Historical, current and future developments of travelling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry: A personal perspective

Desorption Electrospray Ionization Cyclic Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry Imaging for Traumatic Brain Injury Spatial Metabolomics

Lipidomics focuses on investigating alterations in a wide variety of lipids that harness important information on metabolic processes and disease pathology. However, the vast structural diversity of lipids and the presence of isobaric and isomeric species creates serious challenges in feature identification, particularly in mass spectrometry imaging experiments that lack front-end separations. Ion mobility has emerged as a potential solution to address some of these challenges and is increasingly being utilized as part of mass spectrometry imaging platforms. Here, we present the results of a pilot mass spectrometry imaging study on rat brains subjected to traumatic brain injury (TBI) to evaluate the depth and quality of the information yielded by desorption electrospray ionization cyclic ion mobility mass spectrometry (DESI cIM MSI). Imaging data were collected with one and six passes through the cIM cell. Increasing the number of passes increased the ion mobility resolving power and the resolution of isobaric lipids, enabling the creation of more specific maps. Interestingly, drift time data enabled the recognition of multiply charged phosphoinositide species in the complex data set generated. These species have not been previously reported in TBI MSI studies and were found to decrease in the hippocampus region following injury. These changes were attributed to increased enzymatic activity after TBI, releasing arachidonic acid that is converted to eicosanoids to control inflammation. A substantial reduction in NAD and alterations in other adenine metabolites were also observed, supporting the hypothesis that energy metabolism in the brain is severely disrupted in TBI.

IDSimF: An Open-Source Framework for the Simulation of Molecular Ion Dynamics in Mass Spectrometry and Ion Mobility Spectrometry

The development of mass spectrometric and ion mobility devices heavily depends on a comprehensive understanding of the behavior of ions within such systems. Therefore, numerical modeling of ion paths helps to optimize and verify existing devices, and contributes to the development of innovative ion optical systems and multipole geometries. This Article introduces IDSimF (Ion Dynamics Simulation Framework), an open-source simulation tool tailored to the nonrelativistic dynamics of molecular ions in mass and ion mobility spectrometry applications. Addressing limitations in existing software packages, as for example SIMION, OpenFOAM, and COMSOL, IDSimF offers a specialized platform for simulating ion trajectories in electric fields. IDSimF efficiently accounts for space charge effects and considers various ion-neutral collision models while handling chemical kinetics. The framework is highly modular with reduced user input configuration complexity and aims to support simulation efforts in development and optimization of in mass spectrometers.

Evaluation of a Commercial TIMS-Q-TOF Platform for Native Mass Spectrometry

Mass-spectrometry based assays in structural biology studies measure either intact or digested proteins. Typically, different mass spectrometers are dedicated for such measurements: those optimized for rapid analysis of peptides or those designed for high molecular weight analysis. A commercial trapped ion mobility-quadrupole-time-of-flight (TIMS-Q-TOF) platform is widely utilized for proteomics and metabolomics, with ion mobility providing a separation dimension in addition to liquid chromatography. The ability to perform high-quality native mass spectrometry of protein complexes, however, remains largely uninvestigated. Here, we evaluate a commercial TIMS-Q-TOF platform for analyzing noncovalent protein complexes by utilizing the instrument's full range of ion mobility, MS, and MS/MS (both in-source activation and collision cell CID) capabilities. The TIMS analyzer is able to be tuned gently to yield collision cross sections of native-like complexes comparable to those previously reported on various instrument platforms. In-source activation and collision cell CID were robust for both small and large complexes. TIMS-CID was performed on protein complexes streptavidin (53 kDa), avidin (68 kDa), and cholera toxin B (CTB, 58 kDa). Complexes pyruvate kinase (237 kDa) and GroEL (801 kDa) were beyond the trapping capabilities of the commercial TIMS analyzer, but TOF mass spectra could be acquired. The presented results indicate that the commercial TIMS-Q-TOF platform can be used for both omics and native mass spectrometry applications; however, modifications to the commercial RF drivers for both the TIMS analyzer and quadrupole (currently limited to m/z 3000) are necessary to mobility analyze protein complexes greater than about 60 kDa.

Manipulating Non-Dissociative Transformations of Gaseous Ion Ensembles Prior to Ion-Mobility Separation

