Water oxidation electrocatalysis in acidic media with Co-containing polyoxometalates

Non-Noble-Metal-Based Electrocatalysts for Acidic Oxygen Evolution Reaction: Recent Progress, Challenges, and Perspectives

The oxygen evolution reaction (OER) plays a pivotal role in diverse renewable energy storage and conversion technologies, including water electrolysis, electrochemical CO2 reduction, nitrogen fixation, and metal-air batteries. Among various water electrolysis techniques, proton exchange membrane (PEM)-based water electrolysis devices offer numerous advantages, including high current densities, exceptional chemical stability, excellent proton conductivity, and high-purity H2. Nevertheless, the prohibitive cost associated with Ir/Ru-based OER electrocatalysts poses a significant barrier to the broad-scale application of PEM-based water splitting. Consequently, it is crucial to advance the development of non-noble metal OER catalysis substance with high acid-activity and stability, thereby fostering their widespread integration into PEM water electrolyzers (PEMWEs). In this review, a comprehensive analysis of the acidic OER mechanism, encompassing the adsorbate evolution mechanism (AEM), lattice oxygen mechanism (LOM) and oxide path mechanism (OPM) is offered. Subsequently, a systematic summary of recently reported noble-metal-free catalysts including transition metal-based, carbon-based and other types of catalysts is provided. Additionally, a comprehensive compilation of in situ/operando characterization techniques is provided, serving as invaluable tools for furnishing experimental evidence to comprehend the catalytic mechanism. Finally, the present challenges and future research directions concerning precious-metal-free acidic OER are comprehensively summarized and discussed in this review.

Charge Transfer Mechanism on a Cobalt-Polyoxometalate-TiO2 Photoanode for Water Oxidation in Acid

We constructed a photoanode comprising the homogeneous water oxidation catalyst (WOC) Na8K8[Co9(H2O)6(OH)3(HPO4)2(PW9O34)3] (Co9POM) and nanoporous n-type TiO2 photoelectrodes (henceforth "TiO2-Co9POM") by first anchoring the cationic 3-aminopropyltrimethoxysilane (APS) ligand on a metal oxide light absorber, followed by treatment of the metal oxide-APS with a solution of the polyoxometalate WOC. The resulting TiO2-Co9POM photoelectrode exhibits a 3-fold oxygen evolution photocurrent enhancement compared to bare TiO2 in aqueous acidic conditions. Three-element (Co 2p, W 4f, and O 1s) X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and Raman spectroscopy studies before and after use indicate that surface-bound Co9POM retains its structural integrity throughout all photoelectrochemical water oxidation studies reported here. Extensive charge-transfer mechanistic studies by photoelectrochemical techniques and transient absorption spectroscopy elucidate that Co9POM serves as an efficient WOC, extracting photogenerated holes from TiO2 on the picosecond time scale. This is the first comprehensive mechanistic investigation elucidating the roles of polyoxometalates in POM-photoelectrode hybrid oxygen evolution reaction systems.

Two Dimensional Ir-Based Catalysts for Acidic OER

Electrochemical water splitting in acidic media is one of the most promising hydrogen production technologies, yet its practical applications in proton exchange membrane (PEM) water electrolyzers are limited by the anodic oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Iridium (Ir)-based materials are considered as the state-of-the-art catalysts for acidic OER due to their good stability under harsh acidic conditions. However, their activities still have much room for improvement. Two-dimensional (2D) materials are full of the advantages of high-surface area, unique electrical properties, facile surface modification, and good stability, making the development of 2D Ir-based catalysts more attractive for achieving high catalytic performance. In this review, first, the unique advantages of 2D catalysts for electrocatalysis are reviewed. Thereafter, the classification, synthesis methods, and recent OER achievements of 2D Ir-based materials, including pure metals, alloys, oxides, and perovskites are introduced. Finally, the prospects and challenges of developing 2D Ir-based catalysts for future acidic OER are discussed.

