Pyruvate formate-lyase interacts directly with the formate channel FocA to regulate formate translocation

Role of the Escherichia coli FocA and FocB formate channels in controlling proton/potassium fluxes and hydrogen production during osmotic stress in energy-limited, stationary phase fermenting cells

Escherichia coli FocA and FocB formate channels export formate or import it for further disproportionation by the formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) complex to H2 and CO2. Here, we show that under pH and osmotic stress FocA and FocB play important roles in regulating proton and potassium fluxes and couple this with H2 production in stationary-phase cells. Using whole-cell assays with glucose as electron donor, a focB mutant showed a 50 % decrease in VH2, while N'N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) treatment of osmotically stressed cells underlined the role of FOF1 ATPase in H2 production. At pH 7.5 and under osmotic stress FocB contributed to the proton flux but not to the potassium flux. At pH 5.5 both formate channels contributed to the proton and potassium fluxes. Particulalry, a focA mutant had 40 % lower potassium flux whereas the proton flux increased approximately two-fold. Moreover, at pH 5.5H2 production was totally inhibited by DCCD in the focA mutant. Taken together, our results suggest that depending on external pH, the formate channels play an important role in osmoregulation by helping to balance proton/potassium fluxes and H2 production, and thus assist the proton FOF1-ATPase in maintenance of ion gradients in fermenting stationary-phase cells.

Spermidine constitutes a key determinant of motility and attachment of Salmonella Typhimurium through a novel regulatory mechanism

Spermidine is a poly-cationic molecule belonging to the family of polyamines and is ubiquitously present in all organisms. Salmonella synthesizes, and harbours specialized transporters to import spermidine. A group of polyamines have been shown to assist in Salmonella Typhimurium's virulence and regulation of Salmonella pathogenicity Inslad 1 (SPI-1) genes and stress resistance; however, the mechanism remains elusive. The virulence trait of Salmonella depends on its ability to employ multiple surface structures to attach and adhere to the surface of the target cells before invasion and colonization of the host niche. Our study discovers the mechanism by which spermidine assists in the early stages of Salmonella pathogenesis. For the first time, we report that Salmonella Typhimurium regulates spermidine transport and biosynthesis processes in a mutually inclusive manner. Using a mouse model, we show that spermidine is critical for invasion into the murine Peyer's patches, which further validated our in vitro cell line observation. We show that spermidine controls the mRNA expression of fimbrial (fimA) and non-fimbrial adhesins (siiE, pagN) in Salmonella and thereby assists in attachment to host cell surfaces. Spermidine also regulated the motility through the expression of flagellin genes by enhancing the translation of sigma-28, which features an unusual start codon and a poor Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Besides regulating the formation of the adhesive structures, spermidine tunes the expression of the two-component system BarA/SirA to regulate SPI-1 encoded genes. Thus, our study unravels a novel regulatory mechanism by which spermidine exerts critical functions during Salmonella Typhimurium pathogenesis.

The formate-hydrogen axis and its impact on the physiology of enterobacterial fermentation

Formic acid (HCOOH) and dihydrogen (H2) are characteristic products of enterobacterial mixed-acid fermentation, with H2 generation increasing in conjunction with a decrease in extracellular pH. Formate and acetyl-CoA are generated by radical-based and coenzyme A-dependent cleavage of pyruvate catalysed by pyruvate formate-lyase (PflB). Formate is also the source of H2, which is generated along with carbon dioxide through the action of the membrane-associated, cytoplasmically-oriented formate hydrogenlyase (FHL-1) complex. Synthesis of the FHL-1 complex is completely dependent on the cytoplasmic accumulation of formate. Consequently, formate determines its own disproportionation into H2 and CO2 by the FHL-1 complex. Cytoplasmic formate levels are controlled by FocA, a pentameric channel that translocates formic acid/formate bidirectionally between the cytoplasm and periplasm. Each protomer of FocA has a narrow hydrophobic pore through which neutral formic acid can pass. Two conserved amino acid residues, a histidine and a threonine, at the center of the pore control directionality of translocation. The histidine residue is essential for pH-dependent influx of formic acid. Studies with the formate analogue hypophosphite and amino acid variants of FocA suggest that the mechanisms of formic acid efflux and influx differ. Indeed, current data suggest, depending on extracellular formate levels, two separate uptake mechanisms exist, both likely contributing to maintain pH homeostasis. Bidirectional formate/formic acid translocation is dependent on PflB and influx requires an active FHL-1 complex. This review describes the coupling of formate and H2 production in enterobacteria.

Formate production is dispensable for Haemophilus ducreyi virulence in human volunteers

Haemophilus ducreyi is a causative agent of cutaneous ulcers in children who live in the tropics and of the genital ulcer disease chancroid in sexually active persons. In the anaerobic environment of abscesses and ulcers, anaerobic respiration and mixed acid fermentation (MAF) can be used to provide cellular energy. In Escherichia coli, MAF produces formate, acetate, lactate, succinate, and ethanol; however, MAF has not been studied in H. ducreyi. In human challenge experiments with H. ducreyi 35000HP, transcripts of the formate transporter FocA and pyruvate formate lyase (PflB) were upregulated in pustules compared to the inocula. We made single and double mutants of focA and pflB in 35000HP. Growth of 35000HPΔfocA was similar to 35000HP, but 35000HPΔpflB and 35000HPΔfocA-pflB had growth defects during both aerobic and anaerobic growth. Mutants lacking pflB did not secrete formate into the media. However, formate was secreted into the media by 35000HPΔfocA, indicating that H. ducreyi has alternative formate transporters. The pH of the media during anaerobic growth decreased for 35000HP and 35000HPΔfocA, but not for 35000HPΔpflB or 35000HPΔfocA-pflB, indicating that pflB is the main contributor to media acidification during anaerobic growth. We tested whether formate production and transport were required for virulence in seven human volunteers in a mutant versus parent trial between 35000HPΔfocA-pflB and 35000HP. The pustule formation rate was similar for 35000HP (42.9%)- and 35000HPΔfocA-pflB (62%)-inoculated sites. Although formate production occurs during in vitro growth and focA-pflB transcripts are upregulated during human infection, focA and pflB are not required for virulence in humans.

