Meta-stability of the hemifusion intermediate induced by glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored influenza hemagglutinin

Viral Membrane Fusion and the Transmembrane Domain

Initiation of host cell infection by an enveloped virus requires a viral-to-host cell membrane fusion event. This event is mediated by at least one viral transmembrane glycoprotein, termed the fusion protein, which is a key therapeutic target. Viral fusion proteins have been studied for decades, and numerous critical insights into their function have been elucidated. However, the transmembrane region remains one of the most poorly understood facets of these proteins. In the past ten years, the field has made significant advances in understanding the role of the membrane-spanning region of viral fusion proteins. We summarize developments made in the past decade that have contributed to the understanding of the transmembrane region of viral fusion proteins, highlighting not only their critical role in the membrane fusion process, but further demonstrating their involvement in several aspects of the viral lifecycle.

A Hydrophobic Target: Using the Paramyxovirus Fusion Protein Transmembrane Domain To Modulate Fusion Protein Stability

Enveloped viruses utilize surface glycoproteins to bind and fuse with a target cell membrane. The zoonotic Hendra virus (HeV), a member of the family Paramyxoviridae, utilizes the attachment protein (G) and the fusion protein (F) to perform these critical functions. Upon triggering, the trimeric F protein undergoes a large, irreversible conformation change to drive membrane fusion. Previously, we have shown that the transmembrane (TM) domain of the F protein, separate from the rest of the protein, is present in a monomer-trimer equilibrium. This TM-TM association contributes to the stability of the prefusion form of the protein, supporting a role for TM-TM interactions in the control of F protein conformational changes. To determine the impact of disrupting TM-TM interactions, constructs expressing the HeV F TM with limited flanking sequences were synthesized. Coexpression of these constructs with HeV F resulted in dramatic reductions in the stability of F protein expression and fusion activity. In contrast, no effects were observed when the HeV F TM constructs were coexpressed with the nonhomologous parainfluenza virus 5 (PIV5) fusion protein, indicating a requirement for specific interactions. To further examine this, a TM peptide homologous to the PIV5 F TM domain was synthesized. Addition of the peptide prior to infection inhibited infection with PIV5 but did not significantly affect infection with human metapneumovirus, a related virus. These results indicate that targeted disruption of TM-TM interactions significantly impact viral fusion protein stability and function, presenting these interactions as a novel target for antiviral development.IMPORTANCE Enveloped viruses require virus-cell membrane fusion to release the viral genome and replicate. The viral fusion protein triggers from the pre- to the postfusion conformation, an essentially irreversible change, to drive membrane fusion. We found that small proteins containing the TM and a limited flanking region homologous to the fusion protein of the zoonotic Hendra virus reduced protein expression and fusion activity. The introduction of exogenous TM peptides may displace a TM domain, disrupting native TM-TM interactions and globally destabilizing the fusion protein. Supporting this hypothesis, we showed that a sequence-specific transmembrane peptide dramatically reduced viral infection in another enveloped virus model, suggesting a broader inhibitory mechanism. Viral fusion protein TM-TM interactions are important for protein function, and disruption of these interactions dramatically reduces protein stability.

Imaging approaches for analysis of cholesterol distribution and dynamics in the plasma membrane

Cholesterol is an important lipid component of the plasma membrane (PM) of mammalian cells, where it is involved in control of many physiological processes, such as endocytosis, cell migration, cell signalling and surface ruffling. In an attempt to explain these functions of cholesterol, several models have been put forward about cholesterol's lateral and transbilayer organization in the PM. In this article, we review imaging techniques developed over the last two decades for assessing the distribution and dynamics of cholesterol in the PM of mammalian cells. Particular focus is on fluorescence techniques to study the lateral and inter-leaflet distribution of suitable cholesterol analogues in the PM of living cells. We describe also several methods for determining lateral cholesterol dynamics in the PM including fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), single particle tracking (SPT) and spot variation FCS coupled to stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy. For proper interpretation of such measurements, we provide some background in probe photophysics and diffusion phenomena occurring in cell membranes. In particular, we show the equivalence of the reaction-diffusion approach, as used in FRAP and FCS, and continuous time random walk (CTRW) models, as often invoked in SPT studies. We also discuss mass spectrometry (MS) based imaging of cholesterol in the PM of fixed cells and compare this method with fluorescence imaging of sterols. We conclude that evidence from many experimental techniques converges towards a model of a homogeneous distribution of cholesterol with largely free and unhindered diffusion in both leaflets of the PM.

The transmembrane domain peptide of vesicular stomatitis virus promotes both intermediate and pore formation during PEG-mediated vesicle fusion

We propose mechanisms by which the transmembrane domain of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV-TMD) promotes both initiation of fusion and formation of a fusion pore. Time courses of polyethyleneglycol (PEG)-mediated fusion of 25 nm small unilamellar vesicles composed of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE), bovine brain sphingomyelin, and cholesterol (35:30:15:20 molar ratio) were recorded at pH 7.4 at five different temperatures (from 17°C to 37°C) and compared with time courses obtained with the same vesicles containing the fusion-active TMD of the G protein of VSV. Multiple time courses were fitted globally to a one-intermediate ensemble kinetic model to estimate the rate constants for conversion of the aggregated state to an intermediate hemifused state (k1, stalk, or I1) that rapidly transits to an unstable intermediate (I2 state) that converts to a final fusion pore state with a combined rate k3. The probabilities of lipid mixing, contents mixing, and contents leakage in the three states were also obtained from this analysis. The activation thermodynamics for each step were consistent with previously published models of lipid rearrangements during intermediate and pore formation. The influences of VSV-TMD, hexadecane, and VSV-TMD + hexadecane on the kinetics, activation thermodynamics, and membrane structure support the hypothesis that these two agents do not catalyze fusion by a common mechanism, except possibly at the lowest temperatures examined. VSV-TMD primarily catalyzed initial intermediate formation, although it substantially increased the probability of contents mixing in the intermediate state. Our results support the hypothesis that the catalytic influence of VSV-TMD on the initial-intermediate- and pore-forming steps of PEG-mediated fusion derives from its ability to impose a positive intrinsic curvature and thereby stress small unilamellar vesicle outer leaflets as well as the periphery of intermediate microstructures.