Molecules with multiple sites capable of accepting protons form ensembles of protomers. The manifested protomer ratios in such ensembles are influenced by many experimental conditions. In a Synapt G2 ion mobility (IM)-enabled mass spectrometry system, there are several physical locations where ion population changes can be manifested. Using APCI-generated protomers of aminonaphthalenes, we investigated its intramolecular proton transfers from the N-protomer to the C-protomer. This lossless transformation of the N-protomer to the thermodynamically favored C-protomer can take place in the ion source itself. Initially, we learned that the cone gas slows down the transformation to the C-protomer. Gaseous ions are then accelerated in the first vacuum region, where ions undergo collisional activation (heating), which facilitates the transformation to the C-protomer. Afterward, the ions are mass selected and transferred to the pre-IM (Trap)-collision cell, where ions can also be transformed to the thermodynamically favored protomers. Trap accumulated ions are then released to the IM separator via a helium-filled entry cell. The role of helium is to minimize ion activation and scattering taking place upon entry to the high-pressure T-Wave IM separator (TWIMS). The helium cell is known to increase the IM peak resolution. However, we found that significant changes occur depending on the presence or absence of helium. Without helium, source-generated protomers rapidly changed to a predominantly thermodynamically favorable ensemble protomers. Apparently, the introduction of helium into the precell induced a dramatic decrease in collisional "heating" effect, which effectively slowed down the conversion rate of the amino-protomer into the more favorable ring-protomer. The final message is that mobilograms should not be considered as direct real-time, or intrinsic, representations of the protomer ratios in the ion source.

Altering Conformational States of Dynamic Ion Populations using Traveling Wave Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations

With its capacity to store and translate ions across considerable distances and times, traveling wave structures for lossless ion manipulations (TW-SLIM) provide the foundation to expand the scope of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) experiments. While promising, the dynamic electric fields and consequential ion-neutral collisions used to realize extensive degrees of separation have a considerable impact on the empirical results and the fundamental interpretation of observed arrival time distributions. Using a custom-designed set of TW-SLIM boards (∼9 m) coupled with a time-of-flight mass spectrometer (SLIM-ToF), we detail the capacity to systematically alter the gas-phase distribution of select peptide conformers. In addition to discussing the role charge-transfer may play in TW-SLIM experiments that occur at extended time scales, the ability of the SLIM-ToF to perform tandem IMS was leveraged to confirm that both the compact and elongated conformers of bradykinin2+ undergo interconversion within the SLIM. Storage experiments in which ions are confined within SLIM using static potential wells suggest that factors aside from TW-induced ion motion contribute to interconversion. Further investigation into this matter suggests that the use of radio frequency (RF) fields to confine ions within SLIM may play a role in ion heating. Aside from interconversion, storage experiments also provide insight into charge transfer behavior over the course of extended periods. The results of the presented experiments suggest that considerations should be taken when analyzing labile species and inform strategies for the TW-SLIM design and method development.

Identification and quantification of bipyridyl dicarboxylic acid isomers by ion mobility spectrometry

The identification of positional isomers is of interest because different isomers have different chemical or biological functions and applications. The analysis of positional isomers is sometimes challenging since they have similar chemical structures and properties. For example, the analysis of mass cannot identify different positional isomers because they have identical mass-to-charge ratios and show a single mass peak in mass spectrometry. In this study, an efficient and simple qualitative and quantitative analytical method for differentiating 2,2'-bipyridine-3,3'-dicarboxylic acid (3,3'-BDA), 2,2'-bipyridine-4,4'-dicarboxylic acid (4,4'-BDA), and 2,2'-bipyridine-5,5'-dicarboxylic acid (5,5'-BDA) was developed by using ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). The results revealed that the three BDA isomers formed non-covalent complexes with cyclodextrins (CDs) and Mg2+ ions in the gas phase: [β-CD+3,3'/4,4'/5,5'-BDA+Mg]2+ and [γ-CD+3,3'/4,4'/5,5'-BDA+Mg]2+, which were distinguished by measuring the mobility of the complexes because of their spatial conformational differences. The peak-to-peak resolution (Rp-p) values of the three isomers of [γ-CD+3,3'/4,4'/5,5'-BDA+Mg]2+ reached 2.983 and 2.892, respectively. The conformations of the ternary complexes simulated by the theoretical calculations revealed the different interactions and shapes of the stereoisomers, and the predicted results agreed with the experimental results. Simultaneously, further studies on the collisional dissociation of the ternary complexes revealed that the dissociation energies of the different complex ions varied were different owing to the diverse different conformations. Finally, the relative quantitative analysis of the different isomers in mixed samples was performed and satisfactory linearity results (R2 > 0.99) were obtained. Thus, an effective analytical method was proposed for the identification and quantification of BDA isomers without chemical derivatization, offering a promising approach for the identification of similar derivatives or positional isomers that could be applied in various fields including chemicals and pharmaceuticals.

