Some recent contributions of FTIR difference spectroscopy to the study of cytochrome oxidase1

Time-resolved studies of metalloproteins using X-ray free electron laser radiation at SACLA

BACKGROUND

The invention of the X-ray free-electron laser (XFEL) has provided unprecedented new opportunities for structural biology. The advantage of XFEL is an intense pulse of X-rays and a very short pulse duration (<10 fs) promising a damage-free and time-resolved crystallography approach.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Recent time-resolved crystallographic analyses in XFEL facility SACLA are reviewed. Specifically, metalloproteins involved in the essential reactions of bioenergy conversion including photosystem II, cytochrome c oxidase and nitric oxide reductase are described.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

XFEL with pump-probe techniques successfully visualized the process of the reaction and the dynamics of a protein. Since the active center of metalloproteins is very sensitive to the X-ray radiation, damage-free structures obtained by XFEL are essential to draw mechanistic conclusions. Methods and tools for sample delivery and reaction initiation are key for successful measurement of the time-resolved data.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

XFEL is at the center of approaches to gain insight into complex mechanism of structural dynamics and the reactions catalyzed by biological macromolecules. Further development has been carried out to expand the application of time-resolved X-ray crystallography. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Novel measurement techniques for visualizing 'live' protein molecules.

Proton translocation in cytochrome c oxidase: insights from proton exchange kinetics and vibrational spectroscopy

Cytochrome c oxidase is the terminal enzyme in the electron transfer chain. It reduces oxygen to water and harnesses the released energy to translocate protons across the inner mitochondrial membrane. The mechanism by which the oxygen chemistry is coupled to proton translocation is not yet resolved owing to the difficulty of monitoring dynamic proton transfer events. Here we summarize several postulated mechanisms for proton translocation, which have been supported by a variety of vibrational spectroscopic studies. We recently proposed a proton translocation model involving proton accessibility to the regions near the propionate groups of the heme a and heme a3 redox centers of the enzyme based by hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange Raman scattering studies (Egawa et al., PLoS ONE 2013). To advance our understanding of this model and to refine the proton accessibility to the hemes, the H/D exchange dependence of the heme propionate group vibrational modes on temperature and pH was measured. The H/D exchange detected at the propionate groups of heme a3 takes place within a few seconds under all conditions. In contrast, that detected at the heme a propionates occurs in the oxidized but not the reduced enzyme and the H/D exchange is pH-dependent with a pKa of ~8.0 (faster at high pH). Analysis of the thermodynamic parameters revealed that, as the pH is varied, entropy/enthalpy compensation held the free energy of activation in a narrow range. The redox dependence of the possible proton pathways to the heme groups is discussed. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Vibrational spectroscopies and bioenergetic systems.

The O(2) reduction and proton pumping gate mechanism of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase

X-ray structures of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase with bound respiratory inhibitors (O(2) analogues) have been determined at 1.8-2.05Å resolution to investigate the function of the O(2) reduction site which includes two metal sites (Fe(a3)(2+) and Cu(B)(1+)). The X-ray structures of the CO- and NO-bound derivatives indicate that although there are three possible electron donors that can provide electrons to the bound O(2), located in the O(2) reduction site, the formation of the peroxide intermediate is effectively prevented to provide an O(2)-bound form as the initial intermediate. The structural change induced upon binding of CN(-) suggests a non-sequential 3-electron reduction of the bound O(2)(-) for the complete reduction without release of any reactive oxygen species. The X-ray structure of the derivative with CO bound to Cu(B)(1+) after photolysis from Fe(a3)(2+) demonstrates weak side-on binding. This suggests that Cu(B) controls the O(2) supply to Fe(a3)(2+) without electron transfer to provide sufficient time for collection of protons from the negative side of the mitochondrial membrane. The proton-pumping pathway of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase includes a hydrogen-bond network and a water channel located in tandem between the positive and negative side of the mitochondrial membrane. Binding of a strong ligand to Fe(a3) induces a conformational change which significantly narrows the water channel and effectively blocks the back-leakage of protons from the hydrogen bond network. The proton pumping mechanism proposed by these X-ray structural analyses has been functionally confirmed by mutagenesis analyses of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Allosteric cooperativity in respiratory proteins.

