Nutrient budgets for the Bohai Sea: Implication for ratio imbalance of nitrogen to phosphorus input under intense human activities

Key biogeochemical processes and source apportionment of nitrate in the Bohai Sea based on nitrate stable isotopes

Excessive nitrate input is one of the primary factors causing nearshore eutrophication. This study applied the nitrate stable isotope techniques to analyse the biogeochemical processes and sources of nitrate in the Bohai Sea (BHS). The results showed that intensive NO3- assimilation probably occurred at surface in summer, while nitrification primarily occurred in the Yellow River diluted water. In autumn, regional assimilation and nitrification were still identified. For avoiding the interference from assimilation, the isotopic fractionations were further calculated as correction data for the quantitative analysis of nitrate sources. The river inputs were identified as the primary source of nitrate in the BHS in summer and autumn, accounting for >50 %, and the atmospheric deposition was the secondary source. This study provides quantitative data for evaluating the significance of river inputs to the nearshore nitrate, which will be beneficial to policy formulation on the BHS eutrophication control.

Phycospheric bacteria limits the effect of nitrogen and phosphorus imbalance on diatom bloom

Human activities have caused an imbalance in the input nitrogen and phosphorus (N/P) in the biosphere. The imbalance of N/P is one of the characteristics of water eutrophication, which is the fundamental factor responsible for the blooms. The effects of the N/P imbalance on diatom and phycospheric bacteria in blooms are poorly understood. In this study, the N/P molar ratio in real water (14:1) and the predicted N/P molar ratio in future water (65:1) were simulated to analyze the response of Cyclotella sp. and phycospheric bacteria to the N/P imbalance. The results showed that the N/P imbalance inhibited the growth of Cyclotella sp., but prolonged diatom bloom duration. The resistance of Cyclotella sp. to the N/P imbalance is related to phycospheric bacteria, and there are dynamic regulatory mechanisms within the phycospheric bacteria community to resist the N/P imbalance: (1) the increase of HNA bacterial density, the decrease of LNA bacterial density, (2) the increase of phycospheric bacterial diversity and eutrophic bacteria abundance, and the change of denitrifying bacteria abundance, (3) the activity of nitrogen and phosphorus metabolism of HNA bacteria enhanced, while that of LNA bacteria decreased. And the gene hosts of nitrogen and phosphorus metabolism were most enriched in Proteobacteria, indicating that Proteobacteria played an important role in maintaining the stability of phycospheric bacteria and was the dominant phylum resistant to the N/P imbalance. This study clarified that the algal-bacteria system was resistant to the N/P imbalance and implied that the N/P imbalance had little effect on the occurrence of diatom bloom events due to the presence of phycospheric bacteria.

Phosphorus depletion is exacerbated by increasing nitrogen loading in the Bohai sea

Phosphorus (P) is an essential nutrient for algal growth in nearshore ecosystems. In recent years, there has been a shift in nutrient dynamics in nearshore areas, leading to an exacerbation of P limitation, although the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. This study analyzed the P species and budget in the Bohai Sea (BS) from 2011 to 2020, aiming to explore the intrinsic mechanisms of P limitation in the BS. The results show that the main external source of P in the BS was river transport (89%), and the primary fate of P was burial (96%) into the sediment. Due to excessive nitrogen (N) input and biological processes in the BS, the P budget in the BS is unbalanced, resulting in an increase in the N/P ratio, particularly in nearshore areas. Nearshore areas typically have lower concentrations of dissolved inorganic P (DIP) in the water and higher concentrations of reactive P (Reac-P) in the sediments. This pattern is particularly evident in Bohai Bay and the northwest nearshore region, where harmful algal blooms occur frequently. To cope with enhanced P limitation, the biologically driven P regeneration and cycling processes within the BS are accelerated. From 2011 to 2020, the concentration of DIP in the BS during autumn increased, while the content of Reac-P in sediments slightly decreased. Historical data indicate that P depletion in the BS is intensifying and expanding, primarily due to N enrichment and algal production. N enrichment alters the structure and composition of primary production, potentially exacerbating P depletion in the BS. Excessive N may have significant impacts on the P pool, potentially influencing the stability of future coastal ecosystems.

Typhoon-induced stormwater drives nutrient dynamics and triggers phytoplankton blooms in Laizhou Bay, China

In this study, we investigated the hydrological and ecological impacts of heavy rainfall caused by the storm Rumbia and Typhoon Lekima on Laizhou Bay (LZB) through land‒sea synchronous field surveys, online remote sensors, and simulated enclosure experiments. Within two weeks of Rumbia, approximately 9% and 16% of the annual riverine total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) fluxes, respectively, were transported to the LZB and the proportions were 17% and 35%, respectively, for Lekima. The land use on the watersheds increased the rates of land-derived nutrient loading and altered their biogeochemical forms. Consequently, the average concentrations of dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) and phosphorus (DIP) in the LZB increased by 2.6 and 1.0 times post-Rumbia and by 3.5 and 1.3 times post-Lekima, respectively. Relatively lower salinity and temperature, sudden increases in DIN, and strengthened coastal currents stimulated the growth of highly adaptable and small diatoms, resulting in the first diatom blooms. Subsequently, a bloom of Noctiluca scintillans formed.