Perspective elucidating the physiology of a microbial cell: Neidhardt's Holy Grail

A living microbial cell represents a system of high complexity, integration, and extreme order. All processes within that cell interconvert free energy through a multitude of interconnected metabolic reactions that help to maintain the cell in a state of low entropy, which is a characteristic of all living systems. The study of macromolecular interactions outside this cellular environment yields valuable information about the molecular function of macromolecules but represents a system in comparative disorder. Consequently, care must always be taken in interpreting the information gleaned from such studies and must be compared with how the same macromolecules function in vivo, otherwise, discrepancies can arise. The importance of combining reductionist approaches with the study of whole-cell microbial physiology is discussed regarding the long-term aim of understanding how a cell functions in its entirety. This can only be achieved by the continued development of high-resolution structural and multi-omic technologies. It is only by studying the whole cell that we can ever hope to understand how living systems function.

Formate hydrogenlyase, formic acid translocation and hydrogen production: dynamic membrane biology during fermentation

Formate hydrogenlyase-1 (FHL-1) is a complex-I-like enzyme that is commonly found in gram-negative bacteria. The enzyme comprises a peripheral arm and a membrane arm but is not involved in quinone reduction. Instead, FHL-1 couples formate oxidation to the reduction of protons to molecular hydrogen (H₂). Escherichia coli produces FHL-1 under fermentative conditions where it serves to detoxify formic acid in the environment. The membrane biology and bioenergetics surrounding E. coli FHL-1 have long held fascination. Here, we review recent work on understanding the molecular basis of formic acid efflux and influx. We also consider the structure and function of E. coli FHL-1, its relationship with formate transport, and pay particular attention to the molecular interface between the peripheral arm and the membrane arm. Finally, we highlight the interesting phenotype of genetic mutation of the ND1 Loop, which is located at that interface.

Metabolic pathways and ΔpH regulation in Escherichia coli during the fermentation of glucose and glycerol in the presence of formate at pH 6.5: the role of FhlA transcriptional activator

Escherichia coli is able to ferment mixed carbon sources and produce various fermentation end-products. In this study, the function of FhlA protein in the specific growth rate (µ), metabolism, regulation of ΔpH and proton ATPase activity was investigated. Reduced µ in fhlA mutant of ∼25% was shown, suggesting the role of FhlA in the growth process. The utilization rate of glycerol is decreased in fhlA ∼ 2 fold, depending on the oxidation-reduction potential values. Bacteria regulate the activity of hydrogenase enzymes during growth depending on the external pH, which manifests as a lack of hydrogen gas generation during glycerol utilization at pH values below 5.9. It is suggested that cells maintain ΔpH during the fermentative growth via formate-lactate-succinate exchange. The decrement of the value of pHin, but not of pHex in mutant cells, is regulating ΔpH and consequently proton motive force generation.

FocA and its central role in fine-tuning pH homeostasis of enterobacterial formate metabolism

During enterobacterial mixed-acid fermentation, formate is generated from pyruvate by the glycyl-radical enzyme pyruvate formate-lyase (PflB). In Escherichia coli, especially at low pH, formate is then disproportionated to CO₂ and H₂ by the cytoplasmically oriented, membrane-associated formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) complex. If electron acceptors are available, however, formate is oxidized by periplasmically oriented, respiratory formate dehydrogenases. Formate translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane is controlled by the formate channel, FocA, a member of the formate-nitrite transporter (FNT) family of homopentameric anion channels. This review highlights recent advances in our understanding of how FocA helps to maintain intracellular formate and pH homeostasis during fermentation. Efflux and influx of formate/formic acid are distinct processes performed by FocA and both are controlled through protein interaction between FocA's N-terminal domain with PflB. Formic acid efflux by FocA helps to maintain cytoplasmic pH balance during exponential-phase growth. Uptake of formate against the electrochemical gradient (inside negative) is energetically and mechanistically challenging for a fermenting bacterium unless coupled with proton/cation symport. Translocation of formate/formic acid into the cytoplasm necessitates an active FHL complex, whose synthesis also depends on formate. Thus, FocA, FHL and PflB function together to govern formate homeostasis. We explain how FocA achieves efflux of formic acid and propose mechanisms for pH-dependent uptake of formate both with and without proton symport. We propose that FocA displays both channel- and transporter-like behaviour. Whether this translocation behaviour is shared by other members of the FNT family is also discussed.

The Loss of focA Gene Increases the Ability of Salmonella Enteritidis to Exit from Macrophages and Boosts Early Extraintestinal Spread for Systemic Infection in a Mouse Model

Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) can spread from the intestines to cause systemic infection, mainly involving macrophages. Intramacrophage Salmonella exits and reinfects neighboring cells, leading to severe disease. Salmonella genes involved in exiting from macrophages are not well understood or fully identified. A focA::Tn5 mutant was identified by an in vitro assay, with increased ability to exit from macrophages. A defined SEΔfocA mutant and its complemented derivative strain, SEΔfocA::focA, were constructed to confirm this phenotype. Although the lethal ability of focA mutants was similar to that of the parental SE in mice, it was isolated earlier from the liver and spleen than the parental SE. focA mutants induced higher levels of proinflammatory IL-12 and TNF-α compared with the parental SE and SEΔfocA::focA. focA mutants showed higher cytotoxicity and lower formate concentrations than SE and SEΔfocA::focA, whereas there was no change in pyroptosis, apoptosis and flagella formation ability. These current data suggest that the focA gene plays an important role in regulating intramacrophage Salmonella exiting and extraintestinal spread in mice, although the specific mechanism requires further in-depth studies.

