Extreme mechanical stability in protein complexes

Mechanochemistry: Fundamental Principles and Applications

Mechanochemistry is an emerging research field at the interface of physics, mechanics, materials science, and chemistry. Complementary to traditional activation methods in chemistry, such as heat, electricity, and light, mechanochemistry focuses on the activation of chemical reactions by directly or indirectly applying mechanical forces. It has evolved as a powerful tool for controlling chemical reactions in solid state systems, sensing and responding to stresses in polymer materials, regulating interfacial adhesions, and stimulating biological processes. By combining theoretical approaches, simulations and experimental techniques, researchers have gained intricate insights into the mechanisms underlying mechanochemistry. In this review, the physical chemistry principles underpinning mechanochemistry are elucidated and a comprehensive overview of recent significant achievements in the discovery of mechanically responsive chemical processes is provided, with a particular emphasis on their applications in materials science. Additionally, The perspectives and insights into potential future directions for this exciting research field are offered.

Revealing the Control Mechanisms of pH on the Solution Properties of Chitin via Single-Molecule Studies

Chitin is one of the most common polysaccharides and is abundant in the cell walls of fungi and the shells of insects and aquatic organisms as a skeleton. The mechanism of how chitin responds to pH is essential to the precise control of brewing and the design of smart chitin materials. However, this molecular mechanism remains a mystery. Results from single-molecule studies, including single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS), AFM imaging, and molecular dynamic (MD) simulations, have shown that the mechanical and conformational behaviors of chitin molecules show surprising pH responsiveness. This can be compared with how, in natural aqueous solutions, chitin tends to form a more relaxed spreading conformation and show considerable elasticity under low stretching forces in acidic conditions. However, its molecular chain collapses into a rigid globule in alkaline solutions. The results show that the chain state of chitin can be regulated by the proportions of inter- and intramolecular H-bonds, which are determined via the number of water bridges on the chain under different pH values. This basic study may be helpful for understanding the cellular activities of fungi under pH stress and the design of chitin-based drug carriers.

Catch Bond-Mediated Adhesion Drives Staphylococcus aureus Host Cell Invasion

Various viruses and pathogenic bacteria interact with annexin A2 to invade mammalian cells. Here, we show that Staphylococcus aureus engages in extremely strong catch bonds for host cell invasion. By means of single-molecule atomic force microscopy, we find that bacterial surface-located clumping factors bind annexin A2 with extraordinary strength, indicating that these bonds are extremely resilient to mechanical tension. By determining the lifetimes of the complexes under increasing mechanical stress, we demonstrate that the adhesins form catch bonds with their ligand that are capable to sustain forces of 1500-1700 pN. The force-dependent adhesion mechanism identified here provides a molecular framework to explain how S. aureus pathogens tightly attach to host cells during invasion and shows promise for the design of new therapeutics against intracellular S. aureus.

Bacterial Adhesion Strength on Titanium Surfaces Quantified by Atomic Force Microscopy: A Systematic Review

Few studies have been able to elucidate the correlation of factors determining the strength of interaction between bacterial cells and substrate at the molecular level. The aim was to answer the following question: What biophysical factors should be considered when analyzing the bacterial adhesion strength on titanium surfaces and its alloys for implants quantified by atomic force microscopy? This review followed PRISMA. The search strategy was applied in four databases. The selection process was carried out in two stages. The risk of bias was analyzed. One thousand four hundred sixty-three articles were found. After removing the duplicates, 1126 were screened by title and abstract, of which 57 were selected for full reading and 5 were included; 3 had a low risk of bias and 2 moderated risks of bias. (1) The current literature shows the preference of bacteria to adhere to surfaces of the same hydrophilicity. However, this fact was contradicted by this systematic review, which demonstrated that hydrophobic bacteria developed hydrogen bonds and adhered to hydrophilic surfaces; (2) the application of surface treatments that induce the reduction of areas favorable for bacterial adhesion interfere more in the formation of biofilm than surface roughness; and (3) bacterial colonization should be evaluated in time-dependent studies as they develop adaptation mechanisms, related to time, which are obscure in this review.

