Age- and Sex-Specific Nociceptive Response to Endothelin-1

Endothelin-1 enhances acid-sensing ion channel currents in rat primary sensory neurons

Endothelin-1 (ET-1), an endogenous vasoactive peptide, has been found to play an important role in peripheral pain signaling. Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are key sensors for extracellular protons and contribute to pain caused by tissue acidosis. It remains unclear whether an interaction exists between ET-1 and ASICs in primary sensory neurons. In this study, we reported that ET-1 enhanced the activity of ASICs in rat dorsal root ganglia (DRG) neurons. In whole-cell voltage-clamp recording, ASIC currents were evoked by brief local application of pH 6.0 external solution in the presence of TRPV1 channel blocker AMG9810. Pre-application with ET-1 (1−100 nM) dose-dependently increased the proton-evoked ASIC currents with an EC₅₀ value of 7.42 ± 0.21 nM. Pre-application with ET-1 (30 nM) shifted the concentration–response curve of proton upwards with a maximal current response increase of 61.11% ± 4.33%. We showed that ET-1 enhanced ASIC currents through endothelin-A receptor (ET_AR), but not endothelin-B receptor (ET_BR) in both DRG neurons and CHO cells co-expressing ASIC3 and ET_AR. ET-1 enhancement was inhibited by blockade of G-protein or protein kinase C signaling. In current-clamp recording, pre-application with ET-1 (30 nM) significantly increased acid-evoked firing in rat DRG neurons. Finally, we showed that pharmacological blockade of ASICs by amiloride or APETx2 significantly alleviated ET-1-induced flinching and mechanical hyperalgesia in rats. These results suggest that ET-1 sensitizes ASICs in primary sensory neurons via ET_AR and PKC signaling pathway, which may contribute to peripheral ET-1-induced nociceptive behavior in rats.

Endothelin Signaling Contributes to Modulation of Nociception in Early-stage Tongue Cancer in Rats

BACKGROUND

Patients with early stage tongue cancer do not frequently complain of tongue pain. Endothelin-1 signaling is upregulated in the cancerous tongue at the early stage. We tested the hypothesis that endothelin-1 signaling contributes to the modulation of tongue nociception.

METHODS

Squamous cell carcinoma cells were inoculated into the tongue under general anesthesia. Lingual mechanical sensitivity under light anesthesia using forceps from days 1 to 21 (n = 8) and the amounts of endothelin-1 and β-endorphin in the tongue on days 6, 14, and 21 (n = 5 to 7) were examined after the inoculation. The effect of endothelin-A or µ-opioid receptor antagonism on the mechanical sensitivity was examined (n = 5 to 7).

RESULTS

Lingual mechanical sensitivity did not change at the early stage (days 5 to 6) but increased at the late stage (days 13 to 14). The amount of endothelin-1 increased (25.4 ± 4.8 pg/ml vs. 15.0 ± 5.2 pg/ml; P = 0.008), and endothelin-A receptor antagonism in the tongue induced mechanical hypersensitivity at the early stage (51 ± 9 g vs. 81 ± 6 g; P = 0.0001). The µ-opioid receptor antagonism enhanced mechanical hypersensitivity (39 ± 7 g vs. 81 ± 6 g; P < 0.0001), and the amount of β-endorphin increased at the early stage.

CONCLUSIONS

β-Endorphin released from the cancer cells via endothelin-1 signaling is involved in analgesic action in mechanical hypersensitivity at the early stage.

Study of breakthrough cancer pain in an animal model induced by endothelin-1

Cancer patients with bone metastases often suffer breakthrough pain. However, little progress has been made in the treatment of breakthrough pain and its associated mechanism(s) in the patient with cancer due to lacking of resembling and predictive animal models. We previously have demonstrated that endothelin-1 plays an important role in breakthrough cancer pain. In the present study, we have established an animal model of breakthrough cancer pain induced by endothelin-1. The animal model of breakthrough cancer pain is strictly followed the definition and meets the characteristics of breakthrough pain. The model is reliable, reproducible and easy to be produced. To our knowledge, this is the first report for establishing such an animal model. In addition, we also found that a selective ETA receptor antagonist BQ-123 could reverse endothelin-1 induced breakthrough pain. We further studied the characteristics of pain behaviors such as hind limb use score and voluntary wheel running as well as the electrophysiology of sciatic nerve fibers with the model. The murine model shows high resemblance compared to the breakthrough cancer pain in the patients with cancer clinically. It provides a platform for further study of the pathogenesis of breakthrough cancer pain and targeted intervention.

