A-DROP: A predictive model for the formation of oil particle aggregates (OPAs)

Critical shear stress of sunken, No. 6 heavy fuel oil in fresh water

A series of flume- and laboratory-based experiments defined and quantified the thresholds of sunken oil transport using No.6 heavy fuel oil mixed with kaolinite clay. When the sunken oil became mobile, the current-induced bed shear stress exceeded a threshold value specific to the oil, known as critical shear stress (CSS). The oil's CSS was evaluated as a function of water velocity, water temperature, oil condition, and sediment size. Based on experimental results, the stages of oil transport were defined and empirical relationships using the oil's kinematic viscosity (vo) and sediment size were developed to predict oil CSS at each transport stage. For vo<2 × 104 cSt, multiple thresholds of movement were observed: (1) gravity dispersion, (2) rope formation, (3) ripple formation, and (4) break-apart/resuspension. When vo> 6 × 104 cSt, transport was more likely to occur as a single event with the oil remaining intact, saltating over the bed in the direction of flow.

Unveiling the Vertical Migration of Microplastics with Suspended Particulate Matter in the Estuarine Environment: Roles of Salinity, Particle Properties, and Hydrodynamics

The estuary is an energetic area connecting the inland, river, and ocean. The migration of microplastics (MPs) in this highly complex area is tied to the entire ecosystem. In this study, the effects of cohesive SPM (clay) and noncohesive SPM (sand) on the vertical migration of positively buoyant MPs, polyethylene (PE), and negatively buoyant MPs, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), in the estuarine environment under hydrodynamic disturbances were investigated. The settling of positively buoyant MPs was more reliant on the cohesive SPM compared to the settling of negatively buoyant MPs. Moreover, MPs interacting with the SPM mixture at a clay-to-sand ratio of 1:9 settled more efficiently than those interacting with clay alone. A significant positive correlation was observed between MP settling percentage and the salinity level. MP settling percentage was significantly negatively correlated with fluid shear stress for both types of MPs, meanwhile, negatively buoyant MPs were able to resist greater hydraulic disturbances. In the low-energy mixing state, for both types of MPs, the settling percentage reached about 50% in only 10 min. The resuspension process of MPs under hydrodynamic disturbances was also uncovered. Additionally, the migration and potential sites of MPs were described in the context of prevalent environmental phenomena in estuaries.

Aggregation behavior of polyethylene microplastics in the nearshore environment: The role of particle size, environmental condition and turbulent flow

Estuary and coastal waters are hotspot areas for microplastics (MPs) pollution. MPs of varying sizes converge in this complex nearshore environment. Aggregation is an important process that affects the transport and fate of MPs in the aqueous environment. Nevertheless, the influence of different factors on the aggregation behavior and the aggregates structure of MPs is unclear. In this study, the aggregation behavior and the aggregates structure of polyethylene microplastics (PEs) of different sizes under the impact of nearshore environmental conditions (i.e., salinity gradient, dissolved organic matter-DOM, turbulent flow) were investigated. The results show that particle size was the dominant factor affecting the stability of PEs in the aqueous environment, and the critical coagulation concentration (CCC) of PEs shifts to the right with increasing size. It was also found that the size of PEs stable aggregates is negatively correlated with the turbulent kinetic energy dissipation rate. The particle size of PEs can significantly affect the fractal dimension (FD) of stable aggregates, and the smaller the particle size, the more compact the aggregates formed. Moreover, salinity and DOM control the size and FD of PEs stable aggregates through different mechanisms. The findings of this study will be helpful for the prediction of the transport and fate of MPs in the aqueous environment.

Modeling impacts of river hydrodynamics on fate and transport of microplastics in riverine environments

Microplastics pose a significant and growing threat to marine ecosystems and human health. Rivers serve as critical pathways for the entry of inland-produced microplastics into marine environments. In this paper, we developed a numerical modeling scheme using OpenFOAM to investigate the fate and transport of microplastics in a river system. Our simulation results show that microplastics undergo significant aggregation and breakage as they are transported downstream by river flows. This significantly alters the particle size distribution of microplastics. The aggregation-breakage process is mainly controlled by river hydrodynamics and pollution scale. Our findings suggest that a significant extent of particle aggregation occurs at an early stage of the release of microplastics in the river, while the aggregation-breakage process becomes limited as the microplastic plume is gradually dispersed and diluted downstream. Eddy diffusivity drives the dispersion of the microplastic plume in the river, and its spatial patterns affect the aggregation-breakage process.

The Role of Bacteria in the Formation and Migration of Oil-Particle Aggregates (OPAs) after Marine Oil Spills and the Associated Mechanism

Oil spills interact with mineral particles to form oil-particle aggregates (OPAs), which promotes the oil's natural diffusion and biodegradation. We investigated the effect of bacteria on the formation and vertical migration of OPAs under different concentrations and types of particles and proposed and elucidated an oil-particle-bacteria coupling mechanism. The depth of particle penetration into oil droplets (13-17 μm) was more than twice that of the nonbacterial group. Oil that remained in the water column and deposited to the bottom decreased from 87% to 49% and increased from 14% to 15% at high/low concentration, respectively. Interestingly, the median droplet diameter showed a negative correlation (R² = 0.83) and positive correlation (R² = 0.60) at high/low concentration, respectively, with the relative penetration depth first proposed. We further demonstrated that bacteria increased the penetrating depth by a combination of reducing/increasing the interfacial tension, reducing the oil amount (C₁₇-C₃₈) in the OPAs, and increasing the particle width. These effects reduced the droplet size and ultimately changed the vertical migration of OPAs. Finally, we provided a simple assessment of the vertical distribution of OPAs in nearshore environments based on experimental data and suggested that the role of bacteria in increasing the depth of particles penetrating into the oil droplets should not be ignored. These findings will broaden the research perspective of marine oil spill migration.