Distinguishing functional from structural roles of conserved pore residues during formate translocation by the FocA anion channel

The formate‐specific anion channel FocA of Escherichia coli belongs to the superfamily of homopentameric formate‐nitrite transporters (FNT). Minimally nine amino acid residues are conserved in the formate translocation pore of each protomer of the pentamer, including a histidine (H209) and a threonine (T91), both of which are crucial for bidirectional formate translocation through the pore. Information regarding in vivo functional or structural roles for the other seven conserved residues is limited, or nonexistent. Here, we conducted an amino acid‐exchange analysis of these seven conserved residues. Using an established formate‐responsive lacZ‐based assay to monitor changes in intracellular formate levels and anaerobic growth rate due to the inhibitory formate analog hypophosphite, we identified five of the seven residues analyzed to be important for the structural integrity of the pentamer, in particular, two highly conserved asparagine residues, N213 and N262. The remaining two conserved residues, K156 and N172, were essential for formate/hypophosphite translocation. K156 is located on the periplasmic fringe of the pore and aids the attraction of formate to the channel. Here, we show that this residue is also important for formate efflux from the cytoplasm to the periplasm, suggesting a role in formate release from the pore. N172 could be replaced by alanine with retention of low‐level bidirectional anion translocation function; however, exchange for threonine abolished anion translocation. N172 is, therefore, crucial for bidirectional formate translocation, possibly through its interaction with the conserved pore residue, T91.

The FocA channel functions to maintain intracellular formate homeostasis during Escherichia coli fermentation

FocA translocates formate/formic acid bi-directionally across the cytoplasmic membrane when Escherichia coli grows by fermentation. It remains unclear, however, what physiological benefit is imparted by FocA, because formic acid (pK _a=3.75) can diffuse passively across the membrane, especially at low pH. Here, we monitored changes in intra- and extracellular formate levels during batch-culture fermentation, comparing a parental E. coli K-12 strain with its isogenic focA mutant. Our results show that, regardless of the initial pH in the culture, FocA functions to maintain relatively constant intracellular formate levels during growth. Analysis of a strain synthesizing a FocA_T91A variant with an exchange in a conserved threonine residue within the translocation pore revealed the strain accumulated formate intracellularly and imported formate poorly, but in a pH-dependent manner, which was different to uptake by native FocA. We conclude that FocA maintains formate homeostasis, using different mechanisms for efflux and uptake of the anion.

The Autonomous Glycyl Radical Protein GrcA Restores Activity to Inactive Full-Length Pyruvate Formate-Lyase In Vivo

During glucose fermentation, Escherichia coli and many other microorganisms employ the glycyl radical enzyme (GRE) pyruvate formate-lyase (PflB) to catalyze the coenzyme A-dependent cleavage of pyruvate to formate and acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA). Due to its extreme reactivity, the radical in PflB must be controlled carefully and, once generated, is particularly susceptible to dioxygen. Exposure to oxygen of the radical on glycine residue 734 of PflB results in cleavage of the polypeptide chain and consequent inactivation of the enzyme. Two decades ago, a small 14-kDa protein called YfiD (now called autonomous glycyl radical cofactor [GrcA]) was shown to be capable of restoring activity to O₂-inactivated PflB in vitro; however, GrcA has never been shown to have this function in vivo. By constructing a strain with a chromosomally encoded PflB enzyme variant with a G734A residue exchange, we could show that cells retained near-wild type fermentative growth, as well as formate and H₂ production; H₂ is derived by enzymatic disproportionation of formate. Introducing a grcA deletion mutation into this strain completely prevented formate and H₂ generation and reduced anaerobic growth. We could show that the conserved glycine at position 102 on GrcA was necessary for GrcA to restore PflB activity and that this recovered activity depended on the essential cysteine residues 418 and 419 in the active site of PflB. Together, our findings demonstrate that GrcA is capable of restoring in vivo activity to inactive full-length PflB and support a model whereby GrcA displaces the C-terminal glycyl radical domain to rescue the catalytic function of PflB. IMPORTANCE Many facultative anaerobic microorganisms use glycyl radical enzymes (GREs) to catalyze chemically challenging reactions under anaerobic conditions. Pyruvate formate-lyase (PflB) is a GRE that catalyzes cleavage of the carbon-carbon bond of pyruvate during glucose fermentation. The problem is that glycyl radicals are destroyed readily, especially by oxygen. To protect and restore activity to inactivated PflB, bacteria like Escherichia coli have a small autonomous glycyl radical cofactor protein called GrcA, which functions to rescue inactivated PflB. To date, this proposed function of GrcA has only been demonstrated in vitro. Our data reveal that GrcA rescues and restores enzyme activity to an inactive full-length form of PflB in vivo. These results have important implications for the evolution of radical-based enzyme mechanisms.