Modulation of pain in pediatric sickle cell disease: understanding the balance between endothelin mediated vasoconstriction and apelin mediated vasodilation

Children with sickle cell disease (SCD) have painful vaso-occlusive episodes (VOEs), which often reoccur across the individual's lifespan. Vaso-constrictive and vaso-dilatory molecules have been hypothesized to play a role in VOEs. Endothelin-1 (ET-1) is a potent vasoconstrictor that is released during VOEs and is correlated with pain history. Apelin is a vaso-dilatory peptide that also has a modulatory role in pain processing. We hypothesize that the ratio between vaso-dilatory and vaso-constrictive tone in children with SCD may be a marker of pain sensitization and vaso-occlusion. Plasma endothelin and apelin levels were measured in 47 children with SCD. Procedural pain and baseline pain were assessed via child- and caregiver-reports and observational distress. Pain history was assessed using retrospective chart review. Plasma apelin was related to age, with decreased levels in older children. The ratio between apelin and ET-1 was negatively correlated to observational baseline pain. The ratio between apelin and Big ET was negatively correlated to caregiver ratings of baseline pain and positively correlated to history of VOEs, which is possibly due to hydroxyurea treatment. These results suggest that an imbalance in the apelin and endothelin systems may contribute to an increasing number of VOEs and baseline pain in children with SCD.

Evidence for the endothelin system as an emerging therapeutic target for the treatment of chronic pain

Many people worldwide suffer from pain and a portion of these sufferers are diagnosed with a chronic pain condition. The management of chronic pain continues to be a challenge, and despite taking prescribed medication for pain, patients continue to have pain of moderate severity. Current pain therapies are often inadequate, with side effects that limit medication adherence. There is a need to identify novel therapeutic targets for the management of chronic pain. One potential candidate for the treatment of chronic pain is therapies aimed at modulating the vasoactive peptide endothelin-1. In addition to vasoactive properties, endothelin-1 has been implicated in pain transmission in both humans and animal models of nociception. Endothelin-1 directly activates nociceptors and potentiates the effect of other algogens, including capsaicin, formalin, and arachidonic acid. In addition, endothelin-1 has been shown to be involved in inflammatory pain, cancer pain, neuropathic pain, diabetic neuropathy, and pain associated with sickle cell disease. Therefore, endothelin-1 may prove a novel therapeutic target for the relief of many types of chronic pain.

Interactions between glia, the immune system and pain processes during early development

Pain is a serious problem for infants and children and treatment options are limited. Moreover, infants born prematurely or hospitalized for illness likely have concurrent infection that activates the immune system. It is now recognized that the immune system in general and glia in particular influence neurotransmission and that the neural bases of pain are intimately connected to immune function. We know that injuries that induce pain activate immune function and suppressing the immune system alleviates pain. Despite this advance in our understanding, virtually nothing is known of the role that the immune system plays in pain processing in infants and children, even though pain is a serious clinical issue in pediatric medicine. This brief review summarizes the existing data on immune-neural interactions in infants, providing evidence for the immaturity of these interactions.

Paclitaxel-induced neuropathic pain is age dependent and devolves on glial response

BACKGROUND

Paclitaxel is an antimitotic antitumour drug highly effective against a broad range of cancers considered refractory to conventional chemotherapy. One of the main serious side effects of paclitaxel treatment is the induction of peripheral neuropathic pain that often diminishes the patient's quality of life. In this study, we evaluated the severity of the neuropathy induced by paclitaxel and the inflammatory reaction in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord in young, adult and aged male CD1 mice.

METHOD

Hyperalgesia to noxious thermal stimulus and allodynia to non-noxious mechanical stimulus were evaluated using the plantar test and the von Frey filament model, respectively. Spinal cord microglia and astrocytes expression was assessed using Iba1 and glial fibrillary acidic protein immunofluorescence staining, respectively.