Class II fusion proteins

Enveloped viruses rely on fusion proteins in their envelope to fuse the viral membrane to the host-cell membrane. This key step in viral entry delivers the viral genome into the cytoplasm for replication. Although class II fusion proteins are genetically and structurally unrelated to class I fusion proteins, they use the same physical principles and topology as other fusion proteins to drive membrane fusion. Exposure of a fusion loop first allows it to insert into the host-cell membrane. Conserved hydrophobic residues in the fusion loop act as an anchor, which penetrates only partway into the outer bilayer leaflet of the host-cell membrane. Subsequent folding back of the fusion protein on itself directs the C-terminal viral transmembrane anchor towards the fusion loop. This fold-back forces the host-cell membrane (held by the fusion loop) and the viral membrane (held by the C-terminal transmembrane anchor) against each other, resulting in membrane fusion. In class II fusion proteins, the fold-back is triggered by the reduced pH of an endosome, and is accompanied by the assembly of fusion protein monomers into trimers. The fold-back occurs by domain rearrangement rather than by an extensive refolding of secondary structure, but this domain rearrangement and the assembly of monomers into trimers together bury a large surface area. The energy that is thus released exerts a bending force on the apposed viral and cellular membranes, causing them to bend towards each other and, eventually, to fuse.

Beyond anchoring: the expanding role of the hendra virus fusion protein transmembrane domain in protein folding, stability, and function

While work with viral fusion proteins has demonstrated that the transmembrane domain (TMD) can affect protein folding, stability, and membrane fusion promotion, the mechanism(s) remains poorly understood. TMDs could play a role in fusion promotion through direct TMD-TMD interactions, and we have recently shown that isolated TMDs from three paramyxovirus fusion (F) proteins interact as trimers using sedimentation equilibrium (SE) analysis (E. C. Smith, et al., submitted for publication). Immediately N-terminal to the TMD is heptad repeat B (HRB), which plays critical roles in fusion. Interestingly, addition of HRB decreased the stability of the trimeric TMD-TMD interactions. This result, combined with previous findings that HRB forms a trimeric coiled coil in the prefusion form of the whole protein though HRB peptides fail to stably associate in isolation, suggests that the trimeric TMD-TMD interactions work in concert with elements in the F ectodomain head to stabilize a weak HRB interaction. Thus, changes in TMD-TMD interactions could be important in regulating F triggering and refolding. Alanine insertions between the TMD and HRB demonstrated that spacing between these two regions is important for protein stability while not affecting TMD-TMD interactions. Additional mutagenesis of the C-terminal end of the TMD suggests that β-branched residues within the TMD play a role in membrane fusion, potentially through modulation of TMD-TMD interactions. Our results support a model whereby the C-terminal end of the Hendra virus F TMD is an important regulator of TMD-TMD interactions and show that these interactions help hold HRB in place prior to the triggering of membrane fusion.

The final conformation of the complete ectodomain of the HA2 subunit of influenza hemagglutinin can by itself drive low pH-dependent fusion

One of the best characterized fusion proteins, the influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA), mediates fusion between the viral envelope and the endosomal membrane during viral entry into the cell. In the initial conformation of HA, its fusogenic subunit, the transmembrane protein HA2, is locked in a metastable conformation by the receptor-binding HA1 subunit of HA. Acidification in the endosome triggers HA2 refolding toward the final lowest energy conformation. Is the fusion process driven by this final conformation or, as often suggested, by the energy released by protein restructuring? Here we explored structural properties as well as the fusogenic activity of the full sized trimeric HA2(1-185) (here called HA2*) that presents the final conformation of the HA2 ectodomain. We found HA2* to mediate fusion between lipid bilayers and between biological membranes in a low pH-dependent manner. Two mutations known to inhibit HA-mediated fusion strongly inhibited the fusogenic activity of HA2*. At surface densities similar to those of HA in the influenza virus particle, HA2* formed small fusion pores but did not expand them. Our results confirm that the HA1 subunit responsible for receptor binding as well as the transmembrane and cytosolic domains of HA2 is not required for fusion pore opening and substantiate the hypothesis that the final form of HA2 is more important for fusion than the conformational change that generates this form.

Structure and working of viral fusion machinery

This chapter discusses the structure and working of viral fusion machinery. The entry of enveloped viruses into cells requires the fusion of viral and cellular membranes, driven by conformational changes in viral glycoproteins. Structural studies have defined three classes of viral membrane fusion proteins. Despite their different structural organizations, all seem to have a common mechanism of action that generates the same lipid organizations during the fusion pathway. The entry of enveloped viruses into host cells requires binding of the virus to one or more receptors present at the cell surface, followed by fusion of the viral envelope with a cellular membrane. These steps are mediated by virally encoded glycoproteins that promote both receptor recognition and membrane fusion. The first crystal structure of a viral fusion protein ectodomain that has been determined is that of influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) in its prefusion conformation. The structures of viral fusion glycoproteins, of which the conformational change is triggered at low pH, has allowed the identification of amino acid residues that play the role of pH-sensitive molecular switches.

Direct visualization of large and protein-free hemifusion diaphragms

Fusion of cellular membranes is a ubiquitous biological process requiring remodeling of two phospholipid bilayers. We believe it is very likely that merging of membranes proceeds via similar sequential intermediates. Contacting membranes form a stalk between the proximal leaflets that expands radially into an hemifusion diaphragm (HD) and subsequently open to a fusion pore. Although considered to be a key intermediate in fusion, direct experimental verification of this structure is difficult due to its transient nature. Using confocal fluorescence microscopy we have investigated the fusion of giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) containing phosphatidylserine and fluorescent virus derived transmembrane peptides or membrane proteins in the presence of divalent cations. Time-resolved imaging revealed that fusion was preceded by displacement of peptides and fluorescent lipid analogs from the GUV-GUV adhesion region. A detailed analysis of this area being several mum in size revealed that peptides were completely sequestered as expected for an HD. Lateral distribution of lipid analogs was consistent with formation of an HD but not with the presence of two adherent bilayers. Formation and size of the HD were dependent on lipid composition and peptide concentration.

