investigate oscillatory brain activity changes and their associations with subjective fatigue in pwMS.

METHODS

We enrolled 21 pwMS and 21 healthy controls (HC) in this study. Subjects performed a sustained attention task divided into six blocks over the course of 30 minutes, and underwent resting state EEGs before and after the task. During the task, subjects were repeatedly asked to rate their subjective levels of mental fitness, mental exhaustion, and mind wandering. Using Linear Mixed Models, we explored fatigability-related changes by focusing on the time course of changes in reaction time variability, subjective ratings of fatigability, as well as frontomedial theta, and occipital alpha power. We further investigated initial and fatigability-induced differences between pwMS and HC at rest. Finally, Pearson correlations were used to examine the relationship between subjective fatigue and objective fatigability parameters.

RESULTS

Our results revealed a systematically stronger fatigability development in pwMS that was objectively measurable. PwMS reported lower mental fitness levels and demonstrated greater variability in reaction times with time on task. Occipital alpha power significantly increased during the task. Especially for upper alpha power, this increase was significantly more prominent in pwMS compared to HC. However, the time-on-task-induced changes in our study were not associated with the subjective fatigue ratings.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study expand the understanding of the neural mechanisms underlining cognitive fatigability and may complement the fatigue diagnosis and therapy monitoring with quantitative objective methods.

Prospective Associations Between Physical Activity and Perceived Fatigability in Older Men: Differences by Activity Type and Baseline Marital Status

BACKGROUND

Lower physical activity has been cross-sectionally associated with greater perceived fatigability, defined as self-reported fatigue anchored to activity intensity and duration. The temporality of this relationship, and whether it differs by activity type or marital status, remains unclear.

METHODS

In the Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study (N = 1 759), self-reported total, exercise, and household activity were assessed using the Physical Activity Scale for the Elderly across 7 visits (2000-2016). The Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale (range: 0-50; higher scores = greater fatigability) measured physical (mean = 16.6 ± 9.7) and mental (mean = 7.8 ± 8.3) fatigability at Year 14. Least absolute deviation and linear regression were used to examine associations between baseline and change in activity over 14 years with subsequent fatigability. Models were adjusted for demographic, health, and lifestyle factors.

RESULTS

After adjustment, lower baseline (β= -0.08, 95% confidence interval [CI]: -0.12, -0.04) and greater annual declines in total activity (β = -0.09, 95% CI: -0.14, -0.05) were prospectively associated with higher Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale (PFS) Physical scores. Associations were similar for mental fatigability (both p < .05). Lower baseline leisure exercise, but not baseline household activity, predicted higher PFS Physical scores (β = -0.10 vs -0.001). In contrast, greater declines in household activity, but not declines in exercise, were associated with higher PFS Physical scores (β = -0.09 vs -0.03). Lower baseline household activity predicted higher PFS Mental scores only for unmarried men (β = -0.15, 95% CI: -0.29, -0.01, interaction p = .019).

CONCLUSIONS

Baseline total activity and leisure exercise, and declines in total and household activity, were associated with higher subsequent perceived fatigability in older men. Marital status may mitigate the contribution of household activity to subsequent fatigability.

Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue Syndromes: A systematic review and meta-analysis of cardiorespiratory fitness and neuromuscular function compared with healthy individuals

OBJECTIVE

To determine cardiorespiratory fitness and neuromuscular function of people with CFS and FMS compared to healthy individuals.

DESIGN

Systematic review and meta-analysis.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Medline, CINAHL, AMED, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), and PEDro from inception to June 2022.

ELIGIBLE CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES

Studies were included if presenting baseline data on cardiorespiratory fitness and/or neuromuscular function from observational or interventional studies of patients diagnosed with FMS or CFS. Participants were aged 18 years or older, with results also provided for healthy controls. Risk of bias assessment was conducted using the Quality Assessment Tool for Quantitative Studies (EPHPP).