2D-SEIRA spectroscopy to highlight conformational changes of the cytochrome c oxidase induced by direct electron transfer

Potentiometric titrations of the cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) immobilized in a biomimetic membrane system were followed by two-dimensional surface-enhanced IR absorption spectroscopy (2D SEIRAS) in the ATR-mode. Direct electron transfer was employed to vary the redox state of the enzyme. The CcO was shown to undergo a conformational transition from a non-activated to an activated state after it was allowed to turnover in the presence of oxygen. Differences between the non-activated and activated state were revealed by 2D SEIRA spectra recorded as a function of potential. The activated state was characterized by a higher number of correlated transitions as well as a higher number of amino acids associated with electron transfer.

Characterization of the extracellular polymeric substances produced by Escherichia coli using infrared spectroscopic, proteomic, and aggregation studies

The aim of this study was twofold: first, to characterize the free extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and bound EPS produced by Escherichia coli during different growth phases in different media, and then to investigate the role of the free EPS in promoting aggregation. EPS was extracted from a population of E. coli MG1655 cells grown in different media composition (Luria-Bertani (LB) and Luria-Bertani with the addition of 0.5 w/v% glucose at the beginning of the growth phase (LBG)) and at different growth phases (6 and 24 h). The extracted EPS was characterized using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and further identified using one-dimensional gel-based electrophoresis and tandem mass spectrometry. E. coli MG1655 was found to produce significantly lower amounts of bound EPS compared to free EPS under all conditions. The protein content of free EPS increased as the cells progressed from the exponential to stationary phase when grown in LB or LBG, while the carbohydrate content only increased across the growth phases for cells grown in LBG. FTIR revealed a variation in the different functional groups such as amines, carboxyl, and phosphoryl groups for free EPS extracted at the different growth conditions. Over 500 proteins were identified in the free EPS, with 40 proteins common in all growth conditions. Proteins with functionality related to amino acid and carbohydrate metabolism, as well as cell wall and membrane biogenesis were among the highest proteins identified in the free EPS extracted from E. coli MG1655 under all growth and media conditions. The role of bound and free EPS was investigated using a standardized aggregation assay. Bound EPS did not contribute to aggregation of E. coli MG1655. The readdition of free EPS to E. coli MG1655 resulted in aggregation of the cells in all growth conditions. Free EPS extracted from the 24 h E. coli MG1655 cultures grown in LB had the greatest effect on aggregation of cells grow in LBG, with a 30% increase in aggregation observed.

Infrared spectroscopy of proteins

This review discusses the application of infrared spectroscopy to the study of proteins. The focus is on the mid-infrared spectral region and the study of protein reactions by reaction-induced infrared difference spectroscopy.

Metals in membranes

In this critical review we discuss recent advances in understanding the modes of interaction of metal ions with membrane proteins, including channels, pumps, transporters, ATP-binding cassette proteins, G-protein coupled receptors, kinases and respiratory enzymes. Such knowledge provides a basis for elucidating the mechanism of action of some classes of metallodrugs, and a stimulus for the further exploration of the coordination chemistry of metal ions in membranes. Such research offers promise for the discovery of new drugs with unusual modes of action. The article will be of interest to bioinorganic chemists, chemical biologists, biochemists, pharmacologists and medicinal chemists. (247 references).

Structural and Chemical Changes of the PMIntermediate ofParacoccus denitrificansCytochromecOxidase Revealed by IR Spectroscopy with Labeled Tyrosines and Histidine†

Structural and chemical changes in the P(M) intermediate of Paracoccus denitrificans cytochrome c oxidase have been investigated by attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. Prior studies of P(M) minus oxidized (O) IR difference spectra of unlabeled, universally (15)N-labeled and ring-d(4)-tyrosine-labeled proteins (Iwaki, M., Puustinen, A., Wikström, M., and Rich, P. R. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 14370-14378). provided a basis for band assignments to changes in metal centers and the covalently linked His-Tyr ligand of Cu(B) and highlighted a structural alteration of the protonated Glu278 in the P(M) intermediate. This work has been extended to equivalent measurements on enzymes with (13)C(9)(15)N-labeled and ring-(13)C(6)-labeled tyrosine and with (13)C(6)(15)N(3)-labeled histidine. Histidine labeling allows the assignment of troughs at 1104 and 973 cm(-1) in reduced minus O spectra to histidine changes, whereas tyrosine labeling moves otherwise obscured tyrosine bandshifts to 1454-1437 and 1287-1284 cm(-1). P(M) minus O spectra reveal bands at 1506, 1311, and 1094 cm(-1) in the oxidized state that are replaced by a band at 1519 cm(-1) in P(M). These bands shift with both tyrosine- and histidine-labeling, providing evidence for their assignment to the covalent His-Tyr and for its chemical change in P(M). Comparisons of isotope effects on the amide I regions in P(M) minus O spectra demonstrate that amide carbonyl bonds of tyrosine and histidine are major contributors. This suggests a structural alteration in P(M) that is centered on the His276-Pro277-Glu278-Val279-Tyr280 pentapeptide formed by the His-Tyr covalent linkage. This structural change is proposed to mediate the perturbation of the IR band of the protonated Glu278 headgroup.