Structural features of fusogenic model transmembrane domains that differentially regulate inner and outer leaflet mixing in membrane fusion

The transmembrane domains of fusion proteins are known to be important for their fusogenic activity. In an effort to systematically investigate the structure/function relationships of transmembrane domains we had previously designed LV-peptides that mimic natural fusion protein TMDs in their ability to drive fusion after incorporation into liposomal membranes. Here, we investigate the impact of different structural features of LV-peptide TMDs on inner and outer leaflet mixing. We find that fusion driven by the helical peptides involves a hemifusion intermediate as previously seen for natural fusion proteins. Helix backbone dynamics enhances fusion by selectively promoting outer leaflet mixing. Furthermore, the hydrophobic length of the peptides as well as covalent attachment of long acyl chains affects outer and inner leaflet mixing to different extents. Different structural features of transmembrane domains thus appear to differentially influence the rearrangements of lipids in fusion initiation and the hemifusion-to-fusion transition. The relevance of these findings in respect to the function of natural fusion proteins is discussed.

Internalization and fusion mechanism of vesicular stomatitis virus and related rhabdoviruses

Members of the Rhabdoviridae infect a wide variety of animals and plants, and are the causative agents of many important diseases. Rhabdoviruses enter host cells following internalization into endosomes, with the glycoprotein (G protein) mediating both receptor binding to host cells and fusion with the cellular membrane. The recently solved crystal structure of vesicular stomatitis virus G has allowed considerable insight into the mechanism of rhabdovirus entry, in particular the low pH-dependent conformational changes that lead to fusion activation. Rhabdovirus entry shows several distinct features compared with other enveloped viruses; first, the entry process appears to consist of two distinct fusion events, initial fusion into vesicles within endosomes followed by back-fusion into the cytosol; second, the conformational changes in the G protein that lead to fusion activation are reversible; and third, the G protein is structurally distinct from other viral fusion proteins and is not proteolytically cleaved. The internalization and fusion mechanisms of rhabdoviruses are discussed in this article, with a focus on viral systems where the G protein has been studied extensively: vesicular stomatitis virus and rabies virus, as well as viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus.

Class I and class II viral fusion protein structures reveal similar principles in membrane fusion (Review)

Recent crystal structures of Flavivirus and Alphavirus fusion proteins (class II) confirm two major principles of protein machineries that mediate the merger of two opposing lipid bilayers. First, the fusion protein can bridge both membranes tethered by two membrane anchors. Second, refolding or domain rearrangement steps lead to the positioning of both anchors into close proximity at the same end of an elongated structure. Although these two steps are in principle sufficient to pull two opposing membranes together and initiate membrane fusion, accumulating evidence suggests that the process requires the concerted action of a number of fusion proteins at and outside the contact sites. This review will focus on the structures of viral class I and class II fusion proteins and their similarities in facilitating membrane fusion.

Molecular Mechanisms of Flaviviral Membrane Fusion

Enveloped viruses rely on transmembrane fusion proteins to fuse the viral membrane to the host-cell membrane and deliver the viral genome into the cytoplasm for replication. Although the structures and evolutionary origins of viral fusion proteins vary widely, all fusion proteins use the same physical principles and topology to drive membrane fusion. First, exposure of a hydrophobic fusion anchor allows them to insert into the host-cell membrane. Conserved hydrophobic residues in the fusion anchor penetrate part way into the outer bilayer leaflet of the host-cell membrane. The fusion protein then folds back on itself, directing the C-terminal viral transmembrane anchor toward the fusion loop. This fold-back forces the host-cell membrane (held by the fusion loop) and the viral membrane (held by the C-terminal transmembrane anchor) against one another until they fuse. In West Nile virus and other flaviviruses this fold-back in the fusion protein, E, is triggered by the reduced pH of an endosome, is accompanied by the assembly of E monomers into trimers, and occurs by domain rearrangement rather than by an extensive refolding of secondary structure. The rearrangement releases a large amount of energy, which is used to exert a bending force on the apposed viral and cellular membranes, propelling them toward each other and, eventually, causing them to fuse. The conserved regions of E that are responsible for driving membrane fusion are attractive targets for antiviral therapies.

The fusion pores of Ca2+ -triggered exocytosis

The aqueous compartment inside a vesicle makes its first connection with the extracellular fluid through an intermediate structure termed the exocytotic fusion pore. Progress in exocytosis can be measured in terms of the formation and growth of the fusion pore. The fusion pore has become a major focus of research in exocytosis; sensitive biophysical measurements have provided various glimpses of what it looks like and how it behaves. Some of the principal questions about the molecular mechanism of exocytosis can be cast explicitly in terms of properties and transitions of fusion pores. This Review will present current knowledge about fusion pores in Ca(2+)-triggered exocytosis, highlight recent advances and relate questions about fusion pores to broader issues concerning how cells regulate exocytosis and how nerve terminals release neurotransmitter.

Functions of SNAREs in intracellular membrane fusion and lipid bilayer mixing

Intracellular membrane fusion occurs with exquisite coordination and specificity. Each fusion event requires three basic components: Rab-GTPases organize the fusion site; SNARE proteins act during fusion; and N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor (NSF) plus its cofactor alpha-SNAP are required for recycling or activation of the fusion machinery. Whereas Rab-GTPases seem to mediate the initial membrane contact, SNAREs appear to lie at the center of the fusion process. It is known that formation of complexes between SNAREs from apposed membranes is a prerequisite for lipid bilayer mixing; however, the biophysics and many details of SNARE function are still vague. Nevertheless, recent observations are shedding light on the role of SNAREs in membrane fusion. Structural studies are revealing the mechanisms by which SNARES form complexes and interact with other proteins. Furthermore, it is now apparent that the SNARE transmembrane segment not only anchors the protein but engages in SNARE-SNARE interactions and plays an active role in fusion. Recent work indicates that the fusion process itself may comprise two stages and proceed via a hemifusion intermediate.

The energetics of membrane fusion from binding, through hemifusion, pore formation, and pore enlargement

The main steps of viral membrane fusion are local membrane approach, hemifusion, pore formation, and pore enlargement. Experiments and theoretical analyses have helped determine the relative energies required for each step. Key protein structures and conformational changes of the fusion process have been identified. The physical deformations of monolayer bending and lipid tilt have been applied to the steps of membrane fusion. Experiment and theory converge to strongly indicate that, contrary to former conceptions, the fusion process is progressively more energetically difficult: hemifusion has a relatively low energy barrier, pore formation is more energy-consuming, and pore enlargement is the most difficult to achieve.