RESULTS

99 studies including 9853 participants (5808 patients; 4405 healthy controls) met our eligibility criteria. Random effects meta-analysis showed lower cardiorespiratory fitness (VO2max, anaerobic threshold, peak lactate) and neuromuscular function (MVC, fatigability, voluntary activation, muscle volume, muscle mass, rate of perceived exertion) in CFS and FMS compared to controls: all with moderate to high effect sizes.

DISCUSSION

Our results demonstrate lower cardiorespiratory fitness and muscle function in those living with FMS or CFS when compared to controls. There were indications of dysregulated neuro-muscular interactions including heightened perceptions of effort, reduced ability to activate the available musculature during exercise and reduced tolerance of exercise.

TRAIL REGISTRATION

PROSPERO registration number: (CRD42020184108).

Development of a Novel Accelerometry-Based Performance Fatigability Measure for Older Adults

INTRODUCTION

Efforts to study performance fatigability have been limited because of measurement constrains. Accelerometry and advanced statistical methods may enable us to quantify performance fatigability more granularly via objective detection of performance decline. Thus, we developed the Pittsburgh Performance Fatigability Index (PPFI) using triaxial raw accelerations from wrist-worn accelerometer from two in-laboratory 400-m walks.

METHODS

Sixty-three older adults from our cross-sectional study (mean age, 78 yr; 56% women; 88% White) completed fast-paced ( n = 59) and/or usual-paced 400-m walks ( n = 56) with valid accelerometer data. Participants wore ActiGraph GT3X+ accelerometers (The ActiGraph LLC, Pensacola, FL) on nondominant wrist during the walking task. Triaxial raw accelerations from accelerometers were used to compute PPFI, which quantifies percentage of area under the observed gait cadence-versus-time trajectory during a 400-m walk to a hypothetical area that would be produced if the participant sustained maximal cadence throughout the entire walk.

RESULTS

Higher PPFI scores (higher score = greater fatigability) correlated with worse physical function, slower chair stands speed and gait speed, worse cardiorespiratory fitness and mobility, and lower leg peak power (| ρ | = 0.36-0.61 from fast-paced and | ρ | = 0.28-0.67 from usual-paced walks, all P < 0.05). PPFI scores from both walks remained associated with chair stands speed, gait speed, fitness, and mobility, after adjustment for sex, age, race, weight, height, and smoking status; PPFI scores from the fast-paced walk were associated with leg peak power.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings revealed that the objective PPFI is a sensitive measure of performance fatigability for older adults and can serve as a risk assessment tool or outcome measure in future studies and clinical practice.

Translation and linguistic validation of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale for Korean breast cancer survivors: A cognitive interviewing study

Background

Fatigability-the perception of fatigue contextualized to activities of fixed intensity and duration-has received growing attention in oncology research.

Objectives

This study aimed to translate and linguistically validate a Korean-language version of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale.

Methods

Following the Linguistic Validation Manual for Health Outcome Assessment, we applied a multi-stage cognitive interviewing (CI) method to ensure accurate translation and interpretation of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale. After forward- and backward-translation were completed, three rounds of CI regarding the translated instrument were performed with 18 participants having or not having breast cancer.

Results

The first round of CI showed that seven items of the 10-item Korean-language instrument required revision to reflect the physical abilities of breast cancer patients with similar levels of physical activity. After the second round, two additional items were revised to reflect the cultural context and gender roles. During the third round, all participants exhibited full understanding of the Korean-language instrument.

Conclusions

The translated instrument, its quality enriched by cross-cultural linguistic validation in combination with CI, can be effectively used to assess perceived physical and mental fatigability.

Implications for Practice

Use of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale can facilitate oncology nurses' assessment of perceived fatigue levels in cancer patients and can expand understanding of how patients' fatigue perceptions are related to their exercise capacity.

Foundational

This study is valuable as an example of how a multi-stage CI process can be effectively applied in cross-cultural oncology research.