Hydrogen production in the presence of oxygen by Escherichia coli K-12

Escherichia coli is a facultative anaerobe that can grow in a variety of environmental conditions. In the complete absence of O₂, E. coli can perform a mixed-acid fermentation that contains within it an elaborate metabolism of formic acid. In this study, we use cavity-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (CERS), FTIR, liquid Raman spectroscopy, isotopic labelling and molecular genetics to make advances in the understanding of bacterial formate and H₂ metabolism. It is shown that, under anaerobic (anoxic) conditions, formic acid is generated endogenously, excreted briefly from the cell, and then taken up again to be disproportionated to H₂ and CO₂ by formate hydrogenlyase (FHL-1). However, exogenously added D-labelled formate behaves quite differently from the endogenous formate and is taken up immediately, independently, and possibly by a different mechanism, by the cell and converted to H₂ and CO₂. Our data support an anion-proton symport model for formic acid transport. In addition, when E. coli was grown in a micro-aerobic (micro-oxic) environment it was possible to analyse aspects of formate and O₂ respiration occurring alongside anaerobic metabolism. While cells growing under micro-aerobic conditions generated endogenous formic acid, no H₂ was produced. However, addition of exogenous formate at the outset of cell growth did induce FHL-1 biosynthesis and resulted in formate-dependent H₂ production in the presence of O₂.

A single amino acid exchange converts FocA into a unidirectional efflux channel for formate

During mixed-acid fermentation, Escherichia coli initially translocates formate out of the cell, but re-imports it at lower pH. This is performed by FocA, the archetype of the formate-nitrite transporter (FNT) family of pentameric anion channels. Each protomer of FocA has a hydrophobic pore through which formate/formic acid is bidirectionally translocated. It is not understood how the direction of formate/formic acid passage through FocA is controlled by pH. A conserved histidine residue (H209) is located within the translocation pore, suggesting that protonation/deprotonation might be linked to the direction of formate translocation. Using a formate-responsive lacZ-based reporter system we monitored changes in formate levels in vivo when H209 in FocA was exchanged for either of the non-protonatable amino acids asparagine or glutamine, which occur naturally in some FNTs. These FocA variants (with N or Q) functioned as highly efficient formate efflux channels and the bacteria could neither accumulate formate nor produce hydrogen gas. Therefore, the data in this study suggest that this central histidine residue within the FocA pore is required for pH-dependent formate uptake into E. coli cells. We also address why H209 is evolutionarily conserved and provide a physiological rationale for the natural occurrence of N/Q variants of FNT channels.

The soluble cytoplasmic N-terminal domain of the FocA channel gates bidirectional formate translocation

FocA belongs to the pentameric FNT (formate-nitrite transporter) superfamily of anion channels, translocating formate bidirectionally across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli and other microorganisms. While the membrane-integral core of FocA shares considerable amino acid sequence conservation with other FNT family members, the soluble cytoplasmic N-terminal domain does not. To analyze the potential biochemical function of FocA's N-terminal domain in vivo, we constructed truncation derivatives and amino acid-exchange variants, and determined their ability to translocate formate across the membrane of E. coli cells by monitoring intracellular formate levels using a formate-sensitive reporter system. Analysis of strains synthesizing these FocA variants provided insights into formate efflux. Strains lacking the ability to generate formate intracellularly allowed us to determine whether these variants could import formate or its toxic chemical analog hypophosphite. Our findings reveal that the N-terminal domain of FocA is crucial for bidirectional FocA-dependent permeation of formate across the membrane. Moreover, we show that an amino acid sequence motif and secondary structural features of the flexible N-terminal domain are important for formate translocation, and efflux/influx is influenced by pyruvate formate-lyase. The soluble N-terminal domain is, therefore, essential for bidirectional formate translocation by FocA, suggesting a "gate-keeper" function controlling anion accessibility.

Susceptibility of the Formate Hydrogenlyase Reaction to the Protonophore CCCP Depends on the Total Hydrogenase Composition

Fermentative hydrogen production by enterobacteria derives from the activity of the formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) complex, which couples formate oxidation to H2 production. The molybdenum-containing formate dehydrogenase and type-4 [NiFe]-hydrogenase together with three iron-sulfur proteins form the soluble domain, which is attached to the membrane by two integral membrane subunits. The FHL complex is phylogenetically related to respiratory complex I, and it is suspected that it has a role in energy conservation similar to the proton-pumping activity of complex I. We monitored the H2-producing activity of FHL in the presence of different concentrations of the protonophore CCCP. We found an inhibition with an apparent EC50 of 31 µM CCCP in the presence of glucose, a higher tolerance towards CCCP when only the oxidizing hydrogenase Hyd-1 was present, but a higher sensitivity when only Hyd-2 was present. The presence of 200 mM monovalent cations reduced the FHL activity by more than 20%. The Na+/H+ antiporter inhibitor 5-(N-ethyl-N-isopropyl)-amiloride (EIPA) combined with CCCP completely inhibited H2 production. These results indicate a coupling not only between Na+ transport activity and H2 production activity, but also between the FHL reaction, proton import and cation export.

Pseudo-Symmetric Assembly of Protodomains as a Common Denominator in the Evolution of Polytopic Helical Membrane Proteins

The polytopic helical membrane proteome is dominated by proteins containing seven transmembrane helices (7TMHs). They cannot be grouped under a monolithic fold or superfold. However, a parallel structural analysis of folds around that magic number of seven in distinct protein superfamilies (SWEET, PnuC, TRIC, FocA, Aquaporin, GPCRs) reveals a common homology, not in their structural fold, but in their systematic pseudo-symmetric construction during their evolution. Our analysis leads to guiding principles of intragenic duplication and pseudo-symmetric assembly of ancestral transmembrane helical protodomains, consisting of 3 (or 4) helices. A parallel deconstruction and reconstruction of these domains provides a structural and mechanistic framework for their evolutionary paths. It highlights the conformational plasticity inherent to fold formation itself, the role of structural as well as functional constraints in shaping that fold, and the usefulness of protodomains as a tool to probe convergent vs divergent evolution. In the case of FocA vs. Aquaporin, this protodomain analysis sheds new light on their potential divergent evolution at the protodomain level followed by duplication and parallel evolution of the two folds. GPCR domains, whose function does not seem to require symmetry, nevertheless exhibit structural pseudo-symmetry. Their construction follows the same protodomain assembly as any other pseudo-symmetric protein suggesting their potential evolutionary origins. Interestingly, all the 6/7/8TMH pseudo-symmetric folds in this study also assemble as oligomeric forms in the membrane, emphasizing the role of symmetry in evolution, revealing self-assembly and co-evolution not only at the protodomain level but also at the domain level.