Formation of oil-particle aggregates with motor oil and kaolinite clay in cold and warm freshwater

Motor oil is one of the most common pollutants in stormwater runoff in freshwater ecosystems. It can form aggregates with solids (creating oil particle aggregates, OPAs) which complicates the understanding of the fate and transport of motor oil, particularly in cold freshwater, conditions that have not been studied extensively. Laboratory and numerical experiments were conducted with kaolinite clay and three types of motor oil in both cold and warm freshwater, in which: (1) the interaction of clay particles with motor oil was experimentally investigated, in response to changes in oil viscosity, water temperature, and mixing intensity; (2) variability in particle size distribution of the formed OPAs was measured; and (3) a mechanistic OPA formation model was applied and results were compared with experimental data. The results showed that kaolinite clay and motor oil formed mostly droplet-type OPAs, lower-viscosity oil tended to form a wider size range of OPAs, and higher mixing intensity and higher water temperature produced larger numbers of smaller OPAs. Although there was a reasonably good match between the experimental data and the modeling results, more research is needed to further improve the modeling framework.

Modeling the Breakup of Oil-Particle Aggregates in Turbulent Environments for Projectile Penetration

After an oil spill incident, the spilled oil slicks are observed to migrate to the shoreline area. Under the turbulent conditions, they break into small droplets and are suspended in the water column. The dispersed droplets are expected to interact with the suspended particles and form the oil-particle aggregates (OPAs), which significantly changes the transport of the oil. Instead of an earlier assumption that particles cover the oil surface, thus preventing further breakage or aggregation of OPAs, recent studies demonstrated that particles act like projectiles penetrating the oil droplets, resulting in the breakage of OPAs over a longer period of time. A model looking into the OPA breakup through two breakup mechanisms was proposed for the first time. The first method depicted the breakup of one large OPA into two daughter droplets owing to the turbulent nature, while the second method demonstrated the tear of the OPA surface layer caused by particle uprooting. The model was then calibrated by an experimental study targeting crude oil with varied viscosities, along with previous experimental investigations. Three key factors were identified accounting for the breakage of OPAs, where the increase in particle concentration in the natural environment and the increase in turbulent energy of the surrounding flows benefited the breakage of OPAs, and the increase in oil viscosity suppressed the breakage due to large resistance to shear stress. Besides these elements, the impact of the particle shape on the penetration depth was discussed. The model serves as a fundamental theory to describe the evolution of OPAs for fragmentation behavior.

Post-Formation of Oil Particle Aggregates: Breakup and Biodegradation

Spilled oil slicks are likely to break into droplets in the subtidal and intertidal zones of seashores due to wave energy. The nonliving suspended fine particles in coastal ecosystems can interact with the dispersed oil droplets, resulting in the formation of Oil Particle Aggregates (OPAs). Many investigations assumed that these aggregates will settle due to the particles' high density. Recent studies, however, reported that some particles penetrate the oil droplets, which results in further breakup while forming smaller OPAs that remain suspended in the water column. Here, we investigated the interaction of crude oil droplets with intertidal and subtidal sediments, as well as artificial pure kaolinite, in natural seawater. Results showed that the interaction between oil droplets and intertidal sediments was not particularly stable, with an Oil Trapping Efficiency (OTE) < 25%. When using subtidal sediments, OTE reached 56%. With artificial kaolinite, OPA formation and breakup were more significant (OTE reaching up to 67%) and occurred faster (within 12 h). Oil chemistry analysis showed that the biodegradation of oil in seawater (half-life of 485 h) was significantly enhanced with the addition of sediments, with half-lives of 305, 265, and 150 h when adding intertidal sediments, subtidal sediments, and pure kaolinite, respectively. Such results reveal how the sediments' shape and size affect the various oil-sediment interaction mechanisms, and the subsequent impact on the microbial degradation of petroleum hydrocarbons. Future studies should consider investigating the application of fine (several microns) and sharp (elongated-sheeted) sediments as a nondestructive and nontoxic technique for dispersing marine oil spills.

Oil Transport Following the Deepwater Horizon Blowout

The Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 was the largest in US history, covering more than 1,000 km of shorelines and causing losses that exceeded $50 billion. While oil transformation processes are understood at the laboratory scale, the extent of the Deepwater Horizon spill made it challenging to integrate these processes in the field. This review tracks the Deepwater Horizon oil during its journey from the Mississippi Canyon block 252 (MC252) wellhead, first discussing the formation of the oil and gas plume and the ensuing oil droplet size distribution, then focusing on the behavior of the oil on the water surface with and without waves. It then reports on massive drifter experiments in the Gulf of Mexico and the impact of the Mississippi River on the oil transport. Finally, it concludes by addressing the formation of oil-particle aggregates. Although physical processes lend themselves to numerical modeling, we attempted to elucidate them without using advanced modeling, as our goal is to enhance communication among scientists, engineers, and other entities interested in oil spills.