Systematic Approach to the Synthesis of Cobalt-Containing Polyoxometalates for Their Application as Energy Storage Materials

New energy storage materials are an object of study within the framework of the global energy transition. The development of renewable sources is being boosted thanks to stationary energy storage systems such as redox flow batteries (RFBs). This work reports the synthesis of the cobalt-containing Keggin-type polyoxometalates [CoW₁₂O₄₀]^6- (CoW₁₂) and [Co(H₂O)SiW₁₁O₃₉]^6- (CoSiW₁₁), which have previously been shown to have applicability in RFBs. These procedures were reassessed to meet the strict requirements associated with the further implementation of RFBs, including fast and affordable synthetic procedures with high reaction yields. In contrast to the lengthy and complicated synthetic approaches published to date, the optimized synthesis reported in this work enables the isolation of the pure crystalline salt of the CoW₁₂ anion with a 75% reduction of the time of the whole reaction procedure, eliminating tedious steps such as the recrystallization and including a 20% increased yield. The control of the stoichiometry, fine-tuning of reaction conditions, and the identification of intermediate species, as well as the acidic equilibria taking place during the process, were monitored via thermal, spectroscopic, and structural analyses. In the case of the CoSiW₁₁ anion, its preparation was based on a simple and highly efficient procedure. Moreover, promising electrochemical properties were observed with the use of the one-pot synthetic approach, in which the stoichiometric amounts of the starting reagents are dissolved in the supporting electrolyte to be directly implemented as the electrolyte for a RFB.

Photoexcitation of Fe3 O Nodes in MOF Drives Water Oxidation at pH=1 When Ru Catalyst Is Present

Artificial photosynthesis strives to convert the energy of sunlight into sustainable, eco-friendly solar fuels. However, systems with light-driven water oxidation reaction (WOR) at pH=1 are rare. Broadly used [Ru(bpy)₃ ]²⁺ (bpy=2,2'-bipyridine) photosensitizer has a fixed +1.23 V potential which is insufficient to drive most water oxidation catalysts (WOCs) in acid, while Fe₂ O₃ , featuring the highly oxidizing holes, is not stable at low pH. Here, the key examples of Fe-based metal-organic framework (MOF) water oxidation photoelectrocatalysts active at pH=1 are presented. Fe-MIL-126 and Fe MOF-dcbpy structures were formed with 4,4'-biphenyl dicarboxylate (bpdc), 2,2'-bipyridine-5,5'-dicarboxylate (dcbpy) linkers and their mixtures. Presence of dcbpy linkers allows integration of metal-based catalysts via coordination to 2,2'-bipyridine fragments. Fe-based MOFs were doped with Ru-based precursors to achieve highly active MOFs bearing [Ru(bpy)(dcbpy)(H₂ O)₂ ]²⁺ WOC. Materials were analyzed with X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), Fourier transform infra-red (FTIR) spectroscopy, resonance Raman, X-ray absorption spectroscopy, fs optical pump-probe, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), diffuse reflectance and electric conductivity measurements and were modeled by band structure calculations. It is shown that under reaction conditions, Fe^III and Ru^III oxidation states are present, indicating rate-limiting electron transfer in MOF. Fe₃ O nodes emerge as photosensitizers able to drive prolonged O₂ evolution in acid. Further developments are possible via MOF's linker modification for enhanced light absorption, electrical conductivity, reduced MOF solubility in acid, Ru-WOC modification for faster WOC catalysis, or Ru-WOC substitution to 3d metal-based systems. The findings give further insight for development of light-driven water splitting systems based on Earth-abundant metals.

Ionic γ-FeO(OH) Nanocrystal Stabilized by Small Isopolymolybdate Clusters as Reactive Core for Water Oxidation

