The characterization of dissolved organic matter in alkaline fermentation of sewage sludge with different pH for volatile fatty acids production

Untangling the interplay of dissolved organic matters variation with microbial symbiotic network in sludge anaerobic fermentation triggered by various pretreatments

Various pretreatments are commonly adopted to facilitate dissolved organic matter (DOM) release from waste activated sludge (WAS) for high-valued volatile fatty acids (VFAs) promotion, while the interplay impact of DOM dynamics transformation on microbial population and metabolic function traits is poorly understood. This work constructed "DOM-microorganisms-metabolism-VFAs" symbiotic ecologic networks to disclose how DOM dynamics variation intricately interacts with bacterial community networks, assembly processes, and microbial traits during WAS fermentation. The distribution of DOM was altered by different pretreatments, triggering the release of easily biodegradable compounds (O/C ratio > 0.3) and protein-like substance. This alteration greatly improved the substrates biodegradability (higher biological index) and upregulated microbial metabolism capacity (e.g., hydrolysis and fatty acid synthesis). In turn, microbial activity modifications augment substance metabolism level and expedite the conversion of highly reactive compounds (proteins-like DOM) to VFAs, leading to 1.6-4.2 fold rise in VFAs generation. Strong correlations were found between proteins-like DOM and topological properties of DOM-bacteria associations, suggesting that high DOM availability leads to more intricate ecological networks. A change in the way communities assemble, shifting from stronger uniform selection in pH10 and USp reactors to increased randomness in heat reactor, was linked to DOM composition alterations. The ecologic networks further revealed metabolic synergy between hydrolytic-acidogenic bacteria (e.g., Bacteroidota and Firmicutes) and biodegradable DOM (e.g., proteins and amino sugars) leading to higher VFAs generation. This study provides a deeper knowledge of the inherent connections between DOM and microbial traits for efficient VFAs biosynthesis during WAS anaerobic fermentation, offering valuable insights for effective WAS pretreatment strategies.

Chemical characteristics of dissolved organic matter in effluent from sludge alkaline fermentation liquid-fed sequencing batch reactors

Sludge alkaline fermentation liquid (SAFL) is a promising alternative to acetate for improving biological nitrogen removal (BNR) from wastewater. SAFL inevitably contains some refractory compounds, while the characteristics of dissolved organic matter (DOM) in effluent from SAFL-fed BNR process remain unclear. In this study, the molecular weight distribution, fluorescent composition and molecular profiles of DOM in effluent from SAFL and acetate-fed sequencing batch reactors (S-SBRs and A-SBRs, respectively) at different hydraulic retention time (12 h and 24 h) was comparatively investigated. Two carbon sources resulted in similar effluent TN, but a larger amount of DOM, which was bio-refractory or microorganisms-derived, was found in effluent of S-SBRs. Compared to acetate, SAFL increased the proportion of large molecular weight organics and humic-like substances in effluent DOM by 74.87%-101.3% and 37.52%-48.35%, respectively, suggesting their bio-refractory nature. Molecular profiles analysis revealed that effluent DOM of S-SBRs exhibited a more diverse composition and a higher proportion of lignin-like molecules. Microorganisms-derived molecules were found to be the dominant fraction (71.51%-72.70%) in effluent DOM (<800 Da) of S-SBRs. Additionally, a prolonged hydraulic retention time enriched Bacteroidota, Haliangium and unclassified_f_Comamonadaceae, which benefited the degradation of DOM in S-SBRs. The results help to develop strategies on reducing effluent DOM in SAFL-fed BNR process.

Efficient recovery and characterization of humic acids from municipal and manure composts: A comparative study

The recovery of humic acids from low-quality compost obtained in municipal solid waste treatment plants provides opportunities for its valorization. This study compares the recovery and properties of the humic acids obtained from municipal mixed waste compost (MMWC) and manure compost. The effects of temperature, time, and KOH concentration on the ratio of humic acids in the extracted liquid and the content of organic carbon of the precipitates were investigated by response surface methodology. Optimal conditions were 30 °C and 24 h for both composts, with a KOH concentration of 0.53 M for MMWC and 0.25 M for manure compost. The manure compost provided a liquid extract richer in humic acids than MMWC (76.6 % vs. 33.7 %), but the precipitates presented similar organic carbon contents (38.1 % vs. 42.4 %). Regarding composition, both humic acids presented higher organic carbon and nitrogen contents than the composts used as feedstock. The extraction and further precipitation of humic acids reduced the concentration of heavy metals. Humic acids from manure compost have a slightly higher average molecular weight (2650 Da) than those from MMWC (1980 Da), while both present similar C/N ratios and degree of aromaticity. Most contaminants of emerging concern present in the original composts were not detected in the humic acids. Thus, it was demonstrated that MMWC constitutes an attractive source of humic acids with properties similar to those obtained from a high-quality compost and, therefore, with potential economic value.

Promoting short-chain fatty acids production from sewage sludge via acidogenic fermentation: Optimized operation factors and iron-based persulfate activation system

Promoting short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) production and ensuring the stability of SCFAs-producing process are becoming the two major issues for popularizing the acidogenic fermentation (AF). The key controlling operating and influencing factors during anaerobic fermentation process were thoroughly reviewed to facilitate better process performance prediction and to optimize the process control of SCFAs promotion. The wide utilization of iron salt flocculants during wastewater treatment could result in iron accumulating in sewage sludge which influenced AF performance. Additionally, appropriate ferric chloride (FC) could promote the SCFAs accumulation, while poly ferric sulfate (PFS) inhibited the bioprocess. Iron/persulfate (PS) system was proved to effectively enhance the SCFAs production while mechanism analysis revealed that the strong oxidizing radicals remarkably enhanced the solubilization and hydrolysis. Moreover, the changes of oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) and pH caused by iron/PS system exhibited more negative effects on the methanogens, comparing to the acidogenic bacteria. Furthermore, performance and mechanisms of different iron species-activating PS, organic chelating agents and iron-rich biochar derived from sewage sludge were also elucidated to extend and strengthen understanding of the iron/PS system for enhancing SCFAs production. Considering the large amount of generated Fe-sludge and the multiple benefits of iron activating PS system, carbon neutral wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) were proposed with Fe-sludge as a promising recycling composite to improve AF performance. It is expected that this review can deepen the knowledge of optimizing AF process and improving the iron/PS system for enhancing SCFAs production and provide useful insights to researchers in this field.