Aggregation of microplastics and clay particles in the nearshore environment: Characteristics, influencing factors, and implications

Since nearly half of the world's population lives near the coast, coastal areas have become hotspots for microplastic (MP) pollution due to human activity. The ubiquity of natural colloids in coastal waters plays a critical role in the potential fate of, and risks posed by, MPs. Nevertheless, far less has been known regarding the aggregation of MPs with inorganic natural clay colloids, especially in the complicated nearshore environment. In this study, the aggregation behavior of MPs as well as the interaction between MPs and clay particles were investigated under different nearshore environmental conditions (MP-to-clay ratio, salinity gradient, humic acid concentration, and wave energy). The aggregation behavior was subjected by the repulsive energy barrier between particles and external energy transferred to the system. The low energy associated with mild wave conditions was favorable for the occurrence of aggregation, whereas sustained high energy under intense wave conditions was found to be detrimental to the aggregation behavior, and the aggregates were prone to fragmentation even if particles coalesced into large clusters. The analysis for the environmental fate of MPs demonstrated that the shoreline was likely to be the sink for most MPs ultimately.

Exploring the effects of substrate mineral fines on oil translocation in the shoreline environment: Experimental analysis, numerical simulation, and implications for spill response

Mineral fines act a pivotal part in determining the fate and behavior of oil. In this study, the infiltrations of oil emulsion in simulated sediments and natural shoreline sediments were investigated using a fixed bed experiment. Oil infiltration process was simulated based on fixed-bed dispersion model. The role of mineral fines in oil release was explored using simulated and natural sediments. Although mineral fines exhibited a higher affinity for oil, it was found that increasing fines fractions decreased the flow rate of oil emulsion, thereby decreasing the oil retention in the sediment column. In terms of oil release from the sediment, the highest level of oil mass was observed in the oil-mineral flocculation phase compared to the water column and the water surface compartments. Compared to light crude oil, the release of engine oil from sediment was less. The effects of mineral fines on oil infiltration and release were also confirmed by using natural shoreline sediments. Results of our detailed field studies also showed that current shoreline classification datasets do not characterize the presence and fraction of mineral fines at a level of detail required to accurately predict the significance of oil translocation following spill incidents.

Effects of oil properties on the formation of oil-particle aggregates at the presence of chemical dispersant in baffled flask tests

The formation of oil-particle aggregates (OPA) is the major sedimental pathway of spilled oil, which can bring great harm to both the benthic communities and marine environment. In this paper, effects of GM-2 chemical dispersant and oil properties on the formation of OPA was investigated by the EPA baffled flask test. The addition of dispersant can promote the formation of OPA from montmorillonite and five test oils obviously. With the increase of the dispersant dosage, the size of trapped oil in OPA increased and the density of OPA decreased. The dispersant can increase the kinematic viscosity of crude oil, and high viscosity of the oil is advantageous for the formation of OPA. The oil-seawater interfacial tension is reduced after the addition of dispersant, which makes oil dispersed into the water column easier. A kinematic equation of dispersed oil concentration attenuation was modified by introducing the oil property coefficient β. The modified empirical equation can calculate the mass of oil in sunken OPA in oil spill accidents.

Experimental and modeling studies of the effects of nanoclay on the oil behaviors in a water-sand system

When oil is released into the oceans, spilled oil may get to the shoreline driven by wind and wave. This study comprehensively explored the effects of bentonite nanoclay on the oil behaviors in a water-sand system from both experimental and modeling perspectives. Four factors including nanoclay concentration, temperature, salinity, and pH have been studied. The increasing nanoclay concentration resulted in the decrease in remaining oil on sand. Higher temperature and salinity were associated with less residual oil on sand in the presence of nanoclay. The lower residual oil on sand with coexisting nanoclay was found to be at pH 7. The factorial analysis results indicated that the nanoclay concentration showed the most significant impact among these factors. Miscibility modeling results showed an increasing temperature was favorable to the nanoclay miscibility. Moreover, the effect of nanoclay on oil behavior was further revealed through the dynamic simulation, in which it can be seen the nanoclay could penetrate into oil droplets and promote the oil detachment from solid substrate. The results of this study can help understand the role of fine particles in the fate and transport of oil on shoreline and support the risk assessment and response planning after oil spill.

An Overview of Oil-Mineral-Aggregate Formation, Settling, and Transport Processes in Marine Oil Spill Models

An oil spill is considered one of the most serious polluting disasters for a marine environment. When oil is spilled into a marine environment, it is dispersed into the water column as oil droplets which often interact with suspended particles to form oil-mineral-aggregate (OMA). Knowing how OMA form, settle, and are transported is critical to oil spill modelling which can determine the fate and mass balance of the spilled volumes. This review introduces oil weathering and movement, and the commonly used numerical models that oil spill specialists use to determine how a spill will evolve. We conduct in-depth reviews of the environmental factors that influence how OMA form and their settling velocity, and we review how OMA formation and transport are modelled. We point out the existing gaps in current knowledge and the challenges of studying OMA. Such challenges include having to systematically conduct laboratory experiments to investigate how the environment affects OMA formation and settling velocities, and the need for a comprehensive algorithm that can estimate an OMA settling velocity.

Experimental investigations on the vertical distribution and properties of oil-mineral aggregates (OMAs) formed by different clay minerals

After oil spills, the floating oil may interact with suspended minerals to form the oil-mineral aggregates (OMAs) in turbulent environments. In this work, a flume was used in conjunction with a settling device to investigate the vertical distribution and properties of OMAs formed by different clay minerals. The density and size of OMAs depend on the density and surface properties of the constituent particles, which also affect the vertical distribution of dispersed oil. Density of oil-montmorillonite aggregates increased from 1165 to 1897 kg/m3 within 6 h test. Among the four minerals, montmorillonite displayed the highest affinity with dispersed oil and the most significant modification of oil-water interfacial tension. Oil dispersion efficiency was significantly greater and reached 39.3% in the presence of montmorillonite at 300 mg/L compared with the control group (17.6%). Particle concentration is the most important factor for the capture of oil and participation of particles during the OMA formation, while the zeta potential and hydrophobicity have nonsignificant effect on the two processes. Cation exchange capacity has a moderate effect on the sunken oil formation, which is also the second main factor governing the particle participation. Particle size plays a second leading role in governing the sunken oil formation but with a minor contribution of the particle participation.