A neuro-metabolic account of why daylong cognitive work alters the control of economic decisions

Behavioral activities that require control over automatic routines typically feel effortful and result in cognitive fatigue. Beyond subjective report, cognitive fatigue has been conceived as an inflated cost of cognitive control, objectified by more impulsive decisions. However, the origins of such control cost inflation with cognitive work are heavily debated. Here, we suggest a neuro-metabolic account: the cost would relate to the necessity of recycling potentially toxic substances accumulated during cognitive control exertion. We validated this account using magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) to monitor brain metabolites throughout an approximate workday, during which two groups of participants performed either high-demand or low-demand cognitive control tasks, interleaved with economic decisions. Choice-related fatigue markers were only present in the high-demand group, with a reduction of pupil dilation during decision-making and a preference shift toward short-delay and little-effort options (a low-cost bias captured using computational modeling). At the end of the day, high-demand cognitive work resulted in higher glutamate concentration and glutamate/glutamine diffusion in a cognitive control brain region (lateral prefrontal cortex [lPFC]), relative to low-demand cognitive work and to a reference brain region (primary visual cortex [V1]). Taken together with previous fMRI data, these results support a neuro-metabolic model in which glutamate accumulation triggers a regulation mechanism that makes lPFC activation more costly, explaining why cognitive control is harder to mobilize after a strenuous workday.

Coordination between heart rate variability and physical activity may be diminished by fatigability in non-older women in the hour before sleep

Fatigability is related to several diseases as well as the autonomic nervous system. We investigated whether fatigability is associated with coordination between physical acceleration (PA) and parasympathetic nervous activity (PSNA) in women. Overall, 95 women were divided into non-old (n = 50; age: 22-59 years) and old (n = 45; age: ≥60 years) groups. PSNA and PA data were simultaneously obtained every minute for 24 h. We defined %lag0 as the percent ratio of lag = 0 min between PSNA and PA in 1 h. Cornell Medical Index was used to determine the degrees of physical and psychological symptoms. In the non-older group in the hour before sleep, the participants with high fatigability scores had significantly lower %lag0 than those with low fatigability (p < 0.05). Additionally, those with higher fatigability combined with exhaustion in the morning had significantly lower %lag0 than those without exhaustion in the hour before sleep (p < 0.05) but not in the hour after waking up. These results suggest that fatigability in non-older women was associated with loss of coordination between PSNA and PA in the hour before sleep. Additionally, exhaustion in the morning may be related to loss coordination of PSNA and PA during the previous night.

Evaluating Test-Retest Reliability of Fatigability in Chronic Stroke

OBJECTIVES

The subjective nature of fatigue may contribute to inconsistencies in prevalence rates for post-stroke fatigue. More objective performance fatigue measures may offer a more reliable construct of fatigue. Our goal was to establish test-retest reliability of fatigability in stroke during 6-minute walk (6MW) testing. Relationships between post-stoke fatigability and other constructs were assessed.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-three hemiparetic stroke survivors underwent two 6MW tests with portable metabolic monitoring performed at least 48 hours apart. Fatigability was defined as ratio of change in walking speed to distance covered during the 6MW. 6MW oxygen consumption (VO2), peak aerobic capacity (VO2peak), walking speed over-ground, dynamic gait index, fatigue, falls efficacy, and BMI were measured.

RESULTS

Fatigability was highly correlated between both 6MW trials (ICC = 0.99, p < 0.001) with no significant difference between trials (0.08, p = 0.48). The strongest correlation was between fatigability and 6MW VO2 trial 1 and 2 (r = 0.92, p < 0.001 and r = 0.95, p < 0.001, respectively). Moderate-to-strong relationships were observed between fatigability for 6MW and fastest-comfortable walking speed (r = -0.82 and -0.77), self-selected walking speed (r = -7.8 and -0.78), 6MW walking speed (r = -0.80 and 0.80, VO2peak (r = -0.47 and -0.48) (p < 0.001), and DGI (r = -0.70 and -0.68, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

This study establishes test-retest reliability for an objective measure of fatigue in stroke-related disability. The strong correlations between fatigability and other functional measures also provides insight into the contributors underlying fatigability in this population.

REGISTRATION

URL: http://www.clinicaltrials.gov. Unique identifier: NCT01322607.