At near neutral to basic pH, hydrolysis-induced aggregation to insoluble bulk iron-oxide is often regarded as the pitfalls of molecular iron clusters. Iron-oxide nanocrystals are encouragingly active over the molecular clusters and/or bulk oxides albeit, stabilizing such nanostructures in aqueous pH and under turnover condition remain a perdurable challenge. Herein, an Anderson-type [Mo₇ O₂₄ ]^6- isopolyanion, a small (dimension ca. 0.85 nm) isolable polyoxometalate (POM) possessing only {31} atoms, has been introduced for the first time as a covalent linker to stabilize an infinitely stable and aqueous-soluble γ-FeO(OH) nanocore. During the hydrothermal isolation of the material, a partial dissociation of the parent [Mo₇ O₂₄ ]^6- may lead to the in situ generation of few analogous [Mo_x O_y ]^n- clusters, proved by Raman study, which can also participate in stabilizing the γ-FeO(OH) nanocore, Mo_x O_y @FeO(OH). However, due to high ionic charge on {Mo=O} terminals of the [Mo_x O_y ]^n- , they are covalently linked via Mo^VI -μ₂ O-Fe^III bridging to γ-FeO(OH) core in Mo_x O_y @FeO(OH), established by numerous spectroscopic and microscopic evidence. Such bonding mode is more likely as precedent from the coordination motif documented in the transition metal clusters stabilized by this POM. The γ-FeO(OH) nanocore of Mo_x O_y @FeO(OH) behaves as potent active center for electrochemical water oxidation with a overpotential, 263 mV @ 10 mA cm^-2 , lower than that observed for bare γ-FeO(OH). Despite of some molybdenum dissolution from the POM ligands to the electrolyte, residual anionic POM fragments covalently bound to the OER active γ-FeO(OH) core of the Mo_x O_y @FeO(OH) makes the surface predominantly ionic that results in an ordered electrical double layer to promote a better charge transport across the electrode-electrolyte junction, less likely in bulk γ-FeO(OH).

Surface Reconstruction of Cobalt-Based Polyoxometalate and CNT Fiber Composite for Efficient Oxygen Evolution Reaction

Polyoxometalates (POMs), as carbon-free metal-oxo-clusters with unique structural properties, are emerging water-splitting electrocatalysts. Herein, we explore the development of cobalt-containing polyoxometalate immobilized over the carbon nanotube fiber (CNTF) (Co4POM@CNTF) towards efficient electrochemical oxygen evolution reaction (OER). CNTF serves as an excellent electron mediator and highly conductive support, while the self-activation of the part of Co4POM through restructuring in basic media generates cobalt oxides and/or hydroxides that serve as catalytic sites for OER. A modified electrode fabricated through the drop-casting method followed by thermal treatment showed higher OER activity and enhanced stability in alkaline media. Furthermore, advanced physical characterization and electrochemical results demonstrate efficient charge transfer kinetics and high OER performance in terms of low overpotential, small Tafel slope, and good stability over an extended reaction time. The significantly high activity and stability achieved can be ascribed to the efficient electron transfer and highly electrochemically active surface area (ECSA) of the self-activated electrocatalyst immobilized over the highly conductive CNTF. This research is expected to pave the way for developing POM-based electrocatalysts for oxygen electrocatalysis.

Sustainable oxygen evolution electrocatalysis in aqueous 1 M H2SO4 with earth abundant nanostructured Co3O4

Earth-abundant electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) able to work in acidic working conditions are elusive. While many first-row transition metal oxides are competitive in alkaline media, most of them just dissolve or become inactive at high proton concentrations where hydrogen evolution is preferred. Only noble-metal catalysts, such as IrO₂, are fast and stable enough in acidic media. Herein, we report the excellent activity and long-term stability of Co₃O₄-based anodes in 1 M H₂SO₄ (pH 0.1) when processed in a partially hydrophobic carbon-based protecting matrix. These Co₃O₄@C composites reliably drive O₂ evolution a 10 mA cm^-2 current density for >40 h without appearance of performance fatigue, successfully passing benchmarking protocols without incorporating noble metals. Our strategy opens an alternative venue towards fast, energy efficient acid-media water oxidation electrodes.

Structurally Precise Two-Transition-Metal Water Oxidation Catalysts: Quantifying Adjacent 3d Metals by Synchrotron X-Radiation Anomalous Dispersion Scattering