Natural attenuation of oil in marine environments: A review

Natural attenuation is an important process for oil spill management in marine environments. Natural attenuation affects the fate of oil by physical, chemical, and biological processes, which include evaporation, dispersion, dissolution, photo-oxidation, emulsification, oil particle aggregation, and biodegradation. This review examines the cumulative knowledge regarding these natural attenuation processes as well as their simulation and prediction using modelling approaches. An in-depth discussion is provided on how oil type, microbial community and environmental factors contribute to the biodegradation process. It describes how our understanding of the structure and function of indigenous oil degrading microbial communities in the marine environment has been advanced by the application of next generation sequencing tools. The synergetic and/or antagonist effects of oil spill countermeasures such as the application of chemical dispersants, in-situ burning and nutrient enrichment on natural attenuation were explored. Several knowledge gaps were identified regarding the synergetic and/or antagonistic effects of active response countermeasures on the natural attenuation/biodegradation process. This review highlighted the need for field data on both the effectiveness and potential detrimental effects of oil spill response options to support modelling and decision-making on their selection and application.

Investigation into the impact of aged microplastics on oil behavior in shoreline environments

Understanding the interactions between oil and other particles in shoreline can help determine the environmental risk and cleanup strategy after oil spill. Nevertheless, far less has been known regarding the impact of aged MPs on oil behavior in the shoreline environment. In this study, the aging course of polyethylene (PE) in shaking seawater and ultraviolet (UV) radiation conditions was investigated. The seawater aging mainly affected the physical properties of MPs, increasing its surface pores and hydrophilicity. UV aging significantly affected both the physical and chemical properties of MPs, which increased its hydrophilicity and crystallinity, decreased its mean particle size and introduced oxygen-containing functional groups onto MPs. The two-dimensional correlation spectroscopy (2D COS) analysis confirmed the evolution of oxygen-containing functional groups from C-O to CO. The effects of aged MPs on oil behavior in water-sand system were further explored. The oil remaining percentages were non-linearly changed with the increasing aging degree of MPs. The particle size of the aqueous phase after washing was inversely related to the oil remaining percentage. Further FTIR analysis revealed that C-O and C-H functional groups played an important role in the process of oil adsorbed on MPs.

Formation of oil-particle aggregates: Impacts of mixing energy and duration

Spilled oil slicks are likely to break into droplets offshore due to wave energy. The fate and transport of such droplets are affected by suspended particles in local marine environment, through forming oil particle aggregates (OPAs). OPA formation is affected by various factors, including the mixing energy and duration. To evaluate these two factors, lab experiments of OPA formation were conducted using kaolinite at two hydrophobicities in baffled flasks, as represented by the contact angle of 28.8° and 37.7° (original and modified kaolinite). Two mixing energies (energy dissipation rates of 0.05 and 0.5 W/kg) and four durations (10 min, 30 min, 3 h, and 24 h) were considered. Penetration to the oil droplets was observed at 3-5 μm and 5-7 μm for the original and modified kaolinite by confocal microscopy, respectively. At lower mixing energy, volume median diameter d50 of oil droplets increased from 45 μm to 60 μm after 24 h mixing by original kaolinite; for modified kaolinite, d50 decreased from 40 μm to 25 μm after 24 h mixing. The trapped oil amount in negatively buoyant OPAs decreased from 35% (3 h mixing) to 17% (24 h mixing) by original kaolinite; and from 18% to 12% after 24 h mixing by modified kaolinite. Results indicated that the negatively buoyant OPAs formed with original kaolinite at low mixing energy reaggregated after 24 h. At higher mixing energy, d50 decreased from 45 μm to 17 μm after 24 h mixing for both kaolinites. And the trapped oil amount in negatively buoyant OPAs increased to 72% and 49% after 24 h mixing for original and modified kaolinite, respectively. At higher mixing energy, the OPAs formed within 10 min and reached equilibrium at 3 h by original kaolinite. For modified kaolinite, the OPAs continued to form through 24 h.

Performance of dispersed oil and suspended sediment during the oil-sediment aggregation process

Oil-sediment aggregation is an important transport and transformation process of spilled oil, which has been considered as a pathway of spill remediation. This work focused on the individual performance of dispersed oil and sediment during the aggregation process. Dispersion of three oils was first tested and validated in a water tank. An approach of estimating the mass variation of the sediment that has participated in forming the oil-sediment aggregates (OSAs) has been developed by density analysis. Results indicated that the density of the formed OSAs increases during the aggregation. In the context of remediation, it takes longer for sediment to reach equilibrium than for dispersed oil, especially under high mixing energy at a large sediment concentration, which results in the formation of dense OSAs, as well as high aggregation degree and rate. Roncador oil possesses a relatively high capability of capturing sediment to form dense OSAs, especially at an initial sediment concentration of over 150 mg/L. Oil sinking efficiency and the characteristic change rate of aggregated oil mass seem to be proportional to oil dispersion efficiency, and decrease with the mean size of dispersed oil droplets. The process of aggregation can further promote the dispersion of oil into water column. This study also provides fundamental data for the formation kinetics of OSAs.