Towards IMn with Electrostatic Drift Fields: Resetting the Potential of Trapped Ions Between Dimensions of Ion Mobility

Increasing the dimensionality of ion mobility (IM) presents an enticing opportunity to increase the information content and selectivity of many analyses. However, for implementations of IM that use constant electrostatic gradients to separate ions in a buffer gas, technical challenges have limited the adoption of the technique and number of dimensions within individual experiments. Here, we introduce a strategy to "reset" the potentials of ions between IM dimensions. To achieve this, mobility-selected ions are trapped between dimensions of IM, using a combination of RF and electrostatic fields, while the subsequent dimension of IM is devoid of any drift field. By applying an incremental voltage ramp, the potential of the trapping region is elevated, simultaneously establishing the drift field in the subsequent dimension of IM. The trapped ions are then released and separated. We measured similar arrival-time distributions of protein ions using this strategy and a method without potential resetting, suggesting that potential resetting can be performed without additional losses or activation of ions. The findings of those experiments were corroborated by ion trajectory simulations, which exhibited a very small changes in ion position and no significant changes in effective temperatures during potential resetting. Finally, we demonstrate that IM information can be preserved during potential resetting by selecting subpopulations of 9+ cytochrome c ions, resetting their potential, subjecting them to a second-dimension IM separation, and observing the retention of conformers within each subpopulation. We anticipate that this strategy will be useful for advancing flexible, multidimensional experiments on electrostatic IM instruments.

A Research Journey: Over a Decade of Denaturing and Native-MS Analyses of Hydrophobic and Membrane Proteins in Amgen Therapeutic Discovery

Membrane proteins and associated complexes currently comprise the majority of therapeutic targets and remain among the most challenging classes of proteins for analytical characterization. Through long-term strategic collaborations forged between industrial and academic research groups, there has been tremendous progress in advancing membrane protein mass spectrometry (MS) analytical methods and their concomitant application to Amgen therapeutic project progression. Herein, I will describe a detailed and personal account of how electrospray ionization (ESI) native mass spectrometry (nMS), ion mobility-MS (IM-MS), reversed phase liquid chromatographic mass spectrometry (RPLC-MS), high-throughput solid phase extraction mass spectrometry, and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry methods were developed, optimized, and validated within Amgen Research, and importantly, how these analytical methods were applied for membrane and hydrophobic protein analyses and ultimately therapeutic project support and progression. Additionally, I will discuss all the highly important and productive collaborative efforts, both internal Amgen and external academic, which were key in generating the samples, methods, and associated data described herein. I will also describe some early and previously unpublished nano-ESI (nESI) native-MS data from Amgen Research and the highly productive University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) collaboration. I will also present previously unpublished examples of real-life Amgen biotherapeutic membrane protein projects that were supported by all the MS (and IM) analytical techniques described herein. I will start by describing the initial nESI nMS experiments performed at Amgen in 2011 on empty nanodisc molecules, using a quadrupole time-of-flight MS, and how these experiments progressed on to the 15 Tesla Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance MS at UCLA. Then described are monomeric and multimeric membrane protein data acquired in both nESI nMS and tandem-MS modes, using multiple methods of ion activation, resulting in dramatic spectral simplification. Also described is how we investigated the far less established and less published subject, that is denaturing RPLC-MS analysis of membrane proteins, and how we developed a highly robust and reproducible RPLC-MS method capable of effective separation of membrane proteins differing in only the presence or absence of an N-terminal post translational modification. Also described is the evolution of the aforementioned RPLC-MS method into a high-throughput solid phase extraction MS method. Finally, I will give my opinion on key developments and how the area of nMS of membrane proteins needs to evolve to a state where it can be applied within the biopharmaceutical research environment for routine therapeutic project support.

Evaluating dynamic traveling wave profiles for the enhancement of separation and sensitivity in traveling wave structures for lossless ion manipulations

The amenability of traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) to extended separation pathlengths has prompted a recent surge of interest concerning the technique. While promising, the optimization of ion transmission, particularly when analyzing increasingly disparate species, remains an obstacle in TWIMS. To address this issue, we evaluated a suite of dynamic TW profiles using an original TW structures for lossless ion manipulations (TW-SLIM) platform developed at Washington State University. Inspired by the range of gradient elution profiles used in traditional chromatography, three distinct square TW profiles were evaluated: a static approach which represents a traditional waveform, a dual approach which consists of two distinct TW profiles within a given separation event; and a ramp approach which varies TW speed and amplitude at a fixed rate during separation. The three waveform profiles were evaluated in terms of their impact on separation (quantified as resolution) and sensitivity (quantified using signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and ion abundance). Concerning separation, the highest resolution (R) was observed when operating with the static waveform (R = 7.92); however, the ramp waveform performed comparably (R = 7.70) under similar conditions. Regarding SNR, optimum waveform profiles were species dependent. Bradykinin2+ displayed the largest gains in SNR (36.6% increase) when ramping TW speed, while the gains were greatest (33.5% increase) for tetraoctylammonium when modulating TW amplitude with the static waveform. Lastly, significant (>10%) increases in the abundance of tetraoctylammonium ions were observed exclusively when utilizing a ramped waveform. The present set of experiments outline the results and challenges related to optimizing separations using alternative TW profiles and provides insight concerning TW-SLIM method development which may be tailored to enhance select analytical metrics.