Walking energetics and fatigue are associated with physical activity in people with knee osteoarthritis

BACKGROUND

Aberrant biomechanics may influence osteoarthritis-associated physical activity limitations. Our purpose was to evaluate the association of walking energetics, fatigue, and fatigability on physical activity in people with knee osteoarthritis. We hypothesized that using increased energy for walking, experiencing more fatigue, or being more fatigable are associated with less activity, and that fatigue and fatigability mediate the relationships between walking energetics and physical activity.

METHODS

We tested our hypothesis in 30 people with knee osteoarthritis (age 58 ± 9 years, 10 Male/20 Female). Physical activity was assessed using the University of California Los Angeles score. We used a six-minute walk test to predict VO₂max. Next we used a portable oxygen exchange system to measure relative energy used (100 * VO₂rate/VO₂max) and VO₂cost during walking at preferred speeds. We used the Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score subscale to quantify pain, and the Patient Reported Outcome Measurement Instrument System Fatigue survey and a treadmill-based fatigability test to assess fatigue and fatigability. Spearman correlations, regression, and mediation analysis were used to test our hypotheses.

FINDINGS

Greater energy used during walking, fatigue, and fatigability were all associated with lower physical activity (rho = -0.585 to -0.379, P = 0.001 to 0.043). These associations persisted when incorporating pain into the models. Fatigue and fatigability mediated the associations between walking energetics and physical activity.

INTERPRETATION

Walking energetics could be a useful target to promote physical activity in people with osteoarthritis. Further, the effect of walking energetics on physical activity may work through its impact on fatigability.

Psychometric properties of the Korean version of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale in breast cancer survivors

BACKGROUND

Fatigability has recently emerged in oncology as a concept that anchors patients' perceptions of fatigue to defined activities of specified duration and intensity. This study aimed to examine the psychometric properties of the Korean version of the Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale (K-PFS) for women with breast cancer.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study involved 196 women with breast cancer recruited from a tertiary hospital in Seoul, Korea. Reliability was evaluated using Cronbach's alpha, and confirmatory factor analysis was conducted to examine the factor structure of the K-PFS. Four goodness-of-fit values were evaluated: (1) the comparative fit index (CFI), (2) the Tucker-Lewis index (TLI), (3) the root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA), and (4) the standardized root mean square residual (SRMR).

RESULTS

Of the 196 survivors, 71.1% had greater physical fatigability (K-PFS Physical score ≥ 15) and 52.6% had greater mental fatigability (K-PFS Mental score ≥ 13). The Cronbach's alpha coefficient for the total K-PFS scale was 0.926, and the coefficients for the physical and mental fatigability domains were 0.870 and 0.864, respectively. In the confirmatory factor analysis for physical fatigability, the SRMR value (0.076) supported goodness of fit, but other model fit statistics did not (CFI = 0.888, TLI = 0.826, and RMSEA = 0.224). For mental fatigability, although three goodness-of-fit values were acceptable (CFI = 0.948, TLI = 0.919, and SRMR = 0.057), the RMSEA value (0.149) did not indicate good model fit. However, each item coefficient was statistically significant (> 0.5), and the K-PFS was therefore found to be valid from a theoretical perspective.

CONCLUSION

This study provides meaningful information on the reliability and validity of the K-PFS instrument, which was developed to meet an important need in the context of breast cancer survivors. Additional research should examine its test-retest reliability and construct validity with performance measures.

Measures of excess [Formula: see text]CO2 and recovery [Formula: see text]CO2 as indices of performance fatigability during exercise: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

The severity of performance fatigability and the capacity to recover from activity are profoundly influenced by skeletal muscle energetics, specifically the ability to buffer fatigue-inducing ions produced from anaerobic metabolism. Mechanisms responsible for buffering these ions result in the production of excess carbon dioxide (CO2) that can be measured as expired CO2 ([Formula: see text]CO2) during cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET). The primary objective of this study was to assess the feasibility of select assessment procedures for use in planning and carrying out interventional studies, which are larger interventional studies investigating the relationships between CO2 expiration, measured during and after both CPET and submaximal exercise testing, and performance fatigability.