Comparison of nutrients status in Liaodong Bay and Northern Yellow Sea, China: Controlling factors and nutrient budgets

Under the dual stress of global warming and human interaction, Liaodong Bay (LDB) and northern Yellow Sea (NYS) are undergoing significant ecological changes. Little is known about the driving nutrients characteristics supporting fishery resource output in these areas. We carried out three field observations in 2019 to investigate nutrient status. Results showed that dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN), dissolved inorganic phosphorus (DIP), and dissolved silica (DSi) concentrations changed seasonally, with lowest values in spring, and highest values in autumn. High DIN, DIP, and DSi concentrations were detected in LDB and NYS's estuary areas. The Yellow Sea Cold Water Mass plays a role in the distribution and seasonal variation of nutrients. Exchanges across the sediment-water interface, SFGD, atmospheric deposition, and the adjacent sea input dominated DIN dynamics of these areas. DIP primarily came from the adjacent sea input and DSi mainly originated from sediment release and the adjacent sea input. NYS seawater invasion accounted for 13.8% of DIN, 63.4% of DIP, and 35.1% of DSi in LDB. These results provide new insights to better facilitate the formulation of nitrogen and phosphorus reduction and control policies in these marginal seas.

Prediction on daily spatial distribution of chlorophyll-a in coastal seas using a synthetic method of remote sensing, machine learning and numerical modeling

Harmful algal blooms (HABs) pose a severe environmental issue and have significant economic and ecological consequences on coastal oceans. Predicting the occurrence of these blooms has become increasingly vital for coastal communities. To facilitate this, chlorophyll-a (Chl-a) levels have been widely used to forecast algal blooms. Although Hydro-biogeochemical (HBGC) process-based models display reasonable accuracy in predicting hydrodynamic variables and nutrients, they are not as effective in predicting Chl-a. Purely data-driven machine learning techniques also have limitations in accurately predicting Chl-a of high spatio-temporal resolutions. In this study, a coupled HBGC-Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) model was developed to predict the daily surface Chl-a distribution. The HBGC-CNN model integrates the information gathered by the HBGC model on temperature, salinity, dissolved inorganic nitrogen, dissolved organic phosphorus, and zooplankton with the remote sensing Chl-a products for the CNN model training. The results revealed that the HBGC-CNN model can effectively reproduce both daily and seasonal Chl-a variations, and interpret spatiotemporal information related to an HAB event triggered by the heavy rainfall during typhoon Lekima in 2019. Furthermore, this method can be used for data reconstruction, producing gap-free Chl-a products for historical reanalysis, especially in nearshore regions. The successful implementation of the HBGC-CNN model in predicting Chl-a highlights its potential in being incorporated into an operational forecasting system from a regional scale to a global scale, reducing the adverse impact of HAB disasters and facilitating emergency treatment.

Atmospheric deposition and river runoff stimulate the utilization of dissolved organic phosphorus in coastal seas

In coastal seas, the role of atmospheric deposition and river runoff in dissolved organic phosphorus (DOP) utilization is not well understood. Here, we address this knowledge gap by combining microcosm experiments with a global approach considering the relationship between the activity of alkaline phosphatases and changes in phytoplankton biomass in relation to the concentration of dissolved inorganic phosphorus (DIP). Our results suggest that the addition of aerosols and riverine water stimulate the biological utilization of DOP in coastal seas primarily by depleting DIP due to increasing nitrogen concentrations, which enhances phytoplankton growth. This "Anthropogenic Nitrogen Pump" was therefore identified to make DOP an important source of phosphorus for phytoplankton in coastal seas but only when the ratio of chlorophyll a to DIP [Log10 (Chl a / DIP)] is larger than 1.20. Our study therefore suggests that anthropogenic nitrogen input might contribute to the phosphorus cycle in coastal seas.

A simulation-optimization approach based on the compound eutrophication index to identify multi-nutrient allocated load

Eutrophication with nutrient enrichment is a global marine ecosystem concern that threatens human health, economic activities, and ecosystem functions. Therefore, a nutrient load optimization method is required to help control marine eutrophication. However, eutrophication-based nutrient allocated load optimization is a multi-objective project due to a series of eutrophication pressures, such as cross-regional land-based nutrient loads and multi-nutrient regimes and ratios. In this study, a synergistic multi-nutrient control method was developed for the Bohai Sea (BS), China, which links multi-nutrient pressures with eutrophication states. Based on the eutrophication control standard, which is the second level of compound eutrophication index (CEI), the total maximum allocated loads (CEI-based TMALs) of total dissolved nitrogen (TDN), total dissolved phosphorus (TDP), and the chemical oxygen demand (COD) were calculated by a simulation-optimization approach. Using the end year of China's 13th Five-Year Plan (2020) as the reference year, 154 high load pressure jurisdictions (HLPJs) that contribute to eutrophication response segments in the BS were identified. Accordingly, practiced the optimized annual reduction rates of TDN, TDP, and COD in the HLPJs at 15 %, 11 %, and 2 % according to CEIII, respectively, the proportion of eutrophicated areas gradually decreased from 32 % in 2020 to 15 % in 2025 and might be 0 % in 2035 with ecosystem resilience in 2035. In particular, under the annual reduction rates of TDN and TDP optimized based on CEIII, the DIN/DIP molar ratio in the BS decreased to 16:1 by 2035. The simulation-optimization approach associated with the CEI-based TMALs for multi-nutrient control in this study might make implementing land-sea coordination more efficiency and marine nutrient regime stably. This can provide scientific and technological support for improving the health of coastal ecosystems.

