Novel findings associated with MTM1 suggest a higher number of female symptomatic carriers

The myotubular and centronuclear myopathy patient registry: a multifunctional tool for translational research

The Myotubular and Centronuclear Myopathy Registry is an international research database containing key longitudinal data on a diverse and growing cohort of individuals affected by this group of rare and ultra-rare neuromuscular conditions. It can inform and support all areas of translational research including epidemiological and natural history studies, clinical trial feasibility planning, recruitment for clinical trials or other research studies, stand-alone clinical studies, standards of care development, and provision of real-world evidence data. For ten years, it has also served as a valuable communications tool and provided a link between the scientific and patient communities. With the anticipated advent of disease-modifying therapies for these conditions, the registry is a key resource for the generation of post-authorisation data for regulatory decision-making, real world evidence, and patient-reported outcome measures. In this paper we present some key data from the current 444 registered individuals with the following genotype split: MTM1 n=270, DNM2 n=42, BIN1 n=4, TTN n=4, RYR1 n=12, other n=4, unknown n=108. The data presented are consistent with the current literature and the common understanding of a strong genotype/phenotype correlations in CNM, most notably the data supports the current knowledge that XLMTM is typically the most severe form of CNM. Additionally, we outline the ways in which the registry supports research, and, more generally, the importance of continuous investment and development to maintain the relevance of registries for all stakeholders. Further information on the registry and contact details are available on the registry website at www.mtmcnmregistry.org.

Prognostic Value of Genotype-Phenotype Correlations in X-Linked Myotubular Myopathy and the Use of the Face2Gene Application as an Effective Non-Invasive Diagnostic Tool

BACKGROUND

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) is a rare congenital myopathy resulting from dysfunction of the protein myotubularin encoded by the MTM1 gene. XLMTM has a high neonatal and infantile mortality rate due to a severe myopathic phenotype and respiratory failure. However, in a minority of XLMTM cases, patients present with milder phenotypes and achieve ambulation and adulthood. Notable facial dysmorphia is also present.

METHODS

We investigated the genotype-phenotype correlations in newly diagnosed XLMTM patients in a patients' cohort (previously published data plus three novel variants, n = 414). Based on the facial gestalt difference between XLMTM patients and unaffected controls, we investigated the use of the Face2Gene application.

RESULTS

Significant associations between severe phenotype and truncating variants (p < 0.001), frameshift variants (p < 0.001), nonsense variants (p = 0.006), and in/del variants (p = 0.036) were present. Missense variants were significantly associated with the mild and moderate phenotype (p < 0.001). The Face2Gene application showed a significant difference between XLMTM patients and unaffected controls (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Using genotype-phenotype correlations could predict the disease course in most XLMTM patients, but still with limitations. The Face2Gene application seems to be a practical, non-invasive diagnostic approach in XLMTM using the correct algorithm.

Highly asymmetrical distribution of muscle wasting correlates to the heteroplasmy in a patient carrying a large-scale mitochondrial DNA deletion: a novel pathophysiological mechanism for explaining asymmetry in mitochondrial myopathies

Mitochondrial diseases are a heterogeneous group of pathologies, caused by missense mutations, sporadic large-scale deletions of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) or mutations of nuclear maintenance genes. We report the case of a patient in whom extended muscle pathology, biochemical and genetic mtDNA analyses have proven to be essential to elucidate a unique asymmetrical myopathic presentation. From the age of 34 years on, the patient has presented with oculomotor disorders, right facial peripheral palsy and predominantly left upper limb muscle weakness and atrophy. By contrast, he displayed no motor weakness on the right hemi-body, and no sensory symptoms, cerebellar syndrome, hypoacusis, or parkinsonism. Cardiac function was normal. CK levels were elevated (671 UI/L). Electroneuromyography (ENMG) and muscle MRI showed diffuse myogenic alterations, more pronounced on the left side muscles. Biopsy of the left deltoid muscle showed multiple mitochondrial defects, whereas in the right deltoid, mitochondrial defects were much less marked. Extended mitochondrial biochemical and molecular workup revealed a unique mtDNA deletion, with a 63.4% heteroplasmy load in the left deltoid, versus 8.1% in the right one. This case demonstrates that, in mitochondrial myopathies, heteroplasmy levels may drastically vary for the same type of muscle, rising the hypothesis of a new pathophysiological mechanism explaining asymmetry in hereditary myopathies.