Calculated proton uptake on anaerobic reduction of cytochrome C oxidase: is the reaction electroneutral?

Cytochrome c oxidase is a transmembrane proton pump that builds an electrochemical gradient using chemical energy from the reduction of O(2). Ionization states of all residues were calculated with Multi-Conformation Continuum Electrostatics (MCCE) in seven anaerobic oxidase redox states ranging from fully oxidized to fully reduced. One long-standing problem is how proton uptake is coupled to the reduction of the active site binuclear center (BNC). The BNC has two cofactors: heme a(3) and Cu(B). If the protein needs to maintain electroneutrality, then 2 protons will be bound when the BNC is reduced by 2 electrons in the reductive half of the reaction cycle. The effective pK(a)s of ionizable residues around the BNC are evaluated in Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c oxidase. At pH 7, only a hydroxide coordinated to Cu(B) shifts its pK(a) from below 7 to above 7 and so picks up a proton when heme a(3) and Cu(B) are reduced. Glu I-286, Tyr I-288, His I-334, and a second hydroxide on heme a(3) all have pK(a)s above 7 in all redox states, although they have only 1.6-3.5 DeltapK units energy cost for deprotonation. Thus, at equilibrium, they are protonated and cannot serve as proton acceptors. The propionic acids near the BNC are deprotonated with pK(a)s well below 7. They are well stabilized in their anionic state and do not bind a proton upon BNC reduction. This suggests that electroneutrality in the BNC is not maintained during the anaerobic reduction. Proton uptake on reduction of Cu(A), heme a, heme a(3), and Cu(B) shows approximately 2.5 protons bound per 4 electrons, in agreement with prior experiments. One proton is bound by a hydroxyl group in the BNC and the rest to groups far from the BNC. The electrochemical midpoint potential (E(m)) of heme a is calculated in the fully oxidized protein and with 1 or 2 electrons in the BNC. The E(m) of heme a shifts down when the BNC is reduced, which agrees with prior experiments. If the BNC reduction is electroneutral, then the heme a E(m) is independent of the BNC redox state.

Electrostatic environment of hemes in proteins: pK(a)s of hydroxyl ligands

The pK(a)s of ferric aquo-heme and aquo-heme electrochemical midpoints (E(m)s) at pH 7 in sperm whale myoglobin, Aplysia myoblogin, hemoglobin I, heme oxygenase 1, horseradish peroxidase and cytochrome c oxidase were calculated with Multi-Conformation Continuum Electrostatics (MCCE). The pK(a)s span 3.3 pH units from 7.6 in heme oxygenase 1 to 10.9 in peroxidase, and the E(m)s range from -250 mV in peroxidase to 125 mV in Aplysia myoglobin. Proteins with higher in situ ferric aquo-heme pK(a)s tend to have lower E(m)s. Both changes arise from the protein stabilizing a positively charged heme. However, compared with values in solution, the protein shifts the aquo-heme E(m)s more than the pK(a)s. Thus, the protein has a larger effective dielectric constant for the protonation reaction, showing that electron and proton transfers are coupled to different conformational changes that are captured in the MCCE analysis. The calculations reveal a breakdown in the classical continuum electrostatic analysis of pairwise interactions. Comparisons with DFT calculations show that Coulomb's law overestimates the large unfavorable interactions between the ferric water-heme and positively charged groups facing the heme plane by as much as 60%. If interactions with Cu(B) in cytochrome c oxidase and Arg 38 in horseradish peroxidase are not corrected, the pK(a) calculations are in error by as much as 6 pH units. With DFT corrected interactions calculated pK(a)s and E(m)s differ from measured values by less than 1 pH unit or 35 mV, respectively. The in situ aquo-heme pK(a) is important for the function of cytochrome c oxidase since it helps to control the stoichiometry of proton uptake coupled to electron transfer [Song, Michonova-Alexova, and Gunner (2006) Biochemistry 45, 7959-7975].

