New therapeutic and diagnostic opportunities for injured tissue-specific targeting of complement inhibitors and imaging modalities

Complement-targeted therapeutics: Are we there yet, or just getting started?

Therapeutic interventions in the complement system, a key immune-inflammatory mediator and contributor to a broad range of clinical conditions, have long been considered important yet challenging or even unfeasible to achieve. Almost 20 years ago, a spark was lit demonstrating the clinical and commercial viability of complement-targeted therapies. Since then, the field has experienced an impressive expansion of targeted indications and available treatment modalities. Currently, a dozen distinct complement-specific therapeutics covering several intervention points are available in the clinic, benefiting patients suffering from eight disorders, not counting numerous clinical trials and off-label uses. Observing this rapid rise of complement-targeted therapy from obscurity to mainstream with amazement, one might ask whether the peak of this development has now been reached or whether the field will continue marching on to new heights. This review looks at the milestones of complement drug discovery and development achieved so far, surveys the currently approved drug entities and indications, and ventures a glimpse into the future advancements yet to come.

Inhibition of complement C3 signaling ameliorates locomotor and visual dysfunction in autoimmune inflammatory diseases

Neuromyelitis optica (NMO) is an autoimmune inflammatory disease of the central nervous system (CNS) characterized by transverse myelitis and optic neuritis. The pathogenic serum IgG antibody against the aquaporin-4 (AQP4) on astrocytes triggers the activation of the complement cascade, causing astrocyte injury, followed by oligodendrocyte injury, demyelination, and neuronal loss. Complement C3 is positioned as a central player that relays upstream initiation signals to activate downstream effectors, potentially stimulating and amplifying host immune and inflammatory responses. However, whether targeting the inhibition of C3 signaling could ameliorate tissue injury, locomotor defects, and visual impairments in NMO remains to be investigated. In this study, using the targeted C3 inhibitor CR2-Crry led to a significant decrease in complement deposition and demyelination in both slice cultures and focal intracerebral injection models. Moreover, the treatment downregulated the expression of inflammatory cytokines and improved motor dysfunction in a systemic NMO mouse model. Similarly, employing serotype 2/9 adeno-associated virus (AAV2/9) to induce permanent expression of CR2-Crry resulted in a reduction in visual dysfunction by attenuating NMO-like lesions. Our findings reveal the therapeutic value of inhibiting the complement C3 signaling pathway in NMO.

Complement therapeutics are coming of age in rheumatology

The complement system was described over 100 years ago, and it is well established that activation of this pathway accompanies the great majority of autoimmune and inflammatory diseases. In addition, over three decades of work in murine models of human disease have nearly universally demonstrated that complement activation is upstream of tissue injury and the engagement of pro-inflammatory mechanisms such as the elaboration of cytokines and chemokines, as well as myeloid cell recruitment and activation. With that background, and taking advantage of advances in the development of biologic and small-molecule therapeutics, the creation and clinical evaluation of complement therapeutics is now rapidly expanding. This article reviews the current state of the complement therapeutics field, with a focus on their use in diseases cared for or consulted upon by rheumatologists. Included is an overview of the activation mechanisms and components of the system, in addition to the mechanisms by which the complement system interacts with other immune system constituents. The various therapeutic approaches to modulating the system in rheumatic and autoimmune diseases are reviewed. To understand how best to clinically assess the complement system, methods of its evaluation are described. Finally, next-generation therapeutic and diagnostic advances that can be envisioned for the future are discussed.

Contributions of animal models to mechanistic understandings of antibody-dependent disease and roles of the amplification loop

The complement system plays an important pathophysiologic role in human diseases associated with immune or ischemic insults. In addition to understanding the effector mechanisms that are important for the biological effects of the system, substantial efforts have gone into understanding which specific complement activation pathways generate these potent effects. These approaches include the use of gene-targeted mice and specific pathway inhibitors, as well as the integration of human disease genetic and biomarker studies. In some disease states, it is quite clear that the alternate pathway plays a unique role in the initiation of the complement system. However, although initially a widely unexpected finding, it has now been shown in many tissue-based disease models and in initial human studies that engagement of the amplification loop is also essential for tissue injury when the classical and/or lectin pathways initiate pathway activation through pathogenic autoantibodies. This review provides evidence for such a conclusion through animal models, focusing on pathogenic antibody passive transfer models but also other relevant experimental systems. These data, along with initial biomarkers and clinical trial outcomes in human diseases that are associated with pathogenic autoantibodies, suggest that targeting the alternative pathway amplification loop may have near-universal therapeutic utility for tissue-based diseases.