Is the E. coli Homolog of the Formate/Nitrite Transporter Family an Anion Channel? A Computational Study

Formate/nitrite transporters (FNTs) selectively transport monovalent anions and are found in prokaryotes and lower eukaryotes. They play a significant role in bacterial growth and act against the defense mechanism of infected hosts. Because FNTs do not occur in higher animals, they are attractive drug targets for many bacterial diseases. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that they can be classified into eight subgroups, two of which belong to the uncharacterized YfdC-α and YfdC-β groups. Experimentally determined structures of FNTs belonging to different phylogenetic groups adopt the unique aquaporin-like hourglass helical fold. We considered the formate channel from Vibrio cholerae, the hydrosulphide channel from Clostridium difficile, and the uncharacterized channel from Escherichia coli (EcYfdC) to investigate the mechanism of transport and selectivity. Using equilibrium molecular dynamics and umbrella sampling studies, we determined temporal channel radius profiles, permeation events, and potential of mean force profiles of different substrates with the conserved central histidine residue in protonated or neutral form. Unlike the formate channel from V. cholerae and the hydrosulphide channel from C. difficile, molecular dynamics studies showed that the formate substrate was unable to enter the vestibule region of EcYfdC. Absence of a conserved basic residue and presence of acidic residues in the vestibule regions, conserved only in YfdC-α, were found to be responsible for high energy barriers for the anions to enter EcYfdC. Potential of mean force profiles generated for ammonia and ammonium ion revealed that EcYfdC can transport neutral solutes and could possibly be involved in the transport of cations analogous to the mechanism proposed for ammonium transporters. Although YfdC members belong to the FNT family, our studies strongly suggest that EcYfdC is not an anion channel. Absence or presence of specific charged residues at particular positions makes EcYfdC selective for neutral or possibly cationic substrates. Further experimental studies are needed to get a definitive answer to the question of the substrate selectivity of EcYfdC. This provides an example of membrane proteins from the same family transporting substrates of different chemical nature.

Energy-converting hydrogenases: the link between H2 metabolism and energy conservation

The reversible interconversion of molecular hydrogen and protons is one of the most ancient microbial metabolic reactions and catalyzed by hydrogenases. A widespread yet largely enigmatic group comprises multisubunit [NiFe] hydrogenases, that directly couple H₂ metabolism to the electrochemical ion gradient across the membranes of bacteria and of archaea. These complexes are collectively referred to as energy-converting hydrogenases (Ech), as they reversibly transform redox energy into physicochemical energy. Redox energy is typically provided by a low potential electron donor such as reduced ferredoxin to fuel H₂ evolution and the establishment of a transmembrane electrochemical ion gradient ([Formula: see text]). The [Formula: see text] is then utilized by an ATP synthase for energy conservation by generating ATP. This review describes the modular structure/function of Ech complexes, focuses on insights into the energy-converting mechanisms, describes the evolutionary context and delves into the implications of relying on an Ech complex as respiratory enzyme for microbial metabolism.

Understanding the NaCl-dependent behavior of hydrogen production of a marine bacterium, Vibrio tritonius

Biohydrogen is one of the most suitable clean energy sources for sustaining a fossil fuel independent society. The use of both land and ocean bioresources as feedstocks show great potential in maximizing biohydrogen production, but sodium ion is one of the main obstacles in efficient bacterial biohydrogen production. Vibrio tritonius strain AM2 can perform efficient hydrogen production with a molar yield of 1.7 mol H₂/mol mannitol, which corresponds to 85% theoretical molar yield of H₂ production, under saline conditions. With a view to maximizing the hydrogen production using marine biomass, it is important to accumulate knowledge on the effects of salts on the hydrogen production kinetics. Here, we show the kinetics in batch hydrogen production of V. tritonius strain AM2 to investigate the response to various NaCl concentrations. The modified Han-Levenspiel model reveals that salt inhibition in hydrogen production using V. tritonius starts precisely at the point where 10.2 g/L of NaCl is added, and is critically inhibited at 46 g/L. NaCl concentration greatly affects the substrate consumption which in turn affects both growth and hydrogen production. The NaCl-dependent behavior of fermentative hydrogen production of V. tritonius compared to that of Escherichia coli JCM 1649 reveals the marine-adapted fermentative hydrogen production system in V. tritonius. V. tritonius AM2 is capable of producing hydrogen from seaweed carbohydrate under a wide range of NaCl concentrations (5 to 46 g/L). The optimal salt concentration producing the highest levels of hydrogen, optimal substrate consumption and highest molar hydrogen yield is at 10 g/L NaCl (1.0% (w/v)).