Protein-Lipid Interplay in Fusion and Fission of Biological Membranes

Disparate biological processes involve fusion of two membranes into one and fission of one membrane into two. To formulate the possible job description for the proteins that mediate remodeling of biological membranes, we analyze the energy price of disruption and bending of membrane lipid bilayers at the different stages of bilayer fusion. The phenomenology and the pathways of the well-characterized reactions of biological remodeling, such as fusion mediated by influenza hemagglutinin, are compared with those studied for protein-free bilayers. We briefly consider some proteins involved in fusion and fission, and the dependence of remodeling on the lipid composition of the membranes. The specific hypothetical mechanisms by which the proteins can lower the energy price of the bilayer rearrangement are discussed in light of the experimental data and the requirements imposed by the elastic properties of the bilayer.

Progressive truncations C terminal to the membrane-spanning domain of simian immunodeficiency virus Env reduce fusogenicity and increase concentration dependence of Env for fusion

The simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) transmembrane (TM) protein, gp41, has multiple functions, which include anchoring the glycoprotein complex in the lipid envelope of the virus and mediating fusion of the virus and host cell membranes. Recently, a series of mutants of the SIVmac239 TM protein that have truncations at the carboxyl terminus of the membrane-spanning domain (MSD) have been characterized (J. T. West, P. Johnston, S. R. Dubay, and E. Hunter, J. Virol. 75:9601-9612, 2001). These mutants retained membrane anchorage but demonstrated reduced fusogenicity and infectivity as the MSD length was shortened. We have established a novel three-color fluorescence assay, which allows qualitative confocal and quantitative flow cytometric analyses, to further characterize the nature of the fusion defect in five of the MSD mutants: TM185, TM186, TM187, TM188, and TM189. Our analysis showed that each mutant could mediate complete lipid and aqueous dye transfer at early time points after effector and target cell mixing. No hemifusion with only lipid dye flux was detected. However, another intermediate fusion stage, which appears to involve small-fusion-pore formation that allowed small aqueous dye transfer but prevented the exchange of large cytoplasmic components, was identified infrequently in mutant-Env-expressing cell and target cell mixtures. Quantitative flow cytometric analysis of these mutants demonstrated that the TM187, TM188, and TM189 mutants were significantly more fusogenic than TM185 and TM186 but remained significantly impaired compared to the wild type. Moreover, fusion efficiency showed an increased dependence on the expression level of glycoproteins, suggesting that, for these mutants, formation of an active fusion complex was an increasingly stochastic event.

The protein coat in membrane fusion: lessons from fission

Multiple cell biological processes involve two opposite rearrangements of membrane configuration, referred to as fusion and fission. While membrane intermediates in protein-mediated fusion have been studied in some detail, the global force which drives sequential stages of the fusion reaction from early local intermediates to an expanding fusion pore remains unknown. Fusion proceeds via stages, which are analogous but in the opposite direction to that of membrane budding-off and fission driven by protein coats. On the basis of this analogy, we propose that an interconnected coat formed by membrane-bound activated fusion proteins surrounding the membrane contact zone generates the driving force for fusion. This fusion protein coat has a strongly curved intrinsic shape opposite to that of the protein coat driving fission. To relieve internal stresses, the fusion protein coat spontaneously bends out of the initial shape of the membrane surface. This bending produces elastic stresses in the underlying lipid bilayer and drives its fusion with the apposing membrane. The hypothesis that 'bystander' proteins (i.e. fusion proteins outside the contact zone) generate the driving force for fusion offers a new interpretation for a number of known features of the fusion reaction mediated by the prototype fusion protein, influenza hemagglutinin, and might bring new insights into mechanisms of other fusion reactions.

Stochastic simulation of hemagglutinin-mediated fusion pore formation

Studies on fusion between cell pairs have provided evidence that opening and subsequent dilation of a fusion pore are stochastic events. Therefore, adequate modeling of fusion pore formation requires a stochastic approach. Here we present stochastic simulations of hemagglutinin (HA)-mediated fusion pore formation between HA-expressing cells and erythrocytes based on numerical solutions of a master equation. The following elementary processes are taken into account: 1) lateral diffusion of HA-trimers and receptors, 2) aggregation of HA-trimers to immobilized clusters, 3) reversible formation of HA-receptor contacts, and 4) irreversible conversion of HA-receptor contacts into stable links between HA and the target membrane. The contact sites between fusing cells are modeled as superimposed square lattices. The model simulates well the statistical distribution of time delays measured for the various intermediates of fusion pore formation between cell-cell fusion complexes. In particular, these are the formation of small ion-permissive and subsequent lipid-permissive fusion pores detected experimentally (R. Blumenthal, D. P. Sarkar, S. Durell, D. E. Howard, and S. J., J. Cell Biol. 135:63-71). Moreover, by averaging the simulated individual stochastic time courses across a larger population of cell-cell-complexes the model also provides a reasonable description of kinetic measurements on lipid mixing in cell suspensions (T. Danieli, S. L. Pelletier, Y.I. Henis, and J. M. White, 1996, J. Cell Biol. 133:559-569).

Peptide mimics of the vesicular stomatitis virus G-protein transmembrane segment drive membrane fusion in vitro

The efficiency of cell-cell fusion mediated by heterologously expressed vesicular stomatitis virus G-protein has previously been shown to be affected by mutating its transmembrane segment. Here, we show that a synthetic peptide modeled after this transmembrane segment drives liposome-liposome fusion. Addition of millimolar Ca(2+) concentrations strongly potentiated the effect of the peptides suggesting that Ca(2+)-mediated liposome aggregation supports the activity of the peptide. Peptide-driven fusion was suppressed by lysolipid, an established inhibitor of natural membrane fusion, and involved inner and outer leaflets of the liposomal bilayer. Thus, transmembrane segment peptide-driven liposome fusion exhibits important hallmarks characteristic of natural membrane fusion. Importantly, the mutations previously shown to attenuate the function of full-length G-protein in cell-cell fusion also attenuated the fusogenicity of the peptide, albeit in a less pronounced fashion. Therefore, the function of the peptide mimic is dependent on its primary structure, similar to full-length G-protein. Together, our data suggest that the G-protein transmembrane segment is an autonomous functional domain. We propose that it acts at a late step in membrane fusion elicited by vesicular stomatitis virus.