Elevated plasma complement components in facioscapulohumeral dystrophy

Advances in understanding the pathophysiology of facioscapulohumeral dystrophy (FSHD) have led to several therapeutic approaches entering clinical trials and an increased need to develop biomarkers of disease activity and progression. Multiple prior studies have shown early elevation of RNAs encoding components of the complement pathways and relatively widespread activated complement complexes by immunodetection in FSHD muscle. The current study tested plasma from two independent cohorts of FSHD and control subjects and found elevated complement components in both FSHD cohorts. Combining subjects from both cohorts identified complement factors that best distinguished FSHD and controls. Within the FSHD group, a subset of subjects showed elevation in multiple complement components. Together these findings suggest the need for future studies to determine whether measurements of complement activation can be used as a non-invasive measurement of FSHD disease activity, progression and/or response to therapies. In addition, with the ongoing expansion of complement therapeutic approaches, consideration for precision-based targeting of this pathway is appropriate.

Increasing the efficacy and safety of a human complement inhibitor for treating post-transplant cardiac ischemia reperfusion injury by targeting to a graft-specific neoepitope

BACKGROUND

Post-transplant ischemia reperfusion injury (IRI) is a recognized risk factor for subsequent organ dysfunction, alloresponsiveness, and rejection. The complement system is known to play a role in IRI and represents a therapeutic target. Complement is activated in transplanted grafts when circulating IgM antibodies bind to exposed ischemia-induced neoepitopes upon reperfusion, and we investigated the targeting of a human complement inhibitor, CR1, to a post-transplant ischemia-induced neoepitope.

METHODS

A fragment of human CR1 was linked to a single chain antibody construct (C2 scFv) recognizing an injury-specific neoepitope to yield C2-CR1. This construct, along with a soluble untargeted counterpart, was characterized in a cardiac allograft transplantation model of IRI in terms of efficacy and safety.

RESULTS

CR1 was similarly effective against mouse and human complement. C2-CR1 provided effective protection against cardiac IRI at a lower dose than untargeted CR1. The increased efficacy of C2-CR1 relative to CR1 correlated with decreased C3 deposition, and C2-CR1, but not CR1, targeted to cardiac allografts. At a dose necessary to reduce IRI, C2-CR1 had minimal impact on serum complement activity, in contrast to CR1 which resulted in a high level of systemic inhibition. The circulatory half-life of CR1 was markedly longer than that of C2-CR1, and whereas a minimum therapeutic dose of CR1 severely impaired host susceptibility to infection, C2-CR1 had no impact.

CONCLUSION

We show the translational potential of a human complement inhibitor targeted to a universal ischemia-induced graft-specific epitope, and demonstrate advantages compared to an untargeted counterpart in terms of efficacy and safety.

A Family Affair: Addressing the Challenges of Factor H and the Related Proteins

Inflammation is a common denominator of diseases. The complement system, an intrinsic part of the innate immune system, is a key driver of inflammation in numerous disorders. Recently, a family of proteins has been suggested to be of vital importance in conditions characterized by complement dysregulation: the human Factor H (FH) family. This group of proteins consists of FH, Factor H-like protein 1 and five Factor H-related proteins. The FH family has been linked to infectious, vascular, eye, kidney and autoimmune diseases. In contrast to FH, the functions of the other highly homologous proteins are largely unknown and, hence, their role in the different disease-specific pathogenic mechanisms remains elusive. In this perspective review, we address the major challenges ahead in this emerging area, including 1) the controversies about the functional roles of the FH protein family, 2) the discrepancies in quantification of the FH protein family, 3) the unmet needs for validated tools and 4) limitations of animal models. Next, we also discuss the opportunities that exist for the immunology community. A strong multidisciplinary approach is required to solve these obstacles and is only possible through interdisciplinary collaboration between biologists, chemists, geneticists and physicians. We position this review in light of our own perspective, as principal investigators of the SciFiMed Consortium, a consortium aiming to create a comprehensive analytical system for the quantitative and functional assessment of the entire FH protein family.