High-force catch bonds between the Staphylococcus aureus surface protein SdrE and complement regulator factor H drive immune evasion

The invasive bacterial pathogen Staphylococcus aureus recruits the complement regulatory protein factor H (fH) to its surface to evade the human immune system. Here, we report the identification of an extremely high-force catch bond used by the S. aureus surface protein SdrE to efficiently capture fH under mechanical stress. We find that increasing the external force applied to the SdrE-fH complex prolongs the lifetime of the bond at an extraordinary high force, 1,400 pN, above which the bond lifetime decreases as an ordinary slip bond. This catch-bond behavior originates from a variation of the dock, lock and latch interaction, where the SdrE ligand binding domains undergo conformational changes under stress, enabling the formation of long-lived hydrogen bonds with fH. The binding mechanism dissected here represents a potential target for new therapeutics against multidrug-resistant S. aureus strains.

The role of single protein elasticity in mechanobiology

In addition to biochemical signals and genetic considerations, mechanical forces are rapidly emerging as a master regulator of human physiology. Yet the molecular mechanisms that regulate force-induced functionalities across a wide range of scales, encompassing the cell, tissue or organ levels, are comparatively not so well understood. With the advent, development and refining of single molecule nanomechanical techniques, enabling to exquisitely probe the conformational dynamics of individual proteins under the effect of a calibrated force, we have begun to acquire a comprehensive knowledge on the rich plethora of physicochemical principles that regulate the elasticity of single proteins. Here we review the major advances underpinning our current understanding of how the elasticity of single proteins regulates mechanosensing and mechanotransduction. We discuss the present limitations and future challenges of such a prolific and burgeoning field.

Interaction of the Staphylococcus aureus Surface Protein FnBPB with Corneodesmosin Involves Two Distinct, Extremely Strong Bonds

Attachment of Staphylococcus aureus to human skin corneocyte cells plays a critical role in exacerbating the severity of atopic dermatitis (AD). Pathogen-skin adhesion is mediated by bacterial cell-surface proteins called adhesins, including fibronectin-binding protein B (FnBPB). FnBPB binds to corneodesmosin (CDSN), a glycoprotein exposed on AD patient corneocytes. Using single-molecule experiments, we demonstrate that CDSN binding by FnBPB relies on a sophisticated two-site mechanism. Both sites form extremely strong bonds with binding forces of ∼1 and ∼2.5 nN albeit with faster dissociation rates than those reported for homologues of the adhesin. This previously unidentified two-binding site interaction in FnBPB illustrates its remarkable variety of adhesive functions and is of biological significance as the high strength and short bond lifetime will favor efficient skin colonization by the pathogen.

Histidine-Specific Bioconjugation for Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) based single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) is a powerful tool to study the mechanical properties of proteins. In these experiments, site-specific immobilization of proteins is critical, as the tether determines the direction and amplitude of forces applied to the protein of interest. However, existing methods are mainly based on thiol chemistry or specific protein tags, which cannot meet the need of many challenging experiments. Here, we developed a histidine-specific phosphorylation strategy to covalently anchor proteins to an AFM cantilever tip or the substrate via their histidine tag or surface-exposed histidine residues. The formed covalent linkage was mechanically stable with rupture forces of over 1.3 nN. This protein immobilization method considerably improved the pickup rate and data quality of SMFS experiments. We further demonstrated the use of this method to explore the pulling-direction-dependent mechanical stability of green fluorescent protein and the unfolding of the membrane protein archaerhodopsin-3.