Mutations which decouple the proton pump of the cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides perturb the environment of glutamate 286

Mutants that decouple the proton pump of cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides are postulated to do so by increasing the pK(a) of glutamate 286, which is 20 Angstrom away. The possibility that a conformational change near E286 is induced by the decoupling mutations (N139D and N207D) was investigated by FTIR difference spectroscopy. In both decoupled mutants, the reduced-minus-oxidized FTIR difference spectra show a shift of 2 cm(-1) to lower frequency of the band resulting from the absorbance of E286 in the oxidized enzyme. The decoupling mutants may influence E286 by altering the chain of water molecules which runs from the site of the mutations to E286.

Factors influencing the energetics of electron and proton transfers in proteins. What can be learned from calculations

A protein structure should provide the information needed to understand its observed properties. Significant progress has been made in developing accurate calculations of acid/base and oxidation/reduction reactions in proteins. Current methods and their strengths and weaknesses are discussed. The distribution and calculated ionization states in a survey of proteins is described, showing that a significant minority of acidic and basic residues are buried in the protein and that most of these remain ionized. The electrochemistry of heme and quinones are considered. Proton transfers in bacteriorhodopsin and coupled electron and proton transfers in photosynthetic reaction centers, 5-coordinate heme binding proteins and cytochrome c oxidase are highlighted as systems where calculations have provided insight into the reaction mechanism.

Nitric oxide and the respiratory enzyme

Available information on the molecular mechanisms by which nitric oxide (NO) controls the activity of the respiratory enzyme (cytochrome-c-oxidase) is reviewed. We report that, depending on absolute electron flux, NO at physiological concentrations reversibly inhibits cytochrome-c-oxidase by two alternative reaction pathways, yielding either a nitrosyl- or a nitrite-heme a3 derivative. We address a number of hypotheses, envisaging physiological and/or pathological effects of the reactions between NO and cytochrome-c-oxidase.

Thermodynamics of carbon monoxide photodissociation from the fully reduced cytochrome aa3 oxidase from Rb. sphaeroides

Photodissociation of the fully reduced carbonmonoxy bound cytochrome aa3 from Rb. sphaeroides results in ultrafast ligand transfer between heme a3 and CuB, which is followed by thermal dissociation from CuB on longer time scales. We have utilized photoacoustic calorimetry to obtain a detailed thermodynamic description of the mechanism of ligand photodissociation and transfer between heme a3 and CuB. Subsequent to ligand photodissociation an additional process, which has not been characterized previously, was observed with the lifetime of 485 ns at 18 degrees C and is coupled to a volume expansion of 3.3 ml mol(-1). From the temperature dependence, an activation barrier of 4 kcal mol(-1) was determined. We attribute the observed 500 ns process to changes in CuB ligation subsequent to ligand translocation. In a photoacoustic study on CO photodissociation from bovine heart aa3 oxidase, no volume changes were observed on the ns timescale, indicating that a different mechanism may control ligand dissociation and binding within the binuclear center of the bacterial and bovine enzymes.

Acidity of a Cu-Bound Histidine in the Binuclear Center of CytochromecOxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is a crucial enzyme in the respiratory chain. Its function is to couple the reduction of molecular oxygen, which takes place in the Fea3-CuB binuclear center, to proton translocation across the mitochondrial membrane. Although several high-resolution structures of the enzyme are known, the molecular basis of proton pumping activation and its mechanism remain to be elucidated. We examine a recently proposed scheme (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 1858; FEBS Lett. 2004, 566, 126) that involves the deprotonation of the CuB-bound imidazole ring of a histidine (H291 in mammalian CcO) as a key element in the proton pumping mechanism. The central feature of that proposed mechanism is that the pKa values of the imidazole vary significantly depending on the redox state of the metals in the binuclear center. We use density functional theory in combination with continuum electrostatics to calculate the pKa values, successively in bulk water and within the protein, of the Cu-bound imidazole in various Cu- and Cu-Fe complexes. From pKas in bulk water, we derived a value of -266.34 kcal.mol(-1) for the proton solvation free energy (Delta). This estimate is in close agreement with the experimental value of -264.61 kcal.mol(-1) (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, 7314), which reinforces the conclusion that Delta is more negative than previous values used for pKa calculations. Our approach, on the basis of the study of increasingly more detailed models of the CcO binuclear center at different stages of the catalysis, allows us to examine successively the effect of each of the two metals' redox states and of solvation on the acidity of imidazole, whose pKa is approximately 14 in bulk water. This analysis leads to the following conclusions: first, the effect of Cu ligation on the imidazole acidity is negligible regardless of the redox state of the metal. Second, results obtained for Cu-Fe complexes in bulk water indicate that Cu-bound imidazole pKa values lie within the range of 14.8-16.6 throughout binuclear redox states corresponding to the catalytic cycle, demonstrating that the effect of the Fe oxidation states is also negligible. Finally, the low-dielectric CcO proteic environment shifts the acid-base equilibrium toward a neutral imidazole, further increasing the corresponding pKa values. These results are inconsistent with the proposed role of the Cu-bound histidine as a key element in the pumping mechanism. Limitations of continuum solvation models in pKa calculations are discussed.