METHODS

Cross-sectional, pilot study design. Seven healthy subjects (30.7±5.1 years; 5 females) completed a peak CPET and constant work-rate test (CWRT) on separate days, each followed by a 10-min recovery then 10-min walk test. Oxygen consumption ([Formula: see text]O2) and [Formula: see text]CO2 on- and off-kinetics (transition constant and oxidative response index), excess-[Formula: see text]CO2, and performance fatigability severity scores (PFSS) were measured. Data were analyzed using regression analyses.

RESULTS

All subjects that met the inclusion/exclusion criteria and consented to participate in the study completed all exercise testing sessions with no adverse events. All testing procedures were carried out successfully and outcome measures were obtained, as intended, without adverse events. Excess-[Formula: see text]CO2 accounted for 61% of the variability in performance fatigability as measured by [Formula: see text]O2 on-kinetic ORI (ml/s) (R2=0.614; y = 8.474x - 4.379, 95% CI [0.748, 16.200]) and 62% of the variability as measured by PFSS (R2=0.619; y =  - 0.096x + 1.267, 95% CI [-0.183, -0.009]). During CPET, [Formula: see text]CO2 -off ORI accounted for 70% (R2=0.695; y = 1.390x - 11.984, 95% CI [0.331, 2.449]) and [Formula: see text]CO2 -off Kt for 73% of the variability in performance fatigability measured by [Formula: see text]O2 on-kinetic ORI (ml/s) (R2=0.730; y = 1.818x - 13.639, 95% CI [0.548, 3.087]).

CONCLUSION

The findings of this study suggest that utilizing [Formula: see text]CO2 measures may be a viable and useful addition or alternative to [Formula: see text]O2 measures, warranting further study. While the current protocol appeared to be satisfactory, for obtaining select cardiopulmonary and performance fatigability measures as intended, modifications to the current protocol to consider in subsequent, larger studies may include use of an alternate mode or measure to enable control of work rate constancy during performance fatigability testing following initial CPET.

Aerobic capacity and fatigability are associated with activity levels in women with hip osteoarthritis

Physical activity is important for physical function and pain relief in people with lower extremity osteoarthritis (OA). Unfortunately, people with OA are not as active as their peers without OA. The objective of this study was to determine whether aerobic capacity and fatigability are associated with physical activity in women with hip OA. We conducted a cross-sectional analysis of 36 women with hip OA. We assessed aerobic fitness as predicted VO₂ max from a 6-min walk test. We assessed fatigability using a treadmill test. Finally, we assessed self-reported physical activity using the UCLA activity scale and quantified steps per day and activity intensity using accelerometers. We used Pearson correlations to determine associations. We used regression analysis to determine whether fatigability mediated the association between aerobic fitness and physical activity. On average, subjects were moderately active via the UCLA score (5.2 ± 1.3 out of 10). Aerobic fitness (R = 0.582, p < .001) and fatigability (R = 0.516, p =.003) were significantly correlated with UCLA scores. However, aerobic fitness was the best predictor of UCLA scores, as well as sedentary time, and time spent in light activity. Fatigability was not a mediator between aerobic fitness and UCLA scores. Aerobic fitness and fatigability may be modifiable barriers to physical activity in people with OA. Future interventional studies should examine whether improving aerobic fitness improves physical activity or fatigability.

Neuroimaging markers of chronic fatigue in older people: a narrative review

BACKGROUND

Chronic fatigue is a common symptom in older adults. Although some studies have attempted to identify the neuronal correlates of fatigue associated with chronic diseases, the scientific evidence is scarce regarding fatigue in older people not suffering from a specific disease.

AIMS

To gather available evidence of neuroimaging studies investigating the associations between fatigue and brain health in older adults out of the context of a specific disease, and to identify potential brain structures associated with this symptom.

METHODS

Studies considering exclusively patients with a specific disease and/or studies focusing on physiological mechanisms of acute fatigue induced by the realization of cognitive and physical tasks were excluded.