Complement-mediated hypersensitivity reactions to an amphotericin B-containing lipid complex (Abelcet) in pediatric patients and anesthetized rats: Benefits of slow infusion

Intravenous administration of lipid-based nanodrugs can cause hypersensitivity, also known as infusion reactions (IRs), that can be attenuated by slow infusion in adult patients. We studied the role of infusion rate and complement (C) activation in IRs in pediatric patients treated with Abelcet, and also in anesthetized rats. IRs were observed in 6 out of 10 (60%) patients who received Abelcet infusion in 4 h or less, while no patients who received the infusion in 6 h showed C activation or IRs. The rat model indicated an inverse relationship between infusion speed and Abelcet-induced hypotension, taken as an experimental endpoint of IRs, while the rise of C3a in blood, an index of C activation, directly correlated with hypotension. The results suggest that pediatric patients are more prone to produce IRs, and that the optimal infusion time of Abelcet may be much longer than the presently recommended 2 h.

A novel complement inhibitor sMAP-FH targeting both the lectin and alternative complement pathways

Inhibition of the complement activation has emerged as an option for treatment of a range of diseases. Activation of the lectin and alternative pathways (LP and AP, respectively) contribute to the deterioration of conditions in certain diseases such as ischemia-reperfusion injuries and age-related macular degeneration (AMD). In the current study, we generated dual complement inhibitors of the pathways MAp44-FH and sMAP-FH by fusing full-length MAp44 or small mannose-binding lectin-associated protein (sMAP), LP regulators, with the N-terminal five short consensus repeat (SCR) domains of complement factor H (SCR1/5-FH), an AP regulator. The murine forms of both fusion proteins formed a complex with endogenous mannose-binding lectin (MBL) or ficolin A in the circulation when administered in mice intraperitoneally. Multiple complement activation assays revealed that sMAP-FH had significantly higher inhibitory effects on activation of the LP and AP in vivo as well as in vitro compared to MAp44-FH. Human form of sMAP-FH also showed dual inhibitory effects on LP and AP activation in human sera. Our results indicate that the novel fusion protein sMAP-FH inhibits both the LP and AP activation in mice and in human sera, and could be an effective therapeutic agent for diseases in which both the LP and AP activation are significantly involved.

Compendium of current complement therapeutics

The complement system is well known for its role in innate immunity and in maintenance of tissue homeostasis, providing a first line of defence against infection and playing a key role in flagging apoptotic cells and debris for disposal. Unfortunately, complement also contributes to pathogenesis of many diseases, in some cases driving pathology, and in others amplifying or exacerbating the inflammatory and damaging impact of non-complement disease triggers. The driving role of complement in a single disease, paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH), provoked the development and eventual FDA (US Food and Drug Administration) approval of eculizumab (Soliris™), an anti-C5 antibody, for therapy. Although PNH is very rare, eculizumab provided clinical validation and demonstrated that inhibiting the complement system was not only well-tolerated, but also provided rapid therapy and saved lives. This clinical validation, together with advances in genetic analyses that demonstrated strong associations between complement and common diseases, drove new drug discovery programmes in both academic laboratories and large pharmaceutical companies. Numerous drugs have entered clinical development and several are in phase 3 trials; however, many have fallen by the wayside. Despite this high attrition rate, crucial lessons have been learnt and hurdles to development have become clear. These insights have driven development of next generation anti-complement drugs designed to avoid pitfalls and facilitate patient access. In this article, we do not set out to provide a text-heavy review of complement therapeutics but instead will simply highlight the targets, modalities and current status of the plethora of drugs approved or in clinical development. With such a fast-moving drug development landscape, such a compendium will inevitably become out-dated; however, we provide a snapshot of the current field and illustrate the increased choice that clinicians might enjoy in the future in selecting the best drug for their application, decisions based not only on efficacy but also cost, mechanistic target, modality and route of delivery.