RESULTS

All groups of mice showed a higher nociceptive reaction to thermal noxious (hyperalgesia) and mechanical non-noxious (allodynia) stimuli after paclitaxel treatment. However, these signs of neuropathy were enhanced in young mice followed by aged animals. Additionally, paclitaxel evoked a marked microglial and astrocytic response in the spinal cord of young and aged mice, whereas this enhanced reactivity was less important in adult mice. Indeed, the most severe glial activation observed in juvenile animals correlated well with major signs of neuropathy in this group of age.

CONCLUSION

Our results demonstrate that paclitaxel-induced neuropathy in mice is an age-dependent phenomenon whose severity devolves on glial response.

Sensitization to acute procedural pain in pediatric sickle cell disease: modulation by painful vaso-occlusive episodes, age, and endothelin-1

The impact of pain early in life is a salient issue for sickle cell disease (SCD), a genetic condition characterized by painful vaso-occlusive episodes (VOEs) that can begin in the first year of life and persist into adulthood. This study examined the effects of age and pain history (age of onset and frequency of recent VOEs) on acute procedural pain in children with SCD. Endothelin-1, a vaso-active peptide released during VOEs and acute tissue injury, and its precursor, Big Endothelin, were explored as markers of pain sensitization and vaso-occlusion. Sixty-one children with SCD (ages 2 to 18) underwent venipuncture at routine health visits. Procedural pain was assessed via child and caregiver reports and observational distress. Pain history was assessed using retrospective chart review. Three primary results were found: 1) younger age was associated with greater procedural pain across pain outcomes; 2) higher frequency of VOEs was associated with greater procedural pain based on observational distress (regardless of age); and 3) age was found to moderate the relationship between VOEs and procedural pain for child-reported pain and observational distress for children 5 years of age and older. Associations between the endothelin variables and pain prior to venipuncture were also observed.

PERSPECTIVE

For children with SCD, the child's age and recent pain history should be considered in procedural pain management. The endothelin system may be involved in preprocedure pain, but additional research is needed to understand the role of endothelins in pain sensitization.

Sexual dimorphism in endothelin-1 induced mechanical hyperalgesia in the rat

While the onset of mechanical hyperalgesia induced by endothelin-1 was delayed in female rats, compared to males, the duration was much longer. Given that the repeated test stimulus used to assess nociceptive threshold enhances hyperalgesia, a phenomenon we have referred to as stimulus-induced enhancement of hyperalgesia, we also evaluated for sexual dimorphism in the impact of repeated application of the mechanical test stimulus on endothelin-1 hyperalgesia. In male and female rats, endothelin-1 induced hyperalgesia is already maximal at 30 min. At this time stimulus-induced enhancement of hyperalgesia, which is observed only in male rats, persisted for 3-4h. In contrast, in females, it develops only after a very long (15 day) delay, and is still present, without attenuation, at 45 days. Ovariectomy eliminated these differences between male and female rats. These findings suggest marked, ovarian-dependent sexual dimorphism in endothelin-1 induced mechanical hyperalgesia and its enhancement by repeated mechanical stimulation.

Changing mechanisms of opiate tolerance and withdrawal during early development: animal models of the human experience

Human infants may be exposed to opiates through placental transfer from an opiate-using mother or through the direct administration of such drugs to relieve pain (e.g., due to illness or neonatal surgery). Infants of many species show physical dependence and tolerance to opiates. The magnitude of tolerance and the nature of withdrawal differ from those of the adult. Moreover, the mechanisms that contribute to the chronic effects of opiates are not well understood in the infant but include biological processes that are both common to and distinct from those of the adult. We review the animal research literature on the effects of chronic and acute opiate exposure in infants and identify mechanisms of withdrawal and tolerance that are similar to and different from those understood in adults. These mechanisms include opioid pharmacology, underlying neural substrates, and the involvement of other neurotransmitter systems. It appears that brain circuitry and opioid receptor types are similar but that NMDA receptor function is immature in the infant. Intracellular signaling cascades may differ but data are complicated by differences between the effects of chronic versus acute morphine treatment. Given the limited treatment options for the dependent infant patient, further study of the biological functions that are altered by chronic opiate treatment is necessary to guide evidenced-based treatment modalities.