Mixed 3d metal oxides are some of the most promising water oxidation catalysts (WOCs), but it is very difficult to know the locations and percent occupancies of different 3d metals in these heterogeneous catalysts. Without such information, it is hard to quantify catalysis, stability, and other properties of the WOC as a function of the catalyst active site structure. This study combines the site selective synthesis of a homogeneous WOC with two adjacent 3d metals, [Co₂Ni₂(PW₉O₃₄)₂]^10- (Co₂Ni₂P₂) as a tractable molecular model for CoNi oxide, with the use of multiwavelength synchrotron X-radiation anomalous dispersion scattering (synchrotron XRAS) that quantifies both the location and percent occupancy of Co (∼97% outer-central-belt positions only) and Ni (∼97% inner-central-belt positions only) in Co₂Ni₂P₂. This mixed-3d-metal complex catalyzes water oxidation an order of magnitude faster than its isostructural analogue, [Co₄(PW₉O₃₄)₂]^10- (Co₄P₂). Four independent and complementary lines of evidence confirm that Co₂Ni₂P₂ and Co₄P₂ are the principal WOCs and that Co²⁺(aq) is not. Density functional theory (DFT) studies revealed that Co₄P₂ and Co₂Ni₂P₂ have similar frontier orbitals, while stopped-flow kinetic studies and DFT calculations indicate that water oxidation by both complexes follows analogous multistep mechanisms, including likely Co-OOH formation, with the energetics of most steps being lower for Co₂Ni₂P₂ than for Co₄P₂. Synchrotron XRAS should be generally applicable to active-site-structure-reactivity studies of multi-metal heterogeneous and homogeneous catalysts.

Cobalt Phosphotungstate-Based Composites as Bifunctional Electrocatalysts for Oxygen Reactions

The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER) are key reactions in energy-converting systems, such as fuel cells (FCs) and water-splitting (WS) devices. However, the current use of expensive Pt-based electrocatalysts for ORR and IrO2 and RuO2 for OER is still a major drawback for the economic viability of these clean energy technologies. Thus, there is an incessant search for low-cost and efficient electrocatalysts (ECs). Hence, herein, we report the preparation, characterization (Raman, XPS, and SEM), and application of four composites based on doped-carbon materials (CM) and cobalt phosphotungstate (MWCNT_N8_Co4, GF_N8_Co4, GF_ND8_Co4, and GF_NS8_Co4) as ORR and OER electrocatalysts in alkaline medium (pH = 13). Structural characterization confirmed the successful carbon materials doping with N and/or N, S, and the incorporation of the cobalt phosphotungstate. Overall, all composites showed good ORR performance with onset potentials ranging from 0.83 to 0.85 V vs. RHE, excellent tolerance to methanol crossover with current retentions between 88 and 90%, and good stability after 20,000 s at E = 0.55 V vs. RHE (73% to 82% of initial current). In addition, the number of electrons transferred per O2 molecule was close to four, suggesting selectivity to the direct process. Moreover, these composites also presented excellent OER performance with GF_N8_Co4 showing an overpotential of 0.34 V vs. RHE (for j = 10 mA cm−2) and jmax close to 70 mA cm−2. More importantly, this electrocatalyst outperformed state-of-the-art IrO2 electrocatalyst. Thus, this work represents a step forward toward bifunctional electrocatalysts using less expensive materials.

Strategies for Electrochemically Sustainable H2 Production in Acid

Acidified water electrolysis with fast kinetics is widely regarded as a promising option for producing H2 . The main challenge of this technique is the difficulty in realizing sustainable H2 production (SHP) because of the poor stability of most electrode catalysts, especially on the anode side, under strongly acidic and highly polarized electrochemical environments, which leads to surface corrosion and performance degradation. Research efforts focused on tuning the atomic/nano structures of catalysts have been made to address this stability issue, with only limited effectiveness because of inevitable catalyst degradation. A systems approach considering reaction types and system configurations/operations may provide innovative viewpoints and strategies for SHP, although these aspects have been overlooked thus far. This review provides an overview of acidified water electrolysis for systematic investigations of these aspects to achieve SHP. First, the fundamental principles of SHP are discussed. Then, recent advances on design of stable electrode materials are examined, and several new strategies for SHP are proposed, including fabrication of symmetrical heterogeneous electrolysis system and fluid homogeneous electrolysis system, as well as decoupling/hybrid-governed sustainability. Finally, remaining challenges and corresponding opportunities are outlined to stimulate endeavors toward the development of advanced acidified water electrolysis techniques for SHP.