Peptide mimics of SNARE transmembrane segments drive membrane fusion depending on their conformational plasticity

SNARE proteins are essential for different types of intracellular membrane fusion. Whereas interaction between their cytoplasmic domains is held responsible for establishing membrane proximity, the role of the transmembrane segments in the fusion process is currently not clear. Here, we used an in vitro approach based on lipid mixing and electron microscopy to examine a potential fusogenic activity of the transmembrane segments. We show that the presence of synthetic peptides representing the transmembrane segments of the presynaptic soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors (SNAREs) synaptobrevin II (also referred to as VAMP II) or syntaxin 1A, but not of an unrelated control peptide, in liposomal membranes drives their fusion. Liposome aggregation by millimolar Ca(2+) concentrations strongly potentiated the effect of the peptides; this indicates that juxtaposition of the bilayers favours their fusion in the absence of the cytoplasmic SNARE domains. Peptide-driven fusion is reminiscent of natural membrane fusion, since it was suppressed by lysolipid and involved both bilayer leaflets. This suggests transient presence of a hemifusion intermediate followed by complete membrane merger. Structural studies of the peptides in lipid bilayers performed by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy indicated mixtures of alpha-helical and beta-sheet conformations. In isotropic solution, circular dichroism spectroscopy showed the peptides to exist in a concentration-dependent equilibrium of alpha-helical and beta-sheet structures. Interestingly, the fusogenic activity decreased with increasing stability of the alpha-helical solution structure for a panel of variant peptides. Thus, structural plasticity of transmembrane segments may be important for SNARE protein function at a late step in membrane fusion.

The 1-127 HA2 construct of influenza virus hemagglutinin induces cell-cell hemifusion

Conformational changes in the HA2 subunit of influenza hemagglutinin (HA) are coupled to membrane fusion. We investigated the fusogenic activity of the polypeptide FHA2 representing 127 amino-terminal residues of the ectodomain of HA2. While the conformation of FHA2 both at neutral and at low pH is nearly identical to the final low-pH conformation of HA2, FHA2 still induces lipid mixing between liposomes in a low-pH-dependent manner. Here, we found that FHA2 induces lipid mixing between bound cells, indicating that the "spring-loaded" energy is not required for FHA2-mediated membrane merger. Although, unlike HA, FHA2 did not form an expanding fusion pore, both acidic pH and membrane concentrations of FHA2, required for lipid mixing, have been close to those required for HA-mediated fusion. Similar to what is observed for HA, FHA2-induced lipid mixing was reversibly blocked by lysophosphatidylcholine and low temperature, 4 degrees C. The same genetic modification of the fusion peptide inhibits both HA- and FHA2-fusogenic activities. The kink region of FHA2, critical for FHA2-mediated lipid mixing, was exposed in the low-pH conformation of the whole HA prior to fusion. The ability of FHA2 to mediate lipid mixing very similar to HA-mediated lipid mixing is consistent with the hypothesis that hemifusion requires just a portion of the energy released in the conformational change of HA at acidic pH.

The transmembrane domain of influenza hemagglutinin exhibits a stringent length requirement to support the hemifusion to fusion transition

Glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored influenza hemagglutinin (GPI-HA) mediates hemifusion, whereas chimeras with foreign transmembrane (TM) domains mediate full fusion. A possible explanation for these observations is that the TM domain must be a critical length in order for HA to promote full fusion. To test this hypothesis, we analyzed biochemical properties and fusion phenotypes of HA with alterations in its 27-amino acid TM domain. Our mutants included sequential 2-amino acid (Delta2-Delta14) and an 11-amino acid deletion from the COOH-terminal end, deletions of 6 or 8 amino acids from the NH(2)-terminal and middle regions, and a deletion of 12 amino acids from the NH(2)-terminal end of the TM domain. We also made several point mutations in the TM domain. All of the mutants except Delta14 were expressed at the cell surface and displayed biochemical properties virtually identical to wild-type HA. All the mutants that were expressed at the cell surface promoted full fusion, with the notable exception of deletions of >10 amino acids. A mutant in which 11 amino acids were deleted was severely impaired in promoting full fusion. Mutants in which 12 amino acids were deleted (from either end) mediated only hemifusion. Hence, a TM domain of 17 amino acids is needed to efficiently promote full fusion. Addition of either the hydrophilic HA cytoplasmic tail sequence or a single arginine to Delta12 HA, the hemifusion mutant that terminates with 15 (hydrophobic) amino acids of the HA TM domain, restored full fusion activity. Our data support a model in which the TM domain must span the bilayer to promote full fusion.

Modification of the cytoplasmic domain of influenza virus hemagglutinin affects enlargement of the fusion pore

The fusion activity of chimeras of influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) (from A/fpv/Rostock/34; subtype H7) with the transmembrane domain (TM) and/or cytoplasmic tail (CT) either from the nonviral, nonfusogenic T-cell surface protein CD4 or from the fusogenic Sendai virus F-protein was studied. Wild-type or chimeric HA was expressed in CV-1 cells by the transient T7-RNA-polymerase vaccinia virus expression system. Subsequently, the fusion activity of the expression products was monitored with red blood cells or ghosts as target cells. To assess the different steps of fusion, target cells were labeled with the fluorescent membrane label octadecyl rhodamine B-chloride (R18) (membrane fusion) and with the cytoplasmic fluorophores calcein (molecular weight [MW], 623; formation of small aqueous fusion pore) and tetramethylrhodamine-dextran (MW, 10,000; enlargement of fusion pore). All chimeric HA/F-proteins, as well as the chimera with the TM of CD4 and the CT of HA, were able to mediate the different steps of fusion very similarly to wild-type HA. Quite differently, chimeric proteins with the CT of CD4 were strongly impaired in mediating pore enlargement. However, membrane fusion and formation of small pores were similar to those of wild-type HA, indicating that the conformational change of the ectodomain and earlier fusion steps were not inhibited. Various properties of the CT which may affect pore enlargement are considered. We surmise that the hydrophobicity of the sequence adjacent to the transmembrane domain is important for pore dilation.