Enhancing the Depth of Analyses with Next-Generation Ion Mobility Experiments

Recent developments in ion mobility (IM) technology have expanded the capability to separate and characterize gas-phase ions of biomolecules, especially when paired with mass spectrometry. This next generation of IM technology has been ushered in by creative innovation focused on both instrument architectures and how electric fields are applied. In this review, we focus on the application of high-resolution and multidimensional IM to biomolecular analyses, encompassing the fields of glycomics, lipidomics, peptidomics, and proteomics. We highlight selected research that demonstrates the application of the new IM toolkit to challenging biomolecular systems. Through our review of recently published literature, we outline the current strengths of respective technologies and perspectives for future applications.

A Comparison of the Performance of Modular Standalone Do-It-Yourself Ion Mobility Spectrometry Systems

As the spectrum of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) applications expands and more experimental configurations are developed, identifying the correct platform for an experimental campaign becomes more challenging for researchers. Additionally, metrics that compare performance (Rp, for example) often have nuanced differences in definition between platforms that render direct comparisons difficult. Here we present a comparison of three do-it-yourself (DIY) drift tubes that are relatively low cost and easy to construct, where the performance of each is evaluated based on three different metrics: resolving power, the ideality of resolving powers, and accuracy/precision of K0 values. The standard PCBIMS design developed by Reinecke and Clowers (Reinecke, T.; Clowers, B. H. HardwareX 2018, 4, e00030) provided the highest resolving power (>90) and the highest ideality of resolving power ratios (>90% at best) of the three systems. However, the flexible tube (FlexIMS) construction as described by Smith et al. (Smith, B. L. Anal. Chem. 2020, 92 (13), 9104-9112) exhibited the highest degree of precision of K0 values (relative standard deviation of <0.42%). Depending on the application, the drift tube variants presented and evaluated here offer a low-cost alternative to commercial drift-tube systems with levels of performance that approach theoretical maxima.

Comparability of Steroid Collision Cross Sections Using Three Different IM-HRMS Technologies: An Interplatform Study

Steroids play key roles in various biological processes and are characterized by many isomeric variants, which makes their unambiguous identification challenging. Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) has been proposed as a suitable platform for this application, particularly using collision cross section (CCS) databases obtained from different commercial IM-MS instruments. CCS is seen as an ideal additional identification parameter for steroids as long-term repeatability and interlaboratory reproducibility of this measurand are excellent and matrix effects are negligible. While excellent results were demonstrated for individual IM-MS technologies, a systematic comparison of CCS derived from all major commercial IM-MS technologies has not been performed. To address this gap, a comprehensive interlaboratory comparison of 142 CCS values derived from drift tube (DTIM-MS), traveling wave (TWIM-MS), and trapped ion mobility (TIM-MS) platforms using a set of 87 steroids was undertaken. Besides delivering three instrument-specific CCS databases, systematic comparisons revealed excellent interlaboratory performance for 95% of the ions with CCS biases within ±1% for TIM-MS and within ±2% for TWIM-MS with respect to DTIM-MS values. However, a small fraction of ions (<1.5%) showed larger biases of up to 7% indicating that differences in the ion conformation sampled on different instrument types need to be further investigated. Systematic differences between CCS derived from different IM-MS analyzers and implications on the applicability for nontargeted analysis are critically discussed. To the best of our knowledge, this is the most comprehensive interlaboratory study comparing CCS from three different IM-MS technologies for analysis of steroids and small molecules in general.

Different ion mobility-mass spectrometry coupling techniques to promote metabolomics

Metabolomics has become increasingly popular in recent years for many applications ranging from clinical diagnosis, human health to biotechnological questioning. Despite technological advances, metabolomic studies are still currently limited by the difficulty of identifying all metabolites, a class of compounds with great chemical diversity. Although lengthy chromatographic analyses are often used to obtain comprehensive data, many isobar and isomer metabolites still remain unresolved, which is a critical point for the compound identification. Currently, ion mobility spectrometry is being explored in metabolomics as a way to improve metabolome coverage, analysis throughput and isomer separation. In this review, all the steps of a typical workflow for untargeted metabolomics are discussed considering the use of an ion mobility instrument. An overview of metabolomics is first presented followed by a brief description of ion mobility instrumentation. The ion mobility potential for complex mixture analysis is discussed regarding its coupling with a mass spectrometer alone, providing gas-phase separation before mass analysis as well as its combination with different separation platforms (conventional hyphenation but also multidimensional ion mobility couplings), offering multidimensional separation. Various instrumental and analytical conditions for improving the ion mobility separation are also described. Finally, data mining, including software packages and visualization approaches, as well as the construction of ion mobility databases for the metabolite identification are examined.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Techniques to Elucidate the Sugar Code