Nutrient dynamics in the Bohai and North Yellow seas from seasonal to decadal scales: Unveiling Bohai Sea eutrophication mitigation in the 2010s

The eutrophication status in the central Bohai Sea tends to be mitigated in recent years. To explore the recent nutrient status, seasonal surveys were carried out from 2018 to 2021, covering both the Bohai Sea and the adjacent North Yellow Sea. In recent cold seasons, both dissolved inorganic nitrogen concentration (DIN) and the ratio of DIN to soluble reactive phosphorus were lower than those in 2016. In warm seasons, the variations in nutrients and apparent oxygen utilization were correlated with each other, roughly following the traditional Redfield ratio of N:P:O2 of approximately 16:1:(-138). When historical data for N*, which is the excess DIN related to soluble reactive phosphorus, was collated, the Bohai Sea showed a decreasing trend for N* at a rate of -0.64 ± 0.12 μmol N* kg-1 a-1 between 2011 and 2021. During the same period, the North Yellow Sea N* concentrations (i.e., the oceanic end-member of the Bohai Sea N* dynamics) and the local atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition (atmospheric end-member) were estimated to decline at rates of -0.22 ± 0.04 μmol N* kg-1 a-1 and - 0.93 ± 0.34 kg N ha-1 a-2, respectively. Consequently, the oceanic and atmospheric changes accounted for 25.7 % ± 28.4 % and 69.0 % ± 42.6 %, respectively, of the Bohai Sea eutrophication mitigation in 2011-2021. On the long-term changes of the Bohai Sea eutrophication, the terrestrial nutrient source has only minor (likely <10 %) impacts, although it certainly affects the spatial distribution of nutrients. This study has implied that coastal eutrophication is a dynamic process that is subject to sea-land-air interactions, and its mitigation needs both local pollution controls and regional environment management. The latter contains the understanding of oceanic changes and external effects of the air pollution control.

Nutrient changes in the Bohai Sea over the past two decades

With the growing problem of eutrophication in the Bohai Sea, actions have been taken to reduce nutrient inputs, but it remains to be seen whether nutrient levels and structure have been ameliorated. In this study, the nutrient trends in the Bohai Sea are re-examined based on observations from 2000 to 2019. The results suggest that dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) concentrations and DIN/DIP (dissolved inorganic phosphate) ratios gradually increased from 2000 to 2013 but dramatically decreased from 2013 to 2019. The increase and decrease rates of DIN concentrations decreased with increasing water depth, indicating that DIN concentrations in nearshore waters responded more rapidly to changes in human activities. However, DIP concentrations responded weakly to nutrient inputs, with their trends uncoupled. The DIN/DIP ratios have declined close to and in some seasons even below the canonical Redfield ratio in areas with water depths >20 m recently, implying that relative nutrient limitation in these areas may be shifting from relative phosphorus (P) limitation to absence of relative nutrient limitation or relative nitrogen (N) limitation. Atmospheric deposition, wastewater discharge, and riverine input were responsible for 66 %, 21 %, and 13 % of the variance in the decline of DIN concentration, respectively. Several environmental indicators responded positively to the decrease in DIN concentrations and DIN/DIP ratios, with varying degrees of recovery recently. Our study proves the phased success of various nutrient reduction measures taken by the Chinese government to improve the environment of the Bohai Sea over the past decade.

Nutrients transport behavior in inlet river in the Yellow River Delta in winter

The nutrients such as dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN, NH4+-N, NO2--N, and NO3--N), dissolved inorganic phosphorus (DIP, PO43-) and dissolved SiO2 (DSi) funneled by the inlet river are the dominant factors to coastal eutrophication. This study investigated nutrient transport process in typical inlet rivers in the Yellow River Delta. The indicator of coastal eutrophication potential and concentration ratio between upstream and downstream stations were used to evaluate the influence of different sources to the nutrient risks. It showed that urban areas are the most important source of the nutrients in studied rivers. The harbor and mariculture would have greater risk because of their proximity close to the coastal area. Wetland was a vital conversion to eliminate the river nutrients, and the retention could reach 80 %. It is imperative to protect and construct wetlands to reduce the nutrient pollution in the inlet river.