Mechanical Stabilization of a Bacterial Adhesion Complex

The adhesions between Gram-positive bacteria and their hosts are exposed to varying magnitudes of tensile forces. Here, using an ultrastable magnetic tweezer-based single-molecule approach, we show the catch-bond kinetics of the prototypical adhesion complex of SD-repeat protein G (SdrG) to a peptide from fibrinogen β (Fgβ) over a physiologically important force range from piconewton (pN) to tens of pN, which was not technologically accessible to previous studies. At 37 °C, the lifetime of the complex exponentially increases from seconds at several pN to ∼1000 s as the force reaches 30 pN, leading to mechanical stabilization of the adhesion. The dissociation transition pathway is determined as the unbinding of a critical β-strand peptide (“latch” strand of SdrG that secures the entire adhesion complex) away from its binding cleft, leading to the dissociation of the Fgβ ligand. Similar mechanical stabilization behavior is also observed in several homologous adhesions, suggesting the generality of catch-bond kinetics in such bacterial adhesions. We reason that such mechanical stabilization confers multiple advantages in the pathogenesis and adaptation of bacteria.

Optimal Sacrificial Domains in Mechanical Polyproteins: S. epidermidis Adhesins Are Tuned for Work Dissipation

The opportunistic pathogen Staphylococcus epidermidis utilizes a multidomain surface adhesin protein to bind host components and adhere to tissues. While it is known that the interaction between the SdrG receptor and its fibrinopeptide target (FgB) is exceptionally mechanostable (∼2 nN), the influence of downstream B domains (B1 and B2) is unclear. Here, we studied the mechanical relationships between folded B domains and the SdrG receptor bound to FgB. We used protein engineering, single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) with an atomic force microscope (AFM), and Monte Carlo simulations to understand how the mechanical properties of folded sacrificial domains, in general, can be optimally tuned to match the stability of a receptor-ligand complex. Analogous to macroscopic suspension systems, sacrificial shock absorber domains should neither be too weak nor too strong to optimally dissipate mechanical energy. We built artificial molecular shock absorber systems based on the nanobody (VHH) scaffold and studied the competition between domain unfolding and receptor unbinding. We quantitatively determined the optimal stability of shock absorbers that maximizes work dissipation on average for a given receptor and found that natural sacrificial domains from pathogenic S. epidermidis and Clostridium perfringens adhesins exhibit stabilities at or near this optimum within a specific range of loading rates. These findings demonstrate how tuning the stability of sacrificial domains in adhesive polyproteins can be used to maximize mechanical work dissipation and serve as an adhesion strategy by bacteria.

Cell-Cell Mating Interactions: Overview and Potential of Single-Cell Force Spectroscopy

It is an understatement that mating and DNA transfer are key events for living organisms. Among the traits needed to facilitate mating, cell adhesion between gametes is a universal requirement. Thus, there should be specific properties for the adhesion proteins involved in mating. Biochemical and biophysical studies have revealed structural information about mating adhesins, as well as their specificities and affinities, leading to some ideas about these specialized adhesion proteins. Recently, single-cell force spectroscopy (SCFS) has added important findings. In SCFS, mating cells are brought into contact in an atomic force microscope (AFM), and the adhesive forces are monitored through the course of mating. The results have shown some remarkable characteristics of mating adhesins and add knowledge about the design and evolution of mating adhesins.

AFM Identifies a Protein Complex Involved in Pathogen Adhesion Which Ruptures at Three Nanonewtons

Staphylococci bind to the blood protein von Willebrand Factor (vWF), thereby causing endovascular infections. Whether and how this interaction occurs with the medically important pathogen Staphylococcus epidermidis is unknown. Using single-molecule experiments, we demonstrate that the S. epidermidis protein Aap binds vWF via an ultrastrong force, ∼3 nN, the strongest noncovalent biological bond ever reported, and we show that this interaction is activated by tensile loading, suggesting a catch-bond behavior. Aap-vWF binding involves exclusively the A1 domain of vWF but requires both the A and B domains of Aap, as revealed by inhibition assays using specific monoclonal antibodies. Collectively, our results point to a mechanism where force-induced unfolding of the B repeats activates the A domain of Aap, shifting it from a weak- to a strong-binding state, which then engages into an ultrastrong interaction with vWF A1. This shear-dependent function of Aap offers promise for innovative antistaphylococcal therapies.