Cells encode information in the sequence of biopolymers, such as nucleic acids, proteins, and glycans. Although glycans are essential to all living organisms, surprisingly little is known about the "sugar code" and the biological roles of these molecules. The reason glycobiology lags behind its counterparts dealing with nucleic acids and proteins lies in the complexity of carbohydrate structures, which renders their analysis extremely challenging. Building blocks that may differ only in the configuration of a single stereocenter, combined with the vast possibilities to connect monosaccharide units, lead to an immense variety of isomers, which poses a formidable challenge to conventional mass spectrometry. In recent years, however, a combination of innovative ion activation methods, commercialization of ion mobility-mass spectrometry, progress in gas-phase ion spectroscopy, and advances in computational chemistry have led to a revolution in mass spectrometry-based glycan analysis. The present review focuses on the above techniques that expanded the traditional glycomics toolkit and provided spectacular insight into the structure of these fascinating biomolecules. To emphasize the specific challenges associated with them, major classes of mammalian glycans are discussed in separate sections. By doing so, we aim to put the spotlight on the most important element of glycobiology: the glycans themselves.

Accelerating prototyping experiments for traveling wave structures for lossless ion manipulations

Traveling wave structures for lossless ion manipulation (TW-SLIM) has proven a valuable tool for the separation and study of gas-phase ions. Unfortunately, many of the traditional components of TW-SLIM experiments manifest practical and financial barriers to the technique's broad implementation. To this end, a series of technological innovations and methodologies are presented which enable for simplified SLIM experimentation and more rapid TW-SLIM prototyping. In addition to the use of multiple independent board sets that comprise the present SLIM system, we introduce a low-cost, multifunctional traveling wave generator to produce TW within the TW-SLIM. This square-wave producing unit proved effective in realizing TW-SLIM separations compared to traditional approaches. Maintaining a focus on lowering barriers to implementation, the present set of experiments explores the use of on-board injection (OBI) methods, which offer potential alternatives to ion funnel traps. These OBI techniques proved feasible and the ability of this simplified TW-SLIM platform to enhance ion accumulation was established. Further experimentation regarding ion accumulation revealed a complexity to ion accumulation within TW-SLIM that has yet to be expounded upon. Lastly, the ability of the presented TW-SLIM platform to store ions for extended periods (1 s) without significant loss (<10%) was demonstrated. The aforementioned experiments clearly establish the efficacy of a simplified TW-SLIM platform which promises to expand adoption and experimentation of the technique.

Methodology for Analysis of Peptide Consumption by Yeast during Fermentation of Enzymatic Protein Hydrolysate Supplemented Synthetic Medium Using UPLC-IMS-HRMS

Several studies have shown the ability of yeast to consume peptides as a nitrogen source in single-peptide containing media. However, a suitable and cost-effective methodology to study the utilization of peptides by yeast and other microorganisms in a complex peptide mixture has yet to be put forward. This article addresses this issue by presenting a screening methodology for tracking the consumption of peptides by yeast during alcoholic fermentation. As a peptide source, the methodology makes use of an in-house prepared peptide-mapped bovine serum albumin (BSA) proteolytic digest, which was applied to a synthetic grape must. The peptide uptake was analyzed using high-throughput ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography coupled to data-independent acquisition-based ion mobility separation-enabled high-resolution mass spectrometry (UPLC-DIA-IMS-HRMS) analysis. The relative changes of abundance of 123 di- to hexapeptides were monitored and reported during fermentations with three commercial wine strains, demonstrating different uptake kinetics for individual peptides. Using the same peptide-mapped BSA hydrolysate, the applicability of an untargeted workflow was additionally assessed for peptide profiling in unelucidated matrixes. The comparison of the results from peptide mapping and untargeted analysis experiments highlighted the ability of untargeted analysis to consistently identify small molecular weight peptides on the length and amino acid composition. The proposed method, in combination with other analytical techniques, such as gene or protein expression analysis, can be a useful tool for different metabolic studies related to the consumption of complex nitrogen sources by yeast or other microorganisms.

Enhanced Top-Down Protein Characterization with Electron Capture Dissociation and Cyclic Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Tandem mass spectrometry of denatured, multiply charged high mass protein precursor ions yield extremely dense spectra with hundreds of broad and overlapping product ion isotopic distributions of differing charge states that yield an elevated baseline of unresolved "noise" centered about the precursor ion. Development of mass analyzers and signal processing methods to increase mass resolving power and manipulation of precursor and product ion charge through solution additives or ion-ion reactions have been thoroughly explored as solutions to spectral congestion. Here, we demonstrate the utility of electron capture dissociation (ECD) coupled with high-resolution cyclic ion mobility spectrometry (cIMS) to greatly increase top-down protein characterization capabilities. Congestion of protein ECD spectra was reduced using cIMS of the ECD product ions and "mobility fractions", that is, extracted mass spectra for segments of the 2D mobiligram (m/z versus drift time). For small proteins, such as ubiquitin (8.6 kDa), where mass resolving power was not the limiting factor for characterization, pre-IMS ECD and mobility fractions did not significantly increase protein sequence coverage, but an increase in the number of identified product ions was observed. However, a dramatic increase in performance, measured by protein sequence coverage, was observed for larger and more highly charged species, such as the +35 charge state of carbonic anhydrase (29 kDa). Pre-IMS ECD combined with mobility fractions yielded a 135% increase in the number of annotated isotope clusters and a 75% increase in unique product ions compared to processing without using the IMS dimension. These results yielded 89% sequence coverage for carbonic anhydrase.