Role of peripheral endothelin receptors in an animal model of complex regional pain syndrome type 1 (CRPS-I)

Chronic post-ischemic pain (CPIP) is an animal model of CRPS-I developed using a 3-h ischemia-reperfusion injury of the rodent hind paw. The contribution of local endothelin to nociception has been evaluated in CPIP mice by measuring sustained nociceptive behaviors (SNBs) following intraplantar injection of endothelin-1 or -2 (ET-1, ET-2). The effects of local BQ-123 (ETA-R antagonist), BQ-788 (ETB-R antagonist), IRL-1620 (ETB-R agonist) and naloxone (opioid antagonist) were assessed on ET-induced SNBs and/or mechanical and cold allodynia in CPIP mice. ETA-R and ETB-R expression was assessed using immunohistochemistry and Western blot analysis. Compared to shams, CPIP mice exhibited hypersensitivity to local ET-1 and ET-2. BQ-123 reduced ET-1- and ET-2-induced SNBs in both sham and CPIP animals, but not mechanical or cold allodynia. BQ-788 enhanced ET-1- and ET-2-induced SNBs in both sham and CPIP mice, and cold allodynia in CPIP mice. IRL-1620 displayed a non-opioid anti-nociceptive effect on ET-1- and ET-2-induced SNBs and mechanical allodynia in CPIP mice. The distribution of ETA-R and ETB-R was similar in plantar skin of sham and CPIP mice, but both receptors were over-expressed in plantar muscles of CPIP mice. This study shows that ETA-R and ETB-R have differing roles in nociception for sham and CPIP mice. CPIP mice exhibit more local endothelin-induced SNBs, develop a novel local ETB-R agonist-induced (non-opioid) analgesia, and exhibit over-expression of both receptors in plantar muscles, but not skin. The effectiveness of local ETB-R agonists as anti-allodynic treatments in CPIP mice holds promise for novel therapies in CRPS-I patients.

Cocaine- and amphetamine-regulated transcript (CART) peptide activates ERK pathways via NMDA receptors in rat spinal cord dorsal horn in an age-dependent manner

Activation of extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) cascade in the spinal cord dorsal horn may contribute to pain hypersensitivity. Our recent study showed that cocaine- and amphetamine-regulated transcript peptide fragment 55-102 (CARTp) increased the levels of phosphoserine 896 and phosphoserine 897 on the N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) receptor NR1 subunit (pNR1-ser896 and pNR1-ser897) via protein kinase A (PKA) and protein kinase C (PKC) signaling pathways leading to increases in NMDA receptor function in spinal cord dorsal horn neurons. Because NMDA receptor, PKC, and PKA signaling pathways may participate in ERK activation, we examined the effects of CARTp on ERK activation in spinal cord dorsal horn neurons in vitro. Western blot analysis showed a significant increase in the level of phosphorylated (activated) ERK (pERK) in the dorsal part of the spinal cord slices after incubation of the slices with CARTp (300nM). Co-administration of CARTp with an NMDA receptor antagonist, MK801 or AP5, or an ERK inhibitor PD98059 blocked the increase in the level of pERK. Interestingly, the increase in the level of pERK by CARTp was observed in postnatal week 3 (W3) and postnatal week 4 (W4), but not in postnatal week 2 (W2) rats. The age-related responses were also noted by CARTp-induced increases in the levels of pNR1-ser896 and pNR1-ser897. In the in vitro electrophysiological study, CARTp increased the amplitude of NMDA-mediated depolarizations in spinal substantia gelatinosa neurons of W3 and W4 rats, but not W2 rats. The results suggest that CARTp activation of ERK signals via the NMDA receptor in the spinal cord dorsal horn was age-dependent.