Formate hydrogenlyase: A group 4 [NiFe]-hydrogenase in tandem with a formate dehydrogenase

Hydrogenase enzymes are currently under the international research spotlight due to emphasis on biologically produced hydrogen as one potential energy carrier to relinquish the requirement for 'fossil fuel' derived energy. Three major classes of hydrogenase exist in microbes all able to catalyze the reversible oxidation of dihydrogen to protons and electrons. These classes are defined by their active site metal content: [NiFe]-; [FeFe]- and [Fe]-hydrogenases. Of these the [NiFe]-hydrogenases have links to ancient forms of metabolism, utilizing hydrogen as the original source of reductant on Earth. This review progresses to highlight the Group 4 [NiFe]-hydrogenase enzymes that preferentially generate hydrogen exploiting various partner enzymes or ferredoxin, while in some cases translocating ions across biological membranes. Specific focus is paid to Group 4A, the Formate hydrogenlyase complexes. These are the combination of a six or nine subunit [NiFe]-hydrogenase with a soluble formate dehydrogenase to derived electrons from formate oxidation for proton reduction. The incidence, physiology, structure and biotechnological application of these complexes will be explored with attention on Escherichia coli Formate Hydrogenlyase-1 (FHL-1).

Formate Promotes Shigella Intercellular Spread and Virulence Gene Expression

Shigella is an intracellular pathogen that invades the human host cell cytosol and exploits intracellular nutrients for growth, enabling the bacterium to create its own metabolic niche. For Shigella to effectively invade and replicate within the host cytoplasm, it must sense and adapt to changing environmental conditions; however, the mechanisms and signals sensed by S. flexneri are largely unknown. We have found that the secreted Shigella metabolism by-product formate regulates Shigella intracellular virulence gene expression and its ability to spread among epithelial cells. We propose that Shigella senses formate accumulation in the host cytosol as a way to determine intracellular Shigella density and regulate secreted virulence factors accordingly, enabling spatiotemporal regulation of effectors important for dampening the host immune response.

The intracellular human pathogen Shigella flexneri invades the colon epithelium, replicates to high cell density within the host cell, and then spreads to adjacent epithelial cells. When S. flexneri gains access to the host cytosol, the bacteria metabolize host cytosolic carbon using glycolysis and mixed acid fermentation, producing formate as a by-product. We show that S. flexneri infection results in the accumulation of formate within the host cell. Loss of pyruvate formate lyase (PFL; ΔpflB), which converts pyruvate to acetyl coenzyme A (CoA) and formate, eliminates S. flexneri formate production and reduces the ability of S. flexneri to form plaques in epithelial cell monolayers. This defect in PFL does not decrease the intracellular growth rate of S. flexneri; rather, it affects cell-to-cell spread. The S. flexneri ΔpflB mutant plaque defect is complemented by supplying exogenous formate; conversely, deletion of the S. flexneri formate dehydrogenase gene fdnG increases host cell formate accumulation and S. flexneri plaque size. Furthermore, exogenous formate increases plaque size of the wild-type (WT) S. flexneri strain and promotes S. flexneri cell-to-cell spread. We also demonstrate that formate increases the expression of S. flexneri virulence genes icsA and ipaJ. Intracellular S. flexneriicsA and ipaJ expression is dependent on the presence of formate, and ipaJ expression correlates with S. flexneri intracellular density during infection. Finally, consistent with elevated ipaJ, we show that formate alters S. flexneri-infected host interferon- and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-stimulated gene expression. We propose that Shigella-derived formate is an intracellular signal that modulates virulence in response to bacterial metabolism.

Integrating Cross-Linking Experiments with Ab Initio Protein-Protein Docking

Ab initio protein-protein docking algorithms often rely on experimental data to identify the most likely complex structure. We integrated protein-protein docking with the experimental data of chemical cross-linking followed by mass spectrometry. We tested our approach using 19 cases that resulted from an exhaustive search of the Protein Data Bank for protein complexes with cross-links identified in our experiments. We implemented cross-links as constraints based on Euclidean distance or void-volume distance. For most test cases, the rank of the top-scoring near-native prediction was improved by at least twofold compared with docking without the cross-link information, and the success rate for the top 5 predictions nearly tripled. Our results demonstrate the delicate balance between retaining correct predictions and eliminating false positives. Several test cases had multiple components with distinct interfaces, and we present an approach for assigning cross-links to the interfaces. Employing the symmetry information for these cases further improved the performance of complex structure prediction.

Anaerobic Formate and Hydrogen Metabolism

Numerous recent developments in the biochemistry, molecular biology, and physiology of formate and H2 metabolism and of the [NiFe]-hydrogenase (Hyd) cofactor biosynthetic machinery are highlighted. Formate export and import by the aquaporin-like pentameric formate channel FocA is governed by interaction with pyruvate formate-lyase, the enzyme that generates formate. Formate is disproportionated by the reversible formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) complex, which has been isolated, allowing biochemical dissection of evolutionary parallels with complex I of the respiratory chain. A recently identified sulfido-ligand attached to Mo in the active site of formate dehydrogenases led to the proposal of a modified catalytic mechanism. Structural analysis of the homologous, H2-oxidizing Hyd-1 and Hyd-5 identified a novel proximal [4Fe-3S] cluster in the small subunit involved in conferring oxygen tolerance to the enzymes. Synthesis of Salmonella Typhimurium Hyd-5 occurs aerobically, which is novel for an enterobacterial Hyd. The O2-sensitive Hyd-2 enzyme has been shown to be reversible: it presumably acts as a conformational proton pump in the H2-oxidizing mode and is capable of coupling reverse electron transport to drive H2 release. The structural characterization of all the Hyp maturation proteins has given new impulse to studies on the biosynthesis of the Fe(CN)2CO moiety of the [NiFe] cofactor. It is synthesized on a Hyp-scaffold complex, mainly comprising HypC and HypD, before insertion into the apo-large subunit. Finally, clear evidence now exists indicating that Escherichia coli can mature Hyd enzymes differentially, depending on metal ion availability and the prevailing metabolic state. Notably, Hyd-3 of the FHL complex takes precedence over the H2-oxidizing enzymes.