Clinical, genetic, and histological features of centronuclear myopathy in the Netherlands

Centronuclear myopathy (CNM) is a genetically heterogeneous congenital myopathy characterized by muscle weakness, atrophy, and variable degrees of cardiorespiratory involvement. The clinical severity is largely explained by genotype (DNM2, MTM1, RYR1, BIN1, TTN, and other rarer genetic backgrounds), specific mutation(s), and age of the patient. The histopathological hallmark of CNM is the presence of internal centralized nuclei on muscle biopsy. Information on the phenotypical spectrum, subtype prevalence, and phenotype–genotype correlations is limited. To characterize CNM more comprehensively, we retrospectively assessed a national cohort of 48 CNM patients (mean age = 32 ± 24 years, range 0–80, 54% males) from the Netherlands clinically, histologically, and genetically. All information was extracted from entries in the patient's medical records, between 2000 and 2020. Frequent clinical features in addition to muscle weakness and hypotonia were fatigue and exercise intolerance in more mildly affected cases. Genetic analysis showed variants in four genes (18 DNM2, 14 MTM1, 9 RYR1, and 7 BIN1), including 16 novel variants. In addition to central nuclei, histologic examination revealed a large variability of myopathic features in the different genotypes. The identification and characterization of these patients contribute to trial readiness.

Spectrum of Clinical Features in X-Linked Myotubular Myopathy Carriers: An International Questionnaire Study

OBJECTIVE

To characterize the spectrum of clinical features in a cohort of X-linked myotubular myopathy (XL-MTM) carriers, including prevalence, genetic features, clinical symptoms, and signs, as well as associated disease burden.

METHODS

We performed a cross-sectional online questionnaire study among XL-MTM carriers. Participants were recruited from patient associations, medical centers, and registries in the United Kingdom, Germany, and the Netherlands. We used a custom-made questionnaire, the Checklist Individual Strength (CIS), the Frenchay Activities Index (FAI), the Short Form 12 (SF-12) health survey, and the McGill Pain Questionnaire. Carriers were classified as manifesting or nonmanifesting on the basis of self-reported ambulation and muscle weakness.

RESULTS

The prevalence of manifesting carriers in this study population (n = 76) was 51%, subdivided into mild (independent ambulation, 39%), moderate (assisted ambulation, 9%), and severe (wheelchair dependent, 3%) phenotypes. In addition to muscle weakness, manifesting carriers frequently reported fatigue (70%) and exercise intolerance (49%). Manifesting carriers scored higher on the overall CIS (p = 0.001), the fatigue subscale (p < 0.001), and least severe pain subscale (p = 0.005) than nonmanifesting carriers. They scored lower on the FAI (p = 0.005) and the physical component of the SF-12 health survey (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The prevalence of manifesting XL-MTM carriers may be higher than currently assumed, most having a mild phenotype and a wide variety of symptoms. Manifesting carriers are particularly affected by fatigue, limitations of daily activities, pain, and reduced quality of life. Our findings should increase awareness and provide useful information for health care providers and future clinical trials.

Is Gene-Size an Issue for the Diagnosis of Skeletal Muscle Disorders?

Human genes have a variable length. Those having a coding sequence of extraordinary length and a high number of exons were almost impossible to sequence using the traditional Sanger-based gene-by-gene approach. High-throughput sequencing has partly overcome the size-related technical issues, enabling a straightforward, rapid and relatively inexpensive analysis of large genes.