Multiple local contact sites are induced by GPI-linked influenza hemagglutinin during hemifusion and flickering pore formation

Membrane fusion intermediates induced by the glycosylphosphatidylinositol-linked ectodomain of influenza hemagglutinin (GPI-HA) were investigated by rapid freeze, freeze-substitution, thin section electron microscopy, and with simultaneous recordings of whole-cell admittance and fluorescence. Upon triggering, the previously separated membranes developed numerous hourglass shaped points of membrane contact (approximately 10-130 nm waist) when viewed by electron microscopy. Stereo pairs showed close membrane contact at peaks of complementary protrusions, arising from each membrane. With HA, there were fewer contacts, but wide fusion pores. Physiological measurements showed fast lipid dye mixing between cells after acidification, and either fusion pore formation or the lack thereof (true hemifusion). For the earliest pores, a similar conductance distribution and frequency of flickering pores were detected for both HA and GPI-HA. For GPI-HA, lipid mixing was detected prior to, during, or after pore opening, whereas for HA, lipid mixing is seen only after pore opening. Our findings are consistent with a pathway wherein conformational changes in the ectodomain of HA pull membranes towards each other to form a contact site, then hemifusion and pore formation initiate in a small percentage of these contact sites. Finally, the transmembrane domain of HA is needed to complete membrane fusion for macromolecular content mixing.

The lipid-anchored ectodomain of influenza virus hemagglutinin (GPI-HA) is capable of inducing nonenlarging fusion pores

GPI-linked hemagglutinin (GPI-HA) of influenza virus was thought to induce hemifusion without pore formation. Cells expressing either HA or GPI-HA were bound to red blood cells, and their fusion was compared by patch-clamp capacitance measurements and fluorescence microscopy. It is now shown that under more optimal fusion conditions than have been used previously, GPI-HA is also able to induce fusion pore formation before lipid dye spread, although with fewer pores formed than those induced by HA. The GPI-HA pores did not enlarge substantially, as determined by the inability of a small aqueous dye to pass through them. The presence of 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3, 3,3',3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate or octadecylrhodamine B in red blood cells significantly increased the probability of pore formation by GPI-HA; the dyes affected pore formation to a much lesser degree for HA. This greater sensitivity of pore formation to lipid composition suggests that lipids are a more abundant component of a GPI-HA fusion pore than of an HA pore. The finding that GPI-HA can induce pores indicates that the ectodomain of HA is responsible for all steps up to the initial membrane merger and that the transmembrane domain, although not absolutely required, ensures reliable pore formation and is essential for pore growth. GPI-HA is the minimal unit identified to date that supports fusion to the point of pore formation.

Secondary structure, orientation, oligomerization, and lipid interactions of the transmembrane domain of influenza hemagglutinin

Influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA), the viral envelope glycoprotein that mediates fusion between the viral and cellular membranes, is a homotrimer of three subunits, each containing two disulfide-linked polypeptide chains, HA(1) and HA(2). Each HA(2) chain spans the viral membrane with a single putative transmembrane alpha-helix near its C-terminus. Fusion experiments with recombinant HAs suggest that this sequence is required for a late step of membrane fusion, as a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored analogue of HA only mediates "hemifusion" of membranes, i.e., the merging of the proximal, but not distal, leaflets of the two juxtaposed lipid bilayers [Kemble et al. (1994) Cell 76, 383-391]. To find a structural explanation for the function of the transmembrane domain of HA(2) in membrane fusion, we have studied the secondary structure, orientation, oligomerization, and lipid interactions of a synthetic peptide representing the transmembrane segment of X:31 HA (TMX31) by circular dichroism and attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and by gel electrophoresis. The peptide was predominantly alpha-helical in detergent micelles and in phospholipid bilayers. The helicity was increased in lipid bilayers composed of acidic lipids compared to pure phosphatidylcholine bilayers. In planar lipid bilayers, the helices were oriented close to the membrane normal. TMX31 aggregated into small heat-resistant oligomers composed of two to five subunits in SDS micelles. Amide hydrogen exchange experiments indicated that a large fraction of the helical residues were accessible to water, suggesting the possibility that TMX31 forms pores in lipid bilayers. Finally, the peptide increased the acyl chain order in lipid bilayers, which may be related to the preferential association of HA with lipid "rafts" in the cell surface and which may be an important prerequisite for complete membrane fusion.

Hemifusion between cells expressing hemagglutinin of influenza virus and planar membranes can precede the formation of fusion pores that subsequently fully enlarge

The chronological relation between the establishment of lipid continuity and fusion pore formation has been investigated for fusion of cells expressing hemagglutinin (HA) of influenza virus to planar bilayer membranes. Self-quenching concentrations of lipid dye were placed in the planar membrane to monitor lipid mixing, and time-resolved admittance measurements were used to measure fusion pores. For rhodamine-PE, fusion pores always occurred before a detectable amount of dye moved into an HA-expressing cell. However, with DiI in the planar membrane, the relationship was reversed: the spread of dye preceded formation of small pores. In other words, by using DiI as probe, hemifusion was clearly observed to occur before pore formation. For hemifused cells, a small pore could form and subsequently fully enlarge. In contrast, for cells that express a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored ectodomain of HA, hemifusion occurred, but no fully enlarged pores were observed. Therefore, the transmembrane domain of HA is required for the formation of fully enlarging pores. Thus, with the planar bilayer membranes as target, hemifusion can precede pore formation, and the occurrence of lipid dye spread does not preclude formation of pores that can enlarge fully.

Poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-mediated fusion between pure lipid bilayers: a mechanism in common with viral fusion and secretory vesicle release?