Are acidic and basic groups in buried proteins predicted to be ionized?

Ionizable residues play essential roles in proteins, modulating protein stability, fold and function. Asp, Glu, Arg, and Lys make up about a quarter of the residues in an average protein. Multi-conformation continuum electrostatic (MCCE) calculations were used to predict the ionization states of all acidic and basic residues in 490 proteins. Of all 36,192 ionizable residues, 93.5% were predicted to be ionized. Thirty-five percent have lost 4.08 kcal/mol solvation energy (DeltaDeltaG(rxn)) sufficient to shift a pK(a) by three pH units in the absence of other interactions and 17% have DeltaDeltaG(rxn) sufficient to shift pK(a) by five pH units. Overall 85% of these buried residues (DeltaDeltaG(rxn)>5DeltapK units) are ionized, including 92% of the Arg, 86% of the Asp, 77% of the Glu, and 75% of the Lys. Ion-pair interactions stabilize the ionization of both acids and bases. The backbone dipoles stabilize anions more than cations. The interactions with polar side-chains are also different for acids and bases. Asn and Gln stabilize all charges, Ser and Thr stabilize only acids while Tyr rarely stabilize Lys. Thus, hydroxyls are better hydrogen bond donors than acceptors. Buried ionized residues are more likely to be conserved than those on the surface. There are 3.95 residues buried per 100 residues in an average protein.

Insights into the Structure and Function of Redox-Active Tyrosines from Model Compounds

Redox-active tyrosine residues play important roles in long distance electron-transfer reactions in enzymes, including prostaglandin H synthase, ribonucleotide reductase, and photosystem II. In cytochrome c oxidase, a cross-linked tyrosine-histidine cofactor has been proposed to play a role in proton and electron transfer reactions. Studies of tyrosyl radicals in model compounds, generated by UV photolysis, have recently provided new information about the structure and function of these redox-active species. The results of these studies, which combine magnetic resonance and optical spectroscopies, are described in this review.

Modulation of human 5-lipoxygenase activity by membrane lipids

Mammalian 5-lipoxygenase (5-LO) catalyzes the conversion of arachidonic acid (AA) to leukotrienes, potent inflammatory mediators. 5-LO is activated by a Ca(2+)-mediated translocation to membranes, and demonstrates the characteristic features of interfacially activated enzymes, yet the mechanism of membrane binding of 5-LO is not well understood. In an attempt to understand the mechanism of lipid-mediated activation of 5-LO, we have studied the effects of a large set of lipids on human recombinant 5-LO activity, as well as mutual structural effects of 5-LO and membranes. In the presence of 0.35 mM phosphatidylcholine (PC) and 0.2 mM Ca(2+), there was substrate inhibition at >100 microM AA. Data analysis at low AA concentrations yielded the following: K(m) approximately 103 microM and k(cat) approximately 56 s(-1). 5-LO activity was supported by PC more than by any other lipid tested except for a cationic lipid, which was more stimulatory than PC. Binding of 5-LO to zwitterionic and acidic membranes was relatively weak; the extent of binding increased 4-8 times in the presence of Ca(2+), whereas binding to cationic membranes was stronger and essentially Ca(2+)-independent. Polarized attenuated total reflection infrared experiments implied that 5-LO binds to membranes at a defined orientation with the symmetry axis of the putative N-terminal beta-barrel tilted approximately 45 degrees from the membrane normal. Furthermore, membrane binding of 5-LO resulted in dehydration of the membrane surface and was paralleled with stabilization of the structures of both 5-LO and the membrane. Our results provide insight into the understanding of the effects of membrane surface properties on 5-LO-membrane interactions and the interfacial activation of 5-LO.