Lipid analysis by ion mobility spectrometry combined with mass spectrometry: A brief update with a perspective on applications in the clinical laboratory

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is an analytical technique where ions are separated in the gas phase based on their mobility through a buffer gas in the presence of an electric field. An ion passing through an IMS device has a characteristic collisional cross section (CCS) value that depends on the buffer gas used. IMS can be coupled with mass spectrometry (MS), which characterizes an ion based on a mass-to-charge ratio (m/z), to increase analytical specificity and provide further physicochemical information. In particular, IMS-MS is of ever-increasing interest for the analysis of lipids, which can be problematic to accurately identify and quantify in bodily fluids by liquid chromatography (LC) with MS alone due to the presence of isomers, isobars, and structurally similar analogs. IMS provides an additional layer of separation when combined with front-end LC approaches, thereby, enhancing peak capacity and analytical specificity. CCS (and also ion mobility drift time) can be plotted against m/z ion intensity and/or LC retention time in order to generate in-depth molecular profiles of a sample. Utilization of IMS-MS for routine clinical laboratory testing remains relatively unexplored, but areas do exist for potential implementation. A brief update is provided here on lipid analysis using IMS-MS with a perspective on some applications in the clinical laboratory.

Intact Protein Mass Spectrometry for Therapeutic Protein Quantitation, Pharmacokinetics, and Biotransformation in Preclinical and Clinical Studies: An Industry Perspective

Recent advancements in immunocapture methods and mass spectrometer technology have enabled intact protein mass spectrometry to be applied for the characterization of antibodies and other large biotherapeutics from in-life studies. Protein molecules have not been traditionally studied by intact mass or screened for catabolites in the same manner as small molecules, but the landscape has changed. Researchers have presented methods that can be applied to the drug discovery and development stages, and others are exploring the possibilities of the new approaches. However, a wide variety of options for assay development exists without clear recommendation on best practice, and data processing workflows may have limitations depending on the vendor. In this perspective, we share experiences and recommendations for current and future application of mass spectrometry for biotherapeutic molecule monitoring from preclinical and clinical studies.

Denaturing and Native Mass Spectrometric Analytics for Biotherapeutic Drug Discovery Research: Historical, Current, and Future Personal Perspectives

Mass spectrometry (MS) plays a key role throughout all stages of drug development and is now as ubiquitous as other analytical techniques such as surface plasmon resonance, nuclear magnetic resonance, and supercritical fluid chromatography, among others. Herein, we aim to discuss the history of MS, both electrospray and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization, specifically for the analysis of antibodies, evolving through to denaturing and native-MS analysis of newer biologic moieties such as antibody-drug conjugates, multispecific antibodies, and interfering nucleic acid-based therapies. We discuss challenging therapeutic target characterization such as membrane protein receptors. Importantly, we compare and contrast the MS and hyphenated analytical chromatographic methods used to characterize these therapeutic modalities and targets within biopharmaceutical research and highlight the importance of appropriate MS deconvolution software and its essential contribution to project progression. Finally, we describe emerging applications and MS technologies that are still predominantly within either a development or academic stage of use but are poised to have significant impact on future drug development within the biopharmaceutic industry once matured. The views reflected herein are personal and are not meant to be an exhaustive list of all relevant MS performed within biopharmaceutical research but are what we feel have been historically, are currently, and will be in the future the most impactful for the drug development process.

In Silico Reagent Design for Electron-Transfer Dissociation on a Q-TOF

Electron-transfer dissociation is an important technique capable of probing the primary and higher order structure of a wide variety of biomolecules and yielding information that is often inaccessible using other common MS methods. The source of the electron used to initiate the fragmentation event is a radical anion, and the fragmentation process therefore depends intimately on the electronic properties of both the reagent and analyte ions. A good reagent must ionize easily and be sufficiently robust to survive transport to the reaction location, but must also be capable of donating an electron to analyte cations efficiently enough to overcome competition with other ion-ion reaction channels. Inspired by the work of Gunawardena et al. ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 12627), an in silico workflow to allow prescreening of potential electron-transfer reagents for use in glow-discharge sources is described. Approximately 150 candidate molecules have been characterized using this workflow. We discuss in detail the properties of a selected subset of singly and doubly substituted benzenes and introduce five effective new reagents that have been identified as a result of this work.