Imidazole Compounds for Protecting Choroidal Endothelial Cells from Complement Injury

Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is a common, blinding disease associated with increased complement system activity. Eyes with AMD show elevated accumulation of the membrane attack complex (MAC) in the choriocapillaris and degeneration of macular choriocapillaris endothelial cells (ECs). Thus, one could reasonably conclude that the endothelial cell death that occurs in AMD is due to injury by the MAC. We therefore sought to identify strategies for protecting ECs against MAC lysis. RF/6A endothelial cells were pre-incubated with a library of FDA-approved small molecules, followed by incubation with complement intact human serum quantification of cell death. Two closely related molecules identified in the screen, econazole nitrate and miconazole nitrate, were followed in validation and mechanistic studies. Both compounds reduced lysis of choroidal ECs treated with complement-intact serum, across a range of doses from 1 to 100 µM. Cell rescue was confirmed in mouse primary choroidal ECs. Both exosome release and cell surface roughness (assessed using a Holomonitor system) were reduced by drug pretreatment in RF/6A cells, whereas endosome formation increased with both drugs, consistent with imidazole-mediated alterations of cell surface dynamics. The results in the current study provide further proof of principle that small molecules can protect choroidal ECs from MAC-induced cell death and suggest that FDA approved compounds may be beneficial in reducing vascular loss and progression of AMD.

Complement C3-Targeted Gene Therapy Restricts Onset and Progression of Neurodegeneration in Chronic Mouse Glaucoma

Dysregulation of the complement system is implicated in neurodegeneration, including human and animal glaucoma. Optic nerve and retinal damage in glaucoma is preceded by local complement upregulation and activation, but whether targeting this early innate immune response could have therapeutic benefit remains undefined. Because complement signals through three pathways that intersect at complement C3 activation, here we targeted this step to restore complement balance in the glaucomatous retina and to determine its contribution to degeneration onset and/or progression. To achieve this, we combined adeno-associated virus retinal gene therapy with the targeted C3 inhibitor CR2-Crry. We show that intravitreal injection of AAV2.CR2-Crry produced sustained Crry overexpression in the retina and reduced deposition of the activation product complement C3d on retinal ganglion cells and the inner retina of DBA/2J mice. This resulted in neuroprotection of retinal ganglion cell axons and somata despite continued intraocular pressure elevation, suggesting a direct restriction of neurodegeneration onset and progression and significant delay to terminal disease stages. Our study uncovers a damaging effect of complement C3 or downstream complement activation in glaucoma, and it establishes AAV2.CR2-Crry as a viable therapeutic strategy to target pathogenic C3-mediated complement activation in the glaucomatous retina.

Tissue-targeted complement therapeutics

Complement activation contributes to the pathogenesis of numerous inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. Therapeutic complement inhibitors have proven effective in several of these diseases and have now entered clinical use. Complement activation has multiple different biologic effects, however, and the currently available drugs can have undesirable side-effects, such as an increased risk of infection. Several different complement inhibitors have been developed that bind to target molecules, thereby concentrating the drug at a specific anatomic site. This approach appears to be both more effective than untargeted drugs and to have fewer side effects. In this article we review different targeting strategies that have been developed and the evidence supporting the use and benefits of targeted drugs.

The Evolving Landscape for Complement Therapeutics in Rheumatic and Autoimmune Diseases

The complement system is increasingly understood to play major roles in the pathogenesis of human inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. Because of this situation, there are rapidly expanding commercial efforts to develop novel complement inhibitors and effector pathway-modulating drugs. This review provides insights into the evolving understanding of the complement system components, mechanisms of activation within and across the 3 pathways (classical, alternative, and lectin), how the pathways are normally controlled and then dysregulated in target tissues, and what diseases are known to be, in large part, complement-dependent through the successful development and approval of complement therapeutics in patients. Mechanisms of complement activation in rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, and thrombotic microangiopathies are also illustrated. In addition, the specific therapeutic drugs that are both approved and under development are discussed in the context of both nonrheumatic and rheumatic diseases. Finally, the methods by which the complement system can be assessed in humans through biomarker studies are outlined, with the goal of understanding, in specific patients, how the system is functioning.