Several large genes (e.g. TTN, NEB, RYR1, DMD) are recognized as disease-causing in patients with skeletal muscle diseases. However, because of their sheer size, the clinical interpretation of variants in these genes is probably the most challenging aspect of the high-throughput genetic investigation in the field of skeletal muscle diseases.

The main aim of this review is to discuss the technical and interpretative issues related to the diagnostic investigation of large genes and to reflect upon the current state of the art and the future advancements in the field.

Symptomatic heterozygous X-Linked myotubular myopathy female patient with a large deletion at Xq28 and decrease expression of normal allele

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM; OMIM 310400) is a centronuclear congenital muscular disorder of X-linked recessive inheritance. Although female carriers are typically asymptomatic, affected heterozygous females have been described. Here, we describe the case of a sporadic female patient with suspicion of centronuclear myopathy and a heterozygous large deletion at Xq28 encompassing the MAMLD1, MTM1, MTMR1, CD99L2, and HMGB3 genes. The deletion was first detected using a custom next generation sequencing (NGS)-based multigene panel and finally characterized by comparative genomic hybridization array and multiplex ligation probe assay techniques. In this patient we have confirmed, by MTM1 mRNA quantification, a MTM1 gene expression less than the expected 50 percent in patient muscle. The significant 20% reduction in MTM1 mRNA expression in muscle, precludes low level of the normal myotubularin protein as the cause of the phenotype in this heterozygous female. We have also found that BIN1 expression in patient muscle biopsy was significantly increased, and postulate that BIN1 expression will be increased in XLMTM patient muscle as an attempt to maintain muscle function.

Update on Congenital Myopathies in Adulthood

Congenital myopathies (CMs) constitute a group of heterogenous rare inherited muscle diseases with different incidences. They are traditionally grouped based on characteristic histopathological findings revealed on muscle biopsy. In recent decades, the ever-increasing application of modern genetic technologies has not just improved our understanding of their pathophysiology, but also expanded their phenotypic spectrum and contributed to a more genetically based approach for their classification. Later onset forms of CMs are increasingly recognised. They are often considered milder with slower progression, variable clinical presentations and different modes of inheritance. We reviewed the key features and genetic basis of late onset CMs with a special emphasis on those forms that may first manifest in adulthood.

Adult MTM1-related myopathy carriers: Classification based on deep phenotyping

OBJECTIVE

To better characterize adult myotubularin 1 (MTM1)-related myopathy carriers and recommend a phenotypic classification.

METHODS

This cohort study was performed at the NIH Clinical Center. Participants were required to carry a confirmed MTM1 mutation and were recruited via the Congenital Muscle Disease International Registry (n = 8), a traveling local clinic of the Neuromuscular and Neurogenetic Disorders of Childhood Section, National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, NIH and Cure CMD (n = 1), and direct physician referral (n = 1). Neuromuscular examinations, muscle MRI, dynamic breathing MRI, cardiac MRI, pulmonary function tests (PFTs), physical therapy assessments including the Motor Function Measure 32 (MFM-32) scale, and X chromosome inactivation (XCI) studies were performed.

RESULTS

Phenotypic categories were proposed based on ambulatory status and muscle weakness. Carriers were categorized as severe (nonambulatory; n = 1), moderate (minimal independent ambulation/assisted ambulation; n = 3), mild (independent ambulation but with evidence of muscle weakness; n = 4), and nonmanifesting (no evidence of muscle weakness; n = 2). Carriers with more severe muscle weakness exhibited greater degrees of respiratory insufficiency and abnormal signal on muscle imaging. Skeletal asymmetries were evident in both manifesting and nonmanifesting carriers. Skewed XCI did not explain phenotypic severity.

CONCLUSION

This work illustrates the phenotypic range of MTM1-related myopathy carriers in adulthood and recommends a phenotypic classification. This classification, defined by ambulatory status and muscle weakness, is supported by muscle MRI, PFT, and MFM-32 scale composite score findings, which may serve as markers of disease progression and outcome measures in future gene therapy or other clinical trials.