RESULTS

Very few studies on the associations of fatigue with neuroimaging markers are currently available. Fatigue was associated with reduced hippocampus volumes and with hippocampal amyloid deposition. Regarding the association between fatigue and the circuit of basal ganglia, putamen and thalamus were associated with physical fatigability, whereas amygdala and thalamus with mental fatigability. Very limited evidence about white matter integrity found that healthy individuals with high levels of fatigue had a greater total volume of leukoaraiosis.

CONCLUSION

This review suggests that hippocampus damage and potentially loss of function in basal ganglia networks could play a role on chronic fatigue during aging. Further studies are needed to assess the associations of fatigue with white matter alterations.

Carbon Dioxide Expiration and Performance Fatigability Following Aerobic Exercise Training: A Longitudinal, Observational, Pilot Study

Purpose

This study examined the influence of aerobic exercise training (AET) on components of carbon dioxide expiration (VCO2), cardiorespiratory function, and fatigability.

Methods

Twenty healthy adults completed peak cardiopulmonary exercise (CPX) and submaximal tests before and after a vigorous, 4-week AET regimen. Each test was followed by a 10-min recovery and endurance test at 70% of peak wattage attained during CPX. Fatigability was assessed using testing durations and power output. Respiratory buffering (excess VCO2) and non-buffering (metabolic VCO2) were calculated. Data were analyzed for significance (p<0.05) using regressions and paired t-tests.

Results

Significant improvements in all measures of fatigability were observed after AET. A significant increase in excess VCO2 was observed, though not in metabolic VCO2. Excess VCO2 was strongly predictive of fatigability measures.

Conclusion

Significant decreases in fatigability are often observed in clinical populations such as obstructive or restrictive lung disease or pulmonary hypertension following AET, even when peak cardiorespiratory function does not appear to adapt. Decreases in fatigability appear to predict longevity with no yet identified mechanism. These results suggest that respiratory buffering and metabolic components of VCO2 may adapt independently to AET, introducing foundational plausibility for an influence of respiratory buffering adaptation to AET on fatigability status.

Role of Respiratory Buffering in the Relationship Between Recovery and Performance Fatigability Following Aerobic Exercise Training: A Longitudinal, Observational, Pilot Study

Purpose:

This study characterized the influence of excess expired carbon dioxide (excess V̇co 2) in the relationship between recovery and fatigability.

Methods:

Twenty healthy adults completed peak cardiopulmonary exercise tests (CPXs) and constant work rate tests before and after a vigorous, 4-week aerobic exercise training (AET) regimen. Each test was followed by 10 minutes of recovery and an endurance test at 70% of peak watts attained during CPX. Fatigability was assessed by measures of time to exhaustion and power output. Metabolic and recovery capacity indices were obtained. Data were analyzed using correlations and regressions and compared pre/post AET using paired t tests.

Results:

Significant improvements in recovery and fatigability were observed after AET, along with significant increases in total and excess V̇co 2. Relationships between measures of recovery and fatigability were observed, although strengths of the relationships were diminished after controlling analyses for the effect of excess V̇co 2.

Conclusions:

This study suggests that the ionic buffering capacity may moderate the relationship between recovery and fatigability. These results could have implications regarding AET-induced buffering dynamics, and its role in fatigue resistance when performing activities above moderate intensities. This may be of particular importance in patients with cardiopulmonary complications, unable to improve peak aerobic capacity.

Epidemiology of Perceived Physical Fatigability in Older Adults: The Long Life Family Study

BACKGROUND

Fatigability is a construct that measures whole-body tiredness anchored to activities of a fixed intensity and duration; little is known about its epidemiology and heritability.

METHODS

Two generations of family members enriched for exceptional longevity and their spouses were enrolled (2006-2009) in the Long Life Family Study (LLFS). At Visit 2 (2014-2017, N = 2,355) perceived physical fatigability was measured using the 10-item self-administered Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale (PFS), along with demographic, medical, behavioral, physical, and cognitive risk factors.