Membrane fusion is fundamental to the life of eukaryotic cells. Cellular trafficking and compartmentalization, import of food stuffs and export of waste, inter-cellular communication, sexual reproduction, and cell division are all dependent on this basic process. Yet, little is known about the molecular mechanism(s) by which fusion occurs. It is known that fusing membranes must somehow be docked and brought into close contact. Specific proteins, many of which have been identified within the past decade, accomplish this. An electrical connection or 'fusion pore' is established between compartments surrounded by the fusing membranes. Three primary views of the mechanism of pore formation during secretory and viral fusion have been proposed within the past decade. In one view, a protein ring forms an initial transient connection that expands slowly by recruiting lipid so as to form a lipidic junction. In another view, the initial fusion pore consists of a protein-lipid complex that transforms slowly until the fusion proteins dissociate from the complex to form an irreversible lipidic pore. In a third view, the initial pore is a transient lipid pore that fluctuates between open and closed states before either expanding irreversibly or closing. Recent work has helped define the mechanism by which poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) mediates fusion of highly curved model membranes composed only of synthetic phospholipids. PEG is a highly hydrated polymer that can bring vesicle membranes to near molecular contact by making water between them thermodynamically unfavourable. Disrupted packing in the contacting monolayers of these vesicle membranes is necessary to induce fusion. The time course and sequence of molecular events of the ensuing fusion process have also been defined. This sequence of events involves the formation of an initial, transient intermediate in which outer leaflet lipids have mixed and small transient pores join fusing compartments ('stalk'). The transient intermediate transforms in 1-3 min to a fusion-committed, second intermediate ('septum') that then 'pops' to form the fusion pore. Inner leaflet mixing, which is shown to be distinct from outer leaflet mixing, accompanies contents mixing that marks formation of the fusion pore. Both the sequence of events and the activation energies of these events correspond well to those observed in viral membrane fusion and secretory granule fusion. These results strongly support the contention that both viral and secretory fusion events occur by lipid molecule rearrangements that can be studied and defined through the use of PEG-mediated vesicle fusion as a model system. A possible mechanism by which fusion proteins might mediate this lipidic process is described.

Amino acid sequence requirements of the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains of influenza virus hemagglutinin for viable membrane fusion

The amino acid sequence requirements of the transmembrane (TM) domain and cytoplasmic tail (CT) of the hemagglutinin (HA) of influenza virus in membrane fusion have been investigated. Fusion properties of wild-type HA were compared with those of chimeras consisting of the ectodomain of HA and the TM domain and/or CT of polyimmunoglobulin receptor, a nonviral integral membrane protein. The presence of a CT was not required for fusion. But when a TM domain and CT were present, fusion activity was greater when they were derived from the same protein than derived from different proteins. In fact, the chimera with a TM domain of HA and truncated CT of polyimmunoglobulin receptor did not support full fusion, indicating that the two regions are not functionally independent. Despite the fact that there is wide latitude in the sequence of the TM domain that supports fusion, a point mutation of a semiconserved residue within the TM domain of HA inhibited fusion. The ability of a foreign TM domain to support fusion contradicts the hypothesis that a pore is composed solely of fusion proteins and supports the theory that the TM domain creates fusion pores after a stage of hemifusion has been achieved.

Structural intermediates in influenza haemagglutinin-mediated fusion

Fusion pore formation in the haemagglutinin (HA)-mediated fusion is a culmination of a multistep process, which involves low-pH triggered refolding of HA and rearrangement of membrane lipid bilayers. This rearrangement was arrested or slowed down by either altering lipid composition of the membranes, or lowering the density of HA, and/or temperature. The results suggest that fusion starts with the lateral assembly of activated HA into multimeric complexes surrounding future fusion sites. The next fusion stage involves hemifusion, i.e. merger of only contacting membrane monolayers. Lysophosphatidylcholine reversibly arrests fusion prior to this hemifusion stage. In the normal fusion pathway, hemifusion is transient and is not accompanied by any measurable transfer of lipid probes between the membranes. A temperature of 4 degrees C stabilizes this 'restricted hemifusion' intermediate. The restriction of lipid flow through the restricted hemifusion site is HA-dependent and can be released by partial cleaving of low pH-forms of HA with mild proteinase K treatment. Lipid effects indicate that fusion proceeds through two different lipid-involving intermediates, which are characterized by two opposite curvatures of the lipid monolayer. Hemifusion involves formation of a stalk, a local bent connection between the outer membrane monolayers. Fusion pore formation apparently involves bending of the inner membrane monolayers, which come together in hemifusion. To couple low pH-induced refolding of HA with lipid rearrangements, it is proposed that the extension of the alpha-helical coiled coil of HA pulls fusion peptides inserted into the HA-expressing membrane and locally bends the membrane into a saddle-like shape. Elastic energy drives self-assembly of these HA-containing membrane elements into a ring-like complex and causes the bulging of the host membrane into a dimple growing towards the target membrane. Bending stresses in the lipidic top of the dimple facilitate membrane fusion.

Effects of spontaneous bilayer curvature on influenza virus-mediated fusion pores

Cells expressing the hemagglutinin protein of influenza virus were fused to planar bilayer membranes containing the fluorescent lipid probes octadecylrhodamine (R18) or indocarbocyanine (DiI) to investigate whether spontaneous curvature of each monolayer of a target membrane affects the growth of fusion pores. R18 and DiI lowered the transition temperatures for formation of an inverted hexagonal phase, indicating that these probes facilitate the formation of negative curvature structures. The probes are known to translocate from one monolayer of a bilayer membrane to the other in a voltage-dependent manner. The spontaneous curvature of the cis monolayer (facing the cells) or the trans monolayer could therefore be made more negative through control of the polarity of voltage across the planar membrane. Electrical admittance measurements showed that the open times of flickering fusion pores were shorter when probes were in trans monolayers and longer when in cis monolayers compared with times when probe was symmetrically distributed. Open times were the same for probe symmetrically distributed as when probes were not present. Thus, open times were a function of the asymmetry of the spontaneous curvature between the trans and cis monolayers. Enriching the cis monolayer with a negative curvature probe reduced the probability that a small pore would fully enlarge, whereas enriching the trans monolayer promoted enlargement. Lysophosphatidylcholine has positive spontaneous curvature and does not translocate. When lysophosphatidylcholine was placed in trans leaflets of planar membranes, closing of fusion pores was rare. The effects of the negative and positive spontaneous curvature probes do not support the hypothesis that a flickering pore closes from an open state within a hemifusion diaphragm (essentially a "flat" structure). Rather, such effects support the hypothesis that the membrane surrounding the open pore forms a three-dimensional hourglass shape from which the pore flickers shut.