Update on the Genetics of Congenital Myopathies

The congenital myopathies form a large clinically and genetically heterogeneous group of disorders. Currently mutations in at least 27 different genes have been reported to cause a congenital myopathy, but the number is expected to increase due to the accelerated use of next-generation sequencing methods. There is substantial overlap between the causative genes and the clinical and histopathologic features of the congenital myopathies. The mode of inheritance can be autosomal recessive, autosomal dominant or X-linked. Both dominant and recessive mutations in the same gene can cause a similar disease phenotype, and the same clinical phenotype can also be caused by mutations in different genes. Clear genotype-phenotype correlations are few and far between.

Copy Number Variants Account for a Tiny Fraction of Undiagnosed Myopathic Patients

Next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies have led to an increase in the diagnosis of heterogeneous genetic conditions. However, over 50% of patients with a genetically inherited disease are still without a diagnosis. In these cases, different hypotheses are usually postulated, including variants in novel genes or elusive mutations. Although the impact of copy number variants (CNVs) in neuromuscular disorders has been largely ignored to date, missed CNVs are predicted to have a major role in disease causation as some very large genes, such as the dystrophin gene, have prone-to-deletion regions. Since muscle tissues express several large disease genes, the presence of elusive CNVs needs to be comprehensively assessed following an accurate and systematic approach. In this multicenter cohort study, we analyzed 234 undiagnosed myopathy patients using a custom array comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) that covers all muscle disease genes at high resolution. Twenty-two patients (9.4%) showed non-polymorphic CNVs. In 12 patients (5.1%), the identified CNVs were considered responsible for the observed phenotype. An additional ten patients (4.3%) presented candidate CNVs not yet proven to be causative. Our study indicates that deletions and duplications may account for 5⁻9% of genetically unsolved patients. This strongly suggests that other mechanisms of disease are yet to be discovered.

Non-compaction cardiomyopathy and early respiratory failure in an adult symptomatic female carrier of centronuclear myopathy caused by a MTM1 mutation

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) is a rare neuromuscular condition caused by mutations in the MTM1 gene. Female carriers are believed to be usually asymptomatic; nevertheless, recent reports have displayed a wide a spectrum of clinical involvement in females suggesting that MTM1 mutations might be underestimated in this population. Here we report a 55-year-old woman manifesting with an abrupt respiratory decline, whose respiratory function tests revealed a severe restrictive ventilatory defect. The neurological examination identified mild proximal leg weakness and her cardiac evaluation showed a non-compaction cardiomyopathy with normal left ventricle function. Muscle biopsy was consistent with centronuclear myopathy. Next-generation sequencing of 49 genes related to congenital myopathies allowed the identification of a 4 bp deletion in the MTM1 gene, leading to a truncating mutation previously described in males but for the first time reported in a female patient.

The genetics of congenital myopathies

Congenital myopathies are a clinically and genetically heterogeneous group of conditions that most commonly present at or around the time of birth with hypotonia, muscle weakness, and (often) respiratory distress. Historically, this group of disorders has been subclassified based on muscle histopathologic characteristics. There has been an explosion of gene discovery, and there are now at least 32 different genetic causes of disease. With this increased understanding of the genetic basis of disease has come the knowledge that the mutations in congenital myopathy genes can present with a wide variety of clinical phenotypes and can result in a broad spectrum of histopathologic findings on muscle biopsy. In addition, mutations in several genes can share the same histopathologic features. The identification of new genes and interpretation of different pathomechanisms at a molecular level have helped us to understand the clinical and histopathologic similarities that this group of disorders share. In this review, we highlight the genetic understanding for each subtype, its pathogenesis, and the future key issues in congenital myopathies.