Decreased opioid analgesia in weanling rats exposed to endothelin-1 during infancy

Endothelin-1 produces spontaneous nociceptive-associated behaviors that are modulated by the peripheral opioid system. The present study tests the hypothesis that single or repeated exposure to endothelin-1 during infancy decreases opioid analgesia in weanling rats. Morphine analgesia was measured in male and female postnatal day 21 rats following intraplantar endothelin-1 on postnatal day 7, or 11 or both days 7 and 11. In males, exposure to endothelin-1 on postnatal day 11 or both days 7 and 11 produced a statistically significant decrease in morphine analgesia (EC(50)=0.902 and 1.326mg/kg, respectively) compared to control (EC(50)=0.486mg/kg). Similarly in females, exposure to endothelin-1 on postnatal day 11 or both days 7 and 11 produced a statistically significant decrease in morphine analgesia (EC(50)=1.367 and 1.226mg/kg, respectively) compared to control (EC(50)=0.468mg/kg). In addition, females exposed to endothelin-1 on postnatal day 7 exhibited an intermediate decrease in morphine analgesia with an EC(50) of 0.752mg/kg. In males, exposure to endothelin-1 decreased mu opioid receptor expression without changing endothelin-A receptor or endothelin-B receptor expression in the hindpaw skin. In contrast, in females, exposure to endothelin-1 increased expression of both endothelin receptors and the mu opioid receptor in hindpaw skin. These findings suggest a sex-difference in the window of vulnerability and the mechanism by which an acute nociceptive event can induce morphine tolerance.

Models and mechanisms of hyperalgesia and allodynia

Hyperalgesia and allodynia are frequent symptoms of disease and may be useful adaptations to protect vulnerable tissues. Both may, however, also emerge as diseases in their own right. Considerable progress has been made in developing clinically relevant animal models for identifying the most significant underlying mechanisms. This review deals with experimental models that are currently used to measure (sect. II) or to induce (sect. III) hyperalgesia and allodynia in animals. Induction and expression of hyperalgesia and allodynia are context sensitive. This is discussed in section IV. Neuronal and nonneuronal cell populations have been identified that are indispensable for the induction and/or the expression of hyperalgesia and allodynia as summarized in section V. This review focuses on highly topical spinal mechanisms of hyperalgesia and allodynia including intrinsic and synaptic plasticity, the modulation of inhibitory control (sect. VI), and neuroimmune interactions (sect. VII). The scientific use of language improves also in the field of pain research. Refined definitions of some technical terms including the new definitions of hyperalgesia and allodynia by the International Association for the Study of Pain are illustrated and annotated in section I.

Endothelin receptors and pain

The endogenous endothelin (ET) peptides participate in a remarkable variety of pain-relatedprocesses. Pain that is elevated by inflammation, by skin incision, by cancer, during a Sickle Cell Disease crisis and by treatments that mimic neuropathic and inflammatory pain and are all reduced by local administration of antagonists of endothelin receptors. Many effects of endogenously released endothelin are simulated by acute, local subcutaneous administration of endothelin, which at very high concentrations causes pain and at lower concentrations sensitizes the nocifensive reactions to mechanical, thermal and chemical stimuli.

PERSPECTIVE

In this paper we review the biochemistry, second messenger pathways and hetero-receptor coupling that are activated by ET receptors, the cellular physiological responses to ET receptor activation, and the contribution to pain of such mechanisms occurring in the periphery and the CNS. Our goal is to frame the subject of endothelin and pain for a broad readership, and to present the generally accepted as well as the disputed concepts, including important unanswered questions.

Endothelin-1 exposure on postnatal day 7 alters expression of the endothelin B receptor and behavioral sensitivity to endothelin-1 on postnatal day 11

Endothelin (ET)-1 is a chemical mediator released by the body at sites of injury and disease and is involved in various painful states. This study examined whether ET-1 exposure in the neonatal period alters subsequent ET-1 induced nociception and expression of the ET(B) receptor. ET-1 or saline was administered to postnatal day 7 rats. On postnatal day 11, ET-1 or saline was administered; a first exposure to ET-1 for one group, and a second exposure to ET-1 for another group. A statistically significant increase in ET-1 induced paw flinching was observed in postnatal day 11 male rats exposed to ET-1 for the second time as compared to male rats exposed to ET-1 for the first time. In contrast, a statistically significant decrease in ET-1 induced paw flinching was observed in postnatal day 11 female rats exposed to ET-1 for the second time as compared to female rats exposed to ET-1 for the first time. Furthermore, in males a positive correlation was found between ET-1 induced paw flinching on postnatal day 7 versus 11. In contrast, in females a negative correlation was found between ET-1 induced paw flinching on postnatal day 7 versus 11. Changes in behavioral sensitivity to ET-1 were accompanied by sex-specific ET-1 induced changes in expression of the ET(B) receptor on postnatal day 11 in the plantar hind paw with a statistically significant decrease and increase in ET(B) receptor expression in males and females, respectively. These findings suggest that ET-1 exposure in the neonatal period sex-specifically alters expression of the ET(B) receptor and behavioral sensitivity to ET-1 whereby males show sensitization and females show de-sensitization.