Bioconjugation Strategies for Connecting Proteins to DNA-Linkers for Single-Molecule Force-Based Experiments

The mechanical properties of proteins can be studied with single molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) using optical tweezers, atomic force microscopy and magnetic tweezers. It is common to utilize a flexible linker between the protein and trapped probe to exclude short-range interactions in SMFS experiments. One of the most prevalent linkers is DNA due to its well-defined properties, although attachment strategies between the DNA linker and protein or probe may vary. We will therefore provide a general overview of the currently existing non-covalent and covalent bioconjugation strategies to site-specifically conjugate DNA-linkers to the protein of interest. In the search for a standardized conjugation strategy, considerations include their mechanical properties in the context of SMFS, feasibility of site-directed labeling, labeling efficiency, and costs.

An ester bond underlies the mechanical strength of a pathogen surface protein

Gram-positive bacteria can resist large mechanical perturbations during their invasion and colonization by secreting various surface proteins with intramolecular isopeptide or ester bonds. Compared to isopeptide bonds, ester bonds are prone to hydrolysis. It remains elusive whether ester bonds can completely block mechanical extension similarly to isopeptide bonds, or whether ester bonds dissipate mechanical energy by bond rupture. Here, we show that an ester-bond containing stalk domain of Cpe0147 is inextensible even at forces > 2 nN. The ester bond locks the structure to a partially unfolded conformation, in which the ester bond remains largely water inaccessible. This allows the ester bond to withstand considerable mechanical forces and in turn prevent complete protein unfolding. However, the protecting effect might be reduced at non-physiological basic pHs or low calcium concentrations due to destabilizing the protein structures. Inspired by this design principle, we engineer a disulfide mutant resistant to mechanical unfolding under reducing conditions.

Bacterial surface adhesion proteins are characterized by unusual mechanical properties. Here, the authors use atomic force microscopy-based technique to study a surface-anchoring protein Cpe0147 from Clostridium perfringens and show that an ester bond can withstand considerable mechanical forces and prevent complete protein unfolding.

Bacterial adhesion to biomaterials: What regulates this attachment? A review

•

Bacterial adhesion to the surface of dental materials play a significant role in infections.

•

The factors that govern microbial attachment involves different types of physical-chemical interactions and biological processes.

•

Studying bacterial adhesion makes it possible to understand the mechanisms involved in attachment and helps in the search for technologies that promote antibacterial surfaces.

Bacterial attachment to biomaterials is of great interest to the medical and dental field due to its impact on dental implants, dental prostheses, and others, leading to the need to introduce methods for biofilm control and mitigation of infections. Biofilm adhesion is a multifactorial process and involves characteristics relevant to the bacterial cell as well as biological, chemical, and physical properties relative to the surface of biomaterials. Bacteria encountered different environmental conditions during their growth and developed interspecies communication strategies, as well as various mechanisms to detect the environment and facilitate survival, such as chemical sensors or physical detection mechanisms. However, the factors that govern microbial attachment to surfaces are not yet fully understood. In order to understand how bacteria interact with surfaces, as well as to characterize the physical-chemical properties of bacteria adhesins, and to determine their interrelation with the adhesion to the substrate, in recent years new techniques of atomic force microscopy (AFM) have been developed and helped by providing quantitative results. Thus, the purpose of this review is to gather current studies about the factors that regulate microbial adhesion to surfaces in order to offer a guide to studies to obtain technologies that provide an antimicrobial surface.

Staphylococcus aureus vWF-binding protein triggers a strong interaction between clumping factor A and host vWF

The Staphylococcus aureus cell wall-anchored adhesin ClfA binds to the very large blood circulating protein, von Willebrand factor (vWF) via vWF-binding protein (vWbp), a secreted protein that does not bind the cell wall covalently. Here we perform force spectroscopy studies on living bacteria to unravel the molecular mechanism of this interaction. We discover that the presence of all three binding partners leads to very high binding forces (2000 pN), largely outperforming other known ternary complexes involving adhesins. Strikingly, our experiments indicate that a direct interaction involving features of the dock, lock and latch mechanism must occur between ClfA and vWF to sustain the extreme tensile strength of the ternary complex. Our results support a previously undescribed mechanism whereby vWbp activates a direct, ultra-strong interaction between ClfA and vWF. This intriguing interaction represents a potential target for therapeutic interventions, including synthetic peptides inhibiting the ultra-strong interactions between ClfA and its ligands.