Whole exome sequencing discloses a pathogenic MTM1 gene mutation and ends the diagnostic odyssey in an older woman with a progressive and seemingly sporadic myopathy: Case report and literature review of MTM1 manifesting female carriers

We report the case of a 58-year-old woman with a progressive and seemingly sporadic myopathy who, later through whole exome sequencing, was diagnosed as a manifesting carrier of a myotubularin 1 gene mutation (c.342_342 + 4delAGTAA). As the case was a diagnostic challenge for 7 years, we thought it would be helpful to report the patient and review the other 25 cases thus far described. The manifesting carrier state is a rare cause for myopathic weakness in a female but should be strongly considered in kindreds with known affected males with myotubularin 1 gene mutations, and families with history of gestational polyhydramnios or male infantile death. Although the clinical phenotype is quite variable, the findings of ptosis, ophthalmoparesis, facial weakness, and asymmetrical limb involvement should raise the suspicion of the manifesting carrier state. Necklace fibers appear to be a highly sensitive and specific pathologic finding in such cases.

Congenital myopathies: not only a paediatric topic

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This article reviews adult presentations of the major congenital myopathies - central core disease, multiminicore disease, centronuclear myopathy and nemaline myopathy - with an emphasis on common genetic backgrounds, typical clinicopathological features and differential diagnosis.

RECENT FINDINGS

The congenital myopathies are a genetically heterogeneous group of conditions with characteristic histopathological features. Although essentially considered paediatric conditions, some forms - in particular those due to dominant mutations in the skeletal muscle ryanodine receptor (RYR1), the dynamin 2 (DNM2), the amphiphysin 2 (BIN1) and the Kelch repeat-and BTB/POZ domain-containing protein 13 (KBTBD13) gene - may present late into adulthood. Moreover, dominant RYR1 mutations associated with the malignant hyperthermia susceptibility trait have been recently identified as a common cause of (exertional) rhabdomyolysis presenting throughout life. In addition, improved standards of care and development of new therapies will result in an increasing number of patients with early-onset presentations transitioning to the adult neuromuscular clinic. Lastly, if nemaline rods are the predominant histopathological feature, acquired treatable conditions have to be considered in the differential diagnosis.

SUMMARY

Recently identified genotypes and phenotypes indicate a spectrum of the congenital myopathies extending into late adulthood, with important implications for clinical practice.

Next-generation sequencing approaches for the diagnosis of skeletal muscle disorders

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The development of next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies is transforming the practice of medical genetics and revolutionizing the approach to heterogeneous hereditary conditions, including skeletal muscle disorders. Here, we review the different NGS approaches described in the literature so far for the characterization of myopathic patients and the results obtained from the implementation of such approaches in a clinical setting.

RECENT FINDINGS

The overall diagnostic rate of NGS strategies for patients affected by skeletal muscle disorders is higher than the success rate obtained using the traditional gene-by-gene approach. Moreover, many recent articles have been expanding the clinical phenotypes associated with already known disease genes.

SUMMARY

NGS applications will soon be the first-tier test for skeletal muscle disorders. They will improve the diagnosis in myopathic patients, promoting their inclusion into novel therapeutic trials. At the same time, they will improve our knowledge about the molecular mechanisms causing skeletal muscle disorders, favoring the development of novel therapeutic approaches.

Affected female carriers of MTM1 mutations display a wide spectrum of clinical and pathological involvement: delineating diagnostic clues