Effect of mixing intensity on volatile fatty acids production in sludge alkaline fermentation: Insights from dissolved organic matter characteristics and functional microorganisms

Alkaline fermentation for volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production has shown potential as a viable approach to treat sewage sludge. The hydrolysis and acidogenesis of sludge are greatly influenced by mixing. However, the effects of mixing intensity on VFAs production in sludge alkaline fermentation (SAF) remain poorly understood. This study investigated the impacts of mixing intensity (30, 90 and 150 rpm continuous mixing, and 150 rpm intermittent mixing) on VFAs production, dissolved organic matter (DOM) characteristics, phospholipid fatty acid profiles and microbial population distribution in SAF. Results showed that 150 rpm continuous and intermittent mixing enhanced the hydrolysis of sludge, while 150 rpm intermittent mixing resulted in the highest VFAs production (3886 ± 266.1 mg COD/L). Analysis of fluorescent and molecular characteristics of DOM revealed that 150 rpm intermittent mixing facilitated the conversion of released DOM, especially proteins-like substances, into VFAs. The abundance of unsaturated and branched fatty acids of microbes increased under 150 rpm intermittent mixing, which could aid in DOM degradation and VFAs production. Firmicutes and Tissierella were enriched at 150 rpm intermittent mixing, which favored the maximum VFAs yield. Moreover, Firmicutes were found to be the key functional microorganisms influencing the yield of VFAs during SAF. This study provides an understanding about the mixing intensity effects on VFAs production during SAF, which could be helpful to improve the yield of VFAs.

Sewage sludge pretreatment: current status and future prospects

Sewage sludge is regarded by wastewater treatment plants as problematic, from a financial and managerial point of view. Thus, a variety of disposal routes are used, but the most popular is methane fermentation. The proportion of macromolecular compounds in sewage sludges varies, and substrates treated in methane fermentation provide different amounts of biogas with various quality and quantity. Depending on the equipment and financial capabilities for methane fermentation, different methods of sewage sludge pretreatment are available. This review presents the challenges associated with the recalcitrant structure of sewage sludge and the presence of process inhibitors. We also examined the diverse methods of sewage sludge pretreatment that increase methane yield. Moreover, in the field of biological sewage sludge treatment, three future study propositions are proposed: improved pretreatment of sewage sludge using biological methods, assess the changes in microbial consortia caused with pretreatment methods, and verification of microbial impact on biomass degradation.

Insights into thermal hydrolysis pretreatment temperature for enhancing volatile fatty acids production from sludge fermentation: Performance and mechanism

To reveal the impact of thermal hydrolysis pretreatment (THP) temperature on the unclear mechanisms of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production, four groups were established with different temperatures (100, 120, 140 and 160 °C), and high throughput sequencing technology was utilized. The results indicated that the optimal VFAs production occurred at 140 °C. Moreover, as the THP temperature increased, the proportion of acetic acid also increased, accounting for 10.8% to 26.7% of the VFAs, compared to only 4.9% in the control group. Mechanism investigations revealed that THP facilitated the hydrolysis and release of biodegradable organic matter. Moreover, the abundance of VFAs production and hydrolytic microorganisms and related metabolic functional genes expression were evidently improved by THP. Overall, this study deepens the understanding of the mechanisms through which different THP temperatures stimulate the production of VFAs through acidogenic fermentation, providing technical support for future THP application in sludge treatment.

Application and improvement methods of sludge alkaline fermentation liquid as a carbon source for biological nutrient removal: A review

Alkaline fermentation can reduce the amount of waste activated sludge and prepare sludge alkaline fermentation liquid (SAFL) rich in short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), which can be used as a high-quality carbon source for the biological nutrient removal (BNR) process. This review compiles the production method of SAFL and the progress of its application as a BNR carbon source. Compared with traditional carbon sources, SAFL has the advantages of higher efficiency and economy, and different operating conditions can influence the yield and structure of SCFAs in SAFL. SAFL can significantly improve the nutrient removal efficiency of the BNR process. Taking SAFL as the internal carbon source of BNR can simultaneously solve the problem of carbon source shortage and sludge treatment difficulties in wastewater treatment plants, and further reduce the operating cost. However, the alkaline fermentation process results in many refractory organics, ammonia and phosphate in SAFL, which reduces the availability of SAFL as a carbon source. Purifying SCFAs by removing nitrogen and phosphorus, directly extracting SCFAs, or increasing the amount of SCFAs in SAFL by co-fermentation or combining with other pretreatment methods, etc., are effective measures to improve the availability of SAFL.

Thermal hydrolysis pre-treatment has no positive influence on volatile fatty acids production from sewage sludge

The study compares the potential to produce volatile fatty acids (VFA) from sewage sludge, both raw and thermally pre-treated in two modes of operation. In batch mode, raw sludge at pH 8 obtained the highest maximum VFA yield (0.41 g COD-VFA/g CODfed) whereas pre-treated sludge achieved a lower value (0.27 g COD-VFA/g CODfed). The operation of 5-L continuous reactors showed that thermal hydrolysis pre-treatment (THP) did not have any significant influence on VFA yields, averaging 15.1 % g COD-VFA/g COD with raw sludge and 16.6 % g COD-VFA/g COD with pre-treated one. Microbial community analysis showed that phylum Firmicutes was predominant in both reactors and that the enzymatic profiles involved in VFA production were very similar regardless of the substrate fed.

Release characteristics of hydrochar-derived dissolved organic matter: Effects of hydrothermal temperature and environmental conditions

Much research has been done on the preparation and application of hydrochars, but research on the release characteristics of hydrochar-derived dissolved organic matter (HDOM) is very limited; clarifying the release characteristics of HDOM is important for understanding and adjusting the environmental behaviour of hydrochar. Herein, the potential release of HDOM from rice straw-derived hydrochars prepared at different hydrothermal temperatures was investigated under various potential environmental conditions for the first time. The total release quantity and humification degree of HDOM decreased with increasing hydrothermal temperature. The critical dividing line for various hydrothermal reactions, decomposition and polymerization, was in the range of 240 °C-260 °C. Alkaline condition increased the HDOM release amount (up to 299 mg g^-1), molecular weight (as high as 423 Da) and molecular diversity (8857 compounds) from rice straw-derived hydrochars. The unique substances of HDOM released under alkaline condition were mainly distributed in lipids-like substances, CRAM/lignins-like substances, aromatic structures, and tannins-like substances, while few unique substances were found under acidic condition. Additionally, CRAM/lignins-like substances were the most abundant in all HDOM samples, reaching 82%, which were relatively stable and could achieve carbon sequestration in different environments. The findings provided a new insight on understanding the potential environment behaviors of hydrochar.