Expanding horizons in complement drug discovery: challenges and emerging strategies

The complement system is best known for its role in innate immunity, providing a first line of defence against infection, maintaining tissue homeostasis by flagging apoptotic cells and debris for removal, and orchestrating crosstalk between adaptive and innate immunity. In a growing number of diseases, complement is known to drive pathogenesis or to contribute as an inflammatory amplifier of a disease trigger. Association of complement with common and devastating diseases has driven an upsurge in complement drug discovery, but despite a wealth of knowledge in the complexities of the cascade, and many decades of effort, very few drugs have progressed to late-stage clinical studies. The reasons for this are becoming clear with difficulties including high target concentration and turnover, lack of clarity around disease mechanism and unwanted side effects. Lessons learnt from drugs which are either approved, or are currently in late-stage development, or have failed and dropped off the drug development landscape, have been invaluable to drive a new generation of innovative drugs which are progressing through clinical development. In this review, the challenges associated with complement drug discovery are discussed and the current drug development landscape is reviewed. The latest approaches to improve drug characteristics are explored and those agents which employ these technologies to improve accessibility to patients are highlighted.

Brain injury with systemic inflammation in newborns with congenital heart disease undergoing heart surgery

The potential role of systemic inflammation on brain injury in newborns with congenital heart disease (CHD) was assessed by measuring levels of central nervous system (CNS)-derived proteins in serum prior to and following cardiac surgery. A total of 23 newborns (gestational age, 39±1 weeks) with a diagnosis of CHD that required cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) were enrolled in the current study. Serum samples were collected immediately prior to surgery and 2, 24 and 48 h following CPB, and serum levels of phosphorylated neurofilament-heavy subunit (pNF-H), neuron-specific enolase (NSE) and S100B were analyzed. Systemic inflammation was assessed by measuring serum concentrations of complement C5a and complement sC5b9, and the following cytokines: Interleukin (IL)-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, IL12p70, interferon γ and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α. Analysis of cord blood from normal term deliveries (n=26) provided surrogate normative values for newborns. pNF-H and S100B were 2.4- to 2.8-fold higher (P<0.0001) in patient sera than in cord blood prior to surgery and remained elevated following CPB. Pre-surgical serum pNF-H and S100B levels directly correlated with interleukin (IL)-12p70 (ρ=0.442, P<0.05). pNF-H was inversely correlated with arterial pO₂ prior to surgery (ρ=−0.493, P=0.01) and directly correlated with arterial pCO₂ post-CPB (ρ=0.426, P<0.05), suggesting that tissue hypoxia and inflammation contribute to blood brain barrier (BBB) dysfunction and neuronal injury. Serum IL12p70, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10 and TNF-α levels were significantly higher in patients than in normal cord blood and levels of these cytokines increased following CPB (P<0.001). Activation of complement was observed in all patients prior to surgery, and serum C5a and sC5b9 remained elevated up to 48 h post-surgery. Furthermore, they were correlated (P<0.05) with low arterial pO₂, high pCO₂ and elevated arterial pressure in the postoperative period. Length of mechanical ventilation was associated directly with post-surgery serum IL-12p70 and IL-8 concentrations (P<0.05). Elevated serum concentrations of pNF-H and S100B in neonates with CHD suggest BBB dysfunction and CNS injury, with concurrent hypoxemia and an activated inflammatory response potentiating this effect.

Complement: A primer for the coming therapeutic revolution

The complement system is an important part of the innate and adaptive immune systems. Originally characterized as a single serum component contributing to the killing of bacteria, we now know that there are close to sixty complement proteins, multiple activation pathways and a wide range of effector functions mediated by complement. The system plays a critical role in host defense against bacteria, viruses, fungi and other pathogens. However, inappropriate complement activation contributes to the pathophysiology of autoimmune diseases and many inflammatory syndromes. Over the last several decades, therapeutic approaches to inhibit complement activation at various steps in the pathways have met with initial success, particularly at the level of the terminal pathway. This success, combined with insight from animal model studies, has lead to an unprecedented effort by biotech and pharmaceutical companies to begin developing complement inhibitors. As a result, complement has been brought for the first time to the attention of pharmacologists, toxicologists, project managers and others in the drug development industry, as well as those in the investment world. The purpose of this primer is to provide a broad overview of complement immunobiology to help those new to complement understand the rationale behind the current therapeutic directions and the investment potential of these new therapeutics.