RESULTS

Residual genetic heritability of fatigability was 0.263 (p = 6.6 × 10-9) after adjustment for age, sex, and field center. PFS physical scores (mean ± SD) and higher physical fatigability prevalence (% PFS ≥ 15) were greater with each age strata: 60-69 (n = 1,009, 11.0 ± 7.6, 28%), 70-79 (n = 847, 12.5 ± 8.1, 37%), 80-89 (n = 253, 19.3 ± 9.9, 65.2%), and 90-108 (n = 266, 28.6 ± 9.8, 89.5%), p < .0001, adjusted for sex, field center, and family relatedness. Women had a higher prevalence of perceived physical fatigability compared to men, with the largest difference in the 80-89 age strata, 74.8% versus 53.5%, p < .0001. Those with greater body mass index, worse physical and cognitive function, and lower physical activity had significantly higher perceived physical fatigability.

CONCLUSIONS

Perceived physical fatigability is highly prevalent in older adults and strongly associated with age. The family design of LLFS allowed us to estimate the genetic heritability of perceived physical fatigability. Identifying risk factors associated with higher perceived physical fatigability can inform the development of targeted interventions for those most at risk, including older women, older adults with depression, and those who are less physically active.

Chronic fatigue in myelodysplastic syndromes: Looking beyond anemia

Chronic fatigue is the most common and severe symptom in myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) and has a strong negative association with health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Despite anemia being the most common objective manifestation of MDS, and the associated link between anemia and fatigue, evidence on treatments which temporarily mitigate anemia is equivocal regarding the effects on fatigue. Furthermore, previous work has found weak associations between anemia and chronic fatigue in MDS. As such, given that improving HRQoL is one of the primary treatment aims in MDS, further work is required to identify other potential contributors to chronic fatigue in these patients. In addition to anemia, MDS is associated with numerous other deviations in physiological homeostasis and has negative psychological consequences with links to chronic fatigue. Accordingly, the present review provides several potential aetiologic agents relevant to chronic fatigue in MDS which can be used to guide future research in this field.

Translation and validation of the Dutch Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale for older adults

Background

The original Pittsburgh Fatigability Scale (PFS) was developed to assess perceived fatigability in older adults. The objective of this study was to translate the PFS into Dutch and investigate its validity and reliability among hospitalized older adults aged ≥70 years.

Methods

The PFS was translated into Dutch and pretested for comprehensibility by the Three-Step Test Interview method. The factor structure underlying the final version was evaluated by confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and exploratory factor analyses (EFA). Internal consistency of the identified subscales was evaluated by Cronbach’s alpha. Construct validity was evaluated by hypothesis testing. Test-retest reliability was evaluated using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) and Bland Altman plots.

Results

The validation sample included 233 patients. CFA of the original factor structure resulted in poor model fit in our Dutch sample. EFA of PFS physical and mental subscales resulted in a two-factor solution underlying the data with good internal consistency of the identified subscales (Cronbach’s alpha: 0.80–0.92). Five out of six hypotheses were confirmed, indicating good construct validity. Retest assessments were performed among 50 patients and showed good reliability for both the physical (ICC: 0.80, 95%CI: 0.68; 0.88) and mental subscale (ICC: 0.81, 95%CI: 0.68; 0.89).

Conclusion

The Dutch PFS is a valid and reliable instrument to assess fatigability in older hospitalized patients.

Using the NIH symptom science model to understand fatigue and mitochondrial bioenergetics

The symptom of fatigue is prevalent among patients with chronic diseases and conditions such as congestive heart failure and cancer. It has a significant debilitating impact on patients' physical health, quality of life, and well-being. Early detection and appropriate assessment of fatigue is essential for diagnosing, treating, and monitoring disease progression. However, it is often challenging to manage the symptom of fatigue without first investigating the underlying biological mechanisms. In this narrative review, we conceptualize the symptom of fatigue and its relationship with mitochondrial bioenergetics using the National Institute of Health Symptom Science Model (NIH-SSM). In particular, we discuss mental and physical measures to assess fatigue, the importance of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) in cellular and organ functions, and how impaired ATP production contributes to fatigue. Specific methods to measure ATP are described. Recommendations are provided concerning how to integrate biological mechanisms with the symptom of fatigue for future research and clinical practice to help alleviate symptoms and improve patients' quality of life.