Biostimulants in dissolved organic matters recovered from anaerobic digestion sludge with alkali-hydrothermal treatment: Nontarget identification by ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry

Recovering high-value biomaterials from anaerobic digestion sludge (ADS) has attracted considerable attention. However, the molecular features and biological effects of abundant dissolved organic matters (DOMs) in ADS are still unclear, which limits the efficient recycling and application of these bioproducts. This study investigated the molecular composition and transformation of DOMs recovered from ADS through a mild-temperature alkali-hydrothermal treatment (AHT) with ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry and energy spectroscopy, and the fertilizing effects of DOMs were evaluated by rice hydroponics. The results indicated that AHT processes significantly promoted the solubilization and release of DOMs from ADS, where most of DOMs molecules remained unchanged and mainly consisted of N-containing compounds with 1-3 N atoms, featuring aromatic or N-heterocyclic rings. Furthermore, AHT processes at pH of 9-10 induced the hydrolysis of partial protein-like substances in DOMs, which was accompanied by formation of heterocyclic-N compounds. Under AHT at pH of 11-12, protein-like and heterocyclic-N substances were increasingly decomposed into amino-N compounds containing 1 or 5 N atoms, while numerous oxygenated aromatic substances with phytotoxicity were degraded and removed from DOMs. Rice hydroponic test verified that ADS-derived DOMs recovered by AHT process at pH of 12 exhibited the highest bioactivity for rice growth, which was attributed to the abundance of amino compounds and humic substances. This study proposed a novel process for the recovery of high-quality liquid organic fertilizer from ADS through AHT process, which can further enrich the technical options available for the safe utilization of sludge resources.

Enhanced economic benefit of recycling Fe3O4 for promotion of volatile fatty acids production in anaerobic fermentation of food waste

Fe₃O₄ addition in anaerobic fermentation of food waste (FW) is promising for enhancing volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production. However, the large amount of Fe₃O₄ in the digestate fertilizer leads to the waste of resources and possible toxicity to organisms. Thus, this study investigated the feasibility of Fe₃O₄ recycling for VFAs enhancement in anaerobic fermentation of FW and performed the cost-benefit evaluation of this process. Results revealed that Fe₃O₄ could be successfully recycled twice with recovery rates of 71.5% and 65.5%, respectively. X-ray diffraction analysis revealed a slight change to the Fe₂O₃-like structure after 2-time recycling. The VFAs yields were enhanced by 17.2% and 17.0% in Cycles 1 and 2 owing to the enhanced activities of hydrolytic and acid-forming enzymes. The net income of the Fe₃O₄ recycling process was about 13-fold higher than that of the conventional treatment process, suggesting a promising and economically feasible strategy for enhancing VFAs production.

Evaluation of pH regulation in carbohydrate-type municipal waste anaerobic co-fermentation: Roles of pH at acidic, neutral and alkaline conditions

This study investigated and evaluated the roles of acidic (pH 4.0), neutral (pH 7.0) and alkaline (pH 10.0) in anaerobic co-fermentation of sewage sludge and carbohydrate-type municipal waste. CO₂, CH₄ and H₂ are produced in acidic, neutral and alkaline fermentation, respectively. The neutral co-fermentation contained the vast number of aqueous metabolites as total of 22.12 g/L, with the advantage of over 50 % biodegradable components in extracellular polymeric substance and over 80 % hydrolysis rate. Acidic and alkaline pH facilitated ammonia release, with the max concentration of 0.46 g/L and 0.44 g/L, respectively. Microbial analysis indicated that pH is the key parameter to impact microbial activity and drive microbial community transition. The high abundance of Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium and Clostridium was associated with harvest of ethanol, lactic acid and acetate in acidic, neutral and alkaline fermentation. Meanwhile, the floc feature showed better dewaterability (zeta potential -8.48 mV) and poor nutrient convey (distribution spread index 1.03) in acidic fermentation. In summary, acidic and alkaline fermentation were prioritised for targeted spectrum. Neutral fermentation was prioritised for high production. This study presented an upgraded understanding of the pH role in fermentation performance, microbial structure and sludge behaviour, which benefits the development of fermentation processing unit.

Multi-Omics Analysis Reveals the Nitrogen Removal Mechanism Induced by Electron Flow during the Start-up of the Anammox-Centered Process

Significant progress in understanding the key enzymes or species of anammox has been made; however, the nitrogen removal mechanism in complex coupling systems centered on anammox remains limited. In this study, by the combination of metagenomics-metatranscriptomics analyses, the nitrogen removal in the anammox-centered coupling system that entails partial denitrification (PD) and hydrolytic acidification (HA, A-PDHA) was elucidated to be the nitrogen transformation driven by the electron generation-transport-consumption process. The results showed that a total nitrogen (TN) removal efficiency of >98%, with a TN effluence of <1 mg/L and a TN removal contribution via anammox of >98%, was achieved after 59 days under famine operation and alkaline conditions during the start-up process. Further investigation confirmed that famine operation promoted the activity of genes responsible for electron generation in anammox, and increased the abundance or expression of genes related to electron consumption. Alkaline conditions enhanced the electron generation for PD by upregulating the activity of glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase and strengthened electron transfer by increasing the gene encoding quinone pool. Altogether, these variations in the electron flow led to efficient nitrogen removal. These results improve our understanding of the nitrogen removal mechanism and application of the anammox-centered coupling systems in treating nitrogen wastewater.