Energetics and mechanism of anion permeation across formate-nitrite transporters

Formate-nitrite transporters (FNTs) facilitate the translocation of monovalent polyatomic anions, such as formate and nitrite, across biological membranes. FNTs are widely distributed among pathogenic bacteria and eukaryotic parasites, but they lack human homologues, making them attractive drug targets. The mechanisms and energetics involved in anion permeation across the FNTs have remained largely unclear. Both, channel and transporter mode of function have been proposed, with strong indication of proton coupling to the permeation process. We combine molecular dynamics simulations, quantum mechanical calculations, and pK _a calculations, to compute the energetics of the complete permeation cycle of an FNT. We find that anions as such, are not able to traverse the FNT pore. Instead, anion binding into the pore is energetically coupled to protonation of a centrally located histidine. In turn, the histidine can protonate the permeating anion, thereby enabling its release. Such mechanism can accommodate the functional diversity among the FNTs, as it may facilitate both, export and import of substrates, with or without proton co-transport. The mechanism excludes proton leakage via the Grotthuss mechanism, and it rationalises the selectivity for weak acids.

The C-terminal Six Amino Acids of the FNT Channel FocA Are Required for Formate Translocation But Not Homopentamer Integrity

FocA is the archetype of the pentameric formate-nitrite transporter (FNT) superfamily of channels, members of which translocate small organic and inorganic anions across the cytoplasmic membrane of microorganisms. The N- and C-termini of each protomer are cytoplasmically oriented. A Y-L-R motif is found immediately after transmembrane helix 6 at the C-terminus of FNT proteins related to FocA, or those with a role in formate translocation. Previous in vivo studies had revealed that formate translocation through FocA was controlled by interaction with the formate-producing glycyl-radical enzyme pyruvate formate-lyase (PflB) or its structural and functional homolog, TdcE. In this study we analyzed the effect on in vivo formate export and import, as well as on the stability of the homopentamer in the membrane, of successively removing amino acid residues from the C-terminus of FocA. Removal of up to five amino acids was without consequence for either formate translocation or oligomer stability. Removal of a sixth residue (R280) prevented formate uptake by FocA in a strain lacking PflB and significantly reduced, but did not prevent, formate export. Sensitivity to the toxic formate analog hypophosphite, which is also transported into the cell by FocA, was also relieved. Circular dichroism spectroscopy and blue-native PAGE analysis revealed, however, that this variant had near identical secondary and quaternary structural properties to those of native FocA. Interaction with the glycyl radical enzyme, TdcE, was also unaffected by removal of the C-terminal 6 amino acid residues, indicating that impaired interaction with TdcE was not the reason for impaired formate translocation. Removal of a further residue (L279) severely restricted formate export, the stability of the protein and its ability to form homopentamers. Together, these studies revealed that the Y₂₇₈-L₂₇₉-R₂₈₀ motif at the C-terminus is essential for bidirectional formate translocation by FocA, but that L279 is both necessary and sufficient for homopentamer integrity.

Exploring the directionality of Escherichia coli formate hydrogenlyase: a membrane-bound enzyme capable of fixing carbon dioxide to organic acid

During mixed‐acid fermentation Escherichia coli produces formate, which is initially excreted out the cell. Accumulation of formate, and dropping extracellular pH, leads to biosynthesis of the formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) complex. FHL consists of membrane and soluble domains anchored within the inner membrane. The soluble domain comprises a [NiFe] hydrogenase and a formate dehydrogenase that link formate oxidation directly to proton reduction with the release of CO₂ and H₂. Thus, the function of FHL is to oxidize excess formate at low pH. FHL subunits share identity with subunits of the respiratory Complex I. In particular, the FHL membrane domain contains subunits (HycC and HycD) that are homologs of NuoL/M/N and NuoH, respectively, which have been implicated in proton translocation. In this work, strain engineering and new assays demonstrate unequivocally the nonphysiological reverse activity of FHL in vivo and in vitro. Harnessing FHL to reduce CO₂ to formate is biotechnologically important. Moreover, assays for both possible FHL reactions provide opportunities to explore the bioenergetics using biochemical and genetic approaches. Comprehensive mutagenesis of hycC did not identify any single amino acid residues essential for FHL operation. However, the HycD E199, E201, and E203 residues were found to be critically important for FHL function.

The glycyl-radical enzyme 2-ketobutyrate formate-lyase, TdcE, interacts specifically with the formate-translocating FNT-channel protein FocA

Formate is a major product of mixed-acid fermentation in Escherichia coli. Because formate can act as an uncoupler at high concentration it must be excreted from the cell. The FNT (formate-nitrite transporter) membrane channel FocA ensures formate is translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane. Two glycyl-radical enzymes (GREs), pyruvate formate-lyase (PflB) and 2-ketobutyrate formate-lyase (TdcE), generate formate as a product of catalysis during anaerobic growth of Escherichia coli. We demonstrate in this study that TdcE, like PflB, interacts specifically with FocA. His-tagged variants of two other predicted GREs encoded in the genome of E. coli were over-produced and purified and were shown not to interact with FocA, indicating that interaction with FocA is not a general property of GREs per se. Together, these data show that only the GREs TdcE and PflB interact with the FNT channel protein and suggest that, like PflB, TdcE can control formate translocation by FocA.

•

2-ketobutyrate formate-lyase, TdcE, was purified as a chitin-binding protein fusion.

•

TdcE was shown to interact specifically with the formate channel protein FocA.

•

The predicted glycyl radical enzymes PflD and PflF do not interact with FocA.

•

Only glycyl enzymes that generate formate during catalysis interact with FocA.