Modular Ion Mobility Calibrants for Organometallic Anions Based on Tetraorganylborate Salts

Organometallics are widely used in catalysis and synthesis. Their analysis relies heavily on mass spectrometric methods, among which traveling-wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) has gained increasing importance. Collision cross sections (CCS) obtainable by TWIMS significantly aid the structural characterization of ions in the gas phase, but for organometallics, their accuracy has been limited by the lack of appropriate calibrants. Here, we propose tetraorganylborates and their alkali-metal bound oligomers [M_n-1(BR₄)_n]^- (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs; R = aryl, Et; n = 1-6) as calibrants for electrospray ionization (ESI) TWIMS. These species chemically resemble typical organometallics and readily form upon negative-ion mode ESI of solutions of alkali-metal tetraorganylborates. By combining different tetraorganylborate salts, we have generated a large number of anions in a modular manner and determined their CCS values by drift-tube ion mobility spectrometry (DTIMS) (^DTCCS_He = 81-585, ^DTCCS_N2 = 130-704 Ų). In proof-of-concept experiments, we then applied these ^DTCCS values to the calibration of a TWIMS instrument and analyzed phenylcuprate and argentate anions, [Li_n-1M_nPh_2n]^- and [M_nPh_n+1]^- (M = Cu, Ag), as prototypical reactive organometallics. The ^TWCCS_N2 values derived from TWIMS measurements are in excellent agreement with those determined by DTIMS (<2% relative difference), demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed calibration scheme. Moreover, we used theoretical methods to predict the structures and CCS values of the anions considered. These predictions are in good agreement with the experimental results and give further insight into the trends governing the assembly of tetraorganylborate, cuprate, and argentate oligomers.

Determining Collision Cross Sections from Differential Ion Mobility Spectrometry

The experimental determination of ion-neutral collision cross sections (CCSs) is generally confined to ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) technologies that operate under the so-called low-field limit or those that enable empirical calibration strategies (e.g., traveling wave IMS; TWIMS). Correlation of ion trajectories to CCS in other non-linear IMS techniques that employ dynamic electric fields, such as differential mobility spectrometry (DMS), has remained a challenge since its inception. Here, we describe how an ion's CCS can be measured from DMS experiments using a machine learning (ML)-based calibration. The differential mobility of 409 molecular cations (m/z: 86-683 Da and CCS 110-236 Å2) was measured in a N2 environment to train the ML framework. Several open-source ML routines were tested and trained using DMS-MS data in the form of the parent ion's m/z and the compensation voltage required for elution at specific separation voltages between 1500 and 4000 V. The best performing ML model, random forest regression, predicted CCSs with a mean absolute percent error of 2.6 ± 0.4% for analytes excluded from the training set (i.e., out-of-the-bag external validation). This accuracy approaches the inherent statistical error of ∼2.2% for the MobCal-MPI CCS calculations employed for training purposes and the <2% threshold for matching literature CCSs with those obtained on a TWIMS platform.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Protein Complexes Selected by Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly in conjunction with gas-phase ion mobility spectrometry measurements, has proven useful as a structural biology tool for evaluating the stoichiometry, conformation, and topology of protein complexes. Here, we demonstrate the combination of trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) and surface-induced dissociation (SID) on a Bruker SolariX XR 15 T FT-ICR mass spectrometer for the structural analysis of protein complexes. We successfully performed SID on mobility-selected protein complexes, including the streptavidin tetramer and cholera toxin B with bound ligands. Additionally, TIMS-SID was employed on a mixture of the peptides desArg1 and desArg9 bradykinin to mobility-separate and identify the individual peptides. Importantly, results show that native-like conformations can be maintained throughout the TIMS analysis. The TIMS-SID spectra are analogous to SID spectra acquired using quadrupole mass selection, indicating little measurable, if any, structural rearrangement during mobility selection. Mobility parking was used on the ion or mobility of interest and 50-200 SID mass spectra were averaged. High-quality TIMS-SID spectra were acquired over a period of 2-10 min, comparable to or slightly longer than SID coupled with ion mobility on various instrument platforms in our laboratory. The ultrahigh resolving power of the 15 T FT-ICR allowed for the identification and relative quantification of overlapping SID fragments with the same nominal m/z based on isotope patterns, and it shows promise as a platform to probe small mass differences, such as protein/ligand binding or post-translational modifications. These results represent the potential of TIMS-SID-MS for the analysis of both protein complexes and peptides.

Misincorporation Proteomics Technologies: A Review

Proteinopathies are diseases caused by factors that affect proteoform conformation. As such, a prevalent hypothesis is that the misincorporation of noncanonical amino acids into a proteoform results in detrimental structures. However, this hypothesis is missing proteomic evidence, specifically the detection of a noncanonical amino acid in a peptide sequence. This review aims to outline the current state of technology that can be used to investigate mistranslations and misincorporations whilst framing the pursuit as Misincorporation Proteomics (MiP). The current availability of technologies explored herein is mass spectrometry, sample enrichment/preparation, data analysis techniques, and the hyphenation of approaches. While many of these technologies show potential, our review reveals a need for further development and refinement of approaches is still required.