Fe3O4 enhanced efficiency of volatile fatty acids production in anaerobic fermentation of food waste at high loading

High treatment capacity for food waste (FW) is required due to the huge amount generated worldwide. Conversion of FW to volatile fatty acids (VFAs) via anaerobic fermentation is a promising technology; however, inhibition of VFAs production could easily occur at high loadings. In this study, Fe3O4 was used to enhance VFAs production in anaerobic fermentation of FW at high loading, and the mechanisms involved were revealed at microbial levels. Results showed that Fe3O4 significantly enhanced VFAs yield and VFAs productivity of microbes by 160% at high loading (substrate to inoculum (S/I) ratio of 3). The enhancement effect of Fe3O4 was mainly due to the accelerated hydrolysis of particulate/soluble organics, the enriched hydrolytic and acidogenic bacteria, and the reduced relative abundance of Lactobacillus. This study provides a new approach for the high-efficient treatment of FW at high loadings, while the performance and economic benefit should be further studied for practical application.

Synergic role of ferrate and nitrite for triggering waste activated sludge solubilisation and acidogenic fermentation: Effectiveness evaluation and mechanism elucidation

Enhancing anaerobic treatment efficiency of waste activated sludge (WAS) toward preferable resource recovery would be an important requirement for achieving carbon-emission reduction, biosolids minimization, stabilization and security concurrently. This study demonstrated the synergic effect of potassium ferrate (PF) and nitrite on prompting WAS solubilisation and acidogenic fermentation toward harvesting volatile fatty acids (VFAs). The results indicated the PF+NaNO₂ co-pretreatment boosted 7.44 times and 1.32 times higher WAS solubilisation [peak soluble chemical oxygen demand (SCOD) of 2680 ± 52 mg/L] than that by the single nitrite- and PF-pretreatment, respectively, while about 2.77 times and 2.11 times higher VFAs production were achieved (maximum VFAs accumulation of 3536.25 ± 115.24 mg COD/L) as compared with the single pretreatment (nitrite and PF)-fermentations. Afterwards the WAS dewaterability was improved simultaneously after acidogenic fermentation. Moreover, a schematic diagram was established for illustrating mechanisms of the co-pretreatment of PF and nitrite for enhancing the VFAs generation via increasing key hydrolytic enzymes, metabolic functional genes expression, shifting microbial biotransformation pathways and elevating abundances of key microbes in acidogenic fermentation. Furthermore, the mechanistic investigations suggested that the PF addition was conducive to form a relatively conductive fermentation environment for enhancing electron transfer (ET) efficiency, which contributed to the VFAs biotransformation positively. This study provided an effective strategy for enhancing the biodegradation/bioconversion efficiency of WAS organic matters with potential profitable economic returns.

Recent advances and challenges in the bioconversion of acetate to value-added chemicals

Acetate is a major byproduct of the bioconversion of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide, pretreatment of lignocellulose biomass, and microbial fermentation. The utilization and valorization of acetate have been emphasized in transforming waste to clean energy and value-added platform chemicals, contributing to the development of a closed carbon loop toward a low-carbon circular bio-economy. Acetate has been used to produce several platform chemicals, including succinate, 3-hydroxypropionate, and itaconic acid, highlighting the potential of acetate to synthesize many biochemicals and biofuels. On the other hand, the yields and titers have not reached the theoretical maximum. Recently, recombinant strain development and pathway regulation have been suggested to overcome this limitation. This review provides insights into the important constraints limiting the yields and titers of the biochemical and metabolic pathways of bacteria capable of metabolizing acetate for acetate bioconversion. The current developments in recombinant strain engineering are also discussed.

Fermentation liquid as a carbon source for wastewater nitrogen removal reduced nitrogenous disinfection byproduct formation potentials of the effluent

Sludge alkaline fermentation liquid (SAFL) is an alternative to sodium acetate (NaAc) in enhancing wastewater nitrogen removal. Upon SAFL addition, dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) can be externally introduced or biologically synthesized during nitrogen removal, which is an important precursor to toxic nitrogenous disinfection by-products (N-DBPs). This study aims to evaluate the effects of different carbon source addition on effluent DON concentration, composition, and N-DBP formation potentials. A lab-scale A²O system treating real municipal wastewater was operated with NaAc or SAFL as external carbon sources. DON molecules and potential N-DBP precursors were identified by Orbitrap mass spectrometry. Subsequently, major microorganisms contributing to DON biosynthesis were suggested based on metagenomics. It was found that effluent DON was higher with SAFL as the carbon source than NaAc (1.51 ± 0.24 v.s. 0.56 ± 0.08 mg N/L, p < 0.05). Nevertheless, dichloroacetonitrile and nitrosamine formation potentials (7.14 ± 1.02 and 1.57 ± 0.07 μg/mg DON-N, respectively) of the effluent with SAFL addition were 42.79 ± 2.42% and 54.89 ± 1.70% lower than those of NaAc. Protein- and lignin-like compounds were the most abundant DON molecules in the effluent, where alanine, glycine and tyrosine were important precursors to N-DBPs. Azonexus and Flavobacterium spp. were positively correlated with these precursors, and possessed key genes involved in precursor synthesis. SAFL is a promising carbon source, not only for achieving efficient inorganic nitrogen and DON removals, but also for reducing N-DBP formation potentials of chlorinated effluent.

Enhanced production of short-chain fatty acids from sludge by thermal hydrolysis and acidogenic fermentation for organic resource recovery

Acidogenic fermentation (FM treatment) converts organics in waste sludge to valuable short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs). To maintain a favorable condition for the production of SCFAs, an alkali is often added continuously to maintain an alkaline pH in the fermenter. However, this chemical adjustment is costly and biotic hydrolysis is slow. In this research, thermal hydrolysis (TH) was introduced as a pretreatment to enhance fermentation and SCFA production. The results were compared with those obtained from the untreated sludge that underwent fermentation with a daily pH 10 adjustment (NT-FM_pH10). The TH pretreatment resulted in rapid abiotic hydrolysis within a short period (1 h), releasing more than 30.5% of organics into the liquid phase of the sludge. These dissolved organics in sludge promoted rapid acidogenesis and SCFA production. TH together with a one-time alkali pretreatment further increased the production of SCFAs during sludge fermentation (TH&Alk-FM): it produced 22.8% more SCFAs than the non-treated NT-FM_pH10 sludge with alkaline pH control during fermentation. Semicontinuous fermentation further showed the advantage of the TH&Alk-FM process, as a rapid and high production of SCFAs was achieved when the fermentation time was shortened from 5 d to 2 d. The microbial community analysis revealed that TH&Alk-FM and NT-FM_pH10 sludge samples had simple but varied microbial communities. The dominant genera in the TH&Alk-FM sludge were unclassified Ruminococcaceae (18.9%) and unclassified Porphyromonadaceae (22.3%), belonging to the classes Clostridia and Bacteroidia, respectively. NT-FM_pH10 was dominated by Tissierella (23.7%) and Proteiniborus (13.5%), which belong to Clostridia. Compared with NT-FM_pH10, the microbial consortia in TH&Alk-FM were supplied with sufficient soluble organics and performed better in fermentation and SCFA production, without the need for the daily alkali addition to control pH.