Formation of oil-particle aggregates: Particle penetration and impact of particle properties and particle-to-oil concentration ratios

Oil droplets in marine environment interact with particles to form oil particle aggregates (OPA), and alters the transport and fate of oil. We investigated the impact of particles properties on the formation of OPAs. It was found that the distribution of 9 μm spherical silica (sand) particles on the oil droplet was more uniform than the 3 μm silica particles, and it is likely due to the inertia of the larger particles causing them to lodge into the droplet. Also, the OPAs of the 3 μm silica particles were much smaller than those of the 9 μm particles. For kaolinite particles that are rod-like of length around 10 μm, it was found that increasing the hydrophobicity of the particles from a contact angle (CA) of ~ 29^o to 38^o, increases the penetration of the particles in the oil through a projectile penetration mechanism, whereby the particle possesses sufficient inertia to penetrate into the oil. However, a further increase in hydrophbocitiy (CA ~ 57^o) caused the particles to agglomerate together and avoid the oil droplets. The oil droplets got smaller with time probably due to the penetration of the particles in them. For an oil concentration of 500 mg/L, a particle concentration of 100 mg/L was incapable of fragmenting the oil droplets, but particle concentration of 500 mg/L fragmented the droplets similarly to a concentration of 1500 mg/L. This is due to the larger coverage of the droplet surface area by the particles and the subsequent weakening of its structural rigidity through the reduction of the oil-water interfacial tension. The study shows that the fate (e.g., after 24 h) of OPAs greatly depends on the type of sediments where the oil spilled (sand versus clay) and their concentration.

Marine phytoplankton responses to oil and dispersant exposures: Knowledge gained since the Deepwater Horizon oil spill

The Deepwater Horizon oil spill of 2010 brought the ecology and health of the Gulf of Mexico to the forefront of the public's and scientific community's attention. Not only did we need a better understanding of how this oil spill impacted the Gulf of Mexico ecosystem, but we also needed to apply this knowledge to help assess impacts from perturbations in the region and guide future response actions. Phytoplankton represent the base of the food web in oceanic systems. As such, alterations of the phytoplankton community propagate to upper trophic levels. This review brings together new insights into the influence of oil and dispersant on phytoplankton. We bring together laboratory, mesocosm and field experiments, including insights into novel observations of harmful algal bloom (HAB) forming species and zooplankton as well as bacteria-phytoplankton interactions. We finish by addressing knowledge gaps and highlighting key topics for research in novel areas.

Oil Spill Modeling: A Critical Review on Current Trends, Perspectives, and Challenges

Several oil spill simulation models exist in the literature, which are used worldwide to simulate the evolution of an oil slick created from marine traffic, petroleum production, or other sources. These models may range from simple parametric calculations to advanced, new-generation, operational, three-dimensional numerical models, coupled to meteorological, hydrodynamic, and wave models, forecasting in high-resolution and with high precision the transport and fate of oil. This study presents a review of the transport and oil weathering processes and their parameterization and critically examines eighteen state-of-the-art oil spill models in terms of their capacity (a) to simulate these processes, (b) to consider oil released from surface or submerged sources, (c) to assimilate real-time field data for model initiation and forcing, and (d) to assess uncertainty in the produced predictions. Based on our review, the most common oil weathering processes involved are spreading, advection, diffusion, evaporation, emulsification, and dispersion. The majority of existing oil spill models do not consider significant physical processes, such as oil dissolution, photo-oxidation, biodegradation, and vertical mixing. Moreover, timely response to oil spills is lacking in the new generation of oil spill models. Further improvements in oil spill modeling should emphasize more comprehensive parametrization of oil dissolution, biodegradation, entrainment, and prediction of oil particles size distribution following wave action and well blow outs.

Oil dispersion and aggregation with suspended particles in a wave tank

Suspended particulate matter (SPM) in marine environments plays an important role in determining the fate of spilled oil via the generation of oil-particle aggregates (OPAs). A series of mesoscale wave tank experiments and sedimentation tests were conducted to fill the knowledge gap on how the turbulent mixing, temperature, and oil type affect the dispersion of spilled oil and properties of OPAs. Generally, the oil dispersing efficiency was significantly enhanced by high wave energy, which also led to effective oil sinking, large size of OPAs and wide distribution of trapped oil. Nonlinear fitting results indicated that the oil sinking efficiency followed an exponential growth over time. The effect of temperature on oil dispersion and formation of OPAs is primarily attributed to its influence on oil viscosity and interfacial tension. Viscous oils are more likely to interact with particles above 25 °C. However, below 20 °C, a specific oil viscosity that will bring about the maximum OPAs exists. Excessive oil viscosity will lead to a weak binding between oil and SPM and a centralized distribution of trapped oil. Furthermore, spilled oil with a high asphaltene can interact more effectively with particles. Our finding suggested that early prevention of offshore oil sinking is key in summer.

Riverine deposition pattern of oil-particle aggregates considering the coagulation effect

To understand the heterogeneous behavior of oil-particle aggregates (OPAs) in the riverine environment as well as the uncertainties caused by the coupling effects between their stochastic formation and transportation processes, this study employed the coagulation conceptual formula and random-walk particle tracking model. Through careful inspection using the classic Rouse-Vanoni diagram and existing laboratory observations, a vertical diffusivity scheme and the packing coefficient for an oil-sediment interaction model were determined. The density variations and deposition patterns of hypothetically fully developed OPAs as well as the impact of oil-sediment interactions on the longitudinal distribution of deposited OPAs were then investigated. The results indicate that the formation process of OPAs has a significant effect on their longitudinal deposition. The range of potentially trapped OPAs varied from several to hundreds of times the range of cases that exclude oil-sediment interactions. The deposition diagram proposed in this study visualizes the relationship between the configuration and deposition pattern of OPAs and can assist in determining the most unfavorable scenarios for oil-spill countermeasures. Further refinement and calibration of the model are necessary in the future to provide guidelines for oil spill responses and recovery in riverine environments.