Methodologies in the study of cell-cell fusion

The process of membrane fusion has been profitably studied by fusing cells that express fusion proteins on their surfaces to the membranes of target cells. Primary methods for monitoring the occurrence of fusion between cells are measurement of formation of heterokaryons, measurement of activation of reporter genes, measurement of transfer of lipidic and aqueous fluorescent dyes, and electrophysiological recording of fusion pores. Fluorescence and electrical methods have been well developed for fusion of a nucleated cell expressing viral fusion proteins to red blood cell targets. These techniques are now being extended to the study of fusion between two nucleated cells. Microscopic observation of spread of fluorescent dyes from one cell to another is a sensitive and convenient means of detecting fusion on the level of single events. In such studies, both the membrane and the aqueous continuities that occur as a result of fusion can be measured in the same experiment. By following spread of aqueous dyes of different sizes from one cell to another, the growth of a fusion pore can also be followed. By labeling cells with fluorescent probes, a state of hemifusion can be identified if probes in outer membrane leaflets transfer but probes in inner leaflets or aqueous spaces do not. Electrical measurements-both capacitance and double-whole-cell voltage-clamp techniques-are the most sensitive methods yet developed for detecting the formation of pores and for quantifying their growth. These powerful single-event methodologies should be directly applicable to further advances in expressing nonviral fusion proteins on cell surfaces.

Acylation of the influenza hemagglutinin modulates fusion activity

The influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) contains three highly conserved cysteine residues at positions 551, 559, and 562 close to the carboxyl-terminus of the HA2 subunit which serve as palmitylation sites. Wild-type HA of influenza virus A/FPV/Rostock/34 (H7N1) and HA permutated by exchange of the acylated cysteine to serine residues were expressed in CV-1 cells by a SV40 vector system. Since density of immunostained HA on the cell surface measured by flow cytometric analysis did not differ between wild-type and acylation mutants, it was possible to compare acylation mutants and wild-type HA for their capacity to induce membrane fusion at low pH. The following observations were made: (1) lateral diffusion of a lipid-like fluorophore (R-18) from the erythrocyte membrane to the plasma membrane of cells expressing HA on the surface occurred equally well with mutants and wild type. (2) Diffusion of a low-molecular-weight fluorescent water-soluble probe (calcein) from erythrocytes into the cytoplasm of HA-expressing cells was not altered either. (3) However, depending on the position and the number of the deleted acylation sites, the mutants showed a reduced ability to induce syncytia. The data indicate that deacylation of the cytoplasmic tail has no measurable effect on the capacity of HA to induce membrane fusion and pore formation but that it suppresses syncytia formation.

The transmembrane domain in viral fusion: essential role for a conserved glycine residue in vesicular stomatitis virus G protein

The transmembrane (TM) domains of viral fusion proteins are required for fusion, but their precise role is unknown. G protein, the fusion protein of vesicular stomatitis virus, was previously shown to lose syncytia-forming ability if six residues (GLIIGL) were deleted from its TM domain. The 20-residue TM domain of wild-type (TM20) G protein was thus changed into a TM domain of 14 residues (TM14). To assess possible sequence specificity for this loss of function, the two Gly residues in TM20 were replaced with either Ala or Leu. Both mutations resulted in complete loss of fusion activity, as measured by fusion-dependent reporter gene transfer. Single substitutions decreased activity by about half. TM14 was weakly active (15%) but reintroduction of a Gly residue into TM14 by a single Ile --> Gly substitution increased activity to 80%. All mutants retained normal hemifusion activity, i.e., lipid mixing between the outer leaflets of the reacting membranes. Thus, at least one TM Gly residue is required for a late step in fusion mediated by G protein. Gly residues were significantly (2.6-fold; P = 0.004) more abundant in the TM domains of viral fusion proteins than in those of nonfusion proteins and were distributed differently within the TM domain. Thus, Gly residues in the TM domain of other viral fusion proteins may also prove to be important for fusion activity.

The pathway of membrane fusion catalyzed by influenza hemagglutinin: restriction of lipids, hemifusion, and lipidic fusion pore formation

The mechanism of bilayer unification in biological fusion is unclear. We reversibly arrested hemagglutinin (HA)-mediated cell-cell fusion right before fusion pore opening. A low-pH conformation of HA was required to form this intermediate and to ensure fusion beyond it. We present evidence indicating that outer monolayers of the fusing membranes were merged and continuous in this intermediate, but HA restricted lipid mixing. Depending on the surface density of HA and the membrane lipid composition, this restricted hemifusion intermediate either transformed into a fusion pore or expanded into an unrestricted hemifusion, without pores but with unrestricted lipid mixing. Our results suggest that restriction of lipid flux by a ring of activated HA is necessary for successful fusion, during which a lipidic fusion pore develops in a local and transient hemifusion diaphragm.

Fusion activity of transmembrane and cytoplasmic domain chimeras of the influenza virus glycoprotein hemagglutinin

The role of the sequence of transmembrane and cytoplasmic/intraviral domains of influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA, subtype H7) for HA-mediated membrane fusion was explored. To analyze the influence of the two domains on the fusogenic properties of HA, we designed HA-chimeras in which the cytoplasmic tail and/or transmembrane domain of HA was replaced with the corresponding domains of the fusogenic glycoprotein F of Sendai virus. These chimeras, as well as constructs of HA in which the cytoplasmic tail was replaced by peptides of human neurofibromin type 1 (NF1) or c-Raf-1, NF78 (residues 1441 to 1518), and Raf81 (residues 51 to 131), respectively, were expressed in CV-1 cells by using the vaccinia virus-T7 polymerase transient-expression system. Wild-type and chimeric HA were cleaved properly into two subunits and expressed as trimers. Membrane fusion between CV-1 cells and bound human erythrocytes (RBCs) mediated by parental or chimeric HA proteins was studied by a lipid-mixing assay with the lipid-like fluorophore octadecyl rhodamine B chloride (R18). No profound differences in either extent or kinetics could be observed. After the pH was lowered, the above proteins also induced a flow of the aqueous fluorophore calcein from preloaded RBCs into the cytoplasm of the protein-expressing CV-1 cells, indicating that membrane fusion involves both leaflets of the lipid bilayers and leads to formation of an aqueous fusion pore. We conclude that neither HA-specific sequences in the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains nor their length is crucial for HA-induced membrane fusion activity.