Composition Characterization and Transformation Mechanism of Dissolved Organic Matters in a Full-Scale Membrane Bioreactor Treating Co-Digestion Wastewater of Food Waste and Sewage Sludge

The membrane bioreactor (MBR) serves as the most widely used technology in anaerobic digestion wastewater treatment, but the composition and transformation of the dissolved organic matters (DOMs) are vague. This study focused on the composition characterization and transformation mechanism of DOMs in real co-digestion wastewater of food waste and sewage sludge from a full-scale MBR via molecular weight cut-off, 3D-EEM, FT-IR, and SPME-GC/MS. The results indicated that the co-digestion wastewater mainly comprised organics with molecular weight (MW) lower than 1 kDa and dominated by tryptophane-protein-like substances. The hydrolytic/acidogenic process improved the biodegradability with the conversion of high-MW organics into low-MW organics, while the two-stage A/O process possessed the highest contribution to the organic removal with the consumption of most DOMs. However, the deficient removal of refractory organics (MW < 5 kDa) in the ultrafiltration unit led to the residual DOMs in the effluent. The potential functional bacteria in the biological processes have also been identified and were principally affiliated with Proteobacteria and Firmicutes. These findings could help to advance the understanding of the co-digestion wastewater and provide fundamental information for the optimization and development of MBR in anaerobic digestion wastewater treatment.

Potential of anaerobic co-fermentation in wastewater treatments plants: A review

Fermentation (not anaerobic digestion) is an emerging biotechnology to transform waste into easily assimilable organic compounds such as volatile fatty acids, lactic acid and alcohols. Co-fermentation, the simultaneous fermentation of two or more waste, is an opportunity for wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) to increase the yields of sludge mono-fermentation. Most publications have studied waste activated sludge co-fermentation with food waste or agri-industrial waste. Mixing ratio, pH and temperature are the most studied variables. The highest fermentation yields have been generally achieved in mixtures dominated by the most biodegradable substrate at circumneutral pH and mesophilic conditions. Nonetheless, most experiments have been performed in batch assays which results are driven by the capabilities of the starting microbial community and do not allow evaluating the microbial acclimation that occurs under continuous conditions. Temperature, pH, hydraulic retention time and organic load are variables that can be controlled to optimise the performance of continuous co-fermenters (i.e., favour waste hydrolysis and fermentation and limit the proliferation of methanogens). This review also discusses the integration of co-fermentation with other biotechnologies in WWTPs. Overall, this review presents a comprehensive and critical review of the achievements on co-fermentation research and lays the foundation for future research.

Molecular composition and biotoxicity effects of dissolved organic matters in sludge-based carbon: Effects of pyrolysis temperature

Sludge pyrolysis carbonization has shown potential to convert sludge biomass into multifunctional carbon materials. However, ecological risks of dissolved organic matters (DOMs) with obscure molecular characteristics retaining in sludge-based carbons (SBCs) have received little attention. This study investigated the impact of pyrolysis temperatures on the molecular conversion and biotoxicity effects of DOMs in SBCs. The results revealed that DOMs in SBCs_300-400 were mainly derived from depolymerization of biopolymers and the polycondensation and cyclization of small intermediate molecules, which mainly consisted of aromatic CHON compounds with 1-3 N atoms, featuring high unsaturation and molecular weights. High-temperature pyrolysis (500-800 °C) promoted the decomposition and ring-opening of aromatic CHON compounds into saturated aliphatic CHO compounds with 2-4 O atoms in SBCs_500-800. Noteworthily, SBCs_300-400-derived DOMs showed relatively strong biotoxicity on the growth and development of wild-type zebrafish embryos, pakchoi seeds, and Vibrio qinghaiensis Q67, which was significantly related to aromatic amines, phenols, and heterocyclic-N compounds in DOMs of SBCs_300-400. SBCs_500-800-derived DOMs were mainly straight-chain fatty acids and showed no observable acute biotoxicity. This study highlights the negative impact of DOMs in SBCs on the ecological environment, and provides the theoretical basis for controlling toxic byproducts in sludge pyrolysis process.

Quantification of DOM effects on tetracyclines transport during struvite recovery from swine wastewater

Struvite (MgNH₄PO₄·6H₂O) recovered from livestock wastewater may impose a pharmacological threat to the environment, due to the extensive existence of antibiotics in the wastewater. In this study, tetracyclines (TCs) were selected as the typical antibiotics, and the individual processes of dissolved organic matters (DOM) evolution and their effects on TCs migration in struvite recovery from swine wastewater were discriminated and quantified. Results revealed that TCs transport was contributed by the adsorption of pure struvite crystals, struvite adsorbing DOM-TCs complex and DOM aggregation, which occupied 2.29-6.53%, 23.53-34.66%, and 59.09-74.19% of the total TCs migration amounts, respectively. A tangential flow filtration system was employed to divide DOM into five fractional parts on the basis of molecular weight cut-offs. Experimental results indicated that under alkaline conditions of struvite crystallization, DOMs with larger molecular weights, hydrolyzed to DOMs with smaller molecular weights, which consequently promoted TCs re-distribution in DOMs from higher molecular weights to those with lower molecular weights. Furthermore, a distribution model was developed to characterize TCs transport in struvite recovery by describing TCs distribution among various phases, including struvite adsorption, DOM-TCs complexing, DOM aggregation, and free state in the solution, respectively. These outcomes provided new understanding on DOM evolution and effects on antibiotics transport in phosphate recovery from wastewater.