Through force spectroscopy studies on living bacteria, Viljoen et al. characterise the binding of S. aureus to host von Willebrand factor (vWF). They propose that S. aureus vWF-binding protein triggers an ultra-strong interaction between the adhesin clumping factor A and vWF.

AFM in cellular and molecular microbiology

The unique capabilities of the atomic force microscope (AFM), including super-resolution imaging, piconewton force-sensitivity, nanomanipulation and ability to work under physiological conditions, have offered exciting avenues for cellular and molecular biology research. AFM imaging has helped unravel the fine architectures of microbial cell envelopes at the nanoscale, and how these are altered by antimicrobial treatment. Nanomechanical measurements have shed new light on the elasticity, tensile strength and turgor pressure of single cells. Single-molecule and single-cell force spectroscopy experiments have revealed the forces and dynamics of receptor-ligand interactions, the nanoscale distribution of receptors on the cell surface and the elasticity and adhesiveness of bacterial pili. Importantly, recent force spectroscopy studies have demonstrated that extremely stable bonds are formed between bacterial adhesins and their cognate ligands, originating from a catch bond behaviour allowing the pathogen to reinforce adhesion under shear or tensile stress. Here, we survey how the versatility of AFM has enabled addressing crucial questions in microbiology, with emphasis on bacterial pathogens. TAKE AWAYS: AFM topographic imaging unravels the ultrastructure of bacterial envelopes. Nanomechanical mapping shows what makes cell envelopes stiff and resistant to drugs. Force spectroscopy characterises the molecular forces in pathogen adhesion. Stretching pili reveals a wealth of mechanical and adhesive responses.

Stress-Induced Catch-Bonds to Enhance Bacterial Adhesion

Physical forces have a profound influence on bacterial cell physiology and disease. A striking example is the formation of catch-bonds that reinforce under mechanical stress. While mannose-binding by the Escherichia coli FimH adhesin has long been the only thoroughly studied microbial catch-bond, it has recently become clear that proteins from other species, such as staphylococci, are also engaged in such stress-dependent interactions.

Single-Molecule Analysis Demonstrates Stress-Enhanced Binding between Staphylococcus aureus Surface Protein IsdB and Host Cell Integrins

Binding of Staphylococcus aureus surface proteins to endothelial cell integrins plays essential roles in host cell adhesion and invasion, eventually leading to life-threatening diseases. The staphylococcal protein IsdB binds to β3-containing integrins through a mechanism that has never been thoroughly investigated. Here, we identify and characterize at the nanoscale a previously undescribed stress-dependent adhesion between IsdB and integrin α_Vβ₃. The strength of single IsdB-α_Vβ₃ interactions is moderate (∼100 pN) under low stress, but it increases dramatically under high stress (∼1000-2000 pN) to exceed the forces traditionally reported for the binding between integrins and Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) sequences. We suggest a mechanism where high mechanical stress induces conformational changes in the integrin from a low-affinity, weak binding state to a high-affinity, strong binding state. This single-molecule study highlights that direct adhesin-integrin interactions represent potential targets to fight staphylococcal infections.

Force-clamp spectroscopy identifies a catch bond mechanism in a Gram-positive pathogen

Physical forces have profound effects on cellular behavior, physiology, and disease. Perhaps the most intruiguing and fascinating example is the formation of catch-bonds that strengthen cellular adhesion under shear stresses. Today mannose-binding by the Escherichia coli FimH adhesin remains one of the rare microbial catch-bond thoroughly characterized at the molecular level. Here we provide a quantitative demonstration of a catch-bond in living Gram-positive pathogens using force-clamp spectroscopy. We show that the dock, lock, and latch interaction between staphylococcal surface protein SpsD and fibrinogen is strong, and exhibits an unusual catch-slip transition. The bond lifetime first grows with force, but ultimately decreases to behave as a slip bond beyond a critical force (~1 nN) that is orders of magnitude higher than for previously investigated complexes. This catch-bond, never reported for a staphylococcal adhesin, provides the pathogen with a mechanism to tightly control its adhesive function during colonization and infection.