Tumor-evoked sensitization of C nociceptors: a role for endothelin

Primary and metastatic cancers that effect bone are frequently associated with pain. Sensitization of primary afferent C nociceptors innervating tissue near the tumor likely contributes to the chronic pain and hyperalgesia accompanying this condition. This study focused on the role of the endogenous peptide endothelin-1 (ET-1) as a potential peripheral algogen implicated in the process of cancer pain. Electrophysiological response properties, including ongoing activity and responses evoked by heat stimuli, of C nociceptors were recorded in vivo from the tibial nerve in anesthetized control mice and mice exhibiting mechanical hyperalgesia following implantation of fibrosarcoma cells into and around the calcaneus bone. ET-1 (100 microM) injected into the receptive fields of C nociceptors innervating the plantar surface of the hind paw evoked an increase in ongoing activity in both control and tumor-bearing mice. Moreover, the selective ETA receptor antagonist, BQ-123 (3 mM), attenuated tumor-evoked ongoing activity in tumor-bearing mice. Whereas ET-1 produced sensitization of C nociceptors to heat stimuli in control mice, C nociceptors in tumor-bearing mice were sensitized to heat, and their responses were not further increased by ET-1. Importantly, administration of BQ-123 attenuated tumor-evoked sensitization of C nociceptors to heat. We conclude that ET-1 at the tumor site contributes to tumor-evoked excitation and sensitization of C nociceptors through an ETA receptor mediated mechanism.

Endothelin-1-induced pain and hyperalgesia: a review of pathophysiology, clinical manifestations and future therapeutic options

Pain in patients with metastatic cancer contributes to increased suffering in those already burdened by their advancing illness. The causes of this pain are unknown, but are likely to involve the action of tumour-associated mediators and their receptors. In recent years, several chemical mediators have increasingly come to the forefront in the pathophysiology of cancer pain. One such mediator, endothelin-1 (ET-1), is a peptide of 21 amino acids that was initially shown to be a potent vasoconstrictor. Extensive research has revealed that members of the ET family are indeed produced by several epithelial cancerous tumours, in which they act as autocrine and/or paracrine growth factors. Several preclinical and clinical studies of various malignancies have suggested that the ET axis may represent an interesting contributor to tumour progression. In addition, evidence is accumulating to suggest that ET-1 may contribute to pain states both in humans and in other animals. ET-1 both stimulates nociceptors and sensitises them to painful stimuli. Selective stimulation of ET receptors has been implicated as a cause of inflammatory, neuropathic and tumoural pain. ET-1-induced pain-related behaviour seems to be mediated either solely by one receptor type or via both endothelin-A receptors (ETAR) and endothelin-B receptors (ETBR). Whereas stimulation of ETAR on nociceptors always elicits a pain response, stimulation of ETBR may cause analgesia or elicit a pain response, depending on the conditions. The administration of ETAR antagonists in the receptive fields of these nociceptors has been shown to ameliorate pain-related behaviours in animals, as well as in some patients with advanced metastatic prostate cancer. The identification of tumour-associated mediators that might directly or indirectly cause pain in patients with metastatic disease, such as ET-1, should lead to improved, targeted analgesia for patients with advanced cancer. In this review, we will describe the current status of the role of ET-1 in different types of painful syndromes, with special emphasis on its role in the pathophysiology of cancer pain. Finally, potential new treatment options that are based on the role of the ET axis in the pathophysiology of cancer are elaborated.