Bacterial survival strategies in sludge alkaline fermentation for volatile fatty acids production: Study on the physiological properties, temporal evolution and spatial distribution of bacterial community

This study investigated the dynamics of ATP synthase activity, phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA) profile, and temporal evolution and spatial distribution of bacterial community to analyze bacterial survival strategies in sludge alkaline fermentation (SAF) for volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production. The results revealed a significant increase in ATP synthase activity at pH 9 and 10 (p < 0.05), which could contribute to proton entry into cells and benefit bacterial survival. PLFA analysis indicated that the unsaturated fatty acids content increased with the increase of pH. Firmicutes were the dominant microorganisms in the running stage of the pH 10 reactor (35.81-62.34%) and might have been the key microbes that influenced VFAs production. Further analysis of the spatial distribution of microbial community suggested that Firmicutes mainly lived inside flocs during SAF. These findings provide an understanding for bacterial survival strategies in SAF, which could help to develop methods to further improve VFAs yield.

On the sustainability of land applications of sewage sludge: How to apply the sewage biosolid in order to improve soil fertility and increase crop yield?

The fertilization using sewage sludge (SS) and/or SS-derived products have been extensively studied and known to increase crop yield as soil nutrients and plant growth are improved. This study aimed to evaluate two SS application methods (i.e. mulching and mixing with the soil) on soil fertility parameters and the productivity of cereal crops. It compared the effect of SS fertilization methods on changes in soil physicochemical parameters in order to highlight the application mode which gives the best agronomic values and sustains soil productivity. Foliar surface, grain starch content and grain yield of durum wheat (Triticum durum) were determined in plants grown in plastic planters for different fertilization treatments (SS-mulched, SS-mixed, urea, and unfertilized). Each SS treatment was applied in three levels (SS1 = 1% w/w ratio, SS2 = 4%, SS3 = 8.3%). The application of SS improved all soil properties compared to the control and urea, with the SS mulching treatment was the best. The significant improvement of soil fertility was confirmed by soil C:P ratio which indicated a good soil mineralization status, in particular under the screen formed by mulching that helped to conserve high soil moisture for optimizing plant growth. Soil calcium accumulated in greater amount in biosolid-soil mixtures than in SS-mulched soils. Regardless of SS doses, the highest crop grain yields were obtained with the SS mulch treatments. Mulching SS, compared to SS-mixed soils, brings better results in terms of improving soil fertility and yielding high productions. The applicable of this method is also easy in the field and/or large-scale cultures.

Effects of different temperatures and pH values on volatile fatty acids production during codigestion of food waste and thermal-hydrolysed sewage sludge and subsequent volatile fatty acids for polyhydroxyalkanoates production

The effects of temperature (35 °C and 55 °C) and pH (uncontrolled, 7 and 10) on volatile fatty acid (VFA) yields from anaerobic codigestion of food waste, and thermal-hydrolysed sewage sludge were investigated in this study. The results revealed that optimal conditions for VFA production occurred at 35 °C at pH 7 and at 10 and 55 °C at pH 7. The dominant bacterial genera associated with VFA production significantly differed when the temperature and pH were altered, including Prevotella, Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium Megasphaera, Clostridium XlVa, and Coprothermobacter. A temperature of 35 °C at pH 7 favoured mixed acid-type fermentation, while a temperature of 35 °C at pH 10 and 55 °C at pH 7 favoured butyric acid-type fermentation. The maximal polyhydroxyalkanoate content accounted for 54.8% of the dry cell at 35 °C with pH 7 fermentative liquids and comprised 58.9% 3-hydroxybutyrate (3HB) and 41.1% 3-hydroxyvalerate (3HV).

Extent of bioleaching and bioavailability reduction of potentially toxic heavy metals from sewage sludge through pH-controlled fermentation

Utilization of anaerobically stabilized sewage sludge on arable lands serve as a renewable alternative to chemical fertilizers as it enables recycling of valuable nutrients to food chain. However, probable presence of heavy metals in sewage sludge restricts the use of stabilized sludge on lands. In this study, a novel approach based on pH-controlled fermentation and anaerobic metal bioleaching was developed to reduce ecotoxicity potential of fermented sludge prior to its land application. Sewage sludge was subjected to pH-controlled fermentation process at acidic, neutral, and alkaline pH levels with the aim of increasing metal solubilization and decreasing bioavailable metal fractions through anaerobic bioleaching. Alkaline reactor performed the best among all reactors and resulted in 3-fold higher hydrolysis (34%) and 6-fold higher acidification (19%) efficiencies along with 43-fold (in average) higher metal solubilization than that of neutral pH reactor. As a result of alkaline fermentation, 32-57% of the metals remained as bioavailable and 34-59% of the metals were encapsulated as non-bioavailable within solid fraction of fermented sludge (biosolid), whereas 8-12% of total metal was solubilized into fermentation liquor. Our results reveal that anaerobic bioleaching through alkaline fermentation enables biosolid production with less metal content and low bioavailability, facilitating its utilization for agricultural purposes.

Compositional characteristics of dissolved organic matter in pharmaceutical wastewater effluent during ozonation

The compositional characteristics of dissolved organic matter (DOM) in pharmaceutical wastewater effluent can affect the further improvement and application of the ozone treatment process. The present study investigated the changes of chemical structures, molecular weight (MW) distribution, hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity distribution, fluorescence properties and the molecular composition of DOM in pharmaceutical wastewater effluent during ozonation. Besides, the toxicity change of pharmaceutical wastewater effluent during ozonation was estimated. The results show that ozone is prone to attack high MW fractions, which contributes the most to the UV₂₅₄ value and could improve the biodegradability of refractory DOM in pharmaceutical wastewater effluent. Hydrophobic acid contained the most aromatic and unsaturated bonded organic matter, and was more readily oxidized under ozonation. In fluorescent components, ozonation significantly decreased humic-like acid compounds, and hydrophobic humic-like compounds exhibited the highest removal through parallel factor analysis. At the molecular level, the main organics removed by ozone were compounds with high H/C and low O/C, especially compounds where H/C >1.5. The CHO, CHON and CHOS compounds exhibited high removal under ozonation in formula classes. Lignin compounds, condensed aromatics compounds, and unsaturated hydrocarbons were effectively removed by ozone in compound classes. After ozonation, the number of lipid and sugar compounds increased. In addition, O/Cwa (the intensity-weighted average parameters of O/C) and NOSCwa (nominal oxidation state of carbon) were significantly positively correlated with acute toxicity on the luminescence. With the increase of ozone dose, the acute toxicity of pharmaceutical wastewater effluent after ozonation first decreased and then increased.