Meeting report - NSF-sponsored workshop 'Progress and Prospects of Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy in Biological and Chemical Sciences'

The goals of the workshop organized by Piotr Marszalek and Andres Oberhauser that took place between 29 August and 1 September 2019 at Duke University were to bring together leading experts and junior researchers to review past accomplishments, recent advances and limitations in the single-molecule force spectroscopy field, which examines nanomechanical forces in diverse biological processes and pathologies. Talks were organized into four sessions, and two in-depth roundtable discussion sessions were held.

Does protein unfolding play a functional role in vivo?

Unfolding and refolding of multidomain proteins under force have yet to be recognized as a major mechanism of function for proteins in vivo. In this review, we discuss the inherent properties of multidomain proteins under a force vector from a structural and functional perspective. We then characterize three main systems where multidomain proteins could play major roles through mechanical unfolding: muscular contraction, cellular mechanotransduction, and bacterial adhesion. We analyze how key multidomain proteins for each system can produce a gain-of-function from the perspective of a fine-tuned quantized response, a molecular battery, delivery of mechanical work through refolding, elasticity tuning, protection and exposure of cryptic sites, and binding-induced mechanical changes. Understanding how mechanical unfolding and refolding affect function will have important implications in designing mechano-active drugs against conditions such as muscular dystrophy, cancer, or novel antibiotics.

Nanomechanics of the molecular complex between staphylococcal adhesin SpsD and elastin

Staphylococcus pseudintermedius surface protein SpsD binds to extracellular matrix proteins to invade canine epithelial cells. Using single-molecule experiments, we show that SpsD engages in two modes of interaction with elastin that are tightly controlled by physical stress. Binding is weak (∼100 pN) at low tensile force (i.e. loading rate), but is dramatically enhanced (up to ∼1500 pN) by mechanical tension. Consistent with a "dock, lock, and latch" (DLL) mechanism, this force represents among the highest mechanical strengths known for a non-covalent biological interaction. The transition from weak to strong binding correlates with an increase in molecular stiffness but, surprisingly, with a decrease in molecular extension. This unanticipated mechanical behavior indicates that the adhesin is engaged in two distinct interaction mechanisms. Our results emphasize the crucial role of protein nanomechanics in the adhesion of staphylococci, and illustrate their wide diversity of force-dependent ligand-binding activities. These single-molecule mechanical experiments may contribute to the development of antiadhesion approaches to treat infections caused by S. pseudintermedius and other bacterial pathogens engaged in DLL interactions.

Binding Strength of Gram-Positive Bacterial Adhesins

Bacterial pathogens are equipped with specialized surface-exposed proteins that bind strongly to ligands on host tissues and biomaterials. These adhesins play critical roles during infection, especially during the early step of adhesion where the cells are exposed to physical stress. Recent single-molecule experiments have shown that staphylococci interact with their ligands through a wide diversity of mechanosensitive molecular mechanisms. Adhesin-ligand interactions are activated by tensile force and can be ten times stronger than classical non-covalent biological bonds. Overall these studies demonstrate that Gram-positive adhesins feature unusual stress-dependent molecular interactions, which play essential roles during bacterial colonization and dissemination. With an increasing prevalence of multidrug resistant infections caused by Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus epidermidis, chemotherapeutic targeting of adhesins offers an innovative alternative to antibiotics.

How Microbes Use Force To Control Adhesion

Microbial adhesion and biofilm formation are usually studied using molecular and cellular biology assays, optical and electron microscopy, or laminar flow chamber experiments. Today, atomic force microscopy (AFM) represents a valuable addition to these approaches, enabling the measurement of forces involved in microbial adhesion at the single-molecule level. In this minireview, we discuss recent discoveries made applying state-of-the-art AFM techniques to microbial specimens in order to understand the strength and dynamics of adhesive interactions. These studies shed new light on the molecular mechanisms of adhesion and demonstrate an intimate relationship between force and function in microbial adhesins.