An emerging powerful technique for distinguishing isomers: Trapped ion mobility spectrometry time-of-flight mass spectrometry for rapid characterization of estrogen isomers

RATIONALE

Isomer metabolites are involved in metabolic pathways, and their characterization is essential but remains challenging even using high-performance analytical platforms. The addition of ion mobility prior to mass analysis can help to separate isomers. Here, the ability of a recently developed trapped ion mobility spectrometry system to separate metabolite isomers was examined.

METHODS

Three pairs of estrogen isomers were studied as a model of isomeric metabolites under both negative and positive electrospray ionization (ESI) modes using a commercial trapped ion mobility spectrometry-TOF mass spectrometer. The standard metabolites were also spiked into human urine to evaluate the efficiency of trapped ion mobility spectrometry to separate isomers in complex mixtures.

RESULTS

The estradiol glucuronide isomers (E₂ β-3G and E₂ β-17G) could be distinguished as deprotonated species, while the estradiol epimers (E₂ β and E₂ α) and the methoxyestradiol isomers (2-MeO-E₂ β and 4-MeO-E₂ β) were separated as lithiated adducts in positive ionization mode. When performing analyses in the urine matrix, no alteration in the ion mobility resolving power was observed and the measured collision cross section (CCS) values varied by less than 1.0%.

CONCLUSIONS

The trapped ion mobility spectrometry-TOF mass spectrometer enabled the separation of the metabolite isomers with very small differences in CCS values (ΔCCS% = 2%). It is shown to be an effective tool for the rapid characterization of isomers in complex matrices.

Interlaboratory and Interplatform Study of Steroids Collision Cross Section by Traveling Wave Ion Mobility Spectrometry

Collision cross section (CCS) databases based on single-laboratory measurements must be cross-validated to extend their use in peak annotation. This work addresses the validation of the first comprehensive ^TWCCS_N2 database for steroids. First, its long-term robustness was evaluated (i.e., a year and a half after database generation; Synapt G2-S instrument; bias within ±1.0% for 157 ions, 95.7% of the total ions). It was further cross-validated by three external laboratories, including two different TWIMS platforms (i.e., Synapt G2-Si and two Vion IMS QToF; bias within the threshold of ±2.0% for 98.8, 79.9, and 94.0% of the total ions detected by each instrument, respectively). Finally, a cross-laboratory ^TWCCS_N2 database was built for 87 steroids (142 ions). The cross-laboratory database consists of average ^TWCCS_N2 values obtained by the four TWIMS instruments in triplicate measurements. In general, lower deviations were observed between ^TWCCS_N2 measurements and reference values when the cross-laboratory database was applied as a reference instead of the single-laboratory database. Relative standard deviations below 1.5% were observed for interlaboratory measurements (<1.0% for 85.2% of ions) and bias between average values and ^TWCCS_N2 measurements was within the range of ±1.5% for 96.8% of all cases. In the context of this interlaboratory study, this threshold was also suitable for ^TWCCS_N2 measurements of steroid metabolites in calf urine. Greater deviations were observed for steroid sulfates in complex urine samples of adult bovines, showing a slight matrix effect. The implementation of a scoring system for the application of the CCS descriptor in peak annotation is also discussed.

Collision Cross Sections of Charge-Reduced Proteins and Protein Complexes: A Database for Collision Cross Section Calibration

The use of charge-reducing reagents to generate lower-charge ions has gained popularity in the field of native mass spectrometry (MS) and ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS). This is because the lower number of charged sites decreases the propensity for Coulombic repulsions and unfolding/restructuring, helping to preserve the native-like structure. Furthermore, lowering the charge state consequently increases the mass-to-charge values (m/z), effectively increasing spacing between signals originating from small mass differences, such as different proteoforms or protein-drug complexes. IM-MS yields collision cross section (CCS, Ω) values that provide information about the three-dimensional structure of the ion. Traveling wave IM (TWIM) is an established and expanding technique within the native MS field. TWIM measurements require CCS calibration, which is achieved via the use of standard species of known CCS. Current databases for native-like proteins and protein complexes provide CCS values obtained using normal (i.e., non-charge-reducing) conditions. Herein, we explored the validity of using "normal" charge calibrants to calibrate for charge-reduced proteins and show cases where it is not appropriate. Using a custom linear field drift cell that enables the determination of ion mobilities from "first principles", we directly determined CCS values for 19 protein calibrant species under three solution conditions (yielding a broad range of charge states) and two drift gases. This has established a database of CCS and reduced-mobility (K0) values, along with their associated uncertainties, for proteins and protein complexes over a large m/z range. TWIM validation of this database shows improved accuracy over existing methods in calibrating CCS values for charge-reduced proteins.