Progress in Operational Modeling in Support of Oil Spill Response

Following the 2010 Deepwater Horizon accident of a massive blow-out in the Gulf of Mexico, scientists from government, industry, and academia collaborated to advance oil spill modeling and share best practices in model algorithms, parameterizations, and application protocols. This synergy was greatly enhanced by research funded under the Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative (GoMRI), a 10-year enterprise that allowed unprecedented collection of observations and data products, novel experiments, and international collaborations that focused on the Gulf of Mexico, but resulted in the generation of scientific findings and tools of broader value. Operational oil spill modeling greatly benefited from research during the GoMRI decade. This paper provides a comprehensive synthesis of the related scientific advances, remaining challenges, and future outlook. Two main modeling components are discussed: Ocean circulation and oil spill models, to provide details on all attributes that contribute to the success and limitations of the integrated oil spill forecasts. These forecasts are discussed in tandem with uncertainty factors and methods to mitigate them. The paper focuses on operational aspects of oil spill modeling and forecasting, including examples of international operational center practices, observational needs, communication protocols, and promising new methodologies.

The interaction between dispersed crude oil droplets and particulate matter

In this study, the effect of particulate matter type, temperature, oil type and weathering degree on the interaction between dispersed crude oil droplets and particulate matter was investigated. The increase of total petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH) percentage in oil-particle aggregates (OPAs) could be attributed to the increase of oil polarity or viscosity. For small size particulate matter, there was a fine dependence relationship between the TPH percentage in OPAs and the oil viscosity and the content of polar components, respectively (R2 > 0.7502). And the total organic carbon content also played an important role in the formation of OPAs. The petroleum hydrocarbon extracts of OPAs showed a decrease in short-carbon-chain components and a relative increase in long-carbon-chain compounds. Petroleum hydrocarbon compounds trapped by three types of particulate matter exhibited a similar change tendency, but there was no apparent difference in the residual TPH percentage in water.

Simulation for dynamic release of oil from oil-contaminated marine sediment

Dynamic oil release from oil-contaminated sediment to seawater was investigated in kinetic and factor experiments. Oil-release kinetic was described using a two-compartment first-order equation with rapid- and slow-release steps. The rapid-desorption-fraction rate (k_r) was not affected by the ratio of solid-liquid, but significantly affected by sediment pollution level and salinity. The slow-desorption-fraction rate constant (k_s) was affected by sediment pollution level, the ratio of solid-liquid, and salinity. Desorption efficiencies were 1.09-4.04%, increasing as the sediment pollution level and salinity increased and the ratio of solid-liquid decreased. Oil desorption was critically affected by sediment suspension (or lack of). The desorption kinetics curves were unaffected with the shear force for unsuspended sediment, and the desorption efficiency and k_r were increasing with the shear force for suspended sediment, and no significant correlations were found between k_s and hydrodynamic conditions. The results provide a theoretical basis for evaluating ecological risks posed by oil in sediment.

Oil-mineral flocculation and settling velocity in saline water

Cohesive particles in aquatic systems can play an important role in determining the fate of spilled oil via the generation of Oil-Mineral Aggregates (OMAs). Series of laboratory experiments have been conducted aiming at filling the knowledge gap regarding how cohesive clay particles influence the accumulation of petroleum through forming different aggregate structures and their resulting settling velocity. OMAs have been successfully created in a stirring jar with artificial sea-water, crude oil and two types of most common cohesive minerals, Kaolinite and Bentonite clay. With the magnetic stirrer adjusted to 490 rpm to provide a high level homogeneous flow turbulence (Turbulence dissipation ε estimated to be about 0.02 m²⋅s^-3), droplet OMAs and flake/solid OMAs were obtained in oil-Kaolinite sample and oil-Bentonite sample, respectively. Kaolinite clay with relatively low flocculation rate (R_f = 0.13 min^-1) tends to physically attach around the surface of oil droplets. With the lower density of oil, these oil-Kaolinite droplet OMAs generally show lower settling velocity comparing to pure mineral Kaolinite flocs. Differently, Bentonite clay with higher flocculation rate (R_f = 0.66 min^-1) produces more porous flocs that can absorb or be absorbed by the oil and form compact flake/solid OMAs with higher density and settling velocity than pure Bentonite flocs. In the mixed Kaolinite-Bentonite sample (1:1 in weight), oil is observed to preferably interacting with Bentonite and increase settling velocity especially in larger floc size classes.

Effect of the concentration and size of suspended particulate matter on oil-particle aggregation

After spill, the dispersed oil droplets may collide with suspended particulate matter in the water column to form oil-particle aggregates (OPAs) in turbulent environments. It may be an effective pathway to stabilize the oil by taking advantage of the particulate matter to clean up the contaminated waters. A theoretical model in Payne et al. (2003) is adopted to describe the oil-particle aggregation, and a solution method is proposed and validated against a group of experiments. The effect of the particle size and mass concentration on the aggregation has been examined quantitatively in detail. The particles and the oil droplets are consumed at a fixed ratio. Under the same mass concentration, smaller particles can trap more oil droplets, while larger particles tend to interact more quickly with the oil. The oil-particle aggregation rate and the oil trapping efficiency mainly depend on the particle concentration. The theoretical model is applied to predict the decrease of the dispersed oil in nearshore environments, based on the parameters obtained from the experiments. It is efficient to promote the oil-particle aggregation by increasing the particle concentration in the closed bay. In the open sea, the decrease of the dispersed oil can be effectively enhanced by increasing the particle concentration when it is below 0.50 kg/m³. The information presented in this paper can serve to predict the fate of the dispersed oil in coastal waters and provide technical support for oil spill management strategies.