Oxygen Evolution Reaction Driven by Charge Transfer from a Cr Complex to Co-Containing Polyoxometalate in a Porous Ionic Crystal

Considerable efforts have been devoted to developing oxygen evolution reaction (OER) catalysts based on transition metal oxides. Polyoxometalates (POMs) can be regarded as model compounds of transition metal oxides, and cobalt-containing POMs (Co-POMs) have received significant interest as candidates. Nanocomposites based on Co-POMs have been reported to show high OER activities due to synergistic effects among the components; however, the role of each component is unclear due to its complex structure. Herein, we utilize porous ionic crystals (PICs) based on Co-POMs, which enable a composition-structure-function relationship to be established to understand the origin of the synergistic catalysis. Specifically, a Keggin-type POM [α-CoW₁₂O₄₀]^6- and a Cr complex [Cr₃O(OOCCH₂CN)₆(H₂O)₃]⁺ are implemented as PIC building blocks for the OER under nonbasic conditions. The potentially OER-active but highly soluble [α-CoW₁₂O₄₀]^6- was successfully anchored in the crystalline PIC matrix via Coulomb interactions and hydrogen bonding induced by polar cyano groups of the Cr complex. The PIC exhibits efficient and sustained OER catalytic activity, while each building block is inactive. The Tafel slope of the linear sweep voltammetry curve and the relatively large kinetic isotope effect value suggest that elementary steps closely related to the OER rate involve single-electron and proton transfer reactions. Electrochemical and spectroscopic studies clearly show that the synergistic catalysis originates from the charge transfer from the Cr complex to [α-CoW₁₂O₄₀]^6-; the increased electron density of [α-CoW₁₂O₄₀]^6- may increase its basicity and accelerate proton abstraction as well as enhance electron transfer to stabilize the reaction intermediates adsorbed on [α-CoW₁₂O₄₀]^6-.

Multiphase PdCu nanoparticles with improved C1 selectivity in ethanol oxidation

PdCu/CNT-300 catalysts with a mixed crystalline phase were successfully prepared. The introduction of Cu elements and the presence of a phase interface in the mixed phase facilitated electron transfer and increased the rate of the EOR.

Understanding polyoxometalates as water oxidation catalysts through iron vs. cobalt reactivity

Cobalt polyoxometalates (Co-POMs) have emerged as promising water oxidation catalysts (WOCs), with the added advantage of their molecular nature despite being metal oxide fragments. In comparison with metal oxides, that do not offer well-defined active surfaces, POMs have a controlled, discrete structure that allows for precise correlations between experiment and computational analyses. Thus, beyond highly active WOCs, POMs are also model systems to gain deeper mechanistic understanding on the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). The tetracobalt Weakley sandwich [CoII 4(H2O)2(B-α-PW9O34)2]10- (Co4-WS) has been one of the most extensively studied. We have compared its activity with that of the iron analog [FeIII 4(H2O)2(B-α-PW9O34)2]6- (Fe4-WS) looking for the electronic effects determining their activity. Furthermore, the effect of POM nuclearity was also investigated by comparison with the iron- and cobalt-monosubstituted Keggin clusters. Electrocatalytic experiments employing solid state electrodes containing the POMs and the corresponding computational calculations demonstrate that CoII-POMs display better WOC activity than the FeIII derivatives. Moreover, the activity of POMs is less influenced by their nuclearity, thus Weakley sandwich moieties show slightly improved WOC characteristics than Keggin clusters. In good agreement with the experimental data, computational methods, including pK a values, confirm that the resting state for Fe-POMs in neutral media corresponds to the S1 (FeIII-OH) species. Overall, the proposed reaction mechanism for Fe4-WS is analogous to that found for Co4-WS, despite their electronic differences. The potential limiting step is a proton-coupled electron transfer event yielding the active S2 (FeIV[double bond, length as m-dash]O) species, which receives a water nucleophilic attack to form the O-O bond. The latter has activation energies slightly higher than those computed for the Co-POMs, in good agreement with experimental observations. These results provide new insights for the accurate understanding of the structure-reactivity relationships of polyoxometalates in particular, and or metal oxides in general, which are of utmost importance for the development of new bottom-up synthetic approaches to design efficient, robust and non-expensive earth-abundant water oxidation catalysts.

Polyoxometalate modified transparent metal selenide counter electrodes for high-efficiency bifacial dye-sensitized solar cells

We present a facile one-step hydrothermal approach for the growth of PW₁₁Co/Co_0.85Se on a conductive glass substrate, which could be used as transparent CE in bifacial DSSCs with enhanced front and back efficiencies of 7.56% and 5.82%, respectively.