In-situ sludge reduction performance and mechanism in an anoxic/aerobic process coupled with alternating aerobic/anaerobic side-stream reactor

Activated sludge process with anaerobic side-stream reactors (SR) in the sludge recirculation can achieve in-situ sludge reduction, but sludge reduction efficiency is limited with the low hydraulic retention time (HRT) of SR. An anoxic/aerobic (AO) process, AO coupled with anaerobic SR and AO coupled with alternating aerobic/anaerobic side-stream reactor (AO-OASR) were operated to investigate enhancing effects of alternative aerobic and anaerobic condition (AltOA) in SR on sludge reduction and pollutants removal performance. The AltOA was firstly proposed into SR with a low HRT during the long-term continuous operation. The results showed that AO-OASR presented a lower effluent COD concentration (29.6%) with no adverse effect on nitrogen removal, compared to AO, owing to the intensified refractory carbon reuse in the mainstream aerobic tank. The sludge yield in AO-OASR (0.240 g SS/g COD) was 39.7% lower than that in AO. The OASR accelerated sludge lysis and particle organic matter hydrolysis due to the weakened network strength of flocs, leading to an enhanced increase (17.3 mg/L) of dissolved organic matter (DOM), especially for the fraction of molecular weight (MW) < 25 kDa. The OASR reduced the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) content for heterotrophic anabolism in the mainstream reactor by 42.9%, compared to the ASR. MW < 25 kDa of DOM caused the disturbance of oxidative phosphorylation with a decreasing ATP synthase activity under high-level electronic transport system, leading to ATP dissipation. The cooperation interaction of predator (norank_Chitinophagales), hydrolytic/fermentative bacteria (unclassified_Bacteroidia and Delftia), and slow grower (Trichococcus) played a key role in improving the sludge reduction and carbon reuse in AO-OASR. The results provided an efficient and cost-saving technology for sludge reduction with modified SR under low HRT, which is meaningful to overcome the present bottleneck of deficient reduction efficiency for application in wastewater treatment plants.

Interactions of functional microorganisms and their contributions to methane bioconversion to short-chain fatty acids

Methane bioconversion to value-added liquid chemicals has been proposed as a promising solution to augment the petroleum-dominated chemical market. Recent investigations have reported that various electron acceptors (e.g., nitrite and nitrate) are available to drive methane bioconversion to short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs). However, little is known about effects of the rate electron acceptor supplied on liquid chemical production from methane. Herein, three independent membrane biofilm reactors (MBfRs) feeding with respective nitrate, nitrite, combined nitrate and nitrite were operated under high and low rate condition in succession, to study whether feeding rate of electron acceptors could impact the methane bioconversion to SCFAs and the associated microbiological features. Long-term operation showed that all tested electron acceptors with a high supply rate were favorable for methane bioconversion to SCFAs (990.9 mg L^-1d^-1, 1695.7 mg L^-1d^-1, and 2425.7 mg L^-1d^-1), while under a low electron acceptor feeding rate, the SCFA production rate decreased to 8.9 mg L^-1d^-1, 16.8 mg L^-1d^-1, and 260.1 mg L^-1d^-1, respectively. Microbial community characterization showed that the biofilm was predominated by Methanosarcina, Methanobacterium, Propionispora and Clostridium. On the basis of the known metabolism characteristics of these microorganisms, it was assumed that these methanogens and fermenters contributed jointly to methane bioconversion to SCFAs. The findings could be helpful to understand the role of electron acceptor rate in methane bioconversion to liquid chemicals.

Comprehensive comparison of acidic and alkaline anaerobic fermentations of waste activated sludge

This study conducted a comprehensive comparison of acidic (R_5.0) and alkaline (R_10.0) anaerobic fermentations of waste activated sludge (WAS). The results showed that alkaline fermentation was able to increase biopolymer release and benefitted the production of volatile fatty acids (VFAs). However, large amounts of the released organic matter in the R_10.0 fermented liquid had low biodegradability unsuitable for the biological nutrient removal (BNR) process, resulting in increased C, nitrogen, and phosphorus loads in BNR effluent. Further, Al was more readily released than other metals and its maximum concentration reached 134.52 mg/L in R_10.0, 2.99 times higher than in R_5.0. The fermented sludge filterability was severely deteriorated at R_10.0, as indicated by the normalized capillary suction time and specific resistance to filtration. Considering these findings, VFAs from WAS via acidic fermentation may represent a suitable carbon source for direct use in the BNR process.

Dynamic evolution of humic acids during anaerobic digestion: Exploring an effective auxiliary agent for heavy metal remediation

Information on the dynamic evolution of humic acid (HA) from anaerobic digestate and the potential of HA serving as an effective agent for remedying heavy metals is rather scarce. This study monitored the evolution of the structure and functional groups and metal-binding abilities of HA during chicken manure and corn stover anaerobic digestion (AD) processes. Higher increases in aromatic (41-66%) and oxygen-containing functional groups (37-45%) were observed in HA from the AD of corn stover, resulting in higher metal-binding abilities for Cu(II), Co(II), and Ni(II) than those of chicken manure AD. Moreover, HA extracted from fast (before day 12 for chicken manure and day 16 for corn stover), and slow (day 40) methane production stages performed different complexation capacities for the heavy metals. These results reveal the mechanisms of HA and heavy metal interactions, and confirm the potential of HA extracted from AD process for the remediation of heavy metals.