Evaluation of accelerated biodegradation of oil-SPM aggregates (OSAs)

The studies of the formation of oil-Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM) aggregates (OSAs) have advanced significantly in the scientific community, however there is a need to accelerate oil biodegradation that was dispersed by the formation of OSAs. The present research presents a pioneering character regarding the addition of nutrients as biostimulus for autochthonous hydrocarboclastic bacteria in the biodegradation of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons (TPH) dispersed by the formation of OSAs. Water aliquots were taken over 60 days from eight bioreactors to perform ionic species analysis, pH, salinity and temperature monitoring, liquid/liquid extraction, serial dilution methodology and filter membrane. TPH quantification was performed on the gas chromatograph with a flame ionisation detector (GC-FID). The addition of nutrients contributed positively to the rate and extent of biodegradation of TPH in association with field-collected SPM. The best result found was with the lowest nutrient concentration (Bio 1) with an average of 98.65% of TPH reduction.

Formation of OSA and dispersion of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in a tropical estuary as a tool in the prevention of environmental impacts: influence of the biogeochemical characteristics of the estuary

The formation of an oil-suspended particulate material aggregate (OSA) is one of the weathering processes that occur after the spill of oil in marine environments, responsible for the dispersion of hydrocarbons. Oil and particle aggregates are formed from the interaction between small oil droplets and suspended particulate matter (SPM). In general, SPM are fine particles which may be inorganic minerals or organic particles in the water column. OSAs provide vertical dispersion of oil along the water column depending on the acquired density (buoyancy), and may remain near the surface, water column, or bottom of water bodies. The present study examines the formation of these aggregates through the laboratory simulation of an oil spill in the waters of the São Paulo river estuary. The main objective was to investigate the dispersion of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), verifying which estuary characteristics most influenced the formation of OSAs and in addition to determine the regions of probable ecotoxicological impact due to the negative buoyancy of the formed aggregate. The results show that there was greater dispersion to the water column, mainly of lighter PAHs, ranging from 85,804.05 ng g^-1 (P11C) to 566,989.84 ng g^-1 (P17C). The percentage of dispersed PAH concentration per experimental unit ranged from 9.90% in unit P2 to 75.27% in unit P18. The formation of OSAs was influenced mainly by salinity and chlorophyll a. As the most vulnerable regions, the impacts are one mouth (P2 and P4), one central region (P7, P8, and P10), and one source (P18).

Effects of physical parameters and chemical dispersant on the formation of oil-particle aggregates (OPAs) in marine environments

Floating oil and sediments can interact to form oil-particle aggregates (OPAs) in marine environments. Laboratory batch experiments were conducted to investigate the effects of the concentration and size of sediment, temperature, oil types and chemical dispersant on the formation of OPAs. The results showed that the mass of OPAs and oil-particle aggregation rate are mainly related to the sediment concentration. Under the same mass concentration, more oil droplets can be trapped by smaller particles. Nevertheless, larger particles tend to interact more quickly with oil droplets. The effect of temperature on the formation of OPAs is substantially attributed to its influence on oil viscosity, and there is a threshold for oil viscosity which will bring about the maximum OPAs. Spilled oil with a high asphaltene can interact more effectively with the sediments. Appropriate addition of chemical dispersant is favorable for the formation of OPAs while excess addition will inhibit it.

Distribution of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Sunken Oils in the Presence of Chemical Dispersant and Sediment

The formation of sunken oils is mainly dominated by the interaction between spilled oils and sediments. Due to their patchiness and invisibility, cleaning operations become difficult. As a result, sunken oils may cause long-term and significant damage to marine benthonic organisms. In the present study, a bench experiment was designed and conducted to investigate the quantitative distribution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in sunken oils in the presence of chemical dispersant and sediment. The oil sinking efficiency (OSE) of 16 priority total PAHs in the sediment phase was analyzed with different dosages of dispersant. The results showed that the synergistic effect of chemical dispersant and sediment promoted the formation of sunken oils, and the content of PAHs partitioned in the sunken oils increased with the increase of dispersant-to-oil ratios (DORs). Furthermore, with the addition of chemical dispersant, due to the solubility and hydrophobicity of individual PAHs, the high molecular weight (HMW) PAHs with 4–6 rings tended to partition to sediment compared with low molecular weight (LMW) PAHs with 2–3 rings. The synergistic effect of chemical dispersant and sediment could enhance the OSE of HMW PAHs in sunken oils, which might subsequently cause certain risks for marine benthonic organisms.

Classification of oil-particle interactions in aqueous environments: Aggregate types depending on state of oil and particle characteristics

There are significant differences in the aggregation mechanisms and types of aggregates that form by oil-particle interactions in marine and laboratory environments depending on the state of oil (i.e., dissolved, emulsified, floating), size and type of particles involved (i.e., colloidal, granular, organic, inorganic), oil-particle interaction mechanisms, and settling/suspension characteristics. Distinct characteristics of oil-particle aggregates that form by interaction of granular particles with floating oil separate them from the well-known oil-colloidal particle aggregates (OcPA), which are sometimes called Pickering emulsions. Unlike OcPA, which involve emulsified oil (entrained oil droplets suspended in the water column) and colloidal particles, the oil-granular particle aggregates (OgPA) involve the floating oil and granular particles. Here, to clarify the differences and similarities between the two types of aggregates (OcPA and OgPA), we present classification of oil aggregates, drawing attention to important characteristics of OcPA, marine oil snow (MOS), and OgPA.