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM), a severe congenital myopathy, is caused by mutations in the MTM1 gene located on the X chromosome. A majority of affected males die in the early postnatal period, whereas female carriers are believed to be usually asymptomatic. Nevertheless, several affected females have been reported. To assess the phenotypic and pathological spectra of carrier females and to delineate diagnostic clues, we characterized 17 new unrelated affected females and performed a detailed comparison with previously reported cases at the clinical, muscle imaging, histological, ultrastructural and molecular levels. Taken together, the analysis of this large cohort of 43 cases highlights a wide spectrum of clinical severity ranging from severe neonatal and generalized weakness, similar to XLMTM male, to milder adult forms. Several females show a decline in respiratory function. Asymmetric weakness is a noteworthy frequent specific feature potentially correlated to an increased prevalence of highly skewed X inactivation. Asymmetry of growth was also noted. Other diagnostic clues include facial weakness, ptosis and ophthalmoplegia, skeletal and joint abnormalities, and histopathological signs that are hallmarks of centronuclear myopathy such as centralized nuclei and necklace fibers. The histopathological findings also demonstrate a general disorganization of muscle structure in addition to these specific hallmarks. Thus, MTM1 mutations in carrier females define a specific myopathy, which may be independent of the presence of an XLMTM male in the family. As several of the reported affected females carry large heterozygous MTM1 deletions not detectable by Sanger sequencing, and as milder phenotypes present as adult-onset limb-girdle myopathy, the prevalence of this myopathy is likely to be greatly underestimated. This report should aid diagnosis and thus the clinical management and genetic counseling of MTM1 carrier females. Furthermore, the clinical and pathological history of this cohort may be useful for therapeutic projects in males with XLMTM, as it illustrates the spectrum of possible evolution of the disease in patients surviving long term.

Congenital myopathies: clinical phenotypes and new diagnostic tools

Congenital myopathies are a group of genetic muscle disorders characterized clinically by hypotonia and weakness, usually from birth, and a static or slowly progressive clinical course. Historically, congenital myopathies have been classified on the basis of major morphological features seen on muscle biopsy. However, different genes have now been identified as associated with the various phenotypic and histological expressions of these disorders, and in recent years, because of their unexpectedly wide genetic and clinical heterogeneity, next-generation sequencing has increasingly been used for their diagnosis. We reviewed clinical and genetic forms of congenital myopathy and defined possible strategies to improve cost-effectiveness in histological and imaging diagnosis.

Systemic AAV8-Mediated Gene Therapy Drives Whole-Body Correction of Myotubular Myopathy in Dogs

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) results from MTM1 gene mutations and myotubularin deficiency. Most XLMTM patients develop severe muscle weakness leading to respiratory failure and death, typically within 2 years of age. Our objective was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of systemic gene therapy in the p.N155K canine model of XLMTM by performing a dose escalation study. A recombinant adeno-associated virus serotype 8 (rAAV8) vector expressing canine myotubularin (cMTM1) under the muscle-specific desmin promoter (rAAV8-cMTM1) was administered by simple peripheral venous infusion in XLMTM dogs at 10 weeks of age, when signs of the disease are already present. A comprehensive analysis of survival, limb strength, gait, respiratory function, neurological assessment, histology, vector biodistribution, transgene expression, and immune response was performed over a 9-month study period. Results indicate that systemic gene therapy was well tolerated, prolonged lifespan, and corrected the skeletal musculature throughout the body in a dose-dependent manner, defining an efficacious dose in this large-animal model of the disease. These results support the development of gene therapy clinical trials for XLMTM.

An Emerging Female Phenotype with Loss-of-Function Mutations in the Aristaless-Related Homeodomain Transcription Factor ARX

The devastating clinical presentation of X-linked lissencephaly with abnormal genitalia (XLAG) is invariably caused by loss-of-function mutations in the Aristaless-related homeobox (ARX) gene. Mutations in this X-chromosome gene contribute to intellectual disability (ID) with co-morbidities including seizures and movement disorders such as dystonia in affected males. The detection of affected females with mutations in ARX is increasing. We present a family with multiple affected individuals, including two females. Two male siblings presenting with XLAG were deceased prior to full-term gestation or within the first few weeks of life. Of the two female siblings, one presented with behavioral disturbances, mild ID, a seizure disorder, and complete agenesis of the corpus callosum (ACC), similar to the mother's phenotype. A novel insertion mutation in Exon 2 of ARX was identified, c.982delCinsTTT predicted to cause a frameshift at p.(Q328Ffs^* 37). Our finding is consistent with loss-of-function mutations in ARX causing XLAG in hemizygous males and extends the findings of ID and seizures in heterozygous females. We review the reported phenotypes of females with mutations in ARX and highlight the importance of screening ARX in male and female patients with ID, seizures, and in particular with complete ACC.