The Model [NiFe]-Hydrogenases of Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, hydrogen metabolism plays a prominent role in anaerobic physiology. The genome contains the capability to produce and assemble up to four [NiFe]-hydrogenases, each of which are known, or predicted, to contribute to different aspects of cellular metabolism. In recent years, there have been major advances in the understanding of the structure, function, and roles of the E. coli [NiFe]-hydrogenases. The membrane-bound, periplasmically oriented, respiratory Hyd-1 isoenzyme has become one of the most important paradigm systems for understanding an important class of oxygen-tolerant enzymes, as well as providing key information on the mechanism of hydrogen activation per se. The membrane-bound, periplasmically oriented, Hyd-2 isoenzyme has emerged as an unusual, bidirectional redox valve able to link hydrogen oxidation to quinone reduction during anaerobic respiration, or to allow disposal of excess reducing equivalents as hydrogen gas. The membrane-bound, cytoplasmically oriented, Hyd-3 isoenzyme is part of the formate hydrogenlyase complex, which acts to detoxify excess formic acid under anaerobic fermentative conditions and is geared towards hydrogen production under those conditions. Sequence identity between some Hyd-3 subunits and those of the respiratory NADH dehydrogenases has led to hypotheses that the activity of this isoenzyme may be tightly coupled to the formation of transmembrane ion gradients. Finally, the E. coli genome encodes a homologue of Hyd-3, termed Hyd-4, however strong evidence for a physiological role for E. coli Hyd-4 remains elusive. In this review, the versatile hydrogen metabolism of E. coli will be discussed and the roles and potential applications of the spectrum of different types of [NiFe]-hydrogenases available will be explored.

Combining Amine-Reactive Cross-Linkers and Photo-Reactive Amino Acids for 3D-Structure Analysis of Proteins and Protein Complexes

During the last 15 years, the combination of chemical cross-linking and high-resolution mass spectrometry (MS) has matured into an alternative approach for analyzing 3D-structures of proteins and protein complexes. Using the distance constraints imposed by the cross-links, models of the protein or protein complex under investigation can be created. The majority of cross-linking studies are currently conducted with homobifunctional amine-reactive cross-linkers. We extend this "traditional" cross-linking/MS strategy by adding complementary photo-cross-linking data. For this, the diazirine-containing unnatural amino acids photo-leucine and photo-methionine are incorporated into the proteins and cross-link formation is induced by UV-A irradiation. The advantage of the photo-cross-linking strategy is that it is not restricted to lysine residues and that hydrophobic regions in proteins can be targeted, which is advantageous for investigating membrane proteins. We consider the strategy of combining cross-linkers with orthogonal reactivities and distances to be ideally suited for maximizing the amount of structural information that can be gained from a cross-linking experiment.

Comprehensive Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry Reveals Parallel Orientation and Flexible Conformations of Plant HOP2-MND1

The HOP2-MND1 heterodimer is essential for meiotic homologous recombination in plants and other eukaryotes and promotes the repair of DNA double-strand breaks. We investigated the conformational flexibility of HOP2-MND1, important for understanding the mechanistic details of the heterodimer, with chemical cross-linking in combination with mass spectrometry (XL-MS). The final XL-MS workflow encompassed the use of complementary cross-linkers, quenching, digestion, size exclusion enrichment, and HCD-based LC-MS/MS detection prior to data evaluation. We applied two different homobifunctional amine-reactive cross-linkers (DSS and BS(2)G) and one zero-length heterobifunctional cross-linker (EDC). Cross-linked peptides of four biological replicates were analyzed prior to 3D structure prediction by protein threading and protein-protein docking for cross-link-guided molecular modeling. Miniaturization of the size-exclusion enrichment step reduced the required starting material, led to a high amount of cross-linked peptides, and allowed the analysis of replicates. The major interaction site of HOP2-MND1 was identified in the central coiled-coil domains, and an open colinear parallel arrangement of HOP2 and MND1 within the complex was predicted. Moreover, flexibility of the C-terminal capping helices of both complex partners was observed, suggesting the coexistence of a closed complex conformation in solution.

Dissociation behavior of a bifunctional tempo-active ester reagent for peptide structure analysis by free radical initiated peptide sequencing (FRIPS) mass spectrometry

We have synthesized a homobifunctional active ester cross-linking reagent containing a TEMPO (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxy) moiety connected to a benzyl group (Bz), termed TEMPO-Bz-linker. The aim for designing this novel cross-linker was to facilitate MS analysis of cross-linked products by free radical initiated peptide sequencing (FRIPS). The TEMPO-Bz-linker was reacted with all 20 proteinogenic amino acids as well as with model peptides to gain detailed insights into its fragmentation mechanism upon collision activation. The final goal of this proof-of-principle study was to evaluate the potential of the TEMPO-Bz-linker for chemical cross-linking studies to derive 3D-structure information of proteins. Our studies were motivated by the well documented instability of the central NO-C bond of TEMPO-Bz reagents upon collision activation. The fragmentation of this specific bond was investigated in respect to charge states and amino acid composition of a large set of precursor ions resulting in the identification of two distinct fragmentation pathways. Molecular ions with highly basic residues are able to keep the charge carriers located, i.e. protons or sodium cations, and consequently decompose via a homolytic cleavage of the NO-C bond of the TEMPO-Bz-linker. This leads to the formation of complementary open-shell peptide radical cations, while precursor ions that are protonated at the TEMPO-Bz-linker itself exhibit a charge-driven formation of even-electron product ions upon collision activation. MS(3) product ion experiments provided amino acid sequence information and allowed determining the cross-linking site. Our study fully characterizes the CID behavior of the TEMPO-Bz-linker and demonstrates its potential, but also its limitations for chemical cross-linking applications utilizing the special features of open-shell peptide ions on the basis of selective tandem MS analysis.