How the dispersant Corexit impacts the formation of sinking marine oil snow

The vertical transport of sinking marine oil snow (MOS) and oil-sediment aggregations (OSA) during the Deepwater Horizon (DwH) spill contributed appreciably to the unexpected, and exceptional accumulation of oil on the seafloor. However, the role of the dispersant Corexit in mediating oil-sedimentation is still controversial. Here we demonstrate that the formation of diatom MOS is enhanced by chemically undispersed oil, but inhibited by Corexit-dispersed oil. Nevertheless, the sedimentation rate of oil may at times be enhanced by Corexit application, because of an elevated oil content per aggregate when Corexit is used. A conceptual framework explains the seemingly contradictory effects of Corexit application on the sedimentation of oil and marine particles. The redistribution of oil has central ecological implications, and future decisions on mediating measures or damage assessment will have to take the formation of sinking, oil-laden, marine snow into account.

Settling of dilbit-derived oil-mineral aggregates (OMAs) & transport parameters for oil spill modelling

The size and settling velocity of oil-mineral aggregates (OMAs) derived from diluted bitumen are primary constituents in predictive models for evaluating the potential fate of oil spilled in the aquatic environment. A series of low sediment concentration (15mg·L^-1), colder water (<10°C) wave tank experiments designed to measure variability in these parameters in naturally-formed OMAs in response the presence or absence of chemical dispersant are discussed. Corresponding lab experiments revealed settling velocities of artificially formed OMAs on the order of 0.1-0.4mm·s^-1. High-resolution imagery of settling particles were analyzed for particle size, density and settling velocity. In situ formation of OMAs in the wave tank was unsuccessful. Possible effects of chemical dispersant on natural sediment flocculation, the size of suspended oil droplets and clearance rates of suspended particles are discussed.

A New Mechanism of Sediment Attachment to Oil in Turbulent Flows: Projectile Particles

The interaction of oil and sediment in the environment determines, to a large extent, the trajectory and fate of oil. Using confocal microscope imaging techniques to obtain detailed 3D structures of oil-particle aggregates (OPAs) formed in turbulent flows, we elucidated a new mechanism of particle attachment, whereby the particles behave as projectiles penetrating the oil droplets to depths varying from ∼2 to 10 μm due to the hydrodynamic forces in the water. This mechanism results in a higher attachment of particles on oil in comparison with adsorption, as commonly assumed. The projectile hypothesis also explains the fragmentation of oil droplets with time, which occurred after long hours of mixing, leading to the formation of massive OPA clusters. Various lines of inquiry strongly suggested that protruding particles get torn from oil droplets and carry oil with them, causing the torn particles to be amphiphillic so that they contribute to the formation of massive OPAs of smaller oil droplets (<∼5-10 μm). Low particle concentration resulted in large, irregularly shaped oil blobs over time, the deformation of which without fragmentation could be due to partial coverage of the oil droplet surface by particles. The findings herein revealed a new pathway for the fate of oil in environments containing non-negligible sediment concentrations.

An oil spill decision matrix in response to surface spills of various bitumen blends

Canada's production, transport, and sale of diluted bitumen (dilbit) products are expected to increase by a million barrels per day over the next decade. The anticipated growth in oil production and transport increases the risk of oil spills in aquatic areas and places greater demands on oil spill capabilities to respond to spills, which have raised stakeholder concerns. Current oil spill models only predict the transport of bitumen blends that are used in contingency plans and oil spill response strategies, rather than changes in the oil's physical properties that are relevant to spill response. We conducted weathering studies of five oil products (two conventional oils and three bitumen blends) in the Department of Fisheries and Oceans' flume tank. We also considered two initial oil slick thicknesses, 4.0 mm and 7.0 mm. We found that there is a major difference in the time evolution of oil properties (density and viscosity), raising doubts on weathering models that do not consider the thickness of oil. We also developed empirical expressions for the evolution of the density and viscosity of these oil products. The findings from the 4.0 mm results were incorporated with data from the literature to provide an update on the factors to consider during the decision making for spills of diluted bitumen products. The matrix indicated that most response options, including chemical dispersants, work much more effectively within 48 hours of the initiation of weathering. After this window of opportunity closes, natural attenuation or in situ burning is the only option remaining, but containment of oil is a limiting factor for in situ burning.

Capability of Paraguaçu estuary (Todos os Santos Bay, Brazil) to form oil-SPM aggregates (OSA) and their ecotoxicological effects on pelagic and benthic organisms

For experiments concerning the formation of oil-suspended particulate matter (SPM) aggregates (OSA), oil and sediment samples were collected from Campos Basin and six stations of Paraguaçu estuary, Todos os Santos Bay, Brazil, respectively. The sediments samples were analyzed for organic matter determined by the EMBRAPA method, nitrogen determined by the Kjeldahl method, and phosphorus determined by the method described by Aspila. The oil trapped in OSA was extracted following the method described by Moreira. The experiment showed a relationship between the amount of organic matter and OSA formation and consequently the dispersion of the studied oil. On the basis of the buoyancy of OSA and the ecotoxicological effects on pelagic and benthic community, the priority areas for application of remediation techniques are Cachoeira, Maragogipe, and Salinas da Margarida because of the large amount of oil that accumulated at the bottom of the experiment flask (5.85%, 27.95%, and 38,98%; 4.2%, 17.66%, and 32.64%; and 11.82%, 8.07%, and 10.91% respectively).