ATR-FTIR Spectroscopy and Isotope Labeling of the PM Intermediate of Paracoccus denitrificans Cytochrome c Oxidase

The structure of the P(M) intermediate of Paracoccus denitrificans cytochrome c oxidase was investigated by perfusion-induced attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy. Transitions from the oxidized to P(M) state were initiated by perfusion with CO/oxygen buffer, and the extent of conversion was quantitated by simultaneously monitoring visible absorption changes. In prior work, tentative assignments of bands were proposed for heme a(3), a change in the environment of the protonated state of a carboxylic acid, and a covalently linked histidine-tyrosine ligand to Cu(B) that has been found in the catalytic site. In this work, reduced minus oxidized difference spectra at pH 6.5 and 9.0 and P(M) minus oxidized difference spectra at pH 9.0 were compared in unlabeled, universally (15)N-labeled, and tyrosine-ring-d(4)-labeled proteins to improve these assignments. In the reduced minus oxidized difference spectrum, (15)N labeling resulted in large changes in the amide II region and a 9 cm(-1) downshift in a 1105 cm(-1) trough that is attributed to histidine. In contrast, changes induced by tyrosine-ring-d(4) labeling were barely detectable where the isotope-sensitive bands are expected. Both isotope substitutions had large effects on P(M) minus oxidized difference spectra. A prominent trough at 1542 cm(-1) was shifted to 1527 cm(-1) with (15)N labeling, and its magnitude was diminished with the appearance of a 1438 cm(-1) trough with tyrosine-ring-d(4) labeling. Both isotope substitutions also had large effects on a 1314 cm(-1) trough in the same spectra. These shifts indicate that the bands are linked to both a nitrogenous compound and a tyrosine, the most obvious candidate being the covalent histidine-tyrosine ligand of Cu(B). Comparison with model material data suggests that the tyrosine hydroxyl group is protonated when the binuclear center is oxidized but deprotonated in the P(M) intermediate. Positive bands at 1519 and 1570 cm(-1) were replaced with bands at 1504 and 1556 cm(-1), respectively, with tyrosine-ring-d(4) labeling, are characteristic of upsilon(7a)(C-O) and upsilon(C-C) bands of neutral phenolic radicals, and most likely reflect the formation of the neutral radical state of the histidine-tyrosine ligand in P(M).

Targeted Proton Delivery in the Catalyzed Reduction of Oxygen to Water by Bimetallic Pacman Porphyrins

A combined experimental and theoretical investigation of the role of proton delivery in determining O2 reduction pathways catalyzed by cofacial bisporphyrins is presented. A homologous family of dicobalt(II) Pacman porphyrins anchored by xanthene [Co2(DPX) (1) and Co2(DPXM) (3)] and dibenzofuran [Co2(DPD) (2) and Co2(DPDM) (4)] have been synthesized, characterized, and evaluated as catalysts for the direct four-proton, four-electron reduction of O2 to H2O. Structural analysis of the intramolecular diiron(III) mu-oxo complex Fe2O(DPXM) (5) and electrochemical measurements of 1-4 establish that Pacman derivatives bearing an aryl group trans to the spacer possess structural flexibilities and redox properties similar to those of their parent counterparts; however, these trans-aryl catalysts exhibit markedly reduced selectivities for the direct reduction of O2 to H2O over the two-proton, two-electron pathway to H2O2. Density functional theory calculations reveal that trans-aryl substitution results in inefficient proton delivery to O2-bound catalysts compared to unsubstituted congeners. In particular, the HOMO of [Co2(DPXM)(O2)]+ disfavors proton transfer to the bound oxygen species, funneling the O-O activation pathway to single-electron chemistry and the production of H2O2, whereas the HOMO of [Co2(DPX)(O2)]+ directs protonation to the [Co2O2] core to facilitate subsequent multielectron O-O bond activation to generate two molecules of H2O. Our findings highlight the importance of controlling both proton and electron inventories for specific O-O bond activation and offer a unified model for O-O bond activation within the clefts of bimetallic porphyrins.