Changes in the characteristics of dissolved organic matter during sludge treatment: A critical review

Dissolved organic matter (DOM) of sludge is a heterogeneous mixture of high to low molecular weight organic substances which is including proteinaceous compounds, carbohydrates, humic substances, lipids, lignins, organic acids, organic micropollutants and other biological derived substances generated during wastewater treatment. This paper reviews definition, composition, quantification, and transformation of DOM during different sludge treatments, and the complex interplay of DOM with microbial communities. In anaerobic digestion, anaerobic digestion-refractory organic matter, particularly compounds showing polycyclic steroid-like, alkane and aromatic structures can be generated after pretreatment. During dewatering, the DOM fraction of low molecular weight proteins (< 20,000 Dalton) is the key parameter deteriorating sludge dewaterability. During composting, decomposition and polymerization of DOM occur, followed by the formation of humic substances. During landfill treatment, the composition of DOM, particularly humic substances, are related with leachate quality. Finally, suggestions are proposed for a better understanding of the transformation and degradation of DOM during sludge treatment. Future work in sludge studies needs the establishment and implementation of definitions for sample handling and the standardization of DOM methods for analysis, including sample preparation and fractionation, and data integration. A more detailed knowledge of DOM in sludge facilitates the operation and optimization of sludge treatment technologies.

Characteristics of DOM in 14 AAO processes of municipal wastewater treatment plants

The characteristics of dissolved organic matter (DOM) such as chemical composition, molecular weight (MW) distribution and hydrophobic/hydrophilic distribution can affect wastewater treatment efficiency, effluent quality and ecological risk. Fluorescence spectroscopy could provide a quick estimate of DOM characteristics during the monitoring of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). In this study, the characteristic and quantitative correlation of DOM from 14 anaerobic-anoxic-oxic (AAO) processes of WWTPs located in different provinces (municipalities) of China were investigated. The results showed that DOM of MW <1 kDa was the largest group of DOM in influent and secondary effluent, and DOM removal increased as the MW increased. Hydrophilic (HPI) fraction and hydrophobic acid (HPO-A) comprised the major portion of DOM in influent and secondary effluent and exhibited the lowest rate of removal. In addition, DOM concentrations in the northern provinces were higher than in the southern provinces, which were related to the water quality, economy and population. There were positive correlations between specific fluorescence intensity (SFI) and the MW <1 kDa, 1-5 kDa and <10 kDa fractions. The smaller the molecular weight, the better the correlation. Strong positive correlations between regional fluorescence proportion (f_i) and HPI were found. SFI and f_i may be explored as potential indicators of the MW fractions and the hydrophobic/hydrophilic distribution of DOM in AAO processes WWTPs.

In-situ monitoring of the unstable bacterial adhesion process during wastewater biofilm formation: A comprehensive study

The initial bacterial adhesion phase is a pivotal and unstable step in the formation of biofilms. The initiation of biofilm formation is an unstable process caused by the reversible adhesion of bacteria, which is always time-consuming and yet to be elucidated. In this study, impedance-based real time cell analysis (RTCA) was employed to comprehensively investigate the initial bacterial adhesion process. Results showed that the time required for the unstable adhesion process was significantly (p < 0.05) reduced by increasing the initial concentration of bacteria, which is mainly attributed to the large deposition rate of bacteria at high concentrations. In addition, the unstable adhesion process is also regulated by shear stress, derived in this work from orbital shaking. Shear stress improves the reversibility of unstable bacterial attachment. Furthermore, attachment characteristics during the unstable phase vary between different species of bacteria (Sphingomonas rubra, Nakamurella multipartita and mixed bacteria). The S. rubra strain and mixed culture were more prone to adhere to the substratum surface during the unstable process, which was attributed to the smaller xDLVO energy barrier and motility of species in comparison with N. multipartita. Meanwhile, the molecular composition of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in the initial attachment phase presented a significant difference in expressed proteins, indicating the important role of proteins in EPS that strengthen bacterial adhesion. Overall, these findings suggest that during the biofilm reactor start-up process, seed sludge conditions, including the bacterial concentration, composition and hydraulics, need to be carefully considered.

Characteristics of dissolved organic nitrogen in effluent from a biological nitrogen removal process using sludge alkaline fermentation liquid as an external carbon source

The addition of sludge alkaline fermentation liquid (SAFL) to biological nutrient removal (BNR) processes has been widely shown to reduce the dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) in the effluent. However, knowledge regarding the effect of using SAFL in a BNR as an additional carbon source on the characteristics of dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) in the effluent is limited. This study investigated the effect of SAFL addition on effluent DON features and microbial community dynamics in a BNR process treating municipal wastewater. The performance of SAFL was compared with other two reactors (i.e., without an external carbon source and with the addition of sodium acetate). The results showed that the addition of SAFL can significantly reduce effluent DON (p < 0.05). The effluent DON was slightly higher with SAFL than with sodium acetate, but the bioavailable DON of the two reactors was similar (1.06 ± 0.11 vs 1.04 ± 0.12 mg/L, respectively, p > 0.05). The SAFL addition led to a decreased percentage of low molecular weight DON (p < 0.05) as well as an increased ratio of fulvic-like and humic-like substances to proteins-like substances. Moreover, the SAFL addition resulted in a lower percentage of substances resembling proteins/amino sugars and a higher percentage of lignin-like molecules than sodium acetate. These features accounted for the low DON bioavailability. The SAFL promoted the increased abundance of Bacteroidetes, Chloroflexi, Comamonadaceae and Rhodocyclaceae, which could be associated with the decreased effluent DON and its bioavailability. This study indicates that using SAFL as a BNR carbon source not only improves the removal of DIN but also reduces effluent DON and specifically DON bioavailability. These results facilitate the acquisition of comprehensive knowledge regarding the use of SAFL as an alternative external carbon source in the BNR process.

Volatile fatty acid production from semi-synthetic milk processing wastewater under alkali pH: The pearls and pitfalls of microbial culture

Volatile fatty acids (VFA) are one of the most promising sustainable and environmentally friendly bioproduct owing to their wide usage area and high market demand. For this reason, in this study, the evaluation of VFA production from pure and mixed bacterial cultures was aimed. Three different mixed cultures with C. aceticum, C. butyricum and P. acidipropionici as pure cultures were used for inoculation of milk processing wastewater fermentation under pH 10 for 15 days. The mixed culture fermentation had the highest VFA production efficiency whereas the highest amount of acetic, butyric and propionic acid productions were obtained by C. aceticum, C. butyricum and P. acidipropionici, respectively. Also, the mixed cultures demonstrated faster pH regulation and acclimation than the pure cultures tested. Therefore, development of synthetic cultures may offer a useful approach to produce VFA mixtures with one-dominant acid type and with high production efficiency.